WORDS iCONNECTED FOR UNDERGRADUATE ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNERS WORDS iCONNECTED Words That Matter: Vocabulary Intervention Using Integrative Technologies and Social Networking Media for English Language Learners Vocabulary is a key determining factor that greatly impacts students’, particularly English language learners’ (ELLs), academic performances (Li, under review; Roessingh & Douglas, 2010; Snow & Kim, 2006). One of the greatest challenges for these students is to acquire academic and low frequency words in a constrained timeframe; their struggles to learn these words have been centered on the mismatches between their existing knowledge, skills, learning preferences and instructional strategies applied in North American classrooms. These modern students’ abilities to learn and process information are vastly different from that of previous generations as they are heavily immersed in social media and integrative technologies. Contents: Introduction 1 On using text 2 messaging in vocabulary intervention On using Facebook as a forum for discussion and debate 3 Isolating target vocabulary 4 Target vocabulary, 5 definitions and context Facebook debate & discussion questions 13 Extended vocabulary practice 14 Extended writing questions 15 References 16 WORDS iCONNECTED, an innovative vocabulary intervention based on the Word Generation model (Snow, 2008), aims at engaging ELLs in learning these difficult words in meaningful contexts by using social media and mobile devices that are pervasive in their lives. The 22 units in this serial are designed for first-year undergraduate ELLs. It aims to help these diverse students develop their command of academic English, vocabulary in particular, concurrent with improving their understanding of Canadian culture and society. Some Mysteries about Language and Language Learning This unit is based on an article entitled “Nine Ideas about Language” by Harvey A. Daniels (1985), which is adapted from his book “Famous Last Words: The American Language Crisis Reconsidered”. Through learning the fundamental ideas about language and language learning widely accepted by contemporary linguists, and through discussion and debate on their related myths prevalent among Americans, students will learn important words that they need for their reading and writing in academic contexts. 1 WORDs iCONNECTED Using Text Messaging in Vocabulary Intervention HOW? Students will be sent target vocabulary, with a simple definition and a simple sentence using the word in a similar context to the original text. Hey, Words you got to know today Complex (Adj.): something that is made of many different parts that are connected in a complicated or hard to understand way. “The use of Sample sentence: As people grow from children into adults, the language they use to express their ideas and feelings becomes more and more complex. current and emerging social networking technologies offers neomillennial learners the flexibility and ability to create learning communities and revisit content as needed” (Baird & Fisher, 2005) WHY? A Google-commissioned study on smartphone usage — Treasured electronic companion — on 5,013 U.S. adults (aged 18-64). Similar data are found in other countries (Titlow, 2011). Nielsen forecasts: 1 in 2 Americans will have a smartphone by Christmas 2011 compared to just one in 10 in the summer of 2008 due to increased application availability, better native features and declining prices (Tofel, 2010). Report released from comScore (2010) indicates the top mobile content usage was text messaging (63%). Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 2 WORDs iCONNECTED Using Facebook as a Forum for Student Debate HOW? Students will log on to a class Facebook page which will serve as a venue for students to extend their understanding of the text and an opportunity for them to apply their vocabulary in a meaningful context by debating and discussing issues pertaining to the text. Debate From a couple of options, students will choose one debate forum for which they will choose a position on the topic and contribute their argument for or against the given statement on the appropriate Facebook forum. Discussion On the class Facebook page, students will also see two options for discussion questions. Students will chose one question and will post their response in the appropriate forum. Hey, let’s talk about it Do you agree with the following statement, and why? “Language is a species-specific trait of human beings” (Daniels, 1985, p.19). WHY? Facebook has come to dominate social networking in the US. and Canada — the top ten countries on the Facebook user list (Pingdom, 2010) Facebook has crossed the 750 mm active user mark (Facebook, 2011) Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 3 WORDs iCONNECTED Isolating target vocabulary In order to isolate the target vocabulary for this text, the instructor made reference to Coxhead’s (2000) Academic Word List (AWL). The list contains 570 word families that frequently appear in academic texts across a broad range of subject areas; these words are not in the list of the 2000 most commonly used words in English. A simple way to isolate the academic words from any text is to enter an electronic version of the text onto Cobb’s (2011) ‘vocabprofile’ function on the Complete Lexical Tutor website. This site offers a free service which helps teachers to easily identify difficulty of vocabulary of a text by highlighting words in different colours, depending on which word list they appear (first 1000 & 2000 words, academic words and ‘off-list’ words). By transferring the text onto a MS Word file, the instructor can perform a ‘search’ to see how often a target word appears within the body of the text. Words for this unit were selected because they appeared on the AWL and also because they appeared several times throughout the text. Crafting a definition Once the target words were selected, several reputable dictionaries designed for ELLs were consulted to craft a simple and concise definition of the target word as it is used in the context of the reading. In this case, the online versions of the Oxford, Merriam-Webster and Longman dictionaries were utilized. Definitions are limited to 140 characters, in order to accommodate the brevity requirements of a Twitter post. Creating a sample sentence Sample sentences were also created to help students immediately see the target word used in a context that is similar to that in which it appears in the reading. The sample sentence may be a simplified version of the sentence in which the word appears in the text– or the sentence may use the target word in such a way that helps the learner to connect a seeming abstraction with something more comprehensible to the learner. The sample sentence has also been constructed to be no longer than 140 characters, so that it does not exceed the standard length allowed in a Twitter post. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 4 WORDs iCONNECTED Monday 1. underlying (5) 2. features (7) 3. complex (complexity) (6) 4. acquire (6) 5. hypothesis (hypothesizing / hypothetical) (5) Tuesday 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Friday Thursday 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. mutually (4) code (3) constantly (5) style (12) adjust (adjustment) (3) 1. distinction (distinctly)(3) 2. process (8) 3. specific (3) 4. concept (conceptualize) (2) 5. inherently (3 ) Saturday 1. function (2) 2. communicate (communication) (2) 3. community (6) 4. major ( majority)(4) 5. demonstrate (3) tense (s) (2) attach (3) arbitrary (6) requires (4) variations (2) Sunday 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. author (3) considerable(2) reaction (2) obviously (4) shift (2) Wednesday 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. definitions (5) elements (4) isolation (5) logical (9) region (4) Target vocabulary The numbers in brackets indicate the minimum number of times the target word appears in the body of the original text. Target words have been explicitly chosen because they are recycled throughout the text, thus increasing the opportunity for the learner to encounter the word in context. Some words may appear in a variant form from the same word family. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 5 Monday—target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: underlying adjective: a factor that is not easy to notice, but may be a cause or motivation for a particular idea, problem or issue Example: Although languages may look and sound different, they share the same underlying parts; each language has nouns, verbs and rules of grammar. feature noun: an interesting, typical or important characteristic, part or quality of a person, place or thing Example: Some language experts argue that the human brain is programmed at birth to understand the basic features that are common to all languages. complex adjective: something that is made of many different parts that are connected in a complicated or hard to understand way Example: As people grow from children into adults, the language they use to express their ideas and feelings becomes more and more complex. acquire verb: to get something (e.g., a skill) as a result of your own ability and/or effort Example: Children acquire language naturally as they hear their parents and others around them speak. hypothesis noun: a theory or idea to explain something that is based on observable facts but is not yet proven as true Example: Children will guess what they observe to be a rule of their language and then test their hypothesis by applying the rule when they speak. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 6 Tuesday—target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: tense noun: a form of a verb showing the time frame in which an action or state occurs (e.g., past, present, future) Example: In the present tense, “John talks”, but in the past tense, “ John talked”. attach verb: to connect, join or fasten one object to another object Example: In English, you often attach ‘ed’ to the end of a verb to express an action in the past, for example ‘I talk’ becomes ‘I talked’. arbitrary adjective: when something has been chosen or decided without any apparent reason, system, or plan Example: Each language contains sounds (phonemes) that are an arbitrary selection from a wide range of available sounds the human voice can create. require verb: to say that something is necessary because a particular rule or law says so Example: In English grammar, there is a rule that requires a speaker to place an adjective after a noun. variation noun: a difference among a group of similar things Example: If you travel across America, you will notice small variations in the way people say certain words from one place to another. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 7 Wednesday—target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: definition noun: a statement explaining the meaning of a phrase, word or idea Example: A simple definition of the word ‘grammar’ is ‘the system of rules that we use to help us arrange words into meaningful sentences’. element noun: a basic (or essential) part or feature of a whole Example: If I arrange the elements of a sentence (nouns, verbs, adjectives, and prepositions) in the right order, the words will make sense. isolation noun: the separation of a person, place or thing from others Example: Because of the isolation of the people living on the island, they speak English with a different accent from those on the mainland. logical adjective: that which seems to follow the rules of what is natural, sensible and/or reasonable Example: If the words in a sentence do not appear in a logical order, according to the rules of grammar, the message may not be clear. region noun: a geographical area that is somehow different or separated from other parts, often not having exact borders Example: People who live in the north-east region of the U.S.A. tend to speak English with a different accent than those who live in the south-west. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 8 Thursday—target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: mutually adverb: when something is done or felt in an equal way by two or more people involved Example: Although there are some differences between British and Canadian English, in general, the two dialects are mutually understandable. code noun: a system of words or sounds representing a message that can only be understood by another person who knows the system Example: Thomas and I have known each other for so long that we have developed a secret code language that nobody else understands but us. constantly adverb: when something happens repeatedly, all the time or very often Example: The two-year-old boy is talking more and more each day; he is constantly adding new words to his growing vocabulary. style noun: a way of performing, doing, or creating something that is particular to a specific group of people, place or time period Example: I use a casual style of speech when I talk to my friend or relative, but when I talk to my boss, I use language that is more formal. adjust verb: to change something in order to make it work or fit better in a new set of conditions or for a specific purpose. Example: Luke tells both his boss and his best friend about his trip to Mexico, but he adjusts each version of his story to suit the listener. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 9 Friday—target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: distinction noun: a noticeable difference between two similar people or things Example: There is no distinction in the sound of the words “too” and “two” in English, but the meaning and the spelling are different. process noun: a series of actions done on purpose to achieve a result or a series of actions that happen naturally and result in change Example: Words sometimes change meaning over time in a language, as a result of a process that is influenced by changing factors in the society. specific adjective: something connected to one particular person, place, thing, situation etc. Example: French bulldogs, Scottish terriers, German shepherds and English spaniels are all specific kinds of dogs. concept noun: an idea of how or what something is, how it works or how it should be done. Example: People use languages to express concepts in both spoken and written forms. inherently adverb: describing a natural and permanent part of someone or something Example: Some people believe that the British dialect of English is inherently superior than any other dialect of the English language. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 10 Saturday—target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: function verb: to work or operate correctly or in the intended way Example: When used by its own community, a dialect of any language functions perfectly to suit the particular communication needs of its speakers. communicate verb: to express information, thoughts and feelings through the use of words or signs so that another person can understand Example: If two people speak completely different languages, they may use facial expressing and hand gestures to communicate their ideas. community noun: a group of people who may share a particular interest, race, religion, neighbourhood, language job, etc. Example: My grandmother came from a French- speaking community in rural Manitoba; her French was very different from the French I heard in Paris. majority noun: most (i.e., more than half the total) items or people in a particular group Example: By the time children are old enough for school, they will have already learned the majority of the rules of the language spoken at home. demonstrate verb: to show or to give evidence/ proof of something by being an example of it. Example: Sometimes characters on television shows are used to demonstrate a stereotype of a particular language and the people who speak it. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 11 Sunday- target vocabulary with definitions and sample sentences Hey, Words you got to know today: author noun: someone who has written something, for example a book Example: Cara dreams of writing a book about her adventures and becoming a famous author. considerable adjective: large in quantity, size or amount, enough so to be important or to have an effect Example: A legal document would be written with a considerable amount of formal language in comparison to a text message between friends. reaction noun: how a person feels, acts, or thinks in response to something that happens or to something that is said Example: Gloria had a very negative reaction when Phil made fun of her Spanish accent; she was very insulted and started to cry. obviously adverb: describes a situation or information that is either already known or that is easy to understand/ see/ agree with Example: The meanings of some words have obviously changed; for example, 10 years ago the common meaning of ‘twitter’ meant ‘to chirp’ like a bird. shift noun: a change, particularly in how something is done or how people think about something Example: Recent shifts in English grammar have caused us to become more accepting of errors like split infinitives and sentence fragments. Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 12 WORDs iCONNECTED Facebook forums Hey, let’s talk about it The following questions can help guide discussion about the paragraph and check for students’ comprehension. In addition to asking students to consult the text for answers to the questions, teachers can invite students to go beyond the paragraph and tap into their own personal beliefs about the week’s topic. Students will choose one discussion topic and one debate topic and write a brief, yet thoughtful response for each on the appropriate forum on the class Facebook page. Discussion Do you agree with the following statement, and why? “Language is a species-specific trait of human beings” (Daniels, 1985, p.19). or Do you agree or disagree with the following statement and why? “It is easy enough to assert that all languages are equal and efficient in their own sphere of use. But most of us do not really believe in this idea, and certainly do not act as if we did” (Daniels, 1985, p. 33). Debate “The study, occasionally the official worship, of language forms that are both old and formal may retard linguistic changes currently in progress, as well as reinforce our mistaken belief that one style of language is always and truly the best” (Daniels, 1985, p. 35). Should students of English continue to study old, formal works of literature such as Shakespeare, even though nobody speaks or writes like that today.? or Daniels (1985) refers to several examples of national language ‘standards’ and states that “these languages are typically defined as the speech of the upper, or at least educated, classes of society, are the predominant dialect of written communication and are commonly taught to schoolchildren” (p. 25). Should schools continue to insist on this standard, in light of language change? Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 13 WORDs iCONNECTED extended vocabulary practice If students would like more opportunities to practice the target vocabulary , they may access reinforcement exercises on the course website. These exercises would allow students to test their understanding of the target words that have been sent to them through interactive online exercises that give immediate feedback. To create these exercises, the software ‘Hot Potatoes 6’ (Half Baked Software Inc., 2011) was used. The software allows for the teacher to create matching exercises, cloze passages, crossword puzzles, multiple choice, short answer and scrambled sentences. The exercises were derived from the definitions and sample sentences that the students are sent throughout the week. sample sample 14 WORDs iCONNECTED Extended Writing Activity To conclude the unit, students will be asked to apply their understanding of the text and their personal experiences in an extended writing exercise. In this unit, students will be asked to choose one of the topics listed here and to compose a persuasive paragraph, responding to the question they have chosen. Taking a stand –persuasive writing Do you agree with the following statements made by Daniels? Please write an original paragraph based on one of the two following statements in which you argue a position by integrating your personal experience. Topic 1 Daniels (1985) suggests that variations of a language – dialect result from spatial and social isolation and language change. OR Topic 2 “Imitation is not central in language learning and that a child’s main strategies is hypothesizing – deducing from the language she hears an idea about the underlying rules, and then trying it out.” (Daniels, 1985, p.20) Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 15 References Baird, D., & Fisher, M. (2005). Neomillennial user experience design strategies: Utilizing social networking media to support “always on” learning styles. J. Educational Technology Systems 34 (1), 5-32. Cobb, T. (2011) Complete Lexical Tutor V. 6.2: Vocabprofile. Retrieved from http:// www.lextutor.ca/ comScore (2011). comScore Reports January 2011 U.S. Mobile Subscriber Market Share (http:// www.comscore.com/Press_Events/Press_Releases/2011/3/ comScore_Reports_January_2011_U.S._Mobile_Subscriber_Market_Share Coxhead, A. (2000). A new academic word list. TESOL Quarterly, 34, 213-238. Facebook (2011). Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.facebook.com/press/info.php?statistics Half-Baked Software Inc. (2011). Hot Potatoes Version 6. Retrieved from http://hotpot.uvic.ca/ Li, J. (under review). Case studies of four 1.5 generation urban postsecondary students: Facing critical transition from high school to universities. In Roessingh, H. & Douglas, S.TESL Canada Journal. A special issue: Generation 1.5 in Canada: Multiple perspectives on a shifting demographic landscape. Nielsonwire (2010). Global Audience Spends Two Hours More a Month on Social Networks than Last Year. Retrieved from http://blog.nielsen.com/nielsenwire/global/global-audience-spendstwo-hours-more-a-month-on-social-networks-than-last-year/ Pingdom (2010). The top ten countries on Facebook. Retrieved from http:// royal.pingdom.com/2010/08/12/the-top-countries-on-facebook-chart/ Snow, C.E. (2008). The argument for Word Generation. Boston: Strategic Education Partnership and Boston Public School Board. Retrieved September 16, 2008, from http://wordgeneration.org/observe/pd/pd1.html. Snow, C.E., & Kim, Y-S. (2006). Large problem spaces: The challenge of vocabulary for English language learners. In Wagner, R.K., Muse, A., & Tannenbaum, K. (Eds.), Vocabulary acquisition and its implications for reading comprehension, (pp. 123-139). New York: Guilford Press. Tofel, K.C. (2010)1 in 2 Americans Will Have a Smartphone by Christmas 2011. Retrieved from http://gigaom.com/2010/03/26/1-in-2-americans-will-have-a-smartphone-by-christmas-2011/ Copyright ©2011 by Jia Li and iLiteracy Group 16