CHAPTER XII AMYOTROPHIC LATERAL SCLEROSIS (ALS) Presenting complaints in patients with suspected ALS Muscle weakness (usually focal but may be multifocal) Bulbar symptoms (dysarthia, dysphagia, drooling) Spinal symptoms (weakness in an arm or leg) Respiratory symptoms (exertional dyspnea) Fatigue Weight loss Differentiation between UMN & LMN ALS UMN syndrome Loss of dexterity Loss of muscle strength Spasticity Pathologic reflexes Flexor spasms Psuedobulbar signs LMN syndrome Loss of muscle strength Muscle atrophy Hyporeflexia Fasciculations Muscle cramps El Escorial World Federation of Neurology Diagnostic Criteria for ALS The diagnosis of ALS requires the presence of: Signs of lower motor neuron (LMN) degeneration by clinical, electrophysiologic, or neuropathologic examination Signs of upper motor neuron (UMN) degeneration by clinical examination Progressive spread of signs within a region or to other regions with the absence of: Electrophysiologic evidence of other disease processes that might explain the signs of LMN &/or UMN degeneration Neuroimaging evidence of other disease processes that might explain the observed clinical & electrophysiologic signs El Escorial Revised Criteria for the Diagnosis of ALS Definite ALS UMN signs & LMN signs in 3 regions Probable ALS UMN signs & LMN signs in 2 regions with at least some UMN signs rostral to LMN signs Possible ALS UMN signs & LMN signs in I region (together), or UMN signs in 2 or more regions, or UMN & LMN signs in 2 regions with no UMN rostral to LMN signs Probable ALS - Laboratory Supported UMN signs in I or more regions & LMN signs defined by EMG criteria in at least 2 regions 339 El Escorial & Airlie House Diagnostic Criteria for Diagnosis of ALS 1. The presence of a. Evidence of LMN degeneration by clinical, electrophysiological or neuropathologycal examination b. Evidence of UMN degeneration by clinical examination; & c. Progression of the motor syndrome within a region or to other regions, as determined by history or examination; &, 2. The absence of a. Electrophysiological & pathological evidence of other disease processes that might explain the signs of LMN or UMN degeneration; &, b. Neuroimaging evidence of other disease processes that might explain the observed clinical & electrophysiological signs. Categories of Diagnostic Certainty El Escorial Criteria Definite ALS: UMN & LMN signs in three regions. Probable ALS: UMN & LMN signs in at least two regions with UMN signs rostral to (above) LMN signs. Possible ALS: UMN & LMN signs in one region, UMN signs alone in two or more regions, or LMN signs above UMN signs. Suspected ALS: LMN signs only in two or more regions. Airlie House Criteria Clinically Definite ALS: Clinical evidence alone of UMN & LMN signs in 3 regions. Clinically Probable ALS: Clinical evidence alone of UMN & LMN signs in at least two regions with some UMN signs rostral to (above) the LMN signs. Clinically Probable - Laboratory-supported ALS: clinical signs of UMN & LMN dysfunction are in only one region, or UMN signs alone in one region with LMN signs defined by EMG criteria in at least two limbs, together with proper application of neuroimaging & clinical laboratory protocols to exclude other causes. Possible ALS: Clinical signs of UMN & LMN dysfunction in only one region, or UMN signs alone in 2 or more regions; or LMN signs rostral to UMN signs & the diagnosis of Clinically Probable - Lab - supported ALS cannot be, proven. Suspected ALS: This category is deleted from the revised El Escorial Criteria. Diseases which comprise the spectrum of motor neurone disease (MND) ALS/MND Progressive spinal muscular atrophy (PSMA) Primary lateral sclerosis (PLS) Segmental spinal muscular atrophy Focal spinal muscular atrophy Distal spinal muscular atrophy Multifocal motor neuropathy (MMN) Kennedy's disease (progressive X-linked bulbospinal muscular atrophy) Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere syndrome (pontobulbar palsy, with sensorineural deafness) SMN gene-linked spinal muscular atrophy, (SMA) Adult onset progressive, familial SMA Hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP, Strumpell's disease) Fazio-Londe syndrome (infantile progressive bulbar palsy) 340 Other forms (miscellaneous: toxic e.g. lead amyotrophy & axonal polyneuropathy caused by organophosphates, radiation myelopathy, postpoliosyndrome) The Lambert criteria for the electrophysiological confirmation of ALS 1. Normal sensory NCS 2. Motor NCS: CVs that are normal when recording from relatively unaffected muscles & are not less than 70% of the age-based average normal value when recording from severely affected muscles 3. Fibrillation & fasciculation potentials in muscles of the upper & lower extremities or in the muscles of the extremities & the head 4. MUPs which are reduced in number & increased in duration & amplitude *MUP: motor unit potentials, NCS: nerve conduction studies Essential diagnostic tests prior to diagnosis of ALS Routine Hematology & Biochemistry Serum Calcium & Phosphate Thyroid Function Tests Serum protein electrophoresis (SPEP) & Urine protein electrophoresis (UPEP) Lumbar Puncture Analysis for trinucleotide expansion within the androgen receptor gene (in males with lower motor neurone syndrome of bulbar & proximal musculature) Neuroimaging MRI brain (in patients with predominantly upper motor neurone signs) MRI spine (in patients with upper motor neurone signs caudal to lower motor neurone signs, & no bulbar features) Neurophysiology Extensive nerve conduction studies (in patients with predominantly lower motor neurone signs) EMG of 4 limbs & bulbar musculature Muscle biopsy (if EMG is atypical or unusual myopathy is suspected) Hexosaminidase A & B activity (in susceptible Ashkenazi Jewish population) Very long chain fatty acids (in patients with positive family history & predominantly upper motor neuron signs) Clinical features that should lead to re-consideration of the diagnosis of ALS Failure to progress History of poliomyelitis Family history with no affected females & no male to male transmission Symmetrical Signs Pure upper or pure lower motor neurone syndrome UMN signs caudal to LMN signs, with no bulbar involvement Development of sensory signs Development of sphincter disturbances 341 Clinical features of ALS mimic syndrome patients (n = 33) in comparison to ALS patients (n = 404) enrolled on the Irish ALS Register, 1993 - 1997 Age at onset (yrs): Median Range Time from onset of symptoms (yrs): Median Range Time from onset of symptoms to re-diagnosis (yrs): Median Range Site of onset: Lower limb onset Upper limb onset Both upper & lower limbs Bulbar onset (Including patients with simultaneous limb & bulbar onset) ALS Mimic syndromes Males Females (n = 25) (n = 8) 50.8 57.0 22.0 - 70.4 19.5 85.8 All (n =33) 1.0 0.1 - 6.5 5.2 0.6 - 22.2 18 (54.5%) 10 (30.3%) 2 (6.1%) 3 (9.1%) ALS Males Females (n = 241) (n = 163) 65.4 60.8 13.2 - 93.1 29.7 - 91.2 All (n = 404) 0.7 0.1 - 16.0 N/A N/A 117 (28.9%) 77 (19.1%) 44 (10.9%) 166 (41.1%) Revised diagnoses of 33 patients with ALS syndromes referred to the Irish ALS Register, 1993 – 1997. Final diagnosis o Multi-focal motor neuropathy o Kennedy's disease o Motor neuropathy o Non-compressive myelopathy o Spino-muscular atrophy (SMA) o Cervical spondylotic myelopathy o Post-polio syndrome o ALS plus dementia o Multiple sclerosis (MS) o Thyroid disease o Pancoast's syndrome o Uncertain Total number of ALS Mimic patients N 6 4 4 3 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 8 33 342 Loci & Genes underlying Familial ALS (FALS) Familial ALS Dominant Chromosomal locus Gene 21q 9q34 9q21-22 11 SOD1 17q tau NFH Xp11-q12 21q 15q12 2q33-35 SOD1 = Superoxide dismutase Recessive SOD1 Remarks Juvenile onset With dementia Transmission uncertain Frontotemporal dementia with amyotrophy D90A only Diseases Mistaken for ALS Benign fasciculations Parkinson's disease (PD) Kennedy's disease (X-linked bulbospinal muscle atrophy) Brainstem stroke Lumbosacral stenosis Cervical myelopathy Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) Brachial plexopathy Neuropathy Prognosis of ALS: Spinal Onset Versus Bulbar Onset Investigator Spinal onset Tysnes et al.(1991)* 37% Rosen et al (1978)* 44% Jokelainen et al. (1977) ‡ 34 months Kristensen et al. (1977) ‡ 36 months Gubbay et al. (1985) ‡ 38 months Mackay et al. ‡ 36/33 months Tysnes et al (1994) ‡ 26 months *Five - year survival rate. † Statistically significant differences (P< 0.01). ‡ Mean duration of disease. § Data represent spastic / paretic forms. 343 Bulbar onset 9% † 14% † 25 months 24 24 months 26 months 24 / 17 months§ 12 months Core membership of the MND Care Team (the King's model) Team member Team & care coordinator Main Roles Integrates & facilitates care plan; out-reach to regional teams; education; administration of MND Centre; advice on benefits; liaison with support group (e.g., MND Association) Nurse specialist Advice on PEG, RIG, NIPPV; follow-up of patients after admission to wards; out-reach to patients & community services Speech & language therapist Advice on communication, communication aids, swallowing, PEG & RIG Dietician Advice on nutrition, PEG, RIG Physiotherapist Advice on physical therapy, aids & appliances, referral to orthotist Occupational therapist Advice on activities of daily living, aids & appliances, modifications to home, social support; referral to orthotist Respiratory physician Assessment of ventilatory function; advice on NIPPV, tracheostomy Counseling team Psychological counseling & support; family therapy; bereavement support Neurologist Diagnosis, treatment (e.g., riluzole); symptom control; palliative care; integration of medical & social aspects of care; review of diagnosis Neurogeneticist Genetic counseling for familial MND &, genetic testing MND Association Information, equipment, advice on local services, benefits & rights, local volunteers; advocacy at personal, local & national levels Gastroeneterologist / radiologist Placement of PEG, RIG Neuropsychologist Assessment of cognitive function & Care of cognitively impaired patients Clinical Neurophysiologist EMG & nerve conduction studies Primary care physician Prescription & monitoring of drugs; coordination of care locally; symptom control; liaison with hospice/palliative care team Palliative care physician Assessment of need for home care, respite care &/or hospice care; symptom control; terminal care. PEG = Percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy/gastrojujonostomy RIG = Radiologically inserted gastrostomy MND = Motor neurone disease NIPPV = Non-invasive positive pressure ventilation EMG = Electromyography 344 Patient - Specific Problems to be addressed in a Comprehensive Treatment Plan for ALS Speech / communication Swallowing / salivation Sleep / fatigue Respiration Activities of daily living Ambulation Instruments & devices used to enhance speech & communication "Low tech" (e.g., paper/pencil, erasable pad) Communication board Typed communications Crespeaker (converts single words to speech) "Higher tech" instruments (e.g., Light Writer); anticipates word endings. Personal computers: Access to the internet Environmental controls Single letter or phrase through scanning & microswitches Voice preservation TDD (telecommunication device for the deaf); essential for anarthric patients General recommendations to enhance swallowing Assessment by speech pathologist Body weights at every visit Nutritional supplements for protein & caloric maintenance Thickeners for thin liquids Feeding tubes Causes & mechanisms of weight loss & malnutrition in MND Difficulty Bulbar dysfunction Weakness of jaw muscles Weakness/dysphagia (Eating slowly in company) Upper limb weakness Loss of appetite ‘MND cachexia‘ Main contributing factors Weakness of muscles of deglutition. Aspiration during swallowing Spasticity of muscles of deglutition Difficulty chewing Social embarrassment Inability to eat unaided Hypoventilation & respiratory failure; riluzole; depression Uncertain:? Hypermetabolic state The management of nutrition in MND comprises: Assessment & monitoring of dietary intake in relation to the energy, fluid, vitamin & mineral needs of the patient Advice on maintaining a healthy diet Monitoring of weight & anthropometric measures 345 Assessment of the need for & timing of percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy / gastrojejunostomy (PEG) or radiologically inserted gastrostomy (RIG) Advice on PEG or RIG feeding &care of feeding tubes Advantages & disadvantages of PEG, RIG, & NGT Hydration & Nutrition in MND patients Procedure PEG RIG NGT Advantages Standardized procedure for MND patients; risks & benefits well-documented; tubes widely available & standardized Only fine-bore NGT tube required (for introduction of Barium & air); sedation optional; seems to be tolerated well by patients with VC < 50%; can be used with NIPPV Minor, non-invasive procedure; possible to place in virtually all patients; good for maintaining hydration & avoiding IV fluids/feeding Disadvantages Requires sedation, introduction of endoscope tube, recumbency. Not recommended if VC < 50%; requires admission to hospital (2-5 days) Not yet standardized for MND (different tubes for PEG); requires T fasteners to hold stomach wall in place; sutures require removal at 10-14 days. Requires admission to hospital (2-5 days) Nasopharyngeal discomfort, pain or even ulceration; intrusive & unsightly for active patients; narrow diameter limits feeding Benefits & Risks of Gastrostomy Benefits Relatively easy insertion with local anesthesia Flexible dietary choices / delivery modes Bolus / continuous infusion Pureed / commercial liquid diet Diet administered in “normal meal time” Lower risk of cramps / diarrhea than with jejunostomy Risks & other considerations Possible regurgitation / aspiration Requires patient's head to be elevated after feeding Pharmacologic Management of Excessive Salivation Medication Amitriptyline (Tryptizol) Glyopyrrolate Imipramine (Tofranil) Methantheline Methylphenidate (Ritalin) Propantheline (Probanthene) Trihexphenidyl (artane) Dosing schedule* 10 mg hs or am and hs 1-2 mg q4h 50-200 mg hs 50-100 mg q4h 10-20 mg q6h 15-30 mg q4h 2-10 mg q4th *Usual adult dosage used as needed (prn) 346 Symptoms & Signs of Respiratory Insufficiency in MND Symptoms Orthopnoea Dyspnoea on exertion or talking Disturbed night time sleep Excessive daytime sleepiness Fatigue Anorexia Depression Poor concentration &/or memory Morning headache Signs Increased respiratory rate Use of accessory muscles Paradoxical movement of abdomen Decreased chest movement Sweating Hyperdynamic circulation Weight loss Respiratory Management of Patients with ALS Discuss respiratory complications & management options early in disease course Encourage patient / family involvement in major treatment decisions (including periodic review of "code status") Meticulous pulmonary toilet Pneumococcal / influenza vaccines Aggressive treatment of respiratory infections Maintenance of adequate nutritional status Regular monitoring of vital signs / measurement of FVC at every clinic visit Instruction concerning techniques to avoid aspiration Resistive inspiratory training Home use of noninvasive ventilatory assistive devices (e.g., IPPB, CPAP, BiPAP, chest cuirass) Tracheostomy & mechanical ventilation Pharmacologic management: Low-dose theophylline to increase respiratory muscle strength after resistive breathing; diuretics for fluid overload; nebulizer breathing treatments (e.g. Albuterol) to loosen secretions Current criteria for considering assisted ventilation: Patients should have 1. Symptoms relating to respiratory muscle weakness 2. Symptoms suggesting nocturnal hypoventilation 3. Evidence of respiratory muscle weakness 4. Evidence of nocturnal hypoventilation (abnormal polysomnography) Measures for Assisting in Activities of Daily Living Home visit at selected times Bathing Grab bars Chair / bench Handheld shower Toileting Raised toilet seat Grab bars 347 Dressing Assistive devices for buttons / zippers Casual, loose-fitting clothing with elastic waistbands Feeding Large - handled utensils Alternative food preparation (e.g., purees) Grasping Large handles “Reachers” Home management Assistances with shopping, household chores Interventions for Various Other Problems & Complications of ALS Head control Neck brace Rotator cuff tendinitis / impingement Range -of- motion exercises NSAIDs (nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs) Proper lifting by caregivers Painful cramps Quinine Diazepam (Valium) Phenytoin (Epanutin) Other pains Treat symptomatically Spasticity Baclofen (Lioresal) (orally or via implantable pump) Pseudobulbar affect Tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) SSRIs (selctive serotonin reuptake inhibitors) Airlie House Guidelines (ALS Clinical Trials Guidelines) Diagnosis Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria Primary & secondary disease end points Should conform to World Federation of Neurology El Escorial Criteria Sporadic & familial ALS patients can be entered, depending on trial 18-65 years old Evidence of disease progression during the 6 - month period from onset of symptoms, but not more than 5 years Significant sensory abnormalities, dementia, other neurologic disease, uncompansated medical illness, substance abuse, psychiatric illness; non investigational drugs concurrently Death or ventilator dependence, change in muscle strength Control arm; quality -of- life assessment, detailed statistical analysis 348 Compassionate release / treatment indications Information release Commercial concerns Should be used only when assessment of therapeutic efficacy of drug is not compromised Phase of trial Independent data safety monitoring board Phase I, II, III Include physicians & biostaticians Define at start of trial Should not distort conduct of trial Proposed Measurements for Substrates Involved in the Pathology & Functional Deficits in Patients with ALS Domain Pathology Substrate Motor neuron changes Motor neuron loss Corticospinal tract degeneration Strength loss Breathing Measurement (s) Ubiquitin-positive motor neurons Neurofilament-positive motor neurons Glial fibrillary acidic protein-positive corticospinal tract staining MVIC (tongue, limbs); inspiratory & expiratory Impairment force (diaphragm) Respiratory rate; FVC; SVC; PIF Spasticity Ashworth spasticity scale Fine coordination Alternate motion rates; Finger kinematics; motor performance tests; pegboard test Speech Intelligibility test, Frenshay test, ALSFRS Disability Swallowing Deglutition measurements by videofluroscopy or timing; ALSFRS Breathing ALSFRS Limb ALSFRS Loss of independence Sickness Impact Profile, Short Form 36 Handicap Death Survival ALSFRS = ALS functional rating scale; FVC = Forced vital capacity; MVIC = maximal voluntary isometric contraction; PIF = Peak inspiratory flow; SVC = Slow vital capacity Reasons for Performing EMG in ALS To ascertain findings that confirm LMN degeneration in regions with clinically identified involvement To identify LMN degeneration in clinically uninvolved regions To exclude other disorders EMG examinations should be performed in at least 2 muscles of different roots, cranial nerves or peripheral nerves & at least 2 or more of the 4 regions of involvement (bulbar, cervical, thoracic, lumbo sacral). The diagnosis of ALS is supported by the following EMG findings: Reduced recruitment (firing rate > 10 Hz) Large motor unit action potentials Fibrillation potentials Unstable, large motor unit action potentials Reduced motor unit action potentials 349 Reduced motor unit number estimates (MUNE) & increased macro-EMG unit action potentials Other Diagnostic Tests Performed in ALS The following diagnostic tests are not mandatory but can be used primarily to rule out other similar diseases, & secondarily as confirmatory tests Neuroimaging Ascertain findings that may exclude other disease processes Muscle biopsy Ascertain acute & chronic denervation Identify LMN degeneration in clinically uninvolved regions Laboratory tests CBC & serum chemistry panel Endocrine function tests (especially thyroid function tests) Heavy metals (do not perform unless there has been a definite history of exposure) GM1 antibodies (helpful when positive if patient has multifocal motor neuropathy) Therapeutic Agents in ALS Drug class Agents Status Riluzole (Rilutek) Approved Gabapentin (Neurontin) Phase III (approved as an AED) Vitamin E Preclinical Antioxidant CT-I Preclinical Neurotrophic factors IGF-I Phase III GDNF Phse I NT-3 Preclinical NT-4 Preclinical Axokine Preclinical ACT Preclinical Protease inhibitor PN-I Preclinical ACT = µ1-antichymotrypsin; BDNF = brain-derived neurotrophic factor; CT-I = cardiotrophin-I; IGF-I = insulin-like growth factor-I; GDNF = glial-derived neurotrophic factor; NT-3 = neurotrophic factor-3; NT-4 = neurotrophic factor-4; PN-I = protease nexin-I Antiglutamate Drug Treatment: Riluzole (Rilutek) Is it a useful drug in MND? Riluzole is a benzothiazole derivative with complex effects on glutamate neurotransmission including inhibition of presynaptic glutamate release Mechanisms of action of riluzole Effect o Blockade of presynatic glutamate release o NMDA receptor antagonism Mechanism Uncertain: ? effects on Na+ channels; activation of G-protein linked signal transduction Direct, non-competitive receptor blockade 350 o o o Inhibition of glutamate evoked Ca 2+ entry Prevention of neuronal depolarization ? Inhibition of apoptosis Activation of G-protein mediated signal transduction Inactivation of neuronal Na+ Channels Inhibition of stress-activated protein kinase (SAPkinase) Symptomatic Treatment of ALS Symptoms Weakness/ ambulation Exercise Activities of daily living Cramping Spasticity Pain Dysphagia/ swallowing/ weight loss Salivation Loss of speaking Assessment Anticipate need for & Introduce early; keep patients ambulatory as long as possible (independence) Controversial; may be of benefit in ALS; use strength testing as guide Home visits for assessment May cause sleep disturbance Not usually a major problem May cause sleep disturbance Speech pathologist; malnutrition can accelerate course of ALS Can result in laryngospasm or severe coughing Speech & communication Depression/insomnia May cause sleep disturbance Sleep disturbance May be related to leg movements or to myoclonus or apneas; do pulse oximetry or sleep study 351 Treatment Physical therapy, orthopedic & assistive devices, canes, walkers, specialized wheelchairs Exercise in grade 4 or 5 muscles only Safety devices for bath & toilet, dressing & feeding Assistive devices Quinine (Lioresal), diazepam, phenytoin Baclofen Analgesics, opiates, Transcutaneous electical nerve stimulation (TENS) Blenderized food, supplements, feeding tube, percutaneous gastrostomy (PEG) Suction machines; amitriptyline or atropine Paper & pencil, specialized voice ability synthesizers, Etran communications board, TDD (telecommunication device for the deaf), microcomputer-based instruments Antidepressants (offer universally), anxiolytics, electrically powered adjustable bed Clonazepam or Sinemet CR; ventilatory assistance (BiPAP or nasal CPAP) Respiratory/pulmonary weakness Measure FVC every visit; ventilator education Infections From decreased bronchial clearance of secretions Anticipate need; sooner if needs are present Hospice Antisecretory agents, cough medication, tracheostomy; BiPAP, CPAP, chest cuirass volume ventilators Antibiotics; prophylactic vaccines (pneumococcal, influenza) Some common symptoms in ALS & their treatment Symptoms Cramps Cause ? Changes in motor neurone Na+ channel function Treatment Quinine sulphate 200m bid Carbamazepine (Tegretol) Phenytoin (Epanutin) Magnesium Verapamil Corticospinal tract damage Baclofen 10-80mg daily Spasticity Tizanidine 6-24mg daily Dantrolene 25-100mg daily Intrathecal baclofen Memantine 10-60mg daily Bulbar weakness Atropine eye drops Sialorrhoea sub-lingual Atropine 0.25-0.75 mg tds (tabs/liquid) Benztropine (tabs/liquid) Benzhexol (tabs) Hyoscine (tabs/transdermal patches) Amitriptyline (Tryptizol) (tabs/liquid) Glycopyrrolate (liquid: sc/im/via PEG) Salivary gland irradiation Transtympanic neurectomy (?) Botox injection to salivary glands (?) Pseudobulbar syndrome Amitriptyline (Tryptizol) Emotional SSRIs (e.g., citalopram, Lability fluvoxamine) Agents Approved or Under Investigation for the Treatment of ALS Glutamate antagonists Riluzole (approved for the treatment of ALS) Gabapentin (commercially available for treatment of seizure disorders) Neurotrophic factors 352 Insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) Glial-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) Cardiotrophin-I (CT-1) Neurotrophin-3, neurotrophin-4 (NT-3, NT-4) Protease inhibitors 1Antichymotrypsin (ACT) Protease-nexin-1 (PN-1) Antioxidants Vitamin E Conclusions 1. People affected by MD (ALS) are best served by a multi-professional team approach that is 'user-centred'. New models of user-involvement are being developed. 2. Riluzole is associated with improved survival at 12 & 18 months, but the survival gain (estimated at 2-3 months at 18 months) beyond 18 months is unknown. Riluzole is safe & well-tolerated. 3. Recent trials of neurotrophic factors (e.g., subcutaneous & intrathecal BDNF) & related agents have been essentially negative. 4. PEG is associated with prolonged survival & improved nutrition but is hazardous in patients with VC <50% predicted. RIG may offer advantages over PEG in patients with low VC (<50%). 5. New evidence suggests that both survival & QL is improved by non-invasive positive pressure ventilation (NIPPV) but as yet there are no agreed criteria for initiating NIPPV. Currently 10-20% of patients in Europe have NIPPV but this varies widely in different centers. 6. Palliative care encompasses the entire course of MND, not only the final phase. Symptom control is important at all stages. 7. Advance directives are seldom but increasingly used in Europe. Ethical concerns about end of life decisions (e.g., ceasing ventilatory support: physician assisted suicide) are under debate. 353 354