Peet's Coffee & Tea: Who's Buying, Who Isn't, and Why X.460.6 Marketing Research March 7, 2016 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 3 RESEARCH QUESTION .......................................................................................................... 4 SURVEY INSTRUMENT .......................................................................................................... 5 SURVEY RESULTS ................................................................................................................ 8 RECOMMENDATIONS .......................................................................................................... 11 APPENDIX .......................................................................................................................... 13 ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................. 17 2 INTRODUCTION Specialty coffee refers to "the highest-quality green coffee beans roasted to their greatest flavor potential by true craftspeople and then properly brewed to well-establish standards,"1 and Peet's Coffee & Tea is known as the "grandfather of specialty coffee."2 Founded in 1966 by Alfred Peet, Peet's was originally a single store in Berkeley, California that specialized in roasting high-quality coffee. Now Peet's sells its fresh roasted coffee, hand-selected tea, and other related items in 112 retail stores across seven states, as well as through other distribution channels. Unlike Starbucks, one of Peet's main competitors, Peet's has been "content to hang on the sidelines and grow slowly"3 rather than focus on aggressively expanding across the United States. This has allowed the company to concentrate on being at the forefront of developing fresh, specialty coffee. A premium market for Peet's coffee is the baby boomer generation. This post-war generation is primarily made up of women age 50 or older, few minorities, and holders of a large amount of the nation's disposable income.4 "They are among the least interested in trying truly new foods, eating gourmet regularly…" says Elizabeth Sloan, and this makes them more likely to prefer an "old-fashioned" cup of coffee versus the kind of new gourmet coffee beverage one might find at a place like Starbucks. Currently, Peet's has several different ways of selling its whole bean and preground coffee: in its retail stores, through a mail order catalog program, online at 1 http://www.scaa.org/pdfs/Press-What-is-Specialty-Coffee.pdf http://www.peets.com/who_we_are/history_vine.asp 3 "Coffee Supplier's Cup Runneth Over with Plans to Widen Reach," Investor's Business Daily. 4 "Health Vending & Other Emerging Trends," Elizabeth Sloan. 2 3 peets.com, and wholesale at a variety of supermarkets and specialty grocery stores. In addition, Peet's sells directly to hotels and offices. Peet's whole bean coffee's pricing is the same whether sold online at www.peets.com or at their own retail stores. The prices range from $9.95 per pound for House Blend to $24.95 per half-pound of Reserve Coffee beans. At supermarkets like Safeway and Albertson's, Peet's is sold at $11.49 per 12ounce bag, except for House Blend, which is $10.29 per 12-ounce bag. Being a high quality, gourmet coffee that is in high demand, Peet's is usually located in a premium shelving location: close to the middle shelf, right within easy reach. By staying true to its traditional values of roasting coffee by hand, maintaining the highest level of bean freshness, and listening to the desires of their most loyal customers, Peet's has set itself apart from its competitors, especially within California. According to coffee industry analysts at Roth Capital Partners, "Peet's share of the specialty coffee segment is estimated at about 30 percent within California."5 RESEARCH QUESTION As mentioned previously, Peet's does very well with the baby boomer generation. Its focus on tradition and lasting quality are characteristics with which baby boomers closely identify and appreciate. But how is Peet's faring with other generations? Since such information is invaluable to how Peet's may wish to market itself in the future, the research question for this study is "Who is buying Peet's coffee? Why or why not." 5 "Peet's Growth Plan Stays Close to Home," Michele Chandler. 4 The study focuses mainly on coffee consumption in the San Francisco Bay Area, with the objective being to ascertain who is and is not buying Peet's whole bean or preground coffee. Does a particular age group buy Peet's coffee beans more than other age groups? How about a particular gender? And does one's income and home location affect this purchase decision? Additionally, the study examines some of the reasons behind why Peet's is and is not being purchased. For example, does a particular age group believe Peet's coffee is too expensive and that is why it is not being purchased? By examining these and similar questions, the study hopes to identify which population segments like and are familiar with Peet's, as well as which segments do not like and are unfamiliar with Peet's. SURVEY INSTRUMENT The survey is a self-administered online survey housed at SurveyShare.com. It contains a total of 12 questions that query one's consumption of coffee, other drinks of choice (if coffee is never consumed), and coffee bean purchase preferences. Pages five and six of this report contain the full text of the survey questions. Skip patterns are indicated by italicized brackets. 5 1. What is your gender? Male Female 2. What is your age? 18 to 24 25 to 34 35 to 44 45 to 54 55 or older 3. What is your annual household income? Less than $50,000 $50,000 to $99,999 $100,000 to $149,999 $150,000 to $199,999 $200,000 or more Decline to state 4. What best describes the area in which you live? City Rural Suburban 5. Do you drink coffee at all? Yes [skip to Question 7] No 6. Since you do not drink coffee, what beverages do you enjoy drinking the most? Milk [skip to end] Soda [skip to end] Tea [skip to end] Water [skip to end] Other (i.e., juice, sports drinks like Gatorade, alcoholic drinks, etc.) [skip to end] 7. What style of coffee do you buy most often? Whole beans Pre-ground beans Pod/Capsule Do not buy any type of beans because I do not brew my own coffee [skip to end] 8. What size bag of whole bean or pre-ground coffee do you usually buy? 1/2 pound bag 6 1 pound bag 2 pound bag or larger 9. Where do you most often buy your whole bean or pre-ground 8. What size bag of whole bean or pre-ground coffee do you usually buy? 1/2 pound bag 1 pound bag 2 pound bag or larger 9. Where do you most often buy your whole bean or pre-ground coffee? Discount or Warehouse store (e.g., Costco) Farmer's market Online Supermarket or Grocery store 10. Do you buy Peet's whole bean or pre-ground coffee? Yes [skip to Question 12] No 11. Why don't you Peet's whole bean or pre-ground coffee? Please only choose your main reason. Beans are overpriced/too expensive [skip to end] Beans brew coffee that is too strong [skip to end] Difficult to purchase (i.e., not sold everywhere) [skip to end] Have never heard of Peet's / Not familiar with Peet's [skip to end] Peet's caters to yuppies [skip to end] Peet's doesn't sell coffee pods/capsules [skip to end] Prefer beans from a different brand/company [skip to end] Too much variety to choose from [skip to end] 12. Why do you buy Peet's whole bean or pre-ground coffee? Please only choose your main reason. Beans are freshly roasted Beans are of a high quality Beans are well-priced Beans brew strong coffee Beans produce good coffee (i.e., full flavor, rich taste, etc.) Convenient for me to buy Good variety to choose from Peet's has a good reputation Peet's is environmentally friendly 7 Questions one through four are demographic questions that profile the respondents and allow for more in-depth analysis of latter questions. Question five is a filter question that ensures only respondents who drink coffee are asked questions that deal with the purchase coffee beans. Question six is asked only of those who say they do not drink coffee at all. Since Peet's is a purveyor of tea as well as coffee, question six is a part of the survey to see if tea is a drink of choice for those who do not drink coffee. Questions seven through nine examine one's preferences in style, bag size, and location/type of store when it comes to buying coffee beans. Lastly, questions ten through twelve delve into the specifics of who is buying Peet's coffee beans and the reasons behind this purchase decision. SURVEY RESULTS A total of 112 respondents completed the survey. This sample, which was one of convenience and not randomly select, is predominantly female (66%), 44 years old or younger (87%), earners of less than $100,000 a year (58%), and city dwellers (61%). Pivot Table #1 -- What beverage do you enjoy drinking the most [other than coffee]? (question 6) by Type of area live (question 4): Regardless of the type of area in which a respondent lives, the majority of non-coffee drinkers (56%) enjoy drinking water the most. Of the nine respondents who live in a city: 44% prefer water, 33% prefer juice/sports drinks, and 22% prefer soda. None of them chose tea. 8 Of the seven respondents who live in suburbia: 57% prefer water and 29% prefer juice/sports drinks. Once again, tea was not chosen, and neither was soda for this segment of the non-coffee drinking population. The one respondent who lives in a rural area chose water as the beverage he/she enjoys drinking the most. Pivot Table #2 -- Where do you most often buy your whole bean or pre-ground coffee? (question 9) by Income (question 3) and Type of area live (question 4): More than 80% of the people living in a city will buy coffee beans at a specialty store/café or supermarket. 38% of the people living in a suburban area will buy coffee beans at a specialty store/café. An additional 22% will buy coffee beans at a supermarket or discount club. Around 10% of people who live in either a city or suburban area will buy coffee beans online. There is a 50-50 split between specialty stores/cafés and supermarkets for where people earning less than $50,000 a year will buy their coffee beans. People earning $50,000-$99,999 a year tend to buy coffee beans at supermarkets. People earning more than $100,000 a year appear to prefer buying their coffee beans at specialty stores/cafés. Pivot Table #3 -- Do you buy Peet's whole bean or pre-ground coffee? (question 10) by Age (question 2) and Income (question 3): Regardless of income, 18-24 year olds are less likely to buy Peet's coffee beans, while 35-44 year olds are more likely to buy Peet's. Fewer 18-24 year olds with an annual household income of less than $50,000 buy Peet's beans (25% buy, 75% do not). More 35-44 year olds with an annual household income of at least $50,000 buy Peet's beans (71% buy, 29% do not). 9 Pivot Table #4 -- Why do you buy Peet's whole bean or pre-ground coffee? (question 11) by Gender (question 1) and Age (question 2): Of the 32 respondents who report buying Peet's coffee beans, most are female (72%) and between the ages of 25 and 44 (68%). Regardless of gender or age, the most popular reason for why our coffeedrinking respondents buy Peet's beans is because the beans produce good coffee that has a full flavor, good taste, etc. Those ages 25-44 are more concerned with buying beans that produce good coffee than those ages 18-24. For 18-24 year olds, buying beans of high quality and/or beans that produce strong coffee is more important to them. Pivot Table #5 -- Why do you not buy Peet's whole bean or pre-ground coffee? (question 12) by Age (question 1), Income (question 3) and Type of area live (question 4): 18-24 year olds find Peet's beans to be too expensive or difficult to purchase because they are not found everywhere. 25-34 year olds also do not buy Peet's beans because the beans are not sold everywhere, but their lack of familiarity with the Peet's brand is their predominant reason for not buying Peet's. Around 55% of the people living in a city earning less than $50,000 per annum will not buy Peet's because: o they either have not heard of it or they are not familiar with the brand. o the beans are too difficult to purchase because they are not sold everywhere. Other reasons for not buying Peet's are: o The beans are considered to be overpriced or too expensive. o Respondents prefer beans from other brand/company. Please see the Appendix for selected charts of these Pivot Table analyses. 10 RECOMMENDATIONS Based on the above data, Peet's should place its advertising focus on people who are getting married, looking to buy their first homes, and are settling down in their lives. In other words, Peet's should market to those who are in their mid-30s to mid-40s. With more disposable income than they had during their 20s and early-30s, this segment of the population is exhibiting many of the characteristics of the baby boomers Peet's has claimed is its premium market. That is, buying beans they know will produce good coffee is more important to those ages 35-44 than such other factors as convenience and price. Consequently, we recommend Peet's focus more on advertising and promoting coffee gift packages that may be bought as wedding and house warming gifts. These gift packages could include such items as coffee bean samplers, coffee grinders, a set of matching mugs, etc. Our survey has also shown that buying beans known to produce high quality coffee is important to coffee drinkers. As a result of this, we believe Peet's should advertise this point -- and the fact its beans are known for producing good coffee -- more strongly. If more coffee drinkers are made aware of Peet's high quality, good coffee, we think that will boost the company's sales figures. Furthermore, Peet's should consider expanding its distribution channel stores to places such as Whole Foods, Target, etc. Offering Peet's at Whole Foods might attract the attention of those who are more conscious of brand reputation and high quality beans. Offering Peet's at Target, meanwhile, might entice those who are younger and/or more price-conscious. Peet's should also consider expanding its $10.29 price point for a 12ounce bag to include other blends of beans aside from its House Blend. 11 Since the majority of the non-coffee drinkers who completed our survey said water is the beverage they enjoy drinking the most, we recommend Peet's stock bottles of water, as well as other non-coffee beverages, at its retail stores. This would allow Peet's to entice non-coffee drinkers into its stores, and that, in turn, would boost its sales and increase its reputation. Peet's might also want to consider partnering with a well-known distributor of high-quality bottled water, such as Evian, and offering this brand's water in its retail stores. In 2005, the University of California at Berkeley opened its own Peet's café as a campus restaurant near one of its existing dining areas.6 We believe Peet's needs to open similar cafés and retail stores around or in major colleges and universities to increase awareness of Peet's among 18-24 year olds. Implementing some sort of "college special" on beans at these cafés and stores may also help encourage 18-24 years old, who often have a limited budget, to buy Peet's coffee beans. In terms of future marketing research, we recommend this survey be conducted with a larger sample that has been randomly selected. Hopefully that will produce data that does not skew to those who are young and female, as the sample in our survey did. Focus groups should also be conducted with those who buy Peet's beans and those who do not for a more in-depth discussion of the exact reasons behind those purchase decisions. 6 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peet's 12 APPENDIX Figure 1. What beverage [other than coffee] do you enjoy the most? 12 # of respondents 10 8 6 4 2 0 Other (e.g. juice sports drinks like Gatorade alcoholic drinks etc.) Soda Tea Water Figure 2. Where most often buy coffee beans? by Type of City area live Rural Suburban 16 # of respondents 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Cafe or Specialty store Discount or Warehouse store (e.g. Costco) Farmer's market 13 Online Supermarket or Grocery store 14 # of respondents 14 12 Figure 4. Why buy Peet's beans? by Age 9 8 Peet's is environmentally friendly no Peet's has a good reputation Convenient for me to buy Beans produce good coffee (i.e. full flavor rich taste etc.) Beans brew strong coffee Beans are of a high quality Beans are freshly roasted # of respondents Figure 3. Do you buy Peet's beans? by Age 10 8 6 4 2 0 yes 18 25 35 45 55 to 24 to 34 to 44 to 54 or older 18 25 35 45 55 to 24 to 34 to 44 to 54 or older 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Figure 5. Why buy Peet's beans? by Income # of respondents 5 4 Less than $50 000 $50 000 to $99 999 $100 000 to $149 000 $150 000 to $199 999 $200 000 or more Decline to state 3 2 1 Figure 6. Why not buy Peet's beans? by Age 5 Peet's is environmentally friendly Peet's has a good reputation Convenient for me to buy Beans produce good coffee (i.e. full flavor rich taste etc.) Beans brew strong coffee Beans are of a high quality Beans are freshly roasted 0 18 25 35 45 55 to 24 to 34 to 44 to 54 or older # of respondents 4 3 2 1 0 Beans are overpriced/too expensive Beans brew coffee that is too strong Difficult to purchase (i.e. not sold everywhere) 15 Have never heard of Peet's / Not familiar with Peet's Prefer beans from a different brand/company Too much variety to choose from 16 6 5 Too much variety to choose from Prefer beans from a different brand/company Have never heard of Peet's / Not familiar with Peet's Difficult to purchase (i.e. not sold everywhere) Beans brew coffee that is too strong Beans are overpriced/too expensive # of respondents Figure 7. Why not buy Peet's? by Income Less than $50 000 $50 000 to $99 999 $100 000 to $149 000 $150 000 to $199 999 $200 000 or more Decline to state 4 3 2 1 0 ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY Journals and Magazines "Can Advocacy-led Certification Systems Transform Global Corporate Practices? Evidence, and Some Theory," Michael E. Conroy, Sept. 2001. This document discussed fair trade products, such as coffee, and international regulations that have been made or need to be made. It also lightly discussed trends in coffee. "Coffee and Music Create a Potent Mix at Starbucks," Steven Gray and Ethan Smith, Wall Street Journal, 19 July 2005. This article, originally published in WSJ, discusses Starbucks journey into the music industry. "Coffee, Coffee, Everywhere," Sam Whiting, San Francisco Chronicle, 7 May 2000. This article is about how, in the Bay Area, people still flock to Peet's for their coffee despite the influx coffee stores that have opened. "Coffee Supplier's Cup Runneth Over with Plans to Widen Reach," Marilyn Much, Investor's Business Daily, 11 Dec. 2002. This article in Investor's Business Daily is about Peet's move into selling coffee in supermarkets. "Health Vending & Other Emerging Trends," Elizabeth Sloan, Feb. 2005. This document discussed the transition of products being sold in vending machines from the traditional "junk food" to healthier foods. It also discussed the baby boomer generation as being more traditional and less likely to enjoy these foods, and that they relate to products that are "made just for you" such as Peet's Coffee & Tea. "Improving Packaging Production," Beverage Industry, 1 May 2002. This is an article about how Peet's went about improving the efficiency with which they package their beans. 17 "Peet's Growth Plan Stays Close to Home," Michele Chandler, San Jose Mercury News, 3 June 2005. This article discusses how Peet's has chosen a different expansion plan from that of Starbucks. Websites http://www.peets.com Peet's Coffee & Tea's corporate website. Offers a plethora of information on Peet's including its history and roasting technique. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peet%27s Wikipedia entry for Peet's. Provides an overview of the company's history, retail store operations, and current store locations. Peet's Coffee & Tea IPO, http://pro.edgar-online.com Text from Peet's IPO. http://www.starbucks.com Starbucks's corporate website. Provides information on their coffee, their drinks, their company mission statement, etc. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starbucks Wikipedia entry for Starbucks. Provides detailed information on the company's history, retail stores, ventures into music and movies, and criticisms and controversies. http://www.tully's.com Tully's Coffee's corporate website. Offers information on the company's history, wholesale ventures, press releases, etc. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tully%27s Wikipedia entry for Tully's. Provides a short overview of the company. 18 http://www.jcuea.org John Carroll University Entrepreneurs Association's explanation of how to create a SWOT analysis. http://www.coffeeresearch.org/ Website on coffee consumption and various statistics. http://earthtrends.wri.org Website on the changing face of coffee production and its environmental issues. http://www.drinks-business-review.com/ Website on drink research. http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Canopy/1290/basics.html Website on coffee trends. Books Uncommon Grounds: The History of Coffee and How It Transformed Our World (Paperback) by Mark Pendergrast. Coffee: A Dark History (Hardcover) by Antony Wild. The Coffee Book: Anatomy of an Industry from Crop to the Last Drop, Revised and Updated Edition (Paperback) by Gregory Dicum and Nina Luttinger. The Devil's Cup: A History of the World According to Coffee (Paperback) by Stewart Lee Allen. 19 Associations National Coffee Association of U.S.A., Inc. (NCA). Founded in 1911, NCA is one of the first trade associations for the U.S. coffee industry. NCA has helped American coffee companies through a variety of rough times by representing the U.S. coffee industry before the legislative and executive branches of government, including the U.S. Department of Agriculture, U.S. Trade Representative's Office, U.S. Food and Drug Administration and Congressional committees. Its members may be found throughout the United States, as well as overseas. NCA also produces Coffee Trax, a quarterly statistical report on the U.S. coffee market. The report offers 20 pages of charts, tables, and graphs focusing on exportable global coffee production. http://www.ncausa.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=1 Specialty Coffee Association of America (SCAA). The SCAA is the trade association for the specialty coffee industry. One of the SCAA's primary functions is to set the industry's standards for growing, roasting, and brewing. It offers membership to both coffee professionals and coffee enthusiasts. Members are provided with access to professional tools, training seminars, market research, and more. http://www.scaa.org 20