Introduction to unit This unit has been designed for year 10 groups studying PSHE with discrete Citizenship units, but not following a GCSE or other accredited programme. The unit helps to address areas 1 c and d, 2 a, b and c, 3 a and c of the Key Stage Four Programme of Study. This unit was designed to be taught in Citizenship lessons but also to complement the Edexcel RE GCSE course. The idea is that the Citizenship course covers all of the background social and political information, leaving the RE course more time to learn the religious opinions on the issues considered. Feedback from the RE department has been very positive. Starting the unit by considering how politics affects all of us in our daily lives was fairly successful at combating the attitude that politics is irrelevant (an attitude that the majority of my pupils have). It meant that I could refer back to that lesson during the unit if it seemed that pupils were switching off. I was concerned that the essay on voting systems might not work well, particularly as pupils at our school are not used to doing significant pieces of writing in Citizenship lessons. My strategies for dealing with this was linking it to RE, pitching it as an opportunity to practice skills learnt in English, and providing plenty of structure and support for those that needed it. The result was that most pupils produced good quality essays with a range of arguments and concluding with their own opinion. This gave me the opportunity to praise them, and to focus this praise on their citizenship skills. I think it also helped them to start valuing Citizenship as ‘real’ subject! The RE course looks at the Christian foundations of the British Welfare state and it was therefore important to look at Welfare state in some detail in the Citizenship unit. I initially had reservations about teaching the lessons on the welfare state, perhaps partly because it is not an area I know much about but it turned out to be one of the best parts of the unit. Firstly, the pupils enjoyed working out the solutions to the 5 evils. They usually came up with the solutions that were actually put in place from the 1940s onwards and this gave them a sense of achievement. Secondly, it was a topic that they all were able to engage in and had an opinion on as they all have some understanding of education, healthcare, housing, etc. When starting the Welfare state aspect, pupils were very interested to see pictures of their area in the 1940s, and were particularly shocked by the bomb damage. I would therefore recommend finding pictures of the area around your own school for this part. Pupils also enjoyed the debate on the NHS, but this only worked very well with classes that had some experience in debate. If I were teaching the unit again, I would spend more time on how to have a debate if the group were new to debating. Reference note on resources: The worksheet on first past the post and proportional representation is photocopied from the textbook ‘Government and Democracy’ in the PfP ‘Get Into Citizenship’ series The posters on how politics affects us use in Lesson One, and the political bingo activities used in Lessons 2 and 4 are taken from the Democracy cookbook. Additional PowerPoint Resource (in PDF format) Medium Term Plan – British Politics and the Welfare State Lesson Key questions Objectives What do you To consider how much pupils already 1 Activities British politics quiz Identifying activities and issues that are affected by politics already know about politics? How does politics affect your life? know about British politics To introduce the new unit of work To explore the ways in which politics affects pupils’ lives 2 What are MPs and what do they do? What qualities should an MP have? To identify the main roles of an MP To consider the qualities that an MP should have To design an MP Political bingo Discussion and card sort on attributes of an MP Design life size ideal MP 3 How do elections work? How are MP’s elected in Britain? What is proportional representation? To explain how Britain’s electoral system works To develop your own opinion about different voting systems To consider the arguments in favour and against different voting systems Mock voting Work out election results for FPTP and PR elections 4 Is proportional To identify and evaluate arguments representation a in favour and against proportional good or a bad idea? representation To compare proportional representation and first past the post To develop and justify our own opinions about proportional representation and first past the post Identify arguments in favour and against PR from sheet Produce balanced essay with own opinion 5 What is the Welfare state and why was it created? To explain why the Welfare State was set up in Britain To identify the key features of the Welfare State To express our own opinions about the Welfare State 6 What is your opinion of the current welfare state? To recap and develop our knowledge about the Welfare State To consider one part of the Welfare State in detail To develop debating, reasoning, and listening skills Identify problems in Britain now and in 1940s Use timeline to answer questions about welfare state Vote with your feet plenary Debate on whether or not the NHS should charge for medical treatment LESSON PLAN 1 Teacher’s Name: Subject: Miss Jarman Citizenship No. in Group No. of G&T 19 Day/Date: Class: No. on SEN Register: Thurs 20th April y 10 Mixed Ability: or Set Girls School Action 0 School Action Plus 1 8 No. EAL students below NC level 2: Period: 4 of Statemented 0 1 Unit/module of work: (Refer to SoW and NC PoS) British Politics Key ideas/questions/words: What do you already know about politics? How does politics affect your life? Is everything ‘radically political’? Politics, politician, prime minister, chancellor, etc. Learning objectives/We Are Learning To (WALT): Learning outcomes/What I’m Looking For (WILF): By the end of the lesson – 1 cd 2 abc 3ac To consider how much pupils already know about British politics To introduce the new unit of work To explore the ways in which politics affects pupils’ lives Support Staff(s)? Students? N/a No All should have considered how much they already know about politics, understood the connection between the unit and the RE GCSE, and identified a few ways in which politics affects their lives Most should have considered how much they already know about politics, understood the connection between the unit and the RE GCSE course and identified how politics affects numerous different aspects of their lives A few should also have begun to question and consider the benefits and disadvantages of the ways in which politics affects their lives, and the ways in which they can affect politics Literacy focus Group talk, reading for meaning Time Core lesson content Core Teaching/Learning approaches Strategies to meet range of learning needs eg. Less able/more able/EAL, use of SIP Assessment: what/how/who? 10m Starter: British politics quiz Individual work on sheet or read out by teacher Less able pupils may work in pairs to answer questions Extension for more able: brainstorm their opinion of politics Audio visual powerpoint presentation for answers Pupils to feedback answers, teachers to provide correct answers – immediate oral feedback 10m Introduction of new unit Teacher to explain connection between unit of work and RE GCSE (explain has been used in other schools to boost exam grades while meeting legal requirement to learn about Citizenship) Teacher to start brief Audio visual presentation using powerpoint to facilitate understanding Teacher to check understanding by asking questions, no hands up discussion on what pupils think about politics. 15m Main activity: Step 1 Introduce Rousseau quotation: ‘Everything is radically political’. Pupils will decide if they agree. Pupils to work in pairs or groups to brainstorm some of the things which are important to them, activities that they do everyday, etc. Divide into two categories: Things that are affected by politics, things which are not. 15m Main activity: Step 2 Teacher to provide copies of posters about how politics affects where you live, sport, music, etc. Pupils use information to see if they should move any of the activities/issues to different category, and can they identify other things that are affected by politics. 10m Plenary: Class discussion Is everything radically political? Pupil discussion to feedback work. None to be set Homework: All: Most: A few: Risk assessment/Health and Safety Teacher to ensure appropriate groupings of students, to circulate in class to provide support for less able and to encourage more able to think more deeply about the issues raised Sheet to provide more structure and examples for less able and EAL EAL Target Teacher to ensure appropriate groupings of students, to circulate in class to provide support for less able and to encourage more able to think more deeply about the issues raised Sheet to provide more structure and examples for less able and EAL EAL target Differentiated questioning Choose a pupil to facilitate the discussion to extend able pupil Immediate feedback while circulating, and books to be marked after lesson Immediate feedback while circulating, and books to be marked after lesson Immediate verbal feedback from teacher and from peers Other links as appropriate e.g. numeracy/SMSC BRITISH POLITICS How much do you already know? Take a guess if you aren’t sure. 1. Who is the Prime Minister? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… 2. Which are the 3 main political parties? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 3. Who is the Minister for Education? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 4. Who is the leader of the opposition? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5. Who is the Head of State? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 6. How many MPs are there? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 7. Who is the Chancellor of the Exchequer? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 8. How often is a General Election held? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 9. Who can vote in an election? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 10. Who is your MP? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. LESSON PLAN 2 Teacher’s Name: Subject: Miss Jarman Citizenship No. in Group No. of G&T 19 Day/Date: Class: No. on SEN Register: Thurs 27th April y 10 Mixed Ability: or Set Girls School Action 0 School Action Plus 1 8 Period: No. EAL students below NC level 2: 4 of Statemented 0 1 Unit/module of work: (Refer to SoW and NC PoS) British Politics Key ideas/questions/words: What are MPs and what do they do? What qualities should an MP have? Learning objectives/We Are Learning To (WALT): Learning outcomes/What I’m Looking For (WILF): By the end of the lesson – 1 cd 2 abc 3ac To identify the main roles of an MP To consider the qualities that an MP should have To design an MP Support Staff(s)? Students? NY All should be able to identify some of the main roles of an MP and list some of the qualities that they think an MP should have Most should be able to identify several roles of an MP, and explain some of the qualities they think an MP should have A few should also begin to apply this knowledge to evaluate the work of current MPs Literacy focus Group talk, reading for meaning Time Core lesson content Core Teaching/Learning approaches Strategies to meet range of learning needs eg. Less able/more able/EAL, use of SIP Assessment: what/how/who? 10m Starter: Political bingo Individual work to complete work sheet Kinaesthetic task Teacher to explain any unfamiliar words on sheet Pupils to feedback answers, immediate oral feedback 10m Introduction to role of MPs, WALT Teacher to introduce WALT, explain the different types of political representatives in the UK, and give brief introduction to the role of an MP Pupils write down 5 main roles of an MP in their own words. 10m Main activity: Step 1 Pupils work in groups to choose the top 10 attributes of an MP Audio visual presentation using powerpoint Writing frame for less able for roles of an MP Teacher to ensure appropriate groupings for activity Pupils to assign roles in group – leader, reporter. Teacher to circulate to ensure participation and to encourage more able students to articulate reasons for their decisions NY to explain key words to Teacher to check understanding by asking questions, no hands up Books to be marked after lesson Immediate feedback while circulating 20m Main activity: Step 2 Pupils work in groups to design their ‘perfect’ MP (Resources needed – paper, pens, etc) 10m Plenary: Display, explain and discuss Mp design work Reporter from each group explains the choices made by their group, other pupils in class to make comments, ask questions Homework: ‘Meaningful encounters’ worksheet All: To complete first task Most: A few: To complete extended report Risk assessment/Health and Safety Visual task – accessible for all abilities Different expectation in terms of work completed NY to target group and to circulate for support Visual display of work to facilitate understanding Immediate feedback from teacher while circulating – will receive feedback from peers during plenary Immediate verbal feedback from teacher and from peers Other links as appropriate e.g. numeracy/SMSC RE GCSE How does politics affect your life? First think of some things that are important to you, and some things that you do each day. Examples: your family, go to school, listen to music, play football. Now decide for each idea whether it is affected by politics at all. Example: School is affected by politics because the government has made a law that you have to go to school. Make two lists with these titles: ‘Things that are affected by politics’ ‘Things that are not affected by politics’ How does politics affect your life? First think of some things that are important to you, and some things that you do each day. Examples: your family, go to school, listen to music, play football. Now decide for each idea whether it is affected by politics at all. Example: School is affected by politics because the government has made a law that you have to go to school. Make two lists with these titles: ‘Things that are affected by politics’ ‘Things that are not affected by politics’ LESSON PLAN 3 Teacher’s Name: Subject: Miss Jarman Citizenship No. in Group No. of G&T 19 Day/Date: Class: No. on SEN Register: Thurs 4th May Period: y 10 Mixed Ability: or Set Girls School Action 0 School Action Plus 1 8 No. EAL students below NC level 2: 4 of Statemented 0 1 Unit/module of work: (Refer to SoW and NC PoS) British politics Key ideas/questions/words: How do elections work? How are MP’s elected in Britain? What is proportional representation? Learning objectives/We Are Learning To (WALT): To explain how Britain’s electoral system works To develop your own opinion about different voting systems To consider the arguments in favour and against different voting systems Learning outcomes/What I’m Looking For (WILF): By the end of the lesson – All should be able to explain how we vote in elections and what the first past the post system is Most should also be able to explain what proportional representation is, how it is different from FPTP, and should be able to give an opinion on the different systems A few should also have begun to weigh up the arguments for and against each system and be able to give a well reasoned argument to support their opinion Support Staff(s)? Students? Literacy focus Language for arguments and opinions 1 cd 2 abc 3ac NY Time Core lesson content Core Teaching/Learning approaches Strategies to meet range of learning needs eg. Less able/more able/EAL, use of SIP Assessment: what/how/who? 5m Starter: Vote for biscuits! Individual task to introduce the topic (Crick – voting is a habit…) Teacher to explain clearly to less able/EAL pupils Votes to be counted during lesson 10m Introduction: WALT, explain First past the post voting system, explain activities Teacher talk with powerpoint presentation, and questioning to check for understanding Differentiated questioning Written and spoken instructions for clarity Immediate verbal feedback 15m Main activity 1: First Past the Post activity Worksheet based individual written work in exercise book Table provided for less able to stick into book rather than copy One or two students to be given responsibility for counting starter votes NY to support Teacher to circulate and provide immediate verbal feedback and work to be marked in book 5m Mid lesson plenary Feedback answers from first activity and explain proportional representation Differentiated questioning Immediate verbal feedback 15m Main activity 2: Proportional Worksheet based individual written work Table provided for less able to stick into book rather than copy Teacher to circulate and 10m Representation in exercise book Plenary: Class discussion Teacher to explain that next lesson will be extended writing task on voting systems and set homework Feedback from PR activity What do you think of FPTP and PR? Which is fairer? What are the advantages and disadvantages? Extension work – arguments for and against proportional representation NY to support Differentiated questioning Push more able pupils to develop their opinion and support with evidence provide immediate verbal feedback and work to be marked in book Immediate verbal feedback Homework: Research on proportional representation All: Most: A few: Risk assessment/Health and Safety Other links as appropriate e.g. numeracy/SMSC Numeracy RE GCSE Candidate Vote Chocolate chip cookies Jammy dodgers Digestives Candidate Chocolate chip cookies Jammy dodgers Digestives Vote Dartmouth Colchester Blackburn Party Andover Constituency Total votes for each party Seats gained under PR if 1 seat for every 250 votes Total votes for each party Seats gained under PR if 1 seat for every 250 votes Yellow Party Pink Party Purple party Winning party Yellow Party Pink Party Purple party Winning party Dartmouth Colchester Blackburn Party Andover Constituency LESSON PLAN 4 Teacher’s Name: Subject: Miss Jarman Citizenship No. in Group No. of G&T 19 Day/Date: Class: No. on SEN Register: Thurs 18th May y 10 Mixed Ability: or Set Girls School Action 0 School Action Plus 1 8 No. EAL students below NC level 2: Period: 4 of Statemented 0 1 Unit/module of work: (Refer to SoW and NC PoS) British Politics Key ideas/questions/words: Is proportional representation a good or a bad idea? Learning objectives/We Are Learning To (WALT): To identify and evaluate arguments in favour and against proportional representation To compare proportional representation and first past the post To develop and justify our own opinions about proportional representation and first past the post Learning outcomes/What I’m Looking For (WILF): By the end of the lesson – All should have identified 5 arguments in favour and 5 arguments against PR and have used these to construct an essay Most should have evaluated some of the arguments in favour and against PR in their essay, and have developed and justified their own opinion about PR A few should have thoroughly evaluated the arguments in favour and against PR and have developed and justified their opinion about PR Support Staff(s)? Students? Literacy focus Extended writing, justifying a personal opinion 1 cd 2 abc 3ac Time Core lesson content Core Teaching/Learning approaches Strategies to meet range of learning needs eg. Less able/more able/EAL, use of SIP Assessment: what/how/who? 5m Starter: British politics keyword bingo Individual work on worksheet to recap some of the keywords from the unit that they may need in the lesson Differentiated starter worksheets: some letters completed for EAL and less able students to allow them to complete more easily, extension task provided Answers to be fed back to whole class, pupils to correct 5m Introduction: Teacher to explain WALT and WILF Teacher talk with powerpoint presentation and questioning to check for understanding Audio visual presentation – instructions written and spoken for clarity Teacher to check for understanding 10m Main activity 1: Arguments in favour and against PR Work in pairs to divide arguments on worksheet into for and against, then to put into order of importance Less able and kinaesthetic learners can be given scissors and glue to physically divide the arguments NY to support Worksheet with images Teacher to push more able pupils to explain their choices Teacher to circulate and give immediate verbal feedback 5m Mid lesson plenary Whole class to feedback answers and opinions and teacher to explain extended writing task Instructions for task on powerpoint as well as on paper, written and spoken to help all to understand Teacher to question to check for understanding 30m Main activity 2: extended writing task Individual written work in books Writing frame provided for less able and EAL pupils, with keywords at the bottom NY to support Sheet provided explaining how to write an excellent piece – teacher to make high expectations of written work clear to more able pupils Teacher to mark written pieces after lesson. Peer assessment during plenary. 5m Plenary Teacher to ensure appropriate pairings Peer assessment task Pupils swap books to read each others work and identify one good thing about their partner’s work and one point for development, share with each other, and some to share with whole class None to be set Homework: All: Most: A few: Risk assessment/Health and Safety Other links as appropriate e.g. numeracy/SMSC RE GCSE ‘PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION WOULD BE A BETTER SYSTEM THAN FIRST PAST THE POST’. YOU AGREE WITH THIS STATEMENT? HOW FAR DO How to write a brilliant essay… Plan your essay before you start Include a clear introduction and conclusion Use PEE – point, explanation, example Use and explain key words Use all of the arguments from the first activity but explain them in your own words Analyse why some arguments are stronger or weaker Explain why you agree or disagree with each argument Consider whether PR would make the government more representative of what voters want Pay attention to spelling and grammar Proof read your work when you are finished ‘PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION WOULD BE A BETTER SYSTEM THAN FIRST PAST THE POST’. YOU AGREE WITH THIS STATEMENT? HOW FAR DO How to write a brilliant essay… Plan your essay before you start Include a clear introduction and conclusion Use PEE – point, explanation, example Use and explain key words Use all of the arguments from the first activity but explain them in your own words Analyse why some arguments are stronger or weaker Explain why you agree or disagree with each argument Consider whether PR would make the government more representative of what voters want Pay attention to spelling and grammar Proof read your work when you are finished ‘PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION WOULD BE A BETTER SYSTEM THAN FIRST PAST THE POST’. YOU AGREE WITH THIS STATEMENT? HOW FAR DO Use this writing frame to help you write an essay that answers the question above. Proportional representation and first past the post are two different ways of electing MPs. Proportional representation means… First past the post means… Some people argue that proportional representation is better that first past the post because… (use some of the arguments in favour of PR from the first activity) However, other people disagree because… (use some of the arguments against PR from the first activity) I agree/disagree that proportional representation would be a better system than first past the post because… Keywords Proportional representation: adding up all the votes that a party has got from all over the country and giving out places in parliament based on the proportion (percentage %) of the votes the party got First past the post: whoever gets the most votes wins Constituency: the area that an MP represents Coalition: when two or more parties agree to share power and form a government together LESSON PLAN 5 Teacher’s Name: Subject: Miss Jarman Citizenship No. in Group No. of G&T 19 Day/Date: Class: No. on SEN Register: Thurs 8th June Period: y 10 Mixed Ability: or Set Girls School Action 0 School Action Plus 1 8 No. EAL students below NC level 2: 4 of Statemented 0 1 Unit/module of work: (Refer to SoW and NC PoS) British Politics Key ideas/questions/words: What is the Welfare state and why was it created? Learning objectives/We Are Learning To (WALT): Learning outcomes/What I’m Looking For (WILF): By the end of the lesson – 1 cd 2 abc 3ac To explain why the Welfare State was set up in Britain To identify the key features of the Welfare State To express our own opinions about the Welfare State Support Staff(s)? Students? NY All should be able to identify the 5 giant evils, and the key features of the welfare state Most should be able to identify and explain the 5 giant evils, identify the key features of the welfare state, and express their own opinion about the some aspects of the current welfare state A few should also be able to justify their opinions about the welfare state and support it with evidence Literacy focus Group talk, reading for meaning Time Core lesson content Core Teaching/Learning approaches Strategies to meet range of learning needs eg. Less able/more able/EAL, use of SIP Assessment: what/how/who? 10m Starter: What do you think are the 5 biggest problems in Britain at the moment? Individuals write ideas on post-it notes, then choose 5 as a group, then group them on the board for everyone to see and compare Extension for groups that finish quickly to put the problems into order of importance Partly kinaesthetic task NY to support Teachers to circulate to listen for useful group talk Pupils to feedback answers, immediate oral feedback 10m Introduction by teacher Use power point presentation to show problems Britain faced in the 1940s, introduce Beveridge report and 5 giant evils Pupils listen and then match and copy the 5 giant evils Images on presentation to facilitate understanding Printed copy of 5 giant evils for less able and EAL pupils Teacher to check understanding by asking questions 10m Main activity 1: What would you do about each of the 5 giant evils? Pair work to decide what they would do for each, record answers in book Table for less able to complete for clarity Extension: how would you pay for each of the changes you have decided on? Immediate feedback while circulating Different expectation in terms of work produced 20m 10m Main activity 2: Use timeline to identify the key features of the welfare state Individual work in book, questions on board Plenary: Vote with your feet Controversial statements on board, pupils stand along the line of agree and disagree None to be set Homework: All: Most: A few: Risk assessment/Health and Safety Table for less able to complete for clarity Different expectation of work completed – everyone to complete questions 1 and 2, some to complete 3 and 4 Support from NY Immediate feedback from teacher while circulating and work to be marked after lesson Kinaesthetic task Support from NY Immediate verbal feedback from teacher and from peers Other links as appropriate e.g. numeracy/SMSC RE GCSE The 5 Giant Evils Want Ignorance Squalor Disease Idleness What does it mean? What would you do about it? What does the Welfare State do about it? Do you think it has worked? THE WELFARE STATE TIMELINE 1939 Second World War begins 1942 Beveridge report identifies 5 giant evils 1944 The Butler Act makes secondary education compulsory and raises the school leaving age to 15 1945 Second World War ends Family Allowance Act gives payments directly to the mother in order to benefit the children Mass building of council housing estates 1946 ‘New Towns’ project begins to build new towns in place of war damage and slums, with better living conditions and green spaces National Insurance Act -One of the main acts that creates the Welfare State provides money for sickness, unemployment, maternity and pensions as everyone has to contribute – workers and employer - with employees contributing up to 5% of their wages. School Milk act provides one third of a pint of milk free to all school children under 18 1948 The National Health Service is created to provide free health care for everyone in the country 1952 Elizabeth II becomes queen 1979 Margaret Thatcher is elected as prime Minister for the Conservative Party – they reduce the provision of services 1980 Unemployment at highest rate since 1936 LESSON PLAN 6 Teacher’s Name: Subject: Miss Jarman Citizenship No. in Group No. of G&T 19 Day/Date: Class: No. on SEN Register: Thurs 15th June y 10 Mixed Ability: or Set Girls School Action 0 School Action Plus 1 8 No. EAL students below NC level 2: Period: 4 of Statemented 0 1 Unit/module of work: (Refer to SoW and NC PoS) British Politics Key ideas/questions/words: What is the Welfare state and why was it created? What is your opinion of the current welfare state? Learning objectives/We Are Learning To (WALT): Learning outcomes/What I’m Looking For (WILF): By the end of the lesson – 1 cd 2 abc 3ac To recap and develop our knowledge about the Welfare State To consider one part of the Welfare State in detail To develop debating, reasoning, and listening skills All should be able to recall basic facts about the Welfare state, express a simple opinion about the NHS, locate some useful information in the texts provided and contribute at least one relevant point to the debate Most should be able to recall all of the key facts about the welfare state, express and explain an opinion about the NHS, locate a range of useful information in the texts provided and contribute several relevant points to the debate A few should also demonstrate sophisticated debating skills particularly in terms of response to other people’s arguments, and synthesis of points raised Support Staff(s)? NY (EAL specialist teacher – working in partnership) Students? Literacy focus active listening to understand, persuasive language, reading to extract key information, oral skills Time Core lesson content Core Teaching/Learning approaches Strategies to meet range of learning needs eg. Less able/more able/EAL, use of SIP Assessment: what/how/who? 5m Starter: What is your opinion of the NHS? Individual written work – one sentence to explain opinion More able pupils must give an explanation Sentence structure shown on board NY to support Teachers to circulate to read responses, and some pupils to share with whole group - immediate oral feedback 10m Introduction by teacher using power point presentation Images on presentation to facilitate understanding and prompt all pupils NY to support and whole class Kinaesthetic task to engage pupils Teacher to check understanding by asking questions 15m Main activity 1: Debate preparation Pupils listen and respond to recap questions and task explanation Pupils write name on post it note and place on line of agreement Pupils work in two teams to select and Teachers to target less able pupils to ensure understanding, and check that the groups are Immediate feedback while prepare arguments 20m Main activity 2: Debate on ‘The NHS should charge patients for medical treatment’ 2 minute presentation by each team followed by open debate dividing tasks in a way that facilitates everyone’s participation A range of texts provided for differentiation, and a glossary of difficult words in the texts Preparation time means that all pupils should be able to contribute at least one point Differentiation in terms of expectation of performance in debate Support for all from NY circulating – checking that the groups are following the ‘tips for success’ on handout Teacher will be observing performance of all pupils, particularly looking at how well they are able to explain and justify an argument or opinion, and how well they participate Differentiated questioning Kinaesthetic task to engage pupils Plenary: What Whole class feedback Immediate verbal Support from NY went well, what on how well the debate feedback from needs to be went. teacher and from improved? Has the Repeat introduction peers debate changed activity to see if our opinions? Did opinions have changed. we meet our aims? Homework: To research the place that you will be doing your work experience placement All: Most: A few: Risk assessment/Health and Safety Other links as appropriate e.g. numeracy/SMSC 10m RE GCSE THE NHS SHOULD CHARGE PATIENTS FOR MEDICAL TREATMENT Your team will argue against this statement You need to prepare a two minute presentation which will explain your main arguments against the statement. You can decide whether one person gives the presentation, or you share the task between you. You also need to have several more arguments ready for the open debate. Everyone should aim to make at least one contribution to this debate. Use the newspaper articles, and your own ideas, to prepare for the debate. You can highlight key points, underline with different colours, make notes in your book, cut up the articles, etc. Decide what will be most useful for your team. Tips for success: Divide the tasks up in your team Make sure everyone participates Support your arguments with evidence Explain your arguments Listen carefully to the other team so that you can respond to what they say Use persuasive language THE NHS SHOULD CHARGE PATIENTS FOR MEDICAL TREATMENT Your team will argue in favour of this statement You need to prepare a two minute presentation which will explain your main arguments in favour of the statement. You can decide whether one person gives the presentation, or you share the task between you. You also need to have several more arguments ready for the open debate. Everyone should aim to make at least one contribution to this debate. Use the newspaper articles, and your own ideas, to prepare for the debate. You can highlight key points, underline with different colours, make notes in your book, cut up the articles, etc. Decide what will be most useful for your team. Tips for success: Divide the tasks up in your team Make sure everyone participates Support your arguments with evidence Explain your arguments Listen carefully to the other team so that you can respond to what they say Use persuasive language