Real Estate Markets Markets are the means by which buyers and sellers trade goods and services. The real estate market can be broken down into space markets and asset markets. Space Markets – the mechanism for trading the rights to use land and buildings 1. Demand for space is created by those who are willing to pay for the use of space 2. Supply for space is provided by those willing to sell the rights that they own to the users Space markets can be categorized by type of use: 1. Office Space Class A – Superior quality and location that command the highest rents Class B – Highly desirable, but lacking attributes that would otherwise command top dollar Class C – Buildings with few amenities but are in good condition and are modestly priced Class D – Buildings with few amenities in poor locations and generally poor condition 2. Retail Space Freestanding retail – single tenant buildings Neighborhood center – serve a relatively small population within a 1½ mile radius often anchored by a supermarket with other stores providing convenience goods and personal services, such as strip centers (Oak Park Village on N. New Branfels) Community center – serves a larger trade area within a 3-5 mile radius with a wider variety of stores often anchored by a department store (De Zavala/I-10 area or the Colonnade at Wurzbach/I-10) Regional center – serves an area within a 7-12 mile radius often in the form of enclosed malls and anchored by two or more department stores (North Star, Windsor malls) Superregional center – serves areas of up to 50 miles in radius with a tremendous range of products and services (San Marcos outlet) 3. Industrial Space Warehouse and distribution Manufacturing and production Materials processing 4. Agricultural Space Annual and perennial cropland Livestock facilities and grazing 5. Lodging Space Highway motels – Motel 6 Convention/business hotels (have convention space) – Marriott Luxury hotels – La Mansion on the Riverwalk Extended stay hotels/motels (apartments) – Warren Inn Resort or destination hotels – Hyatt Hill Country 6. Residential Space Single family detached homes Single family attached homes (condos, co-ops and townhouses) Manufactured homes Multi-family apartments The demand for real estate space is represented as are all demand curves – a downward sloping line in which the quantity demanded decreases as price increases. The supply for real estate space is somewhat different than the typical supply curve in which the supply increases as the price increases. This is due to the long-term nature of real estate space in which quantity cannot be quickly adjusted changes in demand (see Figure 8.2 on page 157). Figure 8.3 depicts the short-term nature of changes in demand. A drop in demand immediately results in a drop in price since the quantity of available real estate is fixed. An increase in demand will result in an increase in prices (extended the vertical quantity line up until it intersects with the D1 demand curve to see where the equilibrium price P** would be). Longer term, the supply curve is upward sloping as older buildings are replaced with higher density construction. Asset Markets – the market for cash flow rights to real estate ownership (value) Capital Markets – the market for long-term (more than one year) assets. This includes stocks and bonds as well as real estate. Public markets o Publicly traded stocks (equity), bonds and money market (less than one year) instruments o REITs (real estate investment trusts) – invest in real property o Mutual Funds – invest in stocks and bonds (and other financial assets) Private markets o Real property o Privately-held companies o Partnerships (oil and gas, leasing) o Bank loans o Individual mortgages (as opposed to mortgage backed securities, which are publicly traded securities backed, or “securitized”, by mortgages) o Private (venture) debt Like all assets, both real and financial, market prices are determined by 1. Cost of capital (an opportunity cost) – this refers to the fact that investors have alternative investment opportunities in which to earn a rate of return on their invested capital. Thus, investors look at the rates of return that can be earned elsewhere before making an investment in a specific asset. 2. Expectations of future cash flows (which reflect growth opportunities) – how much an investor is willing to pay for an asset is a function of the future cash flows that they can anticipate realizing from the investment. This includes both increases (growth) as well as decreases (decline) in cash flows. 3. Risk – the risk related to the investment is an important consideration in order to compare apples to apples. Clearly, an investment in a government bond has no risk associated with the payments by the government, whereas investment in mortgages has default risk and investment in stocks or real property has uncertainty of cash flows in general due to the residual nature of the ownership claim. As will be seen later, the higher the risk of an investment, everything else the same, the lower price that investors are willing to pay since investors are riskaverse. The definition of “fair market value” can be described as the price at which an asset trades between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither of whom is under compulsion to buy or sell, and both of whom are knowledgeable of the risks and future prospects of the asset The relationship between the Space Market and the Asset Market in real estate is tied together through the cash flows. The price at which the use of real estate space is sold is a function of supply and demand which determines rent. In addition, economic circumstances beyond the supply and demand for space determine the costs of providing space. The difference between rents and costs represent the cash flows available to investors which are valued in the asset market. Economic circumstances in other markets also impact the opportunity cost of capital and, hence, the value of real estate assets and the allocation of capital to providing additional space (supply) in the space market. Real Estate Market Analysis – study of the supply and demand sides of a real estate space market Revenue Considerations: o o o o o o o o Rents – what can be charged to tenants (competitors’ rents) Vacancy rate Amount of competing space currently and anticipated Rate of absorption of space Number of units/floor space on the property Location Type of building Growth prospects All of these factors are interrelated. The term “months supply” of property refers to how long it will take before demand fills a given supply of real estate space. It can be defined as Months Supply Vacant Space Space under Constructi on Net Absorption per Month This is one measure of the desirability of adding new space since it is directly impacts the revenue stream that can be anticipated from development. Important considerations by market segment for revenues: 1. Office Space – employment in occupations requiring office space 2. Lodging – air passenger volume, highway traffic counts, tourism receipts, number of visitors 3. Retail – per capita income, aggregate income 4. Industrial – manufacturing employment, shipping volume 5. Apartments – population, household formation, housing affordability, employment growth 6. Owner-occupied residential – population, household formation, interest rates, employment growth, income growth, apartment rents