MEMORANDUM FOR RECORD SUBJECT: Proceedings – Air Force Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Session GENERAL The Air Force Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Session began at 1:00 p.m. on February 22, 2006 at the Holiday Inn, Pooler Georgia. The Savannah Combat Readiness Training Center, Georgia Air National Guard hosted the meeting and provided excellent support. A. COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS FOR THE AFTERNOON OF FEBRUARY 22, 2006 1. Welcoming Remarks/Introductions - Major General George Patrick (Special Assistant to Chief, National Guard Bureau), Co-Chairman of the Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council, welcomed everyone to the meeting and stated this process would help define better ways of working airspace issues. He relayed that the military is working issues to include the BRAC process, changing the mix of aircraft, use of UAS systems, the QDR, Transformation and the War on Terror. The QDR defines military aviation for the next 4-6 years and we need to be looking out 20 years in the future. 2. National Overview – Brigadier General Michael Akey (Commander, Massachusetts Air National Guard), Co-Chairman of the National Airspace/Range Council. He emphasized that airspace is a National asset, and said this management forum is intended to resolve issues and develop action items. Over the last 15 years, this Council has evolved to try to meet the changing demands of new aircraft and technologies. 3. Unit Operations Briefings – Lt Colonel Tom Moore (NGB/A3A) recognized each flying unit in the SO-SW region and introduced those unit representatives that were in attendance for their comments: Sheppard AFB (T-37and T-38) – Captain Oystein Vollstad (80 OSS/80 GTW) UPT Training, Instructor Pilot Training 250 sorties daily, 50/50 mix Use the Westover, Hollis, Washita and Sheppard 1&2 MOAs Use 300NM radius for instrument training Carswell AFB – Mr. Joseph LeBlanc (301 OG/SUA) The unit utilizes Brady and Brownwood Military Operations Areas (MOA). Deconfliction of low level training routes is accomplished by calling route schedulers. Laughlin AFB (T-38, T-1, T-6) - Captain Jeff Isgett Highest amount of undergraduate pilot training Looking at airspace expansion They have the largest student enrollment and the smallest airspace Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 1 Awaiting BRAC initiative to see fall-out 149 FW (F-16s) Kelly AFB, TX – Colonel John Nichols (149 FW/CC) F-16 training unit The ANG unit at Ellington (Houston) also has F-16s The Predator mission is coming to Texas ANG, likely to the 147 FW at Ellington Many details need to be worked and will offer many challenges Houston Air Route Traffic Control Center (ARTCC) very helpful to military units 159 FW (F-15A) New Orleans, LA - Captain Kristopher Murphy (159FW/SE) Converting to F-15Cs in the summer of 06 Air Defense mission (alert) – they have a lot of oil rig helicopter intercepts Use Eagle Golf/W453 airspace The unit has a deployed mission elsewhere in the world Their biggest concern is about airspace reductions Gulfport Combat Readiness Training Center (CRTC) – Lt Col Russell Madderra (CRTC/CC) Working C-17 issues for utilization at Shelby Range and associated airspace Keesler AFB (C-130J) – Lt Col John Shannon Have new avionic systems issues with new aircraft They fly winter storm and tropical storm missions Reduced Vertical Separation Minima (RVSM) issues are a real concern for the unit Columbus AFB (T-37, T-38 & T-1) – Lt Col Jay Strack Will transition to the T-6 later this year The T-6 will bring a low level night navigation training requirement with it They will be doing simulated flame-out patterns with the T-6 4 MOAs, 12 low levels, 3 Tanker Tracks Deconfliction on low levels is a concern to them 187 FW (F-16Cs) Montgomery AL - Colonel Woody Lamar (187 FW/CC) Weapons training requirement has outgrown existing airspace Trying to get their ATCAA extended to FL 500 They manage 2 MOAs and 3 low level routes With BRAC are getting additional aircraft so will have higher airspace utilization Cape Canaveral – Mr. Art Ladd (1 ROPS/DOUS) Their requirement for airspace is tied to rocket launches and infrequent Seymour Johnson (F15E) – Mr. Larry Pickett (4 OSS/OSR) Only USAF F-15E training squadron Share the Restricted Area/Dare County Range with the Navy Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 2 Range is comprised of 3000 acres and hosts approximately 10,000 sorties a year 2 MOAs & ATCAAS 12 VRs, fly about 12,000 sorties per year 6 Reserve tankers 8 additional KC-135’s Pope AFB – Mr. Craig Judd (43 OSS/OSKA) Gamecock Alpha 7,000 MSL to FL180 and ATCAA. Working airspace changes to lower the floor to 3,000 MSL Environmental study is almost completed and aeronautical request is being worked 118 AW (C-130HC) - Major Glen King (118 AW) Fly transition and airdrop missions 4 SR routes to the restricted area at Ft Campbell Little Rock AFB (C-130) – Mr. Rick Simmons (314 OSS/OSTX) 4 units, 2 operational, 2 training 36 SR routes Approx 80 aircraft on the ramp Use fighter cover until near drop zone Tinker AFB (AWACs) - Mr. Larry Wood (552 OSS/OSOR) 32 AWACs aircraft are in operation and most reside at Tinker AFB Operational missions are flown worldwide including presidential support Noble Eagle mission support is provided by AWACs aircraft Airspace denials are still an issue for approx 20% of their missions Altus AFB, OK (C-5, C-17, KC-135) – Mr. Douglas Winters (97 OSS/DOA) 14 VR/SR/IR low level routes 5 AR tracks 1 drop zone 20 miles west of Altus C-17 Night Vision Goggle ops at Clinton Sherman airport and at Altus AFB. Now are flying more tactical operations designed to avoid low-level small arms fire in the airport environment Most of their training is at Altus but they will be migrating to other airfields Their main customer is the US Army, which is transitioning to higher drop missions One concern is deconfliction of military training routes Savannah CRTC – Lt Col Kirk Simmons (SAV CRTC/DO) Coastal MOA issue process has been ongoing for over 10 years, hopefully to be completed in 2006 Proposal is comprised of a combination of MTR, MOA, and Restricted Area modifications Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 3 Shaw AFB (F-16CJ) - Mr. Art Byers (20 FW Airspace Manager) Three squadrons tasked with the Suppression of Enemy Air Defense (SEAD) mission Aircraft systems are driving the need for additional airspace and range requirements 19 military training routes, 3 to be turned back for lack of use 8 MOAs and 2 Warning Areas 3 AR Tracks Airspace proposal has been ongoing for 3 years. Aeronautical is at FAA Region Charleston AFB (C-17s) - Captain Jim Renfro (437 OSS/OST) 2 training routes and 4 AR tracks North Field is used for drops and air work Eglin AFB (A-10, F-15, F-16, NC-130, UH-1) - Mr. Don Roswell (46 OSS/OSX) 7 Restricted Areas, 8 MOAs, 3 Warning Areas, 2 ATCAAS, 2 MTRs Destin Airport is a concern with growing general aviation traffic. Many other users proposed for use in area such as “Light Jets” Due to BRAC, will be getting Special Operations Training and the F-35 MultiNational Initial Training Course Oklahoma ANG – Brin Gen Robert Ireton (OK-JFHQ) C-130 unit at Oklahoma City F-16 unit at Tulsa, will receive 6 additional aircraft Joint Fires Observer Initiative at Ft Sill Memorandum of Agreement signed by Army, AF & SOCOM Ft Sill is a logical place for training forward observers Army stated requirement is 3000+ FOs Restricted Area airspace modification Washita MOA proposal Army Radar Approach Control has been an issue since 1996 Deconfliction is an issue with all the activity AF Investments at Ft Sill can pay benefits for JTAC training and aircrew CAS training National Park Service Issues – Ms. Vicki McCusker (NPS Natural Sounds Program) Big Bend National Park. A private resort is seeking a precision approach that would go over wilderness area at park. The Natural Sounds Program is working with Laughlin AFB, FAA and park to resolve problem San Antonio Missions. Departures from Stinson Airport (which is used by Randolph AFB) go right over the missions with T-37 aircraft – park has worked with FAA and Randolph with no solution to date, other than replacement of T-37s with other aircraft. Gulf Island National Seashore. Park wants to make contacts to try to resolve noise issues at Ft Pickens. Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 4 4. FEMA/Forest Service – Ms. Julie Stewart (BLM/USFS (Fire & Aviation)) Hurricane Katrina “lessons learned” Hurricane seasons 2003 and 2004 helped open coordination doors ESF-1 (Emergency Support Function-1) (Transportaion) had to deal with destroyed communications impacting ATC. No roads, no ports, rail lines inoperative Population that refused to leave resulted in mass airlift evacuations Established three TFRs for a total of 7571 square miles 14CFR91.137(a)(2) allows 5 types of traffic VFR Airport Traffic IFR Traffic Law Enforcement Media Disaster Response o Many different agencies with disaster response aircraft o Easy to define on fire fighting, very difficult with hurricane o No common frequency for Katrina relief flights Aircraft were instrumental in nearly every aspect of the emergency response Oil rigs flights had to be re-established President of the United States (POTUS) visits (Moving TFRs) Special TFRs for Navy Operations and Air Refueling Spraying for the BUG program Damage affected operational impacts at many area airports Even during evacuations, TSA process was used National Guard helos from 20 states P-3’s, Nav Hawkeyes and Air Force AWACS were critical aviation communication assets. Faith-based Religious groups mobilized quickly with aviation response UAVs operations were considered As air traffic control came back on line the TFRs were reduced in size. Planning for Rita and Wilma went much better with the recent lessons learned Discussion: What can we do in preparation before the next season? Get FEMA, FAA, CONR, 1AF together and review lessoned learned. (CONR and 1AF are hosting a meeting in Spring 06) 5. 1AF/AOC Airspace – Mr. Jim Hicks (Southeast Air Defense Sector Airspace Manager) 1st Air Force is commanded by Major General Mayes Three Air Defense Sectors – Western, Northeast and Southeast When new equipment for Western and Northeast is in place and certified (estimated May 06), the Southeast ADS will be converted to an Air Operations Center. Coordinated over 40,000 Operation Noble Eagle sorties flown since 9/11/01. Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 5 The President (POTUS) moves around a lot which requires temporary airspace restrictions J-rescue ops from Langley transferring to Tyndall AFB Modernization is ongoing at Tyndall and should be completed by May 2006 6. National Parks Service – Ms. Vicki McCusker (NPS Natural Sounds Program) The Natural Sounds Program works to protect natural sounds and visitor experience from noise intrusions in National Park units. Noise intrusions include aircraft, personal watercraft, snowmobiles, NPS maintenance activities, etc. Natural sounds are indicators of the ecosystem and essential to the visitor’s experience Program responsibilities include Acoustic data collection, inventory and analysis Park technical assistance requests Air Tour Management Plans Soundscape Management Planning Liason with military on overflight issues NPS regulary attends regional airspace/range council meetings Many “success stories” between the two agencies AF/NPS Western Pacific Regional Sourcebook –The sourcebook contains the following information: History of AF, NPS Types of airspace and ranges, NPS units Decision making process Developing relationships/problem solving Available at http://www.nature.nps.gov/naturalsounds/issues/, http://www.fs.fed.us/r6/fire/aviation/airspace/web/coord/index.html, http://www.afranges.net/sourcebook.html 7. Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association – Mr. Ian Twombly The AOPA mission is to effectively serve the needs of our members as aircraft owners and pilots…to promote the economy, safety, unity and popularity of flight in general aviation. National survey indicated 67% of GA pilots deviate around SUA 72% of pilots indicated they contact FSS for info on airspace activation. THE CATCH – There is no FAA requirement to transmit all SUA data from centers to FSS locations. Diversions cost $$ The Shaw Airspace Proposal – Alternative B preferred Gamecock Alpha would restrict access to V136 – the only IFR route from Fayetteville to Myrtle Beach. Requested the AOPA be engaged early and often on airspace initiatives Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 6 8. State Aviation Officials Virginia Department of Aviation – Mr. Randall Burdette (Director, VA Department of Aviation) Suggested that the state agencies need to know how to better utilize local aviation assests (faith-based, etc.) during disaster recovery operations. Preplanning and coordination are the keys. We need to plan to use the assets to our advantage. Otherwise, good intentions will clog the logistics network and both sides will experience fruatration. Florida Department of Transportation, Aviation Office - Mr. Dick Null (Florida DOT – Aviation Operations Administrator) Provided copies of Florida's 2006 Airport Directory and Aeronautical Chart for organizations and individuals with flight operations in the State of Florida. Responded to Eglin AFB concern for airspace congestion and need for an air traffic control tower at Destin-Ft Walton Beach Airport stating that the control tower is already included in FDOT FY07 work program funding. FDOT works with Governor Bush’s office to plan for growing military community needs such as transportation infrastructure, affordable housing, medical facilities, and schools, as well as helping military installations prevent airspace obstructions, incompatible land use and encroachment. FDOT needs to be included in military planning to mitigate any adverse impact on airspace and airports in Florida due to increased flight operations expected from relocation of significant numbers of military units and new missions to Florida resulting from the BRAC process FDOT is actively involved in the State of Florida emergency management process, including hurricane recovery operations. FDOT needs Florida National Guard helicopter transportation to public-use airports in the state to assess damage in the aftermath of hurricanes. FDOT reports on airport operational status and fuel availability during hurricanes. North Carolina Aviation Office - Mr. J.H. Pate (NC DOT – Division of Aviation) Communications with the State Aviation Official important before you approach FAA They can help avoid problems 9. Southeast Regional Partnership Initiative – Lt Col Timothy Arch (HQ USAF/A3O-AD, AFRep, SO Region) Regional focus – North/South Carolina, Georgia and Florida. Goals are to improve regional/state and local communication as well as manage, sustain and enhance natural, economic and human resources as well as national defense. DoD interest is to identify win-win initiatives for stakeholders Explore Regional Corridor Opportunities Integrate Data Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 7 Coordinate Community Outreach Tools with OSD Office of Economic Adjustment (OEA) Assess Energy Corridors 10. Break-out sessions for tomorrow The National Park Service Big Bend/San Antonio Missions/Gulf Islands issues Shaw/Savannah/AOPA 1AF/Florida DOT/BLM(USFWS) 11. Session Wrap-up. Maj Gen Patrick closed the afternoon session with thanking the participants for their involvement, and reminded all that many BRAC-related issues are yet to be identified, many of which will raise new challenges for the military. The key to success will be communication and compromise. B. ADJOURN: The Management Session adjourned for the day at 4:45 p.m., 22 February, 2006 D. COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS FOR THE MORNING OF FEBRUARY 23, 2006 1. Opening Remarks – Maj Gen Patrick began the morning session by stating his appreciation for the previous day’s accomplishments and information flow. 2. Warfighter Brief - Colonel Woody Lamar (187 FW) Airspace most commonly used in Iraq is between 10,000 and 20,000 feet. This can only be accomplished when you have total control over the airspace and ground threats However, you have to train for the next threat which could involve anything from the surface to 50,000 feet Air-to-Air Skill sets LOWAT (Low Altitude Tactics) below 5,000 AGL Defensive Counter-Air Surface to FL5000 High Fast Flyer Scenario AMRAAM (Advanced Medium Range Air-Air Missle) loft is a technique used for longer range deliveries Supersonic – Many ordnance deliveries were at supersonic speeds as well as air-air engagements and weapons releases Air-to-Ground Skill Sets Laser Training Ranges – ranges need to be laser certified Urban CAS – need airspace over urban areas for simulated targets No Urban cultural targets over water Supersonic JDAM delivery – requires overland airspace above FL300 Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 8 3. Military Reps to the FAA – Perspectives/Issues - Lt Col Timothy Arch (AFREP FAA ANE-910). Ongoing issues in the SO-SW region at present include: Warning Areas 161B and 171B published to FL 300 4. Military Airspace Data Entry (MADE) Tool - Lt Col Crowe (HQ USAF/A3O-AR) This system is the follow on the MAMS system Streamlines the process for SUA scheduling DoD will save data in excel for reporting purposes Reduces manual workload Indicates when coordination is needed between two or more DoD agencies wanting to schedule the same airspace during the same timeframe Once the training classes are held for each Center, DoD users will be encouraged to use MADE as soon as they have trained personnel There will be mandatory blocks to fill but the overall format is user friendly Why use MADE? Secure User friendly Increased flexibility Eliminates conflicts Streamlined communications Allows for versatile reporting capabilities Reduced errors by automating data validation Milestones…. 7 Installations on line now MADE 2.0 due out in March 06 14 Other Installations in the pipeline MADE program contacts: Jim Perkins, MILOPS Program Manager Strategic Operations Security 202-267-9166 (office) Jim.perkins@faa.gov (email) Mark Brown, MILOPS Project Manager Concepts - Solutions 703-326-3748 (ATCSCC) Mark.Brown@concept-solutions.com (email) FAA MILOPS Help Desk Mon-Fri (8:00am – 4:30 pm EST) 703-326-3755 (office) 703-326-3896 (FAX) support@milops.faa.mil (email) Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 9 5. FAA Perspectives – Mr. Doug Molin (FAA Director of Tactical Operations Southeast) Air Traffic Control Restructuring Plan Congress mandated change Current FAA leadership wants the FAA to be more responsive Recommended by a 1997 National Civil Aviation Board ATO was created by consolidation Reduced nine service areas to three Management levels lowered from eleven to six Cleaner line of communications from controllers to management Systems Operations Western Service area office in Seatle serves 6 ARTCCs and 1 CERAP Central Service area based in Ft Worth serves 8 ARTCCs Eastern Service area (Atlanta office) serves 7 ARTCCs and 1 CERAP Questions FAA is moving away from land-based nagivational systems RVSM implementation – impact to DoD is greater than they anticipated Miltary Operations Specialist (MOS) positions may increase by 32 after 5 March Special use Airspace Processing - Mr. Joe Yadouga (FAA Central Enroute & Oceanic Area Office) En Route and Oceanic Service Areas Airspace proposals to the AFReps, who will forward to the appropriate Service Area FAA Order 7400.2 updated 16 Feb 06 with significant changes 7400.2 and FAA Order 1050.1E include all policies and procedures for airspace Look at appendicies 2-4 in Chapter 32 for environmental coordination guidance The FAA will be a cooperating agency Desire to have legal review of environmental early in the process The areonautical process flow is to be used along with the environemtal process flow. The proponent needs to make sure the aeronautical and environmental processes are consistent with each other. Chapter 32 - Appendix 8 Provides a lot of good information and guidance FAA will participate in scoping meetings with proponent If the legal description of the proposal includes the provision “Other times by NOTAM” in the times of use, make sure the environmental documentation analyzes those “other times”. In summary, get the FAA involoved early in the process and use Chapter 32 to make the process smoother. If everything is done right, process should flow effectively Airspace Contacts: Central: Joe Yadouga (817) 222-5597 Eastern: Armando Castro (404) 305-5590 Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 10 Environmental Contacts: Central – Nan Terry (817) 222-5594 Eastern – Allen Lucas (404) 305-5583 Discussion: The Realistic Bomber Training Initiative (RBTI) is an ongoing process. As a result of the lawsuits filed, the airspace is unsettled but the process is continuing. 6. Department of Homeland Security – Mr. Dick Ward & Mr. Bill Freehafer Customs and Boarder Protection (CBP) The agency has excellent coordination with several nations Primary mission is homeland security 16 P-3 aircraft, 8 AWACS type and 8 long range trackers All possess state of the art electronics and avionics 98% of personnel are prior military, many still in the reserve components WESCAM trackers have infrared tracking capabilities – very effective FEMA support with both dome and long range trackers Provide frequency monitoring and air traffic advisories Provide law enforcement emergency coordination and radio relay capability CONR Integration and Mission Support During Hurricane Katrina E-2’s and E-3’s handled military traffic, P-3’s handled civilian side (over 50%) During other Hurricanes where Title 10 was not enacted, handled airspace for all traffic (National Guard/Coast Guard/Civilian) Long Range Tracker duties included first responder, damage assessment, imagery transmission and logistical support. Provide digital imagery via Big Pipe steaming video, email or hand delivered National Airspace Protection Support to the Depart of Energy through Radiation Plume tracking, Lost Source and Deposition mapping In summary, their primary mission is homeland security, with proper protocol triggers they are available to provide disaster response as demonstrated during Hurricane Katrina rescue efforts They worked with civilian aircraft during Katrina efforts and the Navy E-2s provided military communications The P-3s can share Link 16 hook-ups and utilize several video systems for damage assessment. Their ability to transmit the data while airborne facilitates first responders. 7. Wind Energy – Mr. David Brentzel (AFCEE, Atlanta) Three Regional Environmental Offices (REO) DoD Regional Environmental Coordinators (RECs) support the DoD/Military Services mission through coordination, communication and facilitation of regular environmental issues and activities when these activities affect two or more military services. REO/RECs provide advocacy and outreach Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 11 Energy Policy Act of 2005 (550 pages long) 11 Western States have until Aug 07 to identify corridors for oil, gas and hydrogen pipelines and electrical transmission & distribution facilities and incorporate the corridors into land use and resource plans. The remaining states have until Aug 09 to complete the same analysis. Wind Generated Facilities - Why should we worry? Obstructions for low levels, and radar interference Question about effect of wind turbines on terminal radars – study is underway Windmills are growing because of lower cost to produce electricity. Companies are proposing use of windmill power. Winds in the Southeast are not favorable for Wind Generated Facilities, but there are areas in the mountains that could support this form of energy, such as along the east coast from North Carolina to Maine. Conclusions: Greater energy independence is essential to maintaining the American standard of living. Energy transmission corridors and renewable energy facilities are coming. The DoD should proactively participate in the planning process to minimize mission impact. 8. Breakout Session Recommendations DHS/FEMA. Need to schedule meeting to identify who the key players are for disaster preparedness. Ms. Stewart will write an issue paper and distribute. MTR deconfliction. Lt Col Strack said we need a better process – DoD problem. Poor communications between services, overlapping routes VR/IR for info only. Still have to see and avoid. You can’t stop training if you don’t have TCAS. ACTION ITEM: Address the Policy Board for Federal Aviation (PBFA) with concerns about MTR deconfliction. OPR: AF/A3O-AR and Mr. Molin ACTION ITEM: Research military flight plan system to capture utilization data. OPR: Lt Col Simmons National Park Service. Discussed situations at the three national parks, gained pertinent contact information on two of them to work the issues. Lt Col Rizzo (The Southwest AFREP) may be able to help with concerns at the San Antonio Missions site. Savannah/Shaw AFB. Reviewed the Gamecock & Bulldog MOAs. They may propose going to a full EIS (from an EA) as they expect there will be impacts. They have reviewed this initiative with AOPA. Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 12 9. Action Item Recap – Mr. Pierce (Apogen Technologies) MTR deconfliction. Lt Col Strack said we need a better process – DoD problem. Poor communications between services, overlapping routes VR/IR for info only. Still have to see and avoid. You can’t stop training if you don’t have TCAS. ACTION ITEM: Address the Policy Board for Federal Aviation (PBFA) with concerns about MTR deconfliction. OPR: AF/A3O-AR and Mr. Molin 10. Next Meeting - The Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Management Council will meet in February 2007 at a location to be determined. 11. Closing Remarks. Maj Gen Patrick thanked all for their participation, especially the NonDoD participants, and stressed that we should continue these communications. He gained a new awareness of the sounds of nature and appreciated the presentation by NPS. He thanked AOPA for being there and highlighted the importance of continued dialogue. It is important to put all of this information together and utilize the inputs from various agencies – it will pay off. Brig Gen Akey thanked Lt Col Simmons and Lt Col Moore for hosting and facilitating the meeting. The purpose of these meetings is to communicate with each other and this has been a successful meeting. Colonel Harrison added that further wind farm development is coming and units should work to identify areas where these developments would have the most adverse impact on their flight operations. He urged meeting participants to get involved and provide feedback. E. ADJOURN The Management session adjourned at 12:15 p.m., 23 February 2006. F. APPROVED // Signed // // Signed // GEORGE PATRICK, Major General, USAF JEFFREY HARRISON, Colonel, USAF Director for Ranges and Airspace Air Force Directorate of Operations and Training Co-Chairman, Southern-Southeastern Airspace/Range Council Special Assistant, CNGB Co-Chairman, Southeastern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council Attachments: Agenda List of Attendees Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Page 13 AGENDA 22 February Management Session 1:00 Welcoming Remarks Maj Gen Patrick 1:15 National Overview Brig Gen Akey 1:45 Unit Operations Briefings Lt Col Moore - Aircraft - Airspace - Problems and Issues Being Worked or Recently Solved (Opportunity for other agencies to identify issues) 2:45 Break 3:15 FEMA/Forest Service Mr. Cochran/Ms. Stewart 3:30 1 AF AOC Airspace Mr. Hicks 3:45 National Park Service Ms. McCusker 4:00 AOPA Mr. Twombly 4:15 State Aviation Officials 4:30 Southeast Regional Partnership Initiative Lt Col Arch 4:40 Breakout Sessions for Tomorrow? Lt Col Moore 4:45 Session Wrap Up Maj Gen Patrick Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 1- 1 AGENDA 23 February Management Session 8:00 Opening Remarks Maj Gen Patrick 8:10 Warfighter Brief 8:30 Military Reps to the FAA — Perspectives/Issues Lt Col Arch; Lt Col Rizzo NAVRep DARR 8:45 Military Airspace Data Entry (MADE) Tool Lt Col Crowe 9:00 FAA Perspectives Mr. Molin Mr. Yadouga 9:40 BREAK 10:10 DHS or NORTHCOM – UAV Ops Mr. Ward 10:25 Wind Energy Mr. Brentzel 10:55 Breakout Sessions Lt Col Moore 11:40 Breakout Summaries 11:50 Action Item Recap Mr. Pierce 11:55 Next Meeting Maj Gen Patrick Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 1- 2 LIST OF ATTENDEES BGen Michael Akey HQ MA ANG/CC 50 Maple Street Milford, MA 06078 DSN: 256-7485 Comm: (508) 233-7485 Cell: (413) 209-4922 E-mail: michael.akey@mabarn.ang.af.mil Major Eddie Altizer 166 Liberty Street, Suite 212 Columbus AFB, MS 39710 DSN: 742-3581 Comm: (662) 434-3581 Cell: E-mail: eddie.altizer@columbus.af.mil Lt Col Timothy Arch HQ USAF/A3O-A P.O. Box 20636, ASO-910 Atlanta, GA 30320 DSN: 797-5481`/5482 Comm: (404) 305-6902 Cell: (678) 521-7451 E-mail: timothy.arch@faa.gov Mr. Richard Booth 1300 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, DC 20229 DSN: Comm: (202) 344-3019 Cell: (202) 498-9140 E-mail: richard.booth@dhs.gov Lt Col Dave Boris 817 “H” Street Kessler AFB, MS 39532 DSN: 597-2409 Comm: (228) 377-2409 Cell: E-mail: david.borsi@keesler.af.mil Mr. David Brentzel 60 Forsyth St. S.W., Suite 8-M80 Atlanta, GA 30303 DSN: Comm: ((888)610-7419 or (404) 562-4211 Cell: E-mail: david.brentzel@brooks.af.mil Mr. David Brunsvold P.O. Box 97 Lake Mills, IA 50450 DSN: Comm: (641) 592-0500 Cell: (641) 590-3025 E-mail: daveb@leds.bz Mr. Randall Burdette Director, VA Department of Aviation 5702 Gulfstream Road Richmond, VA 23250-2422 DSN: Comm: (804) 236-3625 Cell: (540) 850-2206 E-mail: randall.burdette@doav.virginia.gov Mr. Art Byers 428 Killian Avenue Shaw AFB, SC 29152 DSN: 965-1122 Comm: (803) 896-1122 Cell: E-mail: art.byers@shaw.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-1 LIST OF ATTENDEES BGen Iwan Clontz 145 AW 5225 Morris Field Dr. Charlotte, NC 28208-5797 DSN: 236-4428 Comm: (704) 391-4428 Cell: E-mail: iwan.clontz@ncchar.ang.af.mil Mr. Scott Cochran USDA Forest Service 860 Briscoe Boulevard Lawrenceville, GA 30043 DSN: Comm: (770) 237-0119 Cell: (202) 380-5306 E-mail: tscochran@fs.fed.us Mr. David Compton 136AW/OSK 500 Hensley Ave Fort Worth, TX 76127 DSN: 874-3103 Comm: 817-852-3103 Cell: Email: david.compton@txcars.ang.af.mil Major Tony Coyle HQ GA ANG/DO Dobbins AFB, GA DSN: 625-6064 Comm: (478-318-1079 Cell: E-mail: anthony.coyle@garobi.ang.af.mil Lt Col William Crowe HQ USAF/A3O-AR 1621 N. Kent St., Ste 320 Rosslyn, VA 22209 DSN: 425-2018 Comm: (703) 588-2018 Cell: E-mail: william.crowe@pentagon.af.mil Mr. Charles Dobson 2 OSS/OSKA Barksdale AFB, LA 71110-2085 DSN: 781-5225 Comm: (318)456-5225 Cell: E-mail: Charlie.dobson@barksdale.af.mil Mr. Lothar Eckardt DHS DSN: Comm: (904) 594-5019 Cell: (904) 814)-4728 E-mail: lothar.eckardt@dhs.gov Mr. Bill Flournoy NC DENR 1601 MSC Raleigh, NC 27699 DSN: Comm: (919) 715-4191 Cell: E-mail: bill.flournoy@ncmail.net Mr. Bill Freehafer DHS/CBP Cecil Field Jacksonville, FL 32003 DSN: Comm: (904) 594-5005 Cell: (904) 579-6093 E-mail: william.g.freehafer@dhs.gov CW5 Gary Glover St. Francis Barracks 82 Marine Street St. Augustine, FL 32085 DSN 822-0494 Comm: (904) 823-0494 Cell: (904) 608-9042 E-mail: gary.glover@fl.ngb.army.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-2 LIST OF ATTENDEES Mr. Tim Gravelle HQ AMC/A36AA Scott AFB, IL 62225 DSN: 779-4557 Comm: (618) 229-4557 Cell: E-mail: timothy.gravelle@scott.af.mil Major Brent Green 14 FTW Columbus AFB, MS DSN: 742-3011 Comm: (662) 434-3011 Cell: E-mail: brent.green@columbus.af.mil DSN: 587-6784 Comm: (315) 334-6784 Cell: (850) 225-6205 E-mail: scott.grinnell@neads.ang.af.mil Mr. Scott Grinnell Northeast Air Defense Sector 387 Hanger Road Rome, NY 13440 Major Tommy Gunter 4715 Hewes Avenue, Building 1 Gulfport, MS 39507 DSN: 363-6053/54 Comm: (228) 214-6053/54 Cell: (228) 323-0081 E-mail: tommy.gunter@mscrtc.ang.af.mil Colonel Jeff Harrison HQ USAF/A3O-AR 1621 N. Kent St., Suite 320 Arlington, VA 22209 DSN: 425-2001/2002 Comm: (703) 588-2001 Cell: E-mail: jeffrey.harrison@pentagon.af.mil Captain Freddie Helton Columbus AFB, MS DSN: 742-1221 Comm: (662) 434-1221 Cell: E-mail: freddie.helton@columbus.af.mil Mr. Jim Hicks SEADS/DOS 650 Florida Ave. Tyndall AFB, FL 32403-5015 DSN: 523-5525 Comm: (850) 283-5525 Cell: E-mail: james.hicks@fljack.ang.af.mil BGen Robert Ireton 3501 Military Circle Oklahoma City, OK 73111 DSN: 628-5207 Comm: (405) 228-5163 Cell: E-mail: robert.ireton@us.army.mil Captain Jeff Isgett 7113 Brown Street Laughlin AFB, TX 78843 DSN 732-5834 Comm: (830) 298-5834 Cell: (210) 326-2385 E-mail: jeffrey.isgett@laughlin.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-3 LIST OF ATTENDEES Ms. Terri Johnson AFREP Southern Region 1701 Columbia Avenue College Park, GA 30337 DSN: 797-5481 Comm: (404) 305-6920 Cell: E-mail: Mr. Danny Jordan 917 OSS – Range Operations Barksdale AFB, LA DSN: 781-9195 Comm: Cell: E-mail: danny.jordan@barksdale.af.mil Mr. Craig Judd 43 OSS/OSKA 1182 Hurst Drive Pope AFB, NC 28308 DSN: 424-7650 Comm: (910) 394-7650 Cell: E-mail: craig.judd@pope.af.mil Major Glenn King 118 AW 240 Knapp Boulevard Nashville, TN 37217 DSN: 778-6362 Comm: (615) 399-5662 Cell: E-mail: glenn.king@tnnash.ang.af.mil Mr. Harry Knudsen ANG/CEVP 3500 Fetchet Avenue Andrews AFB, MD 20762-5157 DSN: 278-8143 Comm: (301) 836-8143 Cell: E-mail: harry.knudsen@ang.af.mil Mr. David Kuhn US Forest Service 4931 Broad River Road Columbia, SC 29212 DSN: Comm: (803) 561-4057 Cell: E-mail: dkuhn@fs.fed.us Mr. Art Ladd 1 ROPS/DOUS 10400 Phillips Pkwy, CCAFS MS 2003 Patrick AFB, FL 32925-2618 DSN: 467-5936 Comm: (321) 853-5936 Cell: E-mail: arthur.ladd@patrick.af.mil Colonel Woody Lamar 187 FW 5187 Selma Highway Montgomery, AL 36108-4824 DSN: 358-9157 Comm: (334) 394-7157 Cell: (334) 549-4707 E-mail: woodward.lamar@almont.ang.af.mil Mr. Joseph LeBlanc 301 OG/SUA 1654 Lyons Drive Carswell AFB, TX 76127 DSN: 739-6903 Comm: (817)782-6903 Cell: E-mail: joseph.leblanc@carswell.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-4 LIST OF ATTENDEES MGen (Ret) Bruce MacLane Apogen Technologies 519 Carriage Drive Atlanta, GA 30328 DSN: Comm: (404) 255-6732 Cell: E-mail: maclaneb@bellsouth.net Lt Col Russell Madderra ANG/CRTC/CC 4715 Hewes Avenue, Building 1 Gulfport, MS 39507-4324 DSN: 363-6001 Comm: (228) 214-6001 Cell: (228) 323-0084 E-mail: russell.madderra@mscrtc.ang.af.mil Mr. Kurt McClure Airspace Manager, Claiborne Range Barksdale AFB, LA DSN: 781-8078 Comm: (318) 456-8078 Cell: E-mail: kurtis.mcclure2@barksdale.af.mil Ms. Vicki McCusker NPS Natural Sounds Program 1201 Oakridge Drive, Suite 100 Fort Collins, CO 80525 DSN: Comm: (970) 267-2117 Cell: E-mail: vicki_mccusker@nps.gov Major Jeff McLemore HQ AFSOF AOC/STA Hurlburt Field, FL 32544-5000 DSN: 579-5350 Comm: (850) 884-5350 Cell: E-mail: jeffery.mclemore@hurlburt.af.mil Mr. Doug Molin FAA – Director of Tactical Operations SE DSN: Comm: Cell: (765) 346-2573 E-mail: douglas.l.molin@faa.gov Lt Col Tom Moore ANG/A3A 1411 Jefferson Davis Hwy Arlington, VA 22202-3233 DSN: 327-0219 Comm: (703) 607-0219 Cell: E-mail: thomas.moore@ngb.ang.af.mil Captain Kristopher Murphy 159FW/SE 400 Russell Ave NAS JRB, LA 70143 DSN: 457-8621 Comm: (504) 391-8621 Cell: E-mail: kristopher.murphy@lanewo.ang.af.mil Mr. Larry Myers HQ AFSOF AOC/STA 100 Bartley Street, Suite 2125 Hurlburt Field, FL 32544-5000 DSN: 579-4191 Comm: (850) 884-4191 Cell: (850) 499-2187 E-mail: lawrence.myers@hurlburt.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-5 LIST OF ATTENDEES Colonel John Nichols 149 FW/CC TX ANG 107 Hensley Street, Suite 1 Lackland AFB, TX 78236-0103 DSN: 945-3510 Comm: (210) 925-3510 Cell: E-mail: john.nichols@txkell.ang.af.mil Mr. Richard Null Florida DOT – Aviation Ops Administrator 605 Suwannee Street, MS 46 Tallahassee, FL 32399-0450 DSN: Comm: (850) 414-4515 Cell: E-mail: Richard.null@dot.state.fl.us Mr. Ed Odom 205 Dodd Boulevard, Suite 101 Langley AFB, VA 23665 DSN: 574-6002 Comm: (757) 764-6002 Cell: (757) 593-3492 E-mail: edward.odom@langley.af.mil MGen George Patrick Special Assistant, CNGB DSN: Comm: (803) 413-2131 Cell: E-mail: george.patrick@pentagon.af.mil Lt Cmdr Ron Parks 250 Lexington Boulevard, Suite 206 Corpus Christi, TX 78419 DSN: 861-2550 Comm: (361) 961-2550 Cell: (361) 438-7851 E-mail: ronnie.parks@navy.mil Mr. J. H. Pate NCDOT-Division of Aviation 1560 MSC Raleigh, NC 27699-1560 DSN: Comm: (919) 840-0112 Cell: E-mail: jpate@dot.state.nc.us Mr. Larry Pickett 4 OSS/OSR 1075 Blakeslee Avenue Seymour Johnson AFB, NC 27531 DSN: 722-2672 Comm: (919) 722-2672 Cell: E-mail: larry.pickett@seymourjohnson.af.mil Mr. Richard Pierce Apogen Technologies 106 Bid A Wee Court Panama City Beach, FL 32413-2783 DSN: Comm: (850) 230-9411 Cell: E-mail: rpierce211@comcast.net Captain Jim Renfro 437 OSS/OST 102 E. Hill Boulevard Charleston AFB, SC 29404 DSN: 673-5613 Comm: (843) 973-5613 Cell: E-mail: james.renfro2@charleston.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-6 LIST OF ATTENDEES Mr. Jim Ries ATCSCC Manager (FAA) 13600 EDS Drive Herdon, VA DSN: Comm: (703) 904-4400 Cell: (202) 437-2953 E-mail: james.ries@faa.gov Mr. Don Roswell 46 OSS/OSX 505 N. Barrancas, Suite 104 Egiln AFB, FL 32542-6818 DSN: 872-6150 Comm: (850) 882-6150 Cell: (850) 855-1457 E-mail: donald.roswell@eglin.af.mil Colonel Alan Rutherford Director of Operations, Florida ANG Dept of Mil Affairs, PO Box 1008 St. Augustine, FL 32084-1008 DSN: 822-0614 Comm: (904) 823-0614 Cell: E-mail: alan.rutherford@fljack.ang.af.mil Captain Ben Schilders 80 OSS/SOOA Sheppard AFB, TX DSN: 736-4970 Comm: (940) 676-4970 Cell: E-mail: ben.schilders@sheppard.af.mil Lt Col John Shannon 812 “H” Street Keesler AFB, MS DSN: 597-1922 Comm: (228) 377-1922 Cell: E-mail: john.shannon@keesler.af.mil Lt Col Kirk Simmons CRTC/DO P.O. Box 7299 Garden City, GA 31418 DSN: 860-3303 Comm: (912) 963-3303 Cell: E-mail: kirk.simmons@gacrtc.ang.af.mil Mr. Rick Simmons 314 OSS/OSTX Little Rock AFB, AR 72099 DSN: 731-3986 Comm: (501) 987-3986 Cell: E-mail: rick.simmons@littlerock.af.mil Major Paul Starkey 14 FTW Columbus AFB, MS DSN: 742-7840 Comm: (662) 434-7840 E-mail: paul.starkey@columbus.af.mil Lt Col John Steinbicker ANG/A3A 1411 Jefferson Davis Highway Arlington, VA 22202-3233 DSN: 327-0725 Comm: (703) 607-0725 Cell: E-mail: john.steinbicker@ngb.ang.af.mil Lt Col Frank Stepongzi AFRC/DOUS 155 Richard Ray Boulevard Robins AFB, GA 30098 DSN: 497-1232 Comm: (478) 327-1232 Cell: E-mail: frank.stepongzi@afrc.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-7 LIST OF ATTENDEES Ms. Julie Stewart BLM/USFS (Fire & Aviation) P.O. Box 3623 Portland, OR 97208 DSN: Comm: (503) 808-6728 Cell: E-mail: julie.stewart@or.blm.gov juliejstewart@aol.com Lt Col Jay Strack Airspace Manager Columbus AFB, MS DSN: 742-7633 Comm: (662) 434-7633 Cell: E-mail: jay.strack@columbus.af.mil Major David Torres HQ ACC/CCJ (JAGO) 204 Dodd Boulevard, Suite 301 Langley AFB, VA 23665 DSN: 574-2756 Comm: (757) 764-2756 Cell: (757) 846-5200 E-mail: david.torres@langley.af.mil Mr. Ian Twombly AOPA 421 Aviation Way Frerdrick, MD DSN: Comm: (301) 695-2207 Cell: E-mail: ian.twombly@aopa.org Mr. David VanBlaricom SEADS/DOS 650 Florida Avenue Tyndall AFB, FL 32403 DSN: 523-5860 Comm: (850) 283-5860 Cell: E-mail: Captain Marco Van den Bosch Sheppard AFB, TX DSN: 736-4970 Comm: Cell: E-mail: marco.vandenbosch@sheppard.af.mil Captain Oystein Vollstad 80 OSS/80 GTW Sheppard AFB, TX 76302 DSN: 736-4970 Comm: Cell: (940) 332-3276 E-mail: oystein.vollstad@sheppard.af.mil Mr. Dick Ward Customs and Border Protection P-3/P-3 AEWs Cecil Field Jacksonville, FL 32003 DSN: Comm: (904) 594-5005/(904) 594-5022 Cell: (904) 509-9672 E-mail: richard.w.ward@dhs.gov Mr. Patrick Welch ANG/A3A 1411 Jefferson Davis Highway Arlington, VA 22202-3231 DSN: 327-2114 Comm: (703) 607-2114 Cell: E-mail: pat.welch@ngb.ang.af.mil Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-8 LIST OF ATTENDEES Mr. Randy Williams MLO Jacksonville ARTCC DSN: 434-3744 Comm: (904) 549-1553 Cell: E-mail: randy.j.williams@faa.gov Mr. Douglas P. Winters 97 OSS/DOA 400 N. Sixth Street Altus AFB, OK 73521 DSN: 866-6098 Comm: (580) 481-6098 Cell: (580) 481-8488 E-mail: douglas.winters@altus.af.mil Mr. Larry Wood 552 OSS/OSOR 7513 Sentry Boulevard, Suite 203 Tinker AFB, OK 73145-9002 DSN: 884-7414 Comm: (405) 734-7414 Cell: E-mail: larry.wood@tinker.af.mil Mr. Joe Yadouga FAA Central Enroute & Oceanic Area Office 3501 Meacham Blvd Ft. Worth, TX 76137 DSN: Comm: (817) 222-5597 Cell: E-mail: joe.yadouga@faa.gov Southern-Southwest Region Airspace/Range Council – Management Sessions 22-23 February 2006 Atch 2-9