Project Report for El Salvador ANNEXES APRIL 2002 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador ANNEX 1. DESCRIPTION OF THE ELEMENT LEAD AND ITS APPLICATIONS Characteristics of Lead Lead is a relatively abundant natural element found on earth. It was one of the earliest metals extracted by man, starting from Galena (Lead Sulfide), Cerussite (Lead carbonate) and Anglesite (Lead sulfate). Lead is a metal with a dull gray appearance, a very brilliant silver color when cut, but it is quickly oxidized to become a dull gray. It melts at 327°Celcius and generates a highly toxic vapor when heated. In nature it is abundant in the mineral galena as lead sulfide. It is very ductile and malleable. The most important lead oxidizes formed are: the monoxide (PbO), called litharge that is Yellow (obtained by heating lead in air), this material is usually contaminated during mining and its color is only yellowish. The lead dioxide (PbO2) is a brown powder; it is an active oxidizer and is used as a positive plate in lead accumulators. Today lead is used in many industries manufacturing a wide range of different products. In Chart A.1 the main industries that use lead in their production processes are shown. Inorganic lead has numerous applications and is used by many industries and processes, but the exact extent of its use in Latin America is unknown. However, the most important applications are the in the battery manufacturing industry, metallurgy, paint pigments, traditional pottery, telecommunication cables and chemical products. A considerable proportion of the lead used is from secondary sources. It is important to mention that due to the large number of industries that use lead in their processes, the environmental regulatory authorities in each country have imposed a series of work place standards for permissible levels of lead in air. Type of Industry 1 Metallurgical 2 Battery Manufacturers 3 Plastics 4 Printing 5 Anticorrosive paints 6 Automotive radiator repairers 7 TEL 8 Gasoline stations 9 Munitions factories Chart A.1. The main industries that use the lead in the manufacture of their products. Source: http://www.saludhoy.com/htm/saludtr/articulo/plomo.htm l The most important market for lead is the automotive SLI (starting, lights, ignition) battery. Other significant markets are the motive power batteries for electric vehicles and the UPS (uninterrupted power supply) batteries used in telecommunications and computer based sectors. Other noteworthy and growing markets include the coatings industries that produce a special lead impregnated glass for televisions and computer monitors to shield against the harmful effects of x-rays. 2 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador ANNEX B. FORMS OF LEAD EXPOSURE Lead intoxication has always been one of the most common occupational illnesses. There are three forms of lead exposure: occupational, para-occupational and environmental. The next table explains how individuals are exposed to lead: Occupational Common among those who work in lead mining, metal smelting and refining and other activities where lead is used (automotive batteries, telecommunication cables, maintenance, etc.); as well as in small scale activities such as radiator repair shops and certain glass production. Para-occupational Para-occupational exposure occurs when lead workers do not wash after work and wear the same clothes at work and at home thereby taking lead dust into their house and exposing the family to lead intoxication, especially small children. Environmental Feasible in the case of people who live near lead smelters or refineries, lead mines or waste dumps, or industries that use lead, for example a battery manufacturing plant, radiator repair shops or traditional craft shops specializing in lead glazes. Source: www.laneta.apc.org/emis/carpeta/plomo-cilas2.htm Occupational lead exposure and contamination is said to be one of the worst chemical pollutants of work places and therefore poses a serious risk to workers’ health. Those working in the lead recovery sectors and the secondary smelters are exposed to lead and possibly other polluting metals. The manufacturers of storage batteries are always subjected to lead exposure. Any grinding activities, agglomeration and metal recovery involving lead produces high concentrations of lead dust and lead vapors at high temperatures. The ingestion of lead contaminated foods and water is the main source of population exposure, followed by the inhalation of lead dusts (such as the lead particulates associated with leaded gasoline) and finally absorption via the skin for certain organic lead compounds. The main pathways for lead absorption in humans are inhalation and ingestion. Almost 40% of lead vapors pass through respirator filters. The absorption of lead dusts depends on the particle size, i.e. smaller than 5 microns, the solubility of the particles and the breathing volume/minute. In essence, the greater the work load the greater the absorption. Environmental exposure is essentially due to contamination of the soil and the atmosphere cause by the emissions from lead smelters. It is considered that a population exposed to lead has a greater probability of developing illnesses or other abnormal conditions. Accordingly, the populations at high risk are those exposed to dangerous levels of lead concentrations or where the risk of exposure is greater than for the majority of the population. In this category the following populations can be identified: Workers in lead industries People living close to mining or industrial sources Residents living close to roads or highways with high vehicular traffic. Person from regions where there is high atmosphere lead pollution. Families of lead industry workers with poor personal hygiene. Pregnant women and children younger than 5 years. People with blood disorders such as and mainly anemia. People with neurological diseases. People with nutritional deficiencies, mainly iron, calcium and certain proteins. 3 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador ANNEXED C ACTIVITIES THAT HAVE HIGH, MEDIUM OR LOW EXPOSURE TO LEAD High exposure Activities with high risk Makers of accumulators Makers of Batteries (accumulators) Makers of lead paste Workers of iron and lead Metal Grinder that use lead Makers of lead counterweights Makers and Manufacturing small lead counterbalances Makers of lead floors Makers of lead protection equipment Makers of lead pipes Casters of lead pipes Lead miners Lead recyclers Welders using Lead solder Workers of lead mills Makers of TEL Makers of TML Medium exposure Activities with medium risk Users of lead based insecticides Makers of paints Makers of pigments Glass makers Glass polishers Low exposure Activities with low risk Makers of varnishes Printers Type setters Brass casters Workers in gasoline stations that still sell fuel with lead additives Workers in shop of repair of vehicles Tinsmiths Very limited exposure Activities with a very low or no risk Steel engravers Cutlery makers Diamond polishers Brick makers Workers in maintenance shops 4 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador ANNEXED D EFFECTS OF LEAD ON HUMAN HEALTH Absorption of lead into the body. The spouses of lead workers can be exposed to lead and the main pathways and absorption into the body is inhalation (breathing) of lead particles in the air from the place of the work and gastrointestinal where lead dust has contaminated the food, due fundamentally to the bad personal habits and hygiene of the lead worker, who may be found to eat and smoke in the workplace, and not wash their hands or face before eating. There is concern for those populations that live near to lead industries or a lead mine, or who have members of the family that work in an industry that uses lead. In these instances the main pathways for lead intoxication are also inhalation and digestive routes. This last category is especially important because young children ingest the lead particles that have been deposited in the floor of the home from contaminated work clothes when they are crawling around the house and pick up objects from the floor and put them in their mouths. Such exposure is due entirely to the deficiencies in personal hygiene and the control of emissions at the industrial sources of lead. Lead can also be ingested by means of the contaminated foods. Types of lead intoxication The two distinct intoxication types of exposure are: Chronic intoxication It is the form of more frequent intoxication and it is due to exposure to small quantities of lead, but over a long period of time. The problems caused can be either temporary or permanent. Some symptoms are not specific to lead intoxication and can be similar to conditions caused by other pollutants, such as: tiredness, irritability, stomachache, appetite loss, metallic taste in the mouth, drowsiness and abdominal pains. Sharp intoxication This is a rare occurrence and is due to the absorption of a great quantity of lead in a short period. It can be observed as the consequence of a massive ingestion of lead. The symptoms of such intoxication are strong abdominal pains, vomiting and even convulsions. More frequent symptoms of lead exposure. The symptoms of excessive exposure to lead will depend on the levels of the metal in the blood. At the present time the exposure to lead is divided in three groups, which are shown in the chart D.1 Little exposure Tiredness Irritable Difficulty in concentrating Disturbed sleep Occasional and light abdominal pain Pain in the muscles Numbness of the hands and legs Moderate exposure Drowsiness Headache Pain in the articulations Tremor in the extremities Nausea and vomit Loss of weight Decrease of the libido Severe exposure Severe abdominal pain of the colic type Damage to the nervous system Paralysis or lost of power in the muscles Convulsions Loss of appetite Death Chart D.2 Most frequent symptoms for lead exposure Source: www.saludhoy.com/htm/saludtr/articulo/plomo.html Human health and harmful lead concentrations. It is recommended that lead in blood levels are as low as possible, particularly among the most vulnerable populations, such as young children and pregnant women. In United States of America the Center for Disease Control (CDC) have established that the lead levels in blood should not surpass the 10g/dl. For lead workers CDC is recommending that the levels do not exceed 30g/dl. The US EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) established a permissible limit value for the concentration of lead in the air at 1.5 g /m3. The EPA also considers that the threshold for lead in blood for the general population should be about 15g/dl. In the case of workers, the blood lead levels, established as permissible by OSHA in 1980, are no greater than 40g /dl for male adults and 30g /dl for women of childbearing age. 5 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador The Association of Industrial Hygienists of American at the American Conference of Government Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) in the United Sates of America recommended values for environmental limits for inorganic lead at 0.05g /m3 and 0.1g /m3 for organic lead with a limit of 30g /dl for lead in blood levels. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) recommended that the occupational and environmental exposure limits should be 50g /m3 per day for 8 hours of work and lead in blood levels of 40g /dl. 6 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador ANNEXED D MEASURES TO REDUCE LEAD EXPOSURE The fundamental principles are firstly to prevent lead inhalation and secondly avoid its ingestion. When it is not possible to avoid using lead, the metallic dust should be avoided; work areas should be damped down with copious quantities of water to avoid dust dispersion in the air. However, the most important measure to take is the elimination or reduction of lead exposure. In the workplace the following measures should be adopted: The elimination of lead and if that is not possible, then efforts should be made to find a suitable non-toxic substitute. To installation of control measures that reduce exposure through ventilation and extraction of the dust particles to an appropriate collector, and in addition the isolation of the process. Use of appropriate personal protective equipment, that is, the use of respiratory equipment (masks that filter the air and prevent the inhalation of leaded particulates) that protects the employee from high and persistent quantities of airborne lead. Practices that reduce exposure with changes of work, i.e. rotation of work. Workers should eat a balanced diet rich in calcium, vitamin C, bran and vitamin D, as scientific studies have demonstrated that such nutrients reduce lead absorption. Workers should have designated places to eat that are isolated from the work process. The workers should have suitable washrooms at the place of work to shower and wash work clothes in order to prevent contamination of the home. Information about the toxicity of lead should be readily available to ensure that workers avoid ingesting lead when eating and do not smoke in the workplace. For the environmental exposure to the lead that is given, is necessary that the competent authorities of to veil in that the companies that manage lead fulfill the laws, regulations and norms strictly in this respect. the results. These measures are categorized as environmental and biological monitoring. The biological monitoring has two types of indicator, exposure and effects. The lead in blood level is the exposure indicator and is influenced by the background levels of lead and any recent exposure. Essentially the blood lead level reflects the amount of lead absorbed during the preceding few weeks. It is not a measure of the total body burden. Additionally, it is important to control lead exposure, measure atmospheric concentrations (in both the workplace and the local community) and biological exposure levels (occupational and general population), and then to communicate 7 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador I ANNEX AND WHAT IT IS A LEAD ACID BATTERY, WHY AND HOW TO RECYCLE THEM. What a lead acid battery is1. Lead-acid batteries either start or power cars, trucks, buses, boats, trains, rapid masstransit systems, recreational vehicles and electric wheelchairs all over the globe. The car battery also provides a stable electrical supply to a vehicle’s electrical system. During power outages, lead-acid batteries provide quiet, pollution-free emergency power for critical operations such as air-traffic control towers, hospitals, railroad crossings, military installations, submarines, and weapons systems. In these situations the telephones stay on and this is because every major telephone company in the world, including mobile telephone service providers, uses lead-acid batteries as backup power to the telecommunications systems. Were it not for standby lead-acid batteries, we probably would have power outages nearly every day because the electric utilities would not be able to handle rapid fluctuations in the demand for electricity. This is when lead-acid batteries come to the rescue, as enormous arrays of batteries delivering large amounts of electricity for short periods of time until additional capacity is added to the grid. Lead-acid batteries power electric fork trucks used in warehouses, factories, mines, and ships. They also power the shuttle vehicles in airports, as well as wheelchairs, amusement park shuttles and golf carts. On the road, lead-acid batteries power electric law-enforcement vehicles, buses, and very soon mail delivery vans. alloy containing various elemental additives that includes one or more of the following and sometimes others not mentioned, antimony, calcium, arsenic, copper, tin, strontium, aluminum, selenium and more recently bismuth and silver. These alloying elements are used to change grid strength, corrosion resistance, reduce over-potential or maintenance, and internal resistance. 3. Porous synthetic plate separators are increasingly made from rib-reinforced polyethylene, but are also available in PVC and fiberglass. 4. The plates are immersed in a liquid electrolyte consisting of 35% sulfuric acid and 65% water. It is the electrolyte that facilitates the chemical reactions that enable the storage and discharge of electrical energy and permit the passage of electrons that provide the current flow. 5. The positive and negative lead terminals used to connect the battery to the car and pass the current from the individual cells via a series of connecting lugs and bridges. Accumulator batteries are formed by connecting the electrolytic cells in series and/or in parallel to take advantage of the capacity of the battery to store electric power for use during power surges or complete failure. Treatment processes for ULAB. Some of the toxic components of the ULAB present a risk to the environment and human health. It is necessary therefore to adopt procedures specifically designed to process these waste streams. To ensure safe handling of ULAB the following procedures can be used: Components of the lead acid battery. Direct Process The modern lead acid battery is manufactured with: 1. A resilient plastic container that is usually polyethylene, but increasingly is made from alternative co-polymers or reinforced, but the case material can also be metallic or a synthetic rubber. 2. Positive and negative internal lead plates. The positive electrode (cathode) typically consists of pure lead dioxide supported on a metallic grid, whereas the negative electrode (anode) consists of a grid of metallic lead Description 1 The ULAB are received from the collector complete, but before passing to the smelter they must be drained of sulfuric acid. This process is usually carried out in cupola furnaces, but rotary furnaces are also used. Advantages Any mechanical or manual breaking is avoided, thereby eliminating the possibility of the electrolyte being poured down the municipal drains. The case and separators are used as energy sources and the solid residue is the only waste. Disadvantages The organic components of the batteries can produce smoke emissions high in particulates. The high sulfur content in the charge material will produce sulfur dioxide gas and adversely affect any surrounding vegetation. Brian Wilson, ILMC, Trinidad 2001. 8 Manejo Ambientalmente Adecuado de Baterías Ácido-plomo Usadas en Centroamérica y el Caribe Diagnóstico de El Salvador Semi-Direct Process Description Before the metallurgical process, the plastic case is separated from the battery’s internal plates and separators. Normally this process uses a Rotary furnace. Advantages It allows the total recycling of the polypropylene, thereby avoiding the risks associated with the combustion of the plastic. The only waste is the solid furnace residue. Disadvantages This is not such a simple process as the ULAB are subject to a preliminary process to remove the plastic case material. The high sulfur content of the battery paste will produce sulfur dioxide and any furnace emissions will adversely affect vegetation. Indirect Process Description The batteries are subjected to a treatment that permits the most complete separation possible of leaded materials prior to the metallurgical process. The two most commonly used furnaces are the Cupola and the Rotary. Advantages It improves the recovery of the contained lead in the feedstock. Reduces undesirable gaseous emissions. Disadvantages Requires the installation of a battery breaker to separate the components. The separate components need to be properly managed. Recommendations for the safe handling of ULAB. ULAB contain lead and a corrosive acid and for that reason they are considered a hazardous waste. Therefore, while being stored prior to recycling or return to the manufacturer/retailer the following should be observed: The ULAB should be tested to determine if it could be recharged and reused. If the ULAB is “spent” is should be placed in a strong leak-proof container. The terminals should be left on the battery and sent for recovery with the battery. The hazardous batteries should stay inside a sealed container that is leak-proof or on a waterproof asphalt surface with a spillage control system. It should be remembered that battery acid will dissolve concrete. The batteries should stay inside a building. If keep outside, the battery storage area should be covered with a roof to protect the ULAB from the rain. It should also protect them from freezing. ULAB destined for recycling should not be stored for more than 6 months. The building used for the storage of ULAB should have good ventilation with vents near to the entrance and close to the floor. The doors should have warning signs that prohibit access to anyone with a naked flame (e.g. cigarettes). All the metallic surfaces should be protected with anticorrosive paint and any tools that are liable to cause sparks must not be place closer that one meter from then UALB. Technical information for the environmentally sound handling of the ULAB In the warehouse and raw materials preparation areas there must be a series of sound environmental practices that are viable and considerably reduce the dust and particulate emissions: a. Storage in closed containers. b. During transportation the materials should be damped down and/or kept in closed vehicles. c. The machinery and the equipment used in the treatment of the materials (the breaking, milling, and classification) should be isolated and completed enclosed. d. A system should be introduced or installed, especially at the transfer or unloading points for the materials, that collects any spillage or dust and transfers the sweepings to the process for treatment. e. Materials handling should be carried out in facilities with ventilation equipment and a system to clean the work areas (point of transfer, material discharges, front end loaders, entrances to the storage areas, etc.) As for the process residues and spillage, processes should be developed to reduce process losses and decrease the generation of furnace residuals as much as possible ensuring whenever possible that by-products are recycled in the plant. The biggest risk of contamination to the floors will be the storage areas for the process feedstock, and the location of the UALB storage. This contamination can be avoided easily with an appropriate floor sealant and good drainage system for the battery acid. 9