ARTS & VENUES DENVER 2012 BUSINESS PLAN AVD STRATEGIC BUSINESS PLAN SUMMARY Mission/Vision Statements Vision: Mission: Building Denver’s communities through arts and performances To enhance Denver’s quality of life and economic vitality through premier public venues, artworks, and entertainment opportunities Strategic Objectives: To achieve the Arts & Venues Denver mission and vision – as well as fulfilling the Mayor’s promise to make Denver a world-class city where everyone matters – the Agency has established the following objectives: Provide quality performance venues (safe/affordable/clean/comfortable) Stimulate economic development and ensure the Agency’s financial sustainability Connect citizens with diverse art experiences Satisfy our many patrons and partners Ensure every team member is critical to our success Business Overview Arts & Venues Denver (AVD) operates City-owned performance venues and oversees Citysponsored cultural and public art programs. The agency also coordinates economic development initiatives in the creative sector. Through collaboration with key cultural constituents and private sector presenters, AVD offers a unique array of entertainment and cultural opportunities and strives to live up to its motto of “Building Unique Denver Connections,” supporting the Mayor’s overall vision for “Creating a world-class city where everyone matters.” The key venues under AVD’s care are: Colorado Convention Center including the Wells Fargo Theater; Crossroads Theater; Denver Coliseum; Denver Performing Arts Complex including Boettcher Concert Hall, Buell Theatre, Ellie Caulkins Opera House; McNichols Building and Red Rocks Amphitheatre. Principal cultural programs include: One Book One Denver; Five Points Jazz Festival; Doors Open Denver; and numerous concert, festival and arts events which are customized annually. The principal focus in creative sector development is the annual Create Denver program which fosters the growth of creative businesses and industries. There are 72 full-time City employees in the agency, including two mayoral appointees. They work in five different locations and have an average tenure of ten years. Due to the episodic nature of the performances and arts/culture events, AVD also employs several hundred contractors and “oncall” staff for maintenance, security, usher and food and beverage service at AVD venues. In June 2011, AVD was formed through the merger of two City agencies: the Denver Office of Cultural Affairs and the Division of Theatres and Arenas. The former had been funded through the City’s General Fund and had seen steady budget cuts over the recent past, while the latter’s Page | 1 steadily improving financial results had required only minimal support from the General Fund since 2008. Through the merger, the new Arts & Venues Denver should be able to pay the salaries and operating expenses of both former agencies from its annual operating surplus, thus saving the City $1.2m from the General Fund. AVD does not operate today like a traditional municipal agency, with funding provided by General Funds. Instead, its two main businesses reside in Special Revenue Funds. One of those funds supports all of the activities above without any General Fund support. The other fund houses the business of the Colorado Convention Center, which plays a crucial role in stimulating economic development in the City by driving business in the hotel, transportation, restaurant and related tourist businesses. This fund requires support from the General Fund at the level of $2.5-3 m annually and that amount is expected to decline at a moderate rate over the next five years. Success and Risk Factors Several factors contribute to AVD’s success. The variety and locations of city-owned entertainment venues provide easy access to a number of entertainment options and city amenities. The Denver Performing Arts Complex, with several theaters of varying size, has a prime location on the resurgent 14th Street corridor with easy access to downtown from around the metro area. The Colorado Convention Center and McNichols Building in Civic Center Park, just down 14th Street, have the same desirable city center location, within easy walking distance of many hotels and restaurants. The historic Denver Coliseum has easy highway access and is walking distance from the National Western complex. Finally, just a short drive from downtown Denver, the iconic Red Rocks Park and Amphitheatre symbolizes Denver’s place at the foot of the Rockies and the venue’s history ensures legendary status with promoters, patrons and performers. AVD has built a solid reputation for providing safe, comfortable and well-managed venues. Event bookers return to the venues time after time, knowing that the venues are cared for and fan experiences will be exceptional. City ownership of these facilities is likewise meaningful to the city’s citizens. Reputation is also a reason for the success of AVD’s events. Over many years, the staff of AVD has built a legacy of delivering a wide array of programs using very limited resources. The staff has very strong links into the community and participate in various arts, entertainment, education and creative sector forums both locally and nationally. There are a number of risks to agency operations. Principal among these is the fact that AVD competes directly with private sector firms with many more resources and much more flexibility than Denver, or any municipality, has. This list of what AVD needs, and competitors have, includes: ready access to capital, speedy decision-making, more flexible work rules, volume discount opportunities, inability to get favorable terms from product/service providers that are part of vertically integrated companies, and efficient contracting processes. Perhaps the most significant risk is the ongoing struggle to get adequate capital funding for both routine maintenance and building upgrades for facilities in which the City has invested more than $1B to date. Challenges related to arts programming are related to simply processing work in an environment where community input is essential. Not surprisingly, in a city of millions, there are a like number of opinions regarding arts and culture. The input is time-consuming, often conflicting and carries the significant risk of disappointing some whose input cannot be accommodated. The very modest program budgets for these programs also pose a challenge, as many non-profit groups have Page | 2 clearly looked to AVD to support their initiatives with both human and financial resources. This has been virtually impossible to do, given AVD’s finite resources in relation to the number of programs it delivers each year. Current Situation Over the past several years, AVD has had very strong results, driven principally by robust attendance at Red Rocks Amphitheatre and successful Broadway shows performed at the Buell Theatre. With prudent management of costs and a continued supply of good shows for these two venues, AVD should be able to fund its own operations without a General Fund transfer. That said, AVD competes directly with private sector venues such Comfort Dental Amphitheater in Greenwood Village, First Bank Center in Broomfield, Pepsi Center, the National Western complex and a host of smaller concert venues such as the University of Denver’s Newman Center and Magness Arena, and the Paramount, Ogden, Bluebird and Fillmore theaters, among others. Even in this very competitive environment, AVD has achieved the following in the past three years: Autonomy for Arts & Venues from the City’s General Fund The merger of the Denver Office of Cultural Affairs with the Division of Theaters and Arenas in a sustainable format Expansion of the Agency’s cultural offerings, concerts and exhibits to encompass a wider diversity of citizens and programs While the Arts & Venues Denver operates more autonomously than many City agencies, due to its Special Revenue Fund structure, it does not have the agility to directly compete on every level with the private sector providers in the venue business. Nowhere is this more apparent than when discussing the issue of how to protect the small operating surplus which is typically generated annually when revenues exceed expenses. This surplus has risen to a fairly healthy level over the past 3-4 years and the Agency has proposed to BMO that $5.0M from this surplus be moved into a reserve to be used for capital improvements that arise annually for the Agency’s many facilities. Just in the past year, the Agency has had to fund a $2.1M improvement at Red Rocks and contribute to a $1.0M renovation of the McNichols Building. Had the Agency not had a cushion in its operating reserve, these internally funded improvements would not have been possible. For instance, AVD currently is coping with costs from extensive wind damage at the Colorado Convention Center – an example of the need for the Agency to have flexibility to manage both near-term and longer-term building improvements, ranging from emergencies to planned upgrades. The key issue is that while there have been several good years of increasing revenue at the Agency’s venues; it is far from a guaranteed trend. So, establishing a permanent reserve ensures that AVD can fund its capital requirements in a timely manner. Communication on these funding plans would still be coordinated with BMO and, where relevant, Public Works. Related to this request for a permanent fund is the need to recognize that each venue has its own unique business opportunity, serves unique arts and cultural audiences but may not have an immediate path to profitability. For instance, when AVD was directed to take on the McNichols Building during the Hickenlooper administration, $1M was allocated from the Agency’s operating reserve, but there was no source provided for future capital needs – needs that are significant in a building more than a century old. Nor was there a way to protect the Agency’s downside in providing a positive cash flow and current use indicates the likelihood of an operating loss. Rather, the city’s order to assume responsibility for McNichols requires that AVD use its annual operating Page | 3 surplus from other venues to fund a building that was added to its portfolio without real regard for building condition or use. There are two opportunities in the current environment to ensure the continued successful operation of the Agency. First, the Agency will need the support of the MO and City Council to establish an operating reserve of $5.0M to fund future capital needs and a corollary process for “refilling” that reserve on an annual basis. Second, AVD and the City should ensure that buildings and venues aren’t brought online—whether a McNichols Building or Ruby Hill Park Pavilion, to give two examples—without ensuring there is a clear path to operating the venue and funding future capital needs. AVD continues to shift its organization to adapt to merger-driven budget and program needs. The merger’s $1.2M in savings to the City’s General Fund has become a permanent cost to AVD and covering these costs, without disrupting venue maintenance or programming, is a priority. The Agency’s business plan must ensure the means to meet these needs. The most near term opportunity is the careful negotiation of upcoming contracts which could result in increased revenue to the agency. One covers the expiring Aramark contract for both building maintenance and food and beverage provision at Red Rocks Amphitheatre and the Denver Coliseum. The other is for the expiring Centerplate food and beverage contract at the Colorado Convention Center and the Denver Performing Arts Complex. MARKET ANALYSIS Market summary and Competition The metro Denver market is characterized as the fourth largest, per capita, concert-going city in the nation. Denver is the 17th largest media market in the US, and has a population which actively spends in the entertainment sector including sports, concerts, film, theater and outdoor activities. The market is highly competitive with residents having entertainment choices among seven pro sports teams, four local university sports programs, outdoor sports including a robust ski industry, an active theater and museum community and dozens of smaller live music venues. As a venue owner-operator, there are a number of venues competing for bookings, fans and sponsorship dollars including venues of similar sizes owned and operated by Kroenke Sports Enterprises (Pepsi Center, Paramount Theatre, FirstBank Center, Dick’s Sporting Goods Park), AEG Live (Bluebird Theater, Ogden Theater), Live Nation (Fillmore Theater, Comfort Dental Amphitheatre), University of Denver Magness Arena and Newman Center and a number of other sports and entertainment venues. As number of arts facilities are considered competition including new facilities such as Lone Tree Arts Center and the Parker Arts Culture & Event Center and older venues like the Arvada Center, Botanic Gardens, and Hudson Gardens. Competition for discretionary dollars spent in AVD buildings includes events at each of the aforementioned venues, but often comes at the expense of tickets sold at AVD buildings too. Family shows, theater, concerts, rodeos and other specialty acts all compete for dollars. Even free events promoted by AVD receive competition from the large number of festivals and events sponsored by other groups. In spite of this competition, the City and County of Denver owns and manages a wide variety of Page | 4 public assembly facilities with many of them being industry leaders: Red Rocks continues to be one of the most desirable venues for bands and fans alike; the Buell Theatre is one of the top Broadway touring venues in the region and country; and the Ellie Caulkins Opera House is unmatched in acoustics and design regionally. Locally, each of AVD’s venues meets a specific need as well as being flexible enough to accommodate a wide range of activities. Customer evaluation decisions Customer evaluation decisions at the consumer level are rarely influenced by the venue – a fan will attend the show regardless of where it is booked. The booker as a customer has terrific input regarding where to book shows and these decisions may be based on venue size, venue age, venue appeal, venue access, booking sales arrangements, percentages allowed to promoters, availability of marketing support, legacy of venue and other factors. INDUSTRY TRENDS Industry overview The entertainment and venues industries remain highly competitive. While sports and entertainment are generally considered to be recession-proof, that hasn’t been the case during the most recent recession. Now, the improving economy has provided for a resurgence in the music touring industry and arts and entertainment spending. While full-scale arena tours are still rare, mid-size and smaller acts continue to book and sell well at mid-level ticket price levels. Likewise, spending for theater productions and in art galleries has begun to increase. Changes in the industry Technology has been a key contributor to changes in the industry. Consumers have more options for their discretionary time from the advent of new technologies and the media content available. This has not hurt the live entertainment industry but has enhanced it. Artists are able to develop new audiences through digital media which then drives new live entertainment opportunities – important since concert businesses have grown as the recording industry has lost sales. New technologies also have made information more readily available, and have enhanced ticket sales options and other revenue streams for businesses like AVD’s. Other trends in the industry: The popularity of electronic and dance music has generated new business A focus on environmental sustainability has produced a number of opportunities It’s become acceptable to allow beverages in Broadway shows – allowing for greater sales Sponsorship evolution has resulted in better fan experiences at all of AVD’s venues Page | 5 Opportunities Continued exploitation of new technologies and improvements to AVD venues that enhance the customer’s experience The possibility of self-promoting concerts and creating new events New food and beverage contracts Hockey at the Coliseum may be a catalyst for the building and the adjacent neighborhoods The City has an opportunity to contribute on a larger scale to the citizens’ quality of life Threats and risks and challenges Funding to maintain venues will be necessary to keep pace with new facilities and competitive factors in the Denver market Increased competition by development of new venues will increase competition Loss of key tenants through financial problems or a change of venue creates a loss of revenue, FDA tax, employment Non-profit arts groups risk financial stability as they are particularly dependent on the overall economy MARKETING AND SALES The marketing and communications group at Arts & Venues Denver serves as an in-house agency providing full-service marketing, advertising and public relations functions. The marketing strategy of the agency is to provide communications support that: drives attendance at AVD events and venues assists promoters and sponsors in selling tickets and activating brands brands venues as city assets builds awareness of cultural programs educates arts fans identifies arts and entertainment as relevant and vital to city life develops business in the creative sector enhances overall fan experience in any venue or through any event or program AVD’s marketing group is committed to clear, educational and inspiring messaging. Communications will invite the region’s residents to experience city-branded events and venues. Sales strategies and tactics vary according to demographics, events and messaging. AVD will use all appropriate media to reach City residents in a variety of demographics. The combined effort of promotion, publicity and advertising – using traditional and new media, earned and paid – all will be considered in opening events and venues to new participants and repeat customers. AVD will make every effort to involve media as community partners in city-sponsored events and venues, thereby providing cost savings and additional publicity for agency properties. AVD will make every effort to enhance audience experiences through creative development of sponsor activation. And, AVD will work to provide timely and relevant information through unified websites and social media efforts. Page | 6 EVENT AND VENUE OPERATIONS Buildings are just buildings until they are brought to life through activation. At the heart of AVD’s function is making the City’s facilities available to showcase a wide variety of arts, entertainment and human connections through music, sport, theater, dance, receptions, lectures and cultural, educational and family programming. AVD venues are rented by many clients (promoters and presenters) with varying frequency – some rent once for special events and other use the facilities for regular programming. The following is a sample of the AVD client roster: DCPA, Colorado Symphony Orchestra, Opera Colorado, Colorado Ballet AEG Live, Live Nation, Feld Entertainment (Ringling Bros. Circus, Disney on Ice) National Western Stock Show Colorado Hockey LLC (anticipated in 2012) Colorado High School Activities Association Denver March Pow Wow Colorado Public Television Denver Film Society Colorado Children’s Chorale Let’s Talk Entertainment Slam Nuba Visit Denver and City-wide conventions such as Microsoft, Ameriprise, Mass Mutual AVD will work to expand this client roster and implement a number of processes that will improve experiences for clients – both venue patrons and promoters. New concessions contracts, wayfinding signage and video projection screens at select venues will improve general fan experiences. Bookers will find the implementation of an online and mobile booking option to expedite the booking process. VENUE OVERVIEW Denver Performing Arts Complex Galleria and Sculpture Park The Galleria is located between the theatres of the Denver Performing Arts Complex (DPAC) and provides protected pedestrian access to the Complex’s ten theatres, event spaces and parking garage. The elevated walkway bridges 13th Street and is sheltered by an 80-ft tall curved glass canopy that was installed in conjunction with the Temple Hoyne Buell Theatre construction in the early 1990’s. The Sculpture Park, adjacent to the performing arts complex, is owned by Denver’s Division of Parks and Recreation and managed by Arts & Venues. The park serves as the front door to DPAC and is rented out by Arts & Venues for special events. The most recent large CIP project was the Galleria paver replacement Phase 1 in 2010 for $500k. The second phase is scheduled for Q3 2012. Ellie Caulkins Opera House in Denver Performing Arts Complex The Denver Municipal Auditorium, now called the Ellie Caulkins Opera House at the Quigg Newton Denver Municipal Auditorium (“The Ellie”), was originally constructed in 1908 specifically to host Page | 7 the Democratic National Convention. The building was designed as a multi-purpose structure to accommodate concerts, operas, theatrical shows, conventions, basketball games, auto shows and circuses. The Auditorium underwent major renovations in 1955 and 1990, which eventually reduced the seating capacity from a maximum of 12,000 to 2,065. Most recently, the City and County of Denver raised $75 million to renovate the historic shell of the old Auditorium Theatre and re-envision the lobby space. The theatre now seats 2,225 patrons on four levels. An event space in the basement currently houses the Kevin Taylor’s at the Opera House restaurant. Concessionaire services are provided by Centerplate. The most recent major construction entailed the $2M bond project known as the Studio Loft on the 4th floor of the Ellie. Chambers Grant Salon/Studio Loft: located in the Newton Auditorium along with the Ellie Caulkins Opera House, these spaces serve as multi-function spaces for receptions, rehearsals, and small performances Buell Theatre in Denver Performing Arts Complex “The Buell” is Denver’s choice for high-profile Broadway shows and is designed to provide the audience with a first-rate theatrical experience. Originally part of the Denver Municipal Auditorium, which was built to house the Democratic National Convention in 1908, the building was converted to a basketball arena in 1953 and housed the ABA Denver Rockets and later the Denver Nuggets. The building was transformed in 1990 into a theatre and now seats 2,884 patrons on three levels. The Buell is a versatile venue and consistently ranks as one of the nation’s top grossing theatre under 3,000 seats. The theatre is generally well maintained, and does not require any major repairs. In 2008, all of the seats in the house were replaced, and in 2009, bar areas were updated and expanded. Boettcher Concert Hall in Denver Performing Arts Complex Boettcher Concert Hall was completed and opened to the public in 1978. The Hall was designed to closely mimic the state-of-the-art vineyard design of the Berliner Philharmonie, which opened in 1963 and received much praise for its original style and excellent acoustics. Unfortunately, Boettcher Concert Hall did not achieve the acoustical success of the Philharmonie, and has undergone several acoustical renovations in the last three decades. In 2007, the citizens of the City and County of Denver voted to approve the Better Denver Bond Program, a $400 million bond issuance that included $60 million dollars for renovations to Boettcher Concert Hall. The Colorado Symphony agreed to provide at least $30 million of additional funding for the project, but has since struggled to raise its portion of the funding. Colorado Convention Center The Colorado Convention Center consists of 2.2 million gross sf; 585,000 sf in the Exhibition Hall, 100,000 sf in 63 meeting spaces, 85,000 sf in two ballrooms and 5,000 sf in the Wells Fargo Theatre. The complex is managed by SMG with concessionaire services provided by Centerplate. The facility is supported by a total of 55 loading docks and 1,000 attached parking spaces and hosts approximately 350 events a year. At a cost of $340 million, the Convention Center underwent an expansion in 2004 that doubled its size. While the expansion was integrated seamlessly into the original building both visually and functionally, the building systems were not fully integrated at the time of the expansion. As such, many of the mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems, as well as some of the finishes, are in need of upgrades. This is due largely to Page | 8 their age and not due to poor maintenance. Major projects in the last four years include partial roof replacement ($2M), variable frequency drives ($900k), ballroom carpet and lighting upgrades ($800k), and card-reader door security ($400k). Denver Coliseum Construction on the Historic Denver Coliseum began in 1949 and was completed in 1952 at a cost of $3 million. The building consists of approximately 122,400 sf in the main building and adjacent Arcade, and seats a maximum of 10,500 patrons. The Barn provides an additional 60,000 sf of unconditioned space adjacent to the Arcade. Four parking lots adjacent to the structure can accommodate 2,604 cars. The Coliseum hosts an average of 120 events each year, including the National Western Stock Show, which accounts for approximately 25% of total annual traffic to the facility. While the Coliseum is profitable on an annual basis, it has not been mechanically upgraded in nearly 60 years of service, and the adjoining 60,000 sf barn has experience several partial roof collapses without significant structural reinforcement or renovation. The reinforced concrete structure of the Coliseum is robust and has been well-maintained by the on-site maintenance staff. The City completed a $7 million renovation of the Coliseum in 2002, but the building is in need of significantly more upgrades to make it a truly viable alternative to Denver’s other indoor venues. With a looming deal to bring a minor league hockey team to the Coliseum, the agency is poised to spend some capital maintenance on hockey infrastructure. Within the next two years, the agency also plans to add new hockey-specific dressing rooms, offices and a digital marquee along I-70. Red Rocks Amphitheatre Red Rocks Amphitheatre is a natural open-air theatre located 15 miles west of Denver, in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains. It was completed in 1941 and is one of the most celebrated outdoor amphitheatres in the country. Pollstar magazine, a leading music industry publication, renamed its annual “best small outdoor venue” prize the Red Rocks Award after bestowing the honor upon Red Rocks for the 11th time. The amphitheatre, which hosts 50-70 shows per year, is part of the larger Red Rocks Park, an 868-acre municipal park that is managed by Denver’s Division of Parks and Recreation and is the flagship of Denver’s storied Mountain Parks. The seating bowl contains 70 tiered rows of bench seating with a maximum capacity of 9,450. The amphitheatre is surrounded by towering natural sandstone formations, namely Creation Rock to the north, Ship Rock to the south, and Stage Rock to the east. The amphitheatre has undergone many renovations since its opening, but received its most recent and significant update in 2002 when a new Visitor Center was constructed at the back of the amphitheatre, a new water treatment and storage system was installed, and a new south concessions building (the South Tower) was built. The North Tower was reconstructed in 2005. Red Rocks has parking for 3,085 cars in six lots with additional curbside parking on the four access roads. Water is collected, treated and stored onsite with a maximum of 14,000 gallons per day of supply, 300,000 gallons of raw storage and 700,000 gallons of finished storage. During the peak of the summer concert season, the facility collects up to 70,000 gallons of raw sewage per day, but is only entitled to discharge 40,000 gallons per day to the Town of Morrison. A 180,000-gallon sewage storage tank is located under one of the parking lots to handle “overflow,” but fines from Morrison for over-discharging are frequent. As a remote outdoor amphitheatre with steep grades, significant natural sandstone formations in close proximity to the patrons, limited space and historical restrictions, Red Rocks presents unique operations and maintenance challenges, which are outlined below. Page | 9 The complex under Arts & Venues management includes the amphitheatre, Visitor Center, Trading Post, remote box office, water treatment plant, six parking lots and four access roads. The biggest investment in 2012 involves construction of a new loading dock and access road for $1.8M. This project provides a separation between truck delivery and patron access and thus will improve operations and safety. By 2013, AVD, Parks and Public Works will have replaced the Road 2 Bridge. Looming large for CIP planning is water and sewer infrastructure. The agency should plan to spend $5M within the next 5 years. CULTURAL PROGRAMMING AND THE CREATIVE INDUSTRY Create Denver 2012 Create Denver seeks to strengthen the overall health and vitality of Denver by supporting the growth and development of the creative sector, including individual artists and creative enterprises such as film, music, art galleries, art districts, fashion and graphic design. Denver’s creative sector consists of more than 2,900 creative enterprises and employs approximately 19,000 people in the city of Denver. The sector includes 8 distinct art districts, more than 120 galleries, 160 performance venues, and approximately 180 film-related businesses. Create Denver’s 2011 programming and accomplishments included, the annual Create Denver Week and Expo, NxLevel for Creatives business development courses, the first annual Art District Summit, Denver Gallery Guide online edition, Create Denver Revolving Loan Fund for creative enterprises, and the Design by Colorado exhibit at Denver International Airport. Cultural Events Special events are a portion of the cultural programs departments. The events are free and open to the public, are designed to address a need in underserved communities and to educate the citizens of metro Denver about the rich cultural and artistic heritage of our community. Cultural events include: The City Free Concert Series; One Book, One Denver; Denver Arts Week and the Mayor’s Awards for Excellence in the Arts. The City Free Concert Series consists of: The Five Points Jazz Festival, Independence Eve Concert, Film Fiesta and the eight-week Skyline Park Concert Series. The Five Points Jazz Festival annually draws 10,000 to 14,000 people to the Welton Street corridor for a day of food, fun and jazz. This event, which takes place the third Saturday in May, is in its ninth year, and has grown from a one venue concert to a street festival with six stages. The Independence Eve Concert in Civic Center Park is in its third year and is by far the largest free concert in the city. The concert is collaborative effort of Arts & Venues Denver, the Civic Center Conservancy and the Colorado Symphony Orchestra. The 2011 attendance for this concert was estimated at nearly 100,000. Film Fiesta is in its second year and replaced the Latino Rhythms Heritage Festival. This Page | 10 four-week film series with performances, celebrates the variety of the Latino culture in Denver. Finally, the Skyline Park concert series takes place weekly in the months of July and August with a variety of bands playing in each week. One Book, One Denver is a community reading program developed by Mayor Hickenlooper. There are three separate programs designed for different age groups. Preschool One Book, One Denver is geared toward children age 3-5 and takes place in mid-April during The Week of the Small Child, Youth One Book, One Denver (new in 2012) is geared toward children ages 9-12 and will take place in June and One Book, One Denver is geared toward high school age students and adults who are occasional readers and takes place in September and October. For all programs the community is invited to get involved in a citywide book club. There are readings and book discussions, as well as other activities that are related to the book. Arts & Venues Denver participates in Denver Arts Week with two events. The Mayor’s Awards for Excellence in the Arts ceremony is the kickoff event to Denver Arts Week and celebrates individuals and organizations that have made a significant contribution to the arts in the City and County of Denver. The second event, called “Under the Glasstop,” brings performers into the Denver Performing Arts Complex for a day of free entertainment that celebrates the performing arts in the City and County of Denver. Growing attendance and adding programming will be a focus on all programs, but in particular, goals for the next 12 months include: Increase attendance to all existing programs by at least 10% Develop 2-day Five Points Jazz Festival for 2013 Develop dance festival for 1st quarter 2013 A major 2012 goal of the agency will be to start the process of defining a large scale cultural plan for the City. A number of cities have roadmaps for creating and nurturing arts and Denver will be well served by engaging a number of publics in similar discussions. Denver Public Art Program Denver’s Public Art Program was established in 1988 under Mayor Federico Peña. The intent of the program was to “…expand the opportunities for Denver residents to experience art in public places, thereby creating more visually pleasing and human environments.” The Order directed that 1% of the construction budget of any capital improvement project over $1 million undertaken by the City be set aside for the inclusion of art in the design and construction of new projects and encouraged the participation of private dollars to enhance this public commitment. The Public Art Ordinance has enabled the City to acquire and display more than 300 works of art in Denver’s parks, recreation centers, civic buildings and streetscapes. In 2011 alone, the public art team installed 25 new and unique works of art in 11 locations. Page | 11 Urban Arts Fund The 2007 Graffiti Task Force Prevention Subcommittee identified a need for programs and initiatives to “reduce the likelihood of graffiti offenses and outline roles and responsibility for stakeholders to prevent graffiti vandalism.” This program funds education programs with youth who create murals in target neighborhoods. Tier III Administrative Support AVD staffs the annual submission of grant requests for the 100+ Tier III arts and science non-profits who receive funding from SCFD. This includes supporting the Denver County Cultural Council and providing technical support to the Tier III grantees. AVD FINANCIAL OVERVIEW The majority of the financial operations of Arts & Venues Denver are reported in Special Revenue Fund (“SRF”) 15815. The Colorado Convention Center financial operations are segregated in SRF 15607. Arts & Venues Denver also encompasses a number of additional special revenue funds and capital improvement funds that finance improvements to the venues. A consolidated AVD summary is presented below. ARTS & VENUES FUNDS OPERATING FUNDS DONATION FUNDS / SPECIAL PURPOSE FUNDS CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT FUNDS Arts & Venues Special Revenue Fund 15815 Preserve The Rocks Donations Special Revenue Fund Fund 15714 Quigg Newton Auditorium Donations Special Revenue Fund Fund 15717 Arts & Venues Capital Projects Fund Fund 39010 Boettcher Concert Hall Maintenance Fund ($20M) Fund 37110 Colorado Convention Center Special Revenue Fund 15607 Temple Hoyne Buell Theatre Donations Special Revenue Fund 15718 Boettcher Concert Hall Donations Special Revenue Fund 15719 Chambers Grant Salon Grant Fund 38186 Boettcher Concert Hall Maintenance Fund 37140 ($40M) DOCA Donations Program Special Revenue Fund 11718 Cultural Capital Maintenance Fund (AVD Share) Fund 34995 Other Agency Capital Projects Fund 34080 Arts & Venues Denver generates revenue primarily through the rental of the facilities and equipment within the facilities, commission payments from concessionaires on food, beverage and merchandise sold in venues, parking fees generated from parking lots and garages adjacent to the facilities, and reimbursed stagehand, usher, and other labor costs. Additional revenue is derived from cultural tourism, corporate sponsorship, and advertising sales, as well as gifts and donations to the agency. Approximately half of Arts & Venues Denver expenditures are variable with event activity and revenue; stagehand, usher and other labor expenses increase or decrease relative to the number of events booked in venues. In addition to labor expenditures (for both full time and contract labor), Arts & Venues Denver incurs professional service expenditures, supplies expenditures, capital equipment expenditures, and other government services (utilities, printing, phones, technology service support, fleet charges, etc.) A forecast of revenue and expenditures is included below. Page | 12 SPECIAL REVENUE FUND 15815 TOTAL ASSETS $ TOTAL LIABILITIES $ BEGINNING FUND BALANCE ADD (SUBTRACT): NET REVENUE (EXPENDITURES) TRANSFERS FROM FUND BALANCE 2009 ACTUAL 2010 ACTUAL 2011 ACTUAL 2012 BUDGET 2013 ESTIMATE 2014 ESTIMATE 2015 ESTIMATE 7,959,311 $ 9,854,595 $ 11,862,727 $ 5,700,000 $ 5,700,000 $ 5,700,000 $ 5,700,000 (1,332,706) $ (4,563,796.03) (2,062,808.55) - (1,177,241) $ (6,652,314.64) (2,578,038.91) 553,000 (2,007,609) (1,200,000) (1,200,000) (1,200,000) (1,200,000) (8,677,353.55) (3,268,393.20) 2,125,000 (9,820,747) (47,500) 5,368,247 (4,500,000) (462,600) 462,600 (4,500,000) (419,500) 419,500 (4,500,000) (483,700) 483,700 (4,500,000) $ (5,700,000) (4,500,000) $ (5,700,000) (4,500,000) $ (5,700,000) (4,500,000) (5,700,000) ENDING FUND BALANCE LIABILITIES + FUND BALANCE $ (6,626,604.58) $ (8,677,353.55) $ (9,820,746.75) $ $ (7,959,311) $ (9,854,595) $ (11,828,356) TOTAL REVENUE $ (20,979,533) $ (20,678,890) $ (22,885,050) $ (21,044,600) (21,602,600) (22,149,500) (22,683,700) $ $ 4,808,901 $ 10,923,006 670,099 366,077 2,148,641 18,916,724 $ 4,429,999 $ 10,608,783 697,590 155,770 2,208,710 18,100,852 $ 4,882,802 $ 11,603,426 738,196 22,403 2,369,829 19,616,657 $ 5,712,700 $ 13,402,900 789,400 387,700 704,400 20,997,100 $ 5,700,000 $ 13,500,000 800,000 400,000 740,000 $ 21,140,000 $ 6,000,000 $ 13,700,000 825,000 425,000 780,000 $ 21,730,000 $ 6,200,000 13,900,000 850,000 450,000 800,000 22,200,000 $ (2,062,809) $ (2,578,039) $ (3,268,393) $ (47,500) $ (462,600) $ (419,500) $ (483,700) EXPENDITURES TOTAL SALARY AND RELATED TOTAL SERVICES TOTAL SUPPLIES TOTAL CAPITAL EQUIPMENT TOTAL GOVT. AND OTHER TOTAL EXPENDITURES NET (REVENUE) EXPENDITURES Assumptions and comments / MD&A The financial forecast assumes some material operational changes in a number of AVD venues. These items include: Coliseum Hockey team plays 31 events with attendance of and FDA tax of $100,000. Crossroads Theatre lease is not extended past 12/31/2012. This results in higher per event revenue and expenditure metrics through the forecast period. Boettcher construction, during which time the venue would be closed for an extended period, resulting in lost revenue, is not included in the financial forecast for AVD. McNichols Building costs are not included in the financial forecast. Utilities are accounted for in services and supplies expense beginning 2012 forward through the projection period and in Other Governmental Expenditures prior to 2012. Cultural Programming funding is fixed throughout the projection period at $1.2M per year. Revenue Surplus / Fund Balance Discussion The financial projection above illustrates that for the past three years, AVD has surplus revenue in excess of expenditures in SRF 15815. This is due to a variety of factors, including operating efficiencies and improvements, increased food and beverage commission percentages, and recurring seasons with a high number of popular commercial events booked in the Buell Theatre and at Red Rocks Amphitheatre. Some of these efficiencies (ex. changes in food and beverage contracts) will shift the burden of providing maintenance funds to support infrastructure from the vendor to the City in return for higher revenues. Because of these revenue surpluses, AVD management was confident in the ability to merge the former DOCA with Theatres and Arenas to form the consolidated AVD agency. As noted previously, this merger saves the General Fund over $1.2M annually, but will in turn reduce future AVD operating surpluses in SRF 15815. In late 2010, AVD management, working with the BMO, developed a policy to further leverage the operating surpluses by using SRF 15815 accumulated fund balance to finance venue improvements. In early 2010, $553,000 was transferred from SRF 15815 fund balance to retire a capital lease obligation for the ECOH opera translation system, saving over $100,000 in future interest expense. In 2011, $1M of fund balance was dedicated to renovation the McNichols building in order to receive a $1M matching grant from the Boettcher Foundation. An additional $1.125M was dedicated to fund a service road and loading dock project at Red Rocks, a project that will greatly enhance the efficiency of the Food and Beverage operations and safety at the Red Page | 13 Rocks Visitors Center. These venue improvements, combined with the integration of the former DOCA and its $1.2M annual budget, reduce accumulated operating fund balance with strategic investments in venue improvements. Key financial metrics A summary of the forecast Key Performance Indicators (“KPI”) is presented below: Consolidated AVD Venues Attendance at All Venues Events held at All Venues 2009 ACTUAL 1,740,052 698 FDA Tax receipts at All Venues 2 Avg. Attendance per Event Avg. FDA Tax per Event Avg. Gross Revenue per Event Avg. Consolidated Expense per Event $ $ $ $ 5,920,277 2,493 8,482 30,057 27,101 2010 ACTUAL 1,696,199 732 $ $ $ $ 6,022,236 2,317 8,227 28,250 24,728 2011 ACTUAL 2012 BUDGET 2013 FORECAST 2014 FORECAST 2015 FORECAST 1,706,638 1,712,573 1,855,000 1,855,000 1,855,000 755 810 653 653 653 $ $ $ $ 6,361,888 2,260 8,426 30,311 25,982 $ $ $ $ 5,853,500 2,114 7,227 25,981 25,922 $ $ $ $ 6,175,000 2,841 9,456 33,082 32,374 $ $ $ $ 6,175,000 2,841 9,456 33,920 33,277 $ $ $ $ 6,175,000 2,841 9,456 34,738 33,997 As the table below illustrates, AVD anticipates greater attendance, gross revenue, and FDA Tax receipts through the projection period. Capital Construction and Maintenance Funding For the past four years, AVD received funding for venue Capital Improvement Projects (“CIP”) from a variety of sources, including bonds (for major venue construction projects), donation funds, grant funds, and the City’s Entertainment and Cultural Capital Projects Fund (ECCPF) 39010. The historical trends clearly illustrate declining sources and amounts of funding available to make improvements in the venues. AVD tracks all capital and maintenance spending with a unique “Org” within the City’s financial accounting system (3050102) and a history of agency spending and the funding sources is included below. AVD Venue Capital and Maintenance Expenditures By Funding Source and Amount Org 3050102 Venue Improvement Fund Sources Private Grant Funds Donation Funds Bond Funds Mill Levy Funds Surplus Seat Tax / ECCPF Funds Total Venue Improvement Funds Expended 2008 2009 2010 2011 $ 1,652,772 $ 1,199,698 $ 331,918 $ 926,947 800,921 14,256 193,943 1,718,198 906,779 1,309,894 1,069,822 317,297 852,085 980,055 4,252,495 3,776,112 2,983,922 1,854,154 $ 8,550,412 $ 7,000,808 $ 5,492,075 $ 4,097,974 Page | 14 Surplus Seat Tax / ECCPF Funds $9,000,000 $8,000,000 Mill Levy Funds $7,000,000 $6,000,000 Bond Funds $5,000,000 $4,000,000 Donation Funds $3,000,000 $2,000,000 Private Grant Funds $1,000,000 $0 2008 2009 2010 2011 Venue Improvement Fund Sources The primary source of funding for AVD venue maintenance is from the City’s Facilities Development Admission Tax (“FDA Tax” or “Seat Tax”), a 10% tax on the purchase price of ticketed admissions to events held in or on City of Denver owned property. This tax was Established in 1975 for the purpose of “...payment of expenses in acquiring, constructing, installing, maintaining, repairing, operating, or improving facilities of the city.” [Chapter 53, Article VII of the DRMC [53-341 through 53-395]. The Treasurer collects the tax and deposits these funds into an apportioned account from which they are first applied to service two outstanding AVD debt issues: the 2003A Buell Theatre Excise Tax Refunding Bonds and the Quigg Newton Auditorium Theatre 2003B COP lease payment. The total of these two annual debt obligations is approximately $5M. Seat Tax collected in excess of these two debt service payments may be used to improve City entertainment and cultural facilities (“surplus seat tax”). The amount of surplus seat tax has declined since 2008, the last year the City received an annual $2.8M payment from the Denver Broncos pursuant to a ten year agreement to build Invesco Field. In addition to funding the agency’s capital improvement projects, surplus seat tax revenue supports annual CIP improvements to the Helen Bonfils Theatre Complex (“HBTC”), the National Western Complex (“NWC”), and the Denver Botanic Gardens (“DBG”) equal to the amount of FDA tax collected in each facility during the previous calendar year. In recent years, the BMO has supplemented surplus seat tax with Mill Levy funding to support venue capital improvement projects for AVD venues. The surplus seat tax and supplemental Mill Levy Funding currently provides approximately $3M per year for AVD venue maintenance, an insufficient amount to maintain AVD venues at historical maintenance levels or desired service levels for patrons, promoters and performers. Furthermore, the lack of adequate CIP and maintenance funding for the existing portfolio of venues will inhibit or altogether eliminate any future expansion of public assembly venues until a new dedicated maintenance funding source is identified. Page | 15 New Special Revenue Fund AVD management strongly recommends establishing a new SRF that is funded by excess operating revenue from SRF 15815 to support necessary venue improvements. Such a policy is consistent with historical practices as previously mentioned, but would not necessitate recurring ordinances in the future to provide additional funding sources for future venue improvements. This financial forecast assumes such a new policy is established to sweep excess operating funds (fund balance over $4.5M) from SRF 15815 into a new special revenue fund dedicated for operating and capital improvements in the venues. The financial projection therefore assumes a level end of year $4.5M fund balance is maintained in SRF 15815 throughout the projection period. AVD SRF 15815 ACCUMULATED REVENUE SURPLUS DEDICATED TO VENUE IMPROVEMENTS 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 $ 6,626,605 $ 9,230,354 $ 11,945,747 $ 9,868,247 $ 4,962,600 $ 4,919,500 $ 4,983,700 553,000 2,125,000 5,368,247 462,600 419,500 483,700 12/31 AVD FUND BALANCE (SRF 15815) $ 6,626,605 $ 8,677,354 $ 9,820,747 $ 4,500,000 $ 4,500,000 $ 4,500,000 $ 4,500,000 $16,000,000 DEDICATED TO VENUE IMPROVEMENTS $14,000,000 $12,000,000 $10,000,000 $8,000,000 ACCUMULATED REVENUE SURPLUS $6,000,000 $4,000,000 $2,000,000 $0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 In addition, based on the event forecast, attendance projections, and FDA Tax revenue and surplus forecast, the aforementioned financial projection assumes that surplus seat tax and mill levy funding will be available to support the AVD capital improvement program at a level of $4M per year. This is believed to be the minimum level required to maintain the existing portfolio of venues current levels of service. A summary of the FDA Tax sources and uses is presented below. Page | 16 FDA TAX COLLECTIONS AND USES 2009- 2015 SOURCES OF FDA TAX REVENUE Football Stadium Annual Payment Convention Center DCPA Helen Bonfils Boettcher Hall Buell Theatre Ellie Caulkins Opera House Crossroads Theatre Coliseum Red Rocks Amphiheatre National Western Denver Botanical Gardens Other / Unallocated to Venue TOTAL FDA TAX COLLECTIONS OTHER SOURCES OF REVENUE Interest Earnings (Fund 39010) Mill Levy Money (Funds 34080 and 34995) TOTAL OTHER SOURCES OF REVENUE TOTAL REVENUE FROM ALL SOURCES ACTUAL 2009 ACTUAL 2010 ACTUAL 2011 BUDGET 2012 ESTIMATED 2013 ESTIMATED 2014 ESTIMATED 2015 554,119 465,228 597,148 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 490,278 576,222 562,703 550,000 550,000 550,000 550,000 387,506 472,002 560,665 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 2,737,510 2,183,482 2,532,078 2,200,000 2,400,000 2,400,000 2,400,000 481,473 555,308 479,503 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 1,911 1,102 3,500 799,505 646,230 569,810 650,000 675,000 675,000 675,000 1,514,283 2,145,476 2,183,193 2,000,000 2,100,000 2,100,000 2,100,000 67,559 75,562 358,192 85,000 358,000 358,000 358,000 139,053 113,580 125,416 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 17,827 35,537 $7,171,285 $7,252,828 $8,005,347 $7,108,500 $7,703,000 $7,703,000 $7,703,000 $ 112,918 $ 33,164 $ 38,795 $ 500,000 1,040,000 1,455,000 $ 612,918 $ 1,073,164 $ 1,493,795 $ $ 7,784,203 $ 8,325,992 $ 9,499,142 $ 35,000 $ 1,215,000 1,250,000 $ 8,358,500 $ 35,000 $ 2,543,021 2,578,021 $ 10,281,021 $ 35,000 $ 2,672,831 2,707,831 $ 10,410,831 $ 35,000 2,672,800 2,707,800 10,410,800 $ 3,054,136 $ 2,558,136 $ 2,857,906 $ USES OF FUNDS Payments for Excise Debt (1st Priority) Pmts for Auditorium 2003 COP debt 3,716,794 3,054,243 $ 3,057,731 $ 3,054,131 $ 3,053,600 1,998,931 1,912,031 1,942,531 2,176,981 2,328,700 2,329,200 117,565 139,053 113,580 125,416 120,000 120,000 194,364 358,190 358,000 358,000 576,222 562,703 550,000 5,880,940 $ 6,281,021 $ 6,410,831 $ 6,410,800 2,477,560 $ 4,000,000 $ 4,000,000 $ 4,000,000 APPROPRIATION FOR CIP Botanic Gardens $ 116,401 $ NW Allocation 470,017 DCPA Helen Bonfils TOTAL USES OF FUNDS 455,374 490,278 $ 7,357,348 $ 5,130,007 $ 5,399,268 $ SURPLUS SEAT TAX AVAILABLE FOR A&VD CIP IMPROVEMENTS $ 426,855 $ 3,195,985 $ 4,099,874 $ 550,000 As the exhibit above clearly illustrates, a significant increase in Mill Levy funding will be required to maintain an annual $4M CIP program to maintain AVD venues. Page | 17