Occupational Health & Safety Practitioner Reading JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS January 2009 ® Contents OVERVIEW .....................................................................................................................1 SECTION 1: INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................2 SECTION 2: PREPARING A JSA ..................................................................................6 SECTION 3: IDENTIFY HAZARDS..............................................................................11 SECTION 4: CONTROL RISKS ...................................................................................12 APPENDIX 1: WORK PLAN.........................................................................................12 APPENDIX 2: JSA FORM ............................................................................................12 Government of Western Australia Department of Commerce Published by WorkSafe, PO Box 294, WEST PERTH WA 6872. Tel: Toll Free 1300 307 877. Email: institute@worksafe.wa.gov.au ® The SafetyLine Institute material has been prepared and published as part of Western Australia’s contribution to national OHS skills development. www.worksafe.wa.gov.au/institute © 2009 State of Western Australia. All rights reserved. Details of copyright conditions are published at the SafetyLine Institute website. Before using this publication note should be taken of the Disclaimer, which is published at the SafetyLine Institute website. READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS OVERVIEW This reading fully details how to undertake a Job Safety Analysis. Objectives After reading this information you should be able to do a Job Safety Analysis Author Ron Greenwood This reading was originally prepared when Ron was Principal OSH Analyst & Systems Advisor at Stratex Worley Pty Ltd, Perth, Western Australia. JANUARY 2009 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 1 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Section 1: INTRODUCTION Glossary of terms When they are first used, glossary terms are indicated with an asterisk (*). Make sure that you are familiar with the Glossary of terms before going any further. Permit to Work Formal written authority for persons, usually trades-persons, to carry out work including maintenance on plant, a building or an item of equipment. 1.1 What is a job safety analysis? A Job Safety Analysis (JSA) is a process of planning for work with safety an integral factor of the way the job is done. It is a method of ensuring that sufficiently skilled manpower, plant/equipment and materials/resources are allocated for a task and all persons ultimately involved are aware of and follow a safe system of work. Photograph courtesy of West Australian Petroleum Pty. Ltd. PAGE 2 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS 1.2 Benefits of JSA Carrying out a Job Safety Analysis must be an important part of an organisation's safety management plan for risk management and consultative work practice processes. In keeping with occupational safety and health (OSH) legislative objectives, it facilitates the hazard identification, assessment and control strategy needed to achieve a safe system of work. In this way, it not only contributes to good safety management, but also to an increase in efficiency and productivity. In reality, making a workplace safer requires the commitment and co-operation of each employee. The Job Safety Analysis process is perhaps one of the most effective ways of enabling an individual employee to participate and work as part of a team. In fact, employees are able to make important contributions and through continuous work practice improvement, establish Best Practice initiatives. Other benefits of conducting a JSA include improved communication about safety as a continuous training medium and the confirmation of skill competency. 1.3 Work requiring a JSA Any work activity whether scheduled or unscheduled should have a Job Safety Analysis carried out, inclusive of: JANUARY 2009 Tasks that have a history of, or potential for, injury, near miss or loss related incidents. Safety critical tasks (eg. fire, explosion, chemical spill and creation of toxic or oxygen deficient atmosphere). Tasks carried out in new environments. Jobs that have changed. Tasks that have been rarely performed or where new people are performing the task. Tasks where workplace application or environmental conditions have or may change. Tasks performed under Permit to Work* conditions. Tasks that may impact on the integrity or output of a processing system. SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 3 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS 1.4 Importance of a work plan A Work Plan is always necessary, to have the scope of the work clarified and broken down into stages so that a JSA can be identified for each separate task. KEY POINT A work Plan is necessary to identify separate tasks that require a separate JSA. An example Work Plan is given on the following page. In addition, a blank Work Plan is included at the end of the reading as an Appendix. PAGE 4 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS WORK PLAN Job No: 123 Supervisor: J. BLOGGS Department: Vehicle Maintenance. Permit Holder: N/A Job Function: Motor Mechanic Location of Work: Perth Maintenance Workshop Equipment No: Reg, XYZ-123 Tag No: N/A Description of Job: 10.000 Kilometre service and tune-up of Hi Lux delivery vehicle Proposed Start Date: 15/04/98 Time: 9 AM Task Duration: 2 hours Tasks: 1. Change Spark Plugs and set Engine Timing 2. Change Oil and Oil Filter 3. Check Brakes and Brake Linings 4. Check Tyres and Wheel Balance Manpower Requirements: 1. Maintenance Supervisor 2. Mechanic Apprentice Plant & Equipment: 1. Mechanical tools and equipment: a. Socket Set b. Multi-Meter c. Tool Kit ( Standard) Chemicals/Bulk Materials: Nil JANUARY 2009 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 5 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Section 2: PREPARING A JSA Development of a JSA involves: Resource forecasting and planning carried out simultaneously by a manager or supervisor. Development of the JSA with the full participation of the employee(s) assigned to complete the task of work. Review and monitoring of its implementation, carried out with the full participation of the employee(s) assigned to complete the task of work. 2.1 Resource forecasting and planning by management Management forecasting This involves forecasting by management of manpower/skill requirements, plant and equipment, and material resources required. This would be completed as a desktop exercise during scheduling and the initial development of the work planned. Supervisor planning This involves planning by the assigned supervisor, to confirm the objective of the task, timeframes, work procedure and deployment of manpower/skill; against the application of plant and equipment and material resources. This would be completed as a desktop exercise involving the selection of and assignment of personnel, and the review of historical information to identify hazard potential and control strategies. PAGE 6 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Issues to consider Consider the following: Who will be responsible for supervising the work? What exactly, is the scope of work to be done? How might the task impact on other workplace activity? How might the task be impacted on by other workplace activity? Where will the job be done? When will the job be done and how long will it take? In what sequence will stages of work be scheduled for completion? What are the manpower/skill requirements? What are the plant and equipment requirements? What chemicals or bulk materials will be required and/or require handling? 2.2 Development of JSA Supervisor Develops JSA in Consultation with Employee(s) Steps to follow are: JANUARY 2009 Review the scope of the job and work plan with the assigned employee(s). Identify each task of the job and review with the assigned employee(s). Identify the procedures involved in each task to be completed. KEY POINT JSA involves reviewing the procedures in logical steps, identifying the hazards, and assessing and controlling the risks. Review the procedures in logical steps. Identify and assess the hazards in each step. Develop solutions to eliminate or control hazards in each step. SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 7 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS 2.3 Monitoring and review of JSA Supervisor Reviews Completed JSA in Consultation with Employee(s) The completed JSA is reviewed by the supervisor, in consultation with assigned employee (s) prior to the commencement of the planned work activity. The employee(s) assigned for the task are trained in the new safe system of work. This confirms an understanding of the scope of the work, levels of employee experience and capability, and planned arrangements for the control of hazards. It also allows further employee identification and analysis of hazard potential and the opportunity to initiate additional control measures. Implemented Safe System is Monitored There is direct observation of the safe system by management, carried out continuously to monitor the adequacy and application of the agreed safe system of work. The JSA is reviewed and updated at the completion of the job for future reference. An example JSA is given on the following page. In addition, a blank JSA form is included at the end of the reading as an appendix. PAGE 8 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS JOB No: 123 JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS DATE: 15/04/1998 JOB DESCRIPTION: 10.000 Kilometre service and tune-up of Hi Lux delivery vehicle START DATE: 15/04/1998 TIME: 09:00 am TASK DURATION: 2 hours 5. TASK DESCRIPTION: Change out Spark Plugs and set Engine Timing # STEP IDENTIFIED HAZARD/LOSS CONTROL METHOD 1 Preparation of workspace The car could be started whilst being worked on. Car could roll. Dropping tools or parts. Tripping or slipping Remove ignition source (Keys, coil H.T>lead). Make sure handbrake is on and car is in gear. In PARK if automatic. Chock wheels, especially if on slope. Protect mudguards with cover. Check for oil spills or obstacles in path. 2 Lift bonnet Bonnet slipping, Wear gloves. Ensure bonnet stay is accurately falling. If spring placed. Hold hand on top of bonnet to control if it is loaded slipping spring loaded. Wear bump cap. from fingers. Hitting head. Cutting on edge of bonnet. 3 Note the plug lead location relative to the cylinder and remove. Replacing wrong lead can cause backfire in carburettor creating fire hazards or damage to exhaust system or engine. 4 Remove all Burns from hot spark plugs. engine. Oil and grease contamination. Sharp edges of cylinder head or rocker cover. 5 Identify type Incorrect spark Check spark plug chart for correct spark plug for of spark plug can cause make and model. (Do not rely on existing plugs for poor performance, information - they may be incorrect). plug. backfire and subsequent damage. JANUARY 2009 Place tape with cylinder number on leads Allow engine to cool. Wear gloves. Cover edges of cylinder head or rocker cover with rags or cloth, leather or vinyl cover. SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 9 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS 6 Decide whether to adjust or replace spark plugs. 7 Clean plugs Plug cleaner if necessary. unsafe eg. Power outlet OK? Air coupling OK? Correct power installed? High voltage, check power lead insulated OK? Removable rubber cap for spark plug fitted OK? Check power point and lead for correct insulation. Check compressed air piping for leaks and at coupling. Check H.T. leads. Check rubber ring tight, no splits. Wear safety goggles and gloves. 8 Replace See step 4. Strip spark plugs. thread in alloy cylinder head. Make sure both spark plug and cylinder threads are clean. Start spark plugs by hand not socket. 9 Connect ignition leads to appropriate spark plug. Wear gloves. See step 3. Hand slipping. Grease, oil contamination. Wrong H.T. lead on spark plug. 10 Check for Leads may be performance incorrectly fitted. Tools left in engine bay. Vehicle in gear. Fire if engine backfires. (N.B. some new spark plugs fail) Do not remove taped numbers until after performance check. Use shadow board for tools or paint eg. yellow. Ensure car is in neutral or PARK if automatic. Have correct fire extinguisher handy throughout operation. 11 Clean tools and equipment. Read Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) carefully. Use appropriate personal protective equipment, eg face mask, respirator mask, gloves, long sleeve shirt, apron, etc. Have correct fire extinguisher close by. Clean tools in a well-ventilated area. WORK TEAM: Solvents and cleaners may be toxic and/or be highly flammable. NAME SIGNATURE NAME SIGNATURE Acknowledgment: 'Right Start' Division of Workplace Health and Safety, Brisbane. PAGE 10 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Section 3: IDENTIFY HAZARDS The complete identification of hazards in each task procedure of the JSA is crucial. Consider the following classifications in the identification of hazard potential: JANUARY 2009 Human factors, eg. competency, training, fitness and fatigue. Simultaneous operations. Damage to plant & equipment and interruption to production. Weather, visibility, lighting & noise. Exposure to hazardous atmospheres, physical & biological agents. Pollution to the environment. Workplace layout, ground conditions (stability/surface/slope), access & egress. KEY POINT A wide-ranging consideration of all possible hazards is necessary. Workplace signage & barricading. Workplace amenities and first aid requirements. Fire prevention & protection. Personal protective equipment. Housekeeping arrangements. Materials handling & manual handling requirements. Materials storage, security and recovery requirements. Use of hazardous substances. Electrical hazard exposure, isolations, tagging and/or lockout requirements. Compressed gas, high-pressure air and oils, water & steam. Suitability of standard & power operated hand tools. Fixed & portable plant & machinery management. Grinding, cutting, heating & welding operations. Mobile plant operation and movement. Excavations, holes & floor openings. Concrete & masonry construction. Ladders & scaffolding requirements, work at height & prevention of falls. Confined space entry. SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 11 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Section 4: CONTROL RISKS The purpose of the JSA process is to identify opportunities for effective risk control in support of ensuring that a safe system of work is in place. In selecting the most appropriate control method, the higher priorities of eliminating the hazard or isolating the process from the worker KEY POINT must be considered for implementation before any lower priority of isolating the Any introduced control measures must be worker (eg. issuing personal protective monitored to confirm their effectiveness. equipment) is considered. Once a risk has been assessed, measures must be taken to reduce the risk to a level that is 'as low as reasonably practicable' (ALARP). OS&H Legislation may provide specific measures to control risks and these must be followed. PAGE 12 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Information or ideas on control measures can come from: Codes of practice Guidance notes Employees Industry associations Unions Government agencies Specialist practitioners/consult ants Manufacturers/supp liers Australian Standards Control measures must be monitored to confirm implementation has been effective. 4.1 Hierarchy of control measures Elimination Removing the hazard or hazardous work practice from the workplace. This is the most effective control measure. Substitution Substituting or replacing the hazard or hazardous work practice with a less hazardous one. Isolation Isolating or separating the hazard or hazardous work practice from persons at the workplace or the general work area. JANUARY 2009 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 13 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Engineering control If the hazard cannot be eliminated, substituted or isolated, engineering control is the next preferred measure to control the risk. It may include modifications to tools or equipment, using enclosures, guarding, mechanical ventilation or automating processes. KEY POINT As control measures are not mutually exclusive, on occasions more than one control measure will need to be used to reduce exposure. Administrative control Introducing policies, and changes in work practice and procedures that reduce the risk. This could include limiting the time employees are exposed to the hazard, reducing the number of employees exposed, rotating jobs, lockout or tag-out procedures, or prohibiting eating and drinking in contaminated areas. Personal protective equipment The risk control application of providing personal protective equipment should be considered only: When other control measures are not practicable. When used in conjunction with other methods to provide a greater measure of protection. Where specified by legislation as a basic requirement. Where personal protective equipment has been provided, its use must be monitored to ensure it is adequate and being worn. APPENDICES Blank copies of the Work Plan and JSA have been included as appendices for you to print off and use in your workplace: PAGE 14 Work Plan - to clarify the scope of the task to be analysed (Appendix 1). JSA Record Form (Appendix 2). SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Your feedback WorkSafe is committed to continuous improvement. If you take the time to complete the online Feedback Form at the SafetyLine Institute website you will assist us to maintain and improve our high standards. JANUARY 2009 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 15 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS Appendix 1 WORK PLAN Supervisor: Permit Holder: Location of Work: Job No: Department: Job Function: Equipment No: Tag No: Description of Job: Proposed Start Date: Time: Task Duration: Tasks: Manpower Requirements: Plant & Equipment: Chemicals/Bulk Materials: PAGE 16 SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE JANUARY 2009 READING – JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS APPENDIX 2 – JSA RECORD FORM JOB NO: JOB SAFETY ANALYSIS DATE: ..../..../.... JOB DESCRIPTION: START DATE: ..../..../.... TIME: ..........am/pm TASK DURATION: ............ TASK DESCRIPTION: # STEP IDENTIFIED HAZARD/LOSS CONTROL METHOD 1 2 3 4 5 Suggest 10 steps ALL TEAM MEMBERS SIGN IN AGREEMENT NAME JANUARY 2009 SIGNATURE SAFETYLINE INSTITUTE PAGE 17