Investment Proposal Delta Air Lines, Inc. (NYSE: DAL) December 7th, 2014 Agenda 1. Industry Overview 1. Airline Industry 2. Industry Distribution 3. Current Situation 2. Company Information 1. Timeline 2. Company Overview 3. Operations 4. Corporate Strategy 5. Labor Peace 6. Delta Trading Overview 3. Valuation 1. Trading Comparable 2. Discounted Cash Flow Analysis 3. Valuation Ranges (Football Field) 4. Recommendation 1. Merits & Risks 2. Conclusion 2 Industry Overview 3 Airline Industry Major Players 4 Year Index Performance Global Commercial Airline Revenue ($ Billions) $800 110% XAL S&P 60% 10% Crude -40% Nov-10 Other $400 Cargo Passenger $200 $0 Nov-11 Nov-12 Nov-13 Source:Yahoo Finance, Bloomberg, International Air Transportation Association (IATA) 4 $600 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014E Industry Distribution Airline Domestic Market Share September 2013 - August 2014 Spirit, 2.00% SkyWest, 2.30% Other, 14.80% Delta, 16.60% ExpressJet, 2.40% Alaska, 4.20% Southwest, 16.40% JetBlue, 5.10% United, 15.30% US Airways, 8.40% American, 12.50% Current Situation Plummeting Oil Prices 1 Year Overview § Since June, the price of oil has declined about 40% § Increased amount of fracking in United States § OPEC’s decision to maintain current oil production § Decrease in global demand of oil § Currently, crude oil (WTI) is trading at $66.81 § Analysts estimate that price will average $63.72 in Jan 2015 110 90 70 WTI 50 Dec-13 Relevance to Airlines § On average, jet fuel accounts for 34% of an airline’s operating costs. Lower fuel prices directly increases airlines’ revenues. § Richard Anderson, Delta CEO, on oil prices during CBS interview: “For every penny the price of jet fuel declines means savings of $40 million for Delta Airlines” Source: Bloomberg, Seeking Alpha,Yahoo Finance 6 Apr-14 Aug-14 Lower Oil Prices ≠ Lower Air Fare § Airlines have not lowered fares § Planes are in full capacity § investors want a payout § new planes are in order § Historical Reference § All carriers tried to raise fares due to sharp spike in energy prices during 2008. Efforts were futile and five airlines went bankrupt Company Information 7 Timeline of Major Events May 1924 Founded in Macon, GA September 2005 Filed for bankruptcy April 1957 Began trading on New York Stock Exchange November 2006 Failed takeover attempt by US Airways Source: Company Website, New York Times, Wall Street Journal 8 April 1987 Merged with Western Airlines and became the fifth largest carrier in the world April 2007 Emerged from bankruptcy November 1991 Purchased substantially all of Pan Am’s trans-Atlantic routes and the Pan Am Shuttle April 2012 Purchased an oil refinery to pursue vertical integration Company Overview Company Summary Headquarters Atlanta, GA Share Price $47.28 Market Cap 39.43 Billion P/E 4.09 52-Wk Range Dividend Yield $26.40 - $47.63 0.80% Financial Performance FY 2010 FY 2011 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014E Revenue $31,755 $35,115 $36,670 $37,773 $40,195 Gross Margin 39.59% 36.97% 37.41% 40.66% 40.86% 10.51% 9.84% 9.80% 13.33% 13.8% Net Income $593 $854 $1,009 $10,540 $2,075 EPS 1.71 1.41 1.83 3.15 3.25 EBITDA Margin Revenue Breakdown 2.50% 1 Year Trading Overview 50 Passenger Segment 10.30% DAL 40 Cargo Segment 30 87.20% Other Sources Source: Capital IQ,Yahoo Finance, Seeking Alpha, Company public filings 9 20 12/3/13 3/3/14 6/3/14 9/3/14 Operations Currently the 3rd largest airline, Delta has added more international capacity than any major U.S. airline in the past few years. Through its vast network and partnership, Delta provides more than 325 destinations on six continents. Whitehorse Ft. McMurray Prince George U.S. Edmonton Vancouver Abbotsford Bellingham Victoria Calgary/Banff Kelowna Deer Lake St. John’s, NL CANADA Seattle/Tacoma Wenatchee ALASKA Portland CANADA Fairbanks Eugene Anchorage Spokane Regina Pasco/Richland Kalispell Yakima /Kennewick Pullman Great Falls Walla Missoula Walla Lewiston Redmond/Bend Helena Butte Winnipeg Medford Idaho Falls Twin Falls Fargo Aberdeen Gillette Sioux Falls Vernal Hayden/Steamboat Springs Omaha Eagle/Vail/Beaver Creek Grand Junction Denver Moab Aspen/ Snowmass Colorado Springs Montrose/ Telluride Cedar City Las Vegas Santa Barbara Burbank Ontario Long Beach Bismarck Casper Rock Springs St. George Los Angeles Bemidji Salt Lake City Fresno/Yosemite Pacific Ocean Grand Forks Rapid City Jackson Hole Pocatello Elko Santa Rosa Reno/Tahoe San Sacramento Francisco Oakland San Jose Mammoth Lakes International Falls Minot Dickinson Billings West Yellowstone Cody Boise Sun Valley Lincoln Palm Springs Wichita Orange County San Diego Albuquerque Tulsa Phoenix/Scottsdale Oklahoma City Killeen/Ft. Hood Oahu San Antonio Kahului Houston (IAH, HOU) Hilo Kona Duluth Greensboro/High Point/Winston-Salem Raleigh/Durham New Bern Charlotte Jacksonville/Camp Lejeune Greenville/ Fayetteville/Ft. Bragg Chattanooga Spartanburg Wilmington Huntsville/ Columbia Myrtle Beach Decatur Nashville Memphis Columbus/ Starkville/ West Point Monroe Shreveport Jackson Birmingham Atlanta Augusta Minneapolis/ St. Paul Milwaukee Salt Lake City Los Angeles Hermosillo Atlantic Ocean Los Mochis Torreon Detroit Tampa Managua Liberia San José Málaga Destination served by one of Delta’s Worldwide Codeshare Partners Ft. Lauderdale/ Hollywood Miami BAHAMAS Effective November 2014. Select routes are seasonal. Some future services subject to government approval. Service may be operated by one of Delta’s codeshare partner airlines or one of Delta’s Connection Carriers. Flights are subject to change without notice. Reykjavik Montego Bay Aberdeen Glasgow Santo Domingo San Juan Antigua St. Kitts Helsinki Nizhny Novgorod Riga Edinburgh Copenhagen Billund Durham Kaliningrad Leeds/Bradford Bremen Hamburg Manchester Humberside Berlin Dublin Norwich Amsterdam Hannover Irkutsk Birmingham Shannon Warsaw (LHR) Cardiff Düsseldorf Bristol (LGW) Cologne Prague Ostrava London Brussels Frankfurt Luxembourg Nuremberg Paris (CDG) Kosice Brest Rennes Strasbourg Stuttgart Munich Vienna Bratislava Zürich Nantes Basel/Mulhouse Budapest Ljubljana Geneva Beijing Zagreb Lyon Milan Venice Trieste Clermont Bordeaux -Ferrand Turin Verona Belgrade Bologna Genoa Toulouse Nic A Coruña M M Seoul e Pisa Florence on ar Bilbao Pau Vigo s Tokyo (HND,tpNRT) Busan ell eille Rome Bari ier Tirana Naples NagoyaBarcelona Brindisi Palma de Osaka Madrid Mallorca Shanghai Fukuoka Reggio Calabria Lamezia Terme Valencia Ibiza (PVG) Lisbon Palermo Athens Catania Málaga Okinawa Malta Bermuda Orlando Freeport/Grand Bahama Hanoi Chiang Mai Panama City Quito Aalborg St. Petersburg Stockholm Linköping Gothenburg Moscow Newcastle Fortaleza Natal Belém Teresina Recife Manaus Hong Kong Goiânia Lima Cuiabá Bangkok Siem Reap Phnom Penh Manila Ho Chi Minh City Phuket Penang Kuala Lumpur Singapore Campo Grande Brasília Portland Istanbul Guam Sapporo Hakodate Aomori Akita Denpasar Bali Niigata Darwin Komatsu Tokyo - Narita (NRT) Okayama Tokyo - Haneda (HND) Nagoya Fukuoka Osaka Oita Kagoshima JAPAN Detroit New York (JFK) Sochi Palau Jakarta Minneapolis/ St. Paul Seattle/Tacoma Krasnodar Bucharest Honolulu Uberlandia Vitória SãoPaulo (CGH) Volgograd Saipan Belo Horizonte Rio de Janeiro Londrina Rio de Janeiro (SDU) São Paulo Kiev Taipei Kaohsiung Maceió Turks and Caicos Kingston Asia Pacific Bergen Oslo Sandefjord Stavanger Salvador St. Thomas St. Maarten Trondheim Alesund -Vigra Raleigh/Durham CARIBBEAN Source: Delta Company Website Punta Cana Barcelona Madrid Destination served by Delta / Delta Connection Boston Hartford/Springfield New York (JFK, LGA) Washington DC (IAD) Nassau Santiago Port-auPrince Miami Route served by Alaska Airlines/ Horizon Air Bogotá 10 Orlando Cancun Key West Freeport/Grand Bahama Grand Cayman Shannon Future Route Service Monterrey Nassau Turks and Caicos La Paz Culiacán Durango Saltillo Los Cabos Mazatlán Zacatecas San Luis Potosi Exuma Punta Cana Tampico Aguascalientes Cancún León Querétaro St. Thomas Mérida Cozumel Puerto Vallarta Poza Rica Santiago St. Maarten Campeche Guadalajara Port-au-Prince San Antigua Morelia Mexico City Ciudad Del Carmen Grand Manzanillo Cayman Veracruz Kingston Santo Juan Villahermosa Minatitlán Ixtapa/Zihuatanejo Montego St. Croix St. Kitts Domingo Belize City Bay Acapulco St. Lucia Roatán Barbados Oaxaca HuatulcoTuxtla Gutierrez San Pedro Sula Grenada Tapachula Aruba Tegucigalpa Bonaire Guatemala City San Salvador Caracas Exuma Montreal Pittsburgh Boston Washington DC New York (JFK) (IAD) Newark Atlanta Philadelphia Mexico City Ciudad Juarez Chihuahua Toronto Sochi Yerevan Prague Amsterdam Düsseldorf Brussels Frankfurt (LHR) Munich London (LGW) Stuttgart Istanbul Venice Zürich Paris Milan (CDG) Pisa Athens Rome Nice Manchester Dublin Kristiansand Columbus Indianapolis Cincinnati Nashville Memphis Atlanta San Diego Detroit (IAH) Delta Air Lines/Delta Connection/ Delta Joint Venture Route West Palm Beach Gulf of Mexico Latin America Seattle Glasgow Cincinnati Houston Charleston Ft. Myers/Naples Harlingen/ South Padre Island Copenhagen Chicago Dallas/ Fort Worth Volgograd Baku Minneapolis/ St. Paul Savannah Brunswick Valdosta Pensacola Alexandria Baton Jacksonville Tallahassee Rouge Panama City Gulfport/Biloxi Lafayette Daytona Beach New Orleans Ft. Walton Gainesville Beach Orlando Tampa/St. Petersburg Melbourne Sarasota/Bradenton MEXICO Moscow Stockholm Reykjavik Las Vegas Knoxville Asheville Columbus/Ft. Benning Montgomery Hawaii Pacific Ocean Salt Lake City Los Angeles Tri-Cities Fayetteville/ Northwest Arkansas Novosibirsk Yekaterinburg Chelyabinsk Perm Ufa Kazan Samara Almaty Nizhny Novgorod Calgary San Francisco Dothan Albany Maui H AWA I I Portland Sault Ste. Marquette Montreal Marie Bangor Ottawa Rhinelander Iron Mountain Pellston/Mackinac Island Escanaba Portland Burlington Minneapolis/ Alpena Wausau Green Bay Traverse City St. Paul Manchester Toronto Appleton/ Albany Boston Syracuse Fox Cities Midland/ Rochester Grand La Crosse Rochester Hartford/ Saginaw Rapids Ithaca Springfield Milwaukee Martha’s Vineyard Buffalo/ Elmira/ Flint Binghamton Nantucket Niagara FallsCorning Madison Kalamazoo/ Providence Lansing Newburgh Cedar Rapids/ Wilkes-Barre/ White Plains Battle Creek Iowa City Scranton Detroit Erie Cleveland New York (JFK, LGA) South Bend Chicago State Newark (ORD, MDW) Akron/Canton College Allentown Des Moines Peoria Philadelphia Moline/ Pittsburgh Ft. Wayne Bloomington Harrisburg Quad Columbus Cities Baltimore Dayton Washington, D.C. (DCA, IAD) Indianapolis Kansas City Cincinnati Charlottesville Charleston St. Louis Richmond Louisville Lexington Newport News/Williamsburg Evansville Springfield/ Norfolk/Virginia Beach Roanoke Branson Brainerd Mobile Austin Kauai Québec Halifax Little Rock Dallas/ Ft. Worth (DFW) Dallas Love Field (DAL) El Paso/ Ciudad Juárez Honolulu Vancouver Seattle/ Tacoma Moncton Thunder Bay Chisholm/ Hibbing Ft. Smith Tucson Lihue Sydney Charlottetown Williston Bozeman Juneau Sitka Ketchikan Europe Saskatoon Yerevan Atlanta Los Angeles Corporate Strategy: Expansion Since the beginning of 2014, Delta has rapidly expanded in Seattle to increase transpacific routes Increased Gates in Seattle Airport § Delta currently has 11 gates at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport § Delta plans to increase the number up to 30 § Delta has designated Seattle as a hub from which to offer an increasing number of transpacific flights Actions § At the beginning of 2014, Delta operated just 34 peak-day departures from Seattle to 15 destinations § Delta now operates about 80 peak-day departures to 25 destinations § By the end of the year, these totals will rise to 93 departures to 32 destinations § Delta recently placed a big order for A350 and A330 planes to be used on transpacific routes from Seattle Amount of Chinese Travelers to U.S. (in Thousands) Opportunities § On November 10, United States and China signed a treaty that will reciprocally increase the validity of short-term business, tourist, and student visas § In the long run, this would lead to more flights between United States and China. Delta’s expansion in Seattle would catch on this trend 3000 2000 1000 0 2013 2014E 2015E 2016E Source: Company Filings,Yahoo Finance, Wall Street Journal, United States Department of State Website, Trade.gov 11 Corporate Strategy: Financial Objectives Since 2009, Delta has been efficient with meeting its financial objectives Debt Reduction Remains A Priority § Delta’s debt is currently at lowest level in 20 years. Delta targets $5 billion as its adjusted net debt by the end of 2016 § At 5 billion target, interest expense will be nearly $1 billion lower than 2009 § Balance Sheet would reach investment grade quality Adjusted Net Debt ($ Billions) $20 $15 § § § § § Domestic refleeting Maintenance Headcount/ productivity Supply chain Technology 12 12.9 11.7 9.4 7.4 $5 5 $0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 3Q 2016E 2014 Non-Fuel Unit Cost Growth (%) 5 4 <2% Growth 3 2 <1.0% 1 0 2012 Source: Delta Company Website, Bloomberg 15 $10 Sustaining Cost Performance § Delta leverages the strengths across the business to sustain the cost performance going forward 17 2013 2014E Long Term Corporate Strategy:Vertical Integration In 2012, Delta purchased an oil refinery outside of Philadelphia, a novel approach to reduce its fuel costs Information § Delta bought the Trainer refinery for $150 million from Phillips 66 § Spent about $100 million to convert the refinery’s existing infrastructure to maximize jet fuel production § The site offers easy access to New York airports and Delta hubs LaGuardia and JFK Partnership Jet Fuel Cost ($/gal) § Long term agreements together with BP plc and Phillips 66 § “They can take all the output of the plant that we don’t need, which will be the gasoline products, the diesel products, and some of the chemical products, and swap those in return for jet fuel in other parts of the country” - Ed Bastian, Delta president and board member Source: Company Website, Factset 13 Q3 '14 Q2 '14 Q1 '14 Q4 '13 Delta $2.90 $2.93 $3.03 $3.05 American $2.98 $3.03 $3.10 $3.06 United $3.01 $3.08 $3.18 $3.09 Labor Peace Unlike its peers, Delta does not face contract issues with its employees Delta American Airlines § Delta Airlines is largely unrepresented by unions § AFA and IAM, the major players, have failed multiple times to organize Delta’s employees § So far, Delta is the only airline to have a unified flight attendants and pilot contract § Last year, American Airlines and US Airways formed a merger § One of American’s primary concern for 2015 is joining employees under single contracts § Last month, the union representing AAL flight attendants rejected the deal § The dispute now goes to binding arbitration United Airlines Southwest Airlines § Similar to American Airlines, the merger between United and Continental in 2010 also raised issues § The company has still yet to reach joint contracts with all its employees § After more than two years of negotiations on a new labor agreement, the union that represents 8,000 Southwest pilots filed for mediation § Other unions also filed for mediation § Transport Workers Union: ramp and cargo workers § International Association of Machinist Union: Customerservice and reservation agents Source: Wallstreet Journal, Nasdaq, Dallasnews 14 Delta Trading Overview 60% 50% 40% June 9,2014 World Bank’s dismal revision to global growth and Luftansa lowering earning forecast December 1,2014 Delta cuts flights to Africa DAL XAL 30% 20% S&P 500 10% November 27,2014 OPEC announces no cut in oil production 0% -10% -20% -30% August 6,2014 Delta reported impressive Q2 results -40% Source: Bloomberg, Factset,Yahoo Finance 15 October 13,2014 Delta falls after lowering Q3 Targets Complaint from American Airlines to regulators October 16,2014 Delta’s profit tops estimates on domestic Crude Oil Valuation 16 Trading Comparables Share Enterprise Price Value Company Name EPS EBITDA 2014E 2015E 2014E EV/EBITDA 2015E P/E 2014E 2015E 2014E 2015E American Airlines Group $ 48.24 $ 43,155.8 $ 5.70 $ 7.57 $ 7,640 $ 8,079 6.0 x 5.7 x 8.4 x 6.3 x United Continental $ 59.29 $ 28,430.2 $ 4.99 $ 6.99 $ 4,307 $ 5,474 7.3 x 5.5 x 11.9 x 8.5 x Southwest Airlines $ 22.47 $ 27,034.4 $ 1.95 $ 2.60 $ 3,261 $ 3,969 8.9 x 7.1 x 20.8 x 15.6 x Alaska Air Group $ 56.76 $ 7,001.4 $ 4.08 $ 4.61 $ 1,121 $ 1,343 6.2 x 5.6 x 13.9 x 12.3 x Jetblue Airways $ 14.82 $ 6,435.7 $ 0.68 $ 1.12 $ 848 $ 1,136 8.0 x 5.9 x 22.0 x 13.3 x Maximum $ 59.29 $ 43,155.8 $ 5.70 $ 7.57 $ 7,640 $ 8,079 8.9 x 7.1 x 22.0 x 15.6 x 75th Percentile $ 56.76 $ 28,430.2 $ 4.99 $ 6.99 $ 4,307 $ 5,474 8.0 x 5.9 x 20.8 x 13.3 x Mean $ 40.32 $ 22,411.5 $ 3.48 $ 4.58 $ 3,435 $ 4,000 7.3 x 6.0 x 15.4 x 11.2 x Median $ 48.24 $ 27,034.4 $ 4.08 $ 4.61 $ 3,261 $ 3,969 7.3 x 5.7 x 13.9 x 12.3 x 25th Percentile $ 22.47 $ 7,001.4 $ 1.95 $ 2.60 $ 1,121 $ 1,343 6.2 x 5.6 x 11.9 x 8.5 x Minimum $ 14.82 $ 6,435.7 $ 0.68 $ 1.12 $ 848 $ 1,136 6.0 x 5.5 x 8.4 x 6.3 x Financial Information DAL Valuation EBITDA $6,941 Net Debt $5,699 EV/EBITDA P/E Multiple Mid 7.3 x 13.9 x Prefered stock $0 High 8.9 x 22.0 x Minority Interest $0 Low 6.0 x 8.4 x Mid $52.82 $45.18 High $65.86 $71.50 Low $42.22 $27.30 EPS $3.25 Diluted Shares Outstanding 851.4 Source: Factset Implied Price/Share Discounted Cash Flow Analysis Free Cash Flow Calculation 2014P 2015P Multiple Method 2016E EBITDA 2016P $4,892.97 $7,351.77 35% 1713 2573 1,742.13 1,864.08 1,975.93 Less: Increase in Working Capital: Less: Capital Expenditures PV of Terminal Value $36,820.52 Sum of PV FCF $13,521.98 EV $50,342.50 346.18 (534.81) Debt ($7,843.00) $180 $180 $180 Cash $4,123.00 Equity Value Present Value of Free Cash Flow $49,544.70 (236.89) Unlevered Free Cash Flow Terminal Value 2568 Plus: Depreciation & Amortization $4,979 $6,116 $7,099 $4,510.08 $5,018.17 $5,276.15 Terminal Multiple 4.5x 5.0x 5.3x 6.0x 7.0x Cost W*C 13.10% 9.80% Debt Cost (A-­‐T) 25.10% 2.00% 0.50% 0 0 0 $58.10 $63.95 $72.55 10% $49.55 $53.74 $56.41 $62.10 $70.47 10.4% $48.97 $53.11 $55.76 $61.38 $69.66 11% $48.11 $52.18 $54.78 $60.32 $68.47 Preferred Equity 12% $46.71 $50.68 $53.21 $58.60 $66.53 WACC 18 Weight 74.90% $55.35 Source: Factset, Bloomberg $55.76 Equity $51.05 $836.20 Share Price 9% $46,622.50 FDSO WACC $5.32 $7,336.99 Less:Taxes $9,312.91 Purchase Multiple EBIT: 10.40% Valuation Range (Football Field) Target Current $46.7 DCF Analysis $72.6 $33.0 Analyst Estimates $73.0 $27.3 P/E - Trading $71.5 $42.2 EV/EBITDA - Trading 52-Week Range $47.63 $26.4 20 $65.9 30 40 50 $47.28 19 60 $54.2 70 80 Recommendation 20 Merits & Risks Delta maintains a global presence with an expansion for growth. However, Delta is also exposed to a variety of risks stemming from factors beyond its control Merits Risks § Increasing global airline industry § Expansion in Seattle airport in response to the increasing flights between United States and China § Decrease in oil prices should provide a bump for Delta’s revenue in Q4 2014 § Delta’s refinery provides a good hedging alternative that no other airline enjoys § Strong emphasis on debt reduction and increasing shareholder returns § Lower fuel costs may prompt Delta to boost capacity unwisely and unprofitably § Oil prices might bounce back, resulting the public to panic and oversell Delta’s shares § Potential global epidemic of Ebola § Intensified price competition with Alaska Airlines when expanding in Seattle § 43.47% ROI compared to industry’s 12.92% § 89.67% debt-to-equity ratio in contrast to industry’s 283.78% § $2 billion share repurchase program to provide flexibility to return additional cash to shareholders Source: Fidelity Investments Conclusion Strong Positioning Vertical Integration Efficient Management Currently the 3rd largest airline, Delta has strong presence in the airline industry Increasing trend of global revenue within industry Controls approximately 16% of domestic market share Expansion of transpacific routes in Seattle and increasing flight trend between U.S. and China § Labor peace compared to its peers § § § § Purchased an refinery to help lower jet fuel costs The asset has helped Delta achieve lower fuel prices than its peers Provides an alternative to jet fuel future contracts The agreement with BP plc and Phillips66 to outsource extra capacity in exchange for jet fuel in other parts of country § Unique only to Delta § § § § § § § § § Emphasis on debt reduction and increasing shareholder returns Successfully reduced net debt by $7.6 Billion within 4 years Initiate share repurchase program to increase investor returns Maintains cost performance through fleet restructuring Impressive key statistics compared to industry Source: Capital IQ, Bloomberg, Factset, Delta Investor Relations, Fidelity Investments 22 Disclaimer: These materials has been prepared by the Goizueta Investment Management Group. This document is for information and illustrative purposes only and does not purport to show actual results. It is not, and should not be regarded as investment advice or as a recommendation regarding any particular security or course of action. Opinions expressed herein are current opinions as of the date appearing in this material only and are subject to change without notice. Reasonable people may disagree about the opinions expressed herein. In the event any of the assumptions used herein do not prove to be true, results are likely to vary substantially. All investments entail risks. There is no guarantee that investment strategies will achieve the desired results under all market conditions and each investor should evaluate its ability to invest for a long term especially during periods of a market downturn. No representation is being made that any account, product, or strategy will or is likely to achieve profits, losses, or results similar to those discussed, if any. No part of this document may be reproduced in any manner, in whole or in part, without the prior written permission of the Goizueta Investment Management Group, other than to your employees. This information is provided with the understanding that with respect to the material provided herein, that you will make your own independent decision with respect to any course of action in connection herewith and as to whether such course of action is appropriate or proper based on your own judgment, and that you are capable of understanding and assessing the merits of a course of action. The Goizueta Investment Management Group does not purport to and does not, in any fashion, provide broker/dealer, consulting or any related services. You may not rely on the statements contained herein. The Goizueta Investment Management Group shall not have any liability for any damages of any kind whatsoever relating to this material. You should consult your advisors with respect to these areas. By accepting this material, you acknowledge, understand and accept the foregoing. © 2014 Goizueta Investment Management Group. All Rights Reserved. Appendix Discounted Cash Flow Analysis Assumptions Historical 2011 2012 Projec9ons 2013 2014P 2015P 2016P Revenue Growth %: 10.8% 4.2% 2.6% 6.8% 7.0% 6.0% COGS % Revenue: 84.6% 83.3% 81.9% 79.3% 74.3% 75.3% SG&A % Revenue: 5.5% 4.3% 4.3% 4.3% 4.3% 4.3% DepreciaQon & AmorQzaQon % Revenue: 4.3% 4.3% 4.4% 4.3% 4.3% 4.3% CapEx % Revenue: 3.6% 5.4% 6.8% 5.8% 6.7% 6.7% ST Receivables % Revenue: 4.4% 4.6% 4.3% 4.4% 4.4% 4.4% Inventories % Revenue: 1.0% 2.8% 2.8% 2.8% 2.8% 2.8% Other Current Assets: 5.3% 4.9% 8.1% 6.1% 6.1% 6.1% 5.4% 7.5% 7.5% 7.5% 7.5% 7.5% 28.8% 28.7% 31.2% 29.6% 29.6% 29.6% ASSETS LIABILITIES Accounts Payable % COGS: Other Current LiabiliQes % COGS: 25 Discounted Cash Flow Analysis EBIT Historical 2011 Projec9ons 2012 2013 2014P 2015P 2016P Revenue: $35,176 $36,670 $37,638 $40,195 $43,009 Cost of Goods Sold: $29,744 $30,555 $30,835 $31,880 $31,961 $34,335 $5,432 $6,115 $6,803 $8,315 $11,048 $11,255 Gross Profit: $45,589 OperaQng Expenses: Selling, General & AdministraQve: EBITDA: DepreciaQon & AmorQzaQon: EBIT: $1,946 $1,590 $1,603 $1,680 $1,832 $1,942 $3,486 $4,525 $5,200 $6,635 $9,216 $9,313 $1,523 $1,565 $1,658 $1,742 $1,864 $1,976 $1,963 $2,960 $3,542 $4,893 $7,352 $7,337 Capex Historical 2011 Capital Expenditures Projec9ons 2012 ($1,254) 2013 ($1,968) 2014P ($2,568) 2015P ($2,331) 2016P ($2,882) ($3,054) Change in NWC Historical 2011 Projec9ons 2012 2013 2014P 2015P 2016P Assets Short-­‐Term Receivables Inventories Other Current Assets Current Assets 1563 1693 1609 $1,786.69 $1,911.76 $2,026.47 367 1023 1063 $1,125.46 $1,204.25 $1,276.50 1879 1807 3054 $2,463.10 $2,635.52 $2,793.65 3809 4523 5726 5375 5752 6097 1600 2293 2300 $2,391.00 $2,397.09 $2,575.10 8563 8765 9632 $9,427.15 $9,451.15 $10,153.03 10163 11058 11932 11818 11848 12728 ($6,354) ($6,535) ($6,206) ($6,443) ($6,097) ($6,632) ($181) $329 ($237) $346 ($535) Liabili9es Accounts Payable Other Current LiabiliQes Current LiabiliQes Net Working Capital Change in NWC 26 Key Statistics Compared to its peers, Delta has attractive key statistics Key Statistic Comparison Delta American United P/E (ttm) 4.09 99.55 19.59 Profit Margin (ttm) 24.75% 0.71% 3.20% ROE (ttm) 158.45% N/A 44.49% 87.51 343.79 312.99 Debt to Equity (mrq) Souce:Yahoo Finance