http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Exhibit A
Product
1 of 27
Ingredient
CIR Conclusion
Healing Garden
White Teatheraphy
Body Lotion,
Sanctuary
Acacia decurrens
extract
"The Panel also concluded
that the available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of the following
ingredients in cosmetic
products: ... Acacia
Decurrens Extract...," CIR at
2.
Healing Garden
White Teatheraphy
Body Soak,
Sanctuary
Acacia decurrens
extract
See id.
Healing Garden
White Teatheraphy
Whipped Souffle
Body Creme,
Sanctuary
Acacia decurrens
extract
See id.
King of Shaves
AlphaGel Shaving
Gel, Supercooled
Menthol
Acacia senegal
extract
"The Panel also concluded
that the available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of the following
ingredients in cosmetic
products: ... Acacia Senegal
Extract," CIR at 2.
Kiss My Face
Shower Gel &
Foaming Bath, Silky
Soft Skin Smoother
Acacia senegal
extract
See id.
Te Tao Body Wash
Acacia senegal
extract
See id.
Revlon Love Pat
Moisturizing Powder, aldioxa
Creamy Ivory
"The safety of Aldioxa has
not been documented and
substantiated. The CIR
Expert Panel cannot conclude
that this ingredient is safe for
use in cosmetic products until
the appropriate safety data
have been obtained and
evaluated," CIR at 10.
Revlon Love Pat
Moisturizing Powder, aldioxa
Rachel
See id.
Revlon Love Pat
Moisturizing Powder, aldioxa
Soft Beige
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
2 of 27
Revlon Love Pat
Moisturizing Powder, aldioxa
Suntan
See id.
Revlon Love Pat
Moisturizing Powder, aldioxa
Translucent Natural
See id.
Zeasorb Super
Absorbent Powder
See id.
aldioxa
Back to Basics basic
texture, get curly curl arachidonic acid
enhacing gel
"The safety of this ingredient
has not been documented and
substantiated for cosmetic
product use. The CIR Expert
Panel cannot conclude
whether Arachidonic Acid is
safe for use in cosmetic
products until such time that
the appropriate safety data
have been obtained and
evaluated," CIR at 21.
Back to Basics basic
texture, get curly, curl arachidonic acid
enhancing shampoo
See id.
DDF Collagen Dry
Skin Mask
arachidonic acid
See id.
Elizabeth Arden Let
There Be Light
Radiant Skin Lotion,
SPF 15
arachidonic acid
See id.
Infusium 23 Extra
Firm Hold Fortifying
Mousse
arachidonic acid
See id.
Peter Thomas Roth
Ceramide Eye
Complex
arachidonic acid
See id.
philosophy amazing
grace perfumed body
gloss
arachidonic acid
See id.
philosophy be
somebody, extra-rich
body cream
arachidonic acid
See id.
philosophy hope in a
jar therapeutic
moisturizer for dry
sensitive skin
arachidonic acid
See id.
philosophy hope in a
jar, therapeutic
moisturizer for dry
sensitive skin
arachidonic acid
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
3 of 27
PHYTOSPECIFIC
Beauty Styling
Creme
arachidonic acid
See id.
PHYTOSPECIFIC
Hydra-Repairing
Shampoo
arachidonic acid
See id.
ABBA Gelsential
Maximum Support
Styling Gel
azulene
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of Azulene
for use in cosmetic products,"
CIR at 27.
Alba Botanica Sea
Kelp Toner
azulene
See id.
Avalon Natural
Products,
Rosemary/Mint Soap
Bar
azulene
See id.
Jason Natural
Cosmetics Tea Tree
Deodorant Stick
azulene
See id.
Jason Natural
Cosmetics Witch
Vera, 84% Aloe Gel
azulene
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Fresh
Botanicals Hairspray
azulene
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics,
Swimmer'S/Sport
Shampoo
azulene
See id.
Nature's Gate
Antiseptic Liquid
Soap
azulene
See id.
Nature's Gate Cool
Mint Gel Natural
Toothpaste
azulene
See id.
Nature's Gate
Roll-On Deodorant,
Spring Fresh Scent
azulene
See id.
Nature's Gate
Wintergreen Gel
Natural Toothpaste
azulene
See id.
Peter Thomas Roth
Gentle Cleansing
Lotion
azulene
See id.
Peter Thomas Roth
Oil-Free Moisturizer
azulene
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
4 of 27
Surgi-Wax Sticks
Hair Remover With
Soothing Azulene
Oil, For Face and
Brows
azulene
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics,
Deodorant (Lav &
Organic-
azulene, Calendula
officinalis
See id.
ABBA Creme-Moist
Luxury Nourishing
Shampoo
Calendula officinalis
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Calendula Officinalis Extract
and Calendula Officinalis for
use in cosmetic products,"
CIR at 46.
AHAVA Time Line
Age Defying
Continual Eye Treat
Calendula officinalis
See id.
AHAVA Time Line
Calendula officinalis
Age Defying Essence
See id.
Andrea EyeQ's Daily
Intensive Eye Creme
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Andrea FaceQ's Face
Make-Up Remover
Pads
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aussie Knot
Forgotten Detangler
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aussie Moist
Conditioner for
Dry/Damaged Hair
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aussie Shampoo,
Moist for
Dry/Damaged Hair
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Avalon Natural
Products, Lavender
Deoderant
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Avalon Natural
Products, Lavender
Hand & Body Lotion
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Avalon Natural
Products, Lemon
Verbena Conditioner
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Avalon Natural
Products, Lemon
Verbena Deodorant
Calendula officinalis
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
5 of 27
Avalon Natural
Products, Lemon
Verbena Hand &
Body Lotion
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Avalon Natural
Products, Lemon
Verbena Shampoo
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aveda Brilliant
Conditioner
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aveda Brilliant,
Universal Styling
Creme
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aveda Color
Enhancing
Conditioner,
Camomile
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Aveda Shampoo,
Camomile for
Calendula officinalis
Highlights & Blondes
See id.
Back to Basics
Sunflower, Moisture
Calendula officinalis
Infusing Shampoo for
all hair types
See id.
DDF Sensitive Skin
Cleansing Gel
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Delux Beauty
Tintstik For the Lips,
Betty
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Delux Beauty
Tintstik For the Lips,
Bubbles SPF15
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Delux Beauty
Tintstik For the Lips,
Dot SPF15
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Delux Beauty
Tintstik For the Lips,
Pinky
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Delux Beauty
Tintstik Tintstik For
the Lips, Darling
SPF15
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Delux Beauty
Tintstik Tintstik For
the Lips, Flossy
SPF15
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Elizabeth Arden
Green Tea Honey
Drops Body Cream
Calendula officinalis
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
6 of 27
Fresh Sugarbath
Body Lotion, Lemon
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Fresh Sugarbath
Body Lotion, Lily
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Fresh Sugarbath
Body Lotion, Lychee
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Fresh Sugarbath
Body Polish, Brown
Sugar
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Herbal Essences
Shampoo, Extra
Body for Fine, Limp
Hair
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Jack Black Face
Buff, Energizing
Scrub
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Jack Black Post
Shave Cooling Gel
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Jason Natural
Cosmetics Satin
Soap, Apricot
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Citrus 6
In 1 Scrubble
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Healthy
Mouth Mouthwash
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, K Spray
Plus For Legs
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Satin
Soap Aloe Vera
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Satin
Soap Chamomile
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics,
Skin-Amins Vitamin
C
Calendula officinalis
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics,
Skin-Amins Vitamin
Complex
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Lierac Relaxing
Anti-Stress Oil
Calendula officinalis
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
modern organic
products conditioner
for fine hair,
lemongrass
7 of 27
Calendula officinalis
See id.
modern organic
products lemon-grass
Calendula officinalis
shampoo for fine hair,
Lemongrass
See id.
Mustela Special
Maternity Formula,
Calendula officinalis
Specific Support Bust
See id.
Nexxus Pep'R'Mint
Herbal Energizing
Shampoo
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Nexxus Retexxtur
Curl Rejuvenating
Treatment
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Nivea for Men After
Shave Balm,
Sensitive Skin,
Unscented
Calendula officinalis
See id.
PCA Skin pHaze 18
Clearskin
Calendula officinalis
See id.
PHYTO Daily
hydrating cream, Dry Calendula officinalis
Hair
See id.
PHYTO Phyto 9
Daily Nourishing
Cream, With 9 Plant
Extracts
Calendula officinalis
See id.
PHYTO Phytomist
Instant Hydrator with
Calendula officinalis
White Lotus Flowers,
Dry Hair
See id.
PHYTOSPECIFIC
Intense Nutrition
Shampoo
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Sovage Transdermal
Lip Plumper
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Sundari Rose and
Lavender Hydrating
Mask
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Te Tao Toning Gel,
Sargasso Seaweed
and Dang Gui
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Visage Naturel Skin
Cleansing Serum
Calendula officinalis
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
8 of 27
Weleda Calendula
Baby Cream
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Calendula
Baby Lotion
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Children's
Tooth Gel
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Foot Balm
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Iris Moisture
Cream, Natural
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Iris Night
Cream
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Skin Food
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Weleda Wild Rose
Body Lotion
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Nexxus Retexxtur
Curl Vitalizing
Shampoo
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
Calendula officinalis, data are insufficient to
cocamidopropylamine support the safety of
oxide
Cocamidopropylamine Oxide
for use in cosmetic products,"
CIR at 63.
Barielle Therapy For
Hands, Ultra Soft
Hand Creme SPF 15
Calendula officinalis,
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of Yarrow
(Achillea Millefolium)
Extract for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 275.
CRABTREE &
EVELYN, LTD.
Gardeners Hand
Therapy
Calendula officinalis,
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Nioxin Bionutrient
Protectives For
Calendula officinalis,
Chemically Enhanced Yarrow (Achillea
Hair, Moisture &
Millefolium) Extract
Strength
See id.
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Hypericum Perforatum
Extract and Hypericum
Perforatum Oil for use in
cosmetic products," CIR at
122.
Phiten Liquid
Titanium, Body
Lotion
Calendula officinalis,
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract,
Hypericum
perforatum extract
Aveda Shampoo,
Rosemary Mint
"The CIR Expert Panel
cocamidopropylamine concludes that the availabe
oxide
data are insufficient to
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
support the safety of
Cocamidopropylamine Oxide
for use in cosmetic products,"
CIR at 63.
Aveda Shampoo, Sap cocamidopropylamine
See id.
Moss
oxide
9 of 27
BATHerapy
BATHerapy Liquid,
Lavender
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
BATHerapy
BATHerapy Liquid,
Original
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Hand Clens Instant
Sanitizing Foam,
Pump
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
KMS Curl Up
Shampoo
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Nature's Gate
Organics Shower &
Bath Gel, Chaomile
& Lemon Verbena
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Nature's Gate
Organics Ulta
Moisturizing Shower
and Bath Gel,
Lemongrass and
Clary Sage
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Neutrogena T/Sal
Shampoo, Maximum
Strength
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Phisoderm Deep
Cleaning Cleanser,
Normal to Dry Skin
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Phisoderm Deep
Cleaning Cleanser,
Normal to Oily Skin
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Phisoderm Gentle
Baby Skin Cleanser
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
PHYTO Phytobrush
Anti-Frizz Shampoo
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
TIGI Bed Head,
Dumb Blonde
Shampoo
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
Umberto Giannini
Big & Beautiful
Amazing Volume
Mousse Mini
cocamidopropylamine
See id.
oxide
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
10 of 27
Fresh Rice Face
Cream
Corylus avellana
(hazel) seed oil
"The CIR Panel concludes
that the available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of ... Hazel (Corylus
Avellana) seed oil ... in
cosmetic products," CIR at
108.
Fresh Sugar Face
Polish
Corylus avellana
(hazel) seed oil
See id.
Banana Boat Baby
Magic Sunblock
Lotion, SPF 50
dibutyl adipate
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of Dibutyl
Adipate for use in
cosmetics," CIR at 71.
Neutrogena Healthy
Defense Oil-Free
Sunblock Spray, SPF
30
dibutyl adipate
See id.
Neutrogena Healthy
Defense Oil-Free
Sunblock Stick, SPF
30
dibutyl adipate
See id.
Revlon ColorStay
Overtime Lash Tint,
Black
dibutyl adipate
See id.
Revlon ColorStay
Overtime Lash Tint,
Blackened Brown
dibutyl adipate
See id.
Revlon ColorStay
Overtime Lash Tint,
Blackest Black
dibutyl adipate
See id.
Agree Conditioner,
Intensive
Moisturizing
Swimmers Solution
dimethyl stearamine
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Dimethyl Stearamine and its
hydrochloride salt as used in
cosmetics," CIR at 79.
Consort Hair Spray
for Men, Extra Hold,
Unscented, Aerosol
dimethyl stearamine
See id.
Consort Hairspray for
Men, Regular Hold,
dimethyl stearamine
Aerosol
See id.
Sebastian Shaper
Plus Hair Spray,
Styling Mist for
dimethyl stearamine
Super Hold and Extra
Control
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Neoteric
Beautiful-Nail Herbal drometrizole
Skin Doctor
"The safety of this ingredient
has not been documented and
substantiated for cosmetic
product use. The CIR Expert
Panel cannot conclude that
Drometrizole is safe for use
in cosmetic products until
such time that the appropriate
safety data have been
obtained and evaluated," CIR
at 86.
Back to Basics Basic
Style, Curl Catalyst
glucose glutamate
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of Glucose
Glutamate for use in
cosmetic products," CIR at
93.
Back to Basics Basic
Style, Sleek Creme
glucose glutamate
Back to Basics Basic
Style, Up Hold
glucose glutamate
Back to Basics final
fi x
Back to Basics Basic
Style, Liquid Lift
Alpha Hydrox AHA
Enhanced Creme,
Anti-Wrinkle
Exfoliant
11 of 27
glucose glutamate,
lecithin
"On the basis of the animal
and clinical data presented in
this report, the Expert Panel
concluded that Lecithin and
Hydrogenated Lecithin are
safe as used in rinse-off
products, safe for use in
leave-on products at
concentrations (less than or
equal to) 15%, and that the
data are insufficient to
determine the safety for use
in cosmetic products where
Lecithin or Hydrogenated
Lecithin are likely to be
inhaled. Lecithin and
Hydrogenated Lecithin
should not be used in
cosmetic products in which
N-nitroso compounds may be
formed," CIR at 136.
glucose glutamate,
sodium benzoate,
lecithin
"The available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of these ingredients in
cosmetic products in which a
primary route of exposure is
inhalation," CIR at 32.
glyceryl dilaurate
"The Expert Panel concludes
that the availabe data are
insufficient to support the
safety of Glyceryl Dilaurate
... for use in cosmetic
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
products," CIR at 96.
12 of 27
Alpha Hydrox
Moisturizing Daily
Lotion, SPF 15
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Coppertone
Sunscreen Lotion,
SPF 4
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Curel Smooth Legs,
Shave Minimizing
Moisturizer
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Dove Face Care
Essential Nutrients,
Day Cream SPF 15
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Dove Face Care
Essential Nutrients,
Day Lotion SPF 15
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Essentiel Elements
Body Lotion, Citrus
Dream
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Essentiel Elements
Body Lotion,
Relaxing, Joie de
Lavender
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Essentiel Elements
Body Lotion,
Uplifting, Fleur
d'amour
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Ash Relief
Moisturizer
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Extra
Moisturizing Body
Wash with Jergens
Lotion
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Extra
Moisturizing Hand
Wash, Cherry
Almond Scent
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Naturally
Smooth Shave
Minimizing
Moisturizer
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Original
Scent Lotion with
glyceryl dilaurate
Cherry Almond Scent
for Dry Skin
See id.
Jergens Skin Cooling
Moisturizer with
Cucumber Extract
See id.
glyceryl dilaurate
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Jergens Skin Firming
Moisturizer
13 of 27
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Soft
glyceryl dilaurate
Shimmer Moisturizer
See id.
Jergens Soothing
Aloe Lotion for Very
Dry Skin
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Jergens Ultra Healing
Extra Dry Skin
glyceryl dilaurate
Moisturizer
See id.
Neoteric Oxygenated
Therapeutic
Moisturizer Lotion,
SPF 15
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Pond's Dramatic
Results Skin
Brightening Age
Defying Moisturizer
with Alpha Hydroxy,
Retinol & Vitam
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
SkinCeuticals Daily
Sun Defense, SPF 20
glyceryl dilaurate
See id.
Glysomed Hand
Cream
glyceryl distearate
"The Expert Panel concludes
that the availabe data are
insufficient to support the
safety of Glyceryl Distearate
... for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 96.
Glysomed Hand
Cream, Unscented
glyceryl distearate
See id.
Neutrogena Pore
Refining Cream, A
Daily Moisturizing
Treatment
glyceryl distearate
See id.
Neutrogena Visibly
Younger Hand Cream glyceryl distearate
SPF 20
See id.
RoC Retinol Actif
Pur Anti-Wrinkle
Treatment, Night
glyceryl distearate
See id.
CARGO Lip Stick
With Sharpener,
Stowe
glyceryl ricinoleate
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of Glyceryl
Ricinoleate as used in
cosmetics," CIR at 101.
CARGO Lip Stick
With Sharpener, Vail
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
14 of 27
CARGO+care
HydraTint HydraTint
for Lips, Amazon
(Sheer Tropical
Magenta-
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
CARGO+care
HydraTint HydraTint
for Lips, Danube
(Sheer Hydrangea
Pink-
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
CARGO+care
HydraTint HydraTint
for Lips, Rhine
(Sheer Burnished
Copper-
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
CARGO+care
HydraTint HydraTint
for Lips, Thames
(Sheer Muted
Blackberry-
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
Gly Derm GLY
Masque with Glyco
Citrates
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
Lola Highlighter
Pencil For the Face,
French Pink
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
Lola Lip / Cheek
Pencil Two in One,
Doll
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Eyes, #01 Dark
Brown
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Eyes, #02 Black
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Eyes, #15 Blue
Shimmer
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Eyes, #16 Lavender
Shimmer
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Eyes, #17 Light Pink
Shimmer
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #05 Rose
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #06 Pink Taupe
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #07 Auburn
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
15 of 27
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #08 Taupe
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #09 Peachy
Brown
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #11 Hot Pink
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #12 Red
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #14 Plum
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
LORAC Pencil for
Lips, #18 Nude
glyceryl ricinoleate
See id.
Eucerin Q10
glyceryl stearate
Anti-Wrinkle
citrate
Sensitive Skin Creme
The Expert Panel concludes
that the availabe data are
insufficient to support the
safety of Glyceryl Stearate
Citrate... for use in cosmetic
products, CIR at 96.
Nivea Body Sheer
Moisture Lotion,
Normal to Dry Skin
glyceryl stearate
citrate
See id.
Nivea Visage
Coenzyme Q10 Plus
Wrinkle Control
Night Creme
glyceryl stearate
citrate
See id.
Nivea Visage
Multiple Results All
In One Anti-Aging
Treatment
glyceryl stearate
citrate
See id.
Amplify by Matrix
Volumizing System
Color XL Shampoo
hydrolyzed rice
protein
"...the available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of ... Hydrolyzed Rice
Protein for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 168.
Amplify by Matrix
Volumizing System
Conditioner
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Amplify by Matrix
Volumizing System
Root Lifter
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Amplify by Matrix
Volumizing System
Shampoo
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Archipelago
Botanicals Morning
Mint Body Wash
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Archipelago
Botanicals Morning
Mint Hydrating
Lotion
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Got2B Spa Foot,
Soothing Soles,
Moisturizing &
Healing Creme
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Rusk Being
Defensive
Conditioner
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Rusk Being Fresh
Shampoo
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
Rusk Wired Internal
Restructure Styling
Cream
hydrolyzed rice
protein
See id.
hydrolyzed rice
protein, Acacia
dealbata leaf wax
"The Panel also concluded
that the available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of the following
ingredients in cosmetic
products: ... Acacia Dealbata
Leaf Wax...," CIR at 2.
Hypericum
perforatum extract
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Hypericum Perforatum
Extract and Hypericum
Perforatum Oil for use in
cosmetic products," CIR at
122.
Fresh Rice Formula
F21C Body Cream
Igia Epil-Stop &
Foam, 6-in-1 Hair
Removal System
AT956
16 of 27
Not Soap, Radio Bath
Hypericum
& Shower Gel,
perforatum extract
Liquid Freud
See id.
Not Soap, Radio Lip
Gloss, Freudian Lips
Hypericum
perforatum extract
See id.
PHYTO Phytonectar
Ultra Nourishing
Shampoo for
Ultra-Dry Hair
Hypericum
perforatum extract
See id.
PHYTO Phytoneutre
Rebalancing Cream
Shampoo
Hypericum
perforatum extract
See id.
SkinCeuticals Daily
Moisture
Hypericum
perforatum extract
See id.
PHYTOMEN
After-Shave Balm
Hypericum
perforatum extract,
Calendula officinalis
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Calendula Officinalis Extract
and Calendula Officinalis for
use in cosmetic products,"
CIR at 46.
Hypericum
Andre For Men Extra perforatum extract,
Strength Hair
Juniperus communis
Remover For the
extract, Yarrow
Body
(Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Juniperus Communis Extract
... for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 132.
Lierac Firming
Hypericum
Toning Oil of Thekoa perforatum oil
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Hypericum Perforatum
Extract and Hypericum
Perforatum Oil for use in
cosmetic products," CIR at
122.
Lierac Lait
Anti-Dessechement
Hypericum
perforatum oil
See id.
Alberto VO5 Herbal
Shampoo for Normal
Hair, Sun Kissed
Raspberry
Juniperus communis
extract
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of
Juniperus Communis Extract
... for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 132.
Philip B. Scent of
Santa Fe Shampoo,
Gentle Daily
Cleansing for All
Hair Types
Juniperus communis
extract
See id.
Lierac Face
Restructurizer
Juniperus communis
extract, Hypericum
perforatum oil,
Calendula officinalis
See id.
PEG-15 cocamine
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of PEG-2,
-3, 5, -10, -15 and -20
Cocamine for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 176.
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the data
availabe on Pentaerythrityl
Rosinate are insufficient to
support the safety of this
ingredient as used in
cosmetic products," CIR at
190.
L'Oreal Studio Line
Invisi-Gel Styling
Gel, Strong Hold
Anna Sui Mascara,
001
17 of 27
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
18 of 27
Awake Hydro Touch
Refill For the Face,
Beige 07
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Hydro Touch
Refill For the Face,
Buff 04
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Hydro Touch
Refill For the Face,
Ecru 08
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Hydro Touch
Refill For the Face,
Nude 03
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Hydro Touch
Refill For the Face,
Sand 06
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Escalate Lash
Mascara, Black
Escalation 01
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Escalate Lash
Mascara, Blue
Escalation 03
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Escalate Lash
Mascara, Brown
Escalation 02
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Escalate Lash
Mascara, Green
Escalation 04
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Escalate Lash
Mascara, Plum
Escalation 05
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Graphics Eye Duo
Eye Color, E-1
(Rose/Pale Pink-
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Graphics Eye Duo
Eye Color, E-2
(Bronze/Beige-
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Graphics Eye Duo
Eye Color, E-3
(Blue/Pale Silver-
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
19 of 27
Awake Stardom
Graphics Eye Duo
Eye Color, E-4
(Turquoise/Pink-
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
Graphics Eye Duo
Eye Color, E-5
(Lilac/Gold-
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom Lip
Palette Lipcolor
Assortment with
Lipstick Brush
pentaerythrityl
rosinate
See id.
Awake Stardom
pentaerythrityl
Optic Force Mascara,
rosinate
Black Hole
See id.
Awake Stardom
pentaerythrityl
Optic Force Mascara,
rosinate
Jupiter Blue
See id.
Awake Stardom
pentaerythrityl
Optic Force Mascara,
rosinate
Venus Brown
See id.
PHYTO
Phytopanama for all
Hair Types
PPG-9
diethylmonium
chloride
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of PPG-9,
-25, -40 Diethylmonium
Chloride for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 210.
Elizabeth Arden
Ceramide, Purifying
Cream Cleanser
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
sodium
support the safety of ...
lauriminodipropionate Sodium
Lauraminodipropionate for
use in cosmetic products,"
CIR at 236.
Elizabeth Arden
Millenium Hydrating
Cleanser
sodium
See id.
lauriminodipropionate
Andrea EyeQ's
Yarrow (Achillea
Anti-Stress Eye Mask Millefolium) Extract
"The CIR Expert Panel
concludes that the availabe
data are insufficient to
support the safety of Yarrow
(Achillea Millefolium)
Extract for use in cosmetic
products," CIR at 275.
Artec Textureline
Yarrow (Achillea
Shampoo, Smoothing Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Biosilk Enviro 54
Firm Sunglitz
See id.
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
20 of 27
Burt's Bees Doctor
Burt's Herbal
Blemish Stick with
Tea Tree Oil
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Burt's Bees Healthy
Treatment Parsley
Blemish Stick with
Willowbark
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
CRABTREE &
EVELYN, LTD.
Gardeners 60 Second
Fix, Hand Recovery
Kit
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
CRABTREE &
EVELYN, LTD.
Lavender Hand
Therapy
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
DDF Nutrient K Plus
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Heavy Duty Motor
Wash, Shower Gel
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Jason Natural
Cosmetics Vitamin K
Yarrow (Achillea
Creme Plus for Skin,
Millefolium) Extract
Measured Dosage
Pump
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Natural
Napca Hand & Body
Lotion
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
JASON Natural
Cosmetics, Vitamin
K Creme Plus
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
JOEY New York
Line Up
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
JOEY New York
Pure Pores Blackhead Yarrow (Achillea
Remover and Pore
Millefolium) Extract
Minimizer Gel
See id.
Kiss My Face All
Night Creme
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Kiss My Face Citrus
Cleanser
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Kiss My Face
Moisturizer, Olive &
Aloe
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Color, After
Millefolium) Extract
Midnight Blue
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
21 of 27
Manic Panic Gel Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Atomic
Millefolium) Extract
Turquoise
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Cotton Candy Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Deadly
Millefolium) Extract
Nightshade
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Flaming
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Fuschia Shock Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Hot Hot Pink Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Infra Red
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Purple Haze
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Shocking Blue Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Ultra Violet
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic Gel Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color, Vampire Red
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Atomic Millefolium) Extract
Turqouise
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Bad
Millefolium) Extract
Boy Blue
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Cotton Millefolium) Extract
Candy Pink
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Deadly Millefolium) Extract
Nightshade
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream,
Millefolium) Extract
Flaming
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
Color Cream, Hot
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Hot Pink
22 of 27
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Infra
Millefolium) Extract
Red
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Lagoon Millefolium) Extract
Blue
See id.
Manic Panic
Yarrow (Achillea
Semi-Permanent Hair
Millefolium) Extract
Color Cream, Lilac
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Mystic Millefolium) Extract
Heather
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, New
Millefolium) Extract
Rose
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream,
Millefolium) Extract
Pillarbox Red
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Pretty Millefolium) Extract
Flamingo
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Purple Millefolium) Extract
Haze
See id.
Manic Panic
Yarrow (Achillea
Semi-Permanent Hair
Millefolium) Extract
Color Cream, Raven
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream,
Millefolium) Extract
Shocking Blue
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Ultra
Millefolium) Extract
Violet
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream,
Millefolium) Extract
Vampire Red
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
23 of 27
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Virgin Millefolium) Extract
Snow
See id.
Manic Panic
Semi-Permanent Hair Yarrow (Achillea
Color Cream, Wild
Millefolium) Extract
Fire
See id.
modern organic
products basil mint
shampoo for normal
to oily hair, Basil
Mint
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
modern organic
products form
foaming gel, heavy
hold
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Nioxin Bionutrient
Actives Cleanser, for
Normal Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Nioxin Bionutrient
Protectives For
Yarrow (Achillea
Chemically Enhanced
Millefolium) Extract
Hair, Structure &
Strength
See id.
Philip B. White
Truffle Moisturizing
Shampoo
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
PHYTO Phytocurl,
Curl Defining Spray
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
PHYTO
Yarrow (Achillea
PhytoMousse Volume
Millefolium) Extract
Foam Shampoo
See id.
PHYTO
Phytovolume with
Yarrow Extract, Fine
and Limp Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Sexy Hair Concepts
Big Sexy Extra Big
Voume Shampoo
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Sexy Hair Concepts
Big Sexy Hair Blow
Dry Volumizing Gel
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
SkinCeuticals
cleansing cream
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
St. Ives Hair Repair
Hot Oil Moisturizing
Treatment for Dry
Damaged Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
TIGI Bed Head,
Chocolate Head
24 of 27
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Wella Lifetex
Yarrow (Achillea
Wellness Flash Flood Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Wella Lifetex
Wellness, Level
Headed
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Wella Lifetex
Yarrow (Achillea
Wellness, Look Alive Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Wella Lifetex
Wellness, Wake-up
Call
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract
See id.
Nioxin Bionutrient
Actives Scalp
Therapy, for Normal
Hair
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract,
Calendula officinalis
See id.
Andre For Men
Instant Wax Hair
Remover Strips For
the Body
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract,
Hypericum
perforatum extract,
Juniperus communis
extract
See id.
Aussie 3 Minute
Miracle, Original
Yarrow (Achillea
Millefolium) Extract,
See id.
sodium
lauriminodipropionate
SkinCeuticals
Equalizing Toner, For
benzoic acid
Combination or Oily
Skin
"The available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of these ingredients in
cosmetic products in which a
primary route of exposure is
inhalation," CIR at 32.
SkinCeuticals
Revitalizing Toner,
For Normal or Dry
Skin
benzoic acid
See id.
Sun-In Super,
Spray-In Hair
Lightener
benzoic acid
See id.
Band-Aid Fast Relief
Calamine Spray
benzyl alcohol
"The available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of these ingredients in
cosmetic products in which a
primary route of exposure is
inhalation," CIR at 32.
Band-Aid Itch Relief
Gel Spritz, External
Analgesic
benzyl alcohol
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Cortizone 10 Quick
Shot Spray
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Feminine
Deodorant Spray,
Baby Powder
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Feminine
Deodorant Spray,
Delicate Breeze
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Feminine
Deodorant Spray,
Extra Strength
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Feminine
Deodorant Spray,
Natural Aloe
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Feminine
Deodorant Spray,
Shower Fresh
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Feminine
Deodorant Spray,
White Blossom
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Pursonals
Feminine Deodorant
Spray 2-Pack Purse
Size, Extra Strength
benzyl alcohol
See id.
FDS Pursonals
Feminine Deodorant
Spray 2-Pack Purse
Size, White Blossom
benzyl alcohol
See id.
Itch-X Dual-Acting
benzyl alcohol
Anti-Itch Spray, Aloe
See id.
Old Spice Cologne
Spray, Original
benzyl alcohol
See id.
Summer's Eve
Feminine Deodorant
Spray, Intimate
Whisper
benzyl alcohol
See id.
Summer's Eve
Feminine Deodorant
Spray, Sensitive Skin
benzyl alcohol
See id.
Almay Luxury Finish
lecithin
Loose Powder, Beige
25 of 27
"On the basis of the animal
and clinical data presented in
this report, the Expert Panel
concluded that Lecithin and
Hydrogenated Lecithin are
safe as used in rinse-off
products, safe for use in
leave-on products at
concentrations (less than or
equal to) 15%, and that the
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
data are insufficient to
determine the safety for use
in cosmetic products where
Lecithin or Hydrogenated
Lecithin are likely to be
inhaled. Lecithin and
Hydrogenated Lecithin
should not be used in
cosmetic products in which
N-nitroso compounds may be
formed," CIR at 136.
26 of 27
Almay Luxury Finish
lecithin
Loose Powder, Ivory
See id.
Almay Luxury Finish
Loose Powder,
lecithin
Translucent
See id.
CARGO Loose
Powder For the Face,
01
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose
Powder For the Face,
02
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose
Powder For the Face,
03
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose
Powder For the Face,
04
lecithin
See id.
CARGO Loose
Powder For the Face,
05
lecithin
See id.
Jason Natural
Cosmetics
Conditioner,
Thin-To-Thick Hair
& Scalp Therapy
lecithin
See id.
Murad Acne
Clarifying Body
Spray
lecithin
See id.
Redken So Long
Heat Treat
lecithin
See id.
Redken Styling No.
15 Spray Starch Heat
Memory Styler
lecithin
See id.
Revlon SkinLights
Face Illuminator
Powder Brightener,
Bare Light
lecithin
See id.
8/25/10 11:16 AM
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/research/petition/exhibitA.php
Revlon SkinLights
Face Illuminator
Powder Bronzer,
Warm Light
lecithin
See id.
Aqua Net Extra
Super Hold
sodium benzoate
Hairspray, Unscented
"The available data are
insufficient to support the
safety of these ingredients in
cosmetic products in which a
primary route of exposure is
inhalation," CIR at 32.
Finesse Extra Hold
Hairspray,
Unscented, Aerosol
sodium benzoate
See id.
Osmotics Balancing
Tonic Facial Mist
sodium benzoate
See id.
Osmotics Firming
Tonic Facial Mist
sodium benzoate
See id.
Sebastian Shaper,
Massive Texture Jel
Mist
sodium benzoate
See id.
Suave Professionals
Freeze Hold
Finishing Spray
sodium benzoate
See id.
Thermasilk Flexible
Hold Hair Spray,
Aerosol
sodium benzoate
See id.
Thermasilk Heat
Activated Ultra Hold,
sodium benzoate
Non-Aerosol
Hairspray
See id.
TRESemme
Hydrology Boosting
Moisture Mousse,
Extra Hold
sodium benzoate
See id.
8-Hydroxyquinoline,
oxyquinoline sulfate
"There are insufficient data to
support the safety of
Oxyquinoline and
Oxyquinoline Sulfate in
leave-on cosmetic products,"
CIR at 169.
Ammens Medicated
Deodorant Powder,
Original Scent
Reference
Cosmetics Ingredient Review (CIR) (2003). 2003 CIR Compendium, containing abstracts, discussions, and
conclusions of CIR cosmetic ingredient safety assessments. Washington DC.
27 of 27
8/25/10 11:16 AM