State of Israel Ministry of Education Pedagogical Secretariat Language Department English Inspectorate Explanations of the Changes in the Literature Program September, 2014 1. The Ministry of Education has announced a variety of Bagrut reforms, as explained in the halima document (May 14, 2014). 2. The reforms for the English Bagrut exams relate to those students who will be in the 10th grade as of September 2014. 3. There are two external English Bagrut exams and one school-based assessment for each level. 4. The school-based assessment is for the literature program. a. The assessment for the module B literature program is the Unit Logs. b. For modules D and F, teachers have the option of choosing between either the Unit Logs or the Literature Bagrut exam, to be marked internally by the English teacher. 5. The halima document gives details regarding the external Bagrut exams: modules A, C, E and G. The purpose of this document is to explain about the two different options for the schoolbased assessment: the Unit Logs or the Literature Bagrut exam. 6. Reminder: For teachers who choose to do the Unit Logs (modules B, D, and F), the English school coordinator needs to send the form: Approval of the School’s Literature program for the Unit Logs to the English Inspector of the school (see Appendix One). CONTENTS A. General Guidelines 3 B. Personal Response 4 C. Unit Logs: Checklist and Calculation of Grade for the Unit Log - All Levels 6 D. Calculation of the Final Grade for Students Doing the Unit Logs - All Levels 8 E. Calculation of the Grade of a Unit for Each Literary Text for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam - Modules F and D 10 F. Calculation of the Grade of the Literature Program for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam - Modules F and D 10 G. Calculation of the Final Grade for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam - Modules F and D 12 H. Unit Logs - Module B 13 I. Random Sampling for the Unit Logs and the Exam – All Levels 15 Appendix One – Approval of the School’s Literature Program for the Log – All Levels 16 Appendix Two – List of Approved Texts for the Three-Point Literature Program 19 2 A. General Guidelines a. For students in the 11th and 12th grades in September 2014, starting from the summer moed 2015, in modules D and F: the alternative question will no longer appear on the exam. the HOTS of Uncovering Motives will replace the HOTS of Problem Solving. b. For students who are in the 10th grade in September 2014: Unit Logs will replace the final Log that included all the work on the literary texts. Each Unit Log contains work on one text only. When the unit has been completed and a grade given, it is no longer kept in a complete Log the way it was in the past. Each Unit Log includes all the Key Components. Teachers will cover the required number of literary texts, one Unit Log at a time. (See pages 14-15 for information about Random Sampling.) Reflection is no longer a Key Component. Instead there will be a Personal Response (Summative Reflection) at the end of each year that the program is studied. (See pages 4-5 for more information.) Students who are doing the Unit Logs need to keep the Unit Logs until the end of the school year in order to use them when they write their Personal Response. Students who are taking the Literature Bagrut exam need to save their work so that they can review for the exam. It is recommended that students doing the exam save their work The administration of the school will decide when to submit the grades of the schoolbased assessment to the Testing Dept. There is no yearly grade (tziyun shnati) or moed bet for school-based assessment (Unit Logs or exam). Module B for external and nivchane mishnei students will include one Access to Information (Reading Comprehension) and 3-4 questions on one short story (from a given list). Details will be posted on the site of the English Inspectorate. 3 B. Personal Response Personal Response replaces the Key Component of Reflection. Students will write a Personal Response at the end of every year that they study literature. Students at the four- and five-point level will answer in English; students at the three-point level will answer in Hebrew/Arabic. The criteria for evaluating Personal Response include: Criteria for Four and Five Points Possible Points Relevancy to questions Answer relates to the question 20 Relevancy to literary text Answers reflect understanding of the literary text 20 Application of HOTS Explanation of applying HOTS to their lives and their learning 20 Personal Perspective Answers clearly include a personal perspective regarding issues such as identifying with the text, character 30 Length At least 100 words 10 TOTAL 100 Criteria for Three Points Written in Hebrew/Arabic Possible Points Relevancy to questions Answer relates to the question 20 Relevancy to literary text Answers reflect understanding of the literary text 20 Application of HOTS Explanation of applying HOTS to their lives and their learning 25 Personal Perspective Answers clearly include a personal perspective regarding issues such as identifying with the text, character 35 Total 100 4 Points given by teacher Points given by teacher Below are suggested questions for all levels (Include at least one question for each of the criteria specified above): - What literary texts did you study? - What text did you enjoy the best and why? - What HOTS did you learn? - How have you applied the HOTS to your own life? - What new things did you learn? - What kind of progress did you make from the beginning of the year? - How did learning literature help improve your English? - Which character did you relate to the most and why? - Which HOTS do you think is most useful for your learning / life and why? 5 State of Israel Ministry of Education Pedagogical Secretariat Language Department English Inspectorate Checklist Student’s Name: Date: Name of Literary Text: A Summer's Reading By Bernard Malmud (17%) Task in Unit Log Short Description of Activity Key Components 1) Pre-Reading Activity Yes List of goals (most while....less while) Comparing with other students) 2) Basic Understanding Lots Questions 3) Analysis and Interpretation Character, Protagonist, Comparing/Contrasting Cause/Effect 4) Bridging Text and Context Immigration to New York for a better life 5) Post-Reading Activity (40%) Conversation between George and Mr. Cattanzara 6) Summative Assessment Lots and Hots Questions Bridging Questions Final Grade 6 No Calculation of Grade for the Unit Log - All Levels % of Grade for Unit Element Presentation Unit Log contains all the required activities for the Key Components, is aesthetic, neatly presented and handed in on time. 10% Graded Key Component Additional graded activities may be included For all graded activities, including ones that cannot be physically inserted (oral, digital, 3-D, etc.), a grading rubric must be included in the Unit Log for each student. 40% Summative Assessment 50% Grade Final Grade TOTAL Comments _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ 7 C. Calculation of the Final Grade for Students Doing the Unit Logs – All Levels a. The calculation of the final grade for students who are doing the Unit Logs now includes Personal Response and Extensive Reading. There is no longer a grade for Presentation. b. New calculation spreadsheets will be uploaded to the TLC site. c. The calculation for the first literature piece is given as an example. Final Grade for Students Doing the Unit Logs - Module F % of Grade Grade Final Grade Play 20% 80 16 Short Story 14% Short Story 14% Short Story 14% Poem 9% Poem 9% Personal Response 5% Extensive Reading (four books) 15% Elements TOTAL 100% 8 D. Calculation of the Final Grade for Students Doing the Unit Logs – All Levels (continued) Final Grade for Students Doing the Unit Logs - Module D % of Grade Grade Final Grade Short Story 17% 80 14 Short Story 17% Short Story 17% Poem 9% Poem 9% Poem 9% Personal Response 7% Extensive Reading (four books) 15% Elements TOTAL 100% Final Grade for Students Doing the Unit Logs - Module B % of Grade Grade Final Grade Short Story 30% 80 24 Short Story 30% Poem 20% Personal Response 5% Extensive Reading (two books) 15% Elements TOTAL 100% 9 D. Calculation of the Grade of a Unit for Each Literary Text for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam - Modules F and D * % of Grade for Unit Grade Final Grade Graded Key Component 40% 75 30 Summative Assessment 60% Element TOTAL * Students who are taking the exam are required to do all the Key Components. E. Calculation of the Grade of the Literature Program for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam - Modules F and D a. New calculation spreadsheets will be uploaded to the TLC site. b. The calculation for the first literature piece is given as an example. Final Grade of Literature Program -Module F % of Final Grade Grade Final Grade Play/Novel 26% 85 22 Short Story 18% Short Story 18% Short Story 18% Poem 10% Poem 10% Literary Text TOTAL 100% 10 F. Calculation of the Grade of the Literature Program for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam - Modules F and D (continued) Final Grade of Literature Program - Module D % of Final Grade Grade Final Grade Short Story 21% 88 18 Short Story 21% Short Story 22% Poem 12% Poem 12% Poem 12% Literary Text TOTAL 100% 11 F. Calculation of the Final Grade for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam Modules F and D a. New calculation spreadsheets will be uploaded to the TLC site. b. The calculation for the first literature piece is given as an example. Final Grade for Students Taking the Literature Bagrut Exam Module F % of Grade Grade Final Grade Final grade for Literature Program 35% 90 32 Personal Response 5% Extensive Reading (four books) 15% Ministry of Education Literature Bagrut Exam 45% Elements TOTAL 100% Final Grade for Students Taking the Literature Exam - Module D % of Grade Grade Final Grade Final grade for Literature Program 35% 80 28 Personal Response 5% Extensive Reading (four books) 15% Ministry of Education Literature Bagrut Exam 45% Elements TOTAL 100% 12 G. Unit Logs - Module B The literature program for three points will include two short stories and one poem. There will be a Unit Log for each of the literary texts. Students need to do activities for all the Key Components for each literary text. Teachers might want to choose literary texts that are based on a theme. The choice of the literary texts must be based on the criteria set by the English Inspectorate: Short Story Length The length of the text is at least 900 words. Literary merit The text was written by a recognized, published author. Universality The themes of the text span place and time. Authentic The story was written originally in English and may have been simplified or abridged. The literary text enriches students and encourages them to respond to the text. Poetry Literary merit The text was written by a recognized, published poet. Universality The themes of the text span place and time. Authentic The poem was written originally in English. The literary text enriches students and encourages them to respond to the text. Teachers can choose any of the texts that are on the approved list on the TLC site. If they wish to teach a text that is not on the list, they must send an email to Bari Nirenberg at bari.texts@gmail.com to ask for approval. Texts may be submitted for approval from May 1st to November 1st. (See Appendix One for a preliminary list of texts that have been approved.) In order to help teachers, the English Inspectorate will post suggested literary texts, ideas for teaching the HOTS, tasks for the Key Components and sample Summative Assessments on the TLC site. 13 H. Unit Logs - Module B (continued) Literature courses will be given in the coming school year. Details will be posted on the site of the English Inspectorate. If a student moves from three to four points, one short story and one poem from the three-point Log may be counted as part of the four-point Log under the condition that these texts have been approved for four points. For each text studied at the three-point level, deduct 10% from the grade. The breakdown of points for Summative Assessment for each literary text for three points includes: Module B Type of Question # of questions Points LOTS Basic Understanding 6-8 questions 60 HOTS Analysis and Interpretation 4 questions 40 Note: The Summative Assessment includes vocabulary, basic understanding, and simple analysis questions. LOTS and HOTS questions can include different question types such as multiple-choice, openended, sentence completion. There is no Bridging Text and Context question on the Summative Assessment for Module B. However, Bridging Text and Context must be included as a Key Component in the Unit Log. 14 H. Random Sampling for Unit Logs and Exams a. For teachers doing the Unit Logs: Teachers fill out the appropriate form from the Testing Dept. (Form numbers will be supplied by the Testing Dept. at a later date.) Teachers report the grades for each of the Unit Logs, Personal Response and Extensive Reading. Teachers will no longer have to calculate the final grades, as this will now be done by the Testing Dept. (This form will be instead of the 9540 form.) Teachers fill out the Excel spreadsheet (which will be in the updated Literature Handbook and on the TLC site) that includes the students’ ID numbers, grades for each Unit Log, (which include grades for the graded Key Component and for the Summative Assessment), Personal Response, and Extensive Reading. It enables teachers to see the final grades of their students. This form is emailed to the English Inspector of the school. For each literary text studied, three Unit Logs per class (one with a high grade, one with an average grade and one with a low grade, when possible) must be kept at school. There should not be two Unit Logs from the same student. In other words, save Unit Logs from different students for each text. These Unit Logs will be randomly sampled during the school year and/or at the end of the school year by either an English counselor or the English Inspector of the school. b. For teachers whose students are taking the Literature Bagrut exam: Teachers fill out the appropriate form from the Testing Dept. (Form numbers will be supplied by the Testing Dept. at a later date.) Teachers report the grades for each literary text studied, Personal Response, Extensive Reading, and the grade of the Literature Bagrut exam. Teachers fill out the Excel spreadsheet (which will be in the updated Literature Handbook and on the TLC site) that includes the students’ ID numbers, grades for each literary text studied, Personal Response, Extensive Reading and the grade of the external Literature Bagrut exam. It enables teachers to see the final grades of their students. This form is emailed to the English Inspector of the school. Teachers must save the marked Literature Bagrut exams until October 31st of the following school year. 15 Appendix One State of Israel Ministry of Education Pedagogic Affairs Language Department English Inspectorate Approval of the School’s Literature Program for the Log – Module F Name of School: Semel #: Yishuv: Name of Teacher: Fax number of school: Module F Genre Name of Literary Text On the Approved Text List Author Yes No One Play or Novel Three Short Stories Two Poems Name of Coordinator: _________________ Signature: ________________ Date:_______ Name of Principal: ____________________ Signature: ________________ Date:_______ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * The Literature program is: Approved Not Approved Comments: Name of English Inspector: _______________ Signature: ____________ 16 Date: __________ State of Israel Ministry of Education Pedagogic Affairs Language Department English Inspectorate Approval of the School’s Literature Program for the Log – Module D Name of School: Semel #: Yishuv: Name of Teacher: Fax number of school: Module D Genre Name of Literary Text On the Approved Text List Author Yes No Three Short Stories Three Poems Name of Coordinator: _________________ Signature: ________________ Date:_______ Name of Principal: ____________________ Signature: ________________ Date:_______ ***************************************************** The Literature program is: Approved Not Approved Comments: Name of English Inspector: _______________ Signature: ____________ 17 Date: __________ State of Israel Ministry of Education Pedagogic Affairs Language Department English Inspectorate Approval of the School’s Literature Program for the Log – Module B Name of School: Semel #: Yishuv: Name of Teacher: Fax number of school: Module B Genre Name of Literary Text On the Approved Text List Author Yes No Two Short Stories One Poem Name of Coordinator: _________________ Signature: ________________ Date:_______ Name of Principal: ____________________ Signature: ________________ Date:_______ ***************************************************** The Literature program is: Approved Not Approved Comments: Name of English Inspector: _______________ Signature: ____________ 18 Date: __________ Appendix Two List of Approved Texts for the Three -Point Literature Program YES = Approved; NO = Not Approved 1. The literature texts in the coursebooks are NOT necessarily approved for the Literature Program. Only the versions of the texts listed below are approved. If you want to use an adapted version of a text that has been published in a book not listed here, you must submit that version for approval. Please note that some stories appear on both the list of approved texts and the list of rejected texts because one version is approved and another is not. 2. If you wish to teach a piece of literature that you feel is worthy and appropriate for your students because of the theme, and it has NOT been approved, you may STILL teach it – however it CANNOT be included as part of the literature program. 3. Any poem or story approved for four points may also be used for three points. Some may be difficult, so use your discretion. 4. There are two lists that follow, organized alphabetically according to genres. 5. There is a separate list (following this one) which includes texts that have NOT been approved. Please refer to that list before submitting a request for a list that is not written here. 19 List of Approved Texts for the Three -Point Literature Program (continued) POEMS Text Author Appears in 1. STORIES – ONLY THESE VERSIONS 1. Text After You, My Dear Alphonse Author Shirley Jackson Appears in A Cool Collection 1 2. Blanket, The Floyd Dell Communicating in English 1, Revised Edition 3. Burge McCall Damon Runyan Choice Reading 4. Dusk Saki Celebrating Literature 5. Feeling of Power, The Isaac Asimov Intermediate Reader 3 6. Fun They Had, The Isaac Asimov Communicating in English 1, Revised Edition 7. Good Lord Will Provide, The Lawrence Treat and Charles M. Plotz A Cool Collection 1 Intermediate Reader 3 (more difficult) 8. Hitchhiker, The Roald Dahl A Cool Collection 1 9. Last Leaf, The O. Henry The Last Leaf and Other Stories, Heinemann ELT Guided Readers 10. Mama and Her Bank Account Kathryn Forbes Intermediate Reader 3 11. Open Window, The Saki Celebrating Literature 12. Sredni Vashtar Saki A Cool Collection 1 13. Suzy and Leah Jane Yolen Steps to Literature 3 14. That’s What Happened to Me Michael Fessier Looking Into Literature 15. Umbrella Man, The Roald Dahl A Cool Collection 1 16. Verger, The W. Somerset Maugham Communicating in English 1, Revised Edition 17. While the Auto Waits O. Henry Intermediate Reader 3 20 List of Texts that are NOT Approved for Three -Point Literature Program Before submitting requests please consult this list and if the text appears here, do NOT request for it to be approved. Please note: 1. Lyrics written as lyrics are not approvable texts for poetry. 2. Following are two lists of texts that have been rejected for the Unit Log, organized alphabetically according to genres. POEMS that are NOT approved for the literature program Text Author Appears in 1. Smile Barbara Hauck That’s Right 2. When Sarah Surfs the Internet Kenn Nesbitt That’s Right STORIES that are NOT approved for the literature program Text Author Appears in 1. All Those Noughts / All Those Zeroes Jake Allsop No version is approved 2. Bank Robbery, The Roger Dean Kiser That’s Right 3. Blanket, The Floyd Dell Intermediate Reader 2 4. Cat Who Thought She Was a Dog and the Dog Who Thought He Was a Cat, The Isaac Bashevis Singer Steps to Literature 5. Fan Club, The Rona Maynard That’s Right 6. Fun They Had, The Isaac Asimov Steps to Literature 7. Not For Sale Jack Norman Stories to Teach and Delight 8. Run, Sheep, Run Rosemary Howland Steps to Literature 9. Third Jump, The Jesse Owens and Paul G. Neimark Celebrating Literature 21