Equalities Impact Assessment Waste prevention, recycling and composting activities Department of Environment & Transport February 2013 106733968 Page 1 of 9 Equality Impact Assessment (EIA) Report For further information on undertaking and completing an Equality Impact Assessment, please see the guidance. Name of policy/ procedure/ function/ service being assessed: Waste prevention, recycling and composting activities Department and Section: Environment and Transport, Waste Name of lead officer and others completing this assessment: Linda Wilson/Anna Low/Vicky Cormie Contact telephone numbers: 0116 305 5587/8127/7291 Date EIA assessment completed: September 2012 Step 1: Defining the function What are the main aims, purpose and objectives of the function? How will they be achieved? Waste prevention, recycling and composting activities aim to foster sustainable waste management practice and behaviour in Leicestershire. Waste prevention involves reducing the amount of waste that is produced by not generating the waste in the first place, by keeping things for longer and reusing items. Recycling and composting involves turning waste into new products. These activities aim to: Reduce the amount of waste sent to landfill therefore resulting in the mitigation of Leicestershire’s environmental impact associated with waste management. Mitigate the cost of waste disposal for the tax payer by limiting exposure to landfill tax charges (currently £64 per tonne increasing by £8 per year). Engage with and encourage local communities to participate in waste prevention, recycling and composting activities through implementing behavioural changes at home and work and participating in volunteer schemes. What are the main activities relating to this function and distinguish who is likely to benefit from these activities. The provision of Leicestershire County Council’s (LCC) waste prevention, recycling and composting function will be determined by the Waste Initiatives Plan. During 2012/13, activities will be implemented to deliver the following key campaigns: Food waste prevention Home composting and food waste digesters Recycling Reuse Activities to successfully deliver these campaigns are likely to include: Conducting roadshows and workshops at community hubs (such as local halls, schools etc.) and during community events (such as farmers markets, local shows/festivals etc.) using the waste 106733968 Page 2 of 9 exhibition trailer when appropriate. Presenting and delivering educational sessions with schools, community groups, local stakeholders etc. Enrolling and training local volunteers within the Master Composter, Real Nappy, Love Food Hate Waste Cooking Class and Waste Action Volunteer schemes to promote sustainable waste management within their community through presenting to their peers, conducting events during community meetings, visiting local residents in their homes to provide advice etc. Communications activities are undertaken regarding waste prevention, recycling and composting on behalf of Waste Management by the Corporate Communications Group. These activities include publicity/advertising relating to events/campaigns including for example: the production and issuing of media releases commissioning of local and social media mechanisms deciding upon which publications/mediums to use and when; and development, design and issuing of leaflets and posters etc. Residents will benefit from the provision of waste prevention, recycling and composting activities. These benefits will arise from a reduced environmental impact associated with waste management, lower cost of waste disposal in Leicestershire and improved community cohesion through more members of the public engaging and participating in local sustainable waste management activities. What outcomes are expected? Waste prevention, recycling and composting activities aim to contribute to: Reducing the total tonnages of household waste produced Increasing recycling rates Increasing composting rates Increasing awareness levels Increasing participation levels Examples of 2012/131 performance indicators that have been produced to monitor the success of the campaigns listed in step 1 above include: Sale of 1000 home compost bins Recruitment of 600 new Rot a Lot members Delivery of 25 talks/activities to educational establishments and community groups Reuse of 40 tonnes of waste via Freeuse 1 these performance indicators will be reviewed and updated during the annual Local Business Plan development process 106733968 Page 3 of 9 Step 2: Potential Impact Who is affected and what barriers may these individuals or groups face? Age Potential barriers exist for elderly members of the public who may want to engage in waste prevention, recycling and composting activities but have difficulty accessing/travelling to community venues where roadshows/events are being held. Potential barriers exist for elderly members of the public who may experience difficulty accessing the waste exhibition trailer that is used during some events due to the need to climb steps upon entry. Potential barriers exist for elderly members of the public due to the continuing demand to reduce communication costs resulting in an increased use of no/low cost social media to communicate messages. It is widely accepted that this type of communication predominantly targets younger members of the public. Disability Potential barriers exist for disabled members of the public who would like to engage in waste prevention, recycling and composting activities but have difficulty accessing/travelling to community venues where roadshows/events are being held. Gender Reassignment Marriage and Civil Partnership Pregnancy and Maternity Race Potential barriers exist for disabled members of the public who may experience difficulty accessing the waste exhibition trailer used during some events due to the need to climb steps upon entry. No barriers identified No barriers identified No barriers identified Potential barriers exist for non-English speaking residents who may experience difficulty in engaging due to not understanding information contained within literature/posters/presentations etc. Potential barriers also exist for minority racial groups in Leicestershire who may be difficult to contact and inform about County Council activities. No barriers identified No barriers identified No barriers identified Potential barriers exist for working people who may not be able to participate if roadshows/events are predominantly undertaken during weekdays between 9am and 5pm. Religion or Belief Sex Sexual Orientation Other groups e.g. rural isolation, deprivation, health inequality, carers, asylum seeker and refugee communities, looked after children, deprived or disadvantaged communities Community Cohesion No barriers identified 106733968 Page 4 of 9 Step 3: Data Collection & Evidence What evidence, research, data and other information do you have which will be relevant to this EIA? What does this information / data tell you about each of the diverse groups? A significant amount of equality and diversity information has been gathered from participants during events. The most recent completed analysis of this information is available in the ‘Waste Prevention and Reuse Project Benefits Assessment District Level Report (2010)’. This report included developing a baseline of information to identify the socio-demographic profiles of residents that have been engaging with WPRP activities during 2008 and 2009. The aim of the assessment was also to identify prevailing behaviour patterns, motivations and potential barriers that participants experienced when engaging in the WPRP activities. The report included the following key recommendations: ‘…ACORN 4 and 5 categories…were not engaging adequately... Steps should be taken to use the findings to better target these demographic groups... Seek to understand why engagement by residents varies from district to district and in particular, take steps to increase engagement from the low uptake districts. Use the mapping of the geographical spread of ACORN categories across Leicestershire to inform future targeting of campaigns and initiatives.’ What further research, data or evidence may be required to fill any gaps in your understanding of the potential or known affects of the function? Have you considered carrying out new data or research? At present, a significant amount of equality and diversity information is being gathered by the Waste Research Project. This project aims to ‘…gather information and gain insight that will enable the development and delivery of more effective waste campaigns and initiatives, that encourage residents to adopt more positive and sustained waste behaviours, that result in a reduction in the amount of waste being produced in Leicestershire and sent for treatment and to landfill.’ There are many activities within the scope of the Waste Research Project. Activities relevant to this EIA include: ‘…literary review including topics such as: behavioural change; waste prevention; reuse; environmental segmentation; lifestyle approach… …survey of people on our existing databases …running of focus groups…’ The aim and activities to be delivered by the Waste Research Project therefore will develop a greater understanding of customers and the level of success of waste prevention, recycling and composting activities. Any existing barriers for protected characteristic groups will be highlighted during the Waste Research Project. The Waste Research Project is due to be completed during Spring 2013. Findings from the activities undertaken within the project will be reported as and when they are completed. This EIA will be updated if the Waste Research Project identifies that any barriers exist for the nine protected characteristic groups. 106733968 Page 5 of 9 Step 4: Consultation and Involvement Have you consulted on this function? Outline any consultation and the outcomes of the consultation in relation to this EIA. See step 3 above. Do any of the barriers you identified actually exist based on this consultation? In the past, following evaluation of feedback forms from real nappy campaign activities it was found that BME mothers were not being engaged appropriately in the real nappy campaign. This issue was addressed through a number of actions such as by specifically targeting BME groups for real nappy talks and advertising in the Leicester Mercury newspaper’s annual Diwali supplement. An Asian Real Nappy Advisor (volunteer) has also been recruited which has greatly increased the number of BME mothers engaging with this campaign. Step 5: Mitigating and assessing the impact If you consider there to be actual or potential adverse impact or discrimination, please outline this below. State whether it is justifiable or legitimate and give reasons. Step 2 identifies potential barriers for the following protected characteristic groups: Age Disability Race Religion or belief It is considered that any potential barriers associated with waste prevention, recycling and composting activities are mitigated by actions described in the box below. No illegal, justifiable or legitimate discrimination has been identified. What can be done to change the function to mitigate any adverse impact? Consider what barriers you can remove, whether reasonable adjustments may be necessary and how any unmet needs that you have identified can be addressed. The following actions have been implemented to mitigate the potential adverse impacts identified in step 2 above: Age Potential issue: elderly members of the public may want to engage in waste prevention, recycling and composting activities but may experience difficulty accessing/travelling to community venues where roadshows/events are being held. Mitigation: assess venues for suitable access for elderly residents prior to arranging events. Potential issue: elderly members of the public may experience difficulty accessing the waste exhibition trailer which is used during some events due to the need to climb steps upon entry. Mitigation: use of the accessibility ramp to prevent elderly members of the public from needing to climb stairs to enter the waste exhibition trailer. Potential issue: young professionals may not be able to participate if roadshows/events are predominantly undertaken during weekdays between 9am and 5pm. Mitigation: ensure events/activities are well distributed throughout all days and times of the week. Disability Potential issue: disabled members of the public may want to engage in waste prevention, recycling and composting activities but have difficulty accessing/travelling to community venues where roadshows/events are being held. Mitigation: assess venues for suitable access for disabled residents prior to arranging events. 106733968 Page 6 of 9 Potential issue: disabled members of the public may experience difficulty accessing the waste exhibition trailer which is used during some events due to the need to climb steps upon entry. Mitigation: use of the accessibility ramp to prevent disabled members of the public from needing to climb stairs to enter the waste exhibition trailer. Race Potential issue: non-English speaking residents may experience difficulty in engaging due to not understanding information contained within leaflets/posters/presentations etc. Mitigation: make leaflets/posters available in various languages upon request. Utilise translation service as necessary. Potential issue: minority racial groups in Leicestershire may be difficult to contact and inform about County Council services/facilities etc. Mitigation: make leaflets/posters available in various languages upon request. Utilise targeted mechanisms (such as community magazines) to engage with particular groups. Step 6: Making a decision Summarise your findings and give an overview of whether the policy will meet Leicestershire County Council’s responsibilities in relation to equality, diversity and human rights. It is considered that the undertaking of waste prevention, reuse, recycling and composting activities is meeting LCC’s responsibilities in relation to equality, diversity and human rights. Step 7: Monitoring, evaluation & review of your function How will you monitor the impact and effectiveness of the function and what monitoring systems will you put in place to monitor this and to promote equality of opportunity and make positive improvements? Monitoring of the corporate compliments, comments and complaints system will ensure any equality, diversity and human rights issues that arise are received and resolved appropriately. Collection of equality and diversity and ACORN demographic group information will continue to be undertaken through surveys and event feedback forms. The findings will be monitored to identify whether the responses indicate that the participants represent the Leicestershire population and whether any barriers for the nine protected characteristic groups exist. The findings will also allow us to tailor the waste prevention, recycling and composting events to suitably meet the needs of the participants. How will the recommendations of this assessment be built into wider planning and review processes? e.g. policy reviews, annual plans and use of performance management systems. Any future changes to waste prevention, reuse, recycling and composting activities will be assessed for potential impact upon equality, diversity and human rights. 106733968 Page 7 of 9 Equality Improvement Plan Please list all the equality objectives, actions and targets that result from the Equality Impact Assessment (continue on separate sheets as necessary). These now need to be included in the relevant service plan for mainstreaming and performance management purposes. Equality Objective Accessible Activities Equality, Diversity & Human Rights Training Data Analysis 106733968 Action Staff successfully use the interpretation and translation service (for language translations) and type talk service (for deaf people) to communicate with various groups. Target Evidence is available to show that all staff directly engaging with stakeholders understand how to access and use the language line and type talk service. Officer Responsible Linda Wilson/ Anna Low By When End of March each year Ensure that roadshows are located with appropriate accessibility provisions (such as adequate disabled parking, public transport access, hearing loop availability etc). The venue accessibility check list is completed prior to roadshow/events and a repository of venue accessibility checks are developed and maintained. Linda Wilson/ Anna Low End of March 2013 Locations of roadshows/ events are well distributed throughout Leicestershire. Undertake roadshows/events in areas of high footfall to ensure engagement with a representative sample of Leicestershire’s population. All staff complete biennial equality, diversity and human rights training. Linda Wilson/ Anna Low End of March each year Linda Wilson/ Anna Low End of March each year Linda Wilson/ Anna Low Analysis of data as part of the Waste Research Project All staff receive equality, diversity and human rights training. Equality and diversity questions are included in all monitoring and evaluation of events. Page 8 of 9 Any identified barriers are resolved promptly and used to inform future activities. Equality Objective Action Analyse survey data from events/activities to identify whether any barriers for the nine protected characteristic groups exist. Target This EIA is updated as necessary upon the discovery of any existing barriers. Officer Responsible Linda Wilson/ Anna Low By When As necessary 1st Authorised Signature (EIA Lead): Vicky Cormie Date: 1st March 2013 2nd Authorised Signature (Member of DMT): Mark Stevens Date: 6th March 2013 Once completed, please send a copy of this form to the Departmental Equalities Group for quality assurance. Once authorised, this Equality Impact Assessment (EIA) Report will need to be published on our website. 106733968 Page 9 of 9