March/April 2004 The Cambridge Chronicle The Cambridge Chronicle will be sent to our clients every other month via e-mail and will have news and information specific to legal staffing and more specifically to Atlanta. We will also publish what is new with Cambridge, for example changes in the benefits we offer our temporary employees and steps we take to improve our services. If you have any suggestions on topics you would like to see, please e-mail us at jlowe@cambridgeprofessionals.com. It is our constant goal to provide not only the best candidates and service, but also to serve as consultants to our clients. State of the Job Market in Atlanta For the first time in over two years we are happy to report that the market has turned and hiring, both temporary and permanent, is on the rise. Speaking on behalf of just Cambridge, and not all legal staffing companies in Atlanta, we saw a substantial increase in temporary hiring in 4th Quarter of 2003 and permanent hiring increased slightly toward the end of 3rd Quarter 2003 and remained strong through 4 th Quarter 2003. First Quarter 2004, has been even better. Permanent hiring for legal secretaries, paralegals, and attorneys has increased substantially in law firms of all sizes. Corporations have increased hiring at all levels, but continue to hire mainly temporary employees. In any case, the market is still an employers market with an abundance of good talent—both temporary and permanent. Some recent employment facts reported are: The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reports that in March 2004, 308,000 new jobs were added to payrolls, the fastest pace in almost 4 years. This should help push business confidence higher, leading to additional permanent, temporary and tempto-perm positions. 1st Quarter 2004 reported a total of 513,000 new jobs, almost 3 times that of 4th Quarter 2003 (179,000 new jobs). No Quarter last year was able to show a positive “jobs” direction! Despite an increase in new jobs, the overall unemployment rate rose from 5.6% to 5.7%. While the BLS did not specify why unemployment increased, it could be due to the fact that job satisfaction is at an all time low with, 1 out of every 2 employees currently unhappy and/or looking. First Annual Salary Survey-Postponed We were scheduled to distribute a salary survey to law firms and corporations around Atlanta this past February. However, because the market is doing better than ever expected—we have been extremely busy and unable to work on a project of this magnitude. We have rescheduled the surveys to go out at the end May, with the results/report being distributed in July. We know that many of you are looking forward to this information and we apologize for any inconvenience. However, we want to make the most of the survey and want it to be a first class resource for our clients. Please keep a look out for the survey, and we encourage each and every one of you to participate. As mentioned before, it will be confidential and will be more useful the greater the participation. Temporary Rate Increase Effective May 31st, 2004 Most of you have probably already been informed that your unemployment insurance was increased beginning January 2004. Unfortunately, we have just received our notice and have spent the last several weeks discussing solutions for dealing with the increase. As you can imagine, staffing companies were hit slightly harder than the average employer, due to the fact we have employees that will work for a period of time and then may not work for a period of time. For us to continue providing the quality candidates, service, and benefits—we pride ourselves on—we will be increasing all temporary bill rates/mark-ups 5% immediately on all new hires (this includes Preferred Partner Agreement Clients). When you call in an order, the recruiters will confirm with you what the bill-rate will be. Since pay rates and bill rates do vary from one temporary employee to the next, we may be able to adjust the pay rate without affecting bill rates. Regardless, as always we will work with you to stay within your budgets, and still provide you with the quality and experience you need. For all temporary employees currently on long-term assignments, their bill rates will be increased as of May 31st, 2004. You will receive a letter in the next several weeks with the new bill-rate. Overall billrates will increase on average $1.00 an hour, but increases overall will range $.50 cents an hour for lower level employees to $3.00 on the very high end and extremely skilled/experienced attorneys. If you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to call. We want to make the transition as seamless as possible, and the effect to you and your business minimal. Don’t Want to Pay a Fee, But Need to Ensure Quality? Your candidates and our rigorous testing services can help you avoid making a hiring mistake. If you hire directly without testing, you put yourself at risk of making a bad hire. Cambridge now offers a full range of testing and background checks for the individuals you hire on your own (without the assistance of a staffing company). Cambridge offers a broad range (over 300 tests available) of skills test, psychological testing, and a full compliment of background checks that can be customized to your needs. We can develop a test profile for each type of position you hire and then it is as easy as calling to schedule an appointment. Once the testing is complete we will email the results to you! The cost is $50.00 per test or background check requested. A small cost to ensure your candidate has been professionally tested. Call us to find out more about how Cambridge can be your testing partner. Sample List Of Available Services Skills Tests Microsoft Word Word Perfect Data Entry Microsoft Excel Power Point Outlook Windows Typing Math Testing Accounting Tests Vocabulary Proofing & Editing Languages Work Attitudes Testing Background Checks Criminal Records Credit Report Driving Record Employment Verification References New Clerks Program While we have always staffed document, copying, and file clerks—we have never had a dedicated resource committed to this area on a full-time basis…. well something else at Cambridge has changed. A few of our clients have hired these clerks, and we are proud to say they are extremely pleased with the quality they have received. Jane Berlin at Rogers & Hardin had this to say, "Thank you, CambridgeStaff, for helping me bring my new caseworker program to fruition! As you know, I want to interview only the most highly qualified recent college grad whose goal it is to attend law school. I now have 22 bright young professionals in the program and the lawyers and paralegals can't say enough good things about the high degree of support they receive at every turn. I appreciate your personal attention and thank you for sending me such outstanding candidates." If you have a need for a clerk or have questions regarding this service, please contact Jenny Voigt or your current Cambridge contact. Flat Perm Fee of $2,000 Temp Hourly Rate of $15.50-$18.60 w/ 90 days option of perm at no additional fee New Temporary Benefits Starting this past February we are offering an additional level of health coverage for our long-term temporary employees. Until now we have always offered heath insurance reimbursement of $100 per month to our temporary employees to apply to the insurance carrier of their choice. In addition, they already receive eligibility in our 401K, holiday and vacation pay. Our new coverage will allow longterm temps (on assignment 6 months or longer) to participate in the same Major Medical coverage fulltime employees at Cambridge enjoy. This level of coverage offers: health, vision, dental, short-term and long-term disability and life insurance through Guardian. Featured Article: Effective Hiring & First Impressions Hiring great talent is not easy and if you are truly interested in hiring the best talent the market holds, it is important to remember that this may be the first interface a candidate will have your organization. So how do you make the first impression a good one? How do make sure you are not wasting time and money? How do you ensure you get the best candidates? How do you close the deal? First things first, HAVE A PROCESS. Make sure you have answers to the following questions prior to interviewing: What and where is the need? When does the position need to be filled by? What will this person be doing (job description)? What are the qualifications for this position? What is the salary range for this position, including bonus potential? Who will this person report to? Where will this person fit in amongst the rest of the team? Who will be the point person on this search? How will we find candidates for this position (post the position, utilize internal recruiters, contact an outside search firm)? What information will be required to determine candidacy (i.e., resume, writing sample, transcripts, test scores) and complete a candidates application? Once complete applications are received for the position, who will review the resumes to determine interest? Who will conduct first interviews? How long will candidates spend with each interviewer? What is the order of interviews? What do we want to ask in a first interview? What do we want to know/accomplish? What do we want to convey? What is important for this person to know about the position? Should we all ask the same questions or different questions? Should we do a panel interview or individual interviews? How will we collect feedback on each interview (evaluation interview forms work best)? Will there be second interviews and who will conduct them? Third interviews? How many candidates do we want to interview for a first, second, third? How are we going to track applicants and manage the process? DEFINING A PROCESS AND SETTING PARAMETERS Before contacting a recruiter or starting a search, it is important that you have the majority of the questions answered above. It is equally as important that there is a consensus regarding the process and the parameters, among all those interviewing and participating in making this hiring decision. I have seen more clients waste time and money, because their own team was not on the same page when interviewing candidates. The most costly outcome when these things are not clearly defined or communicated amongst the team interviewing is not the loss of time or money, but the loss of a great candidate. Candidates will become disinterested, and left with an impression that the organization lacks leadership and direction when they receive mixed messages from the interviewers. If it is a new position, it is very likely that your job description, and even the qualifications you are seeking in a candidate, will change as you start the interview process. This is not a problem, if properly managed and adequately communicated. It is critical to communicate to the candidate that this is a new position, and that the candidate you decide to hire, will depend a great deal on what that person brings to the table. For a newly created position, it is important to look for candidates who are open to change, open minded, and consider themselves able to “think outside the box”. You don’t want someone who needs a clear and concise job description. By the end of the interview process, you will more than likely have a stronger grasp and understanding of what you need and want based on what you hear and see from the candidates. The position is also likely to change in the first year, and it is important the candidate understands this coming in to the position. Innovative organizations would take this new position and the interviewing process as an opportunity to learn. Ask all the candidates who interview to tell you what value they can add to the position. What they bring to the table that was not mentioned in the job description. Is there anything they would add to responsibilities of the position based on their experience. You have (1) established a process; (2) set parameters for the search; (3) garnered consensus amongst your team; and (4) identified candidates that are qualified, and you are interested in interviewing. So lets start interviewing. GENERAL THOUGHTS Make sure to allocate enough time to interview a candidate-At least 30-45 minutes for individual interviews and an hour to an hour and a half for a panel of 2 or more. Every “interviewer” in the process should have general knowledge of the candidate prior to the interview and a “desire” to interview-It’s a fact most people don’t look forward to interviewing. Any company interviewing a “recruit” candidate (a candidate that’s not looking to make a move) must keep in mind that it’s important to “sell” the organization and the opportunity. 9 out of 10 times these are the best candidates and the ones you will want to hire. Initial interviews for recruit candidates are to learn more about the position, company, culture and yes, you, the interviewer! You may want to create two interviews (questions to ask, what you want to accomplish). One interview for recruit candidates and one for non-recruits. The focus for non-recruits—is for them to really sell you. For the recruit candidates—you will be selling each other. Cover “pros” and “cons” of the position with the candidate. Create an outline of what you want in a candidate - Every person in the interview process should do the same. Remember, just like there is no such thing as the perfect job--there’s no such thing as the perfect candidate. If you have 80-90% of what you want, you more than likely have a match. A candidate should be able to (proactively) position what he or she can bring to an organization. Remember it is an interview and the majority of candidates (even recruit candidates) are going to be selling themselves. As the interviewer it is important to determine what is confidence and what is arrogance (the two can get confused), and remember they are selling themselves. Avoid letting your guard down with a candidate. Do not get too personal in the interview. Candidates will often reciprocate and let their guard down—it is human nature for candidates to reciprocate with like action. However, some of the common feedback I have received from clients is the candidate, “felt too comfortable.” This is often times, because the interviewer let them feel too comfortable. Avoid talking too much about yourself or your management style. Telling too much gives candidates the opportunity to alter responses to what they think you want to hear. Ask open-ended questions, and make sure to listen to how they answer a question (directly or indirectly, with or without examples). Listen to what they don’t tell you. Have an outline with pre-determined questions specific to the job, the qualifications required, what is important in regards to fit (i.e., works better autonomously or as a member of a team, deals well with stress or doesn’t, etc.) Take notes and evaluate the candidate at the end of the interview with a few lines on overall general impressions and then rate them on a scale of 1 to 10 against the other candidates you have interviewed. GENERIC QUESTIONS 1. Will you walk me through your background?-The idea is to look for holes in the resume, excessive job movement and lack of relevant experience. Try to spend no more than 15 minutes on a resume “walkthrough”. You can always come back to this in a follow up interview or phone call if there are real concerns. 2. Is there anything you dislike about your previous employers? –It’s not a bad idea to put the candidate on the spot with a question like this. What you’re looking for is to see if a candidate will bad mouth a former manager or organization and for what reasons. You’re also looking to see how a candidate handles an uncomfortable question. 3. Tell me about yourself-The goal of this question (or request) is to learn more about the candidate on a personal level. It’s possible that you might be able to uncover certain personality and character traits if the candidate is given the chance to speak freely. 4. How do you define success?-This is simple. We all have different definitions of success. This question allows the interviewer to match up a candidate’s thoughts on what it is to succeed with their own. At times, people can be worlds apart when it comes to defining the word success. It’s important to know as a manager or colleague, what success is to this person and what drives them to succeed. 5. How have you handled setbacks?-Ask the candidate for specific examples. Try to evaluate if a candidate can think out of the box to resolve issues that may get in their way of succeeding. The idea is to evaluate whether or not you have someone who can handle distractions and difficult situations in a calm, cool and level headed manner. 6. What motivates you?-Is it money? Being number one? As an interviewer, you might want someone who’s a team player, you might be looking for someone who wants to compete day in day out with their fellow colleagues. This can be a tough question for a candidate because a candidate is never quite sure how to answer it. Every candidate has been taught not to say money is a factor that motivates. 7. Talk to me about specific achievements that have occurred in your career The interviewer should be looking for specifics. This is where many candidates trip up. Many candidates find it uncomfortable to brag about achievements. It’s important to find candidates that believe in success and can talk about their achievements in a professional manner. 8. Why are you interviewing? Candidates should be interviewing initially to learn more about the position, company, manager, culture and to see if there is interest to explore the position further. Although there are always exceptions, the best candidates to hire (in the end) are the ones that are not necessarily looking. These types of candidates are operating from a position of strength, not weakness and will tend to make sounder decisions when it comes to job movement. These types of candidates also usually show a greater pattern of success in their professional background. I define these types of candidates as “recruit” candidates. Are you looking to leave your current firm?If the answer is “yes” this is when the interviewer has to really probe. Ask why and let the candidate talk. Follow up each reason the candidate gives with more questions. Dig and dig. 9. What type of management style works best for you?-In my opinion this is one of the most important questions to ask a candidate. Why is it so important? If a manager’s management style doesn’t mesh with a candidate’s needs, you’re looking at a possible disaster. The manager must know their own management style to properly evaluate the answer the candidate gives. What do you expect from a manager? Have you ever had a problem with a previous manager? If so, how did you resolve the problem? 10. Do you have any further questions?-Every interviewer asks this question. But does every interviewer expect and look for the right question from the candidate? The best candidates will try to close you at this point as a follow up to this question. The best candidates will ask you (as a “further” question): Do you have any red flags or concerns? And should follow up by asking you: What’s the next step in the interview process? Do not consider this arrogant or presumptuous. Good candidates should be confident and welcome difficult questions. 11. Why should I hire you? A candidate can either completely make-up for any prior slips in the interview or can totally screw up in the last 5 minutes. Either way it is a good question to ask, especially for non-recruit candidates. However, I will caution that an interviewer needs to look at the entire interview and how the person did overall— not just the answer to this one question. This is a difficult question. YOU FOUND “THE ONE” Alright you have created the process, established the parameters, established your own “general thoughts” on interviewing, garnered consensus, written an outline with job specific and “fit” specific questions to interview recruit and non-recruit candidates, have created an evaluation form, and ….now you have narrowed it down to the candidate you want. What do you do? Prior to even beginning the interview process, you should have established with each and every candidate that came in for an interview, the following: (1) what is his or her current salary with bonus and the breakdown of salary vs. bonus, (2) what is their desired salary (most candidates will only consider a move for an increase), (3) are there any other perks they currently enjoy and would be giving up (are they going to be giving up stock options, year end bonus, paid parking, flex spending program, working one day from home, etc.). If you have this information you are ready to make an offer. After being in the business a while, I have some pretty strong opinions (which most recruiters would not agree with) on what is the right way to make an offer, and I don’t think if you are the employer making an offer directly or a recruiter making an offer on behalf of a client—that the process should change. I believe prior to an offer being made both sides understand there will be no negotiating. As a recruiter, I explain to the candidate that this is not my role. My role is to get you in front of the client, get you through the interview and get you an offer, but not to negotiate an offer. I tell my clients the same thing. Never in the course of a search, do I want my client to question why I am asking for the salary I am (it is simple—that is the magic number that will close the deal). I will advise candidates if their “magic number” is unreasonable, and I will counsel them to reconsider. The “magic” number I give my clients is typically what I will pre-close a candidate based on. I ask the candidate—if you received an offer of x, would you accept? If you can’t pre-close a candidate at this point (it is harder to do when you are the client making the offer directly, however, still doable) I would be skeptical. Make sure you have a candidate that wants an offer and undeniably wants the job. Make sure not to let your 2nd or 3rd choice candidates go until you have a signed acceptance offer and the candidate has communicated to you that he or she resigned their current position. Candidates should not need more than a few days or a weekend to consider an offer. Candidate’s that cannot commit at this point are not serious candidates and are likely to consider counter offers from their current employer, so if you can pre-close—DO. It will save you time and the potential loss of other good candidates (as time goes on, even recruit candidates will start looking at other opportunities). I never recommend an employer come in low, the other side come in high and meet in the middle. This is not a merger of two companies, in essence you are asking someone to join your family and it should be done in the most forthright and honest way possible—where both sides feel like they are winning instead of losing. What I’ve put together are general ideas and thoughts on effective hiring, from setting up the process to closing the deal. Remember your process is a direct reflection of your organization and your people, and if done right can also save you time and money. I hope this article proves useful. If you have any questions, or if you would like to obtain a copy of this article to distribute and use internally with your staff, please feel free to contact me (Janelle Lowe, 404.842.2800 or jlowe@cambridgprofessionals.com). Pay for Performance Program March of last year we rolled out our “Pay For Performance Program”. This program is based on our Quality Survey System implemented two years ago. The surveys are sent out at the end of each temporary assignment to measure how well Cambridge and our employees have performed. We calculate a statistical performance value for each survey response and review every response to insure client satisfaction! This system gives us a vehicle, which statistically measures each employee, for each assignment, and provides formalized feedback used to improve our services and respond to any issues that arise. responses to these surveys. Employees are eligible for a bonus if they meet or exceed expectations while on assignment. This bonus is then paid periodically (there is no additional cost to clients) by Cambridge based on a summary of all assignments and survey results over the bonus period. Though we do coach employees on performance issues, we do not share specific survey responses with them. There are many benefits to the program. The obvious one is a better and more motivated temporary employee. We believe connecting compensation to performance and giving our clients a voice in their evaluation will create better temporary employees. The following are the most recent recipients of PFP Bonuses: Abigail Burns Evelyn Bell Jane Mitchell Suzanne Davidson Akara Hatcher Fran Giampicolo Katherine Brock Tanya Forehand Jennifer Hubbard Shalonda Sumpter Steve Sauro Monique Martel Caroline Grant Phyllis Motes Dana Hayley Temp of the Month Program In addition to the Pay for Performance Bonus Program, Cambridge also recognizes a temp of the month. Similar to the Cambridge Chronicle, Cambridge publishes every other month the Cambridge Temperature. The Cambridge Temperature is the newsletter we publish for our temporary employees. The newsletter serves as a vehicle to keep our temporary employees informed on recent changes at Cambridge (including new referral programs, benefits, etc.), and provide educational and resource material (including, how to be a good temp, interviewing techniques, formatting resumes, writing cover letters, etc.). It also recognizes those temps that have proven themselves, to be exceptional employees to Cambridge through quality work, reliability, dedication and loyalty and recognizes those temps as “Temp of the Month”. The following temporaries have been recognized over the last few months. December January February Shireen Hormozdi, Attorney Fran Giampicollo, Legal Secretary Abigail Burns, Paralegal The “Pay For Performance Bonus ”Cambridge for our Professional Group temporary employees is based on our Center, client’s Suite 200, Atlanta, Georgia 30305 Four Piedmont 404.842.2800 or 1.800.563.6101 phone, 404.842.2805 fax Legal, Financial & General Office Staffing Services