DRAFT #Nov 06V4a SEXUAL HEALTH MATTERS FOR PEOPLE WITH LEARNING DISABILITIES TOO SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 1 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a Preface The area of sexuality and learning disabilities routinely presents services with complicated emotional, legal and ethical issues. The absence of adequate guidance and support increases risk for individual workers, the people they support and the organisations they work in. This policy relates to all organisations providing services to residents of Salford who have learning disabilities. Every organisation providing support to a person with learning disabilities can and should contribute to this important area of growth and development. All organisations providing education, health or social support to adults and children with learning disabilities must work together to ensure that individuals experience a clear and consistent approach as they grow and develop throughout their lives. This document has been developed as a collaborative project involving Community, Voluntary, Non-Statutory, and Statutory organisations from Salford. Representatives from the following organisations have supported the development of this document: Chatsworth High School Clinical Psychology, Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital Cornerstone Project (Barnardo’s & Salford Children’s Service Directorate) Eccles College Inscape House (Salford) Mackay-Gordon Centre, Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital New Directions (Adult Learning Difficulties Team) Oakwood High School Salford Being Heard Salford Family’s Project (Barnardo’s & Salford Children’s Service Directorate) Salford PCT Children’s Community Nursing Team Salford PCT Psycho-Sexual Health Services Salford PCT School Health Advisors Salford PCT Sexual Health Services The Grange This document supports staff working with people with learning disabilities in developing their social and personal relationships. It supports a shared philosophy, which underpins the rights, responsibilities and risks in relation to social and personal relationships for children and adults with learning disabilities, staff and organisations. It is not designed to deal with situations where staff, carers or people with learning disabilities feel that a person is at risk of abuse or exploitation. Existing adult and child protection policies and procedures should be adhered to in those circumstances. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 2 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY Contents Part 1 Introduction 1.1 Key Definitions 1.2 Policy statement 1.3 Social and personal relationships 1.4 Rights and responsibilities 1.5 Context for sexual health work 1.6 Lifelong education 1.7 Affirming sexuality – sexual expression and respect for diversity 1.8 Conclusion and vision Part 2 Strategic overview 2.1 Strategic objectives relating to sexual health 2.2 Values 2.3 Principles 2.4 Accessible Information & Services (Relate & 42nd Street) Action Tim/Geoff 2.5 Implementation Part 3 Key issues 3.1 Lifelong Support Action Tim/Geoff 3.2 Children Action Tim 3.3 Young People 3.4 Adults 3.5 Safeguarding 3.6 Consent 3.7 Privacy & Confidentiality Action Tim/Geoff 3.8 Legal Issues Action Amanda 3.9 Context for multi-disciplinary work 3.10 Personal and sexual relationships 3.11 Partnership working 3.12 Equal opportunities 3.13 Anti oppressive practice 3.14 Pornography & Sexually Explicit Material Action Tim/Geoff/Nigel 3.15 Staff attitudes 3.16 Training 3.17 Service standards, provision, assessment and care management Part 4 Appendices 4.1 Further Help/Contacts Action Tim/Geoff Glossary Action Tim/Geoff 4.2 References 4.3 Related Policies & Procedures 4.4 Easy Read Version Action Nigel SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 3 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a Part 1 Introduction People with learning disabilities have the same rights and responsibilities as everyone else, but may need help with various parts of their lives. Some people may need help to understand their rights and responsibilities regarding social and personal relationships. Evidence suggests that both adults and children with learning disabilities are at an increased risk of abuse or neglect. Sometimes there is a difficult balance to achieve between the promotion of an individuals rights and safeguarding them from abuse. For an individual to achieve their own rights they need to have key skills; knowledge of their rights and responsibilities; and awareness of risks. Services have a responsibility to empower people with learning disabilities to achieve their rights. Services must therefore understand the needs of people with learning disabilities in relation to sexual identity and the potential risks inherent in meeting these needs. Services should promote rights by providing accessible information and opportunities to grow and develop reflecting individuals changing needs. Where people are able to make their own decisions they should be supported by services in this. For people who need more support, services need to understand that individuals rights and needs. This policy concerns rights, responsibilities and risks in relation to social and personal relationships for people with learning disabilities, their carers/relatives, staff and organisations. It is intended that this policy will benefit people with learning disabilities by helping staff, parents and carers to understand the part they play in enabling people to grow and develop to achieve their rights and exercise their responsibilities. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 4 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 1.1 Key Definitions within this policy The terms ‘learning disability’ and ‘learning difficulty’ are often used interchangeably. As the term learning difficulty is used in the Education Act 1996 to include dyslexia and other forms of special learning needs which are not learning disability as defined in the White Paper Valuing People, the term learning disability will be used to avoid confusion. "Learning disability - includes the presence of a significantly reduced ability to understand new and complex information, to learn new skills (impaired intelligence), with; a reduced ability to cope independently (impaired social functioning); which started before childhood with a lasting effect on development." (Valuing People: 2001) Sexuality encompasses sexual health but sexual health does not automatically encompass issues of sexuality. Sexual health is a term often used in association with conditions like HIV/AIDS or sexually transmitted infections, whereas sexuality is something shaped by, for example, environment, health, disability and self-concept. Conversely, sexual ill health would be defined as an inability to express sexuality that is consistent with individual preferences as a result of physical, emotional, social or psychological difficulties. Sexuality - an individual’s self concept, shaped by their personality and expressed as sexual feelings, attitudes, beliefs and behaviours, expressed through heterosexual, homosexual, bisexual, or transsexual orientation. (Sexuality and sexual health in nursing practice: 2000) Sexual Health - the physical, emotional, psychological, social and cultural well-being of a person’s sexual identity, and the capacity and freedom to enjoy and express sexuality without exploitation, oppression, physical or emotional harm. (Sexuality and sexual health in nursing practice: 2000) SRE (Sex and Relationships Education) - learning about sex, sexuality, sexual health and relationships. It is important to think of it as an ongoing process. Through SRE, children, young people and adults gain accurate information and knowledge; develop skills and positive values, which influence their decision-making, opinions, relations and behaviour throughout life. (McKenna: 2005) SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 5 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 1.2 Policy Statement This policy concerns rights, responsibilities and risks in relation to social and personal relationships for people with learning disabilities. It is intended that this policy will benefit people with learning disabilities by helping staff, parents and carers to understand the part they play in enabling people to grow and develop to achieve their rights and exercise their responsibilities. The idea of having a policy about our own social and personal relationships would be unacceptable to all of us. These relationships are a very important and private part of our lives. However, we all have rights and responsibilities in terms of how we conduct our social and personal relationships and we all act within some constraints including being subject to current legislation. People with learning disabilities have the same rights and responsibilities as everyone else. They may however also need support with various parts of their lives including developing social and personal relationships and in understanding their rights and responsibilities. This may necessarily require support from two or more different organisations giving rise to the need for a consistent approach. This policy relates to all organisations providing services to residents of Salford who have learning disabilities. Every organisation providing support to a person with learning disabilities can and should contribute to this important area of growth and development. All organisations providing education, health or social support to adults and children with learning disabilities must work together to ensure that individuals experience a consistent approach as they grow and develop throughout their lives. Staff, parents and carers may find themselves supporting people with learning disabilities with sensitive issues and dilemmas regarding their relationships where there are no easy answers. They will equally be concerned with balancing the rights of people with learning disabilities to develop social and personal relationships whilst protecting individuals who might be at risk of abuse and exploitation. This document endeavours to describe the rights, responsibilities and risks in relation to social and personal relationships for people with learning disabilities, their carers/relatives, staff and organisations. It is not designed to deal with situations where staff, carers or people with learning disabilities feel a person with learning disabilities is at risk of being abused of exploited. In those circumstances adult/child protection policies/procedures should be used. It is intended that this policy will benefit staff, people with learning disabilities and their carers by meeting their mutual interests. From the outset it is important to note that many people with learning disabilities will not require intervention or response from staff concerning their sexual health. However all people with learning disabilities and staff will benefit from guidelines that outline roles and responsibilities in this area. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 6 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 1.3 Social and Personal Relationships We all have a need for social and personal relationships; the strength of that need and the way in which it is expressed will be different for each person. Whilst someone with a learning disability may have frequent contact with people such as family members, they may not be able to develop other relationships. This might be due to them having restricted choices or opportunities, parental attitudes, lack of privacy and high support needs. As with other people it is important for people with learning disabilities to be able to develop a range and variety of relationships. These relationships may therefore include social relationships with acquaintances and more permanent friendships. They may include a range of sexual relationships including same sex relationships. They may include marriage or living with a partner. 1.4 Rights and Responsibilities People with learning disabilities have the same rights to freedom and choice in what they do within the bounds of their society and its law as everyone else. As a first principle, people with learning disabilities should be treated as having equal rights. Issues of consent, mental incapacity and the Mental Health Act 1983 can be applied to all citizens. Implicit in this statement is that everyone has a responsibility to respect the rights of others to freedom and choice. Staff must respect these rights whilst ensuring that a person with learning disabilities is not open to abuse or exploitation. The following is a set of guiding principles, to help solve difficult problems that have come up for staff, service providers and people with learning disabilities. People with learning disabilities have the following rights: Access to guidance, which will assist them in their social, personal and sexual development. Access to support and advice from people who are competent to provide it The right to be assisted in pursuing the type of social and personal relationships they want. The opportunity to develop close, intimate and loving relationships and the privacy that this demands. To have appropriate support and protection from exploitation, abuse and degrading treatment. To have information about himself/herself kept confidential. To have accessible information/explanation in order to make an informed choice. To have an advocate, someone to speak on his/her behalf if wanted. To be treated with respect, consideration and sensitivity. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 7 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a To be given support and assistance to make a complaint if they feel their rights have not been upheld. People with learning disabilities have the following responsibilities To receive advice and information appropriate to their needs To stay within the law as any other citizen. To respect the rights of others. To treat others with respect, consideration and sensitivity. Carers/Relatives (including paid carers) have the following rights: To be clear about their role and the support available to them To be informed and consulted if the adult with learning disabilities has clearly expressed this as their wish. To make representation on behalf of the adult with learning disabilities and themselves. To be treated with respect, consideration and sensitivity. To advice and support from relevant agencies. Not be held responsible for the action of the adult with learning disabilities. To be given support and assistance to make a complaint if their rights/expectations or the rights of the adult with learning disabilities have not been upheld. Carers/Relatives have the following responsibilities: To work constructively with others involved in supporting the adult with learning disabilities as agreed in the care plan or any other agreement. To treat their relative/adult with learning disabilities with respect and consideration. To make distinction between what is in the best interest of their relative/person with a learning disability and what is in their own best interest. To offer a safe and supportive environment which provides appropriate opportunities for risk taking. To keep the services supporting them informed where appropriate. To support the adult with learning disabilities in seeking information and advice where appropriate. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 8 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a Staff and managers have the following rights: To be given relevant information, advice, support supervision, training from someone who is appropriately skilled and conversant policy on personal and social relationships. To be treated with respect, consideration and sensitivity. To be protected from unfair allegations and adverse publicity supported when allegations are made by means of policies procedures. and with and and Staff and managers have the following responsibilities: To work constructively with others within policies and procedures to support people with learning disabilities in pursuing and social relationships. To report any incidents of abuse, neglect or poor practice in line with their employers’ adult/child protection procedures. To make appropriate use of supervision and information given. To seek information and advice. To support the adult with learning disabilities, and provide them with relevant and appropriate information. To ensure that the adult with learning disabilities is kept informed and treated with respect and dignity in a non-abusive environment. To ensure that the law is adhered to and any necessary clarification sought. To make decisions appropriate to their status in the organisation. To actively promote best practice according to the value base, policy and guidelines of the service. To participate in on-going training to help achieve these responsibilities and aims. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 9 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 1.5 CONTEXT FOR SEXUAL HEALTH WORK Issues of sex, sexuality and personal relationships have often been treated as medical issues to be dealt with, for example, by Learning Disability Nurses and Paediatricians. Sex education has largely been dealt with, within Special Schools where the quality and quantity has varied across Salford. There has been little regard for the need for lifelong learning that would enable adult services to continue this work. 1.6 LIFELONG EDUCATION TP 1.7 AFFIRMING SEXUALITY – SEXUAL EXPRESSION & RESPECT FOR DIVERSITY It is important to understand the cultural context within which a person lives. This policy affirms the rights of people to their expression of emotions and sexuality. In providing support to do this the impact of cultural norms has to be taken into account. Each person negotiates these individually and It cannot be assumed that people from particular diverse backgound subscribe to a particular set of norms or expectations. However to provide support it is important to understand the cultural norms that influence people. 1.8 CONCLUSION Issues of sexual health and sexuality should always have been a dimension of multi-disciplinary work across all service areas. The requirements of legislation and best practice make it essential for us to develop a comprehensive framework within which sexual health needs of users can be considered. To do this requires us to adopt a clear policy, a comprehensive strategy to implement this and guidelines to inform practice in each service area. The policy and strategy are necessary to create the culture in which positive sexual health work can take place steered by the targets of the “Nation Strategy for Sexual Health and HIV” (DoH 2001), “Valuing People” (DoH 2001) and “National Teenage Pregnancy Strategy” (DoH 1999), Salford PCT Sexual Health Strategy (2006) Prepared by: Geoff Holliday Service Development Manager Sexual Health Services Salford PCT Tim Plant Learning Disabilities Nurse Children’s Services Salford PCT SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 10 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a Nigel Johnson Quality Development Manager New Directions Joint Learning Difficulty Service Salford City Council/Salford PCT October 2006 SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 11 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a This document is based upon the following source material: Cheshire County Council Social Services “Sexual Health Policy & Strategy to Meet HIV Prevention Objectives of Health of The Nation Report” (1994) British Institute of Learning Disabilities: “Policy and Good Practice Guidelines for Staff Working with People with Learning Disabilities” (2000) Good Practice Guidelines on Sexuality “Relationships and HIV/Target Training and Resources Group on Sexuality HIV and Aids for people working with People with Learning Disabilities in Wandsworth” Sex, Sexuality and People with Learning Disabilities Policy and Guidelines for Staff, Parents and Carers in Bradford SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 12 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a Part 2: STRATEGIC OVERVIEW 2.1 SEXUAL HEALTH: IMPLEMENTING STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES The PCT and partner organisations are supporting the delivery of the Sexual Health Strategy and Teenage Pregnancy Strategy specifically for people who have a learning disability. The Salford PCT Sexual Health Strategy (2006) sets out the following: Develop and implement a policy on sexual health, sexuality and personal relationships. This will be an umbrella policy for all agencies within Salford across child and adult services. Identify the need of learning disabled people for life long sex and relationships education programmes. (This may include formal and informal work delivered in a variety of settings, e.g. PHSE delivered in schools or group-work with adults supporting relationships.) Identify and meet the training needs of: o parents and carers of learning disabled children/adults o professionals/workers in learning disabilities services o professionals/workers in sexual health services, leading to the development of a multi-disciplinary training strategy Re-design existing health promotion materials to be accessible for people who have learning disabilities and support their wider use. Support the re-design of sexual health services to meet the needs of learning disabled people. Identify and address the factors that contribute to poor sexual health as experienced by people who have a learning disability. Improved health outcomes will include: o Increasing uptake of cervical screening o Increasing life opportunities o Reducing unwanted pregnancies o Reducing sexually transmitted infections o Improving poor contraceptive outcomes o Reducing legally and ethically questionable sterilisation o Addressing a fundamental health inequality SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 13 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 2.2.1 VALUES The values that guide work with people with learning disabilities Legal and civil Rights: People with learning disabilities have the right to a decent education, to grow up to vote, to marry and have a family, and to express their opinions, with help and support to do so when necessary. All public services will treat people with learning disabilities as individuals with respect for their dignity, and challenge discrimination on all grounds including disability. People with learning disabilities will also receive the full protection of the law when necessary. Independence: While people’s individual needs will differ, the starting presumption should be one independence, rather than dependence, with public services providing the support needed to maximise this. Independence in this does mean doing everything unaided. Choice: We believe that everyone should be able to make choices. This includes with severe and profound disabilities, who with the right help and support, can make important choices and express preferences about their day-to-day lives. Inclusion: Inclusion means enabling people with learning disabilities to do those ordinary things, make use of mainstream services and be fully included in the local community. (Valuing People: A New Strategy for Learning Disability for the 21st Century. (2001) The values guide work in the area of sexuality and learning disability Acceptance, respect and support for individuals’ sexual expression and identity, provided that neither the individual nor others are coerced or adversely affected by someone’s choice of sexual expression. The understanding that people who have learning disabilities need knowledge and opportunity to develop skills to make healthier choices that will protect them in the broadest sense. These values must work within multi-agency partnerships Equal Opportunities frameworks. All people who have learning disabilities and providers need to have an understanding of the law relating to sexual behaviour, and a right to protection from abuse. In order to make these values a standard of practice for our Partnership Organisations and to apply them in relation to services we provide and those purchased from the private and voluntary sector, an integrated strategy needs to be implemented. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 14 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 2.3 PRINCIPLES The key points of this policy are: Services To ensure that the sexual health needs of all people who have learning disabilities as an integral part of planning services, and of assessment and care management. Guidelines To disseminate the values base to address working practice in each service area, guidance will need to be developed. This may require guidance in support of a group or individuals development. Training and Support To enable service providers to meet these needs and to feel supported by the policy and strategy. Working with Parents and Carers To successfully implement the policy, full consideration must be given to working in partnership with carers to meet the needs of individuals. Safeguarding Safeguarding procedures relating to sexual abuse are a vital dimension of all our work in supporting and protecting people who have learning disabilities. Legal and Ethical Issues The policy provides a framework within which workers can safely address difficult legal and ethical issues. a) This policy recognises that sex and sexuality are a positive aspect of development for all human beings, and that people who use our services should be guaranteed the relevant advice and support to promote their physical and emotional health and well being. b) In applying the policy, consideration has to be given to the dilemma, which may occur between illegal activity and the need to provide advice on sexual matters, which may protect individuals from greater physical harm (e.g. sexually transmitted infections including HIV). c) Our guiding principle has to distinguish between relationships, which are entered into on an informed equal basis, and relationships that are characterised by abuse of power or status. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 15 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 3. KEY ISSUES Part 3 Key issues 3.18 Sex Education Underpinning knowledge People should have full rights and responsibilities as regards their personal relationship and sexuality including the right to: Receive structured education about human development including sexuality and to be helped to develop a positive self-image of themselves. Learn to communicate about sexuality and to develop the appropriate language (including non-verbal) and the vocabulary to do so. The right to be given information, advice and guidelines on inappropriate sexual behaviour that might be socially, culturally or legally unacceptable; To be taught about sexual exploitation, i.e. to be aware of situations when they are at risk of exploitation or of exploiting others. Such teaching or training should include both information and skill development. The right to information about help with contraception and safer sex. This should be done in such a way as not to impose over-protective attitudes. 5.6.1 Key Principles It is important that care workers are aware of the law, which particularly affects people who have learning disabilities with learning disabilities. It should be recognised that this is a sensitive area for all and that we have to avoid our personal, cultural, ethical, moral and/or religious views conflicting with the interests of others. It is impossible to be entirely neutral when discussing or teaching value-laden topics, but good practice dictates that every effort should be made to minimise the effects of personal attitudes. There should be no expectation that a staff member shall be required to change his or her own cultural, ethical, moral and/or religious codes. However, where these prevent a staff member from being directly involved in aspects of the agreed programme, they would still be expected to offer their support to other staff dealing with these issues. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 16 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a Staff need to be aware that some people may find sex education material sexually stimulating. 5.6.2 Training Staff should receive training around sexuality issues. Staff who have a role in delivering sex education should receive additional specific training. If concerns remain – Discuss with your Line Manager or at the MultiDisciplinary Planning Meeting. 3.19 Children 3.20 Young People 3.21 Adults 3.22 Safeguarding All children are deemed to be vulnerable and in need of protection should they be abused in any way. Child protection procedures are a tried and tested part of service provision and apply equally to children with learning difficulties as any other child. Adult Protection Procedures are in place to safe guard vulnerable adults who do not have the mental capacity to protect themselves from harm. Adults with severe learning difficulties are by their nature vulnerable to abuse from others and can be protected under the Multi-agency Adult Protection Procedures. Abuse can occur in any setting either a service based provision or within the individual’s own home. Abuse can be physical, sexual, psychological, financial, neglect, discrimination or institutional. There are no hard and fast boundaries to these categories of abuse and situations may involve more than one aspect of abuse. Sexual abuse includes any forced or coerced sexual activity. It also includes some sexual activity which the individual cannot legally give consent. In acknowledging that people with learning disabilities have the right to sexual expression, protection needs to take on a wider focus, in the context of safeguarding against the risks of sexually transmitted infections, unwanted pregnancies and HIV infection. People who have learning disabilities need access to a whole range of accessible sexual health information, geared to their own needs and abilities. 3.23 Consent Underpinning knowledge (Decision making, by, with and for people with learning disabilities) In relation to people over the age of 18 (16 for medical treatment) the law assumes that people have the mental capacity to make their own decisions and have the capacity to consent. The Law Commission has stated that SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 17 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a people should b e enabled and encouraged to take for themselves those decisions which they are able to take. There are certain circumstances when the right of an adult to make his or her own decision is taken away. This is when the adult is considered not to have sufficient understanding to make the decision and is regarded as lacking legal capacity. Under the Sexual Offences legislation there is no interest in an individual’s capacity if s/he is ‘a defective’ or has a ‘severe mental handicap’, because, if that condition exists, his/her consent is legally invalid. For other people with a learning disability, the general restrictions on sexual activity in relation to age and consent apply as they do to all other people. An adult cannot be deemed incompetent to make a decision about one part of their life, simply because they have been incompetent in other areas. Each decision regarding capacity can only relate to that particular decision-making area. Many people with learning disabilities have never experienced full choice and control over their lives. The law, the practice of service organisations, and public opinion have in the past sometimes endorsed the idea that people with learning disabilities are not able to make decisions for themselves and need protecting for their own good. This is no longer considered appropriate. There is further information on the law as it affects people with learning disabilities and those labelled as being ‘defective’ or ‘severely mentally handicapped’ as defined in the Sexual Offences Act 1956 and 1967 regarding their sexual and personal relationships in Section 1 of the guidance. On a practical level, standard consent forms are invalid for people with learning disabilities. They are unlikely to reflect the depth of exploration required for ascertaining consent. If concerns regarding the issue of consent to sexual relationships remain, you may wish to consider the following: Advocacy services A risk assessment; A multidisciplinary discussion concerning the issue, and/or Referral to an advisory group within the agency; Referral to an expert outside the agency. Flow Chart, etc. The only interests that you should take into account when deciding on a particular course of action is the person’s best interest. It is not lawful to balance these interests against the interests of their family, professionals or the interests of the other people living with the individual. Key Principles Where two people with learning disabilities develop a sexual relationship and appear to be happy with it and there is no evidence of exploitation, many professionals would consider that it would not be reasonable to interrupt the relationship, despite the fact that it may be difficult to establish the capacity to consent. Nevertheless this is a difficult decision in which those involved with the couple need to consider the risks to the individuals as well as their rights. Remember that there are only special legal rules in relation to sexual SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 18 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a relationships/activity where the person in question is a ‘defective’ or has a ‘severe mental handicap’ under the 1956 and 1967 Sexual Offences Act. Those involved with the people should: Document their decisions carefully; Include those closest to the individual, who are familiar with the individual’s usual pattern of communication (not just a medical practitioner), including an independent advocate; Allow sufficient time, in an appropriate location for an assessment to take place (one assessment meeting may well not be enough); Include all available and relevant information; The decisions should: Be justifiable by those who make the assessment; Be open to a simple system of challenge. The person’s potential to make a decision for themselves should be maximised and this includes effective language and communication skills by those trying to ascertain whether the individual can make the decision. This is a crucial point for people with learning disabilities, some of whom do not use speech and many of whom are easily excluded from decisionmaking by complicated language and concepts. All practical steps to communicate with, and involve, people must be used and include: The use of appropriate words, pictures and symbols; Involving people skilled in using these techniques; Involving people close to the individual and familiar with their ways of communicating; A suitable environment and enough time for the communication to take place. Where there are concerns about people with learning disabilities who may be engaged in abusive relationships, there are a number of issues, which should be considered. These include for example: Whether there is a power imbalance between the two people; Whether tangible inducements have been used by one person; Whether, in the case of heterosexual relationships, the people involved know about the risk of pregnancy; Whether both partners know about safer sex and are able to use this knowledge. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 19 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a The greatest possible care must be given to establishing (full) consent to a sexual relationship for a person with learning disabilities, not only because that reflects what is in their best interest, but also because it minimises any likely legal intervention. However, staff should be cautious of using the duty of care (see Section 1) to deny people choice. 5.2.4 Training An understanding about consent issues should be included in the general training provided for staff, especially in the induction pack. If concerns remain If concerns regarding the issue of consent to sexual relationships remain, you may wish to consider the following: A risk assessment; A multidisciplinary discussion concerning the issue, and/or Referral to an advisory group within the agency; Referral to an expert outside the agency. Flow Chart, etc. 3.24 Confidentiality People with learning disabilities, who need help with issues of sex and sexuality, have a right to expect that the confidentiality and sensitivity of the matter be respected. At the same time, they, as well as staff, need to understand that some information passed in confidence, relating to situations of risk, will need to be shared with others (e.g. the line manager). The sexual health strategy requires reviews and care planning procedures to address the sexual health and development needs of people who use our services. The primary aim is to empower individuals (and also ensure protection, where necessary). This principle should basically direct decisions about which information needs to be shared. Detailed confidential information should not be revealed and discussed at a review a matter of routine. If there are real concerns, about matters of risk or protection, they should be discussed with the individual beforehand, and, if necessary, referred to the line manager, to decide how the matter should be handled 3.25 Legal Issues If concerns remain Seek legal advice from your agency’s legal section. 3.26 Context for multi-disciplinary work 3.27 Personal and sexual relationships Underpinning knowledge Staff need to be aware of the law, policy and good practice that governs their work. They need to know why relationships are important to people as well as the reasons for encouraging and developing these. Whilst some individuals will need support in developing and maintaining relationships, others will not. It is the individual’s perception of their sexuality, which is important and the SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 20 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a manner in which they express this within a social situation. This expression can vary and change according to relationships and contexts. Staff should be aware of the concept of self-image and identity. Staff should actively encourage people to take an interest in, and express feelings about, themselves. 5.3.1 Key Principles Workers must take responsibility for their own, ongoing training needs and contribute to their organisations continued development. Work with people regarding their personal and sexual relationships must be within the boundaries of confidentiality and privacy. Workers’ behaviour should be consistent and non-exploitative. Workers will need to be aware of their own beliefs and values and how these may impact on their own behaviour. It is important to be aware of the assumptions, which surround sex and sexuality, and for staff to understand the reasons why it is important not to make assumptions about individuals. Individuals should be encouraged to recognise their own rights and responsibilities. Staff should be aware of the sources of support and guidance in relation to working with people in respect of their personal and sexual relationships. Staff should be made aware of the action to take should they encounter situations in which they feel unable to cope. 5.3.2 Training Training based on Ordinary Life Principles and Person Centred Approaches usually includes consideration of an individual’s self image and identity. Although issues of sexuality may not be explicitly addressed, such issues have relevant connections. If concerns remain Where staff has concerns about the support they receive, they should contact their line manager or other appropriate person (someone you feel comfortable with – this may be another manager within the department, staff counsellor, trade union representative or your professional body). If concerns remain – Discuss with your Line Manager 3.28 Partnership working 3.29 Equal opportunities Underpinning knowledge It is commonly recognised that there are groups of people in our society that are socially excluded groups. These groups of people may be denied access to facilities, services and employment opportunities. Members from socially SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 21 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a excluded groups may have very individual needs in the area of personal and social relationships and care must be taken to ensure equity of service provision in addressing the individual’s need. 5.11.1 Key Principles Common prejudice and discrimination have been identified in the following areas: Race/ethnic origin. Creed. Age. Gender. Martial Status. Class. Sexual orientation. Health. Disability. Before undertaking work with any individual, staff should familiarise themselves with issues around discrimination and individual needs of the person. 5.11.2 Training All agencies should have in place policies regarding the following: Anti-oppressive practice. Anti-discrimination issues. Equal opportunities. All staff should be provided with training in respect of the above. If concerns remain – Where staff feel that equal opportunities are not an integral part of service delivery they should discuss these concerns with their Line Manager or another appropriate person (someone you feel comfortable with – this may be another Manager within the Department, or your professional body). 3.30 Anti oppressive practice Services use the “social model of disability” and address the barriers both practical and attitudinal that prevent people exercising their rights and responsibilities. 3.31 Staff attitudes In the past, sexual activity amongst people with learning disabilities has been responded to inconsistently, depending on the attitudes of SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 22 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a individual staff members. Protection, for example, has tended to take the form of attempts to deny or condemn sexual activity. If staff deny or ignore a person’s wish for sexual activity, or the development of a relationship, the person using the service is likely to be denied access to advice, knowledge and skills that are essential to making an informed choice (for example on issues of safer sex). Staff will also need to be aware of the need for clear boundaries where personal contact may be misinterpreted and cause confusion. Staff will then be vulnerable, and open to criticism. If sexual activity is condemned, the person using the service is given a negative message about sexual expression. This will not promote a climate in which sexual health education programmes can be effective. It also does nothing to prevent the behaviour recurring, even though this may be inappropriate. It may even give rise to further inappropriate or challenging behaviour, of a sexual nature. Staff therefore, need to acknowledge the sexuality of people with learning disabilities, by: Following the values and principles within the “Sex and Sexuality” policy. Being aware of the strategy adopted by the partnership organisations towards sexual health. Developing an awareness of their own attitudes, and how these influence people who have learning disabilities and decision-making processes. Giving appropriate and consistent cues to people who use our services, and using language and that is non-discriminatory and non-judgemental. 3.32 Training 3.33 PARTNERSHIP WITH PARENTS AND CARERS Underpinning knowledge The majority of people with learning disabilities continue to live with parents or other close family carers and the influence and importance of those relationships cannot be underestimated. It is also important to recognise the cultural diversity of individuals and their families, which may influence decision-making and values and attitudes. Key Principles It is important to recognise that parents and carers of people with learning disabilities have no legal say in what their adult relative does. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 23 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a The law does not recognise the ability of anyone to give consent on behalf of another person. However, it must be recognised that parents and carers often have an influence, a sense of responsibility, and may have extreme difficulty coming to terms with their relative’s approach to their personal relationships and their sexuality. It would be important to ensure that they are part of a process to decide the capacity to consent, if in question, of their relative. People involved with people with learning disabilities need to be realistic and accept that family relationships are unique in every situation. It is preferable to initiate contact with carers rather than respond to anxieties on a crisis basis. Parents/carers should only participate in discussions about personal and sexual relationships where the individual concerned has given permission to do so. This should only be undertaken in private with the individual’s confidante, key worker or advocate. There may be times when the person cannot give informed permission or agreement. It is suggested that when people who have learning disabilities join any service (day centres, residential accommodation, etc.) a leaflet should be given to them and parent/carers. This would clearly set out the service’s position and policies on a range of issues, which, of course, would include the development of social and personal relationships. This should include an explanation of the rights of the individuals and a philosophy statement from the service. Parents/carers should be offered opportunities to comment and be involved in the development of education/information about personal and social relationships for people with learning disabilities. Information about such areas should be available to parents/carers before their relative starts to receive a service. Training All staff need to be aware of the potential tension between the various people involved in the care of a person with learning disabilities. This awareness should be included in an induction pack and training should be on going. If concerns remain A service may wish to develop an explicit framework, which sets out clearly what the different relationships are between the service and the parents/carers and the service and the service user. It is important to achieve a balance between parental/carer involvement whilst ensuring the needs of the person with learning disabilities are also met. For example, your service may decide that parents have the right to information but people who have learning disabilities have the rights to SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 24 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a confidentiality. information. This may need to be clearly stated in the service It is important to ensure that parents and carers are aware of the sexual health policy, and involved in discussions. Vehicles for this could include: Leaflets explaining the Partnership organisation’s commitment to the sexual health needs of people who use our service. Including carers, and possibly some people who use our services, on staff training events. Meetings to discuss the issues. Discussion within individual assessments and reviews. The differing attitudes of carers towards sexuality need to be recognised and handled sensitively. At the same time, the rights, needs and views of the person with learning disabilities must be the overriding consideration. Line managers should be consulted where there is an unresolved conflict of opinion, which will have implications for the service to be delivered. 3.34 Service standards, provision, assessment and care management Underpinning knowledge Authorities agreeing a policy on Personal and Social Relationships will not, in itself, ensure that people with learning disabilities are effectively supported in those relationships. As with all policies, it is essential that this be incorporated into Service Specifications and Contracts. 6.1 Key Principles Once a Policy is agreed, all providers of services must be made aware of the policy and its contents. It is advised that all Providers of Services are able to access training. All Service Specifications, Contracts and Service Level Agreements should specify that compliance with the Policy is good practice. Each Service should have a nominated member of staff who takes the lead responsibility for ensuring the Policy is implemented. Contract monitoring arrangements should ensure that the Policy is implemented and that Managers and staff are aware of it. Failure to SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 25 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 6.2 comply should be addressed within the Authorities’ usual contracting procedure. Care Managers should ensure that the Policy is implemented in relation to individuals they are responsible for. Any perceived failure to comply should be reported to the appropriate contracting forum in line with the Authorities’ normal procedure. All services should include guidance on relationships and expectations about behaviours in the Information Leaflet for People who have learning disabilities and their carers so that these are clear. Training Should be part of the Induction Training for new staff. If concerns remain Discuss with the local Registration and Inspection Unit or Social Services Health Authority Contracts Section. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 26 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 5.2.2 12 Key Points on Consent (medical treatment): The Law in England When do health professionals need consent from persons? 1. Before you examine, treat or care for competent adult persons you must obtain their consent. 2. People are always assumed to be competent unless demonstrated otherwise. If you have doubts about their competence, three question need to be considered: “Is the person able to understand what is being told to them?” “Does the person believe what is being said to them?” “Does the person have the ability to weigh up the options and potential outcomes?” Unexpected decisions do not prove the person is incompetent, but it may indicate a need for further information or investigation. 3. Persons may be competent to make some health care decision, event if they are not competent to make others. 4. Giving and obtaining consent is usually a process, not a one-off event. Persons can change their minds and withdraw consent at any time. If there is any doubt, you should always check that the individual still consents to your caring for or treating them. Can children give consent for themselves? 5. Before examining, treating or caring for a child, you must also seek consent. Young people aged 16 and 17 are presumed to have the competence to give consent for themselves. Younger children who understand fully what is involved in the proposed procedure can also give consent (although their parents will ideally be involved). In other cases, someone with parental responsibility must give consent on the child’s behalf, unless they cannot be reached in an emergency. If a competent child consents to treatment, a parent cannot over-ride that consent. Legally, a parent can consent if a competent child refuses, but it is likely that taking such a serious step will be rare. Who is the right person to seek consent? 6. It is always best for the person actually treating the patient to seek the patient’s consent. However, you may seek consent on behalf of colleagues if you are capable of performing the procedure in question, or if you have been specially trained to seek consent for that procedure. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 27 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a What information should be provided? 7. Persons need sufficient information before they can decide whether to give their consent; for example information about the benefits and risks of the proposed treatment and alternative treatments. If the patient is not offered as much information as they reasonably need to make their decision, and in a form they can understand their consent my not be valid. 8. Consent must be given voluntarily; not under any form of duress or undue influence from health professionals, family or friends. Does it matter how the patient gives consent? 9. No; consent can be written, oral or non-verbal. A signature on a consent form does not itself prove the consent is valid – the point of the form is to record the patient’s decision, and also increasingly the decision, and also increasingly the discussions that have taken place. Your Trust or organisation may have a policy setting out when you need to obtain written consent. Refusal of treatment 10. Competent adult persons are entitled to refuse treatment, even when it would clearly benefit their health. The only exception to this rule is where the treatment is for a mental disorder and the patient is detained under the Mental Health Act 1983. A competent pregnant woman may refuse any treatment, even if this would be detrimental to the foetus. People who are not competent to give consent 11. No one can give consent on behalf of an incompetent* adult. However, you may still treat such a patient if the treatment would be in their best interests. “Best interests” go wider than best medical interests, to include factors such as the wishes and beliefs of the patient when competent, their current wishes, their general well being and their spiritual and religious welfare. People close to the patient may be able to give you information on some of these factors. Where the patient has never been competent, relatives, carers and friends may be best placed to advise on the patient’s needs and preferences. 12. If an incompetent patient has clearly indicated in the past, while competent, that they would refuse treatment in certain circumstances (an “advance refusal”) and those circumstances arise, you must abide by that refusal. (Department of Health (2001) SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 28 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 5.8 PORNOGRAPHY AND SEXUALLY EXPLICIT MATERIAL Underpinning knowledge Pornography and sexually explicit materials may include newspapers, mail order catalogues, magazines, books, videos, pictures and specialist telephone services. Some of this kind of material is sometimes referred to as ‘soft porn’ or ‘top shelf’ and is legally available to people, others are generally available. Whatever an individual member of staff’s feelings about such material it is important to distinguish it from materials which would breach the Obscene Publications Act. These materials would, for example, feature illegal sexual activities, often involving children, animals or torture. It is illegal to purchase or own these sorts of materials. It is also an offence to obtain such material for others. 5.8.1 Key Principles While staff may be involved with a Service User who wishes to access such material, they also have a responsibility to explain issues of privacy in regard to its use, the offence it may cause to others, and the legal context of such material (e.g. not showing it to minors). Staff must not promote or initiate the introduction of pornography and sexually explicit material to an adult with learning disability. Services should ensure that people who wish to access or purchase pornography and sexually explicit material do so discreetly and confine its use to within the privacy of their own rooms. 5.8.2 Training As part of Induction Training, all staff should receive input that encourages them to explore their personal values and attitudes in respect to issues of sexuality and the potential tensions between these and effective professional practice. NB: There appears to be no published research regarding the use and effects of pornography and sexually explicit material by and on people with learning disabilities. Most published research focuses on the sex offender population, and therefore does not deal with people who have learning disabilities who use such material and do not commit sexual offences. If concerns remain – If staff are unclear or concerned about the possible consequences of a Service User accessing pornography and sexually explicit material, a multi-disciplinary Risk Assessment should be undertaken. Factors to be considered in such a Risk Assessment would include: SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 29 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a The People who have learning disabilities’ existing sexual values, attitudes and knowledge, including their capacity to realise such material may well cause offence to others. Their capacity to comprehend the ‘fantasy’ element often present in such material. Whether they previously or presently display sexually inappropriate or abuse towards others. Their capacity, and the Service’s support, to ensure such material is used and kept privately. It may be helpful for staff to involve a specialist, such as a clinical psychologist, in the assessment of such factors. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 30 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 5.12 TRAINING The strategy clearly outlines the training needs for all staff regarding the “Sex and Sexuality” Policy, and the development of sexual health work. This ranges from basic awareness raising for all staff, to more in-depth training for those looking to develop sexual health programmes for people who use our services. Staff in the learning disabilities field need access to specific materials geared to the great variety of abilities and needs of the people who use the service. Programmes may need to be run individually or in small group settings. The framework for training support and supervision is contained within the strategy for sexual health. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 31 DRAFT #Nov 06V4a 5.13 CONFIDENTIALITY . Sexual health needs are an integral part of overall health and wellbeing. The Standard Assessment forms section regarding Health and Emotional well-being is the place to consider this. In providing services great care should be taken by staff to be sensitive and responsive to arrangements and suggestions, which may impinge on relationships and sexuality. (It is possible that the impact may not be immediately obvious.) Staff need to think creatively in addressing individual needs, e.g. in the provision of equipment which may enhance quality of life in general but may, if not explored sensitively, have an adverse affect on the sexual health or relationship of the service user and partner. Intimate personal care tasks should of course be dealt with very sensitively. Staff need to recognise that intimate personal care tasks, e.g. washing, toileting, etc, may be upsetting for close relatives particularly partners who may feel unhappy that such tasks are sometimes undertaken by others. Staff should consider the potential impact on the emotional and personal relationships of the service user, which may not be obvious or spoken about. Conclusion This document developed as a collaborative project provides a platform for consistent multi-agency working for all people with learning disabilities. It will not provide definitive solutions and answers to all the situations and questions you may have concerning this work. It will provide a framework within which the right questions may be asked and guidance toward a solution. Each situation will be different and everyone you work with is an individual. This document will help to protect and enrich the lives of people who have a learning disability and support and protect those who provide care services to this potentially vulnerable group. Key points to observe at all times are DIGNITY, CHOICE AND RESPECT. SALFORD PCT & PARTNERSHIP ORGANISATIONS LEARNING DISABILITIES SEXUAL HEALTH POLICY & GUIDELINES GEOFF HOLLIDAY & TIM PLANT 2005 32