Journal of Internet Technology
Confidential Manuscript Review Form
This review form is a written evaluation form including reviewer’s comments, which are to be
confidential and for use by the Editor only. The second page, containing the reviewer’s comments,
will be transmitted to the author(s).
Title of the manuscript: _________________________________________________________
Serial Number: ________________________________________________________________
Review’s Name:___________________________ E-mail:______________________________
PAPER RATING:
_____ Outstanding
_____ Very Good
______Good
_____ Fair
_____ Poor
PUBLICATION RECOMMENDATION:
1.
___
Accept as is (or subject to minor changes)
2.
___
Accept subject to suitable revision
3.
___
Return for major revision and resubmission
4.
___
Reject
5.
___
More suitable for publication in another journal
such as _________________________________________
I.
TECHNICAL CONTENT:
1
Does this paper present new ideas or results that have not been previously published?
___ Yes
2
___ Minor
Are the results/ideas presented in this paper important enough for publication?
___ Definitely
3
___ Perhaps
___ No
Are the contents supported/verified by independent evidence (measurements, prior results, etc.)?
___ Yes
II.
___ No
Is the paper technically correct?
___ Yes
4
___ No
___ No
GENERAL CONTENT:
1
Is the subject matter relevant to JIT?
___ Yes
2
___ No
Please rate the overall quality of the paper
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
(very good)
3
0
(very poor)
___ No
Is the grammar/spelling adequate for publication?
___ Yes
5
1
Is the paper concisely written for publication?
___ Yes
4
2
___ No
Does the abstract properly reflect the content of the work?
___ Yes
___ No
JIT FORM: Confidential Manuscript Review Form
第 1 頁
Journal of Internet Technology
III.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AUTHOR(S)
(Note: We will rely most on these comments for rejection or acceptance of the paper.)
………………………………………………………………………………………….
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS FOR EDITOR ONLY:
JIT FORM: Confidential Manuscript Review Form
第 2 頁