INFORMATION SYSTEMS JOURNAL (ISJ)
Evaluation Form
Reviewer Name
ISJ Paper Number
Title of Paper
Please evaluate the paper according to the following criteria and enter the number in the box):
Unacceptable
1
Poor
2
Average
3
Good
4
Excellent
5
Not Applicable
X
Evaluation
Significance of the topic
Appropriateness to the ISJ
Adequacy of the literature review
Development of
concepts/hypotheses
Quality of research design
Adequacy of data analysis
Legitimacy of conclusions
Significance for practice
Contribution to literature
Clarity of presentation
Yes
No
Is the title of the paper accurate/relevant? (If no, indicate why below)
Are previsous appropriate ISJ papers referenced? (If no, indicate details below)
Recommendation to the Editors
Accept as presented
Accept with specified revisions
Accept only if the authors make major revisions
Revise and resubmit
Reject with encouragement to submit to another journal
(specify journal or type)
Reject outright
Please provide comments for the author(s) below, without attribution. You may also provide additional
comments for the editors only. These will not be conveyed to the authors.
Thank you for your review and your contribution to the Information Systems Journal (ISJ).
Comments for Authors (normally a page at least, if you are requesting changes please be as specific as
possible) :
Comments for the Associate Editor (AE):
Please return to the appropriate ISJ Associate Editor (AE)