Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs Research Study on International Recycling Experience Annex A A4 ITALY - MONZA A4.1 OVERVIEW A summary description of Monza and key recycling data are presented in Table A4.1. Table AA4.1 Overview of Monza City Background Population Details Density 3619/km2 Type of area Urban & rural Type of housing Apartments: 45% (concentrated in city centre) Houses: 55% (predominantly in the suburban areas) Definition of MSW All waste from the domestic sector, and commercial waste similar to household waste Recycling target At national level, recycling levels for MSW are set at: 119 790 Recycling achievement Principal Recycling Drivers 15% of collected material for 1999; 25% for 2001; 35% for 2003. Officially published figures stated separate collection at 51% (1999), corresponding to 236 kg per capita (total waste production was 464 kg per capita). No recycling achievement has been reported. landfill disposal charges; requirement to provide door to door collection systems; markets for paper and glass; public information campaign. Monza has one of the highest recycling rates in the region of Lombardy. The population is representative in terms of income and education levels of the rest of the region. Lombardy is the richest region in Italy. Separate collection rates, not including bulky waste, are 20 per cent for the rest of Northern Italy, 8 per cent in central Italy and 2 per cent in Southern Italy. A4.2 RECYCLING TRENDS 55 250 tonnes of municipal solid waste was produced in Monza in 1999. 51 per cent of domestic and commercial waste was collected for recycling. The rest represents mixed waste collected from apartment buildings. Figure A4.1 shows the overall municipal solid waste trends since 1995 and changes in recycling rates over this period. Figure AA4.1 Trends in MSW generation and amount of household and commercial recycling in Monza Figure A4.2 shows the amounts of material collected by separate collection and then recycled in Monza in 1999. Figure AA4.2 Quantities of separately collected materials for households and the commercial sector, 1999 The Municipal data cannot be disaggregated to determine the rate of recyclable collection for households. There are low residual wastes for kitchen waste (98 per cent purity), glass (98 per cent purity) and paper (95 per cent purity). Collection of plastic has a purity of only 62 per cent. A4.3 MSW MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE Collection and treatment of MSW and recycled material is a duty of the municipality. Collection activities in Monza are performed by an external contractor. The present contract is for six years. There are around 10 companies that compete for the contracts. Material recovery and separation plants are owned by private companies. The contractor receives income from the collection service it provides to the municipality. The collection companies sell the collected materials to private treatment plants. Some contracts between the collection company and the processors may specify that the collection companies receive a percentage of revenue sales of the recycled material. Packaging waste collected is bought by the National Packaging Association (CONAI), see Section A4.6 for further details. CONAI finances its obligations under the agreement with a packaging fee levied on sales of packaging, see Section A4.7 for further details. A4.4 COLLECTION MECHANISM AND ACCESSIBILITY OF RECYCLING FACILITIES Separate collection for kitchen waste started in March 1997 and was extended to the rest of Monza by July 1998. Separate door to door collection of paper and plastic started in July 1998. Previous to the introduction of separate collection systems, a purple bag was used for collection of commingled materials. Table A4.2. shows collection methods and final disposal of MSW. Table AA4.2 Management strategy for municipal solid waste Types of materials Method type MSW not separated (including public street cleaning, large household waste not recycled) White transparent bag; door Landfill to door Kitchen waste Bucket or bin (120 litres for Composting apartments and 10 litres for houses); Door to door Garden waste Civic amenity site Paper and cardboard Box or bin (120 litres) door Recycling to door Glass and aluminium cans Recycling containers (for apartments) Recycling Plastic (tanks for liquids) and Yellow bag; Door to door aluminium cans (for houses); Recycling areas in each apartment building. Recycling Metals Civic amenity site Recycling Wood Civic amenity site Recycling Large bulky waste Collection on demand Recycling Others (small white goods, Civic amenity site small quantities of hazardous waste, etc. ) Final disposal Composting Recycling Building waste Civic amenity site Landfill Any waste that has been incorrectly sorted may not be collected. Similarly, clear plastic bags for refuse allow quality control of refuse. There are around 250 recycling containers for glass and aluminium, indicating a population density of 479 people per recycling container. Recycling containers for paper and plastic, and for kitchen waste, are being phased in for apartments, at a density of one set of containers for every 7 to 10 apartments. Currently, mixed waste is collected from apartment buildings, although future efforts will focus on increasing sorting from apartments. Kitchen waste is collected separately from other recyclables and refuse. Every house receives a bin (10 litres) for collection of organic matter and biodegradable bags (100 per household per year) . The bins are placed on the road sides on collection days, and are emptied manually. Apartments are provided with 120 litre containers for separated kitchen waste. High-rise buildings, canteens and fruit shops have been provided with 240 litre bins for temporary deposit of separated kitchen waste. The bins are placed on the roadside on collection days and is emptied mechanically. Home composting is also encouraged by the Municipality, with free composting courses offered. Backyard composting is a common activity, partly due to the fact that, traditionally, it has been done, but also because collection companies can refuse to collect rubbish that has been sorted incorrectly. Paper and cardboard, and plastic and aluminium collection takes place once a week. Residual MSW collection takes place twice a week. Kitchen waste is collected twice a week. Refuse collection and separated material collection takes place on different days. Kitchen waste and other recyclables are collected using bulk lorries. Waste is then transferred to compacting vehicles which transport the recyclables to their respective collection and separation plants. The use of bulk lorries and compacting vehicles reduces collection costs. Street markets are provided with compacting vehicles for waste such as wood, paper, organic and mixed residual. A4.4.1 Participation Rate Official figures are not available. However, the ability for collection companies to refuse to collect waste that is incorrectly sorted is a strong driver for households to sort their waste. It is therefore likely that participation is high. A4.5 COSTS AND REVENUES Garden waste is sold to composting plants for around 20 Euro (£12) per tonne. Kitchen waste has a price of around 60 Euro (£36) per tonne. The higher price reflects the fact that the latter is better suited to production of quality compost. Table A4.3 provides details of the prices of separately collection materials. The cost of public information campaigns is around 25 000 Euro (£15 000) per year (two publicity campaigns have been carried out since the beginning of the collection scheme in 1998). The publicity campaign focuses on the distribution of literature and posters. A4.6 SUCCESS OF THE SCHEME Local authorities are required to provide separate collection of packaging from other types of waste in the domestic sector. The landfill disposal fee Lombardy provides a strong incentive for refuse collection companies to collect waste that has been correctly sorted. Strong public relation activities have further been of critical support to the two drivers noted above. Prior to the implementation of municipal collection systems, demand for recyclable paper and glass by processors was the only driver behind recycling activity. A4.7 LEGAL/ REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS The Waste Management and Packaging Act was issued in 1997 (see Legislative Decree 22/97), in response to the EC Directives 91/156 on waste, 91/689 on hazardous waste, and 94/62 on packaging and packaging waste. The decree phases out landfilling of waste other than building waste or waste coming from sorting activities not later than July 2001. Targets for achieving waste separation are 15 per cent in 1999, 25 per cent in 2000 and 35 per cent in 2003. The decree requires that local authorities provide the means for separate collection of packaging from other types of waste in the domestic sector. Packaging producers are obligated to participate in the National Packaging Association (CONAI). In July 1999, an agreement was made between the National Association of Italian Municipalities (ANCI) and the National Packaging Association (CONAI) that regulates the modalities of collection and storage of packaging material. The agreement states: the price which is paid by CONAI to municipalities for the recycled materials; the quality standards for materials (the price is strictly dependent on such quality; the collection mechanisms, according to the size of municipality. The agreement states that steel, aluminium and plastic waste shall be delivered by municipalities to collection areas located: for municipalities with fewer than 100 000 inhabitants, at less than 25 km; for municipalities with 100 000 to 300 000 inhabitants, at less than 30 km; for municipalities with more than 300 000 inhabitants, at less than 25 km. A4.8 FISCAL INCENTIVES The packaging fee was introduced in 1998 at a national level. Table A4.3 outlines the level of fee levied on different packaging materials. Table AA4.3 Levels of packaging fee[1] Material Packaging fee Price paid to municipalities (min £/tonne max: according to impurity rate. £/tonne. Paper and cellulose 9 6 - 7 (for mixed paper); 39 - 45 (for pure paper packaging). Plastic 42 63 - 120 Glass 3 9 - 18 Wood 1.5 3-6 Aluminium 30 90 - 105 Steel and ferrous metals 9 18 - 36 The Regional Law 13/97 fixed a tax on waste disposed to landfill or to incinerators without energy recovery. The landfill tax is equivalent to 12 Euro (£7) per tonne in Lombardy. This tax is additional to the disposal fee paid to landfill owners. A4.8.1 Waste Disposal Costs The average cost of incineration is 96 Euro (£58) per tonne. The average cost of landfill for non-hazardous waste is 103 Euro (£62) per tonne. Transportation costs must be added these figures, and these are equivalent to an average of 20 Euro (£12) per tonne. A4.8.2 Charging Systems for Waste Management Waste charges in Monza are financed by an annual flat-rate tax, linked to the size of accommodation being considered. This is soon to be replaced by a fee, on the basis of volume, weight of waste or an average waste production rate per capita. A4.9 PUBLIC AWARENESS Strong public relations activities have been carried out by the municipality to ensure the smooth running of collection systems. These can be summarised as: information campaigns; organisation of public meetings; creation of an information shop (Ecosportello) for citizens to ask for further details on separate collection and waste management; organisation of free composting courses; schools environmental education programmes; and discussions of recycling issues with stall holders in street markets. Initial problems with the collection system were related to the volume of the available collection bins (inappropriate sizes for households) and the distribution of too few recycling bags. The municipality organises meetings with the public in each of the five districts of the municipality. Here, they distribute information leaflets, and discuss problems with the public. The municipality holds meetings with apartment building administrators and with the private cleaning companies building owners hire to discuss any problems. A4.10 MARKETS FOR END PRODUCTS Table AA4.4 Markets for recycled products Material End Use Paper and Cellulose Production of paper board (90% is made from waste paper). Production of newsprint; Production of sanitary products. Plastic Production of plastic goods, such as furniture. Some used for energy recovery. Glass Production of glass. Wood Production of plywood, cellulose material and composting. Aluminium Used in foundries as raw material. More than 20 foundries accept aluminium packaging. Steel and Used in foundries as raw material. There are six plants ferrous metals. in Italy which treat steel from cans and other packaging to produce steel sheets and raw materials for foundries. Italy imports waste paper because national production only covers 30 per cent of demand. There are around 100 paper mills which use waste paper in Italy, 20 of which are located in Lombardy. Recycled glass forms currently 34 per cent of glass produced. The markets for plastic are weak and, in some cases, non-government organisations support the financing of plastic recycling. Kitchen waste is recycled and used by farms that are located at large distances from the municipality (around 300 kms.) Garden waste is sent to a composting plant located 20 km from the municipality. This composting plant distributes the product for free to residents and farmers in the nearby areas. Composting plants are meeting quality standards stipulated by regulation. A key driver for recycling activity before formal collection systems for separated waste were put into place by the municipality was the existence of markets for paper and glass. A4.11 FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS Future development will include: a new waste fee that will replace the actual annual flat rate tax system; a public information campaign to advise days and times for door to door collections; the building of a second civic amenity site; and the hiring of another contractor to collect all waste from car parts. [1] FT 12/04/00 £1 = 0.602 [ Previous ] [ Contents ] [ Next ] Published 26 April 2001 Waste Index Environmental Protection Index Defra Home Page