Computer Lab Manager Training Course Zambia Pacific Trust Module 2: Management and Leadership Summary This module involves exposure to the broad variety of management topics that relate to the daily work of a computer lab manager. The online instruction in this course covers some of the motivation behind management and some practical assignments in management and organization. The workshop session allows for group discussions of the issues around people and financial management as well as opportunities to work on financial planning and budgeting. 1 Module 2: Management and Leadership Resource Book Author: Heidi Neff, Consultant to Zambia Pacific Trust, heidihneff@gmail.com First Edition – May 2010 More information about Heidi Neff and Zambia Pacific Trust is found at the end of this module. Acknowledgements The Computer Lab Manager Training Course resource books were made possible due to the efforts and encouragement provided by a variety of people around the world. Special thanks are due to two pioneering organizations working on computers in education in Zambia who provided advice and materials: Computers for Zambian Schools and Crescent Future Kids. Three international development aid organizations: Camara, VVOB and IICD, also deserve special recognition for their contributions to this document and the efforts they are making to use ICT as a tool for development and education in Zambia and elsewhere. Many individuals also contributed their time, expertise and advice to the crafting of this module. Key among them is Bornwell Mwewa. In addition, none of Zambia Pacific Trust’s work toward improving computer education at schools in Lusaka, Zambia would have been possible without the support, advice and equipment provided by Seattle Academy in Seattle, Washington, USA. Licensing This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-ncsa/3.0/us/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA. Zambia Pacific Trust welcomes and encourages organizations to use any of the modules of the Computer Lab Manager Training Course in a manner they deem appropriate, excluding making a profit from the sale or distribution of the material. Organizations are welcome to use portions of these modules in other documents, but they should attribute the material that is used to Zambia Pacific Trust. Zambia Pacific Trust also appreciates knowing who is benefiting from this material, and requests that individuals and organizations please email Bornwell Mwewa (bornwellmwewa@gmail.com), Heidi Neff (heidi.h.neff@gmail.com) and Zambia Pacific Trust (info@zptrust.org) and describe how the material is being used. 2 Module 2 Table of Contents 1. Introduction 1.1. Introduction to the Computer Lab Manager Training Course 1.2. Introduction to Module 2 2. The Big Picture for Management and Leadership 2.1. The Typical Day 2.2. Getting into the “Leadership Zone” 2.3. Feeling Overwhelmed 2.4. Assignments/Activities 3. Lab Cleanliness and Condition 3.1. Why Computer Labs Should be Clean and in Good Repair 3.2. Keeping a Computer Lab Clean 3.3. Keeping a Computer Lab in Good Repair 3.4. Assignments/Activities 4. Organization 4.1. Overall Purpose 4.2. Strategies for Physical Organization 4.3. Equipment Inventories 4.4. Strategies for Electronic Organization 4.5. Collecting and Organizing User Data 4.6. Assignments/Activities 5. Security 5.1. Physical Security 5.2. Security Policy 5.3. Insurance 5.4. Assignments/Activities 6. Management 6.1. Overall Definition and Purpose 6.2. Managing Customers, Clients and Students 6.3. Managing Coworkers 6.4. Assignments/Activities 7. Leadership, Time Management and Project Organization 7.1. Leadership Overview 7.2. Time Management 7.3. Organizing and Leading Meetings 7.4. Documentation 7.5. Assignments/Activities 8. Planning 8.1. Planning Overview 8.2. Strategic Planning 8.3. Planning and Managing a Special Event 8.4. Assignments/Activities 3 9. Financial Management 9.1. Overall Purpose 9.2. Planning for Sustainability 9.3. The Financial Planning Process 9.4. Working With a Budget 9.5. Avoiding Financial Corruption 9.6. Basic Marketing Skills 9.7. Assignments/Activities 10. Communication and Interpersonal Skills 10.1. Effective Communication 10.2. Communicating with Different Types of People 10.3. Effective Email Communication 10.4. Communicating with Project Partners and Donors 10.5. Networking and Seeking and Creating Partnerships 10.6. Customer Relations Skills 10.7. Assignments/Activities 11. Overall Assignment/Activities 12. Planning Resources 12.1. Initial Planning, Project Organization 12.2. Strategic Planning 13. Bibliography Module 2 Text 1. Introduction 1.1. Introduction to the Computer Lab Manager Training Course The Computer Lab Manager Training Course was developed by Zambia Pacific Trust in collaboration with a variety of organizations working on IT related development projects in Zambia. While these projects are in several different sectors (health, education, agriculture and community), all of the organizations recognized the need to increase the number of people who have training in computers past the standard level of a computer user. A particular need that was identified was for individuals who could maintain dynamic and well functioning computer labs and other centers for IT use within a particular project. Therefore, a multifaceted training course was developed to meet these needs including both the “hard skills” of computer maintenance, repair, and networking and the “soft skills” of management, leadership, communication and instruction. Readers may find more emphasis shown on educational projects, since that is the area of Zambia Pacific Trust’s experience. However, most topics discussed apply equally well in the other sectors where IT is used. The resource books for these modules are designed to be used as a part of an instructor-led four module course, with each course including both a distance (online) 4 instruction component and a one week face-to-face workshop. This resource book is written to accompany the second of the four modules listed below. Module 1: Computer Maintenance, Troubleshooting and Repair Module 2: Management and Leadership Module 3: Instruction, Facilitating IT Use and IT in Education Module 4: Networking, Communication and Web 2.0 The target audience for this training course is adult learners who already have intermediate computer user skills and significant experience using computers. Ideally, participants are already employed as computer lab managers, computer project coordinators or Internet café managers. While the course is tailored to those working in educational or community organizations, the course is still valuable for those working in a similar capacity in the private sector. These learning materials are also valuable for people who are not involved in a formal course, but instead are studying independently to become computer lab managers or improve their skills as computer lab managers. Learners who are using these materials for self study are encouraged to make the training as hands-on as possible, performing as many of the assignments and activities as they can practically achieve. In addition all learners, whether using these materials for self-study or as a part of a formal course, would benefit from continuing to develop their own skills in three important areas that are not included in this course: Touch Typing, English Reading and Writing, and Computer User Skills. Suggested resources for self study in these areas are presented in section 1.3 of the Module 1 resource book. 1.2. Introduction to Module 2 Module 1 of this course covered the most obvious of the needs of a computer lab manager: to keep the computers in good working order. A computer lab manager does not just manage the computers, however, but is responsible for keeping an entire computer project in good working order. Although less straight forward than computer maintenance and repair, this aspect of a computer lab manager’s job is even more important. While it is possible to bring in volunteers to help with computer repair, it is not very practical to ask others to organize the day-to-day running of a computer lab. Here is where the computer lab manager needs to develop the management and leadership skills to make the computer lab a place where students, coworkers or clients look forward to coming to use computers, participate in courses or take advantage of other opportunities or resources. It is important to note that management and leadership are large topics and there is significant additional training that a lab manager could obtain in many of the sub topics discussed in this module. Lab managers are encouraged to consider this module to be just an introduction to management and leadership, and to continue their studies in any of the areas below that they find particularly interesting. For example, more advanced training in project 5 management, strategic planning and financial planning is available in a variety of formats, ranging from free online lessons to formal participation in certificate courses. Interested computer lab managers are encouraged to investigate options through online searches and discussions with local training institutions. Table of Contents 2. The Big Picture for Management and Leadership 2.1. The Typical Day What do lab managers do on a typical day? This is going to vary from person to person and organization to organization, but it is likely to include at least opening and closing the lab, making sure that the facilities are clean and secure, keeping all equipment in good working order, keeping appropriate records, communicating with other stakeholders in the organization, and managing other employees, interns, or volunteers. The computer lab manager may also be teaching or in charge of some sort of computer education project at the lab. A computer lab manager may also be asked to build awareness of projects and opportunities in the lab, and initiate new projects to benefit the target audience for the project. Financial matters may also be important such as collecting fees from users or seeking outside funding for the support of the project. All computer lab managers should make sure that they have a job description that reflects the realities of their working situation and the needs of the community they serve. If a computer lab manager finds that an appropriate job description does not exist, efforts should be made to meet with his or her supervisor or steering committee promptly to formulate such a document. When preparing a job description, those involved should take some time to envision what a typical day will look like for the computer lab manager, including estimates of how much time will be spent on different aspects of the work. Although individual days will vary widely (for example – if some key equipment malfunctions, most of a day might be devoted to its repair), this exercise gives the manager a good indication of how much time overall should be spent on certain aspects of his or her job. 2.2. Getting into the “Leadership Zone” Most of the tasks mentioned above require the computer lab manager to be a leader in the computer lab. Those that don’t require the manager to lead others at least require the manager to be organized and responsible. The tip box here includes some basic tips to help computer lab managers think and act like leaders. Leadership is also discussed further in chapter 7, later in this module. One of the most important ways that leaders can behave is to demonstrate empowerment. Empowerment is used here to mean ability to effect change or growth in your organization. The empowered lab manager does not easily “give up” when faced with a 6 challenge, but works through the problem until finding an acceptable solution. In addition to being the attitude of pushing forward and finding success, empowerment also results when the computer lab manager’s supervisor or steering committee has given the lab manager the authority to make decisions that affect the running of the computer lab. Tips for Getting into the “Leadership Zone” 1. Start thinking of yourself as a leader in everything you do. This will help others see you as someone worth following. 2. So what does it mean to think/act as a leader? a. You consistently demonstrate the organization and management skills needed for your project to succeed. b. You inspire and encourage everyone that you work with to help in your efforts to make your computer project the best it can be. 3. Note that being a leader doesn’t mean you have all the answers or all the skills yourself. You can demonstrate leadership while collecting information and knowledge from others and organizing teams to work together. 4. Being a leader also does not mean that you wield unnecessary power in your interactions with others. You can work with others gently and in a way that respects their talents and efforts. Imagine being a visitor to a computer lab over the course of a year and gradually observing the deterioration of the working conditions of the computer lab. Several of the power adapters needed to plug in electrical equipment have broken, and the overhead florescent lights are gradually starting to dim and flicker. It is no longer an easy or pleasant lab to work in, but the computer lab manager has not shown sufficient interest in changing this situation. When asked about the problems, the computer lab manager says that he (or she) didn’t think there was anything he could do about the adapters, and also that he did mention once to his steering committee about the light bulbs, but no action resulted. How would this situation be different if the computer lab manager was empowered or in “the leadership zone”? Here’s one possible scenario: The computer lab manager would have realized the importance of keeping the computer lab facilities in good working order. The computer lab manager would have been making note of how many adapters and bulbs needed to be replaced each year and preparing an annual budget for small repairs such as this. The computer lab manager would be initiating discussions with his supervisor or steering committee on the importance of budgeting for small repairs and recommending a system for the budget and expenditures. The computer lab manager would be also advocating for immediate replacement of the current faulty equipment while a system is being developed. 2.3. Feeling Overwhelmed Given all of the tasks mentioned in section 2.1 (and the additional tasks that are likely to be found in a computer lab manager’s job description), it is likely that a computer lab manager 7 will sometimes feel overwhelmed. Imagine the day described here: A computer lab manager opens a school computer lab and starts the usual setup procedure. The manager then gets ready to deliver a lesson to community members that are first-time computer users, and starts to review her (or his) notes in the last few minutes before the class starts. While she is studying, her school’s science department head shows up and says that he has been asked to immediately make a spreadsheet with his department’s budget request for the next year and he needs the manager’s assistance right now. Meanwhile the intern who was helping set up the computer lab for the lesson notices that three computers won’t turn on and has come to the lab manager to ask her for assistance. The lab manager now has three simultaneous demands on her time and attention! Any computer lab manager is bound to have experiences like the one described above. Sometimes the day just gets out of control due overlapping needs and requests. The tip box here provides some suggestions for managing these stressful moments. Tips for Managing Stressful Moments Are there all of a sudden multiple demands on your time? Here are some tips for how to respond: 1. Start by taking a deep breath and pausing to settle your mind. 2. Recognize that you are only human, and cannot do everything at once. Then set your priorities for the moment: a. What needs to happen now to allow an upcoming activity to continue? b. What can be scheduled for later? (But make sure you commit to a scheduled time.) c. What tasks can be delegated to assistants or volunteers? 3. Don’t “scare off” people that you cannot assist at the current moment. a. Remain calm and encouraging as you politely let them know why you can’t help them at the current moment. Raising your voice won’t lower your stress and certainly won’t contribute to a positive and encouraging atmosphere. b. Make sure that your lab users understand your operating schedule and the importance you place on it. c. Schedule a time later that day that you can assist the lab user. It would be even better, however, if a computer lab manager could avoid having these overwhelming moments in the first place. While these moments still might happen occasionally, the frequency can be reduced significantly by developing some of the skills discussed later in this module. Clear communication about schedules and services, good record keeping about equipment malfunctions, and good existing relationships with stakeholders would all have helped in the situation described here. It’s also wise for the manager to make sure that there are a variety of trained individuals (interns, assistants, volunteers, etc.) who can help with some of the common needs of computer lab users and equipment. 8 2.4. Assignments/Activities 2.4.1. What do you do on a typical day? If you are already a computer lab manager, keep a daily log for at least a week that notes down all the different tasks you worked on during the week and the approximate number of hours spent on each. Summarize these findings as a list of what tasks you do (and for how long) on an average day. If you do not yet work in a computer lab, interview someone in your community who works in a computer lab and report on that interview. 2.4.2. Check your “empowerment”. How empowered are you to make improve the operation of your computer lab? Consider factors such as your decision making power about programs, schedules and purchases, and your ability to make take care of lab expenses in a timely manner. Also consider your character. How likely are you to push hard to solve a problem? Summarize your thoughts and findings. 2.4.3. Workshop Activity: Participate in a group discussion on stress management. Make sure everyone in the group contributes their thoughts and ideas on how they manage stress. Table of Contents 3. Lab Cleanliness and Condition 3.1. Why Computer Labs Should be Clean and in Good Repair Keeping a lab clean and in good repair should be high on any list of computer lab manager’s responsibilities. This is important for a variety of reasons that affect the overall quality of your computer project. The three main categories of these reasons are described below. Attitudes. A well cared for computer lab is much more inviting for users. Who wants to work in a room where they get their clothes dusty as soon as they sit down? Who wants to work on a hot day in a room with broken fans? Also a dirty lab implies a lack of respect for the facility from those that work there. Users might wonder how important this facility is if no one takes the time to keep it clean and well functioning. If they think that no one cares for the facility, they might be less likely to use it or even worse, more likely to steal from it. Donors also are likely to be unimpressed by a facility that they don’t see as well cared for. Equipment. A clean computer lab helps equipment last longer. Dust in particular takes a toll on computers and other electronic devices (see more in Module 1). Spills from neglected beverages can also cause significant damage. In addition, keeping a computer lab orderly makes it much easier to keep track of and inventory equipment. Safety and Security. The most important safety concern is that electrical equipment should be kept in good working order to avoid the risks of electrical shock and fires. Faulty electrical equipment might also tempt a computer lab manager to run an electrical extension cord across a path way. If someone trips over this cord they could fall and hurt themselves or pull expensive equipment off a table and cause serious damage. It is also common for door locks and handles to become damaged. This could either cause difficulty in allowing lab users 9 to exit the lab quickly in an emergency, or difficulty with locking the lab at the end of the day. Keeping a lab clean and orderly can also help keep equipment from “disappearing” into the hands of lab users. It is much harder to keep track of valuable small equipment (such as tools and flash drives) in a lab that has cluttered surfaces and no policy for returning equipment to a designated storage place after use. 3.2. Keeping a Computer Lab Clean Keeping a computer lab Tips for Keeping a Computer Lab Clean clean begins with preventive measures. Some tips for Here are some ways to keep a computer lab cleaner keeping a computer lab clean longer. are included in the tip box here. 1. Make sure there is a clearly labeled waste bin. Despite the above 2. Provide a mat by the door for wiping wet or muddy measures, however, some dirt feet. and dust will still make its way 3. Have rules clearly posted that prohibit eating and into the computer lab. drinking near computers. Computer lab managers should 4. Consider keeping the windows closed to reduce make a daily schedule for basic dust, particularly on days when the wind is blowing dust removal that begins with strongly. This will be a challenge on hot days, but wiping dust off counters and air-conditioning (if affordable) is one solution. tables, and is followed by 5. Avoid floor coverings (such as deep carpets) that sweeping (or vacuuming) the collect dust and are difficult to clean. floor of the computer lab and any adjacent rooms. If the project uses laptop computers it is best to take care of this cleaning while the computers are being stored elsewhere. Desktop computers can be provided with dust covers to be used during cleaning as well as for long periods when the computers are not in use. A schedule should also be made for periodic (at least weekly) mopping of the floor. A few times a year the computer lab should be deeply cleaned, including dusting ceiling beams, window sills, and all shelves. The cleaning tasks mentioned above are the kind of work that the lab manager can easily delegate to other workers, but the manager should still participate in cleaning periodically. This demonstrates the importance of thorough work and also can be used to build a spirit of teamwork and cooperation amongst the lab users and staff. It is also important when scheduling and delegating to make sure that everyone participating in the cleaning process is fully informed about the schedule and about the importance of keeping the computer lab clean. 3.3. Keeping a Computer Lab in Good Repair Keeping a computer lab in good repair requires a computer lab manager to have a heightened awareness of the condition of the lab equipment and fixtures, and a drive to keep the equipment and fixtures in good condition despite the hassles involved. The tip box here describes some tips for keeping a computer lab in good repair. 10 The computer lab manager will also need to work with other parties to make these repairs happen. This includes working with his or her supervisor to develop a petty cash system or an easy system for requesting funds. The lab manager will also need to develop good working relationships with workers who can perform the commonly needed repairs at a reasonable price. Tips for Keeping Your Computer Lab in Good Repair 1. Periodically inspect all equipment and fixtures and ask all other employees, interns or volunteers to report to you any problems they see with equipment or fixtures. 2. Keep a log of problems with lab fixtures, including the date that the problem was noted and the date the problem was addressed. This will help keep track of issues and raise your awareness about how often certain problems (i.e. burned out light bulbs or faulty network cables) occur. 3. Put a high priority on making small repairs, and work with others involved as needed to make sure repairs happen. Since this may be a higher priority for you than for other people, you may need to give frequent (but pleasant) reminders to get the work done. 4. As you gain more experience with making small repairs, begin to forecast likely future repairs and keep common spare parts on hand. 3.4. Assignments/Activities 3.4.1. Cleaning Equipment Budget. The first obstacle to proper cleaning of a computer lab is a lack of the required equipment and supplies. Observe a computer lab and think about what equipment is needed there to do a proper job. Include the types (mops, brooms, etc.) as well as the numbers needed. Make two budgets for cleaning equipment and supplies. The first should include be the “start up” budget for a new project, and the second one should be an annual budget for equipment and supplies that are likely to get used up or broken over the course of a year. If possible, use a spreadsheet program such as MS Excel to make these budgets. 3.4.2. Cleaning Schedule. If you are already working in a computer lab, think about the cleaning needs for your lab on a daily, weekly, and yearly basis. Make a schedule that describes what work needs to be done when and by whom. Discuss this schedule with your steering committee or supervisor and together develop a plan for communicating the schedule to everyone involved. 3.4.3. Inspect an Internet Café. Visit a local Internet café and discretely consider the condition of the computer lab. Is the environment conducive to work? Why or why not? How clean is the facility? Is the facility in good repair or do you see signs of insufficient maintenance? Summarize your findings. 3.4.4. Workshop Activity: look around the computer lab where your workshop session is being held. Then discuss the following questions: What are the sources of dust in the room? What can be done to reduce dust? How often should the furniture be dusted? How often should the room be swept and mopped? Note any differences in opinion amongst those present. Table of Contents 11 4. Organization 4.1. Overall Purpose. Organizational skills do not come naturally to all of us, but most working adults would agree that it is very useful to be organized. It is usually when we are searching around for some important piece of paper that we really wished that we were better organized! A well organized lab is certainly easier to work in, and it also (like a clean lab) sends the right signal to potential learners, clients and donors. It shows that the people who work in the lab care about the resources that they have and are professional and well prepared. Some specific organizational suggestions are included in the sections that follow. 4.2. Strategies for Physical Organization In most cases an office in a new project starts with just a few books and disks, which are easy enough to find. But as a collection grows, often there is no system in place to keep the resources organized in a way that allows for easy access. As a result, many computer lab offices gradually come to contain a large jumble of unorganized materials. Below are four different categories of items that all should have their own distinct shelf or cupboard space, and then some suggestions for organizational strategies within each category. Equipment. A computer lab manager should do a visual inspection of various pieces of small equipment while considering an organization strategy. Which items are used most often? Which small items would get lost if mixed in with larger items? Which items are so old (or broken or not useful) that they should instead be taken to an e-waste facility? Once that initial assessment is done, the computer lab manager should organize the equipment for ease of use and with similar items grouped together (for example, a shelf space with a stack of neatly coiled patch cables). Small items can be organized by type and placed in well labeled boxes (for example, a box of small hand tools). Disks. CD-ROM and DVD disks are commonly found in computer labs and can contain various types of information. Some are found in plastic “jewel boxes” and others in sleeves or even without any protective coverings. The computer lab manager should begin by sorting through all of the disks, making sure that all of the disks are clearly labeled. Damaged or obsolete disks should be removed. The lab manager should then sort the disks into some large categories for separate storage. Four categories that might be useful are shown in the table below. Computer Utilities - operating systems, disk images, anti-virus software and other tools for setting up computers Computer Applications - office software, miscellaneous software for users E-learning/Education - educational software, encyclopedias or collections of academic presentations Electronic Documents - instructor’s lesson plans, copies of monthly computer lab reports, photos, back-up copies of various computer files 12 Once the computer lab manager has organized the disks into these categories, they need to be stored in a way that preserves the disks and also allows for easy access. The computer lab manager will need to see what supplies are available locally, but binders containing loose “pages” of disk sleeves are a good option, as are the zip up books of sleeves often used to store music CD-ROMs. Books. A computer lab is likely to have a small but important collection of books including some “how to” guides or other tools for computer lab maintenance, some IT instruction texts, and log books containing important information about computer users, equipment or finances. The computer lab manager should feel free to sort these books in the way that makes the most sense to him or her and then allow for appropriate shelf space to store the books. If other people are permitted to use any of the books, they should be instructed to return the books to the place on the shelf where they found them. Paper Documents. A computer lab manager will also end up with paper documents or files that need to be stored. These documents could include quotations and invoices, letters with signatures or stamps, or handwritten documents (such as attendance sheets for an event). The standard way of saving documents is really the best option here: place the documents in file folders that are appropriately and clearly labeled. When there are a large number of documents of a single type, these documents should have a separate file folder, and new file folders should be created periodically and labeled by date. For example, for tracking purchases, a project might need a file labeled “Receipts 2009” or if purchases are quite frequent then there could be separate files for each month. The lab manager might also use a ring binder instead of a file folder for items that should be kept in date order. The file folders and binders should also be organized in a way that makes them easy find on a shelf, such as sorted by date or alphabetically by name. Whatever system is used, however, it is most important that the computer lab manager is diligent in using the system. This includes taking the time to add new documents to the proper file and putting folders back in the proper location on the shelf. A computer lab manger’s schedule needs to include a small amount of time to allow for these tasks to occur. 4.3. Equipment Inventories Imagine this scenario: a computer lab has just been broken into by thieves. The computer lab manager is surveying the scene with a police officer and they both can see that two LCD computer monitors have been stolen. The police officer then asks: “is anything else missing”? The manager then pauses for a bit, and then confesses that she (or he) isn’t sure. She tries to remember how many recently donated CPUs were stacked in the corner, or how many laptops were in the stack in the office. Wouldn’t it be helpful if this lab manager had a readily accessible inventory sheet that she could refer to while the police officer was there? Similarly, imagine if a laptop donor comes to a computer lab and asks how many functioning P4 laptops they had. The donor would be pleased to know that the lab manager had that information at her fingertips. 13 All items of significant value in your computer lab should be inventoried. This includes clearly labeling all items using a sensible numbering system and then creating an inventory of each item, listing important characteristics of the item. For an inventory of laptop computers, for example, the list should include the make and model, the serial number, useful specifications (such as processor type or speed, hard drive capacity, and operating system used) and any significant performance problems that the computer lab manager is unable to fix. It is best to create this inventory using an electronic spreadsheet program so that the inventory can easily be updated. A regular schedule for updating these inventories should be established. A clear and current inventory is, as mentioned previously, very useful in communicating with law enforcement authorities or with potential donors of more equipment. An inventory is also a great planning tool for any computer project or Internet café. For example, if the inventory shows that the organization only has one old printer and that it is functioning poorly, then this might encourage the steering committee to budget for a new printer in the next year. 4.4. Strategies for Electronic Organization Most computer users gradually store more and more electronic files (documents, spreadsheets, presentations, etc.) on their computers. When people first start using personal computers, it is very easy for them to find their documents because they have so few documents to look through. Eventually, though, most users get to a point where they struggle to find the file they created a few weeks ago. Below are some tips to help organize files for better access. File Location. It is important that users be aware of where on computer they are saving files. If saved in the wrong location, a file can be difficult to find again. The first time a file is saved, the Save As, dialog box opens, and at the top there is a “Save In” box showing the location that the file is being saved in. The computer lab manager should become accustomed to checking the location and also determine how to change the location. The method for this depends on the application software being used. Naming. A computer file should have a name that is brief but informative. For example, a letter should not be named “Dear Sir” but instead “Letter to Mumba”. If the computer lab manger frequently corresponds with Mr. Mumba, more information such as the date or topic might also help. A computer inventory spreadsheet should not be named “inventory” but instead “Chawama Comp Inventory 9-08”. Including the date helps a reader know how current the information is, and including the project location is useful when communicating the information to donors (who might be working with multiple projects). Creating Folders. General storage in “My Documents” works for a small number of files, but creating subfolders will be helpful as soon as the computer lab manager has more than about 20 files. The computer lab manager should look at the types of files that he or she has created and make some suitable folders to move the files into. For example, the computer lab manager might want folders for “Reports”, “Inventories”, “Communication” and “IT 14 Instruction”. Fortunately folders can be gradually created and re-sorted to meet the changing needs of any computer user. One tool to use if a folder does start to get a bit full is viewing by details (select Details from the View menu in an open folder) and then clicking on a column heading (such as Name or Date) to sort the items in the folder. This makes it easier to find the documents with a certain type of file name, or the documents that were modified on a certain date. Backing Up. Whatever strategies are used for organizing computer files, it is particularly important that the computer lab manager remembers to frequently make backup copies of these files. Computers sometimes fail or are stolen and it would be a shame for a project to lose all of its data when this happened. It is wise to set up a schedule for making backup copies on a regular basis, such as once a month. In addition, while working on particularly important documents, the computer lab manager should consider making a backup any time significant changes to the document have been made. While a small amount of information can be backed up onto a USB Flash Drive, it is more secure to periodically make copies of all files on CD-ROM or DVD disks. These disks can then be stored in case of an emergency. Storing data on an external hard drive is also a good option. 4.5. Collecting and Organizing User Data User data is a collection of information about the clients or students who use a computer lab. While not all organizations will collect the same information, below is a list of some of the commonly collected data: Names and descriptions (i.e. teacher, student or community member, grade level of student) of users Date, start and end time of computer use Identification name/number of computer used Purpose of visit (i.e. Internet research, typing, preparing a presentation, lesson) Whether or not this is the first visit (ever? or this month?) for this particular user Fee paid User comments An Internet café might be most interested in the numbers of users and the fees paid, but the purposes of user’s visits might also help with marketing efforts. For a community or school project, donors might be particularly interested in knowing what audience is being served the most by their donations. Including the names of users can help an organization follow up on thefts that occur in the lab, but may not be appropriate for commercial projects such as Internet cafés. In most cases the easiest way for an organization to keep user data is to have a well organized and clearly labeled log book kept at a location near the entrance to the lab. During the peak hours (busiest times) for a computer lab, the manager could assign an intern, student monitor or volunteer to make sure that the log book is filled out properly for all users. The computer lab manager should discuss with his or her supervisor or project steering committee to determine what data should be collected and what should be done with the data collected in 15 the log book. Typically, after the log book has been used for a month or other specified unit of time, the computer lab manager will summarize the data electronically (in a spreadsheet) and include this information in reports to supervisors, donors, or other interested parties. High user numbers are a great indication of the success of a computer project, and this data should be shared widely to celebrate the achievement, thank the individuals responsible for the success and encourage further successes. Analyzing trends in user data can also be valuable as a part of project planning. Perhaps the data reveal that a certain target audience is not using the facility, and so a special effort should be made to attract those users. Or perhaps the data show that the lab is being used little at a certain time of the day. This could result in a change of operating hours, or the institution of a new course during the low use hours. Data that shows low use or negative trends should not be seen as “bad news” but as an opportunity to help a program adapt to meet changing needs. 4.6. Assignments/Activities 4.6.1. Have a look around your computer lab and office (or the lab and office at another computer project). What organizational systems do you already see in place? If there are areas that seem disorganized, what organizational strategies would you suggest? 4.6.2. Make some physical improvements to your office or computer lab. Collect boxes, build shelves, or figure out some other method to sub-divide your storage spaces. Summarize your efforts and the outcomes. 4.6.3. Imagine that you were creating an inventory of the educational CD-ROM disks that your computer project owned. What sort of information do you think should be included in this inventory? Make a sample spreadsheet showing all of the column headings for the inventory and including example information for six disks. (The examples do not have to be actual disks if your project doesn’t own any.) 4.6.4. Practice using Save As on your computer to save a copy of a file in a different location and with a different name. Write a summary of the steps that need to be performed to make these changes. 4.6.5. Make a back up copy (backup) of all of your documents. Depending on the equipment you have available to you and the type of computer you are using, this backup might be on a CD-ROM or DVD disk, or an external hard drive. Do not make your backup on a USB flash drive unless you have no other options. After making the backup, check and make sure that all the backup files are found on the disk or drive and can be opened successfully. 4.6.6. Workshop Activity: Your instructor will copy a group of files (documents, etc.) on to the desktop of your computer. View the files and decide a sensible storage strategy for them. Determine where to store the files, make folders, and move the files as needed. Also rename the spreadsheet files more appropriately. 4.6.7. Workshop Activity: Participate in a discussion on how you manage file storage for your learners/clients. Should they be allowed to store documents on the hard drives of particular computers? Should they use USB flash drives or CD-ROMs? Table of Contents 16 5. Security 5.1. Physical Security It doesn’t take much to convince most people of the benefits of a secure computer lab. How can a project be sustained if valuable equipment regularly disappears? Theft is often a significant problem when computer projects are located in or adjacent to underserved communities, and the more portable the equipment is (such as laptop computers) the larger the problem. In Zambian computer projects thieves have been known to break through roof tiles, crawl over ceilings from adjacent rooms, and even break through walls to take computers! The measures taken to ensure physical security will vary for each lab but should as a minimum include the installation of burglar bars over all windows and doors and high quality locks. Keys should not be distributed widely. Some labs will also consider installing alarm systems or hiring security guards. Laptop computers should be stored in the most secure area of the computer lab, such as a locking closet with burglar bars on the ceiling and door. 5.2. Security Policy A computer project steering committee should work with a computer lab manager to develop a thorough security policy for the computer lab. Here are some topics to address in this policy. Record keeping procedure (such as recording information in a log book) for equipment use Record keeping procedure for lab users (as discussed in section 4.5) Key distribution policy Procedure for lab access when computer lab manger is not present (such afterhours use or in the case of lab manager illness) A strategy for managing user’s bags and backpacks Procedure to follow once a theft has occurred A strategy (such as password protection on specific files or computers) for securing sensitive files (such as those containing financial information or student marks/scores) 5.3. Insurance A computer project steering committee should also investigate the possibility of obtaining insurance for the computers or other valuable hardware in the computer lab. The price for this insurance will vary with the deductible (the non-covered amount) chosen, the number and quality of the computers, and the security of the facility. For example, the insurance might be cheaper if the computer lab has an alarm system and monitoring by a security company. If the steering committee decides that insurance is not affordable, then a discussion (and plan) should follow about what the organization intends to do if a computer is stolen. Will it be replaced? And if so, using what funds? Perhaps the organization could establish a reserve fund to be used in case of theft or other significant damage to key equipment. 17 5.4. Assignments/Activities 5.4.1. Perform a security audit of your computer lab or a local Internet café. What strengths and weaknesses do you see in the physical security of the room? If you were a thief, how would you gain access to the room and what items of value would you be able to remove? 5.4.2. Visit an insurance agency and ask for a quotation for insurance for 10 laptop computers valued at $500.00 USD each. Discuss with the insurance agent the different options for the amount insured and any deductibles. 5.4.3. Interview the computer lab manager at a local computer project about security. Does the computer project have a security policy in place? Have they had any thefts? How did they respond to the thefts (in terms of adjusting security as a result, or recovering or replacing the stolen equipment)? 5.4.4. What data is valuable for your organization? Consider all of the information that is stored on the computer lab manager’s computer. What files there contain information that if lost would create problems for lab management or future planning? What files there contain information that is sensitive or private? Summarize your findings and include a strategy for how your organization does (or will) make regular back-up copies and also ensure that there is no unauthorized access to sensitive files. 5.4.5. Workshop Activity: Participate in a role play about interviewing suspects after a theft. 5.4.6. Workshop Activity: Look around the facility where your workshop is taking place. Note any areas that you think show insufficient security, and then participate in a group discussion about how security could be improved at that facility. Table of Contents 6. Management 6.1. Overall Definition and Purpose Management has a variety of definitions, but in general refers to the coordination of efforts, money or materials to achieve certain goals. In this section we will focus on working with people to accomplish the desired outcomes of a computer project. The specific topics of project organization, planning, leadership, and financial management will be covered in later sections. 6.2. Managing Customers, Clients and Students 6.2.1. An Important Reminder Some people are tempted to think of a manager as a boss or dictator who can rule strictly and wield power over others. While it is important to have enough structure to keep an organization running smoothly, it’s equally important not to let the use of power overshadow the overall purposes or goals of the project. The computer lab manager needs to make sure not to alienate or belittle users, and to create an atmosphere of encouragement and enthusiasm for everyone. If an encouraging atmosphere is not created, the project risks straying far from its mission. It is also important that the manager develop and implement all policies with a mind for fairness and equality for all users. 18 6.2.2. Developing, Communicating and Using Policies The idea of a security policy has already come up in this manual, but there are other valuable policies to consider as well. These policies should be thought of as tools to allow for smooth running of a computer lab or Internet café. There is no set formula for these sorts of policies as they will depend on the type of computer project and the ages of the users, but some types of policies to consider are discussed below. Whatever policies are implemented, however, it is quite important that they are thoroughly communicated to all users. This could include posting policies clearly in the lab, and including a discussion of the policies in all training sessions or orientation sessions for new users. Appropriate Use. What is the appropriate use of the computers in a computer lab? Are they there for the users to use as they see fit? Or are there activities that would be in conflict with the organization’s mission, goals or culture? While this is going to vary depending on the nature of the project, most computer labs will have some activities that they choose to prohibit. These would likely include viewing pornography over the Internet, or participating in illegal activities such as downloading pirated music or films. Some organizations might also prohibit noisy activities such as listening to music (without headphones) or making phone calls. Educational institutions are likely to focus computer use on strictly academic activities. This could result in the prohibition of computer games, online chatting, online shopping, or visiting entertainment focused websites. Email use might be restricted to a certain sub-group of students based on their age or experience with computers. Malware Prevention. As discussed in Module 1 of this course, computer viruses and other malware can cause significant problems for a computer lab. Any computer user education that occurs at a computer project should include some information about viruses and how to avoid them. In addition, however, some policies for virus prevention should be considered. Since USB flash drives are one of the major tools for spreading malware, a policy could prohibit the use of these flash drives, or require them to be scanned by computer lab staff before they can be used. Users can also download malware, often unwittingly. Policies prohibiting the downloading of software may help here, as will adjusting the security settings on a browser program or firewall (discussed in Module 4) to avoid accidental downloads. User File Storage. Most computer lab and Internet café users do not have their own computers, so the options for storing their own files are limited. Using a USB flash drive is a common method, but has the virus problems previously discussed. If a policy prohibits flash drive use, the computer lab might allow users to copy (burn) their files onto CD-ROM disks and also provide some training on this procedure. Other options include encouraging online document storage, which is available for free through several companies, or allowing users to store their information in certain locations on specific computers. If choosing the latter option, the computer lab will need to make (and communicate) a policy about how these files will be stored (such as naming standards and appropriate locations) and when these files will be periodically removed from the user computers to free up space for others. 19 Equitable Time and Resource Sharing. It is likely that there will be some times when a computer lab will very busy, and there will be some resources (perhaps a particular educational disk) that are very popular. The lab manager should consider the organization’s mission again here. It probably doesn’t serve the mission to let a small group of people dominate the most precious times of day or resources for all users. In this case it would be helpful to develop and communicate policies to “share the wealth” a bit more fairly. For an Internet café or a school computer project this could include setting time limits on users during peak time periods. A school computer project might also consider designating the open access time for different groups of users on a rotating schedule. For example, grade 10 pupils use the lab on Mondays; grade 11 pupils on Tuesdays, etc. If adopting such a schedule, the computer lab manager will need to consider how to accommodate teacher computer use in a way that also seems fair and consistent with the project mission. 6.2.3. Managing and Assisting Unskilled Users What happens when an unskilled user enters an Internet café? They probably have a specific mission. Someone has asked them to send an email, or Tips for Assisting Unskilled Users to look up a particular web page. Perhaps they are searching for 1. Be encouraging and enthusiastic but also discrete. work and have been told that The user may be ashamed of his or her lack of they need to prepare a CV. In knowledge. these situations it is not 2. Ask questions to further asses the needs of this lab unreasonable for a lab manager user. Is there a simple request you can help with? to think: “Ugh. Where do I 3. If the user would like some general/overall start?” The manager may be too assistance, here are some strategies to try busy to help, or worried that the a. Encourage another user to allow the new user new user will somehow damage to observe their work for a while, so that they a computer. The manager needs can gain familiarity with the operation of a to remember, however, that it is computer. important not to scare off b. Ask another lab worker or volunteer to assist potential users or learners. c. Make an appointment with the user for an Success with this individual could introductory one-on-one lesson. result in the person becoming a d. Encourage the new user to sign up for a basic IT training course participant or skills course regular lab user. The tip box here includes some tips for More tips on working with learners are provided in assisting unskilled users. Module 3. 6.2.4. Technical Tools for Managing Users Given some of the concerns presented in the last two sections, a computer lab manager might consider using a tool that limits what lab users can do on a computer. To accomplish this task, there are several types of Internet café management software available, some even at no cost. In addition to monitoring the time a customer is on a computer and calculating usage costs, Internet café management software can also be set up to limit the customer’s access to a 20 computer’s hard drive. Some Internet café management software prevents access to prohibited websites, and prevents the downloading of programs. This software does require that the computers are networked via a server. Server use is covered briefly in Module 4 of this course. Two examples of free Internet café management programs are HandyCafe (www.handycafe.com) for Windows servers and OutKafe (http://outkastsolutions.co.za) for Linux servers. Another option for protecting a computer from unintentional changes made by inexperienced users is to install software that limits some users from accessing certain programs or tools on a computer and also can be used to clean off unwanted files and changes by “resetting” a computer to known configuration periodically. Microsoft has a program called SteadyState that is available for free for use on computers running licensed copies of a Microsoft Windows operating system. More information is available on the Microsoft website. 6.3. Managing Coworkers 6.3.1. Who are a Lab Manager’s Coworkers? Coworkers are anyone who a lab manager works with on a regular basis towards the goal of having a smoothly operating computer project. They could include any of the following groups: Steering Committee Members. This is a particularly important group to have a good working relationship with, since they have significant impact on the overall plan and implementation for a computer project. For more information about steering committees, see A Handbook for Telecenter Staffs (Colle, R.D. and Roman, R. 2003. Cornell University). Available online at: http://ip.cals.cornell.edu/commdev/handbook.cfm Assistant Lab Managers. In a large computer project or Internet café, it’s possible that additional staff would be hired to assist in daily operations Interns. Typically these are young adults who are looking for some on-the-job experience and training. They are hired for a limited period of time and are ideally given opportunities to do work that is challenging and educational for them. Student Lab Monitors. In a school computer project some specially selected and trained pupils can be of significant assistance in the daily running of a computer project. They are usually willing to volunteer in exchange for some extra training and some unique privileges (such as extra time in the computer lab or permission to use email). Student monitor tasks include setting up equipment in the morning, filling out log book entries for users or equipment, offering assistance to less skilled users, providing additional security, and assisting with lab cleaning. Volunteers. In a school or community computer project, there may be skilled members of the surrounding community (or even visitors from abroad) who would like to volunteer their services for the benefit of the project. These volunteers should be encouraged and given opportunities to assist users or the lab manager in a way that best suits their skills. Having a visiting volunteer offer a training session in a subject of interest to them can be a good way to build excitement for a computer project. 21 6.3.2. Tone, Expectations and Motivation With all coworkers, the manager’s first job is to set an appropriate tone for their relationship with the coworker and the coworker’s relationship to the project. This should be a tone of encouragement and enthusiasm with all coworkers. The coworkers should know that they are a part of an exciting program and that their efforts are truly appreciated. While it is important to maintain professionalism in a computer lab, the atmosphere can be both professional and exciting at the same time. The manager should demonstrate and share expectations for professional conduct. This includes the following: Keeping Time. The lab manager and all coworkers should be expected to show up for work on time and begin and end all training sessions according to posted schedules. Wearing Appropriate Attire. This will vary depending on the organization and the standards of the surrounding community, but the manager should make sure to set and discuss reasonable standards for clothing. All workers, however, should be encouraged to wear comfortable shoes due to the length of time they may be standing. Conversing Professionally. Workers should avoid using language that is offensive to the community, and be particularly sensitive to the groups (such as women and racial or religious minorities) who may be the target of derogatory language. Coworkers should also avoid discussing dating or making personal overtures to other coworkers or lab users. This could be considered harassment by some and is certainly distracting from the purpose of the computer lab. The lab manager also should make sure that all coworkers see themselves as valuable parts of a vibrant system. It is important that the manager make sure that all coworkers have opportunities to participate in the lab in ways that are exciting, engaging and if possible educational for them. While it is true, for example, that the sweeping does need to be done, no one coworker should always be put in charge of the sweeping. The manager should encourage everyone to learn and practice new skills as they work. The manager should periodically consider what will motivate all employees to perform their best and keep improving. Motivation may take the form of celebrations and thank-you gifts, opportunities for employees to earn privileges or equipment, or opportunities for employees to attend workshops or otherwise continue their education. 6.3.3. Preparing and Sharing Job Descriptions All employees of a computer lab (including the lab manager him or herself) should have clear job descriptions prepared and then discussed with them. Prospective employees should be given job descriptions to review before being hired for a job. When job descriptions are being updated or revised, the employees should have an opportunity to provide input into the job description. Preparation of job descriptions should be the joint responsibility of the computer lab manager and his or her steering committee or supervisor. Below are some key items to include in a job description. 22 An overview of all tasks to be performed (management, instruction, security, record keeping etc.) An indication of typical allocation of hours (in other words, how many hours in the average week should be spent on each task) Prohibited tasks (outside paid work, computer games, etc.) Work hours (specific days and times) Holidays and personal leave (how many days can be taken, procedure for requesting leave, etc.) 6.3.4. Setting and Keeping Work Schedules Setting clear work schedules with all coworkers (including volunteers) is important for the smooth running of a computer project. The manager needs to balance the needs of the individual coworker with the needs of the project, and find the best compromise possible. Once work schedules are set, it is then the manager’s job to make sure that they are communicated clearly and seen as important. In cultures where keeping to a time schedule is seen as a low priority, the lab manager will need to remind coworkers of the importance of giving the computer lab users enough time to use their precious resource. The computer lab manager may also want to consider in advance what strategy to use with employees that consistently are not keeping to their work schedule. Sometimes, despite everyone’s best intentions, life problems prevent someone from appearing for a scheduled work shift. This most likely occurs due to an illness. All coworkers should be encouraged to contact the lab manager as soon as they know that they will be late or absent from a work shift. If the computer lab manager is ill, he or she would need to communicate his or her absence to the supervisor or a designated individual on the project steering committee. Before an emergency occurs, though, the computer lab manager should discuss this with the project steering committee to develop a plan for these eventualities. Questions to address include: Who should open the computer lab in the morning if the manager is not present? How can security still be prioritized with reduced staffing? and Is there someone who can fill in during scheduled lessons or training sessions if the instructor is not available? There are no set answers to these questions. Some steering committees may decide to pull people from other work in order to maintain “business as usual” whereas other organizations may decide that they do not have enough staffing flexibility and thus need to reduce hours or postpone events. 6.3.5. Performance Reviews A performance review (also called a performance appraisal) is a periodic opportunity for an employer and an employee to together review an employee’s performance and make an action plan for his or her work in the future. Performance reviews are an important tool in helping employees to meet their full working potential. While they often have the negative image of being associated with disciplinary action for an employee, they can also be used in a positive ways. A performance review might be a good opportunity to formally praise an employee for a job well done. A performance review can also be used to help avoid disciplinary action by instead setting performance targets and identifying training needs. It is best if 23 performance reviews occur on a regular basis (such as annually) and are not associated directly with the contract renewal process. There are many methods used for performance reviews, and each organization’s steering committee should determine the method that best suits their purposes. One simple method is shown in the tip box here. Tips for Performing an Employee Performance Review 1. Distribute copies of the employee’s job description to the employee and a few coworkers. 2. After allowing time for everyone to review the job description, collect confidential feedback from the employee and his or her coworkers about how the employee is meeting the expectations of the job description. If possible, feedback would be collected from people who work at a variety of different levels of responsibility within the organization. 3. Combine the feedback collected with your own insights in order to prepare a report that includes praise for the employee, a description of any areas of concern about the employee’s performance and recommended actions that be taken to help the employee improve as needed. 4. Be mindful of the fact that some employees will have a tendency to focus on the negative feedback they receive and may not fully hear the positive feedback. Therefore it is important that you emphasize the positive feedback and if possible end both the written report and any meetings about the report on a positive note. 5. Discuss this report privately with the employee and then distribute it to the project steering committee. 6.4. Assignments/Activities 6.4.1. Visit a computer lab and observe the interactions between the lab manager (or other staff) and lab users/clients. Did the lab manager communicate policies and procedures as needed? Did the users/clients feel as though their needs were being met? Summarize your findings. 6.4.2. For your current place of work, who are you coworkers? Make a list of everyone you work with (if it’s a large number, you can consider categories of people (i.e. “security guards” and “instructors”, rather than individuals). For each category of coworker, answer the following questions: What are your common goals? What areas are you likely to have conflict in (professionally, not personally)? What is most important about your communication with them? 6.4.3. What motivates you to do your best work? If you were your supervisor, what could you reasonably do to help motivate you? Summarize your thoughts. 6.4.4. If you are already employed in a computer lab, have a conversation with your steering committee chair or supervisor about your computer lab project. Ask the supervisor what his or her dreams, expectations, and fears are about the project. Also provide your own answers to these questions. Summarize your findings during the conversation. 6.4.5. Do you currently have a job description? If so, read it and review it. Does it match your daily work? Is it thorough enough in guiding your work? If you don’t have a job description, draft a job description for your current work (or for a friend if you are unemployed). 24 6.4.6. Learn more about either Internet café management software (by doing and Internet search or seeing the examples in section 6.2.4) or Microsoft Windows SteadyState (go to http://www.microsoft.com/windows/products/winfamily/sharedaccess/default.mspx). What hardware and other software is needed to run these programs? What technical skill is required of the manager? 6.4.7. Workshop Activity: Participate in a discussion about setting a schedule for a computer project. The instructor will give you a scenario for a particular project including the number of staff, the types of users and their different interests and needs. The group will discuss the scenario and suggest a weekly schedule. 6.4.8. Workshop Activity: Participate in a role play with a staff member about a performance issue. 6.4.9. Workshop Activity: Experiment with a computer using Microsoft Windows SteadyState or with a computer lab running Internet café management software. 6.4.10. Workshop Activity: Develop a job description for an intern or student computer lab monitor. Share your draft job description with the group and collect feedback from the other participants. Table of Contents 7. Leadership, Time Management and Project Organization 7.1. Leadership Overview 7.1.1. Characteristics of Leaders What are the characteristics of a leader? There surely are many different answers to this question, and certainly not all leaders have the same character, but here are some characteristics to consider: Proactive. This term refers to a person who pushes to make the progress they want to see happen. Instead of waiting for others to take the lead, this person investigates possibilities, and seeks opportunity and partnerships as needed. The proactive leader does need to be careful, though, not to be so pushy or aggressive that they overwhelm others. Creative. The creative leader is one who looks at problem and does not see a dead end. Instead this person thinks “what are some different ways I can work around this?” and then experiments until that way is found. A related concept is being innovative, or looking for new and different ideas. Inclusive. The inclusive leader is a person who makes sure that a new project is undertaken as a team effort, and that the needs and opinions of all stakeholders are considered and (if possible) incorporated. The inclusive leader recognizes that there will be much greater support in a community for a project if the ideas and needs of the community are taken into account from the beginning. This also requires the leader to be a good listener, taking care to hear all ideas, even those that he or she disagrees with. 25 The leader also should not lose sight of some important managerial skills that have already been discussed in this module. For example, it is important that the leader be well organized, in order to keep track of all of the documents and materials involved in a project. The leader should also be a good communicator, so that everyone stays connected and has opportunities to contribute to the effort. Empowerment (in both the attitude and the working environment) is also important, as discussed in section 2.2 of this module. 7.1.2. What if You Aren’t a “Born Leader”? Some readers of this text might feel a bit intimidated now. They may feel that they don’t have any of the characteristics described above, and therefore cannot lead. While not all of us are “born leaders” that does not mean we cannot learn the skills involved! This is certainly an area where “practice makes perfect” and a good way to start is by leading a small project and using it as a learning experience. People who are in leadership roles for the first time should consider watching and learning from other leaders around them, and even asking those they are working with on a project to provide advice on how they wish to be lead. A new leader will likely find that people are very encouraging and supportive of his or her efforts. 7.1.3. Watch the Attitude! It is important to note that a project leader (or any computer lab manager) should not be a dictator. A lab manager may start to feel that since he or she was asked to lead a certain project, then he or she can force everyone to comply with his or her demands. This attitude, however, is likely to alienate the people that the manager is working with and not contribute to an open and sharing environment. It is important to remember that great ideas and valuable skills can be contributed from a variety of individuals at all the different levels of an organization. People should be encouraged to participate and collaborate where possible. There may be times when a manager is required to delegate undesirable tasks. This can be done, however, with significant appreciation, and communication about the importance of the task. Hopefully the individuals asked to perform these undesirable tasks will also have opportunities to be involved in more enjoyable or enriching tasks. 7.2. Time Management Good time management is important for both the daily running of a computer lab and for those taking on special projects. Both aspects of time management are discussed here. 7.2.1. Consistent Operating Hours and Activity Schedules For a computer project or Internet cafe to be successful, lab users and clients need to know when they can come and use the computers. If a potential user comes during the advertised hours and finds no one present, they may become discouraged and never come again. It is therefore important that operating hours be posted and adhered to clearly. If a schedule change needs to be made on a rare occasion, the change should be posted as far in advance of the time change as possible. 26 To emphasize this point further, managers need to make sure that they understand the importance of actually keeping to the posted time. If the posted schedule says that the lab opens at 8:00 in the morning, then the lab should be opened at exactly 8:00! Potential users that appear on time will not be impressed by the dedication of the staff if they are not there as scheduled. In addition, if a manager in a school computer project is scheduled to begin a lesson at 10:00, then they should genuinely begin the lesson at that time and not wait until all of the learners are present. Those who are present will be rewarded with a lesson that lasts the full time slot, and those who arrive late will see how committed the rest of the group is and may consider changing their behavior for the next lesson. Setting daily schedules for an educational computer project is an important way to manage time and distribute it fairly amongst all users. The tip box here provides some tips for developing a schedule for an educational computer lab. Once a daily schedule has been set, it is important that it be widely publicized. Posting a schedule on the computer lab door, in classrooms and in various gathering spaces will both inform users of when they can come and serve as a reminder of the opportunities available to them in the computer lab. Tips for Developing a Schedule for an Educational Computer Lab When setting a computer lab schedule, make sure that you address the questions below: 1. Consider the different user groups – do they each have time slots for using the lab that match their availability? 2. Do all students get an equal share of time in the lab? 3. Are time limits set so that individual users don’t monopolize the resource? 4. Are teachers/instructors given more flexible access to the computer lab (in a way that doesn’t disturb organized lessons and activities)? 5. Does your daily schedule reflect the goals of your organization? 7.2.2. Daily Time Organization for the Computer Lab Manager The Lab Manager for is likely to have some tasks during his or her day that have to occur at fixed times (such as set-up, clean-up and scheduled lessons) and other tasks that need to occur, but not at a particular time (such as offering individual assistance, keeping up with correspondence and organizational tasks, repairing equipment and eating lunch). If there are specific tasks that a lab manager wants to make sure happen that day, it is wise to begin the day by thinking about when these events should occur and even making a note on his or her daily calendar or diary to schedule the event. Keeping an up to date “to do” list of important tasks is also helpful. There are times when a computer lab manager is completing a task that involves long pauses. For example, this can occur when a lab manager is downloading a file from the Internet or reimaging a computer. During these times it is appropriate for the lab manager to multi-task (work on another task alongside the first one). Perhaps they can catch up on email? Or look for good educational resources on the Internet? Or update a computer inventory? It is also good 27 for a computer lab manager to think ahead about tasks that can be done during the following situations: The lab manager’s computer is busy with other tasks (such as reinstalling a program) The Internet is not available There is a power outage Having a list in advance of activities that can be performed during these times will help the computer lab manager become more efficient and productive. 7.2.3. Time Management in a Project When the computer lab manager is leading a team on a new project, such as developing a new training course, it’s important to consider the implementation time frame for the project very carefully. Initial enthusiasm for a project can inspire people to give unrealistically short time frames (such as “we will write the curriculum in the next two weeks”), without thinking about how they will manage all of the other work they need to do as a part of daily life. People also often don’t realize how long effective communication takes. For example, if you are requesting feedback via email and an important stakeholder only checks email weekly, you will need to allow sufficient time for this communication method to work (or consider other methods of communication). Continuing with the training course example, time also needs to be allowed to gather funds for a project, provide orientation or training for the trainers, recruit and confirm participants, and gather all needed supplies. When setting the time frame for a new project, the leader should come prepared with a list of steps that he or she knows will be involved in project implementation. For each of these steps, the team should consider how long the job will take and whether it needs to be done in a specific order. In addition, some additional time should be included for unanticipated tasks or issues that develop. With this approach, a realistic time frame for project implementation can be developed. 7.3. Organizing and Leading Meetings A computer lab manager is likely to have an opportunity to organize or lead a meeting while working in a computer lab. This could be a meeting of a team that is organizing an event or planning a workshop. It could also be a meeting called to address a problem, or it could be a meeting called to review or evaluate an event or project. Whatever the reason for the meeting, it will be more productive if it is well organized and well lead. The main tasks for organizing a meeting are communicating with participants and setting the agenda. Effective communication with participants begins with setting a meeting date and time, sending invitations and receiving RSVPs (replies indicating whether or not someone will attend). In this process, it helps (if it is logistically possible) to include the participants in the decision making about the date and time for the meeting. The organizer can propose a few dates and times and see which one works the best for the participants. Communication with participants should continue to include reminder phone calls or emails to ensure attendance. In a well organized meeting, the organizer has also prepared an agenda in advance. If possible, the organizer comes up with some ideas and emails the participants to ask them if 28 there is anything else that needs to be included. During the meeting one of the first items of business should be an agenda review, to give participants another opportunity to suggest additions or changes. Below is an example of a meeting agenda outline for one meeting in an ongoing series of meetings. Agenda Review Review of either the minutes of the previous meeting or action items (promised activities) from the last meeting. Agenda item #1 Agenda item #2 Agenda item #3 Next Steps: o Review of action items from this meeting o Listing agenda items for next meeting o Setting date, time and location for next meeting Some meetings also begin and close with prayer, but meeting organizers need to be sensitive to the varying faiths of the participants and should not assume that all meeting participants will be inspired by the ministry of one participant. During a meeting, it is the meeting leader’s (facilitator’s) responsibility to make sure that the meeting runs well and is productive. Some important tips for leading meetings are included in the tip box here. Another important responsibility for a group leader (meeting facilitator) is to make the meeting as inclusive as possible. This can be a challenge in a large group meeting, but even in those situations it is valuable to have as many different voices heard as possible. Based on the numbers of people and the needs of the group, it may or may not be important for the group members to raise their hands and be recognized by the facilitator before speaking. If hand raising is used, the Tips for Leading Successful and Productive Meetings 1. It is your responsibility to make sure that the group starts the meeting on time. It is not fair to those who have come on time to have to wait a long time for tardy participants. 2. Make sure that the group sticks to the agreed upon agenda. If a participant is leading the group into another topic, gently remind the participant of the item that is being discussed. If the group agrees that this new topic is important to discuss, it can be added in as an agenda item at the next meeting, or the group can agree to change the agenda to accommodate this item. 3. Keep an eye on the time. If it appears that a particular agenda item is taking up all the time, ask the group if it is more important to finish that agenda item or continue with the rest of the agenda. 4. When the group agrees to items that require action, make sure that volunteers are sought to complete the required actions. You do not want any “gray areas” in which participants are unclear about who is going to do the work. 29 facilitator can be sure to call on a variety of people. If many hands are raised, the facilitator might need to keep a list of the people waiting to speak, so that no one is forgotten. In a small group where people are speaking freely, the facilitator still might want to call on a quiet participant to make sure that they feel encouraged to share ideas. The facilitator also needs to become aware of when productive conversation has ended. The group members may have begun to repeat themselves, or some meeting attendees may be showing signs of losing interest. When this happens, the facilitator might suggest that agreement has been reached and check to make sure that is the case. Or if it is clear that agreement has not been reached, the facilitator could suggest that the item be raised again at the next meeting. If it is an issue that is both important and requires immediate action, then the facilitator could call for a vote of those present, or suggest that the issue be sent to a higher authority for decision. 7.4. Documentation Some readers might now be thinking “Ugh! Documentation means writing….I’m not a writer!” Preparing meeting minutes and reports can be very intimidating for people who don’t have much experience writing or are poor typists. The tip box here includes some tips for those of you who find yourself worrying about documentation. Tips for First Time Minute Takers 1. Give yourself plenty of time. You don’t want to feel too rushed or pressured to get a report done. 2. Use the meeting agenda as an organizational tool for your minutes. The agenda items can be the headings for the different sections of your notes. 3. Give yourself permission not to do a perfect job. Readers will appreciate the fact that you are trying, and you will improve with practice. 4. Be willing to ask for and accept suggestions for improvement. Consider any negative feedback you get as a part of a good learning experience, and not some judgment of your character. 5. Keep practicing your touch typing (using the resources suggested in the introduction to this course in Module 1). Over time you will become much more efficient at typing up minutes. 7.4.1. When and Why to Document If there are some lab managers who are still reluctant to take minutes or write reports after the above tips, perhaps a discussion of the purpose of documentation would be helpful. Imagine this scenario: Two coworkers are organizing a celebration for the graduates of a significant training program. They meet informally to figure out what preparations need to be done. Then the day of the event arrives and they discover that each one of them thought that the other person was responsible for obtaining soft drinks. It ends up being a thirsty crowd! Taking notes, even informally, of the planning meeting could have avoided this problem. In preparation for the event, each coworker might have looked at the notes and asked: “Is there anything in here that I forgot about?” 30 Here are some questions to ask when deciding whether or not someone needs to write up minutes from a meeting or a report from an event: Did enough things happen at the event/meeting that the participants are likely to forget some of them in the near future? Were the discussions at the meeting complicated enough that reviewing notes later might help some people to understand the discussions more fully? Was there anyone who was not present at the meeting or an event that would want to be involved or know what occurred? Did the meeting or event involve significant expenditures of funds or decisions to spend funds? Are there donors who would like to know how a particular project they have funded is proceeding? 7.4.2. Preparing Reports and Minutes Once a decision has been made to record minutes for a meeting or write a report for an event, there are several other factors to be considered. First, the manager might be wondering how much information needs to be written. This is certainly going to vary depending on the style of the writer and the needs of the recipients, and the manager is going to have to discover by experience (and the feedback he or she receives) what works best. At a minimum, though, the minutes for a meeting should include a list of all attendees (unless a very large group), all agenda items, all topics discussed, and all decisions that are made. When reporting an event, the attendees and agenda are both important. Any significant outcomes or recommendations for future events should also be reported. For both meetings and events, the recorder is not going to be able to keep track of every word that is spoken, and should not attempt to do so. However, the key points of the discussion should be included. Here is an example of a discussion summary: “The group discussed the pros and cons of switching Internet providers. It was stated that the current provider, Smith Communication, offers the best price in town for our bandwidth level, but it was also noted that the customer service offered by Smith has been poor.” One time-saving tool for preparing minutes and reports is to use a template. This is a document that is already formatted properly for the minutes or report, and includes text (such as headings) that will be the same for all meeting minutes or event reports. These templates can be created by a lab manager to meet the needs of the group that he or she participates in, or they can be found online (for MS Word templates see http://office.microsoft.com/enus/templates/ct101172601033.aspx). In MS Word a template can be saved as a template file (the file extension is .dot) instead of as a regular document. Each time a user opens a template file a new document based on that template is automatically created. The template file itself is saved in its original state for the next use. Once the minutes or a report has been prepared, the lab manager should proof read it before distribution. Items to look out for are in the list below: Are the spelling and grammar correct? 31 Does the tone appropriately represent the event (not too negative, for example)? Is the document professional (avoiding colloquial expressions or inside jokes)? Will someone who was unable to attend the event find the minutes or report understandable and useful? After these items are attended to, the minutes or report can be distributed. Often a group will have a policy of first distributing a draft only to those who were in attendance, asking for corrections or other feedback within a certain time period. After this feedback has been received and incorporated, then the final minutes or report is distributed more widely. 7.5. Assignments/Activities 7.5.1. Review the leadership characteristics described in section 6.1, and then assess yourself in these areas. In what ways are you a strong leader and in what areas do you need to improve? Set yourself some goals for improving your leadership skill and some activities that will help you reach those goals. 7.5.2. Can you stick to a daily schedule? Attempt this challenge: choose a typical work day in the near future, and set yourself a schedule that includes start and end times for all activities that you plan on engaging in. At the end of the day, evaluate your performance. Did you pay enough attention to the clock to move on when needed? Had you set a realistic and achievable schedule in the first place? Had you forgotten to include some necessary work (or personal time)? Did unforeseen events arise that challenged your ability to stick to the schedule? If so, how did you react? 7.5.3. Imagine that you are a part of an ongoing team that meets to review the activity of an Internet café and suggest improvements for the project. You are the designated minutes taker for these meetings. Prepare a template that could be used for minute taking that includes all headings and recurring agenda items. 7.5.4. Analyze a meeting you recently attended. Describe the meeting purpose, and then answer these questions: Did the meeting facilitator (leader) keep the group on track and on time? Did the meeting facilitator make sure that all voices were heard? Did the participants act as a team or were there significant conflicting interests or opinions? What else about the meeting went well or went poorly? 7.5.5. Workshop Activity: Participate in a group discussion about time management in your culture. What can be done to help people be productive and timely while still taking cultural norms into account? 7.5.6. Workshop Activity: Participate in a role play on leading a meeting. Your instructors will describe the meeting topic and assign specific roles to the participants. After the role play, participate in a group discussion about what went well and what could have been improved. Table of Contents 8. Planning 8.1. Planning Overview 32 We all plan at least informally in our lives. It might be planning the family dinner menus for the week, it might be planning a party for a friend, or it might be planning a strategy to complete a degree. Without any planning, our existence would be truly just day-to-day and probably less inspiring and enjoyable. The same is true for a computer project. If we don’t make plans for events or improvements, there is likely to be less excitement in running the project. In addition, if we don’t plan for certain maintenance needs (such as new light bulbs or printer cartridges) we will find that working in the computer lab is certainly less enjoyable and productive. An Internet café might even lose some customers if they haven’t planned to keep the computers up to date and performing well. There is quite a bit written about the initial planning stage for telecenters or other community computer projects. Any organization just beginning a computer project would be well advised to use the information available in the planning resources listed at the end of this module. The recommended steps for an initial project plan include community involvement, needs assessment, establishing a mission and goals, determining what services to offer, what equipment is needed and financial planning, among other topics. 8.2. Strategic Planning Even if a computer project was well planned before initial implementation, there are going to be times when more planning is needed. This could be for a variety of reasons. Perhaps the project is considering a change in direction. Or perhaps the donor funding has been exhausted and a new plan for sustainability needs to be developed. Also some donor agencies require planning before they will consider donating to a particular project or organization. The justification for this is that these donors believe that a planning process is necessary to ensure that a project is well thought out and that the right amount of funds are being provided for right purpose. Whatever the purpose of the planning, it is important that the computer lab manager not carry out the planning alone. The planning will be much more effective if it is a group process, involving at least some steering committee members, and preferably also someone with financial expertise or authority. Before beginning any sort of project planning, an organization should make sure that they have vision, mission and goals statements that will guide their planning. Here are descriptions of these statements: Vision. The vision for a project should describe an ideal future for the project. It should also give a direction, inspire action and explain why the project exists. Mission. A mission is an action-oriented statement of what the project does or why it exists. The mission statement should address these three questions: “What is the main purpose or function of the project?” “Who are the beneficiaries?” and “What needs is the project trying to address?” Goals. The goals give the specifics of the direction for a project. For example, one goal for a school computer project could be “To use computers as a source of educational information for pupils and teachers”. Goals should be realistic and achievable for the project, but they can be relatively broad. A project will probably have more than one goal. 33 Strategic planning itself is an ongoing process in which an organization envisions the future, and then determines what steps will help the organization reach that future vision. There are many different approaches used for strategic planning, and also organizations will plan for different lengths of time. A very long range plan is useful for an organization that has large goals that will only be achieved gradually. Long range planning is also valuable for projects to use as they consider equipment replacement. For example, the computers that serve an organization very well now will likely be quite slow and out of date in 5 years time. A long range plan can ensure that there will be funds available to replace those computers in 5 years. One tool used for planning is called a Logical Framework (Log Frame). This is a valuable tool for an organization because it ties all objectives into the activities that will result from the objectives and the outcomes that are expected from these activities. In other words, a log frame describes the process that the organization will follow to meet their objectives. A log frame can cover a short or long time frame, depending on how long an organization thinks it will take them to meet their goals. Since many computer projects will work with institutions that have annual funding cycles, a process for developing a one year log frame is suggested here. The different elements of a simple log frame are described below1: Objectives. These are specific changes or outcomes that are desired for your project. They do not describe the activities, but the concrete goals in a specific area. They use words that indicate change such as “increase”, “decrease”, “strengthen” and “improve”. They also are SMART (Specific, Measurable, Appropriate, Realistic and Time-bound). A project may have several objectives that combine to match the overall project goals. These objectives could be about infrastructure (facilities and equipment) or they could be about the programs (computer training, academic use of computers, etc.) that the project delivers. Example objectives for a computer education project could be: “Improve IT training for pupils by starting a vocational IT skills training project within the next year.” Or “Increase number of computers available for users from 15 to 20.” Activities. These are the specific actions that will result in meeting the above objectives. Activities can be events that occur in the computer lab or “behind the scenes” activities such as purchasing. There can be several activities under each objective. Example activities for a computer education project could be “Offer computer repair training to 20 school leavers” or “Increase seating capacity in the computer lab to 40 learners”. Indicators. These are the evidence for whether or not the activities have been carried out and the objectives achieved. This is the information or data that an organization will collect to monitor its projects. Examples from the above activities are “number of school 1 Find Your Way in Successful Fundraising, Irma Knieriem & Ashley Wheaton VSO Volunteers, Zambia (2006) 34 leavers completing computer repair course”, “feedback from school leavers completing computer repair course” and “numbers of new desks and chairs purchased”. Means of Verification (MOV’s). These are the methods that an organization will use for measuring, verifying or analyzing their indicators. They are also the tools used in an evaluation process. Some example MOV’s are listed here: o Collecting inventories and attendance lists o Collecting, analyzing and reporting information from users (such as number and purpose of visits) o Collecting and analyzing information on lab income, before and after institution of a new income generating venture o Holding periodic meetings of stakeholders and asking them to reflect on how the project is meeting its goals o Conducting and analyzing written surveys of stakeholders o Conducting and analyzing individual interviews with stakeholders o For a school computer project - Comparing performance indicators (such as exam scores in academic subjects, or rate of employment after leaving school) for lab users and non users o For a school computer project - Comparing performance indicators (such as exam scores in academic subjects) for lab users before and after improvement of a project element. One layout for a simple log frame is shown here, with example text included. Notice that it allows for multiple activities for a single objective. Objectives 1 Improve quality of IT instruction for pupils 2 Increase number of pupils who are trained at one time Log Frame for School Computer Project Activities Indicators Means of Verification 1.1 Send two IT Number of teachers Collecting receipts and instructors for receiving further certificates from training further training training courses Number of pupils Comparing pupil scores on improving in IT exams and projects, before performance and after instructor training 1.2 Purchase an LCD Projector is Projector is in use, and projector and train purchased receipt has been collected instructors on its and included in a report proper use Projector is used by Pupils are surveyed about instructors, and is projector use and improving pupil understanding understanding 2.1 Organize and Pupil attendance Comparing pupil attendance implement a system improves records before and after for informing pupils implementing system of upcoming lessons 35 2.2 Purchase 4 additional used desk top computers 3 Develop a small Internet café as an income generating venture 3.1 Purchase 2 additional used desk top computers 3.2 Train intern to advertise and manage Internet cafe 3.3 Operate Internet cafe Four additional computers are purchased and installed Two additional computers are purchased and installed in designated area for Internet cafe Intern receives training Computers are in use and receipts have been collected and included in reports Computers are in use and receipts have been collected and included in Internet café project report Collecting receipt and certificate from training course (or if informal training, report from instructor) Internet café is in Preparing financial operation and raising statements for café funds operation and including them in Internet café project report 8.3. Planning and Managing a Special Event It is likely that a computer lab manager is at some point going to be asked to organize a special event. This could be a workshop, a celebration, or perhaps an outing of some sort for people involved in the computer lab. When planning such an event, it is best to start as soon as possible and get others to help in the process. Beginning with a team planning meeting is a good start (see organizing and leading meetings in section 7.3). For a workshop, here are some of the items that would need to be planned: Workshop purpose, agenda and trainers Workshop budget (fees for trainers and assistants, printing learning materials, facility rental, paper and printing for certificates, refreshments, talk time and transport for organizers) and resulting cost for participants Invitation letters for participants, including costs and registration deadline Detailed schedule including work assignments for trainers and assistants How workshop will be evaluated and reported Arrangements for collecting training materials, refreshments and any other needed supplies 8.4. Assignments/Activities 8.4.1. Do some web research about organizations working on promoting ICT use in developing countries, or ICT4D. For three different organizations, summarize what you found about their mission, vision or goals. This information is often found on an “About Us” page. Then look at some of the activities reported on the web pages for these three 36 organizations. Do the activities relate to or seem to be guided by the mission, vision or goals? Explain briefly. 8.4.2. Does your organization have Mission, Vision and Goals statements? If not, take some time to draft the statements that you personally think would work for your organization. If they do have these statements, take some time to compare them to the work done by your organization. Are the Mission, Vision and Goals statements reflected in the daily activity of your project? Does it appear that these statements guided the project development? 8.4.3. Imagine that your organization (or if you are not employed, a community project in your town) is going to undergo a strategic planning process. Who should be on the planning team? List their names (or positions) and what expertise or important views they would bring to the planning process. 8.4.4. Build a log frame for a small community computer project that has the following objectives: 1. Increase the number of community computer members who can use computers at the same time. 2. Establish a broad band Internet connection. 3. Use the project computers to provide relevant agriculture information. Complete all sections of the log frame, making guesses about the project and costs as needed. 8.4.5. Workshop Activity: Working with a team, brainstorm about common small parts that need to be repaired and replaced in a computer lab. Consider how many of these items are used and how often they fail. Then make a plan/schedule for replacing small parts in a typical computer lab. Be as specific as possible about the parts that need to be repaired or replaced and the time frame for this. If time allows at the workshop, also draft an annual budget for small part repair and replacement. 8.4.6. Workshop Activity: Imagine that you are on a team that is organizing a half day workshop on computer lab security. First you will participate in a group brainstorming session about all of the work that will need to be done to plan and prepare for the workshop. Then you will be assigned a small team that will plan one aspect of this workshop, and then report back to the larger group. Table of Contents 9. Financial Management 9.1. Overall Purpose Why do we need to manage money in a computer project? Compare a computer project to a family with a small income. Both entities have frequent and occasional expenditures that need to be accommodated. The comparison is clarified in the table below. Comparison of Family and Computer Project Expenditures Expenditure Type Family Computer Project High Frequency Food, Electricity, Rent, Internet, Electricity, Rent, Transportation Salaries Medium Frequency School Fees, Household Small Equipment Supplies, Clothes Repair/Replacement, Ink 37 Low Frequency (but typically expensive) Large Household Appliances, Vehicles, Purchasing a Home, Higher Education Cartridges, Learning Materials Computer Replacement, Major Facilities Repair/Upgrade or Expansion, Implementation of a New Major Program When a family does not manage scarce financial resources, it is likely that they will account for the high frequency items, which often demand immediate attention, but not think about the medium and low frequency items, even though these are also of high importance. The same problem could occur with a computer project. It is true that there isn’t always enough money to save for the low frequency items, but with good financial planning and money management skills, both a family and a computer project have a better chance of getting to those items than if they did not plan at all. 9.2. Planning for Sustainability When a computer project plans for the medium and low frequency events in the above table, they are planning for sustainability. A project will last if it doesn’t just ask “How are we going to pay the salaries next month?” but instead thinks “What is our long term strategy for making this project last?”. The project steering committee needs to forecast what is going to be needed to maintain the project at its current level (the medium frequency expenditures in the above table) and what is going to keep the project competitive and exciting (the low frequency expenditures). The steering committee can also be thinking of ways to break down large expenses into more manageable amounts. For example, instead of planning to replace 20 computers in one year, the committee could plan to replace 4 computers a year over a period of 5 years. A computer project is financially sustainable either when it brings in sufficient income to cover expenses, or it delivers on a social mission so effectively that the project is worthy of continued donor funding2 . A steering committee should spend significant time strategizing how it will become financially sustainable while developing a financial plan for an organization. The next three paragraphs discuss some different strategies for becoming financially sustainable. One logical strategy for financial sustainability for many computer projects is to charge user fees. This is the most likely source of income for an Internet café. School and college computer labs can also generate funds from user fees, but this needs to be taken care of in a way that is not counter to school goals or requirements (for example, a primary school in Zambia could not charge user fees because of the commitment that the Zambian government has made to free primary education for all), and with full support of the school’s PTA. Any educational institution charging user fees would be wise to take care of these fees through the 2 12 Habits of Highly Effective ICT-Enabled Development Initiatives, Bridges.Org, www.bridges.org/12_habits, accessed October 28, 2009 38 bursar’s office and alongside tuition. Therefore learners who cannot pay can make arrangements through the bursar’s office (as they would for their tuition) and will not be prevented from entering the computer lab. Both Internet cafes and educational computer projects need to make sure that they set fees that are reasonable for their users. If the majority of the target audience cannot afford the fees, the project will certainly not survive. If user fees cannot cover all likely expenses, an organization might consider offering additional services that can generate more income, either because they are perceived to be of higher value or because they attract a wealthier clientele. For example, an Internet café or school computer project could consider offering computer skills courses to members of the surrounding community. When planning these courses, the organization would need to make sure that these courses did not interfere with the core activities of the project. A school project may decide, for example, that community courses can only be offered in the evenings when there are no pupils using the lab. When setting budgets for these courses, the organization would need to take into account any additional staff training that was necessary as well as extra pay for staff that are required to work longer hours. If additional funding is still needed, the steering committee can make an appeal to donors in the government or non-profit arena. The justification here will need to be as stated previously – this project is so valuable to the local community and is delivering so well on its social mission, that it deserves ongoing support. Perhaps the project can become a demonstration model for a community development organization or a new government project, or it can be adopted by a local private business as a part of their corporate social responsibility plan. In some cases, ongoing equipment donations could also be considered a part of sustainable operation, as long as donor organization can be counted on for ongoing donations. 9.3. The Financial Planning Process Financial planning should be a part of the overall project planning process, so that an organization is aware of what its initiatives will cost and has a good strategy for raising these funds and sustaining the organization. In fact, the more an organization is able to think about its long term plans (and those low frequency but big expenditures discussed earlier), the more successful their financial planning will be. Advice on long term financial planning is readily available on the Internet. For this text, we will focus on the financial planning for an organization using an annual strategic plan, as described in section 8.2 of this text. 9.3.1. Financial Planning for Activities Recall that (using the Log Frame planning style) activities are the actions that an organization takes in order to meet an objective. Some of these activities will have clear costs associated with them. A steering committee should discuss and prepare a financial plan for these costs. The steering committee may discover that an objective needs to become a multiyear project in order to make the annual activities reasonably affordable. The steering committee should also think about where funding might come from for these costs. An example of a financial plan for the Log Frame shown in section 6.3 is shown here. Please note 39 that these costs are just examples and should not be considered accurate. The plan also is incomplete because it does not include staff wages, security costs and several other likely ongoing expenses. Item Description Instructor Training Course Participation Fees Transportation for Instructor Training Course Participants Six good quality used desktop computers Printer Cartridges, black New LCD Projector Small repairs and replacement fund for lab equipment Internet connection fee 2009 Financial Plan Number Needed and Total Cost (USD) Unit Cost (USD) 2 learners at $200 400 each Suggested Funding Sources Donors and School 2 at $20 each 40 School teacher education fund 6 at $250 each 1500 Donors and School 10 at $30 each 1 at $1000 $400 per year 300 1000 400 Internet café income Donors and School Internet café income 12 months at $250 3000 Pupil user fees and Internet café income Grand Total Costs 6640 When putting together a financial plan, the steering committee should try to make accurate cost estimates for all expenses. This will require some time investigating local shops and providers. After several years of operation, the steering committee should have enough past experience with ongoing costs to make relatively accurate estimates. It is also always wise to allow some contingency in case prices rise. As a steering committee becomes more experienced in financial planning, they also should replace the last column of the above table with actual projections of the funds available from each source. They can also develop a separate income plan, such as the example shown below. Item Description 2009 Income Plan Estimated Number Available and Unit Income (USD) 500 learners at $5 per year $100 per month 100 pages per month at $.25/page Pupil Computer Fee Internet Café (weekend) Fees Printing Fee for Lab and Café Users Short Course (evening) Six short courses, 15 participants Participant Fees each, $10 per participant Government Funding for Pilot 1 grant 40 Total Income (USD) 2,500 1200 300 900 1000 Project NGO Donation for Lab Improvements Grand Total Costs 1 grant 1000 6,900 9.3.2. Reviewing the Plan One a planning committee has developed a financial plan, they should take some time to make sure that it is correct and reasonable before moving forward. It would be tragic to have made a significant error that ends up having a negative effect on a key project. The first step in reviewing the plan is checking the mathematics very carefully. Has a zero been dropped somewhere? Are all the calculations correct? Then the plan should be circulated to some other stakeholders in the project to make sure that they also don’t see any problems. Donors with experience with similar projects may also be able to provide advice. 9.4. Working With a Budget 9.4.1. Financial Plan vs. Budget What is the difference between a financial plan and a budget? A financial plan is a planning committee’s effort to set financial direction for an organization. It also is a tool used to explain to likely project funders how you intend to use the money they contribute. However, these funders may not contribute as much money as anticipated, or there may be other constraints set on the amount of funds that the project has to work with. The budget is what you end up actually working with for the year (or other specified time frame). A budget must be balanced so that income matches or exceeds expenditures. Budgets can also be created on different levels of a project. For example, a computer lab might have an overall operating budget, but then have smaller budgets for specific projects. Below is an example of a budget for a small training workshop: Item Income Participant Fees Total Income Budget for Computer Training Workshop Description Amount (USD) Expenditures Facilitator’s Fee Assistants’ Fees Printing of Training Materials Printing of Certificates Refreshments Fuel and Phone Credit for Organizer Unanticipated Expenses Total Expenditures $20 each for 20 participants 400 400 $130 2 @ $30 $50 $2 each for 20 participants $80 $10 130 60 50 40 80 10 $30 30 400 41 9.4.2. Working With a Budget Here is the most important thing to know about working with a budget: once a budget has been established, a manager should make every effort possible to stick to that budget. If small variations need to be made, they should be kept within the limit of the “unanticipated expenses” or contingency line of the budget. If it becomes clear that a budget is not reasonable, the manager needs to communicate clearly and promptly with the steering committee (or a project organizing team) to determine sources of additional income. 9.4.3. Basic Bookkeeping/Accounting Skills While an organization may choose to contract with an accounting firm to finalize or audit accounts after a specified amount of time (month, quarter or year), the daily bookkeeping for a computer project is likely to be the responsibility of the computer lab manager. This is not a cause for panic! The basic goals involved in bookkeeping are very simple: 1) Know how much money you are earning and spending 2) Know how much money is available 3) Keep clear records so that you can explain items 1 and 2 to other people. A few more steps on how to perform the tasks needed to achieve these goals are described below. Keeping Receipts. It is important to keep track of all receipts (for purchases made by the project) as well as clear records of project income. All receipts should be kept and organized by date. If the project has few of these small pieces of paper, they can easily be organized in a labeled file or envelope for each month or for each specific small project. If the number of receipts is larger, a good way to organize them is with a ring binder. The receipts are hole-punched and added to the binder in date order. Several small receipts can be taped to a larger page. If the receipts do not indicate what item was purchased and the date of the expenditure, this information should be hand-written onto the receipt. Records of project income can be kept in a similar manner if the organization is able to keep copies of paid invoices or receipts given to those paying. However, if the organization (such as an Internet café) frequently receives small user fees, it will be easier to keep a log of the fees received in a log book for Internet café income. At the end of each day, the fees received should be totaled and the log book page signed by the manager. Keeping Daily Records. While income and expenditures are still fresh in the mind, the computer lab manager should make sure they are recorded in a log book. The log book should be designed to clearly indicate the following for each item: date, description and amount. If the project only has one “pool” of money (such as a petty cash box) this log book can also keep a running record of how much money is in that pool (see more on petty cash management, below). Otherwise the log book should also indicate which source of funds (such as a bank account or petty cash fund) the money was taken from or added to. Balances of these funds should also be kept current, so that the manager knows how much money is available for the project. A cheque book should have a balance sheet or receipt tabs attached for this purpose. 42 Keeping a Budget/Income/Expenditures Spreadsheet . The handwritten records described above should periodically (perhaps weekly) be recorded in a spreadsheet that summarizes income and expenditures and compares them to the project budget. It’s very important that a computer lab manager becomes familiar with the basic spreadsheet skills needed to meet this task: Adding rows and columns to a spreadsheet, entering information into a spreadsheet, formatting cells for currency, adding columns, and performing basic calculations. Below is an example of the spreadsheet that resulted from adding income and expenditures to the project budget example used previously. Budget and Expenditures Worksheet Budget Actual Item Income Participant Fees Description Amount (USD) Description Amount (USD) $20 each for 20 participants 400 Only 18 participants 360 Total Income Expenditures Facilitator’s Fee Assistants’ Fees Printing of Training Materials Printing of Certificates Refreshments Fuel and Phone Credit for Organizer Unanticipated Expenses Total Expenditures Difference Between Income and Expenditures 400 360 $130 2 @ $30 $50 130 60 50 130 60 45 $2 each for 20 participants $80 40 Only 18 printed 36 80 (see separate breakdown) 65 $10 10 $30 30 400 12 CD-ROM disks 10 358 2 Preparing Financial Reports. A computer lab manager should discuss with his or her steering committee or supervisor to determine how often financial reports are required. It is likely that a financial report should be prepared at the end of any special project. In addition, if a project has regular cash flow due to income generating activities, monthly financial reports should be prepared for these activities. A financial report can be as simple as a spreadsheet (such as the one shown above) and a brief explanation of the expenditures and any overall comments. For the example project shown here, the manager might explain why the numbers of participants was decreased, what efforts were made to save costs as a result, and where the excess funds will go. 43 9.5. Avoiding Financial Corruption 9.5.1. Managing Petty Cash Many computer projects have good reasons to have some cash on hand. It could be funds received from income generating ventures, or it could be funds needed for the purchase of small lab supplies. This money, however, can also be an easy target for theft. Below are some techniques for keeping these funds safe and accounted for: Keep the funds secure in a locking cash box or desk drawer, and if possible in a location that is not easily visible for lab users. If possible, involve more than one person in the safe storage of the funds. For example, the cash box can be kept in the office of one coworker, while the key is kept by another coworker. Keep a petty cash log book that includes lines for date, description, amount of income or expenditure, running balance and signatures. Have a standard procedure for cash box withdrawals, such as the requirement of two signatures. 9.5.2. Involving Others It is important that financial management not be the sole responsibility of one individual. Some managers, in moments of desperation, may be tempted to steal or misdirect funds if they do not think anyone would notice. This can be avoided if more than one person is involved in all financial matters. On a daily, weekly or monthly level, this could be as simple as having a coworker who cosigns on all petty cash expenditures and reviews all financial records with the lab manager. A computer project should also periodically hire an outside accountant to review all project records and books. This individual does not have a vested interest in a particular project and thus is likely to give objective feedback. In addition, some donor agencies require that the financial books for a project that they fund be formally audited. A financial audit is a way for an outside person to review and affirm that the financial statements and records of the organization are complete and accurate. 9.5.3. Keeping the Purpose and Goals in Mind Raising awareness about the purpose and goals of a computer project is a tool that a computer lab manager can use to help avoid corruption. If the computer lab manager keeps the community informed about the purpose and goals of a computer project, the project will be seen as beneficial in the community and hopefully will be less of a target for theft or corruption. For some people it is easy to steal or misdirect funds when these funds are seen as “just some rich person’s money that they will never miss.” If, on the other hand, the funds are seen as belonging to the community project, and that the funds have an identified beneficial purpose, it is clear now that these funds are vital and certainly will be missed. 9.6. Basic Marketing Skills 44 Most computer projects will need to have some sort of income generating venture, and for some projects (such as Internet cafés) income generation plays a key role. Therefore, it is important that a computer lab manager knows how to attract customers to a project. Marketing is valuable as a way to keep your organization visible in the community, stimulate interest in your project and inform community members of new opportunities. When beginning to market your project, it is important to know your target audience. Where do these people gather? Those gathering places could be good places to post a project flyers. What aspects of your project are most attractive to this audience? Those aspects could be featured clearly and in a large font on the flyer. There are several sources of advice for marketing for telecentres. The Community Telecentre Cookbook for Africa3 lists the following as good marketing methods for a computer project to consider: Print Media. This includes newspapers, church newsletters, corporate partner newsletters, and pamphlets from partner NGOs. The telecentre can keep an eye out for special newspaper sections/supplements that relate to IT or education, and can also publish press releases. Television and Radio. Advertisements on public and private TV and Radio stations are an option if affordable. The manager could also keep an eye out for talk show programs that are relevant to the business of the computer project. These might offer free ways to discuss related issues and raise awareness on the services offered by the computer project. Community Bulletin Boards. These bulletin boards may be found in community health centres, schools, or markets. They are key places to advertise the project’s offerings and schedule, and also to advertise special events, staff openings, or the need for volunteers. A full course on Grassroots Marketing for telecentres is available as a part of the Trainings Commons Modules4, and is recommended reading for those managers who will need to do significant marketing for their projects. 9.7. Assignments/Activities 9.7.1. What is one of your personal goals? Describe your financial plan for achieving that goal. 9.7.2. Design a budget for a small event, such as a party for graduates of a training course. 9.7.3. Practice your spreadsheet skills with the budget you designed in the previous exercise. Make sure to include some formatting of cells and texts (number formatting, bold text, different font sizes, borders) and some use of formulas (multiplication, auto sum) 3 The Community Telecentre Cookbook for Africa, Mike Jensen and Anriette Esterhuysen, UNESCO, 2001. Available from http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0012/001230/123004e.pdf 4 Trainings Commons Modules, Telecentre.Org, 2008. Available from http://www.telecentreacademy.org/browse/Detailed/2684.html 45 9.7.4. Visit a small community project (it doesn’t have to be a computer project). How do they manage cash and keep track of their income and expenditures? Do you think their system is sufficient for the needs of their project? Why or why not? Summarize your findings. 9.7.5. Writing a financial report for the project example used in section 9.4 of this text. Include a summary of the information shown in the spreadsheet, as well as any additional explanations that you think would be helpful. Feel free to invent plausible a story for an explanation. 9.7.6. Imagine that you are working for a community computer project that has decided to begin offering a web design course for youth that are already IT literate. Develop and describe a good marketing strategy for this course. 9.7.7. There are many “gray areas” of corruption. These are situations in which funds are misused, but the misuse is small or well hidden or socially acceptable. Below are three scenarios that possibly involve “gray areas” of corruption. Consider each one and then state: 1) Whether or not you think it represents corruption, and why. 2) What you think should be done by a coworker who observes this corruption. 1) A coworker is given a small transportation allowance to work on marketing a new training course. Her actual transportation costs are a bit less, but she doesn’t report or return the excess. 2) An IT instructor at your project is also doing some data entry work for an outside (unrelated) project to earn money. After he has finished instructing a course for the day, he stays in the computer lab and works on data entry for two hours, apparently oblivious to the growing queue of community members waiting to use the computer. 3) Some visiting donors from oversees bring to your project a large supply of USB flash drives, with the request that they be given as prizes to deserving learners who have reached certain milestones in their IT training. Once the donors have left, the head teacher at your school requests a flash drive and you feel obligated to provide one. 9.7.8. Workshop Activity: In a small group, discuss the scenarios from the previous assignment. Compare your opinions on whether or not each scenario represents corruption. Also discuss what could have been done initially to avoid these situations. 9.7.9. Workshop Activity: Share the budget spreadsheet you created in assignment 9.7.3 above with other members of the class. How do the spreadsheets produced by different people compare? Make sure that this becomes an opportunity to learn some new skills when using a spreadsheet application. 9.7.10. Workshop Activity: In a small group, design and prepare a flyer for the party mentioned in assignment 9.7.2 above. Be sure that all of the basic information for the event (What? When? Where? Who should attend?) is included in a creative and inspiring layout. Share your flyer with the larger group, and note any improvements suggested by others. Table of Contents 46 10.Communication and Interpersonal Skills 10.1. Effective Communication What does it mean to effectively communicate? In basic terms, it means that someone has an opportunity to deliver a message that they believe is important, and that this message is received, understood and responded to appropriately. Most of us have probably been involved in situations where we felt that communication was not effective. This could be sending an email that no one responded to, making a statement in a meeting that was misunderstood, or even not being given an opportunity to make an important contribution to a conversation. When a lab manager is considering how to be an effective communicator, the key factors to consider are below: Opportunity/Inclusion. Does the communication method include all key stakeholders in an issue? Is everyone given an opportunity to voice their opinions? Clarity/Understanding. Are unusual or colloquial (slang) words avoided or explained? Is translation into other languages provided as needed? Are illiterate, visually impaired or deaf stakeholders included in the communication? If communicating in a meeting, is the speaking loud enough for everyone to hear? Tone and Non-verbal Communication. In face to face communication do the facial expressions and body language portray the desired emotions? Is the tone of communication (written and oral) respectful, professional and encouraging? Listening. Do listeners show (via eye contact, facial expressions or questioning) that they are listening and engaged? Response. Are all stakeholders given an opportunity to respond to a statement or issue? Are responses received in a way that shows good listening, interest and respect? When written responses are requested, are they provided promptly and clearly? There are many different methods of communication, including one to one discussions, telephone calls, group meetings, radio broadcasts, Internet blogs, email, etc. Most of the factors mentioned above are relevant for all of these methods. A lab manager should take opportunities to self-reflect on his or her communication where possible. Was the communication effective? Why or why not? For most of us, learning good communication skills is a gradual and life-long process. 10.2. Communicating With Different Types of People Our background, experiences, culture, goals and abilities/disabilities all affect our ability to communicate with others. It is important for the computer lab manager to be aware of the fact that working with a diverse group of people means adapting to diverse communication needs and skills. The tip box here includes tips for communicating effectively with people who are from different backgrounds or cultures. In all cases the computer lab manager should choose to err on the side of respect and clarity in all communication. 47 Tips for Communicating Effectively with Diverse Groups of People 1. Try to “put yourself in the shoes” of the people you are communicating with to determine how to communicate with them effectively. For example, think about how important it is (or isn’t) to develop a personal connection with meeting participants before attending to the business of the day. 2. If English language is a barrier, you might consider avoiding overly technical language or finding a translator. 3. Be aware of culture and class issues and standards in the local culture. For example, a community leader may want certain protocols to be observed before getting to the matters at hand. 4. Be aware of religious differences. For example, a person who is not religious may feel offended by an email that thanks God for a certain opportunity or event. 5. Be aware of the fact that perceived shame can result in ineffective communication. For example, an adult who is just learning how to use a computer may feel that communicating their educational needs in front of young pupils is embarrassing and demeaning. You might need to create a more private atmosphere for this communication. A computer lab manager should be particularly aware of the needs of special populations within his or her project’s community. Someone who is intellectually challenged may need information to be presented more slowly or with repetition. A visually impaired person will need assistance in accessing email or other online communication tools. A deaf person will need sign language interpretation in a meeting, and may also need assistance with written materials. 10.3. Effective Email Communication Effective email communication will be discussed more fully in Module 4 of this course, but these basic email communication tips are important enough to be emphasized in this module as well: Include a relevant subject line in all emails. Use a respectful tone and avoid words that will be difficult to understand or are too colloquial. Check the email for spelling and grammar before sending. When receiving email, make sure that you reply if a reply is requested. If you are very busy, this can be as simple as “I am sorry that I am too busy to give this much thought now but…” When sending a reply, consider whether it is for just the sender (Reply) or meant for everyone the original message was sent to (Reply All). 10.4. Communicating with Project Partners and Donors Effective communication is very important to establishing and keeping good relationships with project partners and donors. No partner or donor wishes to make a 48 contribution to a project and then hear nothing about the outcomes of their contribution. The partners need to know that they have made a difference to the project, that their efforts are appreciated, and that their continued involvement is welcome. 10.4.1. When to Communicate with Partners and Donors Communication with partners and donors should occur regularly, but exact frequency and content of the communication will vary with different organizations. The lab manager should have a discussion with partners/donors at the beginning of their working relationship to find out what communication is appreciated and expected. This may end up in a system of monthly or quarterly reports on the progress of a project. Partners and donors are also likely to appreciate impromptu communication when an important event has occurred. For example, if the first group of learners from a new training project are about to graduate, a donor to the project would be interested to know of this exciting development, and might want to be invited to the graduation ceremony. 10.4.2. Reporting the “Bad News” Sometimes lab managers are reluctant to report problems to partners or donors. We all have a tendency to want to avoid embarrassment or disapproval, but in most cases avoiding needed communication will only make a situation worse. If a project experiences a significant setback such as the theft of a key piece of equipment, or a major illness of a key coworker, the best course of action is to communicate this news promptly and in a way that shows that the problem it being taken seriously and the organization is already working on ways to solve the problem. The donor will appreciate the transparency and the fact that the manager is trying to address the problem promptly. The donor may even have some helpful suggestions. If, on the other hand, the manager avoids communication, they are likely to have a more embarrassment later when the donors discover the setback for themselves. Another challenge in communication is that in many cultures there is a strong tendency for people to be polite and enthusiastic by giving positive answers even when they know that they aren’t exactly true. An example of this might be when a client asks “can I have that document ready by 12:00?” and the printer says “sure!” to be polite, even though he thinks realistically that it might not be ready until 13:00. The client ends up frustrated, though, when they return at 12:00 to find the work unfinished. This sort of communication challenge can lead to a lab manager telling a donor that a proposed project is a great idea, even while thinking about some serious implementation problems for the project. Solving this sort of communication challenge involves awareness and effort on both sides. In this example, the lab manager could be positive but also raise some of the problems that will need to be addressed in order to make the project successful. If the lab manager does not do this, there will likely be a stage later in implementation of the project where the donor becomes very upset when they discover a big problem that the lab manager did not warn them about! The donor also needs to learn to probe a bit deeper and ask questions that elicit feedback on specific steps in project implementation, and not just a yes or no answer. 10.5. Networking and Seeking and Creating Partnerships 49 Communicating effectively will help a lab manager make good connections with other lab managers as well as possible project donors and partners. This is a gradual process that can result in a very fruitful sharing of ideas and resources if handled professionally. If a lab manager sends out desperate sounding emails such as “Help! Can anyone fix my virus problem?” or “Our project needs funding this week or we will have to close our doors!” they will likely scare away possible opportunities by demonstrating his or her own poor planning or lack of skill. On the other hand, sharing general information about your exciting project on an email discussion group, or inviting others working in the same field to visit your computer project and share ideas can result in great opportunities to learn from a group of like-minded individuals. If a possible donor has been identified, it is best to find out what kinds of projects the donor contributes to, what the requirements are for donations, and how the application process works before approaching the donor directly. Once it is clear that the project is a potential candidate for a donation, the manager can initiate communication in a professional and respectful way. It is also important for the lab manager to be aware of the difference between a donor and a partner. Donors see their role as giving something (funds, time and materials) that a project needs, whereas partners instead emphasize their involvement as a part of a joint effort. Partners will want to know answers to questions such as these: “What is the local organization contributing to their new project?”, “How does the local organization plan to make this project sustainable once our contribution is exhausted?” or “What is the local organization going to contribute to benefit us?”. A local organization may not immediately think that they can benefit a large international partner, but in fact there are many ways to do so. A local organization has experience “on the ground” with project implementation that is quite valuable to share with an international partner who is building their own knowledge base. Also many international partners are looking for opportunities for a cross-cultural experience for their volunteers. 10.6. Customer Relations Skills Effective communication and engagement with customers and clients is important for all projects. If the customers do not have a pleasant experience at an Internet café, they are less likely to return again. Most of us have had experiences as customers that have been frustrating and demoralizing. Perhaps it was a sales clerk who chatted on the phone instead of finishing a sale. Perhaps it was a customer service representative who did not accept the return of a faulty item. Or perhaps it was the waiter who said that the meal would be ready in 15 minutes, when it actually took 45 minutes. In order to avoid having similar experiences in a computer lab, the manager should do the following: Greet and interact with all clients with enthusiasm Communicate clearly with all clients, including letting them know when there are problems that might delay their needs being met Address the needs of clients as quickly as possible. This may mean redirecting coworkers from other tasks. If the client’s needs cannot be met (perhaps due to a scheduling conflict) this should be communicated promptly, and arrangements made to meet at an alternate time 50 Apologize respectfully when the needs of the client cannot be met Give clients an opportunity to voice their concerns or criticisms The catch phrase “the customer is always right” may not always be true, but is still a good reminder of the attitude that should be used when approaching customers and clients. If the clients do not feel that their needs are being met and their concerns heard, they are less likely to return. This is important even in non-fee paying educational and community projects. If the lab users stay away because the lab is not meeting their needs, then there is no justification for continuing the project! It is important for a computer lab manager to try to turn challenging client interactions into opportunities for the project. If they give a client an opportunity to offer feedback, this could result in a good suggestion for improving a project. The interaction with the difficult client might also raise the lab manager’s awareness about a community need that is not being met. The client might then engage with the lab manager about ways to address this need by making changes or additions to the computer lab project offerings. All interactions with customers, clients or other lab users, whether difficult or not, should be used as opportunities to build momentum and enthusiasm for the computer project. The heart of any computer project is its community of users. If they are excited they will make the lab a vital and successful venture. These users will invite their friends, and suggest new programs. Therefore the computer lab manager should make sure that all users feel welcome and encouraged, and that they all have opportunities to provide input for the project. 10.7. Assignments/Activities 10.7.1. Practice sending and receiving email with your online course instructor and fellow learners. Make sure that you practice using reply and reply all, and sending attachments. All emails should also be spell checked. 10.7.2. If you are already a part of a computer project, ask a donor or project partner about communication. What sort of information do they want to hear and what sort of reports do they want to receive? How often do they wish to hear from you or your organization? 10.7.3. Reflect on your experiences with a challenging communication situation. When did you feel that your message was not heard? Or when did cultural differences make it difficult for you to communicate a message? Describe the situation and then what could have been done to improve communication. 10.7.4. Imagine that you are the computer lab manager that has just experienced the theft of two laptop computers. You need to report this theft to the donor of the computers, and you know that the donor will appreciate having this information. However, you are reluctant to report the theft until all of the facts are known, and the police investigations are proceeding very slowly. You also are reluctant to communicate bad news. How can you handle this situation? When do you think you should contact the donor? What do you think you should say/write? 10.7.5. Workshop Activity: Participate in a group discussion about the previous question (10.7.4). See if the group can come to agreement on the answers to the questions. 51 10.7.6. Workshop Activity: Participate in a role play about a difficult customer. Focus on ways to turn the difficult interaction into an opportunity to learn or change. 10.7.7. Workshop Activity: Participate in a role play between a supervisor and a subordinate worker. The supervisor wants to implement a project that the worker has some serious concerns about. However, in their culture it is not appropriate for the subordinate worker to say “it won’t work”. 10.7.8. Workshop Activity: Participate in a role play on seeking a partnership with a NGO working in your area. Consider the needs of the project and effective ways to communicate these needs while also portraying enthusiasm for your project. Table of Contents 11.Overall Assignment/Activities 11.1. Job Description Awareness. The activities below are designed to get computer lab managers who are already employed to consider how they spend their time. 11.1.1. What are the tasks that you currently do every day? Week? Month? Term? Year? Brainstorm a list of items in each of these categories. 11.1.2. Look at the list you created in the previous assignment. Is it the right amount of work to do or are you unable to do all of the tasks as often as you think they need to be done? If you cannot get everything done that you think is a part of your job, what solutions do you suggest? 11.1.3. What does your supervisor (or steering committee) think that you do? Have a conversation with your supervisor in which you ask him or her to list the tasks as you did in the first question (but don’t let the supervisor see your answers beforehand). Then compare lists and note any significant differences. 11.2. Sustainability for an organization is not just about having enough money. What else does your organization (or another community project in your area) need to think about using up or “burning out”? What are some good suggestions for how to keep this organization sustained in these areas? 11.3. For any organization it is critically important that the organization’s mission and goals are reflected in the actions of the organization. Is this the case for your organization (or another community project in your area)? If not, what is something important that you learned from this module that could help make that happen? 11.4. Having too much work to do is a common problem for many computer lab managers. Design an internship or student computer lab monitor project in a way that will decrease your (or another computer lab manager’s) workload in the long run. Write a brief description of this project idea. How many interns/monitors would be involved? How many hours a week would they work? What jobs would they do? How would they be trained? How would they be supervised? 11.5. Workshop Activity: Your instructors will present a scenario of a computer project that is having significant challenges. It has lost momentum and direction, and funding is very scarce. After hearing the scenario, you will be divided into teams to address different aspects of this challenge (listed below). Your group will come up with a plan to share with the whole class. 52 11.5.1. How can the project set up an affordable system for keeping the computer lab clean and in good repair? 11.5.2. The project cannot afford an alarm system or an extra security guard. How can they avoid thefts? 11.5.3. How can the project work with the local community to start an exciting, helpful and affordable new activity? 11.5.4. How can the project find and approach new donors? 11.6. Workshop Activity: Participate in a workshop evaluation process. Table of Contents 12.Planning Resources 12.1. Initial Planning, Project Organization Hughes, S., Eashwar, S and Jennings, V.E. (Eds). (2004). How to Get Started and Keep Going: A Guide to Community Multimedia Centres. Paris: UNESCO. Available from http://portal.unesco.org/ci/en/ev.phpURL_ID=22578&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html Esterhuysen, A. and Jensen, M. (2001). The Community Telecentre Cookbook for Africa. UNESCO. Available from http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0012/001230/123004e.pdf. 12.2. Strategic Planning Strodel, M.E. (2003). Simple Steps to Effective Organizational Planning, The Alliance for New York State Arts Organizations. http://www.thealliancenys.org/capacity/articles/MarthaPlanningArticle.pdf, accessed October 30, 2009. Lyddon, J. (1999). Management Guide #7, Strategic Planning in Smaller Nonprofit Organizations, Western Michigan State University, http://www.wmich.edu/nonprofit/Guide/guide7.htm, accessed October 30, 2000 Knieriem, I. and Wheaton, A. (2006). Find Your Way in Successful Fundraising, Lusaka, Zambia: VSO. Ortengren, K. (2003). The Logical Framework Approach – A Summary of the Theory Behind the LFA Method. Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency, Available from: www.sida.se/publications Table of Contents 53 13.Bibliography Bridges.Org. (n.d.). 12 Habits of Highly Effective ICT-Enabled Development Initiatives. Retrieved October 28, 2009, from Bridges.org: www.bridges.org/12_habits Colle, R. and Roman, R. (2003). A Handbook for Telecenter Staffs. Cornell University. Available from: http://ip.cals.cornell.edu/commdev/handbook.cfm Computers for Zambian Schools. (2007). How to Make the Most of Your Computers. Lusaka, Zambia. Esterhuysen, A. and Jensen, M. (2001). The Community Telecentre Cookbook for Africa. UNESCO. Available from http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0012/001230/123004e.pdf. Hughes, S., Eashwar, S and Jennings, V.E. (Eds). (2004). How to Get Started and Keep Going: A Guide to Community Multimedia Centres. Paris: UNESCO. Available from http://portal.unesco.org/ci/en/ev.phpURL_ID=22578&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html Knieriem, I. and Wheaton, A. (2006). Find Your Way in Successful Fundraising, Lusaka, Zambia: VSO. Management. (2009). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved October 23, 2009, from: www.wikipedia.org UNESCO Bangkok (2004). Schoolnet Toolkit. Vancouver: Commonwealth of Learning. Available from http://www.unescobkk.org/en/education/ict/online-resources/e-library/elibrary Telecentre.org. (2008). Trainings Commons Modules. Telecentre Academy. Available from http://www.telecentreacademy.org/browse/Detailed/2684.html About Zambia Pacific Trust There are many challenges for schools and community organizations in Zambia to consider when starting or maintaining computer projects. Sourcing good quality computers is just the beginning. The organizations also need to consider infrastructure issues, staff training, computer education curricula, and internet connectivity. Zambia Pacific Trust (ZPT) helps institutions address these challenges through advice, training, and a cost-sharing grant process. ZPT currently works with five schools in the Lusaka area, but has plans to add other organizations in the future. For more information please contact info@zptrust.org. About Heidi Neff 54 Heidi Neff is a former high school science teacher with 15 years of experience in the classroom. While teaching in Seattle, Washington, she used computers extensively as a part of her curriculum. She also assisted with computer training in Zambian schools as a part of the Seattle Academy Zambia Program. Ms. Neff starting working with ZPT in 2006, assisting their efforts to support school computer projects in Zambia. She is currently a consultant specializing in IT in Education. For more information please contact her at heidi.h.heff@gmail.com. 55