Learning Enquiry: What is the secret of the standing stones? Linked to Alderman’s Barrow, on Exmoor National Park. This document is one of many free web-based resources produced as part of the Moorland Classroom project. To explore the whole resource, including maps, video content and ‘how to’ guides please visit: http://www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Learning Aims Pupils will be supported in and outside of the classroom to: Gain an understanding of the chronology of Exmoor and in particular the historic environment together with some cultural aspects of life associated with the Bronze Age period Make links and associations between the patterns of their own lives and those of the people of Bronze Age communities Appreciate that, whilst archaeology and historical interpretation of the past is not an exact science, archaeologists have developed the skills to infer things from the evidence that remains, allowing us to empathise with our ancestors. Recognise, describe and explain the moorland landscape of Exmoor and develop a sense of how and why it has changed in the past, how it might be changing now and how it might change in the future Recognise, describe and explain elements of the biodiversity of Exmoor and in particular the significance of hedge banks both as distinctive historical features of the landscape and important ecological habitats which can be compared with hedgerows in the school’s local area Appreciate how both historic and modern day people exploit the environment of Exmoor in order to survive and make a living Collect and interpret a range of qualitative and quantitative primary data through fieldwork, which enhances understanding of the distinctive character of the Exmoor landscape and its historic and cultural lineage www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 1 of 11 Learning and teaching activities and curriculum progression 1. Introduction This enquiry provides an opportunity for pupils to investigate aspects of life on Exmoor during the Bronze Age with a focus on Alderman’s Barrow and the unexplained stone setting, located nearby on Almsworthy Common (see Aldermans-1-Map). Both these features are accessible from the road southwest of Lucott Cross. As well as providing a prehistoric dimension the enquiry also presents a relevant context for exploring bank hedgerows, an important aspect of Exmoor’s biodiversity and a distinctive feature of the landscape. The Bronze age on Exmoor is dated between 2,000 and 700BC – in other words between 4,000 and 2,300 years ago. The greatest change from the earlier Mesolithic and Neolithic periods was that people were living in settled communities and were clearing areas of woodland in order to farm the land and growing crops and keeping livestock such as cattle – they were no longer nomadic hunters and gatherers. Ploughs were pulled by domesticated cattle (oxen) and wild breeds of cattle (aurochs) became extinct. Crops such as early varieties of wheat were sown into fields and harvested and stored. People lived in round houses, usually just two or three in each settlement, sometimes within a small compound or enclosure and surrounded by both arable fields and managed grassland for animal pasture. Not much evidence of round houses remains on the ground today on Exmoor but they are often clearly seen on aerial photographs. The Bronze Age on Exmoor is associated with the building of barrows and the construction of stone settings. Barrows are round mounds where the dead were buried or their ashes placed after cremation. Barrows were considered to have been sacred places associated with rituals and practices, making them an active part of the landscape rather than ‘cemeteries’ used only for burial purposes. Although stone circles and stone rows are found throughout the country, stone settings are unique to Exmoor – over 60 in total. Many barrows survive on Exmoor (over 400) largely because there has been much less ploughing of the land over the last 4,000 years compared with more lowland locations. The Bronze Age signifies the appearance of Bronze to make items such as axe heads, daggers and decorative torcs, brooches and beads. There are also distinctive pottery types associated with the Bronze Age and on Exmoor the pottery discovered is of the Trevisker Ware type, this includes urns, beakers and pots. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 2 of 11 1. Bronze Age Settlements Give out Aldermans-1-Map and ask the pupils to locate Alderman’s Barrow at the grid reference 837424. At this point do not explain what Alderman’s Barrow is (for the moment it’s just a place on Exmoor). Explain that people lived in and around Alderman’s Barrow about 4,000 years ago. Now give out Aldermans-2-Great_Hill. Explain that this is what archaeologists think the landscape looking directly east from Alderman’s Barrow may have looked like 4,000 years ago. Ask the pupils to look carefully at the picture and describe everything they can see. Take time to discuss with pupils their responses and in particular to develop key vocabulary e.g. fields, hedgerows, huts, woodland, animals, scattered trees, hills etc. Now encourage them to come up with 6 questions each they would like to know the answers to beginning with Where, When, Who, Why, What and How. Take feedback from the pupils and make a list on the board. Which are the most common questions? Tell the pupils that they are going to spend some time studying Bronze Age people who lived at Almsworthy Common (824419) about 4,000 years ago and during the investigation will seek to answer as many of the questions they have raised as possible. 2. A question which will certainly be amongst those asked will be something along the lines of: What were their homes like? Tell the pupils that the artist has also drawn a picture from the perspective of the house in the centre of Aldermans-2-Great_Hill looking directly back towards Alderman’s Barrow from which the first picture was drawn. Before showing them the picture, challenge the pupils to draw what they think the house would have looked like. What shape is it? What do they think it would have been made from? How many people would have lived in it? What else would have been inside? What about immediately outside and around the building? Gain as many clues from Aldermans-2-Great_Hill as possible. Now support the pupils to draw both the outside of the building and the inside on a large A3 plain piece of paper. Take plenty of time here to allow pupils to describe their buildings together with the rationale for what they have drawn. Next give out Aldermans-3-Round_House and Aldermans-4-View_GtHill. Encourage the pupils to look carefully at this painting. What does it suggest to us about the lives of Bronze Age people in and around Almsworthy Common? For example, what did they eat? The houses of the Bronze Age people of Exmoor were round and conical in shape, constructed using wooden posts which supported a wall and a thatched roof of heather and bracken which extended down below the wall, almost to the ground. Inside would have lived extended families of perhaps 6-8 adults and children. Wheat would have been the staple food which would have been grown in surrounding fields and this diet would have been supplemented by cattle, sheep, pigs and deer. Pigs would have been kept in compounds close to the round houses with cattle grazing the pasture in fields nearby. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 3 of 11 3. Bronze Age Barrows Take the pupils back to Aldermans-4-View_GtHill. Remind the pupils that this is some idea of what the view from the round houses on Great Hill back to Alderman’s Barrow might have looked like 4,000 years ago during the Bronze Age. One of the people represented in the round house is looking at Alderman’s Barrow on the horizon. So what did Alderman’s Barrow look like? What was it? Why might it have been important to the people? Take time to discuss ideas with the pupils and summarise key points: looks like a small round hill or mound on the horizon – which is exactly what it was – where bodies of members of the community or their ashes after cremation were buried when they died. Now give the pupils Aldermans-5Aldermans_Photos; the importance of the star is explained in Field Activity 1 later on in the Enquiry. There is not much to be seen of the mound which formed Alderman’s Barrow today. The barrow would have been approximately 24m in diameter and probably 3-4m high – not unlike the barrow shown in Aldermans-6-Treyford. Explain that when people were buried in the barrow they would have been laid to rest with artefacts or objects made by human beings. Some of these might have been of great beauty or value e.g. such as the rich necklace of beads including some made of amber which was discovered in a barrow at North Molton (Aldermans-7Beads) and distinctive pottery such as the Culbone beaker (Aldermans-8Beaker). Modern day replica’s of some of these items can be found in the Moorland Classroom loan box, available from Exmoor National Park Authority. 4. An interesting exercise to follow this is to ask the pupils to choose 10 artefacts that they would select to be buried with them in a barrow for archaeologists to excavate in 4,000 years or so time. First of all ask the pupils to think of all the things they would want to be buried with from their lives today. For the sake of argument we can assume that everything will remain preserved for 4,000 years even if it is paper or cloth. Give the pupils plenty of time to think this through and to come to a considered answer. After they have chosen ten things individually ask the pupils to tell everyone else what they have chosen and why. Start preparing a list of things in common that the pupils have selected – what things are practical, beautiful, sentimental etc. Take time to discuss with pupils what all the artefacts they have chosen will tell people in 4,000 years’ time about their lives today. Are all the things material products or more personal things such as photographs? With this exercise it is common for pupils to reflect about their choices as they make them and discuss what others are thinking and then to change their preferences so it is important to allow enough time to enable this to happen. Finally and as a summative piece, ask the pupils to write in journalistic style genre, the front page of Western Daily News for a date in the year 6012 www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 4 of 11 announcing the amazing discovery of your burial barrow and describing the amazing things that have been found with your remains. Before doing this it is important to model the outcome required and the conventions of writing in a journalistic style. Show the pupils Aldermans-9-WMN and point out the six conventions to be followed when writing a newspaper report (see also Aldermans-10-Media_Recount) i.e.: o Short, sharp and snappy headline which is large and bold o A sub headline which is underneath the headline and tells some more about the story in equally dramatic language o A graphic photograph to draw the reader’s attention o A very short first paragraph which summarises the whole story and encourages the reader to read on - usually by finishing with continued on page 2 or see more amazing photographs on pages 7 and 8 o The story is then written in short paragraphs with short sentences in chronological order o A final concluding paragraph sums up the whole story which may also give the personal view of the author or of the editor/owner of the newspaper 5. Remind pupils that barrows such as the one close to Almsworthy Common were not just graves or cemeteries that were just visited occasionally when people were buried or cremated. They were almost certainly visited for rituals and celebrations at other times throughout the year. They were also important for the people who lived close by. They were constructed in prominent positions e.g. on hills or ridges, where people would see them every day and be reminded of their ancestry and the people who came before them. It would appear also that some were built on land boundaries between one community and another. A worthwhile exercise at this stage is to explore with the pupils all of the ways in which communities today celebrate our links to the past and remind each other of the people who have come before. Give out Aldermans-11-Links which can be used as a prompt to initiate this exercise. Consider producing a large display showing Alderman’s Barrow and the Bronze Age community of Almsworthy Common living in close proximity to it juxtapositioned with modern day examples from the local community of the school which serve as links to the past in a similar way. 6. Stone Settings Ask the pupils to look again at the map extract in Aldermans-1-Map and in particular the stone setting indicated at 842417. Now distribute Aldermans12-Almsworthy and ask the pupils to look carefully at the images. What shape are the stones? How have they been put into the ground? Approximately what is their height and width? Are they the same colour? Explain that there are 16 stones laid out in a small area of open moorland measuring about 100m2 and they survived here for over 4,000 years – incredible! Now show the pupils Aldermans-13-Almsworthy_Impression. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 5 of 11 Ask the pupils to speculate as to what the men in the artist’s reconstruction may have been thinking and discussing as they ‘planted’ the stones. Explain that the reason for laying out the stones is still a mystery and no one is certain to this day what their purpose was or what they represent or symbolise. Tell the pupils that some archaeologists believe that 4,000 years ago what is now Almsworthy Common would not have been open moorland (as the artist’s impression suggests) but covered with forest. This being so the stones would probably have been laid out in a small glade or open space in the forest where no trees were growing and sunlight would be shining in – rather than open moorland. Some suggest that there may have been a spring or stream here at the time as well. Discuss with the pupils how this might change their view of the purpose of the stones? Next give each pupil a plain sheet of A3 paper and ask them to draw what they think the stones may have looked like 4,000 years ago in a sunny forest glade with water. How might the people have thought about them, what might they have symbolised and why might they then walk from where they were living into the forest to be with the stones? Is it possible that their main function was aesthetic – even a ‘garden’ like arrangement where people may have gone just to relax, think or contemplate away from the pretty harsh regime of life on the outside? A possible extension of this idea is to consider looking at modern societies where the laying out of rocks and stones in an aesthetic way is an important aspect of the culture – such as Japan. In Japan Karesansui (rock gardens) have been an important cultural aspect of life for thousands of years. In a rock garden symbolism is very important with raked sand and gravel symbolising rivers and groups of stone or rock symbolising islands. Above all the overall arrangement of rocks is a symbolic expression of religious Buddism and Shinto beliefs. A very good example of a traditional Japanese rock garden can be seen at Ryonanji in the city of Kyoto (Aldermans-14Japan). 7. The Bronze Age Hut Circle Close to the stone settings on Almsworthy Common can be seen the remains of a Bronze Age round house (or to use the archaeological term hut circle), the outline of which can be seen very clearly on aerial photographs – see Aldermans-15-Hut. On Exmoor archaeologists and historians often find that aerial photographs provide a much clearer view and impression of old sites than can be gained from a survey on the ground. Why do the pupils think this is? Ask the pupils to look at the four aerial photographs of different places on Exmoor (Aldermans-16-Aerial_Photos) and to try to work out what each is showing – Shoulsbury Castle (Iron Age Fort), Peat cuttings at Blackpitts, Slocomslade World War 2 military camp and Furzebury Brake Iron Age enclosure. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 6 of 11 8. The role of Hedges in the Moorland landscape. Exmoor’s hedges play a key part in defining the landscape character of the Exmoor National Park and surrounding area. They contribute to agricultural management by providing shelter to livestock and crops, support valuable wildlife habitats and are an important historical record of human activity. The small fields within Exmoor’s valleys are typically bounded by mixed species hedges and medieval banks. These are valuable for wildlife, supporting a diverse range of plants and animals. On the higher moorland areas such as Almsworthy Common earth and stone faced beech hedge banks are characteristic and originated during the periods of common land enclosures about 200 years ago. At Almsworthy Common the original beech hedge bank to the south east of Alderman’s Barrow has been left to grow and lines of beech trees now define where the hedge used to be as can be seen in Aldermans-17-Hedges. There is now an opportunity to do some hedgerow focused investigations in the local area of the school to compare with the hedge banks at Almsworthy Common. 9. Give out the set of nine photograph shrub cards (Aldermans-18-Shrubs) to pupils working in pairs and also the list of nine names on the final sheet which they can use to match to the images. Are there any which they recognise e.g. Holly and can match up immediately? The remaining identification can be done through searching online for images of each of the shrubs. Now give out the answers in Aldermans-19-Shrubs_Answers and get the pupils to compare with their answers and identify what might cause mistaken identification. Talk to pupils about how Exmoor hedges contain such a rich variety of shrubs and trees which are amazingly important for wildlife such as birds and insects. 10. Give out the sheet which provides the approximate date that hedges with 1-9 species in it would have been “born” e.g. 4 species 440 years and 8 species 880 years etc. (Aldermans-20-Hooper). Each of the number of species equates to an historical date e.g., a hedge with 5 species within it would have been “born” in 1461. The pupils will have dated a number of hedges locally and can now use the table as a means of beginning an historical investigation. First of all give then the images of 10 monarchs of England that were reigning in each of the years 1901, 1791, 1681 etc. (Aldermans-21Monarchs) Do they recognise any of the monarchs e.g. Queen Victoria? Support can be provided by giving children the names of the monarchs for them to research and then match to the correct date. 11. Images a - I (Aldermans-22-History) are of historical events that occurred on each of the dates 1901, 1791, 1681 etc. Can the children match up any of the events to any of the dates? Further research, if required, into each of the events will provide a match up with the correct dates. There is now an opportunity to investigate in more detail through an enquiry one or more of the historical events which occurred on each of the dates 1901, 1791, 1681 etc. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 7 of 11 For example: How did Britain change during Queen Victoria’s reign? Why was there a revolution in France? What was life like for ordinary people during the reign of Elizabeth 1st? Was Christopher Columbus the greatest explorer of all time? How did people try to protect themselves from the Black Death? Why did Henry III fight the Welsh? Why are there so many wonderful cathedrals in England? Who were the Vikings? 12. Find more excellent ideas and investigations about hedgerows in the OPAL Biodiversity Survey Pack. Please visit www.OPALexplorenature.org to download their resources or to contact the OPAL staff. Almsworthy Common on location: fieldwork opportunities to support Alderman’s Barrow Learning Enquiry Equipment Checklist In addition to the usual materials for writing and drawing including some A3 drawing paper, the following specialist equipment is required to support the fieldwork activities: Fieldwork Activity 1 – – A large tape measure to support the pupils estimates of size. Fieldwork Activity 3 – A magnetic compass. Ideally one for each pair of pupils. Directions Alderman’s Barrow and Almsworthy Common are accessible by coach (drop off at Lucott Cross SS845432) with a 1km walk along the minor road to Alderman’s Barrow. If a minibus is used then it can drive all the way to Alderman’s Barrow which is beside the road. A walk and activities of an hour and a half or so here can begin at Alderman’s Barrow itself. In poor weather the route can be very exposed and wet and cold and it goes without saying that it should be walked by teachers in advance of the visit by pupils. Fieldwork Activity 1 – Sizing the Barrow Ask the pupils what they think the post with a star sign on the top is doing alongside the barrow and discuss different ideas. During the Second World War there was a good deal of weapons testing and tank training on Exmoor and important antiquities were marked with a star sign to tell gunnery crews to www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 8 of 11 avoid using them as attractive targets! Whilst at the barrow ask the pupils to stand around the perimeter and estimate its diameter by pacing out the distance – approximately 29m. Also approximately how high is the barrow today? Given the diameter and present day height they have estimated, how high do they think it might have been when constructed? Ask the children to look in at the centre of the barrow. Here an irregular pit has been dug about 8m across and 0.7m deep. Why do they think this was dug? The answer could be that it was dug by robbers. What would they have been hoping to find? While at the barrow encourage the pupils to look around 360’. From how far away would Alderman’s Barrow have been seen? Is it in a prominent position? Why might that be? Explain to the pupils that the barrow was not just a grave for bodies and ashes of the dead. It was also a very important symbol to the people of the Bronze Age living on and around Almsworthy . Common – their link to their ancestors and an important place probably for rituals and celebrations. What rituals and celebrations might the Bronze age people have organised 4,000 years ago around Alderman’s Barrow? Ask the pupils to think about what would have been important in the lives of people then - changes in the seasons perhaps e.g. the arrival of Spring, the birth of children as well of course as burial rites. Fieldwork Activity 2 – Hedge Banks From Alderman’s Barrow follow the track beside the hedge bank to the south east taking time to stop and look at the makeup of the bank. From what has it been constructed? Originally it would have been planted out with beech saplings that would have been laid or coppiced to keep it to about 2m high and thick. It has not been managed at all for many years and as a result mature beech trees have grown up along the top of the bank. The soil to make the bank would have needed to have been excavated from somewhere and one possibility is the sunken grassy hollow on the right after about 800m some 30m off the track to the right and defined by some raised humps. Take time to discuss with pupils why a bank was needed to plant the beech saplings in? Why were they not just planted in the ground? One reason is that soils are shallow and without depth the plants would have remained stunted. The hollow here is a great place to have a snack and together the pupils together to describe and explain activities. Fieldwork Activity 3 – Mapping the Stones Returning to the hedge bank continue to follow it (approximately 400m) to the corner where the fence turns away to the left. At this point turn back north west on an obvious track. Within a 100m or so the pupils will begin to encounter the standing stones which are just visible above the heather. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 9 of 11 Divide the pupils into pairs and set each pair the task of finding a stone in the heather and standing by it. Once all of the stones have been located set the pupils the task of mapping the pattern that the stones make. Still with the pupils standing by each of the stones challenge them to think what the pattern of how they are standing would look like directly from above. Tell them that this is the pattern that needs to be recorded. Each pair can work together to produce their pattern. Beginning with the stone they are at in the middle of their piece of paper, pace out the distance to all of the other stones and start to mark them on their plan. Using an A3 piece of paper they will need to be supported to work out a scale e.g. 1cm = I pace. If enough compasses are available then the pupils can calculate the compass direction of each stone as well as it distance from their central stone. Each of the finished plans can be collected in and analysed back at school with each pair being invited to display their pattern and describe what they think the pattern may be. Is there a pattern to the stones and if so what might the pattern mean? Fieldwork Activity 4 – Reconstructing a hut circle Continuing on from the stones along the track which makes its way back to the road. After about 400m from the stones look out for the outline of the Bronze Age hut circle to the right of the path. An almost circular mound can be seen made out of heaped up earth and turf. This would have been removed to make the flat interior of the hut and the wooden posts supporting the hut would have been place inside of the mound and not on it. Point out the gap in the mound which would have been the doorway to the hut. After explaining to the pupils that the hut would have been held up by wooden posts and have had a roof of thatched heather and ferns that reached down beyond the wall to almost ground level, and a hole in the top to let out the smoke from the fire – challenge to the children to draw their own reconstruction of what the hut would have looked like when it was originally built. www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 10 of 11 Learning outcomes Through the range of learning and teaching activities the pupils have opportunities to: Recognise and identify Express views and ask questions Respond to simple questions Observe and describe Select appropriate information Undertake simple subject based tasks Use simple subject vocabulary Compare and contrast Offer reasons Use basic subject skills Use secondary evidence Communicate views and opinions Use appropriate subject vocabulary Understand natural patterns and processes Understand human patterns and processes Demonstrate understanding through explanation Use a range of subject skills Suggest enquiry questions and investigate them Use primary evidence Select information to answer an enquiry Identify, describe and explain patterns, processes, links and relationships Reach conclusions and make judgements Reach substantiated conclusions consistent with the evidence which draw on the application of attitudes and values Critical evaluate both the enquiry process and conclusions reached for validity and trustworthiness www.exmoor-nationalpark.gov.uk/moorland-classroom Page 11 of 11