August 2009 Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust Equality Impact Assessment First Stage Screening Template The EIA Panel recommends that the Equality Screening Template (below) is used to consider if equality impact assessment is necessary. To be completed and attached when submitted to the Equality Impact Assessment Panel for consideration and recommendation. Appendix A - EQUALITY SCREENING TOOL – PHARMACY SERVICES Yes/No 1. Comments (state any evidence available that helped you to answer the question) Does the policy/guidance affect one group less or more favourably than another on the basis of: Race, Nationality and Ethnic Origin (including gypsies and travellers) Yes Race equality is relevant to Pharmacy because patients whose first language is not English may have difficulties in understanding their medicines and how to take them correctly. Most patient information leaflets handed out in Pharmacy are in English and non-English speaking patients will have difficulties understanding the text. Pharmacy needs to set up access to the Interpreter Service and Office Managers to get a list of other languages spoken by the staff within Pharmacy. Disability Yes The outpatient counters in Chase Farm and Edgware pharmacies are not lowered and wheelchair bound patients may find it difficult to speak to the staff. There is no system in place to announce to partially sighted patients to let them know their prescriptions are ready for collection. There are no facilities to produce Braille instructions at Barnet and Chase Farm hospitals either. The ticket display monitor is installed on the wrong side at Barnet Hospital. Gender and Culture Yes There is no private area to discuss sensitive information with the patients on either site. There is also no published information for patients who preferred to speak to a Pharmacy of the same sex. The preference for Pharmacy is to identify a private consulting room for this purpose and to raise awareness of the Patient Helpline telephone number. Religion or belief Yes We do not normally inform the patients about the origin of gelatine capsules unless they specifically ask for the information. Some patients e.g. Hindu religion may be affected by gelatine capsules made from bovine source. We are training our staff and suggest they raised this with patients who are known vegetarian. Yes There is no private area to discuss sensitive information with the patients on either site. There Sexual orientation including lesbian, gay and bisexual people 1 August 2009 Yes/No Comments (state any evidence available that helped you to answer the question) is also no published information for patients who preferred to speak to a Pharmacy of the same sex. The preference for Pharmacy is to identify a private consulting room for this purpose and to raise awareness of the Patient Helpline telephone number. Age Yes Elderly patients who have reduced mobility will find the corridor at Barnet Hospital too long to walk. Ensure the outpatient staff know about this and advise the elderly patients accordingly. Put up a sign at the from of the door to inform elderly patients of the long corridor. The door to CFH outpatient department is quite stiff and some elderly patients especially those on crutches and in wheelchairs may find the doors difficult to negotiate. The plan is to leave the door open during working hours. 2. Is there any evidence that some groups are affected differently? Yes Patients whose first language is not English. Ticket display monitor not readily visible at Barnet Hospital and patients with hearing difficulties may be affected. No loudspeaker system and partiallysighted patients may not be able to read the ticket display monitor. 3. If you have identified potential discrimination, are any exceptions valid, legal and/or justifiable? No There is none. 4. Is the impact of the equality issues identified in Pharmacy likely to be negative? Yes Please see above 5. If so can the impact be avoided? Yes Access to Interpreter Service Moving the ticket display unit at Barnet Hospital to a more visible position Putting up telephone number for Pharmacy Helpline in dispensaries Identify an area for private consultation Find out how to access leaflets in other languages Advise vegetarian patients about contents of gelatine capsules 6. What alternatives are there to achieving the policy/guidance without the impact? Yes Provide a list of staff in the department who can speak other languages to the outpatient pharmacy. Bid for capital money to produce leaflets in top 3 non-English language and move display unit at Barnet Hospital. 7. Can we reduce the impact by taking different action? Yes Partially. It would be preferable to have a dedicated Pharmacy private counselling room If you have identified a potential discriminatory impact of this procedural document, please refer it to the Equality Impact Assessment Panel, together with any suggestions as to the action required to avoid/reduce this impact. 2 August 2009 Equality Impact Assessment Form for High Level Screening – Pharmacy The aim of this form is to establish whether there is any impact i.e. positive or negative on how services are provided whether this is intended or not. It will also consider what needs to be addressed to ensure equality of opportunity in accessing services. Where areas are found to experience negative impact or have a high potential of adverse impact, a full assessment should be undertaken. 1a. Name of the Service Pharmacy 1b. Is this a new service or an existing service ? An existing service 1c. Is this a full impact assessment or a partial impact assessment ? This is a full impact assessment 1d. State Date of Assessment August 2009 3 August 2009 2. Main Purpose of the Service The primary role of the Pharmacy Department at Barnet, Chase Farm and Edgware Hospitals is to care for the local patients, through ensuring the best use of medicines, and providing information about medicines to both patients and to the professionals who treat them. 3. Current Priority for Reviewing the Service To consider an equality impact assessment. Low Medium High √ 4a. Overall Equality Question Is there a reason to believe that the Pharmacy impacts disproportionately on a particular group of patients i.e patients who suffer from physical impairment or visual impairment. Check all the equality strands, age, disability, gender, race, sexual orientation, religion or belief. Negative impact. Patients whose first language is not English may not know how to access all the services provided by Pharmacy. They may also have difficulties understanding the instructions on the labels. Pharmacy is designing a poster to raise awareness of the Pharmacy Helpline, which is available to patients between 10am and 2pm. Pharmacy is also developing pictorial instructions to help those patients with language difficulties. We are working with the Interpreter services to ensure staff can access for non-English speaking patients when needed (contact Humera Khan, Interpreter Manager at Barnet Hospital). The Inpatient Survey 2008 carried out by Picker Institute showed that 29% of patients felt that they did not receive written or verbal information about their medicines on discharge. 4 August 2009 4b. It is important to take account of how the service is accessed, how delivery impacts on men and women, and how the service carries out its duties to patients. Please state which target group this service impacts upon and state whether it’s a positive or negative impact and give further details as to why. Negative impact. There is presently no designated consulting room for pharmacist to discuss sensitive matters with patients. 5a. Race /Ethnicity Equality You could look at a breakdown of patients along ethnic origins in the local population/ethnicity of patients compared to 2001 Census, 2007 Patient Survey Outcomes, Patient Suggestion Schemes data, etc, if you don’t have any, then discuss what you need to put in place to seek patients views. The Inpatient Survey 2008 showed that 84% of our patients are from White background, 2% mixed and 3% Asian. We are working with the Interpreter Service to develop medicines information leaflets for the top 3 non-English languages. 5b. Is there any inequality in the service provided ? Yes. Currently the Pharmacy only has leaflets in English language and do not specifically carter for other ethnic groups. 5c. Do you have a higher rate of DNA in a particular ethnic group if yes, how many and what does the ethnicity data show us ?. Is there any adverse trend? We have not monitored any current data held on ethnicity. The first task is to ensure that the data is collected within outpatient dispensary for all patients, and then an analysis can be undertaken. This would require a collaborative effort between the Outpatient team and the Pharmacy directorate. 6. Age Equality The Pharmacy service is open to all age groups of patients. 5 August 2009 6a. What is the average age of patients attending the service ? This information is available for the Medicines Directorate but it needs to be specific to Pharmacy. 6b. Which age group represents the highest patient activity/throughput ? From the Inpatient Survey 2008 the highest user group is aged 70 + which is at 41%, followed by 40-49 at 23%, 60-69 at 20%. 6c. Has the service put anything in place to address any particular need for a specific age group ? Positive Impact The new Pharmacy labelling system allows the pharmacists to produce large prints for patients with sight difficulties. There are play areas in both waiting rooms for children and chairs for elderly patients to sit when they wait for their medicines. Barnet Pharmacy will put a poster to inform patients of the long corridor and advise those on crutches or walking difficulties to ask someone to help them. 7. Gender 7a. Which gender access the service most ? From the Inpatient Survey 2008 by Picker Institute 39% were male and 60% female. In practice we see a good mix of male and female patients accessing the Pharmacy service. 7b. Has anything been put in place to help more access the service ? There is a good mix of female and male pharmacy staff working in the department. Pharmacy will oblige if there is a patient preference for a particular gender to counsel them about their medicines. 7c. Do we need to take any positive actions to target due to issues relating to deprived wards in the locality ? 6 August 2009 The CSC is planning to run outreach services in West Hendon where it has been identified that there is a gap in the service. This is a positive action and will benefit the local community. 7d. Are there any cultural issues identified that may affect the patient group ? This does not seem to be a problem to date. We would write on the Patient Helpline poster about patient’s right to request to discuss sensitive matter in private and confidential. 7e. Does the trust need to identify any local stakeholder partners to address any of the issues stated above? The Pharmacy needs to work with the local Racial Equality Councils to establish whether there is any patient group affected. 8. Disability Equality 8a. Do we have any data on the range of disabilities presented by patients and if yes, how has the service put in place reasonable adjustments to address their needs i.e. hard hearing/sight impairments – have we got loops in place on the wards, have we got a special appointments letter we send to them directing them to named staff to help them ? Positive Impact The data on the range of disabilities is currently unavailable. We have ramps/ lifts/wheelchairs/ toilets available for patients with disabilities at the both sites. We do not have hearing loops for the hearing impaired, or Braille leaflets for the visually impaired. We do not have pictorial leaflets for patients with learning needs. Without relevant data it is difficult to ascertain the reasonable adjustments required by the services within Pharmacy. 8b. What additional support have we put in place for disabled patients ? Additional chairs for seating at Barnet Hospital. Capital bid for counter to be lowered at Edgware Pharmacy and ticket counter to be moved at Barnet Pharmacy. 7 August 2009 8c. What other barriers have we identified for them in accessing our services ? Positive Impact Language barrier for patients who require an interpreter. We have ‘Language line’ and access to interpreters if required. Leaflets to be translated in other languages. Use of Pictorial posters for patients with learning difficulties and non-English speaking. Consideration of positioning of signposts in relation to patients with disabilities. 9. Religious belief 9a. Does the service know the religious or beliefs of majority of its patients ? This information is not currently available for Pharmacy. 9b. Is the service meeting religious/ beliefs needs of patients accessing the service? We are raising awareness on the origin of gelatine capsules for Pharmacy staff, in case vegetarian and certain religious patient groups want to know the contents. 9c. What adjustments do we have in place for religious equality? i.e. patients who may for example request the need to be assisted by a female nurse in line with patient choice. Positive Impact We have a good mix of female and male pharmacy staff working in Barnet and Chase Farm. If a need for a male pharmacist arises at Edgware Hospital the Pharmacy Manager will contact the Outpatient Department to request assistant from a male nurse. 9d. Sexual Orientation Equality Postive Impact All patients treated with dignity and respect regardless of sexual orientation. Gender unspecific toilet facilities are available at Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals. There are also genders specific WC’s available at both sites with baby changing facilities. Equality training is provided to all staff and monitoring of complaints will help to develop and enhance the services available, and to provide extra resources where necessary. 8 August 2009 10. Further Information 10a. Is action in place to address any impact identified and what other actions are you considering in the light of these findings ?. Further information and Action Plan to be agreed Action Required Who is responsible Date of Completion Investigate use of interpreters to contact Chief Pharmacist patients where the GP has indicated that English is not their first language. 31 August 2009 Displaying Pharmacy Patient Helpline Dispensary Managers contact details in all outpatient dispensary waiting areas. 30 September 2009 Identify private consulting Outpatient Department 30 September 2009 area Move ticket display unit at Barnet in Chief Pharmacist Senior Pharmacy Manager Barnet 31 October 2009 Investigate provision of leaflets and Senior Pharmacy Manager Chase patient correspondence in Braille and other languages. 31 October 2009 9 August 2009 Raise awareness gelatine capsules about sources of Medicines Information Manager 31 October 2009 All staff to attend Equality Awareness Senior Pharmacy Managers training 31 December 2009 Incorporate Equality Awareness into all Senior Pharmacy Managers staff appraisals 31 December 2009 Hearing Loops 31 December 2009 Senior Pharmacy Managers Amend departmental patient satisfaction Chief Pharmacist survey to cover disability, race, gender, sexual orientation, religion and belief, age and human rights. 31 December 2009 10b. Please give details of action taken. Patient questionnaires Patient forums Posters for Matron to distribute in Outpatient clinics Leaflets in other languages to be considered 10 August 2009 10c. State what the Pharmacy could put in place to promote equality for patients ? Ensure all staff attend Equality and Diversity training sessions and feed back to staff about patients’ needs . 11. Human Rights / Mental Health Capacity Act Training - Do you regularly monitor staff release and attendance at the Trust’s Human Rights and Mental Health Capacity Act training ? This is monitored by HR department. 12. Date for next review: October 2010………………………………………………… 13. Revised Priority for reviewing policy: Low Medium High √ 14. Names of Speciality Medicine Leads for Equality Impact Assessment: TF Chan, Chief Pharmacist BCF Carol Ashurst, Pharmacy Manager, Barnet Hospital Beverley Bevan, Medicines Management Principal Pharmacist BCF Lyn Jackson, Pharmacy Manager, Edgware Hospital Alan Sebti, Pharmacy Manager, Chase Farm Hospital Stella Wan, Production Services Manager, BCF 11