WATERBERG DISTRICT MUNICIPALITY MINING DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY PHASE ONE AND TWO: POLICY AND CURRENT SITUATION ASSESSMENT DISCUSSION DOCUMENT GLEN STEYN AND ASSOCIATES 3 FEBRUARY 2006 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. PURPOSE AND BACKGROUND 3 2. 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 POLICY ASSESSMENT Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act Mining Charter Limpopo Growth and Development Strategy Limpopo Mining Strategy (Draft) Integrated Development Plan for WDM Local Economic Development Plan for WDM Spatial Development Framework for WDM Marketing & Investment Strategy for WDM IDPs and LEDs for Local Municipalities in WDM Case Studies of International Best Practice 4 4 4 5 8 11 16 17 17 20 21 3. 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 CURRENT SITUATION ASSESSMENT Geological Overview Economic Geology Current Mining Operations Mining in the District Economy Opportunities for Expansion Business-as-Usual Scenario for Mining in WDM 23 23 24 30 33 35 36 4. CONCLUSION ON PHASE ONE AND TWO 38 ANNEXURE ANNEXURE ANNEXURE ANNEXURE ONE: MAP OF MINING ACTIVITIES IN WDM TWO: DIAGRAM OF THE COAL CLUSTER THREE: DIAGRAM OF THE PGM VALUE CHAIN FOUR: GEOLOGY MAP OF WATERBERG DISTRICT 40 41 42 43 2 1. PURPOSE AND BACKGROUND The purpose of this strategy formulation process is to provide WDM with a policy instrument by which leadership and strategic direction can be given to the mining industry for: Increased competitiveness on a sustainable basis, Increased investment as a basis for job creation and economic growth, Improvements in the quality of life of the district population, including priorities such as BEE, as well as reductions in HIV/AIDS and poverty, Regional integration. This mining development strategy is part of a broader intervention that is aimed at accelerated economic development in Waterberg District. The mining development strategy will be compiled in the following five distinct phases: Policy Assessment Current Situation Assessment Scenario Analysis Project Development Opportunities, and Implementation Plan. The policy and current situation assessments are presented in this report as a discussion document. It will be formalised once comments from stakeholders have been received. Report Two will deal with the results of the scenario analysis and is scheduled for release as a discussion document at the end of February 2006. Report Three will cover project development opportunities as well as the implementation plan and this will be released as a discussion document at the end of March. All three reports will be consolidated into a final strategy document once stakeholder comments have been received. 3 2. 2.1 POLICY ASSESSMENT Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act The object of the Minerals and Petroleum Development Act, No. 28 of 2002, is to make provision for the equitable access to and sustainable development of the nation’s mineral and petroleum resources; and to provide for matters connected therewith, such as prospecting and mining and rights and permits. The Act recognizes the following principles: That the country’s mineral and petroleum resources belong to the nation and that the State is the custodian thereof Mining can and should contribute to economic growth and job creation There is a need to promote the local and rural development and the social upliftment of communities affected by mining The State should be committed to eradicating all discriminatory practices in the mining and petroleum industries The State should endeavor to bring about equitable access to South Africa’s mineral and petroleum resources, particularly for historically disadvantaged persons The nation’s mineral and petroleum resources should be developed in an orderly and ecologically sustainable manner Holders of mining and petroleum rights should contribute towards the socio-economic development of the areas in which they are operating Security of tenure should be provided in respect of prospecting, exploration, mining and production operations. The Municipality has no jurisdiction over the administration and granting of mineral rights but it does have the right to be consulted on each application that will affect the Waterberg District. It is therefore imperative that a good working relationship should be established between WDM and the DME Regional Manager in Limpopo. The municipality is also obliged to facilitate the economic and mining development processes by building networks and promoting good working relationships between various institutions in the sector, such as private companies, parastatal development organizations and public infrastructure agencies. 2.2 Mining Charter The Broad-Based Socio –Economic Empowerment Charter for the South African Mining Industry is an agreement drawn and entered into by the social partners in the mining industry which seeks to redress the imbalances that existed and still exist in the mining industry. The Charter is a way in which the social partners commit themselves to the implementation of the relevant provisions of the Constitution and the Mineral and Petroleum Development Act which also aim to redress historical social and economic inequalities. The charter should also be read and applied in relation to the following pieces of legislation: The Preferential Procurement Framework Act Supply Chain Management Act The Competition Act The Skills Development Act. 4 The signatories to the charter have committed themselves to substantial improvements in literacy, numeracy, as well as skills training within the mining industry. Targets to achieve 40% HDI participation in management and 10% participation of women in mining by October 2007 were also agreed upon. Thirdly, signatories undertook to remove all discrimination against foreign migrant labour and to improve the standard of housing for mine employees. A progression of procurement from historically disadvantaged South African (HDSA) companies was accepted. Mining companies also agreed to achieve 26% ownership of mining assets by HDSA companies before October 2012 and to assist these companies in raising finance for this purpose. Finally, all signatories agreed upon a scorecard for the regular reporting of progress. WDM has an important role to play in promoting the stake of historically disadvantaged companies that are based in Waterberg District within the targets of the charter. 2.3 Limpopo Growth and Development Strategy 2.3.1 Competitive Clusters for Growth and Development One objective of the Limpopo Growth and Development Strategy is to increase economic growth at a rate that will raise the contribution from Limpopo towards national wealth creation from 6.5% in 2001 to 9% by 2010 and to 12% by 2020. The relevant strategy is to adopt the development cluster value-chain approach, as a vehicle to raise the international competitiveness and investment rating of the Province, to combine public and private sector contributions to development and to align the interventions of various public development institutions for greater impact. Clusters are critical masses, spatially concentrated and of unusual competitive success in a particular field. They encompass an array of linked industries, from suppliers and providers of infrastructure to down-stream activities and service organisations. They also include training, research and governmental institutions. Competitive advantage within these clusters is driven not so much by the source and cost of inputs as by the productive use of inputs, which requires continuous innovation. Middle and low-income countries have traditionally competed in the world market with cheap labour and natural resources. In order to move beyond this stage, the development of well-functioning clusters is essential. Promoting cluster formation will require policy attention to issues such as: Improving education and skills; Provision of essential infrastructure; Building capacity in technology; Opening access to capital markets, and Improving institutions / institutional efficiency. Once a cluster begins to form, a self-reinforcing cycle promotes its growth. Clusters improve competitiveness by increasing productivity, by driving the direction and pace of innovation and by stimulating the formation of new business. It is therefore, the perfect context, within which to develop a strategy to promote 5 economic growth, to create sustainable opportunities for local economic development and SMMEs; and to offer acceptable returns for investments in development. Two of the seven competitive clusters for Limpopo that were identified and approved in the Provincial Growth and Development Strategy fall within the mining sector of Waterberg District. These are the platinum and coal mining clusters with their associated value chains and extracts from the PGDS for these clusters are provided below. 2.3.2 Approved Mining Clusters for Waterberg District Platinum Group Metals Mining Cluster Anchor projects for this cluster will be the existing and new platinum mines and all the up-stream development potential that emerges from this. Up-stream development potential includes the establishment of local suppliers for mine purchases, as well as business to provide the shopping needs of the work force. Down-stream activities refer to the smelter that has already been constructed in Polokwane with the potential for expansion, as well as a refinery that is envisaged in the future. Public sector interventions to improve the competitiveness of this PGM cluster include the upgrading of access roads, water source development, education and skills development with specific reference to the mining sector and improved service delivery for residential development around the mines. A map is provided in Annexure One that reflects the location of existing and future mining and mineral processing activities. It provides a useful starting point for the mining cluster planning process. Coal Mining and the Petrochemical Cluster at Lephalale Proposals have been developed to expand the existing Grootegeluk Coal Mine and the power station and also to build an aromatics extraction factory, which will form the core of this cluster. The factory will be fed with chemical grade coal from Grootegeluk Mine. A wide range of down-stream opportunities exists in the styrofoam, plastic, nylon and rubber product industries. A memorandum of understanding for the compilation of a feasibility study has been signed between Kumba Resources (Grootegeluk Mine) and Limpopo Province. Public sector interventions include approval for the expansion of the power station, water source development, education and skills development with specific reference to the chemical industry, and a rail link to Richards Bay in the long term. Annexure Two reflects the existing and proposed future developments pertaining to the Coal and Petrochemical Cluster. In practical terms, it means that the value-chains of the following potential mining development clusters have to be analysed. It should be noted, that these are by no means the only potential clusters within the various Districts. Other development clusters should also be identified and promoted over time, but it is important to start with a manageable number in order to achieve the momentum required to extend the value-chains of each cluster. 6 2.3.3 Methodology for Cluster Value Chain Analysis The following methodology was adopted for the analysis of the cluster value-chains in Limpopo. 1. Illustrate the cluster value-chain graphically with the main production activity in the center. Quantify the economic value and impact of the current main activity. Illustrate and quantify the existing links up-stream, in terms of inputs and services to the main production activity, and down-stream, in terms of value-adding activities. 2. Identify opportunities for new production, expansion of existing production and for efficiency improvements along the value-chain. Illustrate links with neighbouring provinces and countries. 3. Ring fence opportunities for SMME and for poverty reduction within the cluster development opportunities identified in step two above. 4. Identify infrastructure and logistical improvements that could increase the competitiveness of the cluster value-chain. 5. Identify skills development and institutional improvements that could increase the competitiveness of the cluster value-chain. 6. Illustrate the entire cluster value-chain in GIS format. 7. Incorporate the cluster value-chain and its development opportunities (investment, SMME, poverty reduction, infrastructure, as well as skills and institutional development) in the district and municipal IDPs. 8. Reflect the role of national and provincial departments regarding each cluster value-chain in the departmental strategic plans and budgets. 9. Prepare and implement business plans for each opportunity as part of the district and municipal LED processes. (This will be discussed in report 3). 10. Establish a mechanism to monitor the progress and development impact of each cluster value-chain. Cluster value-chain analyses were at an advanced stage by August 2004 and were discussed with provincial departments, districts and municipalities. During this time some work was completed on the PGM value chain, which is reflected in Annexure Three. These analyses also formed the basis for Sector Summits that were held between August – September 2004, involving private sector participants in the agriculture, mining and tourism sectors. The competitive cluster value-chain approach has been adopted and is supported by all stakeholders. The following resolutions were taken to inform the way forward: 7 2.3.4 Resolutions of Development Summits General resolutions Working groups comprising government, labour and business should be established for each of the proposed cluster value-chains, in order to accelerate the cluster development process. Relevant districts and municipalities should be represented on the cluster working groups. These cluster working groups should have access to project management capacity and should be co-ordinated by an executive provincial cluster working group; Infrastructure, including water, transport, electricity and ICT should be upgraded to improve integration, productivity and competitiveness within and across each cluster; Education and training institutions should provide skills development programmes that contribute to improved productivity and competitiveness within each cluster; Research and development should be increased to promote new product (opportunity) development and to improve competitiveness of the proposed clusters; Investment promotion, LED project identification and provincial marketing should reflect the cluster priorities; Business plans are required for each new development opportunity within every cluster and these business plans should reflect the issues raised above, as well as the proposed project contribution to job-creation, to SMME promotion, to gender issues and to BEE; These business plans should be incorporated into departmental strategic plans and IDPs at the district and municipal levels, and In anticipation of the financing strategies that will have to be part of the business plans, a workshop is required to identify and deal with the issues that constrain access to finance in all sectors and across the entire spectrum of business activity from SMME to major corporate projects. The entire spectrum of financing institutions would therefore, need to participate in the workshop and in its resolutions. Specific Mining Summit resolutions In addition to the generic resolutions above, the National Mining Charter and its seven major elements will provide the policy framework for mining development. The target is to eradicate illiteracy by 2009. Accommodation should be transformed from hostels to homes. Finally, a premium will be placed on exploration to discover new mineral reserves and to identify new mining opportunities. WDM is likely to make more progress by leading the way in terms of the value chain planning and development processes, rather than to wait for the provincial government to complete the process for all the clusters. 2.4 Limpopo Mining Strategy (Draft) 2.4.1. Introduction Currently Limpopo has not compiled an official mining strategy but plans are in place to develop one in the near future. This document outlines some of the main features that are likely to appear in such a strategy. The PIDS (Provincial Industrial Development Strategy) is guided by the national industrial development policy, 8 which emphasises among others, a move away from primary natural resource orientation to value addition and beneficiation, information and innovation; spatial development initiatives around economic clusters, employment equity and black economic empowerment and finally, transforming the South African economy to redress past legacies of inequality. Limpopo is abundantly endowed with natural resources; particularly minerals and flora. The substantial mining operations do not contribute significantly and directly to the upliftment of the citizens of the province. In addition the raw materials from these resources are exported without adding much value, hence leaving the province poorer than it could be. Owing to significant investments in the province, mainly from mining, the economic growth of the province in 2001 was 6.8%, which is well above the national average. This growth has, however, not translated into the creation of jobs in sufficient numbers that are so desperately needed to sustain livelihoods. 2.4.2 Strategic Considerations A two pronged strategy for enhancing the quality of life in the province, namely, wealth creation and poverty alleviation, is required. Many discussions have taken place on procurement related to mining, mining operations, beneficiation and value addition. Most of the inputs to the mining operations are provided by suppliers residing outside the province. It will be beneficial if some of the suppliers can relocate to the province and create partnerships with local business especially the BEEs. It is further essential to establish downstream and secondary industries in the mineral value chain; which will remain functional and productive long after the mines have ceased to operate, thus providing job opportunities and avoiding ghost towns. At the center of these activities is the need to create jobs and acquire skills at appropriate levels, which will match these tasks. Hence, capacity for development of such skills is essential. Furthermore, beneficiation is substantially underpinned by research and innovation, implying the necessity of expertise in high level training. Such training involves extensive mentoring, development of human resources and research infrastructure. However the Limpopo province is disadvantaged in this regard, since it has low capacity for generating sophisticated skills at short notice. In addition investment in training, research and innovation has been minimal. In 2001, the expenditure on research and development in the province was 1.3% of the national allocation, when in terms of its population and size the province commands 10%. This under funding has persisted over several decades and has created a significant deficit in terms of research infrastructure and expertise residing in the province. Furthermore, lack of adequate research infrastructure makes it exceedingly difficult to attract and retain suitable human capital in the province. It therefore becomes imperative to implement strategies that will correct these anomalies. An interface with national strategies such as the small scale mining initiative, integrated manufacturing strategy, as well as the national research and development strategy, should be created. 9 2.4.3 Considerations for Implementation The rollout of the mining clusters for purposes of creating jobs involves an analysis of their respective value chains. Activities that are prominent in mining value chains to unlock the potential of job creation are discussed below. Exploration is the entry point and it commences with appraisal and assessments of mineral occurrences in the province. This is followed by techno-economic studies and adaptation, as well as development of appropriate extraction technologies, and where necessary involving test work at laboratory to pilot level. Mine planning follows and will assist in compiling a comprehensive business plan which could facilitate acquisition of funding. This sets the scene for the mining stage, which encompasses mining inputs, mining operations, mining outputs, beneficiation of raw materials and value addition entailing establishment of industries that produce manufactured goods out of raw materials or other associated secondary industries. The execution of plans will involve local and provincial governments, with the provision of basic infrastructure and inputs aligned with their economic planning. The Department of Minerals and Energy could facilitate the plans in accordance with the execution of the Mining and Petroleum Resource Development Act (MPRD) and various national departments could lend support in line with their strategies. National laboratories such as Council for Geosciences (assessment of occurrences), Mintek (techno-economic studies and extraction technology) and CSIR Miningtek (Mining design) could play a significant role in collaboration with local tertiary institutions in building capacity in these areas. The latter play an important role in human resource development through skills training by offering certificates, diplomas and degree programmes. Value addition to raw materials will be a collaborative effort of the institutions above, where research, innovation and postgraduate training could be pursued. Collaboration with other institutions locally and internationally could facilitate skills and technology transfer and capacity building. The plans for each mineral cluster will unfold differently with resources provided judiciously at various stages of the value chain to optimize job creation. However, the rollout of the plan could be piloted with selected minerals. The Mining strategy cannot operate in a vacuum in the province and will have to be aligned with the activities of the other lead sectors. The role of digital databases linked to a spatial system through a GIS will be useful in facilitating co-ordination. Mining is capital intensive and can justify substantial capital outlays in infrastructure development in areas where little infrastructure existed before. Once this is in place, other opportunities are created, such as transportation, water, energy and power supply. From this provision, tourism and agriculture can be introduced to localities adjacent to the mine, thereby creating economic sustainability after the mining reserves are depleted. 10 2.5 Integrated Development Plan for WDM The following four tables were extracted from the analysis section of the IDP for WDM. They provide information on the potential for three classes of minerals per local municipality and on the operating mines in the District. The three mineral classes are precious metals, ferrous and base metals, as well as industrial minerals. All local municipalities have some mineral potential, although it is relatively less in Mookgopong and Modimolle. Some of the mining projects on the list in table four, such as coal liquefaction at Lephalale, are still in the planning stage. Economic objectives for mining in the IDP are to ensure economic growth of 5% in sector over the next five years, but no figure is provided to indicate the size of the sector as reference point for 2005. The strategies contained in the IDP to achieve this objective are to create awareness about mining opportunities, to identify support programmes for mining co-operatives and to promote SMMEs in mining through the provision of incentives. The two economic development projects for the mining sector that are contained in the IDP are the recycling of coal ash for brick block manufacturing and the establishment of a pebble co-operative. 11 TABLE 2.5.1: PRECIOUS METALS AND DIAMONDS PER LOCAL MUNICIPALITY MUNICIPALITY MINERAL LOCATION DEPOSIT CORRIDOR NAME STATUS STATUS Bela-Bela Gold Plat river Small scale Outside the 50 km radius of the Diamonds Mackenzie Sufficient East-West (Kimberlite) corridor, within the 20 km radius of the Trans-Limpopo corridor Modimolle 20 km radius of the TransLimpopo corridor Mogalakwena Platinum Platinum reef Sufficient Within the 20 Gold Rebone Small scale km radius of the Ga-Mathapo Small scale East-West corridor Mookgopong Platinum Swaershoek Medium scale 50 km corridor Mountains area Lephalale Diamond Swartwater Large and 50 km outside (Kimberlite) small scale 50 km radius Thabazimbi Platinum Northam Sufficient Outside the 50 Gold complex Sufficient km radius Kaya se put Medium scale Outside the 5o (Madikwe) km radius Dwaalboom Outside the 50 km radius SOURCE: COUNCIL FOR GEOSCIENCE TABLE 2.5.2: FERROUS AND BASE METALS PER LOCAL MUNICIPALITY MUNICIPALITY MINERAL LOCATION DEPOSIT CORRIDOR NAME STATUS STATUS Bela-Bela *1 Modimolle *1 Mogalakwena Mookgopong *1 Lephalale *2 Manganese Copper Tin Cobalt Silica Manganese Iron Tin Zirconium Nickel Vanadium Tin Titanium Molybdenum Chrome Lead Tin Iron Copper Nickel Thabazimbi Iron Nickel Beryllium Plat river Modimolle Modimolle/Vaalwater Alma Alma Witkop Droomdlea Along the N11 Tin mines Waterberg mountains Tin mines Chrome mines Vlakfontein/Uitgedaght Swaerhoek Mountains Kauletsi Tom Burke Kauletsi/ Glenover/Rosedale Doornfontein Thabazimbi Northam Rooibokkraal Small scale Small scale Small scale Small scale Sufficient Small scale Small scale Small scale Small scale Sufficient Sufficient Sufficient Small scale Small scale Sufficient Small scale Sufficient Small Small Small Small Small scale scale scale scale scale Sufficient (CPR) Sufficient Small scale Outside the 50 km radius. Outside the 50 km radius. Within a 20 radius Core of the SDI Within the 20 radius Within the 20 radius Within the 20 radius Within the 50 radius Within the 50 radius Within the 50 radius Within a 50 radius Outside the 50 radius Within the 50 radius Outside the 50 radius km km km km km km km km km km km Outside the 50 km radius Outside the 50 km radius Outside the 50 km radius SOURCE: COUNCIL FOR GEOSCIENCE 2002 NOTES: *1 Municipalities within the Springbok Flats *2 Municipality within the Waterberg/Ellisras coal field 13 TABLE 2.5.3: INDUSTRIAL MINERALS PER LOCAL MUNICIPALITY MUNICIPALITY MINERAL NAME Bela-Bela*1 Lime stone Calcite Sandstone Refractory clay Fluorspar Modimolle*1 Silica Kieselguhr Fluorspar Barytes Phosphate Granite Chrysotile Brickclay Lime stone Andalusite Flourspar Fluorspar Sandstone Granite Refractory clay, Marble, Phosphate,Topaz &Feldspar Mogalakwena Mookgopong*1 Lephalale *2 Thabazimbi Attapulgite Lime stone Vermiculite Barytes Crocidolite Andalusite LOCATION DEPOSIT STATUS CORRIDOR STATUS Radium Rust de Winter Eersbewond Buyskop Eersbewood Platriver Kleinnood Keespoort Keespoort Glen Alpine Setateng Kaditshwene Matlala Zebediela road Zebediela road Drommondlea Marken Vlakfontein Vlakfontein Columbia Onverwaght Small scale Sufficient and small scale Sufficient Medium scale Sufficient Outside the 50 km radius of the corridor Sufficient Small scale Small scale Sufficient Medium scale Sufficient Medium scale Medium scale Small scale Small scale Small scale Small scale Sufficient Medium scale Outside the 50 km radius Atherstone Swartwitpenbok-fontein Rooibokkraal Morongwe Berg van winde Ferrogate Medium scale Medium scale Small scale Small scale Small scale Sufficient 20 km of both the East-West and TransLimpopo Within 50 km radius of the East-West and of Trans-Limpopo Outside the 50 km radius of the East-West and Trans-Limpopo Outside the 50 km radius of East-West and Trans-Limpopo SOURCE: COUNCIL FOR GEOSCIENCE SAMINDABA (SOUTH AFRICAN MINERAL DEPOSIT DATABASE 2002) NOTES: *1 Municipalities within the Springbok flats coal field *2 Municipality within the Waterberg/Ellisras coal field TABLE 2.5.4: MINING PROJECTS ALONG THE EAST-WEST CORRIDOR PROJECT NAME PRE INVESTMENT ACTION COST R’000 INVESTMENT R’000 PPL Mine Done N/A 350 000 ESTIMATED NUMBER OF JOBS 250 Amandelbult Grootgeluk Colliery N/A N/A 202 000 150 000 200 100 Coal Liquefying Project Done Feasibility study Ongoing Feasibility study 500 150 0000 Platreef Project Feasibility study 60 000 Vanadis Project Done Haaspan Granite LOCATION DESCRIPTION Overysel 815 LR Vaalkop 819 LR (Mokopane) Northam Lephalale Expansion of open pit mine 300 Waterberg coalfields (Lephalale) 130 0000 800 N/A 54 000 350 Feasibility study 30 25 000 80 Done N/A 500 200 Drenthe 778 LR Awaitrivier 777 LR (Mokopane) Molendraai (Mapela) Haaspan (Bakenberg) Bakenberg and Matlala region Establishment of a plant for the production of carbon chemicals from coal Re-evaluation and mining of platinum resources (PGM) Buffalo Fluorspar Project Modimolle Silica Done Done N/A N/A 5 000 30 000 50 80 Mookgopong Modimolle Rooiberg Tin Project Feasibility study 150 150 000 150 Rooiberg R 60,680 million R 3,766 500 billion 2 560 Matlala Stone Crushers Totals the existing Expansion of existing mine Mining of additional reserves Extraction of vanadium bearing magnetite deposits Granite mining Production of stone aggregates from dolerite boulders Mining of Flourspar mineral Mining of silica sand and establishment of a beneficiation plant for silica products Re-evaluation of the old Tin deposits Source: Integrated Development Plan for WDM, 2005-06. 15 2.6 Local Economic Development Plan for WDM The economic overview section of the LED for WDM contains a description of the mining potential in each local municipality. It also contains a table on the mining projects that were identified as part of the spatial development initiative process in Limpopo. The table is reproduced below. There are no specific recommendations regarding mining development strategies, other than a general statement about SMME development in the mining sector. LED project proposals include a programme to facilitate SMME participation in the mining industry, raising the wall of the Mogol dam, upgrading the road from Modimolle to Lephalale, skills development and the establishment of sectoral working groups. The description of the mining potential in each local municipality is reproduced below for convenient reference. The statement below that mining in Mogalakwena is small is incorrect. 2.6.1 Thabazimbi A large proportion of the mining sector output comes from this municipality. The Northam complex is rich in precious metals and diamonds and ferrous and base metals. Among the key products are gold, while large quantities of platinum and nickel are found in this complex. There is iron in the Thabazimbi town area and beryllium, which provides an opportunity for small-scale mining activities. 2.6.2 Mokgalakwena Municipality According to the LED of WDM this municipality derives little from the mining sector. This is incorrect. It states further that the platinum sub-sector is central to the local mining industry. The supply of platinum resources in the Vaalkop farm is abundant. Gold, though limited, is the only other precious metal found in the area. Ferrous and base metals consist of nickel, vanadium and tin, with titanium and molybdenum found on a limited scale. 2.6.3 Lephalale Municipality Activities relating to mining are centered upon the well resourced Waterberg coalfield. A project to extract methane from this coalmine is currently being explored. There is also a small-scale presence of minerals such as diamond, iron, copper, nickel, refractory clay, marble, phosphate, topaz and feldspar. 2.6.4 Modimolle Municipality In general, the mining sector in this Municipality is unlikely to take center stage in the local economic development agenda in the foreseeable future. There are no precious metals in the area. Available resources are not economically significant, and examples of resources include silica, manganese, iron, tin, zirconium, kieselguhr and fluorspar. A small-scale silica project is being planned for Modimolle town. 2.6.5 Mookgophong The overall indication is that the mining sector plays a small part in the local economy. There are some platinum reserves, as well as ferrous and base metals that include chrome and tin. 2.6.6 Bela-Bela Municipality According to the LED strategy the contribution from mining towards local economic development in this municipality is insignificant, though diamond resources are available in the area. There are occurrences of precious metals, particularly gold. Other metals especially the ferrous and base metals, are found on a limited scale, and some of these metals comprise manganese, copper, tin and cobalt. The profile of industrial metals is positive. Several mining projects were identified as part of the spatial development initiative (SDI) process as indicated in the table below. Table 2.6: SDI Mining projects identified in the Waterberg Location Name of project Capital Required Mogalakwena PPL mine R350m Platreef R130m Vanadis R54m Haaspan Granite R25m Matlala stone crushers R500m Thabazimbi Amandelbult R202m Lephalale Grootgeluk Colliery R150m Mookgophong Buffalo Fluorspar R500m Modimole Silica R30m Thabazimbi Rooiberg Tin R150m Total 11 R3 766 500 Source: LED Strategy for WDM 2.7 District Jobs 250 800 350 80 200 200 100 50 80 150 2 560 Spatial Development Framework for WDM The Spatial Development Framework for WDM contains extracts on mining from all local municipality IDPs in the District. This is discussed in section 2.9 below. Reference is specifically made to the potential for platinum mining, the Waterberg Coalfields and the possibility of extracting coal bed methane. There is also a discussion on mineral potential per commodity that has been extracted from various WDM IDP documents. The strategy section cautions against the sterilization of mineral potential by way of residential settlement and calls for judicious environmental management programmes on mining projects. 2.8 Marketing & Investment Strategy for WDM The marketing and investment strategy for WDM contains an extensive analysis of the mining sector. It maintains that mining can be regarded as the most important economic sector of Waterberg District Municipality. Aside from the Thabazimbi iron ore mine, the region produces vast qualities of platinum at Mokopane and Northam. Its coalfield at Lephalale, formerly Ellisras, fuels a giant Eskom power station, but its remaining reserves of the black gold are largely untapped. Mining resources, according to the strategy document, include the following: 17 Precious metals: Gold, Diamonds (Kimberlite), and Platinum; and Ferrous and base metals: Copper, Tin, Manganese, Colbat, Iron, Nickel, Titanium, Molybdenum, Vanadium, Chrome, Lead, Berylium, etc. It states that investment opportunities are found in the following: The Coal Mining cluster in the Lephalale area. The prospects could contribute towards job creation and turn the area into the province’s new coal source. Waterberg’s coal reserves have over 6.5 billion tons of coal, making it South Africa’s third largest coal reserve after Witbank and Highveld fields. In addition, various important minerals, such as chromium, tin, etc. are currently mined in the area. Apart from the popular precious and ferrous metals, Waterberg offers opportunities to expand the exploitation of minerals such as attapulgite clay, fluorspar, phosphate topaz, etc. Of special interest to potential investors, is the potential for coal liquefaction. Furthermore, Waterberg has a large deposit of antimony. This strategic chemical element is used in alloys and in medicine. Five specific projects are listed in the marketing and investment strategy, as summarised below. PRODUCT 1: Coal Liquification Location: Lephalale Local Municipality Potential Markets: Markets do exist nationally and internationally. As raw material coal may be supplied to gas producers, direct as fuel, or cooking. The Waterberg coal can be used for the following purposes: gas generation; direct liquefaction as fuel, blend coking in ferro-alloy industries and PF combustion for electricity generation. Competitiveness: The major coal producing areas in South Africa have reached maturity and large scale expansion limited. The Waterberg coalfield offers the potential to sustain energy development in the long term when coal production enters a declining phase in the traditional high producing areas. Resources Needed: Infrastructure, machinery, human resources, capital investment, etc. Strategic Goals: Job creation, Black Economic Empowerment, poverty reduction, integrated rural development, etc. PRODUCT 2: Platinum Location: It is found in Mogalakwena and Thabazimbi. Potential Markets: Markets for platinum are found nationally and internationally. It is in demand for manufacturing of corrosion-resistant products. The metal will be in demand for the next ten years. Competitiveness: Mineralisation on the Platreef (Mogalakwena) is intense and open cast mining reduces production costs. Resources Needed: Infrastructure, human resources, capital investment, etc. Strategic Goals: Black economic empowerment, job creation, poverty reduction, etc. PRODUCT 3: Vanadium Location: Mollendraai. The main magnetic layer in this area is about 8m thick and occurs about 230m above the first appearance of the magnetite in the sequence and some 110m above the lowest layer. 18 Potential Markets: The market for vanadium is mostly international and prospects are that demand will exceed supply for the next decade. Competitiveness: Mogalakwena has large deposits of Vanadium and could become the major source of this metal in the next 15 to 20 years. Resources Needed: Infrastructure, human resources, capital investment, etc. Strategic Goals: Black economic empowerment, job creation, poverty reduction, etc. PRODUCT 4: Gold Location: Bela-Bela Plat River and Thabazimbi (Madikwe) Potential Markets: Gold is amongst the most popular metals. Its markets are both national and international. Competitiveness: Relatively at small scale, Thabazimbi is known to have good prospects in gold mining. Resources Needed: Infrastructure, human resources, capital investment, etc. Strategic Goals: Black economic empowerment, job creation, poverty reduction, etc. PRODUCT 5: Diamonds (Kimberlite) Location: Bela-Bela (Mckenzie) and Lephalale (Swatwater) Potential Markets: These very hard indigenous African crystalline carbon stones valued as gems are in demand all over the world. Competitiveness: Relatively at large sufficient scale for exploitation, Lephalale has had extensive mining experience and has the drive to pursue diamond products development. Resources Needed: Infrastructure, human resources, capital investment, etc. Strategic Goals: Black economic empowerment, job creation, poverty reduction, etc. The marketing and investment strategy recommends five strategic focus areas: Encouraging Local Business Growth and Retention Improving the Local Business Investment Climate Promoting Inward Investment Investment in Hard Strategic Infrastructure Integrating Low Income or Hard-to-Employ Workers. The establishment of a District Investment Council with an operations manager is proposed to drive the implementation process. The following diagram of the mining industry value chain is provided in the marketing and investment strategy. Figure 1: Value Chain in Mining Industry 19 INBOUND LOGISTICS OUTBOUND LOGISTICS OPERATIONS INVESTMENTS INPUTS END-USER RETAILERS PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT: IMPROVED QUALITY INCREASED FLEXIBILITY JUST IN TIME MARKETING INFRASTRUCTURE MONETARY HUMAN RESOURCES RAW MATERIAL ETC. RAW MATERIALS Shafts 2.9 EXTRACTION PROCESSING IDPs and LEDs for Local Municipalities in WDM Extracts on mining from the Integrated Development Plans of the six local municipalities in WDM are reproduced below for convenient reference. 2.9.1 Bela Bela The IDP contains no information that is directly related to mining. 2.9.2 Lephalale According to the Lephalale IDP document, mining shows a negative growth trend. It is expected that the proposals concerning the expansion of the local coal mine and the development of associated industries will reverse this negative trend. The Waterberg coalfield has significant reserves (±50% of the Republic of South Africa’s total reserve) and represents a major development opportunity. A pilot project is being planned to examine the feasibility of the extraction of methane and other related activities. Coal beneficiation is contained in the project section of the IDP. 2.9.3 Modimolle 20 The occurrence of tin and coal is described and reference is made to the planning of a small scale silica project outside Modimolle town. 2.9.4 Mogalakwena The Mogalakwena IDP indicates that the contribution from mining to the municipal GGP was R41 million in 2001 but this is likely to be a considerable understatement. It also includes a discussion on the mineral occurrences in the municipal areas, as well as a table with information on operating mines. There is reference to the prospect of a new platinum or palladium mine on the farm Volspruit 326KP. The LED strategy has only general statements about mining and small scale mining development. Only stone crushing is included in the project section of the LED strategy. 2.9.5 Mookgopong According to the IDP mining in Mookgopong is confined to fluorspar (with a limited lifespan) and to tin. 2.9.6 Thabazimbi Mining is reflected as by far the largest employer in Thabazimbi Municipality. The names and locations of operating mines are also provided. However, Thabazimbi Iron Ore Mine is approaching depletion with reserves that are likely to run out before 2015. The Thabazimbi Investment Initiative (a private initiative) was recently established as a Section 21 Company to promote and facilitate economic development in the area. The IDP document contains no strategies or projects relating to mining, apart from the statement that an LED strategy should be compiled. 2.10 Case Studies of International Best Practice The province of South Australia has characteristics that are very similar to those of the Waterberg District in South Africa. It is therefore considered appropriate to reflect on the strategic development planning process in that province. South Australia has a strategic plan of which one objective is to grow prosperity. This objective attaches priority to sustained economic growth resulting in rising living standards, with all South Australians sharing in the benefits through more and better job opportunities and accessible, high quality services. The targets within this objective that relate specifically to mining are to make Australia a favoured mineral investment destination for private investment by with exploration expenditure targeted to almost treble to $100 million by Mineral production is targeted to reach $3 billion by 2020, with a further $1 worth of minerals processing by that time. South 2010, 2007. billion The priority action for these targets is to develop an innovative and internationally competitive sustainable mineral exploration industry through investment in 21 exploration, production and processing. Primary responsibility for this action is allocated to the state (provincial) government and to industry. Indicators of progress include quarterly and annual measures of performance in terms of exploration, performance and international attraction. A Mineral Resources Group has been assembled to facilitate mineral exploration and development. The opportunities for and possible benefits from a closer working relationship between this Mineral Resources Group and the Waterberg District Municipality will be considered in subsequent phases of this mining development strategy formulation process. 22 3. 3.1 CURRENT SITUATION ASSESSMENT Geological Overview The geology of the Waterberg district is shown in Annexure Four. The oldest rocks in the Waterberg district municipality are represented by the Beit Bridge Complex and the Pietersburg Greenstone Belt. The Pietersburg Greenstone Belt is of limited extend and it outcrops in the eastern portion f the district. The Beit Bridge Complex consisting of a variety of high-grade metamorphic rocks covers the northern portion of the district. These rocks are associated with corundum, nickel and beryllium. Archaean granite and gneiss that form the floor on which sediments of the Transvaal Supergroup were deposited, represent the oldest rocks in the district. These rocks outcrop mainly in the southwestern and eastern portions of the district. Although poorly mineralised, the Archaean Granite and Gneisses host some pegmatite minerals including quartz, feldspar, beryllium, mica, lepidolite, tantalum, scheelite and tin), corundum, graphite, copper and gold in places (Wilson, 1998). The Transvaal Supergroup forms the immediate footwall rock to the Bushveld Complex and consists of quartzite at the base, overlain by dolomite, banded ironstone, alternating shale and quartzite, and an upper basaltic and volcanic phase. The rocks of the Transvaal Supergroup are associated with zinc, lead, gold, fluorspar, iron, asbestos and andalusite. (Wilson, 1998). The Bushveld Complex represents the largest layered intrusion on earth covering an area of about 65 000 km2. It consists of the mafic and ultramafic rocks termed the Rustenburg Layered Suite, and an acid phase represented by the Lebowa Granite and the Rashoop Granophyre Suites. The rocks of the Bushveld Complex crop out in four sub-circular structures (the western, eastern, northern or Potgietersrus and the Far western limbs. In the Waterberg district, the Bushveld Complex is represented by the rocks belonging to the northern and western limbs. The Rustenburg Layered Suite of the Bushveld Complex host vast resources of platinum group elements, chrome, vanadium and nickel. These rocks are estimated to contain about 75 % and 50 % of the world `s resources of platinum and palladium respectively (Cawthorn, 1999). The acid phase of the Bushveld Complex is associated with fluorspar, tin and copper mineralisation. A generalised geological map of the Bushveld Complex showing the outcrop of the different limbs comprising the Bushveld Complex is presented in figure one below. 23 Figure One: Outcrops on the Bushveld Complex 3.2 Economic Geology The rocks covering the Waterberg district area are well endowed with a significant number of economically important minerals that include the platinum group metals, iron, coal, andalusite, tin and fluorite. Some of these minerals are currently exploited for their economic value while exploration is on-going in order to expand the lifespan of the existing mines and also to identify and develop new deposits. This description of the mineral commodities and their future potential is structured in the sequence of their current economic importance. 3.2.1. Platinum Group Metals (PGM) Platinum group metals (platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium, osmium, and iridium) occur in the mafic and ultramafic rocks of the Bushveld Complex. In this complex, the platinum group metals occur in layers known as the Merensky Reef, the UG 2 Chromitite and the Platreef. Significant amounts of base metal sulphides are associated with the Bushveld Complex mineralised horizons. The Merensky Reef and the UG 2-chromitite seam occur in the north-western limb, south of Thabazimbi while the Platreef occurs only in the northern limb extending north-south of Mokopane. According to Cawthorn (1999), in the Merensky Reef, Platreef and the UG 2 Chromitite, the relative proportions of platinum and palladium are about 55 % and 32 %, 44 % and 46 %, and 46 % and 30 % respectively, with the other metals comprising about 15 %. The PGM grades in these Reefs are shown in the table below. 24 Table 3.2.1: PGM grades in the Bushveld Complex in grams per ton (g/t) Metal Merensky Reef UG 2 Platreef Platinum 3.24 2.46 1.26 Palladium 1.37 2.04 1.38 Ruthenium 0.44 0.72 0.12 Rhodium 0.16 0.54 0.09 Iridium 0.06 0.11 0.02 Osmium 0.04 0.10 0.02 Total 5.31 5.97 2.89 Source: Keller, 1983 Until the early 90`s, platinum group metals production was confined to the Merensky Reef and the UG 2 Chromitite. Although exploitation of the Platreef dates back to the early 1920`s, large-scale production only began in the 1990`s with the opening of Anglo Platinum Potgietersrus Platinum mine at Sandsloot. The Merensky Reef is typically a heterogenous pegmatoidal feldspathic pyroxenite with scattered sulphide blebs and is generally bounded by narrow chromitite stringers (Viljoen and Schürmann, 1998). The reef varies in thickness from less than 3 cm to about 14 m. At the Union Section, Amandelbult and at Northam Platinum Mine a gradual change in depth occurs from thick Merensky Reef (> 1 m) via areas of increasing potholing to narrow reef. According to Viljoen and Schürmann (1998) a variety of PGE alloys, dominantly iron-rich phases constituting 40 % of the PGM`s are regionally the most important at the Union, and Amandelbult Sections and at the Northam Platinum mine. These platinum group metals occur either attached or enclosed to base metal sulphides, enclosed in silicates and to a lesser extent attached to chromite or iron oxides. The base metals in order of abundance are pyrrhotite, pentlandite, chalcopyrite, pyrite, cubanite and rare sulpharsenides, galena and sphalerite (Lee, 1996). The UG 2 Chromitite occurs 15 to 400 m below the Merensky Reef. This reef contains up to 10 ppm PGE + Au. The platinum group metals are concentrated towards the base of the UG 2 Chromitite as well as in the middle, or towards the upper contact. The copper and nickel content of the UG 2 Chromitite are generally low (< 0.05 %). The Platreef is a major PGE-Ni-Cu mineralised horizon in the northern limb of the Bushveld Complex. It attains a maximum thickness of about 400 m. Unlike the Merensky and the UG 2 chromitite Reefs, the Platreef is developed at the base of the layered sequence. Mineralisation within the Platreef varies along strike and this variation is attributed to the variations in footwall rocks. The Platreef has relatively more palladium than the Merensky and the UG 2 chromitite Reefs. 25 3.2.2 Coal The Waterberg (Ellisras) Coalfield, covering an area of approximately 88 km x 40 km was discovered in the 1920`s. Coal occurs associated with the Karoo Supergroup rocks. This outcrops in the western portion of the Waterberg district. This coalfield is heavily faulted with the major faults striking in the east-west direction. The coalfield is divided into eastern and western sectors by the Daarby fault (Snyman, 1998). The western sector is shallower while the eastern sector is relatively deeper. Faulting has rendered some areas unmineable; however, the scarcity of dolerite intrusions offsets the structural complexity of the area to a certain degree. Here, the coal-bearing interval attains a thickness of about 115m. The Waterberg coalfield hosts over 40 % of South Africa’s in situ mineable coal reserves and is considered as the major source of South African coal in the next century. 3.2.3 Iron Ore Economically important deposits of iron occur associated with the Penge Formation of the Transvaal Supergroup. These deposits are currently exploited by Thabazimbi iron mine on the farms Donkerpoort 344 KQ and Kwaggashoek 345 KQ located about 180 km northwest of Pretoria. Occurrences are reported on the farms Melkbosch 139 MR, Deptford 16 LR, Doornkraal 15 LR, Houndslow 372 LQ, Adriaanshoop 291 KQ, Cornwal 313 KQ and Donkerpoort 448 KQ. Some iron deposits (i.e. Goevernements Plaats 417 KQ and Oskuil 390 KQ) occur associated with vanadium and titanium. The distribution of these deposits was controlled by large scale pre-Karoo thrust faulting and post-Karoo normal faulting. At Thabazimbi mine, the ore is made of high-grade hematite that occurs in the basal portion of the Penge Formation and has a dip of 60 º (Astrup et al., 1998). Hematite with iron content of less than 56 % is considered as waste. 3.2.4. Diamonds Diamond deposits occur on the farms Palmietgat 34 JR, Oaks 153 MR and Zuurverdiend 167 KP. The deposit at Palmietgat 34 JR is exploited by Palmietgat mine while the Oaks mine (De Beers) is exploiting by the Oaks deposit. The Zuurverdiend 167 KP deposit was never exploited. The Oaks mine established in 1998 is located about 20 km from Swartwater. The Oaks kimberlite pipe is approximately one hectare in size. This is a group I type kimberlite, which was intruded into the quartzo-feldspathic and amphibolite gneisses of the Limpopo belt. The current reserves at the Oaks mine will be depleted in 2008. The kimberlite ore body has inferred resource of 3.7 million tons and reserve of 2.1 million tons to a mining depth of 110 m. 3.2.5. Andalusite Andalusite is well developed near Thabazimbi in the Timeball Hill Formation shale of the Transvaal Supergroup (Blain et al., 1976). Deposits of andalusite occur on the farms Bufffelsfoentein 353 KQ, Rooywal 441 KQ, Grootfoentein 352 KQ and Rhenosterkloof 483 KQ, with occurrences reported on Buffelshoek 351 KQ, Roodedam 368 KP and Weltervreden 478 KQ. On the farm Grootfontein 352 KQ, andalusite occurs as medium grained porphyroblasts, 0.4 cm in diameter and up to 5 cm in length in weathered hornfels. According to Oostrhuis (1998), the orebody 26 strikes in a northeast-southwest direction with a true thickness of 210 m and a dip of 55 º to the southeast. On this farm andalusite contains about 54 - 59 wt percent Al2O3, constituting 10 to 13 % of the rock. 3.2.6. Dimension stone Dimension stone incorporates all naturally occurring rock material cut, shaped or selected for use in blocks, slabs, sheets or other construction units of specific shape or size, and employed for exterior or interior parts of buildings, foundations, kerbing, paving, flagging or for other architectural or engineering purposes (Stone in Southern Africa, 1999). The dimension stone quarried from the Bushveld Complex is in strong demand on the world market and dominates export sales, owing to high quality, competitive prices and reliability of supply. 3.2.7. Limestone Limestone occurs in the Transvaal Supergroup and this can be exploited and used for cement production and/ or for agricultural purposes. Rocks of the Frisco Formation that forms the footwall rock to the Bushveld Complex on the farm Vaalkop 819 LR are a potential source of limestone (Martini, 1987). The main limestone deposit in the Waterberg district is located 9 km north-northeast of Mokopane on the farm Uitloop 3 KS (Martini and Wilson, 1998). This deposit was exploited in the past but production ceased. 3.2.8. Calcite Calcite deposits occur on the farms Syferfoentein 608 KR, Leeuwdoorns 607 KR and Middleplaats 604 KR. The Syferfoentein deposit was exploited by Monte Carlo while the Leeuwdooms 607 KR and Middleplaats 604 KR deposits were never exploited. 3.2.9. Chrome Chromite occurs in seams in the Critical and Lower Zones of the Waterberg Complex. On the farm Zwartfontein 818 LR north-northwest of Mokopane, three chromitite layers are present in the plagioclase bearing rocks (Schürmann et al., 1998). Two other chromitite layers of no economic importance crop out on the farm Vaalkop 819 LR (van der Merwe, 1978). In the Mokopane area chromitite was discovered in the early sixties on the farms Grassvalley 293 KR and Zoetveld 294 KR about 17 km south-southwest of Mokopane (Coetzee and Coetzee, 1976). The composition for this ore ranges from 42-45 percent Cr2O3, 14 -15 percent FeO, 6-9 percent SiO2 and a Cr/Fe ratio of 2.4 to 2.7 (Cotzee and Coetzee, 1976). This ore was superior in grade to any other chromitite mined in the Bushveld Complex at that time (Hulbert and Von Gruenewaldt, 1986). This deposit was exploited by Grasvalley chrome mine owned by SAMANCOR. However, the area is structurally complex. 3.2.10. Tin The Zaaiplaats tin deposits are located some 35 km northwest of Mokopane. These important deposits occur associated with the acid phase of the Bushveld Complex. The most important deposits are found on the farms Roodepoort 222 KR, Zaaiplaats 223 KR, Salomon`s Tempel 230 KR, Groenfontein 227 KR, Welgelegen 246KR, Doornhoek 342 KR and Stravoren 676 KS. Tin mineralisation occurs in pipe-like roughly cylindrical bodies, flat ventricular bodies and as disseminations. These 27 pipes range in diameter from a few centimetres to 12 m with an average diameter of 1 to 2 m. Pipe-like bodies have a cassiterite content ranging from nil to 70 percent with metallic tin averages 12 to 30 % (Crocker et al., 1976). On the farms Groenvley 224 KR and Appingendam 805 LR cassiterite occur along with molybdenite, arsenopyrite, fluorite, bastnaesite and other rare-earth minerals (Bullen et al, 1995). Values of up to 3.2 % Sn have been recorded on the farm Groenvley 224 KR over a width of 0.91 m. The Sn content of these rocks varies significantly. 3.2.11. Fluorite Fluorspar was mined from acid rocks of the Bushveld Complex in the past, however due to the low price of fluorite the mines have closed. Fluorspar was exploited northwest of Mookgopong on the farm Buffelsfontein 347 KR by Buffalo Fluorspar mine. This mine was closed in 1994 due to low prices of fluorspar. The dumps are currently being reworked as a source of crushed rock. Crocker and Martini (1976) reported ore reserves amounting to 60 million tons at 16 percent CaF2. The Vischgat deposit occurs south of Mookgopong on the farm Vischgat 520 KR. Fluorite deposit were also exploited in the Vila Nora segment of the Bushveld Complex on the farm Grobbelaars Hoek 462 LR. Fluorspar was also exploited west of Bela-Bela (Warmbaths) on Zwartkloof 470 KR by the Zwartkloof Fluorspar mine and also on the farm Rhenosterhoekspruit 466 KQ by Rheno Fluorspar mine. The Zwartkloof Fluorspar mine closed due to the low prices of fluorspar and problems in upgrading such low-grade material to acid grade (Crocker and Martini, 1976). According to Crocker and Martini (1976) original estimates of the Zwartkloof deposit indicated an ore body of 5 to 7 million tons. 3.2.12. Clay Kaolin deposits occur on the farm Rooiboscbaak 107 KS, approximately 20 km northeast of Zebediela railway station (Horn and Strydom, 1998) and also on Weenen 40 KS. The Weenen deposit is exploited by Weenen Brickyard for brick making. Refractory plastic or fire clay occurrence has been reported from Cyferfoentein 457 KR south of Modimolle. 3.2.13. Molybdenum Molybdenum occurrence is reported on Groenvlei 224 KR, Hartbeestfoentein 62 KS, Appingendam 805 LR and Stravoren 676 KS. Molybdenum is also found associated with tin deposits (i.e. at Stravoren 676 KS). Appingendam mine exploited the Groenvlei deposit. The Groenvlei deposit has an estimated reserve of 1 300 t at an average grade of 3 % MoS2 (Wilson and Cole, 1998). There is currently no molybdenum production in the country. 3.2.14. Phosphate Phosphate has been exploited from Glenover 371 LQ, Houndslow 372 LQ and St. Agnesfontein 347 LQ between 1958 to 1983 by Glenover Phosphate Ltd (Wilson, 1998). In the Upper Zone of the Bushveld Complex occurrence of apatite with P2O5 content in the magnetite averaging between 5 and 8% is reported on Deugdzaamheid 197 LR, Turflaagte 214 LR, Grootwater 436 LR and Klippan 437 LR (Wilson, 1998). A resource of 25 Mt has been established to a vertical depth of 100 m on the farm Turflaagte (Grobler and Whitefield, 1969). 28 3.2.15. Cobalt Cobalt is produced as a by-product from platinum group metals mining in the Merensky Reef, Platreef and the UG 2 Chromitite. This zone carries about 1.5 % cobalt (Hammerbeck and Schürmann, 1998). However these bodies have limited lateral and vertical extent and are of no economic importance (Hammerbeck and Schürmann, 1998). 3.2.16. Copper In the Bushveld Complex copper occurs associated with both the acid and mafic rocks. Copper produced in the Waterberg comes from the Bushveld Complex as a by-product from the Merensky Reef and the Platreef and also associated with the Transvaal Supergoup rocks. Copper occurrences are reported close to the mutual border of Planknek 43 KS and Weenen 40 KS about 10 km east of Mokopane (Wilson, 1998). These occur in the form of malachite, bornite and chalcopyrite associated with galena in the quartz veins within dolomite. Other occurrences are reported on the farms Mauritius 183 MR, Theuniskloof 164 MR, Smirna 188 MR, Klipvley 174 MR, Mietjesfontein 220 MR, Karrieboschdrift 163 MR, Rosendale 221 MR, Slangkop 162 MR, Davidslust 240 MR, Cambridge 242 MR, Dassenburg 75 MR, Bottlellang 115 MR, Zeekoevlei 11LR, Reward 435 LR, Glenover 371 LQ and Lngwater 62 KR. On the farm Stavoren 676 KS copper is found associated with tin mineralisation (Wilson, 1998). Disseminated copper sulphides occurrence is reported from the farm Nederland 51 KS 20 km southeast of Mokopane. 3.2.17. Gold Gold is produced as a by-product from platinum mines exploiting the UG 2, Merensky Reef and the Platreef in the Bushveld Complex. In the Transvaal Supergroup gold mineralisation is found associated with the basal conglomerate of the Black reef quartzite formation in the Kaapsehoop area at the base of the Transvaal Supergroup (Ward and Wilson, 1998). Mining for these deposits was not successful because of the limited extends of the conglomerate and erratic distribution of gold. 3.2.18. Nickel In the Waterberg district, nickel is produced as a by-product of PGM processing from the Platreef and the Merensky Reef. Hydrothermal nickel occurrence is reported from Blaauwbank 515 KQ about 6 km to the east of the main workings of the disfuntional Rooiberg Tin mines (Hammerbeck and Schürmann, 1998). 3.2.19. Lead About 1 500 t of galena has been mined from the deposit on Leeubosch 129 KQ, 16 km north of Thabazimbi in the Malmani dolomites (du Toit, 1998). It occurs along bedding planes in early intergranular spaces in the dolomite of the Lyttelton Formation, in vertical siderite veins, as well as in pod-like bodies of siderite with galena deposited in karst cavities. Occurrences of lead mineralization have been reported from the farms Turflaagte 214 LR, Deugdzaamheid 197 LR, Waterval 443 KQ, Planknek 43 KS and Nooitgedacht 92 KR. Galena also occur as an accessory mineral associated with the tin mineralisation (i.e. on the farm Groenvley 224 KR and Stavoren 676 KS) hosted in the Bobbejaankop granite of the Bushveld Complex. 29 3.2.20. Tantalum and niobium Cassiterite from tin deposits related to the Bushveld Complex contains an average of less than 0.5 % tantalum and niobium (Ollia, 1986). 3.2.21. Tungsten Scheelite is the major ore bearing body of tungsten in the Waterberg district. Its occurrence is reported on the farms Zaaiplaats 223 KR and the Roodepoort 222 KR (Bowles and Hammerbeck, 1998). 3.2.22. Vanadium Vanadium deposits are found on the farms Gezond 235 KR, Commandodrift 238 KR, Molendraai 811 LR, Nooitgedacht 11 JQ, Rooipoort 46 KS, Macalacaskop 243 KS, Jaagbaan 291 KR and Mozambique 807 LR. Occurrences are also recorded on the farms Eulalie 186 LR, Deugdzaamheid 197 LR and Klippan 437 LR. These deposits and occurrences generally occur in the titaniferous magnetite seams in the upper portion of the Rustenburg Layered Suite of the Bushveld Complex Vanadium is found mainly associated with iron and titanium. 3.2.23. Manganese In the Waterberg district occurrences of manganese are reported on the farms Frischgewaagd 445 KR, De Nyl Zyn Oog 423 KR, Tweefontein 463 KR and Cyferfontein 457 KR (Hammerbeck, 1976). These deposits are either small or poor quality that even small-scale mining is uneconomic. At the Thabazimbi iron mine manganese ore assaying up to 57 % Mn occurs (Astrup and Tsikos, 1998). According to Astrup and Tsikos (1998) the ore is of good quality, but mining presents serious difficulties because of the treacherous nature of the ground. 3.3 Current Mining Operations 3.3.1 Platinum There are currently four operating platinum mines in the Waterberg district which include the Union and Amandebult sections of the Rustenburg Platinum mine, Potgietersrus Platinum and Northam Platinum mine. The production figures for these mines are shown in the table below. The Union Section, Amandebult Section and Northam Mine exploit the Merensky Reef and the UG 2 Chromitite while Potgietersrus Platinum is currently the only mine exploiting the Platreef. Potgietersrus Platinum is currently operating two open pits: the Sandsloot and the Zwartfontein south pits with plans to start production from the third (Overysel/ Zwartfontein north) in early 2006. 30 Table 3.3.1 Production Figures for Platinum Mines in WDM Amandelbult Section# Refined Production Platinum Palladium Rhodium Gold PGMs Nickel Copper 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 oz oz oz oz oz tons tons 2003 2002 2001 2000 605,6 272,0 64,8 19,8 1 048 4,0 2,3 634,6 277,1 66,1 24,0 1 102 3,9 2,3 711,0 314,7 71,9 23,6 1 229 4,2 2,1 679,3 299,4 73,0 23,0 1 172 4,2 2,3 570,8 261,1 57,2 22,1 982 4,1 2,3 2003 2002 2001 2000 313,2 132,6 43,6 5,8 572,0 1,1 0,5 284,7 125,8 40,2 5,2 514,7 1,0 0,4 280,4 122,2 42,3 4,8 505,2 1,1 0,5 288,8 137,7 42,1 5,3 528,5 1,4 0,7 2002 2001 2000 165,3 159,0 12,1 17,1 349,4 3,4 1,9 211,1 219,8 16,4 21,2 462,9 4,2 2,2 194,1 203,7 13,9 19,6 424,0 4,4 2,3 2004 Union Section# Refined production Platinum Palladium Rhodium Gold PGMs Nickel Copper 2004 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 oz oz oz oz oz tons tons 319,6 139,8 47,6 5,4 581,6 1,1 0,5 Potgietersrus Platinum# Refined Production Platinum Palladium Rhodium Gold PGMs Nickel Copper 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 2004 2003 oz oz oz oz oz tons tons Northam Platinum* Refined production Platinum 000 oz Palladium 000 oz Rhodium 000 oz Gold 000 oz Total (3 PGE +Au) 000 oz Copper 000 tons Nickel (tonnes) 000 tons 196,0 209,2 13,1 21,7 431,9 5,1 2,9 2005 202.459 98.255 17.619 6.881 325.214 0.953 1.677 188,9 196,9 12,5 21,4 411,0 5,7 3,2 2004 212.006 102.884 18.423 7.234 34.0547 1.015 1.816 # Data from Anglo Platinum website *Data from Northam Platinum website 31 The largest producer of refined platinum in Waterberg district municipality is the Amandelbult mine, followed by Union Section, Northam and Potgietersrus Platinum respectively. Union Section is located just across the boundary from Amandelbult (Thabazimbi) and is situated in Northwest Province. At Amendelbult Section there was an increase in the refined platinum ounces produced in 2000 to 2002. In 2003 to 2004 there was a decrease in the production of refined platinum from 634600 oz to 605600 oz. Northam mine also recorded a decrease in the production of refined platinum from 212006 oz in 2004 to 202459 oz in 2005. This mine produces approximately 340 000 oz of platinum, palladium, rhodium and gold (3 PGE + Au) from the Merensky Reef and the UG 2 Chromitite. Within the Northam lease area reserves are measured at 12.7 M oz with resource base of 17.4 M oz. Potgietersrus Platinum is the only operating mine in the northern limb exploiting the Platreef. It produces about 200 100 ounces of refined platinum from two pits (Sandsloot and Zwartfontein south pit). In 2003, the global supplies of platinum, palladium and rhodium rose by 16.7 % to 419.2 t and the demand grew by 4.3 % to 385.9 t (SAIM, 2003/2004). The supply of platinum group metals is expected to increase due to expansion of the existing operations in the northern and western limbs of the Bushveld Complex. 3.3.2 Coal Coal is exploited from the Waterberg coalfields at Grootegeluk Coal Mine (Kumba Resources) on the farm Enkelbult 462 LQ, a subsidiary of Kumba Resources. This colliery was developed in mid 1970s. Production figures are presented in the table below, reflecting a steady increase. In the year 2004, the Grootegeluk Colliery produced 17.4 million tonnes of coal and had 2827 employees at the end of 2005. Table 3.3.2: Coal Production (‘000 tons) from Grootegeluk Colliery Coal Type 2004 2003 2002 2001 Thermal Coal 14,356 14,097 13,198 11,934 Coking Coal 1,972 1,781 1,670 1,536 Other Coal 1,403 1,323 1,194 1,258 Total 17,731 17,201 16,062 14,728 Source: Kumba Resources 2004 Annual Report). 2000 12,072 1,312 1,152 14,536 3.3.3 Iron Ore The Thabazimbi Iron Ore Mine produces about 2.5 Mt of iron per annum. In 2004 the mine had sufficient ore to continue operating until 2012. Astrup et al. (1998) reported total in situ reserves of high-grade hematite ore of 87.5 Mt with an additional 19 Mt of calcic ore. Measured reserve estimates for 2004 are 12,4 million tons proven and 8, 6 millions probable. Measured resource estimates for the same year are 32,43 million tons being indicated resources and 16, 9 million tons inferred resources. The Thabazimbi iron mine also plays a significant role in terms of employment in the district. In 2004 the mine had 950 employees. 32 3.3.4 Other Mines in WDM The Oaks Diamond Mine has a total workforce of about 152 people including contractors. In 2003, production was 100 123 carats from treating 312 kt of ore at 32.1 carats/100 tons. On Grootfontein 352 KQ andalusite mining began in 1977 by Weedon`s Minerals (Pty) Ltd (Oosterhuis, 1998). Anglovaal Ltd acquired this company in 1991 and the name was changed to Rhino Andalusite mines. It is the largest andalusite producer in South Africa. Andalusite Resources (Pty) Ltd a subsidiary of African Mineral, Trading and Exploration (Pty) Ltd produces andalusite from its operations at Maroelesfontein 366 KQ. Rough granite is produced from the Bushveld Complex by Africa Red Granite Quarries, Red Stone Mining and Bestaf Granite (Pty) Ltd and Marlin Granite (Pty) Ltd. Bushveld Granite is exploited on the farm Klipplaatdrift 787 LR and Leyden 804 LR by Lebowa Granite (Pty)/Bestaf Granite (Pty) Ltd. This sector employs more than 150 people. Limestone is currently exploited on the farms Calais 563 KS, Malgas 154 KS, Singapore 585 KS and Syferfontein 608 KR by Leo Limestone, Inca mining and Syferfontein calcite (Pty) Ltd respectively. Currently, the Syferfontein deposit is exploited by Syferfontein calcite (Pty) Ltd. Syferfontein calcite (Pty) Ltd had 38 employees in July 2005. Zwartkop is the only mine currently exploiting chrome in the Waterberg district municipality on the farm Zwartkop 369 KQ. 3.4 Mining in the District Economy Estimates of the contribution from mining to the Gross Geographic Product (GGP) of Waterberg District are outdated. These estimates were compiled in 2001 and concluded that the size of the Waterberg district economy was R9.6 billion in 2000. The GGP of Limpopo was estimated to be R36 billion and Waterberg was the biggest district economy in the Province. Mining was the biggest sector in Waterberg, contributing R4 billion to the district economy. The reason why these estimates can no longer be used is because Statistics South Africa has re-based the national and provincial production figures. GGP for Limpopo was R93.2 billion at 2004 prices and R59 billion for 2000, but the breakdown within districts is not available. However, the GGP co-efficient for the mining sector in Limpopo is known from the Limpopo input-output model to be 0.34. The GGP from mining can therefore be estimated if the sales figures for the various commodities can be obtained. This is quantified in the table below. 33 Table 3.4.1: Estimated Value of Mineral Commodity Sales from WDM R’m Commodity 2004 2003 2002 2001 Platinum Group 8,193 7,437 9,408 9,084 Coal 1,500 1,400 1,300 1,200 Iron Ore 500 450 450 450 Diamonds 85 100 100 100 Other 95 90 85 80 Total 10,370 9,480 11,340 10,910 Source: Annual Reports (Kumba values are estimated from consolidated figures in their annual report. Other, mostly granite and lime, is estimated) On the basis of these estimates, the contribution from the mining sector to GGP in Waterberg District is approximately R3.5 billion. Another way of estimating economic impact is to consider capital investment patterns by mining companies. Table 3.4.2: Actual Capital Expenditure at Mines in WDM R’m Mine Ongoing 2004 Expansion 04 Ongoing 2003 Amandelbult 314 0 435 PPRust 186 0 339 Northam 118 172 Grootegeluk 205 125 Total 823 1071 Source: Annual Reports Expansion 03 0 0 Although there is considerable exploration underway, actual capital expenditure appears to be declining, which provides no confidence that production will be expanded considerably in the short to medium term. Thirdly, employment in the mining industry is an important indicator of economic impact. It is evident from the table below that mining employment has increased considerably in Mogalakwena Municipality and to some extent in Lephalale between 1996 and 2001. However, total employment in the mining sector for Waterberg District has actually declined, with the largest loss in Thabazimbi Municipality. Table 3.4.3: Employment in the Mining Sector in WDM Municipality 2001 1996 NP361: Thabazimbi 9619 12824 NP362: Lephalale 1828 1459 NP364: Mookgopong 89 14 NP365: Modimolle 86 48 NP366: Bela-Bela 51 15 NP367: Mogalakwena 1650 497 Total 13323 14857 Source: Stats SA Census 2001 and 1996 The labour force in WDM was 140,235 persons in 2001, which means that 9.5% of the labour force is employed in the mining sector. The Thabazimbi Municipality will 34 be very sensitive to further losses, because 37% of its labour force is employed in the mining sector. A list of employment per mine is currently being obtained from the Inspector of Mines. 3.5 Opportunities for Expansion 3.5.1 Platinum group metals The increase in the platinum group metals prices in recent years has put much pressure on mining and exploration companies to increase their production and consequently, to expand the lifespan of the mines. This in itself has resulted in renewed search for new deposits and an expansion of ore reserves. The Bushveld Complex, in particular the northern limb has in the recent years become a major exploration target for the PGE and other elements such as nickel and copper. Companies exploring the Platreef include Platinum Group Metals (Pty) Ltd, Platreef Resources (Pty) Ltd, Anglo Platinum, Eersteling Gold Mining Company, Anooraq Resources, AfriOre, Pan Palladium and AIM Resources. The Waterberg District has the potential to become the major producer of platinum group metals in the world. Export earnings are forecast to increase from 3 378 million US dollars in 2003 to 5 127 million US dollars in 2008 (SAIM, 2003/2004). The planned expansions and opening of new platinum mines (particularly in the Mokopane area) will led to an increase in gold, copper, nickel and cobalt production in the Waterberg District. 3.5.2 Coal The Waterberg Coalfield appears to be the replacement for the Mpumalanga coalfields. However, the Waterberg Coalfield is located away from major markets. In trying to solve the transportation problem a combined task team was established to consider at a new railway line linking the Waterberg area to Middleburg, which would allow Grootegeluk to rail coal over a much shorter route. Kumba Resources estimates that coal output from the Waterberg coalfields could double to about 40 Mt/year as part of the investment in additional power generation. Availability of good infrastructure in the district will enhance the potential for the Waterberg to become a significant mining and industrial center in South Africa. This coalfield is also a promising area for coal bed methane extraction. 3.5.3 Iron ore Thabazimbi Iron Mine is approaching depletion and closure could occur in 2012. However, hematite with less than 56 % iron is considered as waste. This waste may be processed for its iron content in the future depending on the demand, price and availability of iron deposits in the country. Vast reserves of vanadium bearing, titano-magnetite occur in the Upper Zone of the Bushveld Complex. 3.5.4. Dimension stone A large variety of rocks with a potential to be used as dimension stone occur in the Waterberg district municipality. Lack of good road and rail infrastructure are major limiting factors in the development of the dimension stone industry in the district. 35 Processing of the material should also be done in the vicinity of quarrying in order to reduce transportation costs, thereby increasing income from such operations. Waste produced from these operations can be used as aggregate for construction. 3.5.5 Chrome Chrome was extracted from the Bushveld Complex rocks south of Mokopane on the farm Grasvalley. Depending on the price, demand and supply for chrome, the Grasvally deposit represents a potential resource for exploitation. 3.5.6 Tin and fluorite A number of tin and fluorite mines were operating in the Waterberg district municipality. However, due to low prices for tin and fluorite the mines have closed. The increase in the demand for tin and fluorite can lead to reopening of some of these mines. 3.6 Business-as-Usual Scenario for Mining in WDM At this early stage of analysis, it is evident that platinum, coal and iron ore are the three most important mineral commodities in WDM. Platinum extraction from the Platreef has caused mining to become an important economic sector in Mogalakwena Municipality. Production is increasing for all three these commodities, although employment has declined, particularly in Thabazimbi. There are considerable market and private sector pressures to increase capital investment in all three commodities even further. These pressures are being contained by limitations in terms of water availability, transport costs and skills. In the business as usual scenario it is assumed that economic infrastructure will not be expanded significantly over the next decade and the skills shortage will remain. It is also assumed that no particular effort will be made to promote new project developments, such as expansions to Matimba Power Station or extraction of iron and vanadium from the large deposits of vanadiferous magnetite that occurs in the district. Coal bed methane gas will remain untapped under this assumption. Under this scenario some mining developments are likely to occur, such as a new opencast mine for Anglo Platinum in the Mogalakwena Municipality. However, this mine is intended to replace the existing mine that is expected to reach the end of its useful life in 2015. Limited coal mining expansions could also occur, most probably in association with adjacent opencast mining developments in Botswana. Thabazimbi Iron Mine is expected to be depleted by 2012. Despite these developments, employment is unlikely to increase substantially and could even decline in areas like Thabazimbi. The business as usual scenario therefore holds some benefits for Mogalakwena and Lephalale municipalities, but is particularly negative for Thabazimbi Municipality. The status quo in terms of the relative insignificance of the mining sector for Modimolle and Mookgopong Municipalities is likely to remain. 36 This scenario suggests that mining will remain a significant sector in the Waterberg District economy, but that its vast potential will not be fully realised. The contribution from this sector to poverty reduction will therefore also be limited. A business as usual scenario should be avoided in order to promote the development objectives of WDM. Accelerated development will require a concerted intervention, which is the topic of subsequent phases of this mining development strategy formulation process. 37 4. CONCLUSION ON PHASE ONE AND TWO The purpose of this strategy formulation process is to provide WDM with a policy instrument by which leadership and strategic direction can be given to the mining industry for: Increased competitiveness on a sustainable basis, Increased investment as a basis for job creation and economic growth, Improvements in the quality of life of the district population, including priorities such as BEE, as well as reductions in HIV/AIDS and poverty, Regional integration. This mining development strategy is part of a broader intervention that is aimed at accelerated economic development in Waterberg District. The mining development strategy will be compiled in the following five distinct phases: Policy Assessment Current Situation Assessment Scenario Analysis Project Development Opportunities, and Implementation Plan. The policy and current situation assessments are presented in this report as a discussion document. It will be formalised once comments from stakeholders have been received. In terms of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Act, WDM has no direct jurisdiction in terms of mining, but it may facilitate the development process. It is therefore imperative that a good working relationship should be established between WDM and the DME Regional Manager in Limpopo. The municipality is also obliged to facilitate the economic and mining development processes by building networks and promoting good working relationships between various institutions in the sector, such as private companies, parastatal development organizations and public infrastructure agencies. An interface with national strategies such as the small scale mining initiative, integrated manufacturing strategy, as well as the national research and development strategy, should be created. WDM has an important role to play in promoting the stake of historically disadvantaged companies that are based in Waterberg District within the targets of the mining charter. The relevant provincial growth and development strategy is to adopt the development cluster value-chain approach, as a vehicle to raise the international competitiveness and investment rating of the Province, to combine public and private sector contributions to development and to align the interventions of various public development institutions for greater impact. Two of the seven competitive clusters for Limpopo that were identified and approved in the Provincial Growth and Development Strategy fall within the mining sector of Waterberg District. These are the platinum and coal mining clusters with their associated value chains. 38 The Marketing and Investment Strategy for WDM also recommends the cluster value chain approach as the appropriate instrument for development planning purposes and the establishment of a District Investment Council with an operations manager is proposed to drive the implementation process. LED project proposals include a programme to facilitate SMME participation in the mining industry, raising the wall of the Mogol dam, upgrading the road from Modimolle to Lephalale, skills development and the establishment of sectoral working groups. South Australia is considered to be a useful example of international practice in terms of development planning in the mining sector and its results will be assessed for the purpose of comparison. The rocks covering the Waterberg district area are well endowed with a significant number of economically important minerals that include the platinum group metals, iron, coal, andalusite, tin and fluoride. Some of these minerals are currently exploited for their economic value while exploration is on-going in order to expand the lifespan of the existing mines and also to identify and develop new deposits. Sales value of mining production from WDM has increased beyond R10 billion, which implies a contribution to GGP of approximately R3.5 billion. However, capital investment and employment in mining appears to be decreasing. A business as usual scenario suggests that mining will remain a significant sector in the Waterberg District economy, but that its vast potential will not be fully realised. The contribution from this sector to poverty reduction will therefore also be limited. This scenario should be avoided in order to promote the development objectives of WDM. Accelerated development will require a concerted intervention, which is the topic of subsequent phases of this mining development strategy formulation process. Report Two will deal with the results of the scenario analysis. It will include a SWOT analysis for mining development and a proposed strategy to reach the highroad scenario. This report is scheduled for release as a discussion document at the end of February 2006. Report Three will cover project development opportunities as well as the implementation plan and this will be released as a discussion document at the end of March. All three reports will be consolidated into a final strategy document once stakeholder comments have been received. 39 ANNEXURE ONE ANNEXURE TWO BATEMAN PROJECT HOLDINGS PREFEASIBILITY STUDY: NOVEMBER 1991 ‘The upper ecca coal at Kumba’s Grootegeluk mine has been demonstrated to be The most liquefiable coal known in the world’ Increased mining And beneficiation From Grootegeluk R2.4 bn capital investment 1mta chemical Plus 100 000 Grade low ash Tons of coal hydrogen Increased supply to Iscor and Eskom to maintain production ratios. Multiproduct mine, including use of waste dump Fuel Aromatics Anglocoal CBM? Downstream Plastics Industry 41 Annexure Three: Limpopo Value-chain Analysis for Platinum Group Metals Capital to perform surveys Capital to purchase licenses EXPLORATION Geological survey information Analytical & geology skills CAPITAL EQUIPMENT FINANCE MINE PLANNING PROJECT PROCESS ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT NEW SHAFT SET UP CONSTRUCTION (Some Local Jobs Only) CONSUMABLES (Few produced in Limpopo) ENERGY LABOUR Up-Stream CAPITAL EQUIPMENT (Mills, flotation cells, Ion exchange etc) CHEMICALS (Flotation Reagents etc) ENERGY MINING SERVICES (Some Local Jobs Only) Undertaken by Limpopo resource/firms/people Undertaken by non Limpopo resources/firms/people SMELTING REFINING PROCESS ENGINEERING & DEVELOPMENT SKILLS (OUTSOURCED) FACTORY & MANAGEMENT JOBS BEE through Procurement Opportunities 42 ANNEXURE FOUR