Chapter 6 Behavior & Student Discipline The purpose of this chapter is to provide guidance and supports for teachers and administrators when working to support student behavior of students with special needs, parameters and guidance with student discipline. Functional Behavioral Assessments "Functional behavioral assessment" or "FBA" means a process for gathering information to maximize the efficiency of behavioral supports. The majority of student behavior is purposeful, and the behavior (appropriate and inappropriate) relates to the context(s) in which it occurs. Past-to-present events influence behavior. FBA’s provide a predictive function to improve the understanding of the causes of behavior, to facilitate hypothesis-driven interventions, to assist with skill building rather than punishment and increase chance of positive student outcomes. When a Functional Behavioral Evaluation is Required? A Functional Behavioral Assessment is required when: a student is evaluated for an emotional and behavioral disorders disability (Minnesota Rule 3525.1329). an IEP team makes a determination that conditional procedures should be in a student’s comprehensive behavior intervention plan (Minnesota Rule 3525.2710 Subp. 4F). an IEP team wants to consider strategies, positive behavioral interventions, and supports to address a student behavior that impedes his or her learning or that of others. a pattern of removal has the effect of a change in placement for a student. an IEP team is considering a more restrictive placement due to behavioral concerns. emergency conditional procedures are used twice in a 30 calendar day period, or when the IEP team determines it’s needed. 6-1 8/26/08 The data that is gathered through a Functional Behavior Assessment forms the basis to develop Behavior Intervention Plans (BIP). FBA Reporting Components The FBA can be part of an initial or reevaluation or it can completed as a stand alone report. The following components of the FBA must be addressed in the via a supplemental evaluation report or via an initial or reevaluation evaluation report: Description of problem behaviors: Challenging behaviors defined in observable and measurable terms (i.e., one can see and count the behavior) When the behavior is most likely to occur: Identification of events, times, and situations that predict the occurrence of the behavior When the behavior is least likely to occur: Identification of events, times, and situations that predict the nonoccurrence of the behavior Identifies the Antecedents, Consequences, and Reinforcers that maintain the behavior Hypothesis statement: Possible functions of the behavior Replacement behaviors: Possible positive alternative behaviors Assessment tools: Includes a variety of data collection methods and sources that facilitate the development of hypotheses and summary statements regarding behavioral patterns. FBA Data Collection Tools The purpose of data collection is to objectively support (or deny) a relation between a students behavior and environmental events. It provides preintervention information that is useful for determining the significance of the problem behavior and the effects of environmental, curricular, and replacement behavior manipulations. It also provides a baseline for hypotheses statements that will guide behavior support plan development. 6-2 8/26/08 The following data collection tools and activities are commonly used when conducting an FBA. It is required to list these tools and activities on the Notice of Evaluation. Parent and staff interviews can be conducted individually or through team process Student interview Frustration and stress survey Direct Observations of Student File Review: Carefully review information for patterns and necessary information District FBA Expectations A team approach is important when completing the evaluation process of behavior. It is not the role of the school psychologist to conduct the entire FBA. A lead is needed to coordinate assessment and gather information. Data collection requires communication and collaboration among team members -who collects what information can vary. FBA Timelines A parent’s written consent must be obtained before a district proceeds with a FBA. The district may proceed if it can demonstrate and document that it has taken reasonable measures to obtain parent consent and the parent has not responded after 14 calendar days. Reasonable measures to obtain parent consent means more than one attempt. The FBA evaluation report must be written within 30 school days after receiving parent/guardian signature. The date of the evaluation report signifies completion of the evaluation. 6-3 8/26/08 FBA Requirements Related to Suspensions/Removals Student removed for 1 school day or less (but not suspended) Student suspended for less than 5 consecutive school days Student suspended for 5 to 10 consecutive school days Student removed for 10 cumulative school days in a school year or less Student removed for 11 cumulative school days in a school year or more Student placed on in-school suspension Parent requests a manifestation determination following any removal for disciplinary reasons Student suspended from the bus IEP Team Meeting Required No* Manifestation Determination Required No* Functional Behavioral Assessment Plan Required No* No* No* No* Yes Yes No* No No No Yes Yes Yes No** No** No** Yes Yes No* Depends*** Depends*** Depends*** Behavior Intervention Plans For a child whose behavior(s) impedes his or her learning or that of others, the IEP team shall consider strategies, positive behavioral interventions, and supports that address the behavior. Consideration of a behavior intervention plan should only be developed once a Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA) has been conducted. The objective of any behavioral intervention must be the following: pupils acquire appropriate behaviors and skills skill acquisition focus rather than merely behavior reduction or elimination designed to allow a student to benefit from an appropriate, individualized educational program Any student with a disability can have a Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP). A BIP should be in place if conditional procedures are used. Once in place, they must be reviewed with entire school team that works with the student. When in place, team members should be aware that most behavior does not improve immediately. A minimum of six weeks is needed before target 6-4 8/26/08 behaviors decrease. Target behaviors usually escalate during the initial six week intervention. BIP Process The IEP process must be used when developing a BIP and the district must have permission to implement it. The district has developed a BIP form to be attached to the IEP and documented in the IEP adaptation section. A BIP can be withdrawn anytime by the parent. Components of a BIP There are seven components to a BIP. Target Behaviors: Target behaviors identified should align with the target behaviors on the FBA. Target behaviors must be observable and measurable and can be aligned with behavioral goals and objectives on the IEP. Replacement Behaviors: Replacement behaviors are positive and observable and replace the undesired behavior Proactive Strategies: Describes the strategies, methods or programming implemented to teach the replacement behaviors Crisis Plan: Outlines the steps the school team will follow in a crisis situation. It can include the use of manual restraints and locked time out rooms which are not prohibited. Risks: Coordination activities with family: Process for Review: Personnel Responsible for Implementation: Prohibited Behavioral Procedures The following procedures may not be used under any circumstance Corporal punishment Assuming a specified position Use of light and sounds, noxious smells, sprays as an adverse stimulus 6-5 8/26/08 Denying or restricting access to equipment such as hearing aids, communication boards Faradic shock Restriction of auditory or visual sense Withholding water or meals, access to toilets Conditional Procedures & Emergency Procedures Conditional procedures may be used in emergency situations or as outlined in the BIP. If they are used in an emergency situation, they must be used to protect one pupil from another person from physical injury or emotional abuse due to verbal/nonverbal threats or to prevent property damage. If they are used twice in a 30 day period, an IEP team meeting must be held to determine if FBA and/or services are adequate. If they are outlined in the BIP, then the team can used them as outlined in the BIP. Conditional Procedures Are: Manual restraint Manual or locked restraints intended to prevent injury Time out procedures for seclusion in a specially designed room Temporary delay of meals or water for no more than 15 minutes Use of Locked Time Out Rooms If a locked time out room is used, wording in the BIP must address: Criteria to return the student back to the desired activity When used, that staff will monitor student When used, student will have access to water and bathroom every 15 minutes When used, staff will document the number of student occurrences Time out rooms must be Tamper proof Have an observation window 6-6 8/26/08 Meet all fire and safety codes Have heat, cooling and proper ventilation Space size of 5’ by 6’ and large enough for the student to stand Discipline for Students with Disabilities When students with disabilities are disciplined for a violation of the Standards or Student Conduct, it is critical for building administrators and a student’s case manager work through this process together. While it is the administrator’s role to assess conduct violations and determine discipline for the violation, it is the case manager’s role to assure that appropriate due process procedures are being followed as outlined in this chapter. It is crucial to accurately track and document all suspensions and removals. Student removed for 1 school day or less (but not suspended) Student suspended for less than 5 consecutive school days Student suspended for 5 to 10 consecutive school days Student removed for 10 cumulative school days in a school year or less Student removed for 11 cumulative school days in a school year or more Student placed on in-school suspension Parent requests a manifestation determination following any removal for disciplinary reasons Student suspended from the bus IEP Team Meeting Required No* Manifestation Determination Required No* Functional Behavioral Assessment Plan Required No* No* No* No* Yes Yes No* No No No Yes Yes Yes No** No** No** Yes Yes No* Depends*** Depends*** Depends*** The “Ten Day” Clock Discipline for student with disabilities is different than for students not identified with a disability. Any student with a disability may be removed for up to 10 school days a year. When the removal reaches the tenth day, the due process 6-7 8/26/08 protections afforded to the student under FERPA and IDEIA 2004 may limit certain disciplinary actions. The ten-day “clock” is based on the school year, not on the placement of the student. The language of the federal regulations clearly refers to days of removal in a school year. Also, the ten-day “clock” is not based on school of attendance. The federal regulations do not have a provision to reset the ten days because a student moves to a different school or district. Portions of a school day that a student had been removed would be included in determining whether the student had been removed for more than 10 cumulative school days or subjected to a change of placement under 34 C.F.R § 300.519. In School Suspensions An in-school suspension would not be considered a part of the 10 days of removal addressed in paragraph (a) of C.F.R. § 300.520 as long as the student is afforded the opportunity to continue to appropriately progress in the general curriculum, continue to receive the services specified on his or her IEP, and continue to participate with non-disabled students to the extent they would have in their current placement. Suspensions or Removals for 5 or More Consecutive School Days and for More than 10 Cumulative School Days When a student is removed for 5 or more consecutive days or more than ten cumulative school days in a school year, three things must occur: 1. A manifestation determination must be made. 2. The school must provide the services deemed necessary by school personnel in consultation with the student’s special education teacher to enable the student to appropriately progress in the genera curriculum and advance toward achieving the goals set out in the student’s IEP. 3. If an FBA has not been completed, the IEP team must convene and develop an FBA plan. If an FBA has been completed, the IEP team must review the plan and modify it as necessary. 6-8 8/26/08 Suspensions from a Bus Suspension from the bus counts against the 10 cumulative days of removal if bus transportation is a part of the student’s IEP and the transportation is necessary for the student to obtain access to the location where all other services will be delivered. A bus suspension would be treated as a suspension under 34 C.F.R. § 300.520 unless the school provides the bus service in some other way. If the bus transportation is not a part of the student’s IEP, a bus suspension would typically not be a suspension under 34 C.F.R. § 300.520 and would therefore not be included in the 10 day count. Suspension Re entry Plan Meetings For any student with a disability, a suspension reentry meeting may occur after the student was suspended. Manifestation Meetings Related to Suspensions/Removals Within 10 school days of any decision to change the placement of a child with a disability because of a violation of a code of student conduct, the district, the parent, and relevant members of the student’s IEP team (as determined by the parents and the district) must review all relevant information in the student’s file, including the student’s IEP, teacher observations, and any relevant information provided by the parents, to determine: 1) If the conduct in question was caused by, or had a direct relationship to, the child’s disability, or 2) If the conduct in question was the direct result of the district’s failure to implement the IEP. This team meeting must occur if the student is removed for more than 5 consecutive or 10 cumulative school days and/or any time a removal constitutes a change in placement. The IEP team must also determine whether the IEP is appropriate and revise it. 6-9 8/26/08 Documentation of the Manifestation Meeting A manifestation meeting must occur within five days of the suspension. IEP team must follow steps 1- 4 provided on the Manifestation Determination Meeting form and document the team decision as to whether the behavior is or is not considered a manifestation of the student’s disability. If, as part of step 2, the IEP team determines the IEP is NOT appropriate, it must propose changes to the IEP and provide notice of the proposed changes to the parent. This may be done following the manifestation determination. If the IEP team determines the district failed to implement the IEP, the district must take immediate steps to remedy those deficiencies. If the IEP team determines the student’s behavior was a manifestation of the student’s disability, the IEP team must: 1) Conduct a FBA, unless the district had conducted a FBA before the behavior that resulted in the change of placement occurred, and implement a behavioral intervention plan, and modify it, as necessary, to address the behavior; and 2) Return the student to the placement from which he or she was removed, unless the parent and district agree to a change of placement as part of the modification of the behavioral intervention plan. 45 Day Unilateral Change in Placement The student need not be returned to his or her placement, even though the behavior was a manifestation of the student’s disability, if the child: carries a weapon to school or possesses a weapon at school, on school premises, or to or at a school function; knowingly possesses or uses illegal drugs, or sells or solicits the sale of a controlled substance, while at school, on school premises, or at a school function; or has inflicted serious bodily injury upon another person while at school, on school premises, or at a school function. “Serious bodily injury” is defined as bodily injury which involves: 6-10 8/26/08 a substantial risk of death; extreme physical pain; protracted and obvious disfigurement; or protracted loss or impairment of the function of a bodily member, organ or mental faculty. “Bodily injury” means: a cut, abrasion, bruise, burn, or disfigurement; physical pain; illness; impairment of the function of a bodily member, organ, or mental faculty; or any other injury to the body, no matter how temporary. In this scenario, the district would propose a program for the 45 day placement change. The student would be placed or remain on homebound services until an appropriate placement could be found. If the parents do not agree that the student’s behavior was a manifestation of his or her disability, they may request an expedited due process hearing to challenge that determination. The district and parents may also agree to attempt conciliation, mediation, or some other alternative to a hearing to resolve the dispute. Expulsions When considering an expulsion for a student with a disability, the IEP must first conduct a manifestation meeting. If the outcome was that the conduct was a manifestation of the student’s disability, the team may initiate a change in placement, but may not expel or suspend long term. Disciplinary Records If a separate disciplinary record/file is maintained by the administrator on students with disabilities for disciplinary actions, those records are considered part of the educational record and must follow the student. 6-11 8/26/08 Altered School Day This refers to altering the length of time that a student is at school as compared to other students in the same grade level. An altered school day is sometimes used for students with medical or mental health needs. Altered School Day is a team decision based on the students needs, it is not to be used as a means to discipline the child. Any days altered due to disciplinary reasons apply to suspension as outlined under the Pupil’s Fair Dismissal Act. 6-12 8/26/08