Bullying Fact sheet 6 - Prevention of Workplace Bullying Bullying can occur in any workplace, given certain circumstances. While an organisation might appear to be free from bullying, it still may be happening. Bullying can be difficult to detect. Incidents of bullying may not always be reported because employees might: Fear retribution or “payback” from the bully Believe that no one will act on the problem Fear being labelled “weak” or “whinging” Think that reporting will affect their career prospects Accept bullying as a normal part of work culture As bullying can occur wherever people work together, this fact sheet recommends that employers implement a range of prevention measures. Because any one measure by itself will not adequately reduce the risk of bullying, it is important that these measures are used in conjunction with each other. An employer may, in consultation with health and safety representatives, decide which measures are best to implement in their workplace. Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter The Labor Council of NSW has developed a Dignity and Respect in the Workplace charter to help prevent bullying at work. The charter is set out below. Draft Dignity & Respect in the Workplace Charter This organisation is committed to a workplace that provides dignity and respect to all its employees. Dignity and respect requires our workplace culture to consist of acceptable behaviours. Preamble Everyone in the workplace, irrespective of their position, deserves to be treated with dignity and respect. No one should suffer bullying or harassment while going about their work. This can put at risk the health, safety and wellbeing of all employees. This organisation has therefore adopted a policy of ‘zero tolerance’ to bullying or harassment at work. Definitions Dignity and respect requires an organisation to have and maintain a certain behavioural culture. Acceptable and unacceptable behaviour are defined below. What is unreasonable or inappropriate behaviour? Bullying Workplace bullying, or harassment, is repeated unreasonable behaviour directed toward an employee, or group of employees, that creates a risk to health and safety. Within this definition: “repeated” refers to the persistent nature of the behaviour, not the specific form the behaviour takes. Behaviour is considered ‘repeated’ if an established pattern can be identified. It may involve a series of diverse incidents – eg verbal abuse, deliberate damage to personal property etc “unreasonable behaviour” means behaviour that a reasonable person, having regard to all the circumstances, would expect to victimise, humiliate, undermine or threaten. “…having regard to all the circumstances” does not mean that this hypothetical person has total knowledge of every aspect of the situation. Rather this person knows as much as the alleged bully could reasonably be expected to know. “behaviour” includes actions of individuals or a group, and may involve using a system of work as a means of victimising, humiliating, undermining or threatening. “risk to health and safety” includes risk to the mental or physical health of the employee. Types of Bullying Behaviour The following types of behaviour, where repeated of occurring as part of a pattern of behaviour, could be considered bullying: Being overloaded with work, or not being given enough work to do; Being required to perform tasks without proper training or instruction, and which may place an employee at risk from injury; Unreasonable overtime, unfair rostering, allocation of work or being asked to perform non-work related tasks; Being excessively supervised or criticised; Subjected to constant ridicule and being put down in front of co-employees; Damage or interference with personal belongings, sabotage or undermining of work; Being the victim of loud and abusive, threatening or derogatory language usually when co-employees are present; Open or implied threat of the sack, or demotion or being pressured to resign; Creation of an oppressive and/or unhappy work environment to coerce or intimidate employees; Intimidation or threats to employees not to report or complain about conditions, unacceptable behaviours or health, safety and welfare; Leaving offensive messages on email or by telephone; Maliciously excluding and isolating a person from workplace activities, and promotional opportunities; Humiliating a person through gestures, or sarcastic, racist, or derogatory comments, often in front of clients, management or co- employees; Spreading gossip, false or malicious rumours about a person with intent to cause damage to a employee’s employment or reputation; Inequitable use of performance management. There are bound to be occasional differences of opinion, conflicts and problems in working relationships – these are part of working life. However, if workplace behaviour is repeated, unnecessary, deliberate and unprovoked, offensive, and is used to intimidate, humiliate, or threaten a employee, then workplace bullying exists and this will not be tolerated by our organisation. Single Incidents of Harassing Type Behaviour A single incident of harassing type behaviour may not consider to be bullying. Nevertheless, this will not be ignored or allowed. This organisation will intervene to ensure that these incidents do not escalate. This will help prevent future incidents occurring. Examples of acceptable behaviour Managerial Actions Legitimate managerial actions include: Performance management processes; Action taken to transfer, make redundant or terminate an employee in a fair and equitable manner; Justified decisions not to provide a promotion in connection with an employee’s employment; Disciplinary procedures for proven misconduct, and other behaviour or actions involving proven breaches of discipline; Managed business processes, such as workplace change or restructuring conducted in consultation with the employees and their representatives, which is required under the NSW Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 (‘the Act’). Management and Supervisory Responsibilities This organisation has a ‘duty of care’ under the Act in relation to the health safety and welfare of all our employees. This includes a commitment to the psychological wellbeing of every employee employed by this organisation. Employee participation is a key element in effective Health and Safety management systems. It promotes commitment to health and safety and develops a positive health and safety culture. This organisation committed to fostering an environment consistent with consultative processes. Employers have responsibilities under legislation, including the responsibility to provide a safe workplace. Key areas of legislation that provide for dignity and respect at work include: NSW Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 (‘the Act’) and NSW Occupational Health and Safety Regulation 2001 (‘the Regulation’) Clause 9 of the Regulation requires all employers in NSW, regardless of size, to identify workplace risks. Violence and psychological hazards are defined as workplace risks. This clearly identifies bullying, as a psychological hazard, to be a risk. The OHS Regulation requires employers to eliminate risks associated with bullying and the only way to eliminate these risks is to have policies and procedures that respect dignity in the workplace. These policies and procedures should effectively deal with the issue by clearly setting out processes for complaints and appeals, provision of training for managers and supervisors and promotion of awareness amongst employees. Employers, in order to meet their primary ‘duty of care’ obligations under the Act and the Regulation, have an obligation to conduct risk assessments to ensure risks from hazards, including bullying, are appropriately managed. This includes having processes to ensure respect and dignity exists in the workplace, as well as an anti-bullying policy and program. NSW IRA 1996 & Federal WRA 1997: both prohibit harassment on the grounds of trade union activity and both include unfair dismissal procedures. NSW Anti Discrimination Act 1977: prohibits workplace harassment on following grounds: Sex, pregnancy, race – colour – nationality – descent – ethnic or ethno religious background, marital status, disability (actual, past future or presumed), age transgender, sexual harassment, carer’s responsibilities. Federal HREOC Act 1986: prohibits workplace harassment on the following grounds: Political opinion, social origin, medical record, criminal record, trade union activity and religion. Federal RDA 1975: prohibits workplace harassment on the following grounds: Race, colour and nationality. Federal SDA 1984: prohibits workplace harassment on the following grounds: Sex, marital status and pregnancy. Federal DDA 1992: prohibits workplace harassment on the following grounds: Disability and impairment. Federal Age DA 2004: recently passed & probably prohibits workplace harassment on the grounds of age, but you need to check this. Employee Involvement Employees will be committed to: Reporting hazard, risk, or incident to the employer Participating in consultation during Risk Assessment Participating in training and awareness of the development of a dignity and respect in the workplace policy and procedures Adherence to a Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter Promoting a culture of respect and dignity for their fellow employees Five Steps To A Bully-Free Workplace This organisation is committed to the five steps to a workplace with dignity and respect: STEP 1 - Workplace Consultation Set up appropriate consultative mechanisms involving our employees and their representatives to develop this organisation’s Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter. Employees must be involved in the development of this code. It is important that the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter reflect the needs and nature of this organisation. A risk assessment will be conducted to ensure that this organisation is not ‘at risk’ by fostering a culture that encourages or tacitly condones harassment and bullying. STEP 2 - Workplace Awareness campaign All employees from senior management down will be made aware of the meaning and application of the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter, the meaning of zero tolerance, and be given the ability to identify workplace bullying or circumstances including How to recognise bullying The possible effects of bullying Where to get further information The organisation will do this through OH&S induction and other training, posters, stickers and flyers explaining the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter. STEP 3 – Training and Development The organisation will establish an effective training program for management and supervisors specifically tailored to the needs of our organisation and to meet the zero tolerance objectives. Management and supervisors will be trained in how to develop a workplace culture that encourages dignity and respect and is consistent with the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter, and the zero tolerance objectives. The training will include the skills necessary to manage the issue including skills in mediation and negotiation. In addition to the training supervisors, managers, OH&S representatives and staff will be provided with a Dignity and Respect toolkit to assist them in the ongoing risk management process. STEP 4 – Procedures To Deal With Complaints This organisation will establish a complaints mechanism that includes: A time frame for complaints - complaints investigated immediately. A process that includes a record of the problem (e.g. an incident report form) and any other relevant information about the allegation, which should be forwarded to a designated responsible person and acted upon immediately. A trained, designated and impartial mediator who has authority to act to resolve the problem to ensure a fair and equitable outcome. In some instances it may be appropriate for the mediator to be sourced from outside of this organisation. Support for parties involved; including counselling, formal apologies and any other appropriate action. Ultimately prevention through an effective Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter, and zero tolerance for bullying is the best way to ensure a productive and harmonious workplace. STEP 5 - Consultation and feedback A 6 monthly review of the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter and grievance procedures and mechanisms ensure that the policy remains effective and relevant. The review will involve consultation between senior management, relevant unions, OH&S Representatives and employees on the performance of the organisation on how it has met the objectives of the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter in the previous 6-month period. The review will identify, any relevant matter, strategy or performance targets for inclusion in the Dignity and Respect in the Workplace Charter for the next 6 months. This organisation is committed to the wellbeing of our entire workforce and has agreed to meet the objectives outlined in this Charter SIGNATURES EMPLOYEE ELECTED UNION REPRESENTATIVES EMPLOYER REPRESENTATIVES OH&S COMMITTEE/REPRESENTATIVES OH&S COMMITTEE/REPRESENTATIVES Consultation An employer has a duty to consult with his or her employees’ elected health and safety representatives about health and safety matters. This can be done through whatever consultative mechanisms are decided upon as appropriate in the workplace. There are broadly three forms of workplace consultative arrangements for occupational health and safety in NSW: Individual safety representatives directly represented in the work-group Occupational Health and Safety Committees with representatives from various workgroups Other agreed arrangements. The acceptable forms of occupational health and safety consultative structures are set out in Chapter 3 of the OHS Regulation2001. It is good business practice to consult directly with employees on health and safety matters that affect them. Consultation allows managers and supervisors to hear directly from employees about how safety policies affect the workplace and how they can be best implemented. Consultation will help an employer to: Establish whether bullying is a problem in the workplace Determine the best way of communicating the prevention message Successfully implement prevention measures There are a number of other ways in which an employer can consult in the workplace, including direct discussion, staff meetings, toolbox meetings, health and safety committee meetings, and special working groups. When developing prevention methods, consultation should take place as early as possible. Enough time should be allowed for health and safety representatives to discuss bullying issues with employees in their designated work group and with the employer. When consulting, an employer should consider the needs of any employees from non-English speaking backgrounds. What to consult about Consultation should occur regarding the development of: Strategies for raising awareness, including appropriate training of staff including managers and supervisors A Code of Conduct Policy for the workplace Procedures for reporting incidents Procedures for investigating incidents Bullying resolution procedures Consultation should also occur when identifying bullying risk factors and developing measures to address risk factors. In most of the situations above, it will be practicable for an employer to consult with health and safety representatives. Refer to check list Create Awareness As a first step in creating a workplace free of bullying, employers should promote awareness of the issue among employees, including managers and supervisors. By raising awareness, employers will be in a better position to identify workplace bullying, or circumstances in which bullying could occur. In workplaces with preventative measures in place and no record of workplace bullying, awareness raising reinforces management commitment to a bullying-free working environment. In workplaces considering steps to manage the issue of bullying for the first time, awareness raising should make clear to everyone that bullying is unacceptable and that incidents of such behaviour should be reported. Awareness-raising information should communicate: How to recognise bullying The possible effects of bullying Where to get further information Channels of communication may include formal, training sessions, staff bulletins, intranet, staff meetings and informal discussion groups. In particular, information should be provided when: Recruiting employees (including appointing or promoting managers and supervisors) Running induction training Engaging contractors or supplying services to others Involving health and safety representatives and employees in the development of in-house policies can also play an important role in raising awareness.