How to use leveled readers to improve Chinese reading proficiency for upper elementary Chinese Immersion students Yuqi Zhao Northern Trails 5/6 School Forest Hills Public Schools December 2014 Section 1: Research Questions I teach in 5th grade Chinese Immersion Program in a local elementary school of Grand Rapids, Michigan. We are a 5th and 6th-grade school and each grade has over 250 students. We are running two kinds of Immersion Program: Chinese Immersion and Spanish Immersion. Before students enter the 5th grade Chinese Immersion class, they have already had over 5-year experience of learning Chinese. They learned math and science through Chinese since they were in the kindergarten. However, the story in the 5th grade is different; we do not use Chinese to teach math and science any more, we focus only on Chinese literacy. Teaching Chinese reading and writing are the most important components in our daily teaching and learning practice. This school year is my second year teaching in the program. Last year I taught the pioneer group, they are the very first cohort to enroll in the program. Based on my observation, I found that, the general reading proficiency of the students in our Chinese Immersion program is really low. That is to say their Chinese reading skills cannot support them reading the books that fit their current intelligence development and interests. The books they can read and understand are too childish for their age group. When reflecting on this phenomenon, I’m thinking that if I can do some daily instruction to help my students sharpen their Chinese reading skills and improve their reading proficiency that would be helpful to gradually support them reading more great books. Although I found the similar situation in Chinese writing, I still want to put my research focus on improving student’s proficiency in reading. Reading is the input of language learning, and writing is the output of language learning. Sufficient comprehensible language input is the foundation of quality language output. Therefore, reading proficiency is the foundation of writing, only when you become a good reader, can you become a good writer. In addition, reading is a big important chunk of our 5th grade Chinese Immersion curriculum; we have to pay more attention to improving the reading to guarantee our students have high quality learning experiences. What’s more, we have a bunch of Chinese reading materials in our school media center. Those books are brand new and just launched in the media center last year, but seldom of the students would like to check out those Chinese books. Majority of them said that those books are too hard to read. If I can help my students improve their reading proficiency and build confidence in reading Chinese, they would have more chances to enjoy different kinds of interesting Chinese books and have more pleasant experience of learning and using Chinese. Last but not the least; the school district bought me a set of leveled Chinese readers with corresponding audios last year. This set of readers is designed based on vocabulary; it has 100-character level all the way to 1200-character level. In each level, students can learn around 100 characters through reading the stories. This set of readers is systematically developed and well organized. I really want to make full use of these materials to support my students and enrich their Chinese learning. Based on all the information I mentioned above, I’ m planning to do an inquiry research project about “How to use leveled readers to improve Chinese reading proficiency for upper elementary Chinese Immersion students”, and I expand this topic into three sub-research questions. The first one is “what does the Chinese reading lesson include?” The second one is “to what extent do the leveled readers impact my students’ learning in reading?” The last one is “to what extent do the leveled readers impact my students’ engagement in reading?” Section 2: Literature Review For this inquiry research project, I focus on how to use leveled readers to improve my students’ Chinese reading proficiency, and I narrow down my research into Chinese Immersion, Chinese Language and Chinese Reading three main areas. After researching, I decided to include the following sources in my literature review. There are 7 empirical literatures in academic journals, 2 videos and 1 website article. First of all, I should have a look at the development and problems found in Chinese Immersion Program. Because that my research is under the Chinese Immersion circumstance, I think it is necessary and important for me to get more information about the Chinese Immersion Program before I start my research. One of the researches explored the benefits and challenges of language immersion, including academic and educational achievement, language and literacy development, cognitive skill development, and economic and sociocultural advantages. My inquiry project explores the ways to develop students’ reading proficiency. Thus, I want to see what research says about the ways of improving American students’ Chinese literacy proficiency. Fortune, T. W. (2013) states that program designers wagered that making the second language the sole medium for teaching core subject content, instead of teaching the second language separately, would result in more students reaching higher levels of proficiency. This quote reminds me the importance of combining content and language in my reading teaching. Another article I’m interested in introduces Chinese Immersion from a big picture. It includes what is Chinese Immersion teaching, typical problems found in the program and the advice for development. There are three main problems mentioned in this article that is about establishing curriculum system, teacher training and the textbooks shortness. Based on the local Chinese teachers’ feedback, it is difficult to find available textbooks and materials; therefore they have to write the textbooks by themselves, which is not systematical. According to the last problem, the author advice that Chinese teachers and American teachers should work together to write the textbooks. However, every year, Confucius Institute Headquarters (Hanban) devotes a huge amount of money, time and energy into writing Chinese textbooks, but only a few can be adopted in the real oversea teaching. We have textbooks in our school district Chinese Immersion Program, but my students do not like it, because the textbooks are dry and boring, these books cannot match American students’ learning style. Under this circumstance, the teacher training and professional development of how to use teaching strategies to remedy the disadvantages of textbooks and materials we current have seems more urgent and important than writing textbooks. Secondly, I believe that if we can learn more about the features of Chinese language, can we learn better in reading and writing Chinese. Especially for the students whose mother tongue is quite different from Chinese. I found an evidence-based research, which is about teaching reading to Chinese and other three countries’ children. The reason why I choose this research is that I want to learn more theories and difference about Chinese reading and English reading. Thurlow, M., Liu, K., Albus, D., & Shyyan, V. (2003) found that because the Chinese writing system represents morphemes, not phonemes as in an alphabetic language, and there is no direct sound-symbol correspondence, Chinese children must memorize many characters in order to learn to read. The vocabulary is the key to Chinese reading, the student who has larger vocabulary should have better reading experience than the student who has less vocabulary. What’s more, Anderson, Shu, & Zhang Anderson, Shu, & Zhang (1995) mentioned that the literature indicates that students learning Chinese are able to learn meanings of characters from context through reading grade appropriate books. In addition, in Reading Strategies Revealed in Chinese Children’s Oral Reading, Wu, X., & Anderson, R. C. (2007) indicate that, unlike learning to read English, learning to read Chinese does not require knowledge of grapheme-phoneme correspondences but, instead, requires knowledge of phoneticsyllable correspondences. Therefore the phonological awareness is the key to learning to read Chinese. However the phonetic clue doesn’t work all the time, learning phonological analogies and semantic analogies can help students decode a character directly. What’s more, some of the researchers summarized the features of Chinese words; first one is that there is a large amount of compound words. If you knows the meaning of A and B, it is easy for you to decode the meaning of AB, but AC compound may represent totally different meaning, which the readers cannot figure out if they don’t know either character in this compound. Therefore, a reading problem may emerge when the students cannot recognize the specific character in compound word. Jin, H., Lin, D., Zhang, D., Wen, H., Zhu, H., He, X., & Mo, L. (2010) indicate that in teaching and training, educational practitioners should not only emphasize students’ single character identification; instead, teaching multiple reading skills is necessary in Chinese literacy instruction, including how to segment sentences, how to identify compound words, and how to visually recognize a single character. These findings help me rethink about the features of Chinese language and characters. It is so true that I should expand my students’ vocabulary as well as develop their reading skills to recognize the compound words and distinguish the compound words from the single characters. As for the reading skills, there is a research which is looking for the relationship between L1 and L2 reading skills. Han, F. (2012) States that L1 reading skills maybe more important than FL proficiency for the transfer of FL reading skills for the learners at lower-intermediate level. Based on the limited Chinese language proficiency of my students, I have to consider reminding them to transfer their English reading skills into Chinese reading. Excepting the reading vocabulary and reading skills, understanding and comprehension also is an important chunk to look at when thinking about improving students’ reading proficiency. Improving Reading Strategies through an Understanding of Culture and Language explored the relationship between Chinese language and culture background knowledge and the reading comprehension. As they found, the reading problem for students of Chinese is that, the students can recognize characters in a sentence, but they cannot comprehend the meaning of the sentence. This problem is very obvious in my 5th grade Chinese Immersion class, my students can decode well in the given passage, but I can still tell that they do not understand the meaning of sentences by their sentence segments. The typical error is making unnecessary stops in compound words. Thirdly, I’m so curious about how other Chinese teacher did in their reading class and also want to see how their kids perform in Chinese reading. One of the videos I found in YouTube is about 4th grade Chinese Immersion interactive read aloud lesson. The teacher read a story about “scare”, she used a lot of “making connections” comprehension strategies in the process. The students tried to find the things happened in their life that scared them and expressed how they felt when they were scared. The content of the story itself is sallow to the 4th grade students, but the teacher asking the students make connections with their own life helps the students have opportunities to practice their reading strategies. Another video I found demonstrates a small group reading performance of kindergarten students, I’m so surprised by their reading fluency and the amount of vocabulary they can read. I noticed that the students using their fingers to help them read. When they read the story of Little Red Hen, they pointed out the characters they reading at the same time. I think this strategy is helpful for improving students’ reading accuracy and fluency, meanwhile this strategy fits for the features of Chinese. Chinese is made of characters, and these characters are monosyllable, which means every sound represents a specific Chinese character. Pointing out what they are reading can help the students make connection with the sounds and characters, and then enhance their understanding of characters, words and the story. As a result, this strategy also helps develop their reading comprehension skills. Another point I noticed in the video is that all the kids read with tones, they are not only reading, but also acting. Make reading dramatize is also a way to help students practice their reading comprehension. At the end of the literature review, I found an interesting article talking about the relationship between reading and cognitive level, including the analyzing of basic cognitive issues, reading fluency and vocabulary acquisition and higher-level skills. Walter, H. C. (2003) found that less-skilled L2 readers do not necessarily have fewer strategies than skilled readers, but they are less able to choose the appropriate strategy for the problem at hand. This finding gives me a better idea in how to guide my students does Chinese reading deferentially, and leveled readers are really good fits for the differentiation. To sum up, some of the researches focus on analyzing the feature of Chinese language and then finding solutions to develop reading comprehension skills, some of the researches try to find the relationship between English and Chinese, and to see whether there are any possibilities to transfer the L1 reading skills into foreign language learning. All of the researches help me have a better understanding about my inquire research project and I think that I’m on the right track to use leveled readers and the corresponding audios to help students expand their vocabulary and improve their reading proficiency. Section 3: Investigative Approach and Tools A description of your participants The participants I am going to study with are the whole group of my 5th grade Chinese Immersion students. Most of them are around 10 years old and have been learning Chinese for 6 years. From kindergarten through fourth grade, they were continuously learning Math and Science in Chinese. A description of the setting of your study I am conducting this study in my Chinese class. Every school day we spend at least 30 minutes on reading and testing. Students use their Chrome books listen to the audio of the book they are studying now and practice reading after that. If they feel prepared, then the students would come to me or my teaching assistant to have a test. They should read through the books, which are only 7 pages for each book. There are only two grades in my school, and both grades have Chinese Immersion program, the focus of 5th grade is reading and writing and to help the students transfer smoothly from 4th grade. Therefore enhance language foundation skills are extremely important for students in 5th grade, and we spend most of time to practice characters and literacy pieces. A description of the data you will collect and the tools that you will use to collect this data The three Data Collection Tools I choose to use are: A Professional Journal, Work Samples, and Student-kept Records. I designed two different forms for recording the data. The first one is Reading Notes, one piece of Reading Notes just for one book. In this piece of paper contains the basic information about the book and the learning process of the students, they should write down the name of the book, the date when starting to read this book, and the characters they don’t know in the book. When they come to me for the test, they should bring this paper to me and I should record the mistakes they make during the test. If students pass the test of that book, I would make a stamp on that Reading Notes and then put that paper in their folders. Next, they should take a new Reading Note and start a new book reading learning. The second form is Weekly Reading Review Sheet, the students should record the name of books they plan to review in home and the questions they might have in that form and parents should sign after that. The purpose of this form is to help students record their learning and reviewing process in home. Sub question 1: what does the Chinese reading lesson include? Data Collection Tool 1: A Professional Journal Materials: Leveled Chinese Readers and corresponding recordings Instruction: how to Data Collection Tool 2: Work Samples Assessment: The students comet to teachers to read the story they learned by Data Collection Tool 3: Student- Kept Records Weekly reading review sheet read individually Technology support: how to use Google Drive to play shared reading resource Parents Support: how to review readings in homeclarification letters and emails Sub question 2: to what extent do the leveled readers impact my students’ learning in reading? Sub question 3: to what extent do the leveled readers impact my students’ engagement in reading? The students start to require extent reading block The students require to have a test on their current leveled reading frequently themselves Reading Notes: record their reading process and the vocabulary learning process. Reward Stamps: More and more students pass the test and rewards stamps, which means their reading amount is accumulated and their vocabulary is expanded Reading Notes: More and more students pass the test and get rewards. Enhance their memory of current expanded vocabulary Double check the questions they may still have even when they pass the test. A timeline for your study: The leveled reading project started from Oct. 7th, my study timeline is from Oct. 7th to Nov. 11th. A description of your role as the researcher At the beginning of the research, my role of teacher takes major part. Because the two major data collection tools, work samples and student-kept records, are both depend on students. I have to make sure they understand how to record their learning appropriately and make sure the data they present to me can be used in my research. It takes time to train the students to get used to the new reading procedures and I’m very firm on that, therefore the teacher role is in the leading position. After one or two weeks, most of the students got used to the procedures and they can do reading very well by themselves, my role of researcher takes major part, I takes more time to observe the students and record their progress, and analyze their common mistakes during test. A plan for dealing with any ethical issues that you may encounter in conducting your project Currently, I have no ethical issues emerged right now. If I have to do an audio or video record, I will check with my school office first to ask for permission to do so. As far as I can see, at the beginning of the school year, the school sent out the permission slips for all the parents. If the parents don’t allow their kids appear in the video or audio, they would inform the school office. The school office would send out the list to teachers, so when videotaping occurs, teachers understand who should be excluded in the camera. Section 4: Data Analysis /Findings Description of what happened during your project I start the leveled reading project at early October; the data collecting period is about 4 weeks. There are 3 major parts included in the project, materials, instructions, and parents support. As for the materials, there are two sections, first section is the paper version leveled Chinese readers, and second section is the digital version readers and the corresponding audios. The problem is that I only have one set of the leveled readers, sometimes the students have to share the same book, which would slow down their reading practicing. Therefore I scanned all the books and made them the digital version. I shared all the digital version readers and the corresponding audios with my students through Google Drive. In this way, every single student have their very own books and audios, they can definitely do their own practice without other’s disturbing. At the same time, I can do differentiation clearly and easily. What’s more, they can easily do review in home through Google Drive. The second part is about instructions. In this part, I also conduct two sections, the first section is about individual reading instruction and the second section is about technology instruction. Technology instruction is easier; I just demonstrate how to use the google drive to find the digital books and the audios and how to open the file to start to read. My students get it very quick and soon become an expert. Reading instruction takes me more time to practice with my students. I explained how to use the Reading Notes during the reading time. First of all, they should go through the whole book and pick up the words they have never met and then write down on the left column of the Reading Notes. Second, they should listen to the audio and repeat the audio sentence by sentence. They should use “listen to Read” method to finish the whole book. The best part of the readers is that every reader has the equal number of pages. That is to say, no matter the 100 level readers or the 1200 level readers, they are all 14-page books, and each page has the same pattern, the left side contains Chinese words and the right side has pictures. This kind of neat organization can help students get used to the regular practice and get familiar with the readers faster. After the “listen to read” practice, they should go back to the Reading Notes and go over the left column again to see whether they adapt some of the new words, and then record the learned vocabulary in the “I got it” column and put the rest of the characters in the “I forgot” column. When they complete the whole learning process, they just write down the date in the date column. The purpose of the Reading Notes is to help the students track their learning process and record their learning. When they finish one book, they should come to me or my teaching assistant to read the whole book, if they only make 3 or less mistakes, they pass the test and can earn a red stamp on their Reading Notes. The third part of the leveled reading project is about parent support. After two weeks of starting the leveled reading in my class, I found that only do reading in class is not enough for my students to sustain what they have learned. If they can do review reading in home, that would be more beneficial for improving their reading proficiency. Therefore I sent out a Chinese reading homework clarification home and ask the parents to support the students reading in home with the digital books and the audios. After that, the parents should sign on the Weekly Reading Review Sheet. The review reading materials is the readers they’ve already passed in class; they should read them again to keep their memories fresh. Generally speaking, my students did a great job on reading in class, but only a few students keep doing the home reviewing consistently. My hunch is that I can in charge of the class reading but can’t reach the home reviewing parts easily. After I mentioned the home reviewing reading in the parent-teacher conference, parents showed their understanding and the welling to support, home reviewing parts gets better than before. Description of how you examined your data Every day I can get tons of data back from student’s Reading Notes, tests, Weekly Review Sheets and the interaction with my students in Chinese class. I recorded their reading progress carefully, and compare and contrast students’ latest Reading Notes and the Notes they did before, to see whether I can find any improvement in expanding vocabulary. I kept a pad of post-it notes in my pocket and jotted down the evidence of their reading improvement, and then discuss with my teaching assistant about the new findings. I also made a survey with my students in the end, and used their self-assessment results to examine my findings. Findings from each data source separately The first data collection tool I used is A Professional Journal. I use post-it notes to jot down my observations and new findings in class, or make up the notes during the recess time or my preparation time. I want to share two typical stories from my professional journal. One day my teaching assistant was testing a girl in her seat, all of sudden, the girl could not stop crying and my teaching assistant stopped testing immediately and tried her best to comfort the girl. I was testing other students, and I stopped and came to my teaching assistant. She told me that, Kaela wanted to pass the test desperately, but she still had some words need to work with, I suggested her to have a little bit review before her taking the second test. I sat down with Kaela, and she said that I’m OK but I really want to pass the test and move to the higher level. I was so touched by her words. Through Kaela’s story, I can deeply feel that my students really take the leveled reading class seriously and the higher level readers motivate them to read more and learn more. In addition, this is also a great example to show me that “leveled readers” impact my students’ engagement in reading. Another story is about students sharing in class. One day morning, we were having the words study lessons. I led students learning new vocabulary in our textbook. When we came to the word “brush”, Stewart raised his hand and shouted out the “brush” in Chinese. I was so surprised by this, and asked him where did he learn this word. Stewart said that I learned it from my reading book. And then, he can’t stop sharing his reading experience and the story he learned. He said that there is a story in 400 level books, Lili, the girl wanted a birthday present and her mother said I would not give you one but I would take you to the store to pick one. And then his brother wanted to go with them. His brother suggested her lots of presents; one of them was a tooth brush. Stewart couldn’t stopping retelling the story in front of the whole class, it seems like that he was conducting a presentation. At the same time, I noticed that Leya was nodding her head frequently to agree with Stewart’s retelling. I tested other students about this story; I knew every single detail about it. I was so surprised that Stewart never missed a detail about the story. After that class, I was so excited; I knew that they could make connections between the books the read and our daily learnings. Moreover, some of students showed me impressive reading comprehension skills. I believe that “Listen to Read” help my students expand their vocabulary in context, at the same time, the practice help them improve their reading comprehension and proficiency. This is also an evidence to show me that “leveled readers” impact my students’ learning in reading. The second tool I used is Work Samples. The Reading Notes which used to record their reading process is my major work sample. It is so much fun to read and dig information from the Reading Notes. I collected Jonid’s Reading Notes from the first week to the fourth week. Jonid started from 400 level, and he is good at Chinese. As for a learning model student, Jonid work really hard on his leveled reading. You can tell from his Reading Notes that he takes a lot of notes to help him remember the new vocabulary he selected from the readers. When compare the vocabulary on the notes, you can easily found that the amount of the characters is increasing and so does the complexity of the vocabulary. I hunch is that the leveled readers provide the students a chance to immerse in divers vocabularies, not only the basic vocabulary, but also the daily life vocabulary and school life vocabulary. This is really great way to enhance their reading foundation. Reading materials are made of characters, the more characters they know, the more stories they can read. The third tool I used is Student-Kept Records, which is the Weekly review sheet. As I mentioned before, only a few students keep recording the home review reading. Therefore I got less data back from this tool. However, I still found something interesting. Sophia is one of students who keep doing recording her home review reading. Every morning, she comes to me before the class starts, and shows me her home review reading records, and then asks me the questions about the words she picked out last night when reviewing. Gradually, I found that the words she asked me were the words she was really struggle with. After asking questions for several times, she finally got the words, and can get them right when the words show up again in other books. This story tells me that home review reading is tedious but necessary; it is really works for students to master the words. Practice makes perfect! Patterns and themes that you found across data sources I also did a survey about the “leveled readers” reading project among my students, one of the questions is that do you like the reading test? I have 27 students in total and 20 of them said they like it. To some degrees, using “leveled readers” and having a testing system are helpful in engaging students in reading. Another question is about learning, all of the students admitted that they leaned new vocabulary from the “leveled readers”, and 24 out of 27 students said that they learned a lot of vocabulary from the reading lesson. Based on the data I collected and the feedbacks from my students, I believed that the “leveled readers” and the “listen to read” method help my students expand their vocabulary and improve their reading comprehension and proficiency. Section 5: Conclusion A connection to the literature review When go back to my literature review, I found that my inquiry research proved the researches I digged before. First of all, I found that vocabulary is the foundation of reading in my literature review, the more vocabulary they get, the more they can read. My students’ improvement in expanding their vocabularies and developing their reading proficiency proved this point. Secondly, in the literature review, I found the research talks about the importance of the context in reading, I believe that Stewart’s sharing is just a right example about how context help students’ understanding and comprehension in reading. A discussion of your reflective stance My students and I really enjoy this “leveled readers” reading project. The survey shows that only 4 students don’t like “listen to read” and 17 out of 27 like it. I also had a discussion with my students about the reading project we are doing right now. Generally speaking, they like it, and they feel so proud when they get the reward stamps, but the stories are too long in the higher level, sometime they lose their patience to practice the long story. I believe I will continue to do this reading project, and I will search more suitable materials for students to support their reading practice. A description of how your findings will guide your next steps In addition, I really appreciate Stephanie Irizarry’s advice. Stephanie is our school district immersion instruction coach; I shared my project with her and told her my concerns about how to expand the vocabulary effectively in future. She helped me analyzed the Reading Notes I designed, and advised me to add understanding section and apply self-assessment scale in the Reading Notes. That is to say, after the students write down the new vocabulary and read the story, they can use the scale to self-assess their vocabulary learning. We use Marzano assessment in our school district and there are 4 numbers in the self-assessment scale, Number 1 means I don’t get it, Number 2 means I can understand with help, Number 3 means I can understand and Number 4 means I understand and I can teach others. How exciting if I can use self-assessment in my students’ reading process! Therefore, I decide to adapt Stephanie’s idea in my future reading program. Future presentation of this work I really appreciate that I had a chance to conduct this reading project, I learned a lot in the process of doing the project. I will be more than happy to share what my students and I did and what I found in the project with my Chinese Immersion colleagues. If I have a chance, I’d like to share my work in some Chinese Immersion conferences. Reference: Fortune, T. W. (2013). What the research says about immersion. Center for Advanced Research on Language Acquisition. Web, 25. Xiuqin, L. (2012) The characteristics and problems of Chinese Immersion in US——Case study of Minnesota University Confucius Classroom. Newsletter of the International Society for Chinese Language Teaching, volume 14. Retrieved from http://www.shihan.org.cn/topics/100338 Thurlow, M., Liu, K., Albus, D., & Shyyan, V. (2003). Literature on Early Literacy Instruction in Four Languages (Chinese, Korean, Navajo, Russian). National Center on Educational Outcomes, University of Minnesota. Wu, X., & Anderson, R. C. (2007). Reading Strategies Revealed in Chinese Children's Oral Reading. Literacy Teaching and Learning, 12(1), 47-72. Jin, H., Lin, D., Zhang, D., Wen, H., Zhu, H., He, X., & Mo, L. (2010). Reading Disabilities of Chinese Elementary School Students: Beyond the Phonological Deficits of Single-Character Identification. International Journal of Special Education, 25(2), 1-7. Wen, X. (1998). Improving Reading Strategies through an Understanding of Culture and Language. Han, F. (2012). Transfer or Threshold: The Relationship between L1 and FL Comprehension Monitoring. Australian Association for Research in Education (NJ1). Ping, Y. (YouTube). (2011, September 8). Little Red Hen with Hats. Podcast retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jpkvR7bcnw Walter, H. C. (2003). Reading in a second language. LTSN Subject Centre for Languages, Linguistics and Area Studies (UK) The Guide to Good Practice.