8th GRADE ELA: IDENTITY AND SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY UNIT 1: The Impact of Prejudice on Morals and Justice ANCHOR TEXT: To Kill a Mockingbird Essential Questions: Does American law guarantee justice for all? How does personal experience contribute to prejudice? How do our preconceptions influence our sense of justice? Can a hero have both good and bad qualities? What are the roles of parents and society in the moral education of children? Guiding Questions: How can examining an author’s life inform and expand our understanding of a novel? How does studying setting and historical context help us understand the motivations of characters? How does the type of narrator determine the point of view from which the story is told? How does class inequality create conflict in society? How is a protagonists journey enriched by characters with different motivations and beliefs? What techniques are used by an author to create a character? Why is it important to support ideas with textual evidence? How do writers use figurative language to help readers visualize and experience events and emotions in a story? In what ways can Socratic Seminar discussion contribute to our understanding of a text? How can identifying and understanding symbols reveal new interpretations of a novel? How does an author’s use of symbolism add power and meaning to a story? What events or influences cause characters to change their beliefs? How does family influence our morals and beliefs? How does the author’s development of plot create suspense and add depth to characters? How does experience change our view of the world? How are characters’ beliefs and/or choices impacted by dynamics of power? How do we determine what evidence to cite to support ideas? How can we develop ideas for our own writing by examining a model text? What is the difference between paraphrasing and plagiarism? How can we organize our ideas before writing an essay? How can we use language to add power and meaning to our writing? Why is it important to monitor and reflect on progress as readers and writers? 1 Enduring Understandings: People have both good and bad qualities Issues of race are still relevant today Parents and society play important roles in the moral education of children Class inequality creates conflict in society Experience as well as assumptions contribute to prejudice Conflict is presented through the juxtaposition of social justice and law. NYS Common Core Standards for English Language Arts Assessed: Reading Standards for Literature (Grade 8) Standard 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10 Reading Standards for Information (Grade 8) Standard 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10 Writing Standards (Grade 8) Standard 1a-e, 2a-f, 3a-d, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9a-b, 10 Speaking and Listening Standards (Grade 8) Standard 1a-d, 2, 3, 4, 6 Language Standards (Grade 8) Standard 1b-d, 2a-c, 3a, 4a-d, 5a-c, 6 Teacher Designed Standards Assessed: 1. Students will reflect upon their work as literary critics by: a) identifying strengths. b) identifying struggles. c) setting goals to improve their work. d) revising their work to make it better e) asking questions to improve their understanding. 2 ASSESSMENT EVIDENCE Authentic Performance Task(s): Alignment to NYS Common Core Standards: 1. Listen to and take detailed notes on the life and accomplishments of Harper Lee. Use your notes to answer questions and write a short essay about social influences that had an impact on Harper Lee. 2. Mr. Raymond gives the appearance of being an alcoholic in order for the white community to accept his spending time with the black community. Is he brave or foolish for this behavior? Use specific and relevant textual evidence to support your ideas. 3. Using specific details from the text, choose an event and explain how this event reveals the development of Jem and Scout as dynamic characters. Two examples have been provided for you. 4. Analyze the poem, “The Barrier” by Claude McKay using the novel and a historical document on Alabama Jim Crow laws related to miscegenation. Based on evidence from the novel, predict how the residents of Maycomb would react to the speaker’s relationship with the woman. Use the novel and the document to argue whether the legal consequences or the social consequences are more severe. 5. Read the historical document: “Judge Horton Orders a New Trial in the Case of Haywood Patterson June 22, 1933,” paying particular attention to the discrediting of Victoria Price’s testimony. Create a TChart. In the left column, record key arguments in the trial of Haywood 1. Patterson. In the write column, record key arguments in Tom Robinson’s trial. Highlight the similarities between the two cases. 6. Write a short essay in which you explain how the events and themes contribute to the significance of the title. Be sure to include specific evidence from the text. 1. 11c: Recognize and illustrate social, historical, and cultural features in the presentation of literary texts. 2. RI2: Determine a central idea of a text and analyze its development over the course of the text, including its relationship to supporting ideas. 3. RL3: Analyze how particular lines of dialogue or incidents in a story or drama reveal aspects of a character. RI5: Analyze in detail the structure of a specific paragraph in a text, including the role of particular sentences in developing and refining a key concept. 4. SL3: Delineate a speaker’s argument and specific claims, evaluating the soundness of the reasoning and relevance and sufficiency of the evidence. W11A: Make well-supported textual and thematic connections across genres. RI3: Analyze how a text makes connections among and distinctions between individuals, ideas and events. RL11: Make well-supported personal, cultural, textual, and thematic connections across genres 5. RL1: Cite the textual evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of what the text says explicit as well as inferences drawn from the text. 3 Pre/Post Reading: 1. Students will respond to the essential questions at the start of the unit and at the end of the unit. (pre/post) Formative Assessments: (See Appendix) 1. Daily reader response journal entries 2. Class discussions 3. Quizzes and tests 4. Class work 5. Homework Summative Assessment: 1. Citing specific evidence from the novel as well as 3 outside sources (i.e., historical nonfiction), write an essay in which you discuss how social issues presented in the novel contributed to the divide among the residents of Maycomb, as well as the impact of this divide on Atticus, Jem, and Scout. Common Core State Standards: RL.8.1: Cite the textual evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text. W.9: Draw evidence from literary or informational texts to support analysis, reflection, and research. TEACHING AND LEARNING PLAN Teaching and Learning Activities: 1. Use essential questions a hook introducing themes in the novel. 2. Begin with an Anticipation Guide 3. Create a KWL with students about racism in America’s past. 4. Use unit teaching points and guiding questions to close read. 5. Have students view and critique the film version of the text, paying particular attention to how the film stays faithful to or departs from the text. 6. Introduce grammar as a means of strengthening and elevating the power and effectiveness of written pieces. 7. Have students engage in Socratic Seminar discussion of the text, for which they engage in close reading of a particular passage and prepare questions to generate critical analysis and debate. 8. Read informational text to analyze particular passages in the novel. 9. Use essential questions as a post-assessment, using details and examples from the text to examine whether new information has changed students’ initial opinions. 10. Read and interpret poetry. 11. Have students peer edit and revise written summative assessment. Resources Needed: Anchor Text: To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee Poems: “The Barrier” by Claude McKay, “If a Clown” by Stephen Dunn Jim Crow Laws in Alabama Internet sources for information on The Scottsboro Trials Film: To Kill a Mockingbird Resource for related scholarly essays: http://www.ssrn.com/ 4 UNIT 2: The Impact of Prejudice on Morals and Justice Essential Question: How does prejudice impact morality and justice? WEEKLY CALENDAR (November 7 – January 27) Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1 1) EQ: Does American 1. Individual Historical context law guarantee response to of Jim Crow South justice for all? essential Biography of 2) How can examining questions. Harper Lee an author’s life 2. Anticipation Guide inform and expand 3. Performance our understanding Task 1: Listening of a novel? /Note-taking Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RI 3, 5, 8; W 4, 9b, 10; SL 1d 3; L 2a, b, c, 4a, 6 Week 2 Guiding Questions 3) How does class inequality create conflict in society? Topics/Lessons Characterization Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1. Students will journal about first impressions of characters 2. Create a diagram of social class using textual evidence. Key Vocabulary segregation, justice, contentious, tentative, taciturn Key Vocabulary Setting, culture, social class, inequality, prejudice Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 2; RI 3, 5, 8; W4, 9b, 10; SL1d; L2a, b, c, 4a, 6 5 Week 3 Guiding Questions 4) How does the type of narrator determine the point of view from which the story is told? 5) How do we talk about poetry? Topics/Lessons Point of View Public speaking; speaking for dramatic effect Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1. Write and present a chapter of the novel in first person from Boo Radley’s perspective. 2. Read and analyze “If a Clown” and discuss point of view as presented in the poem. Key Vocabulary Omniscient narrator, limited narrator, point of view, perspective Projection, inflection Speaker, subject Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 6; W 3a, b, c, d, 4, 9a, 10; SL 4, 6; L 3a, 4a, c, 5a, b, c, 6 Week 4 Guiding Questions 6) How is a protagonists journey enriched by characters with different motivations and beliefs? 7) What techniques are used by an author to create a character? Topics/Lessons Determining character traits Types of characters Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1. Character Traits graphic organizer, record trait and cite supporting evidence for multiple characters. 2. Write a short essay arguing who or what the antagonist is, using specific and relevant evidence. Key Vocabulary Protagonist, antagonist, flaw, idealism, major/minor character, foil, malevolent, assuage, impotent, impudent, piety, predilection Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 4, 6, 9; RI 3, W 1a, b, c, d, 4, 9a, 10; SL 1a, b, c, d; L 4a, b, c, 5a, b, c, d 6 6 Week 5 Guiding Questions 8) What is an effective discussion question? 9) What conflicts are developing within and between characters? Topics/Lessons Conflict Writing an effective discussion question Assessments Key Vocabulary (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1. Create a T-Chart Internal / External and record conflict, juxtaposition examples of internal and external conflict in the novel. 2. Dialogue Journal entry: posing and answering a textbased discussion question Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 3, 4, 6; RI 5, W 7, 9a, 10; SL 1c; L 2a, b, c, 6 Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 6 11) In what ways can 1. Pose and discuss text-based Close reading Socratic Seminar questions in a Socratic Seminar Socratic Seminar discussion contribute about characters’ choices and behaviors and to our understanding likeability. language of a text? Generating effective discussion questions Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 4; RI 5; W 3a, b, c, d, 9a; SL 1a, b, c, d; L 1b, c, d, 2a, b, c, 3a Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) Key Vocabulary Socratic method, inquiry Key Vocabulary 7 7 How can we use technology to conduct intellectual conversations with our peers online? 1. Research the natural features of mockingbirds and write a short essay explaining how they relate to the story. 2. Complete a webquest on the Scottsboro trials 3. Respond to discussion board questions about the novel and about the Scottsboro trials Conducting research Discussion Board etiquette and expectations Symbolism Blog Discussion Board Posting Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 4; RI 1, 3, 4; W 2a, b, c, d, e, f, 7, 8; L 4a, b, c, d Week 8 Guiding Questions 15) What events or influences cause characters to change their beliefs? Topics/Lessons Character Development Issues of race in today’s society Cause and effect Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1. Performance Task 2: Using textual evidence, write a short essay arguing whether Mr. Raymond is more brave or foolish. 2. Performance Task 3: Choose an event and explain how this event reveals the development of Jem and Scout as dynamic characters. Key Vocabulary static/dynamic round/flat evolution role-reversal elements of a trial: prosecution defense testimony witness deliberation verdict Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 2, 3, 4; RI 5, 8; W 1a, b, c, d, e, 4; L 2a, b, c, 3a Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) Key Vocabulary 8 9 18) EQ: What are the roles of parents and society in the moral education of children? Scottsboro Trials Poetry analysis 1. Performance Task 4: Analyze “The Barrier” by Claude McKay using the novel and a Jim Crow document 2. Performance Task 5: Read Haywood Patterson historical document and compare key arguments of the trial to Tom Robinson’s poetic devices: rhyme, structure, point of view Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 2, 4, 5, 10; RI 1, 3, 9, 10; W 4, 8, 9b; L 2a, b, c, 3a Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 10 21) How are characters’ 1. Create a T-Chart. In the left Theme beliefs and/or choices column, list the characters Revisit rules and impacted by dynamics from most powerful to least procedure for of power? powerful. In the right column, Socratic Seminar 22) How do we explain your choices using Choosing textual determine what details from the novel. evidence evidence to cite to Discuss in Socratic Seminar. support ideas? Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 2; RI 1, 2; W 2a, b, c, d, e, f, 4; SL 1a, b, c, d, L 5a, b, c, 6 Key Vocabulary Theme 9 Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 1. Essay outline with selected evidence 22) How can we develop Creating an Outline ideas for our own writing Writing a thesis by examining a model statement text? 2. Drafted Developing a strong 23) What is the difference introductions and body introduction between paraphrasing paragraphs of Writing topic sentences and plagiarism? Explaining evidence with Character Analysis 24) How can we organize Essay transitions and analysis our ideas before writing an essay? Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 2, 3, 4; W 2a, b, c, d, e, f, 4, 5, 6, 10; SL 1a; L 1b, c, d, 2a, b, c, 3a, 6 Week Guiding Questions Topics/Lessons Assessments (diagnostic, formative, summative, interim) 12 25) How can we use 1. Final draft of Revision Word language to add power Character Analysis choice and meaning to our Essay Grammar / writing? Spelling 26) Why is it important 2. Reflection on Peer editing / to monitor and reflect on writing process, editing symbols progress as readers and personal growth Publishing writers? Word processing Reflection 11 Key Vocabulary Original thought, thesis, catchy opening, transitions Plagiarism, academic integrity Key Vocabulary Revision, editing, agreement, homonyms Standards Grade 8 Assessed: RL 1, 2, 3, 4; W 2a, b, c, d, e, f, 4, 5, 6, 10; SL 1a; L 1b, c, d, 2a, b, c, 3a, 6 Appendix I. Daily Journal Entries 10 (Example) Directions: Interpret the following quote using the 4 Step Process.* Remember to relate the quote to chapter 10 of To Kill a Mockingbird in Step 4. “Pride makes us artificial and humility makes us real.” – Thomas Merton II. Classwork Citing evidence as support 1. On page 99, Jem characterizes himself and Atticus as gentlemen. Choose a quote from pages 97-99 that supports this characterization. Response to questions based on reading 1. In what ways are the characters of Calpurnia and Tom Robinson representative of the black community in Maycomb? 2. Using specific examples from the text, explain what Atticus means when he says he’s “in favor of Southern womanhood as much as anybody, but not for preserving polite fiction at the expense of human life” on page 147. Notes based on reading and writing process Group Work 1. As a group, organize characters, symbols, personality traits, and other significant words (prewritten on post-its) from the novel into categories on chart paper. Present categories to the class, explaining your reasoning for associating words and characters. III. Homework Example: Naming the Chapter After reading Chapter 7 of To Kill a Mockingbird, what title would you give it? Write a short essay explaining your choice. Be sure to include specific details and transition phrases. *The 1. 2. 3. 4. Four Step Process for Quote Interpretation: (author) once said, “copy the quote” In other words (say what you think the quote means) I (agree/disagree) with this quote because… This quote relates to To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee in that… 11 If a Clown by Stephen Dunn If a clown came out of the woods, a standard-looking clown with oversized polka-dot clothes, floppy shoes, a red, bulbous nose, and you saw him on the edge of your property, there’d be nothing funny about that, would there? A bear might be preferable, especially if black and berry-driven. And if this clown began waving his hands with those big white gloves that clowns wear, and you realized he wanted your attention, had something apparently urgent to tell you, would you pivot and run from him, or stay put, as my friend did, who seemed to understand here was a clown who didn’t know where he was, a clown without a context? What could be sadder, my friend thought, than a clown in need of a context? If then the clown said to you that he was on his way to a kid’s birthday party, his car had broken down, and he needed a ride, would you give him one? Or would the connection between the comic and the appalling, as it pertained to clowns, be suddenly so clear that you’d be paralyzed by it? And if you were the clown, and my friend hesitated, as he did, would you make a sad face, and with an enormous finger wipe away an imaginary tear? How far would you trust your art? I can tell you it worked. Most of the guests had gone when my friend and the clown drove up, and the family was angry. But the clown twisted a balloon into the shape of a bird and gave it to the kid, who smiled, let it rise to the ceiling. If you were the kid, the birthday boy, what from then on would be your relationship with disappointment? With joy? Whom would you blame or extoll? 12 Jim Crow Laws: Alabama Close Enacted 27 Jim Crow segregation laws between 1865 and 1965: including six each against miscegenation and desegregated schools. A 1915 health care segregation law prevented white nurses from caring for black male patients. Unlike other former Confederacy states, no laws were enacted during the Reconstruction period barring segregation. Miscegenation violations carried the harshest penalties. Violators could be sentenced to the penitentiary for two to seven years of hard labor. After the Brown decision, six segregation laws were passed, including a Birmingham city ordinance requiring segregated public accommodations and recreational areas. 1865: Miscegenation [Constitution] Stated that it was the duty of the general assembly to periodically enact laws prohibiting intermarriage between whites and blacks, or with persons of mixed blood, and to establish penalties. 1865: Miscegenation [Constitution] Stated that it was the duty of the general assembly to periodically enact laws prohibiting intermarriage between whites and blacks, or with persons of mixed blood, and to establish penalties. 1867: Miscegenation [State Code] Set penalties for intermarriage and cohabitation between blacks and whites. Penalties: Confinement in the penitentiary at hard labor between two and seven years. Those who issued the license or performed such a ceremony could be fined from $100 to $1,000, or imprisoned for six months, or both. 1928: Miscegenation [State Code] Miscegenation declared a felony. 1940: Miscegenation [State Code] Prohibited intermarriage and cohabitation between whites and blacks or the descendant of any Negro. Penalty: Imprisonment in the penitentiary for two to seven years. Ministers and justices of the peace faced fines between $100 and $1,000 and could be imprisoned in the county jail for up to six months. http://www.jimcrowhistory.org/scripts/jimcrow/insidesouth.cgi?state=alabama THE BARRIER by: Claude McKay (1890-1948) MUST not gaze at them although Your eyes are dawning day; I must not watch you as you go Your sun-illumined way; I hear but I must never heed The fascinating note, Which, fluting like a river reed, Comes from your trembling throat; I must not see upon your face Love's softly glowing spark; For there's the barrier of race, You're fair and I am dark. "The Barrier" is reprinted from Harlem Shadows. Claude McKay. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1922. 13 14