Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery Participant manual Table of contents 1. 1 2 3 4 2. INTRODUCTION 3 BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT ..................................................................................................................... 3 TARGET GROUP ........................................................................................................................................... 4 GOAL AND OBJECTIVES ............................................................................................................................... 4 MODEL AND STRUCTURE OF THE MANUAL ................................................................................................ 4 TRAINING SESSIONS 6 DAY 1 – ACTIVITIES AND HANDOUTS .............................................................................................................................. 7 DAY 2 - ACTIVITIES AND HANDOUT............................................................................................................................... 21 DAY 3 - ACTIVITIES AND HANDOUTS ............................................................................................................................. 32 10. REFERENCES AND RESOURCES 46 Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 2 1. Introduction 1 Background and context The current situation of frequent armed conflicts, as well as natural and man-made disasters in different parts of the world has led to a growing number of internally displaced people and refugees. In the Middle East for example, millions of people have left their homes in search of safe places where they are offered temporary shelter, with growing needs for aid. In his appeal for aid for refugees from Syria,Alexander Aleinikoff1, Deputy High Commissioner at UNHCR said, on the side-lines of the World Economic Forum at the Dead Sea, that the refugee community is projected to double from the current 1.5 million to 3 million by the end of 2013. Aleinikoff added that if the violence continues, the needs will only continue to grow. In such a situation, aid providers are faced with all types of challenges in responding not only to their traditional basic needs such as shelter, food, water, and medical care, but also to educational needs of children and youth whose regular schooling has been interrupted. Education is increasingly gaining the attention of several humanitarian organizations and host countries as a fundamental human right that is part of the aid package.The main challenge remains how to provide quality education while ensuring equal access to all primary school age children. Teachers play a central role in the education sector, as the main actors who are capable of bringing the change expected by communities with the graduates of the school system. The current situation where schools are required to increase access to all children while providing them with quality training of teachers is therefore one of the major components in any education intervention, including in emergencies. The Inter-Agency Network on Education in Emergencies (INEE) considers training crucial to achievement of the minimum standards in Teaching and Learning. This training manual has been developed as a result of the current emergent situation in Syria where Palestinian refugees fled into Lebanon, as part of UNRWA’s response to the crisis. The Lebanon Field Office (LFO) has integrated the refugees into the UNRWA Education System, catering for those who registered with UNRWA by organizing a double shift system, with afternoon classes in the existing schools. In addition,recently qualified teachers have been recruited under a special programme for Palestine Refugees Students from Syria (PRS), in order to respond to the educational needs of the increasing number of children in these schools. A Rapid Needs Assessment undertaken by NRC2 Lebanon Office in five selected schools revealed there was a need for most of the newly appointed teachers for PRS to be trained and supported in an accelerated training program.The program would focus on classroom management, lesson planning and interactive teaching approaches for education during crisis and emergencies, psychosocial support and communication skills. The “Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery” has been developed under the HQ Framework for Education in Emergency and in collaboration with UNRWA Lebanon Fields Office (LFO). It is part of the efforts of UNRWA’s education department, through its TDSE Unit, to train newly recruited teachers of UNRWA schools how to respond to the educational needs of Palestinian Refugees Students from Syria. The manual can be used in addition to tools produced by other units of the education department or stakeholders dealing with cross-cutting issues such as inclusive education and human rights. 1 UNRWA Media Review, Public Information Office Jordan Field, 27 May 2013. Amman, Jordan 2 NRC, Rapid Education Needs Assessment for Palestine Refugee Students from Syria in five UNRWA Schools in Lebanon, February 2013 Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 3 2 Target group 3 Goal and objectives Although the programme is primarily designed for teachers who are responsible for students of elementary, preparatory and secondary schools in the special conditions of UNRWA Schools in Lebanon, it can also be revised and adapted to similar situations that require teacher training in emergency scenarios. The commitment and skills of UNRWA teachers have been the foundation of a successful education system that has operated across UNRWA’s five Fields over the last sixty years. In emergency situations, this commitment and teachers' overall role is central towards the provision of quality education. This training manual will serve as a guiding and supporting tool for facilitators and all other teachers in the context of emergencies to better understand UNRWA’s education programme; what it consists of, what resources are available to draw upon towards achieving its overall vision of establishing “an education system which develops the full potential of Palestine refugees to enable them to be confident, innovative, questioning, thoughtful, tolerant and open minded, upholding human values and religious tolerance, proud of their Palestine identity and contributing positively to the development of their society and the global community”. The training aims to equip teachers with necessary professional knowledge, attitudes and skills to enable them to effectively and confidently perform their duties. More specifically, it is expected that at the end of the training, teachers will be able to: 1. Demonstrate understanding of UNRWA Education programme. 2. Understand how children learn and its “implications for teachers”. 3. Manage the teaching and learning process and space under the specific conditions of emergencies. 4. Use child-centred methodologies of teaching and learning. 5. Demonstrate self-confidence and motivation in performing their duties. 6. Assess students learning needs and use continuous assessment to inform their lesson planning. 7. Adapt and enrich the teaching content in core learning areas (Arabic, English, Maths and Science) to respond to students’ needs. 4 Model and structure of the manual The manual can be used for a face-to-face three day training of five hours each, with additional materials for self-study by teachers. It is divided into topics and subjects that have been prepared for ease of use by facilitators. These provide teachers with guiding principles, strategies and tips for effective teaching and learning in orderto strengthen their abilities and pedagogical skills to perform better in their duties. The manual is made up of two documents: one addressing facilitators and the other addressing teachers. The facilitator will require access to both documents in order to lead the training. The definitions of the training techniques are listed at the end of the facilitators' guide as annexes and will support any facilitator in leading the sessions regardless of their training experience. It is worth noting that the training methodology has been adapted to suit situations of emergency,i.e., the power point presentations are presented as additional resources in the annexes, yet their use is optional depending on the availability of resources. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 4 A sample outline of the three-day training would look as follows: Day Day1 Training hours Topics/Subjects Introductions, expectations and objectives UNRWA Education Programme Child-centered methodologies of teaching and learning Managing the teaching and learning process and space under the specific conditions of emergencies Understanding assessment in teaching and learning The role of assessment in supporting learning Types of assessment : Formative vs Summative Importance of feedback 5 Day2 Day3 Identifying key numeracy and literacy concepts and skills Techniques for developing numeracy and literacy skills Cross curricular approach of teaching numeracy and literacy 5 5 Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 5 2. Training sessions Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 6 Day 1 – Activities and handouts Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 7 H1: Topic 'How Children Learn' (Sessions 1&2 /Slides 19-29 from the Day 1 PPT) 1. To the teachers Write three practises that you have used in the classroom? 2. Can you add two practises after discussions with your colleagues? - Total estimated time of the activity (75 minutes) (30 minutes Group work, 15 minutes reporting, 30 minutes reflection into classroom practice) Group work: 30 minutes Facilitator follows the jig sawing technique in conducting this task (Facilitators may refer to the Facilitators' notes on description of the technique and for more information on group work) Participants are divided into groups. The number of the groups depends on the number of participants. Each group should not exceed five members. The task each group is required to accomplish is reading and discussion of one of the principles below. How children learn: In the discussion of how children learn, the focus should be on three principles widely recognized as the basis on which teachers should design learning environments in today’s schools: 1. learning environments that encourage students to be active learners 2. to collaborate with other students and 3. to use meaningful tasks and authentic materials. This is integrated with cognitive factors that are primarily internal, but also interact with environmental factors in important ways. In the following paragraphs, a summary of research findings on these principles are introduced with application and tips on their classroom use. Principle No. 1: Learning requires an active, constructive involvement of the learner. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 8 Researchfindings Learning at school requires students to pay attention, observe, memorize, understand, set goals and assume responsibility for their own learning. These cognitive activities are not possible without active involvement and engagement of the learner. Teachers must help students to become active, motivated and goal oriented by building on their natural desire to explore, to understand new things and to master them. In the classroom It is a challenge for teachers to create interesting and challenging learning environments that encourage active involvement of students. The following are some suggestions as to how this can be done: • Avoid situations where students are passive listeners for long periods of time. • Provide students with hands-on activities, such as experiments, observations, projects, etc. • Encourage participation in classroom discussions and other collaborative activities. • Organize school visits to museums and technological parks. • Allow students to take some control over their own learning.Taking control over one’s learning means allowing students to make some decisions about what to learn and how. • Assist students in creating learning goals that are consistent with their interests and future aspirations. Principle No.2: Learning is primarily a social activity and participation in the social life of the school is central for learning to occur Research findings For many researchers, social participation is the main activity through which learning occurs. Social activity and participation begin early on. Parents interact with their children and through these interactions children acquire the behaviours that enable them to become effective members of society. According to the psychologist Lev Vygotsky, the way children learn is by internalizing the activities, habits, vocabulary and ideas of the members of the community in which they grow up. The establishment of a fruitful collaborative and co-operative atmosphere is an essential part of school learning. Research has shown that social collaboration can boost student achievement, provided that the kinds of interactions that are encouraged contribute to learning. Finally, social activities are interesting in their own right and help to keep students involved in their academic work. Students work harder to improve the quality of their products (essays, projects, artwork, etc.) when they know that they will be shared with other students. In the classroom Teachers can do many things to encourage social participation in ways that facilitate learning: • They can assign students to work in groups and assume the role of a coach/co-ordinator who provides guidance and support to the groups. • They can create a classroom environment that includes group workspaces where resources are shared. • Through modelling and coaching, they can teach students how to co-operate with each other. • They can create circumstances for students to interact with each other, to express their opinions and to evaluate other students’ arguments. • An important aspect of social learning is to link the school to the community at large. In this way, students’ opportunities for social participation are enlarged. Principle No.3: People learn best when they participate inactivities that are perceived to be useful inreal life and are culturally relevant Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 9 Research findings Many school activities are not meaningful since students understand neither why they are doing them nor what their purpose and usefulness is. Sometimes school activities are not meaningful because they are not culturally appropriate. Many schools are communities where children from diverse cultures learn together. There are systematic cultural differences in practices, in habits, in social roles, etc., that influence learning. Sometimes meaningful activities for students coming from one cultural group are not meaningful to students who are coming from another cultural group. In the classroom Teachers can make classroom activities more meaningful by situating them in an authentic context. An example of an authentic context is one in which the activity is typically used in real life. For example, students can improve their oral language and communication skills by participating in debates. They can improve their writing skills by being involved in the preparation of a classroom newspaper. Students can learn science by participating in a community or school environmental project. The school can be in contact with local scientists and invite them to lecture, or allow the students to visit their laboratories. It is also important for teachers to be aware of the cultural differences of the children in their classroom and to respect these differences. They must see them as strengths to build on, rather than as defects. Children will feel differently in the classroom if their culture is reflected in the common activities. School routines that are unfamiliar to some children can be introduced gradually so that the transition can be less traumatic for ethnically diverse groups. Principle No.4: New knowledge is constructed on the basis of what is already understood and believed Research findings The idea that people’s ability to learn something new follows from what they already know is not new, but more recent research findings have shown that the ability to relate new information to prior knowledge is critical for learning. It is not possible for someone to understand, remember or learn something that is completely unfamiliar. Some prior knowledge is necessary to understand the task at hand. But having the prerequisite prior knowledge is still not sufficient to ensure adequate results. People must activate their prior knowledge in order to be able to use it for understanding and for learning. Research shows that students do not consistently see the relationships between new material that they read and what they already know. Research also shows that learning is enhanced when teachers pay close attention to the prior knowledge of the learner and use this knowledge as the starting point for instruction. In the classroom Teachers can help students activate prior knowledge and use it for the task at hand. This can be done in a number of ways. • Teachers can discuss the content of a lesson before starting in order to ensure that the students have the necessary prior knowledge and in order to activate this knowledge. • Often students’ prior knowledge is incomplete or there are false beliefs and critical misconceptions. Teachers do not simply need to know that students know something about the topic to be introduced. They need to investigate students’ prior knowledge in detail so that false beliefs and misconceptions can be identified. • Teachers may need to go back to cover important prerequisite material or ask the students to do some preparatory work on their own. • Teachers can ask the kind of question that helps students see relationships between what they are reading and what they already know. • Effective teachers can help students to grasp relationships and make connections. They can do so by providing a model or a scaffold that students can use as support in their efforts to improve their performance. Principle No.5: Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 10 Learners must know how to plan andmonitor their learning, how to set their ownlearning goals and how to correct errors Research findings The term ‘self-regulation’ is used here to indicate students’ ability to monitor their own learning, to understand when they are making errors, and to know how to correct them. Self-regulation is not the same as being strategic. People can use strategies for learning mechanically without being fully aware of what they are doing. Self-regulation involves the development of specific strategies that help learners evaluate their learning, check their understanding and correct errors when appropriate. Self-regulation requires reflection in the sense of being aware of one’s own beliefs and strategies. Reflection can develop through discussion, debates and essays, where children are encouraged to express their opinions and defend them. Another important aspect of reflection is being able to distinguish appearance from reality, common beliefs from scientific knowledge, etc. In the classroom Teachers can help students become self-regulated and reflective by providing opportunities: • To plan how to solve problems, design experiments and read books; • To evaluate the statements, arguments, solutions to problems of others, as well as of one’s self; • To check their thinking and ask themselves questions about their understanding— (Why am I doing what I am doing? How well am I doing? What remains to be done?); • To develop realistic knowledge of themselves as learners— (I am good in reading, but need to work on my mathematics); • To set their own learning goals; • To know what are the most effective strategies to use and when to use them. Principle No.6: People learn by employing effective and flexible strategies that help them tounderstand, reason, memorize and solve problems Research findings Children develop strategies to help themselves solve problems from an early age. For example, when preschool children are told to go to the supermarket to buy a list of food items, they often repeat the items on their way to remember them better. These children have discovered rehearsal as a strategy to improve their memory without anybody telling them to do so. When they go to school, children need help from teachers to develop appropriate strategies for solving mathematics problems, when understanding texts, doing science, learning from other students, etc. Research shows that when teachers make systematic attempts to teach learning strategies to students substantial gains can result. Strategies are important because they help students understand and solve problems in ways that are appropriate for the situation at hand. Strategies can improve learning and make it faster. Strategies may differ in their accuracy, in their difficulty of execution, in their processing demands and in the range of problems to which they apply. The broader the range of strategies that children can use appropriately, the more successful they can be in problem solving, in reading, in text comprehension and in memorizing. In the classroom Teachers must recognize the importance of students knowing and using a variety of strategies. The teaching of strategies can be done directly or indirectly. In the latter case, the teacher can give students a task and provide a model of the inquiry process or ask key questions. For example, in reading, teachers can explicitly show students how to outline the important points in a text and how to summarize them. Alternatively, they can ask a group of students to discuss a text and summarize it. They can help in this process by participating in the discussion and by asking critical questions. In science, teachers can show students how to conduct experiments: how to form hypotheses, how to keep a systematic record of their findings, and how to evaluate Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 11 them. It is important to ensure that students learn to use these strategies on their own and do not always rely on teachers to provide the necessary support. Teachers need to gradually fade their assistance and allow students to take greater responsibility for their learning. Principle No.7: Sometimes prior knowledge can stand in the way of learning something new.Students must learn how to solve internal inconsistencies and restructure existingconceptions when necessary Research findings Sometimes existing knowledge can stand in the way of understanding new information. While this is often the case in the learning of science and mathematics, it can apply to all subject matter areas. It happens because our current understanding of the physical and social world, of history, of theorizing about numbers, etc., is the product of thousands of years of cultural activity that has radically changed intuitive ways of explaining phenomena. For example, in the area of mathematics, many children make mistakes when they use fractions because they use rules that apply to natural numbers only. Similarly, in the physical sciences, students form various misconceptions. The idea that the Earth is round like a pancake or like a sphere flattened on the top happens because it reconciles the scientific information that the Earth is round, with the intuitive belief that it is flat and that people live upon its top. Such misconceptions do not apply only in young children. They are common in high school and college students as well. In the classroom What can teachers do to facilitate the understanding of counterintuitive information? • Teachers need to be aware that students have prior beliefs and incomplete understandings that can conflict with what is being taught at school. • It is important to create the circumstances where alternative beliefs and explanations can be externalized and expressed. • Teachers need to build on the existing ideas of students and slowly lead them to more mature understandings. Ignoring prior beliefs can lead to the formation of misconceptions. • Students must be provided with observations and experiments that have the potential of showing to them that some of their beliefs can be wrong. Examples from the history of science can be used for this purpose. • Scientific explanations must be presented with clarity and, when possible, exemplified with models. • Students must be given enough time to restructure their prior conceptions. In order to do this, it is better to design curricula that deal with fewer topics in greater depth than attempting to cover a great deal of topics in a superficial manner. Principle No.8: Learning is better when material is organized around general principles and explanations, rather than when it is based on the memorization of isolated facts and procedures Research findings All teachers want their students to understand what they are learning and not to memorize facts in a superficial way. Research shows that when information is superficially memorized it is easily forgotten. On the contrary, when something is understood, it is not forgotten easily and it can be transferred to other situations (see also the next principle on transfer). In order to understand what they are being taught, students must be given the Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 12 opportunity to think about what they are doing, to talk about it with other students and with teachers, to clarify it and to understand how it applies in many situations In the classroom How does one teach for understanding? The following are some tasks teachers can carry out in order to promote understanding of the material that has been taught: • Ask students to explain a phenomenon or a concept in their own words. • Show students how to provide examples that illustrate how a principle applies or how a law works. • Students must be able to solve characteristic problems in the subject-matter area. Problems can increase in difficulty as students acquire greater expertise. • When students understand the material, they can see similarities and differences, they can compare and contrast, and they can understand and generate analogies. • Teach students how to abstract general principles from specific cases and generalize from specific examples. Principle No.9: Learning becomes more meaningful when the lessons are applied to real-life situations. Research findings Students often cannot apply what they have learned at school to solve real-world problems. For example, they may learn about Newton’s laws at school but fail to see how they apply in real life situations. Transfer is very important. Why should someone want to go to school if what is learned there does not transfer to other situations and cannot be used outside the school? In the classroom Teachers can improve students’ ability to transfer what they have learned at school by: • Insisting on mastery of subject matter. Without an adequate degree of understanding, transfer cannot take place (see previous principle). • Helping students see the transfer implications of the information they have learned. • Applying what has been learned in one subject-matter area to other areas to which it may be related. • Showing students how to abstract general principles from concrete examples. • Helping students learn how to monitor their learning and how to seek and use feedback about their progress. • Teach for understanding rather than for memorization (see previous principle). Principle No.10: Learning is a complex cognitive activity thatcannot be rushed. It requires considerabletime and periods of practice to start buildingexpertise in an area. Research findings Research shows that people must carry out a great deal of practice to acquire expertise in an area. Even small differences in the amount of time during which people are exposed to information can result in large differences in the information they have acquired. Cognitive psychologists Chase & Simon (1973) studied chess experts and found that they had often spent as many as 50,000 hours practising chess. A 35-year-old chess master who has spent 50,000 hours playing chess must have spent four to five hours on the chessboard from the age of 5 every day for thirty years! Less accomplished players have spent considerably less time playing chess. Research shows that the reading and writing skills of high school students relate to the hours they have spent on reading and writing. Effective reading and writing requires a lot of practice. Students from disadvantaged environments who have fewer opportunities to learn and who miss school because of work or illness will not Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 13 be expected to do as well at school compared to children who had more time to practice and acquire information. In the classroom Many educational programmes are designed to increase one’s exposure to learning situations preferably at an early age. Here are some recommendations for teachers that can help students spend more time on learning tasks. • Increase the amount of time students spend on learning in the classroom. • Give students learning tasks that are consistent with what they already know. • Do not try to cover too many topics at once. Give students time to understand the new information. • Help students engage in ‘deliberate practice’ that includes active thinking and monitoring of their own learning. • Give students access to books so that they can practice reading at home. • Be in contact with parents so that they can learn to provide richer educational experiences for their children. Principle No.11: Children learn best when their individual differences are taken into consideration. Research findings Research shows that there are major developmental differences in learning. As children develop, they form new ways of representing the world and they also change the processes and strategies they use to manipulate these representations. In addition, there are important individual differences in learning. Developmental psychologist Howard Gardner has argued that there are many dimensions of human intelligence other than the logical and linguistic skills that are usually valued in most school environments. Some children are gifted in music, others have exceptional spatial skills (required, for example, by architects and artists), or bodily/ kinaesthetic abilities (required by athletes), or abilities to relate to other people, etc. Schools must create the best environment for the development of children taking into consideration such individual differences. In the classroom The following are recommendations for creating the best environment for the development of children, while recognizing their individual differences: • Learn how to assess children’s knowledge, strategies and modes of learning adequately. • Introduce children to a wide range of materials, activities and learning tasks that include language, mathematics, natural sciences, social sciences, art, music, movement, social understanding, etc. • Identify students’ areas of strength, paying particular attention to the interest, persistence and confidence they demonstrate in different kinds of activities. • Support students’ areas of strength and utilize these areas to improve overall academic performance. • Guide and challenge students’ thinking and learning. • Ask children thought-provoking questions and give them problems to solve. Urge children to test hypotheses in a variety of ways. • Create connections to the real world by introducing problems and materials drawn from everyday situations. • Show children how they can use their unique profiles of intelligence to solve real-world problems. • Create circumstances for students to interact with people in the community, and particularly with adults who are knowledgeable and enthusiastic about the kinds of things that are of interest to the students. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 14 Principle No.12: Learning is critically influenced by learner motivation. Teachers can help studentsbecome more motivated learners by their behaviour and the statements they make. Research findings Motivated learners are easy to recognize because they have a passion for achieving their goals and are ready to expend a great deal of effort. They also show considerable determination and persistence. This influences the amount and quality of what is learned. All teachers want to have motivated learners in their classrooms. How can they achieve this? Psychologists distinguish between two kinds of motivation: extrinsic motivation and intrinsic motivation. Extrinsic motivation results when positive rewards are used to increase the frequency of target behaviour. Praise, high grades, awards, money and food can be used for that effect. Intrinsic motivation is when learners actively participate in activities without having to be rewarded for it. The child who likes to put together puzzles for the fun of it is intrinsically motivated. An important characteristic of intrinsically motivated learners is their belief that effort is important for success. Teachers can influence students’ determination to achieve by their behaviour and the statements they make. In the classroom Teachers must use encouraging statements that reflect an honest evaluation of learner performance: • Recognize student accomplishments. • Attribute student achievement to internal and not external factors (e.g. ‘you have good ideas’). • Help students believe in themselves (e.g. ‘you are putting a lot of effort on math and your grades have muchimproved’). • Provide feedback to children about the strategies they use and instruction as to how to improve them. • Help learners set realistic goals. It is also important to: • Refrain from grouping students according to their ability. Ability grouping gives the message that ability is valued more than effort. • Promote co-operation rather than competition. Research suggests that competitive arrangements that encourage students to work alone to achieve high grades and rewards tend to give the message that what is valued is ability and diminish intrinsic motivation. • Provide novel and interesting tasks that challenge learners’ curiosity and higher-order thinking skills at the appropriate level of difficulty. (15 minutes) Expert groups discuss the principles among each other. 30minutes pair & share activity: Participants (think pair & share) to select a certain activity from the textbooks they have taught and plan to teach it based on the principles discussed above. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 15 H2: Topic 'Demonstrate understanding of child-centered methodologies of teaching and learning' (Session 3 / Slides 30-43 from the Day 1 PPT) Total estimated Time: (45 minutes) Case Study / Group work: Participants are divided into groups. Each group is handed one case study from the three case studiesbelow. (Facilitators may refer to the Facilitators' notes on description of the technique and for more information on Case Study) 10 minutes Individual activity Each participant should have to go through the case study individually, write down ideas and notes 15 minutes Discussion / Group work: Facilitator asks participants to discuss their ideas and notes regarding the case study. Then using a flip chart they write the main points for reporting to the other groups. (The facilitator reminds the groups of the importance of dividing ther roles among group members). Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 16 Case study 1 Sami teaches the third grade in Karmel School. He planned that the children, as part of the science curriculum, would learn about concepts of domestic and wild animals. The day before the lesson, he asked them to bring some pictures of animals that live in their area for the science class. He also found some pictures, as he knew that not all the children would be able to bring in a picture. In the lesson, he asked some of the class to tell him what they knew about these animals and then he asked others what they wanted to know about the animals. Many of them wanted to know about their life cycle, their habits, how to look after them and what they eat. Sami divided the class into groups of four students each and asked them to classify each of the animals into one of two groups: Animals we keep and use in different ways e.g. for meat, milk and travel. Animals we don't keep or use. He worked two examples with the students, putting the answers on the blackboard. After that, he gave each group a large piece of paper, on which he had drawn the outline of a table (see below). Sami asked them to classify the animals into two groups by placing each picture on one side of the table and writing the animal’s name next to it. He gave them 15 minutes to do the activity and asked them to choose one person to act as the group spokesperson to explain to the rest of the class what they had done. They recorded their answers in the following way: Animals we keep and use Animals we don’t keep or use Picture Picture Name Goat Name Oryx As the children worked, Sami moved around the groups listening to their discussions, supporting and encouraging them, answering questions, observing their progress, and giving feedback. After 15 minutes, Sami asked each group spokesperson to stick the group’s answers on the wall and then explain their ideas to the whole class. As they did this, Sami helped to facilitate any questions from other children. He highlighted any differences in ideas between groups and helped them agree on their answers where necessary. He then asked students to suggest a name for each group of animals and listed their answers on the board. Some of the children had used the word ‘wild’ for those that are not kept or used. But no one had used the word ‘domesticated’ and so Sami gave them this word to use for those animals that are kept and used. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 17 Case study 2 Kifah teaches Arabic to sixth grade students at UNRWA Akka Elementary School. She decided that the class would do a project on water. She knew that her class was studying water in their science class and she agreed with Reem, the science teacher, that she would use that theme for teaching Arabic. Kifah decided to begin the topic with a brainstorming session. She wrote the word ‘WATER’ in the middle of the board and then asked the children to put up their hands with ideas and words that they think about when they hear the word water. She wrote down all their answers without making any comment until there were no more answers. Before she asked the children to talk about the ideas, Kifah checked that all the children knew what the words meant and encouraged them to share their ideas about meanings of words to help each other. She then asked the children to look closely at all these answers and discuss with their neighbour whether they could link all the different ideas together and, if so, how. She gave them ten minutes to talk and then asked some of the pairs to give her one example of the links they could make or themes they could identify. She showed the links on the board using a different coloured chalk to link the words. All the children actively engaged with this. As the lesson proceeded, Kifah began to identify themes that were emerging to the children. These included: Uses of water. Dangers from water. Cultural beliefs about water. What water is like. Sources of water. Next, Kifah asked the children to work in pairs to choose one of the themes and to write a short story based around that theme. Again, she checked the children’s understanding of terms and together they shared words and phrases that could be used to describe the different features and characteristics of water. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 18 Case study 3 Kawther teaches a Grade 3 class at Al Breish elementary school in Gaza. She arranged with her head teacher to ask a local storyteller to come and tell some stories to her class. She particularly asked the storyteller to include the Al-Shater Hassan story. The children found the story very interesting and had a lot of questions for the storyteller. After thanking her, Kawther asked her class to tell her the main parts of the story, which she listed, on the board. Next, she divided her class into groups and asked them to think how they could act the whole story or any favourite part of the story. She gave them 20 minutes to sort out their ideas andpractise. Shesentsome of her class out into the playground so there was more room in the class for all to try out their ideas. She called the class together and then asked each group in turn to show what they had done so far. The children watched each group with great interest and applauded at the end. Kawther was delighted with how well they had listened and was amazed with their performance and the interesting ways the groups acted out the same incident. The children asked if they could do this again as they liked both the storytelling and acting and seemed to remember much more. In the next lesson, Kawther asked her class to draw pictures of some of the events of the story and then to write what happened. She collected these together and made them into a book, which she stapled together and put in the classroom for the children to look at and read. She gave it the title Al-Shater Hassan Story as retold by Grade 3. The class were very proud and excited to see their book! Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 19 H3: Topic 'Manage the teaching and learning process and space under conditions of emergency' (Session 4 / Slides 44-48 from the Day 1 PPT) Total Time (40 minutes: 20 minutes group work and 20 minutes feedback discussion) 20 minutes Group work: Facilitator asks participants to produce a resources grid;s/he emphasizes the need to reflect the context of emergencies in their work. Interest groups are formed for this task (Facilitators may refer to the Facilitators' notes on description of the technique and for more information on group work) Participants think about the curriculum they are teaching. Select one area of the curriculum in which you can use the local environment and community to make teaching more active and interesting. Draw a grid like the one below, except keep it blank. Brainstorm among the group various ideas how you could use the environment in different ways. You may want to do six different ideas for one area of the curriculum, rather than doing one idea for six different areas of the curriculum. Curriculum area Local resource to be used Nature of use 1. Mathematics area of the playground measuring skills 2. Art using plants as dyes making own dyes 3. Language environmental print ways adverts capture interest 4. Science 5. Geography 6. History Now pin on the wall all the charts that you and other teachers have prepared. Are there other ideas that you could use? Would you want to change some of your ideas to the ideas of a colleague? 20 minutes Individual activity Participants are asked to select a certain activity from the textbooks they have taught then plan for teaching it using the resources grid produced by the groups. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 20 Day 2 - Activities and handout Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 21 Day 2: Assessment in teaching and learning Answer to the follow questions 3. What are the keys messages of Day 1 sessions? - 2. What are your expectations for today’s sessions on assessment in teaching and learning? - Suggested expectations: Understanding of the concept, role, and different types of assessment Knowledge, understanding of and ability to efficiently use a variety of different types of questions to aid learning; Ability to provide feedback in teaching and learning. 3. What are the various activities that normally take place in the classroom? Indicate among the activities above, those related to assessment, and explain what differentiates them from the others. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 22 Definition of assessment Assessment is generally referred to as an investigation carried out before planning educational activities and intervening in an emergency to determine needs and gaps in the response as well as available resources. In the context of teaching and learning, teachers and other education personnel often measure learning outcomes by way of testing learners’ progress and achievement. An ‘assessment of learning outcomes’ is determined by and based on the curriculum of an education programme. 4. Different types of assessment Case study: SBTD hand out 20 Module 3, Unit 9 3. Case Study 20 Nabeel teaches a Grade 5 class in Syria. At the end of one week when he had been teaching about volcanoes, Nabeel wanted to find out what the children had learnt. He gave them a description of the way volcanoes develop and erupt but he left blank 20 key words that had to be filled in. Every child wrote his/her name on the paper and then proceeded to fill the gaps in. On completion they exchanged their papers with another child. Nabeelthen had a question and answer session to agree the answers and for the children to mark each other’s work. They returned the marked sheets with a count of correct answers listed at the bottom. Nabeel asked for a show of hands as to who had got more than 5 correct. Nearly all the children put their hands up. Nabeel asked them to keep their hands up if they got more than 10. He then asked them to keep their hands up if they got more than 15. As he saw the hands come down, he got an idea of who had succeeded well and who was having difficulty. He collected in the sheets so that he could see, later in the day, whether there were common errors among all the children. For homework, children had to think how they would explain the reasons why a volcano erupts to a Grade 2 child. He asked them to write notes about this and bring them to the next lesson because the following week they were going to try out their explanations. Nabeel took the volcano sheets home and, as he prepared his lessons for the following week, he looked at which children had done well and who needed more support. For his next lesson he organised the children into groups, putting stronger and weaker children together. He asked each group to work on a presentation about volcanoes for a group of Grade 2 children. Nabeel went round the groups supporting the children he had identified as needing extra support sensitively, asking questions of individuals and the group to ensure everybody understood. The children practised their presentations and Nabeel gave feedback to each group, both on the content and ways of presenting, to help them make their presentations more effective. The children in Grade 2 came to hear the presentations by the groups and Nabeel went around and listened to each one. As a consequence, Nabeel was able to judge that only two children had still not fully understood the topic.During a class reading activity the next day, he took the two children aside for ten minutes and helped them understand by asking them together to describe the process to him. Activity: Based on Nabeel’s case, Think about your own teaching. Discuss with a colleague how often you use these sorts of approaches and how do you gather information about the children in your class? Note: To be really effective, a teacher needs to challenge and enlighten his/her pupils’ thinking and understanding each and every day. In order to do this, the teacher needs to be aware of Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 23 what children already know and use this information to build and extend their knowledge and skills. Types of assessment A part from the initial assessment that can be used to determine placement or educational level of a learner, there are two main types of assessments which are often used as integral part of strengthening the teaching and learning process: Formative assessment: Continuous evaluation of learners and learning. The information collected is used to improve teaching and learning process. Teachers and other education personnel use information to modify approaches and materials to improve outcomes. Examples may include homework, oral reports, or essays. Summative Assessment: Evaluation of previous learning to determine achievement. Examinations and other methods are used to determine learner achievement and preparedness to proceed to the next levels of education. 5. Tools and methods of assessment List different tools used in assessment Teachers need to regularly use a variety of assessment tools and methods that reflect the agreed learning outcomes and their indicators. However, these assessment tools should always be adapted to reflect information needed in a specific context and environment. Following is a non-exhaustive list of tools used in the assessment of various learning outcomes, which are classified according to various criteria and indicators: Knowledge: closed questions (e.g., true-false or multiple choice questionnaires), openended questions (e.g., essays, sentence completion), analysis of a case study or fictional scenario, time lines, picture sorting, role-plays and simulations; Attitudes: closed-ended questions, open-ended questions, analysis of a case study or fictional scenario, role-plays and simulations, and scales (e.g., Likert scales, semantic differential scales and social distance scales); Skills: closed-ended questions, analysis of a case study or fictional scenario, role-plays and simulations, checklists and diaries and journals; Behavioural intent: closed-ended questions, analysis of a case study or fictional scenario, role-plays and simulations, checklists, diaries and journals and ‘intent to behave’ statements Suggestions to improve classroom assessment The following are a number of suggestions designed to improve teachers’ classroom procedures. They may also be used to inform teacher education courses. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 24 Assessment should be an integral and frequent aspect of teaching, in which questions that focus on meaningful aspects of learning are used. Teachers should develop reasonable, but challenging, expectations for all pupils, using a variety of methods in a variety of situations (e.g., essays, homework, and projects). The focus in assessment should be on diagnostic and formative aspects, rather than normative aspects (i.e., assessments that rank students on the basis of results). Teachers should ask questions that allow students display higher-order thinking skills (not just recall) and that require inferential and deductive reasoning. Pupils’ understanding of the general principles of a curriculum domain should be assessed, as well as their ability to use appropriate methods and strategies in solving problems. Readily understood and prompt feedback should be provided to students. Students’ processes (how they approach/analyse issues), not just products, should be assessed. Assessment should help students reflect on their own learning. Questions should require students to explore/expand on issues, not just repeat information. The results of assessments, when appropriate, should be communicated to parents and other interested parties (e.g., other teachers). The use of criterion-referenced tests can enrich teachers’ classroom assessment practice. Periodic administration (every few weeks) of the tests will provide information on what students have learned, when there is a need for further teaching, and identify students in need of additional help. 5. QUESTIONING TECHNIQUES TO PROMOTE A VARIED APPROACH TO CLASSROOM-BASED ASSESSMENT PRACTICE 4. INTRODUCTION Questioning is one of the most important skills that teachers learn and develop. It is a valuable tool in helping children learn and make sense of their world and it encourages deeper thinking and creativity. 5 Importance of questioning in teaching and learning 5. Activity 23 Look at the list below, which describes ten reasons for asking questions. Which do you think are most directly related to monitoring progress? 1. To arouse interest and curiosity about a topic. 2. To focus attention on a particular issue or concept. 3. To develop an active approach to learning. 4. To stimulate children to ask questions of themselves and others. 5. To structure a task in such a way that learning will be maximised. 6. To diagnose specific difficulties that prevent children from learning. 7. To communicate to the class that they are expected to be involved in the lesson. 8. To provide an opportunity for children to assimilate and reflect upon information. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 25 9. To help the development of thinking skills. 10. To express a genuine interest in the ideas and feelings of children. It is clear that 2, 5, 6 and 8 are clearly related to learning progress and the others all are related to helping children learn and to understand better how they learn. But all the ways of questioning in this list have a place in the teacher’s repertoire of questioning skills. The important thing is to be aware of which types of question need to be frequently used in order to assess learning and progress, and which types of question help learning. 6 Different types of questions Classify the following questions into two different categories according to the types of responses that they require: ‘How many days are they in one week?’ ‘Look at this photograph of oil tankers. Why do you think some are smaller than others in the picture?’ Is Dubai the capital city of Emirates? Explain the best way of drawing a square. Questions (1), and (3) can be answered with a simple statement or fact or with a ‘yes’ or ‘no’. They are close–ended questions. Closed questions are used to direct the conversation. They get specific information or confirm facts, and generally have only one answer Questions (2) and (4) encourage a variety of responses. They are open-ended questions. Open-ended questions prompts children to think more deeply about the concept or issue raised in the question and to suggest answers. Well-chosen openended questions are similar to higher-order questions, as they encourage creativity and thinking. 7 Improving questioning techniques Children learn better if the questions they are asked are demanding but within their capabilities. Questioning is therefore a technique that teachers can master through practice and experience and we need often to think if the responses that we receive from children in class are those expected from the questions that we ask in order to help them learn better. Steps to consider for improving our questioning techniques: 1. Questions need to be structured, rather like signposts that point to the correct destination. The important point is that a well-defined initial focus is an essential tactic of effective questioning. 2. Questions need to be at an appropriate level of understanding for the child or class. You will need to choose language and terminology that the children understand. 3. Questions need to be directed at extending learning and distributed around the class. 4. Questions need to be paused and paced. By allowing time for children to reflect before answering to the questions, and even after the child’s initial response the quality and length of children’s answers can improve significantly. 5. Questions need to prompt and probe. Prompts and probes are follow-up questions when the first answers a child provides are inadequate or inappropriate. They are perhaps the most important questions to develop and ‘scaffold’ children’s understanding. They are very important in formatively assessing how a child is progressing. These are questions that: rephrase the question, maybe in simpler terms; or Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 26 pick up some key points in the topic and lead back to the original question; or review the information given so far and then return to the original question. 6. Here are some examples of probing and prompting questions that you could use: Does that always apply? Can you give me an example of that? How does that fit in? Why do you think that is true? Is there another view? What is the idea behind that? Can you tell me the difference between the two? Some common errors in questioning: Asking too many questions at once. Asking a question and answering it yourself. Asking questions of only certain children (such as the ones who will know the answer). Asking a difficult question too early in a topic. Asking irrelevant questions. Always asking the same types of questions (such as ‘closed’ ones). Asking questions in a threatening way (such as shouting). Not giving children time to think. Not correcting wrong answers. Ignoring children’s answers. Failing to build on answers. Asking questions that children cannot answer. Group work: In a group of 3 to 5, discuss and list some characteristics of effective and inadequate questioning techniques. Effective questioning techniques Inadequate questioning techniques Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 27 8 5. Feedback in teaching and learning What is meant by feedback? In the teaching and learning context, feedback is giving information about a child’s success in learning during an activity, a lesson or a term, and providing support and advice on how to improve. The child needs to see the information given during feedback as useful; otherwise he/she will not act upon it. 6. Activity 21 Choose a lesson you are teaching this week. Then, as you go through the lesson, make a note of: times when you gave feedback to a child or the class about their learning progress; names of the children who received that feedback. Keep a record of your answers in your course notebook. Find a colleague on the programme in the school who has done the same exercise, and who you do not mind sharing this information with, to discuss the following questions: What percentage of children received feedback in the lesson? Could you have changed the way you gave feedback to include more children? If so, how? Could you have changed the way you gave feedback to include fewer children having more detailed feedback? If so, how? How would you ensure in future lessons that those children not receiving feedback in this lesson did not miss out? What strategies could you use to allow you to give feedback to groups rather than individuals? After your discussion, make notes in your course notebook of the different ideas you thought about together and suggest when and how you might use them. Role play: In small groups of 5-6, play the role of teacher and students, so as to practice questioning and feedback, using different areas of specialization, and note different aspects of effective way of providing feedback, and to be shared with the rest of participants in plenary. 9 How to give feedback to children Remember always that your comments should provide a prompt to help the child to move forward. A question, therefore, can be more effective at helping understanding than just giving the child the information. You might need two or three questions to elicit the understanding, but this develops a very powerful approach to teaching and learning. For example, you could say to a child, ‘This is good so far, but have you thought about which factors affect your breathing rate? You could write in your ideas about this at the end.’ Some teachers have developed sets of cards that they use when giving feedback. The cards might have some half-completed statements on, such as: Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 28 Have you thought about … Discuss this with your partner … Look in your book on page … The teacher moves quickly around the class giving out cards to some and filling in the spaces appropriately. For example, ‘Have you thought about comparing the right- and left-hand side of the table?’ Or ‘Look in your book on page 63. Look especially at the diagram.’ The children often like the idea of getting a card. And it’s a quick way for the teacher to establish a dialogue with a larger number of children. In giving feedback, it is wise to use a variety of techniques and strategies to keep children interested and to help you engage with as many children as you can. Keeping track of the feedback you give is useful – this will ensure that no child is left out and it helps you to track all the children’s progress. Try the next activity, which asks you to record your feedback activity in a lesson or two. 7. Activity 22 Draw up a chart with the names of the children in your class or a class you teach down one side and lessons you will be teaching them in the coming one or two weeks along the other side. See the example below: Name Lina Eman Lana Mariam Lesson1 √ √ Lesson 2 √ √ Lesson3 √ √* Lesson4 √* √ Total 3 4 1 0 Every time you have an individual ‘feedback’ discussion with a child put a tick against their name in the appropriate box. If the feedback was extended, that is, you had to spend more time than normal, or go back to the same child a number of times, put an asterisk against the tick. At the end of the period of time you have selected, reflect on the following questions: What percentage of the class were you able to speak to? Did the percentage you achieved ensure that you would be able to give feedback to every child within a two- or three-week period? Did you manage to speak to those who might be finding the topic difficult? Did you manage to give feedback to those finding the topic fairly easy? Were you able to give them a supplementary, more demanding, task? What types of feedback did you give? Was it helpful to the children? How do you know this? For example, did they finish the work without further help? Did they write a clear explanation that showed they understood the ideas? Plenary discussion: Reflect and discuss with a colleague on the following important findings that provide guidance on ways to enhance your skills in providing feedback. Written and oral feedback can be equally effective provided each is done in some depth. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 29 Giving praise is valuable, but praise that is specific to the task and mentions attributes of the task that have been well done is more effective than general praise. Feedback is more effective if it is focused on the task rather than the general personality of the child. Feedback on behaviour and presentation may be necessary, but it should not detract from consistent feedback on tasks. Feedback should always indicate a future action; what the child should do next, given the discussion you have had with them. Mistakes should be seen as important learning opportunities. Whole-class feedback can be helpful. For example, ‘You have all done very well this lesson. I think everyone now understands why this battle was lost.’ The child needs to see the feedback as useful, and so how you give the feedback must be sensitive to the child as a learner and person. This does not suggest that all forms of feedback can be used in every lesson or even every week. But it does say that for children to learn effectively they do need regular feedback. 8. Activity 20: Audit of your own assessment practice In the following chart there are 15 statements. Please read them and then rate yourself on each one using the following four-point scale: Mostly true (1) Often true (2) Rarely true (3) Never true (4) Now complete the chart. 10 Teacher audit of assessment practice: Checklist Please put () under the suitable heading alongside each statement. Assessment practices Mostly true 1 Often true 2 Rarely true 3 Never true 4 1. Assessment provides me with useful evidence of my pupils’ understandings, which I use to plan subsequent lessons. 2. The feedback that my pupils receive helps them improve. 3. My assessment practices help children learn independently. 4. Children are told how well they have done in relation to their own previous performance. 5. Assessment of children’s work includes comments and helpful guidance. 6. I provide guidance to help my pupils Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 30 assess their own work. 7. I identify the children’s strengths and advise them how to develop them further. 8. Children are encouraged to view mistakes as valuable learning opportunities. 9. I use questions mainly to elicit reasons and explanations from the children. 10. I keep records of individuals’ learning progress. 11. Assessment criteria are discussed with children in ways that they understand. 12. Children are given opportunities to assess one another’s work. 13. I regularly discuss with children ways they could improve how they learn. 14. Children’s learning objectives are discussed with them in way they understand. 15. Children are helped to find ways of addressing problems in their learning. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 31 Day 3 - Activities and handouts Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 32 Day 3- Prompting Numeracy and Literacy skills Discuss your expectations of day3 session with your colleagues and write them down on a flip chart. Suggested expectation are as follows: o o o Identify key numeracy and literacy concepts and skills Be able to use techniques for developing numeracy and literacy skills Understanding of cross curricular approach of teaching numeracy and literacy In cooperation with your colleagues in your group answer the following questions: What’s your definition of “learning literacy skills”? Do you think it’s important if yes why? Learning literacy skills Ability to identify, understand, interpret, create, communicate, compute and use printed materials associated with varying contexts. It involves a continuum of learning in enabling individuals to achieve their goals, to develop their knowledge and potential, and to participate fully in their community and wider society. Importance of learning literacy skills: Developing good literacy and numeracy skills among all young people is fundamental to the life chances of each individual and essential to the quality and equity of the societies. Think Pair & share: What are the techniques you know that may help develop literacy? Suggested techniques for developing literacy skills: • • • • • • • • • Innovative activities, techniques, and experiences using both oral and written language to stimulate children’s positive relationships with literacy. Quick, ongoing, informal literacy assessments. Songs, rhymes, chants, and poems. Journaling ideas. Meaningfully involve families. Classroom-proven, teacher-friendly ways to enhance the literacy development of all your students. Incorporate meaningful literacy experiences into children’s daily play Develop listening skills through the use of games, activities and classroom techniques that really work Use a variety of effective interactive writing techniques to involve students in large group writing experiences Creating a classroom where all students are involved in listening, speaking, reading, and writing Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 33 H1 35 minutes Group work: Facilitator follows the buzz-group technique; participants are divided into 4 groups.Theyare handed out one case study from the following 2 case studies. Facilitator asks participants to read, reflect and discuss their ideas and notes regarding the case study as a group, write down their comments on a flip chart, then to choose a presenter to introduce their comments in front of other groups (The facilitator reminds the groups of the importance of dividing the roles among group members). Case study 1 (case study 26/U13/M4/SBTD) Fatmeh joined Baq’aa School as an elementary teacher two years ago. She teaches science and is a teacher to a Grade 5 class. Many of her pupils have difficulties in reading from the science textbook so Fatmeh plans ways of teaching them about science that makes it easier for them to access the information in the textbook. Fatmeh planned to teach the class about the classification of animals. She started the lesson by showing the children the names of the five ‘classes’ or groups of animals with backbones (vertebrates): mammals birds fish reptiles amphibians She had written these on flashcards (strips of card with the name of one animal class on each card) and displayed them on her desk. She then gave each child a picture of an animal and then asked a child in turn to come up to the front and put the picture next to the flashcard with the name of the animal class to which they thought it belonged. Then she asked children questions about what they knew about the animal classes, the characteristics of each class and the differences between the classes. Fatmeh then divided the students into five groups and gave each group one of the animal classes. She asked them to create something, for example make up a song or design a poster to show what they knew about that animal class. Or they could draw different animals from that class and write about them, which they could then make into a book. In the next lesson, Fatmeh asked each group of students to present their work to the rest of the class. The children were really excited about the activities and some asked if they could do more work on their animal projects at home. After the topic, Fatmeh thought about the lessons and how much the children had joined in and enjoyed them. She was very surprised how much they seemed to gain from them – even those who did not normally join in much with activities. Case study 2 (case study 27/U13/M4/SBTD) Housni, an Arabic teacher in Sayda Elementary School in EinHilweh camp, has a Grade 3 class. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 34 Housni wanted his pupils to develop their literacy skills beyond the classroom. He wanted them to understand how important literacy was to all aspects of life beyond the school. To do this he developed a literacy project that would encourage his pupils to explore literacy at home and in the community. At the end of school one day, Housni asked his class to observe on their way home all the different places where they could read some text – street signs, names of shops, adverts and posters. He asked them to note down the different words they had seen. When the children came to school the next day, they shared what they had seen and Housni listed the words on the board. He then asked the children to make up sentences using the words they had collected. In the next lesson, he asked them to draw a ‘map’ of their way home with the different shops and signs they saw marked on the map. On another occasion, Housni asked his pupils to collect empty food packets (for example chips, biscuits, juice, milk), wash them out and bring them to school. At school the children had a look at the different packets and what was written on them. They learned many new words this way, such as the names of the ingredients. Another activity Housni used was based around daily newspapers, which he asked children to bring into class and which he also collected and brought in himself. He asked the children to look at a newspaper, select an article that interested them and make notes about it. He then arranged them in groups of four to six, putting children who had chosen the same article together so they could hear each other’s interpretation of the story and discuss the different ways of describing the same story. If they were different, why was this? The discussion was very lively as the children were really interested in what they had found out. He also asked all the class to comment on how clear the original newspaper articles were to read. Housni noted how well the children picked out the key points and how well they discussed the stories. He was also aware of how much their vocabulary had extended through this exercise. All these activities that Housni did in and around the normal school day captured his class’s interest. Housni was most impressed with how well the children had worked together and with their learning of so many new words. The children were also comparing what they learned with their friends and talked about the activities daily. Housni started getting more and more ideas about how to teach literacy through everyday situations. Individual activity Write five points regarding developing learning literacy skills you acquired from the previous discussions. Techniques to develop learning literacy skills: There are many ways in which you, as a teacher, can develop children’s literacy and life skills. You just need to think creatively about what you can do and be clear about what the learning intentions are for the children and then pitch your lessons at their level using appropriate resources, texts and language for them. Take your pupils to a shop, library, museum or other place in the community to expose them to reading and understanding the language around them in a different setting. If possible, show them computers, mobile phones and ways of utilising them for information sharing and communication. Encourage the children to practise writing in different ways, by writing adverts, announcements, letters, stories, factual texts and so on. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 35 You may use environmental print, that is, the print found around your school’s location, to help their literacy learning. Individual activity Answer the following questions: 1-What types of text students should interpret and understand? 2- List all the techniques that could be used with your students to help them understand and respond to information texts. Reading visual images If you think about all the kinds of information texts that you read, whether these are in the pages of textbooks, in advertising leaflets or on computer screens, they frequently include diagrams, charts, graphs, drawings, photographs or maps. To be successful as readers, we all need to understand how words, figures and images work together to present information. Many writers on education now stress the importance of visual literacy. Learning how to read and respond to photographs and drawings is one part of becoming visually literate. Reading and responding to charts, graphs and diagrams is another. Teaching reading comprehension: Reading for comprehension is central to learning to read. With younger children, it is important to help them develop skills and strategies to access the content of the simple texts they are reading. This includes expanding their vocabulary by developing their recognition and meaning of an increasing range of words. Older children need to be able to read a variety of different types of texts, such as stories, poetry, plays, information texts, charts and tables. They also need to develop skills to extract information more quickly from the text, such as being able to use headings, subheadings, bullet points and pictures or diagrams. Without such skills, children will not be able to read, for example, a social science or science text. As children become more competent readers, the skills of skimming, questioning and reviewing texts become much more important. Depending on the age of the children you teach, you will need to plan and adapt activities to match their levels and skills in reading. Young children may, for example, only pick out key words in a short text to help them skim for meaning, whereas older children would be able to pick out key phrases and significant indicators from headings, subheadings, pictures and charts to gain an overview of the text’s main ideas. Summarisingis a key skill for reading and thinking. It can be one way to assess children’s reading comprehension, but being able to summarise can also help the reader to come to a new understanding of a text. Children who can summarise effectively can learn more efficiently. But what is summarising? And how can we teach it? At its most basic, summarising is the process of condensing a text or an experience into statements of the most important ideas. Children can be taught these skills from an early stage, but activities to teach these skills need to be appropriate to their age. Summarising requires a reader to select the important ideas, ignore irrelevant information and paraphrase the author’s words. For young children, this could be asking a child to tell retell a story orally to the rest of the class. It is best to start by asking children to summarise texts they are familiar with and move into more unknown texts as they become more skilled. This same kind of activity could be done collaboratively with a group or with the whole class, where children work together with the teacher ‘scaffolding’ the process in the early stages until the children fully understand it. To summarise a text, a reader needs to thoroughly understand what the author is saying. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in 36 Emergencies and Recovery It is easy to see why summarising is so often used as a measure of reading comprehension. But it is also a way of synthesising the key points of a text. Asking a child to write a summary of a short text can provide some interesting insight into how that child is reading and processing text. For example, some children will become side-tracked by details that are so interesting that they pull the reader away from the main ideas. These readers will need help with selecting the most important information from the text. Skimming and scanning we adjust our reading speed and technique depending on our purpose. If we are searching for specific information, looking for clues, or reviewing information we skim read the text or scan it for key words. These are skills that children need to develop, as without them it is difficult to move forward as children progress from primary to secondary school. H2 30 minutes Group work & role play: Participants are handed out one case study from the following 2 case studies. Facilitator asks participants to reflect and discuss their ideas and notes regarding the case study as a group, then to choose two members to role play as two teachers discussing the case study & the comments regarding the case study in front of others. Case study 1 (case study 28/U14/M4/SBTD) At a teacher’s workshop in Irbid, Jordan, teachers of Arabic as a mother language were asked to read a ‘nonsense’ text and answer questions on it. The first sentence in this text was: ‘ ’أقمتبأرضمصرفالورائيتخببيالمطيوالأماميand the first ‘comprehension’ question was ‘Who was the speaker in this line of the poem?’ Every teacher knew that the answer was ‘I’. In their discussion, the teachers realised they could give the ‘correct’ answer because they know that in Arabic ‘I’ was the subject of this sentence. They didn’t need to know who or what ‘I’ was, in order to give the answer. The teachers also realised that the question did not help their understanding of the text! After the discussion, they worked in small groups to design questions and tasks to help them know whether or not children had really understood the texts on which their questions and tasks were based. They learned that questions should not require children to just copy information from one sentence in the text for their answer. The teachers instead designed tasks in which children had to complete a table, design a poster or make notes to use in a debate, and listed the kinds of questions they would ask in order to assess their pupils’ understanding. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 37 Case study 2 (case study 29/U14/M4/SBTD) Hadiya likes to make each pupil in her Grade 6 class of 30 children feel special. In her classroom she has a large sheet of paper with the month and day of each pupil’s birthday. On each birthday, the children sing ‘Happy Birthday’ to their classmates. One day, a pupil commented that in some months they sing the birthday song much more often than in other months. Hadiya decided to use this comment to do some numeracy and visual literacy work on pie charts. First, she asked the children to work in pairs to look at the big sheet and work out how many children had their birthday in each month. She then wrote the names of the months on the board and as a class they agreed on the final numbers. She wrote the number of children that had their birthday in each month next to the name of the month (e.g. January – 1, February – 3, and so on). Next she drew a large circle on the board and told children to imagine that this was a pie and that as there were 30 in the class there would be 30 sections in the pie, one for each pupil. The sections would join to make slices. There would be 12 slices, because there are 12 months in a year. Each slice would represent the number of children who had their birthday in a particular month, so each slice would likely be a different size. She began with the month with most birthdays – September. Children quickly got the idea of making 12 slices of different sizes within the circle to represent the number of birthdays in each month as a percentage of the class. Each child drew a circle and then divided the circle into 30 sections – one for each child (each section was 12 degrees on a protractor). They were then asked to make each slice a different colour to clearly show what proportion of children had birthdays in a certain month. The class talked about other information they could use and put into a pie chart. They decided to explore how many children played different sports, how many supported each team in the national soccer league and how many children spoke a different language. Different groups of children worked on the different pie charts and their final charts were displayed for all to see. The children were very interested in the range of information they could easily gather from the charts and they liked the fact that the information was based on their own lives. Group work: Discuss the concept of numeracy and its importance among your group, and write down the agreed upon definition. What is numeracy and why it is important? What does it mean when someone is said to be numerate and what does it mean to be numerate in this increasingly digital age? One definition states that ‘we are numerate if we have developed the confidence and competence in using number which will allow us to solve problems, analyse information and make informed decisions based on calculations’ (Scottish Government, Curriculum for Excellence: Building the Curriculum 4: Skills for learning, Skills for life, Skills for work, 2009). Being numerate enables a person to function in everyday life and contribute effectively to society. It also increases their opportunities within the world of work and establishes secure mathematical foundations, which can be built upon through lifelong learning. Being numerate is an important fundamental life skill that permeates all aspects of our life – from doing the weekly shopping, to arranging a mortgage or bank loan, to finding a job. Being numerate is another form of literacy – it helps us to become more financially literate. Financial literacy involves being able to understand money and manage it wisely so that children may grow into financially responsible adults, free from the anxieties of debt and secure in their future. Being able to interpret numerical information appropriately, for example to check if there is enough money for the rent or to travel to school, and use such information to draw Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 38 conclusions, assess risk and make informed decisions about money matters is crucial to survival in a fiscal world. Numeracy can be defined as a proficiency, which involves confidence and competence with numbers and measures. It requires an understanding of the number system, a repertoire of computational skills and an inclination and ability to solve number problems in a variety of contexts. Numeracy also demands practical understanding of the ways in which information is gathered by counting and measuring, and is presented or represented in graphs, diagrams, charts and tables. Numeracy includes: understanding the number concept and number system (ones, tens, hundreds, thousands); understanding and using mathematical symbols; being able to compare numbers; mastering basic number operations (addition, subtraction, multiplication, division); measurement (time, distance, area, weight, volume etc.); money; geometry; reading and explaining data, graphs, diagrams, charts; logical reasoning; mental arithmetic; estimation and rounding; fractions, decimal fractions and percentages. These areas and skills relate to the whole curriculum and can be practised across all subjects and used in a range of contexts and situations. For example, being able to find the area of a shape mathematically enables a person to calculate how much paint is needed to decorate a wall or how many vegetables can be sown in a field. In the same way that being able to read is essential, being numerate is crucial to life in this digital age. The importance of using games in teaching numeracy: Using games to develop mathematical knowledge and skills can be both challenging and enjoyable. To make classes enjoyable, many mathematics teachers already employ games – some of which are numerically based and allow practice of the four rules of addition subtraction, multiplication and division, and others that are more conceptually based, such as exploring the properties of the movement of air. For example, with this last idea, a simple board game could be made where each player throws a dice and then moves their counter along a pathway on the board towards a winning point. When the student stops on a particular square on the board, they have to answer a question about the properties of air. If they answer correctly, then they can move on. If they do not answer correctly, they have to miss a turn before they can throw the dice and move along the board again. One student reads the questions out and has the answers. As well as helping children learn new things, games can also play a part in just making many lessons fun and learning stimulating. Whatever topic you are teaching, such as the reasons for Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 39 the decline of the Roman Empire in history or the table of elements in science, games can become a part of your classroom strategies for children to learn new ideas, practise skills or consolidate their thinking. Evidence suggests that games enable learners to work at higher levels. Asplin (2003) noted in her study that simply playing a game as a time-filler or casually was not sufficient to improve mental computation skills. The author argued that if a game is deemed worthy of playing, then it should be elevated from the status of a time-filler or activity for early finishers to an integral part of the teaching sequence. Asplin went on to note that in a class where the teacher encouraged students to describe orally their moves in any game they were playing, and where the children were grouped according to ability, gains in mental computation ability were much higher. Most children have a natural desire to win and this encourages them to look at the problem or game in different ways and so extend their thinking. The discussion that occurs within the group playing the game is often more task focused than in an ordinary mathematics lesson. The players are also encouraged to use mental arithmetic more. For example, when playing a game about the properties of different kinds of triangle, pupils may need to work out the size of the angles in an equilateral triangle. Listening to the talk as they try to work out the angles will give insight into what they understand. Do they know that the internal angles of an equilateral triangle add up to 180°and therefore each angle would be 180° divided by 3 i.e. 60° for each angle? As games do not often have written outcomes, there have to be other ways to measure children’s achievement. The next section explores this further. First, read the Case Study, which shows how Aasif shares his experience with his colleagues during a school professional development session. H3 45 minutes Group work: Participants are handed out one case study from the following 2 case studies. - Facilitator asks participants who choose case study 1 to reflect and discuss their ideas and notes regarding the case study as a group, write down their comments on a flip chart, then to choose a presenter to introduce their comments in front of other group -Facilitator asks the other groups who choose case study 2 to write a dialogue based on text1 in favour of or against promoting numeracy skills through educational games, then to present what they prepared in front of others (The facilitator reminds the groups of the importance of dividing the roles among group members). Case study 1 (case study 32/U16/M4/SBTD) Sawsan teaches Grade 2 at Asma Elem Co Ed B School in Gaza. Sawsan was planning work to develop her pupils’ knowledge and understanding of the multiplication tables for 3, 4 and 5. She had spent some time using number charts with her pupils to work out the multiples in each table and now she wanted her class to become quicker at being able to use these tables. She talked with the school mathematics coordinator who suggested she used a game to help the children. At first, Sawsan was not too sure about this as she thought the children would not learn as easily or concentrate very well. However, she listened to the instructions as to how to play a kind of bingo that the maths coordinator gave her. She took a set of Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in 40 Emergencies and Recovery the bingo cards and the counters that he had made to use with his class to her own home to try it out for herself with her own children. In this way, she was prepared for what she was going to do and say in class and how she was going to organise the classroom and seat the children. The next day, Sawsan arrived early at school and made sure the desks were organised for group work. She wanted the children to sit in groups of eight to play and she put a set of cards out for each group. After registration, Sawsan told the class they were going to play a game and, of course, they were very excited. She explained the rules and told them that one person was to be the ‘caller’ and the rest needed a bingo card to play. She gave each caller a card containing multiplication tables from 1-5, then the other students in the group need to know the result. 1x2 1x3 1x4 1x5 2x2 2x3 2x4 2x5 3x2 3x3 3x4 3x5 4x2 4x3 4x4 4x5 5x2 5x3 5x4 5x5 6x2 6x3 6x4 6x5 7x2 7x3 7x4 7x5 8x2 8x3 8x4 8x5 9x2 9x3 9x4 9x5 10x2 10x3 10x4 10x5 All the players had a card like the following, in which each number was an answer to one of the caller’s results. 12 9 45 20 18 16 27 32 As each result was called out, the children had to look at their bingo cards to see if they had the answer. If they had the answer they would cover it with a counter. The first person to cover their entire card with counters called out ‘Bingo!’ Their bingo card was checked and if the child had covered all numbers that reflected the answers of the results called out then that child was the winner. The group then changed the caller and played again. They played until everyone had had a go as caller, and then Sawsan stopped the class and asked if they had enjoyed the experience. The answer was a unanimous ‘Yes!’ Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 41 She then asked them to think what mathematics they had been learning and if playing the game had helped them. Sawsan was very impressed with their thoughtful answers and reflections on how much they had learnt without realising it. They asked if they could play again and Sawsan said they would do it every morning for the next week after registration, which they did. At the end of the week, she returned the set to the maths coordinator but planned to make a new set to keep in the maths corner of the classroom so the children could play it with their friends at playtime if they wished. Case study 2 (case study 33/U16/M4/SBTD) Aasif had been using games in his class for some time, especially in mathematics, as he saw the benefit to the pupils when they played such games. The head teacher had been to see his class playing maths games and asked Aasif to share his ideas with the staff at a meeting to look at interactive ways of working in the classroom. Aasif realised that many of his colleagues would be worried about how they would know what the children were learning if they used games and would be concerned that they would lose control of their classes. He decided to start by playing a simple number bond game with the staff for just a few minutes and then asked them to think about what they might learn from playing the game. There was much discussion about this and all the teachers agreed that the game provided time to practise skills in a supportive environment. They also talked of how they had enjoyed playing together and could see the benefit for the pupils. However, they did ask how this would allow them to assess children’s achievement. Aasif explained that when the children were playing games, he moved around the class and watched and listened to what the children were doing and saying. He told his colleagues that he found this a very useful way to identify problems and would sometimes spend time talking these through with the group or with the whole class if it was a common mistake or problem. But also he told the staff how he noticed children who were not very sure or confident, and was able to help them as they played. Sometimes he said he organised the whole class to play a game but with pairs acting as a single player. This method, he noted, was particularly helpful if the game was new and introducing quite difficult ideas and concepts, because each person could support the other as they decided on the answers or on what move to make. He also showed his colleagues his record book, in which he recorded observations on each student about their achievements in each game. Here he also included children’s own comments on their ability and understanding with regard to the games. He said how he had found out from this how much the children were able to assess their own competence and understanding. Finally, he offered the staff the use of the small set of different games he had made to try in their own classes and suggested they could all talk about their experiences at the next staff meeting in a month’s time. Individual Activity: Write down 5 points to show the advantages of using games in teaching numeracy skills? Answer the following question: What is meant by cross curricula approach? Cross curricular studies cut through traditional subject matter lines and explore relationships of subjects to one another. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 42 For example, "writing across the curriculum" entails teaching writing in every subject-matter. Teachers of all arts and science develop and implement a writing program in their subjects that coordinates with the other writing programs throughout the school. In traditional writing programs, those that are not cross curricular, writing is taught only in English classes, and teachers in other subjects depend on English language to teach the skills that students need to write in all other subjects. Cross curricula approach in teaching numeracy: is not perceived as easy to teach by most teachers and many may feel that they need more support to teach numeracy than literacy, perhaps because they themselves did not like maths at school. However, developing numeracy across the curriculum provides opportunities for children to improve their accuracy and learn how to interpret information. Learning how to present information in a quantitative way and develop children’s problem solving and thinking skills goes beyond just the mathematics lessons. Making learning numeracy across the curriculum a success needs the support of all teachers if it is to be effective and have an impact on children’ learning. As a teacher, it is important for you to know the key areas of numeracy in order to explore within your subject the opportunities for extending and complementing numeracy teaching and learning in mathematics lessons. All teachers have a responsibility for promoting numeracy. For example, in social studies, the teacher could present a map of a country to children and ask them to estimate the distance between two cities or to determine which is farther from, for example, Amman – Irbid or Zarqa? Or a science teacher could ask pupils to measure the difference in size between different species of snails that can be found in the local area. The following are examples of how numeracy concepts and skills can be applied in other subjects: History: includes concept of time, concept of number and dates, sequencing events and dates, understanding and comparing large numbers, using a timeline, logical reasoning. For example, being able to sequence numbers and dates will help a child be able to see why some events such as the start of a war happened. Science: includes making measurements, collecting data, comparing, and interpreting data, graphs and diagrams, estimation, logical reasoning. For example, asking children to measure the extension of a spring with different weights will involve them in various measuring tasks and devising ways of recording their results. Social studies: includes such ideas as concept of time, collecting data, comparing, and interpreting data, graphs and diagrams, estimation, logical reasoning, practical application of mathematics in everyday life (such as percentage calculations and dealing with money). Arabic: includes reading and writing numbers, learning to read the clock, learning about money. English: includes reading and writing numbers, time and measurement concepts in English. Vocational education and training: includes making measurements (distance, area, volume, timing), geometry (shapes), and estimation. For example, asking children to estimate how much of each material they will need to tile a floor and then working out the actual cost helps them to see how to judge the possibility of being able to afford to do the job. Physical education: includes number concept, measurements, and practical activities of measuring distance. Children can measure heartbeat and pulse rates and recovery rates to judge their fitness. Arts: includes geometry (shapes), perspective. Understanding how shapes tessellate will help children design their own patterns in traditional styles. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 43 Religion: time concept, practical situations in which you need numeracy such as events like funerals. H4 20 minutes Group work: Participants are handed out the following case study. Facilitator asks participants to reflect and discuss their ideas and notes regarding the case study as a group and to write down their comments on a post-it note.They are then asked to stick it on a flip chart on the board. Participants should move to the board and read all the pinned post-it notes and write down new ideas they haven’t recorded themselves. Case study 1 (case study 31/U16/M4/SBTD) Following a staff meeting that focused on how teachers could help children become more confident and competent in numeracy, Rhagda, a science teacher, was working on her planning for the next term. She was trying to identify key points on the topic on Forces where she could support the new school initiative of emphasising numeracy across the curriculum. She was aware that often, for example, she had to help some of her Grade 6 children with the calculations needed to do the science tasks. In the past, she just waited until the problem arose, but this time she planned lesson time to show the children how to do the necessary calculations once they had made their measurements. Before the lesson, she checked with the head of mathematics the agreed method for the calculations she planned to do. She then set up two examples for the start of the lesson that would show the children how to do the measuring and discussed with them how to make a table to record their results in such a way that it would make it easier for the children to interpret their findings. The pupils were introduced to a problem and the maths needed through a story that Raghda had written about how the spring of a toy broke. The children’s task was to discover what spring would be best for a new toy. Raghda helped them devise their tests and decide what measurements they needed to test the stretch and strength of the springs. She provided them with different springs and range of objects to test the springs. The outcome was that the children were very focused as they worked in groups and shared the tasks. Rahgda was amazed and very pleased at the quality of work from the children. During their plenary discussion of the task, she listened carefully to how they decided which the strongest spring was. The children discussed with Raghda how they measured the extension of their springs, and some of the problems they had in measuring such a moveable object as accurately as possible. Raghda questioned each group about their methods and the mathematics they had done and was impressed at the level of understanding they showed. She was particularly pleased how many children whom she normally thought did not like number and mathematics were able to talk coherently about their findings. They had also learnt how to change just one variable as they did their tests to make sure it was a ‘fair’ test and that their measuring skills were accurate. 30 minutes Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 44 Group Activity Participants are asked to implement the following activity, facilitator should make sure that each trainee has implemented the activity, and then choose one of the trainees to present and discuss his example with the trainees as a whole. Activity 1 (activity 35/U15/M4/SBTD) Plan an activity for one lesson with a special focus on finding out about children’s mathematical competency. Look at what you intend to teach the following week and identify a lesson that will involve children using their numeracy skills. You will need to ensure that the activity you plan will allow the children to achieve your intended learning outcomes, for example being able to calculate percentages of exports of particular crops from Jordan to compare with the exports of other countries. Using group or pair work will enable children to talk through their ideas and help them think more deeply about the task. When planning a lesson to find out students’ mathematical competence in a particular area, consider the following steps: What numeracy skills will the children need to understand? (For example, working out percentages.) Find out if your children have already practised the skill in mathematics. Use this information to plan your lesson. (For example, plan to do some percentage sums and use data about crops as context.) Think of how to apply the numeracy concept in a real situation to show children the importance and relevance of mathematics. (For example, set a problem or question for children to find out what the biggest export crops from Jordan are.) Plan what resources you need to use. (For example, data about crop production in Jordan and exports of each crop.) Make sure you give the children time to explore and practise. (For example, show children how to work out the percentage of each crop that is exported in order to compare Jordan’s exports with those of another country.) What kind of evidence will you gather to show what the children have learnt? You could listen to them as they are talking, make notes of their discussion, look at their plans, and/or look at their final outcome – whether this is a written account, a poster, an artefact they have made, or a presentation of what they did. What criteria will you use to judge their achievements in your subject and in numeracy? Make notes of your answers to these questions in your Course Notebook and think how you might develop your support within your subject area to help children be numerically confident and competent. Training Manual for Effective Teaching and Learning in Emergencies and Recovery 45 9. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. References and resources School Based Teacher Development programme materials, UNRWA, 2011 INEE materials UNESCO materials: 'How children learn'. SPRED material: 'Collective Learning'. ' http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/studentlife/revisionandskills/skills/debating_skills.shtml http://teachertools.londongt.org/?page=classroomQuestioningSkills http://712educators.about.com/od/teachingstrategies/a/Effective-Teacher-Questioning-Techniques.htm EiE Teacher Training 46