First Presentation
Group
Leadership
Summary
1
91
88
Focus on findings, not process of analysis;
Disjointed, integrate the readings; reflections?
2
83
90
Missing important elements of the readings;
needs more reflection
3
92
85
Disjointed; relevance of first article?; emphasis
on individual masks the readings’ findings
4
92
90
Reactions are not detailed; observations not
integrated; too long
5
93
94
1
95
88
Little depth
2
90
88
Misses main points of articles; rushed; LGBT is
not a chosen lifestyle, and articles did not
present it as such
3
97
97
Excellent summary (one voice, finds most
important issues, and sees themes across
articles); lacks adequate reflection by group
4
94
90
Lengthy review; little attention to themes
across articles; grammar and spelling issues
5
94
96
Nice integration of articles, reflection
1
94
78
Missing summary of readings
2
88
90
Poor writing; little reflection
3
93
98
Good summary and integration
4
89
97
Nice summary; needs more integration
5
95
88
poor writing; lacks integration, reflection
Make-up/Extra credit 97
95
Nice work
Second Presentation
Third Presentation