TRANSMISSION LINE PATROLLING PROTOCOL/GUIDELINES FOR NORTHERN REGION 1. Background Hon'ble Commission in its Order on Petition No. 146/MP/2013 with IA 36/2013 dated 20.02.2014 had pointed out that there were instances of Grid disturbance due to nonclearance of bushing/jungle clearance or non-trimming of tree branches within the RoW to transmission lines periodically. 2. Transmission Line Patrolling Protocol/Guidelines for NR-NRPC Regular and Periodic maintenance of transmission system is of utmost importance for its uninterrupted operation. All the Power Utilities have their own set procedure. State-of-theArt Operation and Maintenance Practices that includes state of art condition monitoring techniques, Live Line monitoring and maintenance, Disaster Management System etc. need to be initiated. Trees and power lines are not a good mix. One tree limb may cause a "blackout" that cut power to million people in the country. Patrolling and tree trimming/removal or jungle clearance shall always be part of maintenance of Transmission Licensee to eliminate potential hazards. The patrols, which could be done by helicopter or "foot" patrols, will include trimming and removal of trees within the power line right-of-way. This effort will ensure a reliable electric system while protecting the public safety for customers throughout the Region. By maintaining an appropriate clearance in the power line right-of-way, we can reduce tree-related power outages. Trees and limbs falling on power lines cause power outages and disruptions of electric system. Trees too close to power lines can provide a path for electricity to reach the ground, which can result in property damage or serious injury to anyone touching the tree. Therefore in order to avoid any unforeseen, it is necessary to have transmission line patrolling protocol/guidelines which shall also take into account the terrain, forest cover and reach in that area and ensure regular monitoring as per requirement in that area to ensure efficient operation. Proper maintenance of transmission lines help to reduce scheduled outages and increase the stability and reliability of power system. Systematic and regular maintenance works is a pre-requisite for a healthy power system. 3. Patrolling Guidelines to be followed A detailed schedule of patrolling is to be chalked out for each line by various levels (From Work man to Executive). The person carrying out patrolling has to check various items as per the standard check list and indicate the same in the format. These checks, the next level person verifies, when he goes for patrolling. 3.1 Categorization: Transmission lines shall be patrolled at periodicity depending upon the terrain and different patrolling schedules shall be implemented by the transmission licensees for normal sections, vulnerable sections/terrains and most vulnerable sections/terrain. Most Vulnerable Section/Terrain: Transmission lines i. passing through coastal, forest, high/fast tree growth areas ii. Passing through areas prone to flux/soil erosion/hilly tracts/ level crossings iii. Passing through areas change of river course/ critical due to flood/ critical land sliding iv. Very heavy polluted areas Vulnerable Section/Terrain: Transmission lines i. emanating from generating stations ii. of 765 kV, 400 kV and 220/230 kV(Critical lines) iii. of Multiple circuit lines iv. prone to theft v. Heavy/medium polluted areas Normal Sections: Transmission line sections not prone to frequent defects and not covered under above vulnerable and most vulnerable sections Each transmission utility would categorize each of the line with the above criteria and furnish the details to NRPC/NRLDC. Some lines could be categorized under different category however location details, Ckm under different category would be furnished. New elements details would be furnished as and when they are commissioned. 3.2 Frequency of Patrolling SL. No. Section/Terrain Frequency and by whom 1 Normal Quarterly by Junior Staff Six monthly by Yearly by Senior Executive Engineer 2 Vulnerable Bi-Monthly (Once in two months) by Junior Staff Once in four months by Senior Engineer Half Yearly by Executive 3 Most Vulnerable Monthly by Junior Staff Quarterly by Senior Engineer Half Yearly by Executive 3.2.1 The patrolling schedules for ground inspection of live lines and tower top inspection of de-energized lines shall be separately issued by the licensees. Patrolling and condition monitoring of the lines shall be done both by inspection from ground using visual and thermal instruments as well as tower top inspections. 3.2.2 Tower top patrolling shall be done for the transmission lines categorized under Most Vulnerable Section/terrain under live condition or during shut down. 3.2.3 The important lines shall be inspected by senior engineers after patrolling by junior staff and maintenance works such as tree cutting and replacement of damaged insulators shall be carried out immediately after patrolling, wherever required. 3.2.4 Patrolling would be ensured up to switch yard of generating stations/switch yards of other transmission utilities wherever applicable. Necessary cooperation would be ensured by respective utilities. 3.3 Patrolling Check list Patrolling check list would cover at least the following points. However, the transmission utility would add additional check points as per requirement. A. Clearance of Trees, Shrubs etc: • Check adequacy of clearance of trees, shrubs, bushes, etc., from line conductor • Cut all trees, bushes, shrubs which infringe on clearance • Check grass growth on boundary wall of farms, which can grow to a height to infringe clearance B. Towers: • • • • • • • • • • Check the back filling/soil removal of foundation of Tower. Check the concrete of chimney for cracks. For tower location, provided with revetment ensure that retaining wall is neither broken nor in danger of falling. Check earthing of tower. Check all tower members are intact, in place and not damaged. Check galvanizing / painting of tower members are in proper condition. Check there is no corrosion of any part of tower/ hardware. Check anti climbing devices and barbed wiring are fixed and are in place. Check the number plate, danger board, phase plate and circuit plate. Clear all bird nests on tower / cross arms. C. Insulator and Hardware: • Check flash over / chipped insulators. • Test insulators by Hot line method once in a year for healthiness of insulators. • Replace failed insulators. • Check arcing horns for loose connections. • Check vibration dampers • Check jumpers connections by thermo vision camera by hot line staff. • Check armour rods of suspension clamps. • Check jumper connections at tension point, suspension clamps. • Check earth bond provided on suspension and tension hardware of earth wire. D. Conductor and Earth Wire • • Check for visible damages like cut strands, deposits, burn marks. Check midspan joint of conductor / ground wire damage of conductor and ground wire strands. 3.4 Patrolling reporting/ record Each transmission utility would furnish the annual schedule of patrolling to NRPC/NRLDC along with annual outage data by October each year. Compliance report of the patrolling/maintenance carried out during previous month with respect to schedule would be furnished to NRPC/NRLDC in the OCC meeting 4. Maintenance 4.1 Each line would be maintained as per the following schedule. Area Frequency Forest/ High growth /Very heavy polluted Once every four (4) months. It would be ensured in the months of May/June before monsoon Heavy / Medium polluted Once in every four (4) months. It would be ensured in month of November just before winter Coastal Once in every four (4) months. It would be ensured in month of February just before summer Light polluted Once in six months. It would be ensured in month of November just before winter Lines emanating from Generating Stations Once in six months Balance(not covered above) Once in a year 4.2 Maintenance and cleaning of various equipment fittings, accessories, primary instruments and sensors shall be carried out when they are de-energized during the shutdown of main equipment so as to minimize shutdown time. 4.3 Where defects are observed through condition monitoring or during patrolling and inspection, the maintenance work/attending works on various items of equipment may be advanced depending on the condition of the equipment. 4.4 Pruning of tree branches and clearing of vegetation within the Right of Way and up to 10m away from Right of Way and sectioning of vegetation around the tower footing shall be carried out frequently in a continuous manner. 4.5 The maintenance responsibility would be clearly spelt out for the lines terminating at switch yards of generating stations/other transmission utilities. Maintenance would be ensured as per the above schedule. 4.6 Maintenance records: The records of all maintenance carried out for each transmission line shall be kept in the table formats in electronic form and hard copy and the next due date for maintenance of each item of work shall be clearly marked in such tables and formats. 4.7 Duration of Outages: All the planned maintenance would be completed within 8 hours in day. All the transmission utilities would arrange for additional man power to meet the requirement. Only in extreme contingency planned maintenance would be permitted for two days or more after the approval from the OCC forum. 4.8 Maintenance of Tools and Equipment The maintenance staff shall be made aware of the list of tools, devices and equipment for various maintenance and rectification works on transmission lines and the tools shall be made readily available and certified for usage. 4.9 Inventory control and spare part management- The required spare parts shall be kept in stock, to ensure speedy the maintenance of the equipment. Computerized materials management system shall be developed by the Entities to optimize inventory. 4.10 Identified defects during patrolling would be closed by maintenance as per the line schedule / requirement and it would be recorded. During next visit by senior staff/executive, he would ensure all patrolling points have been cleared. 5. Maintenance/Patrolling Audit a) An internal committee may be established by the Entities to verify whether actual maintenance/patrolling works are carried out for the over head transmission line in compliance of the RPC Guidelines and procedures/policy of the transmission company. b) The observations of the Committee shall be put up to the management of the Entity for perusal and taking corrective action, if any. 6. Disaster management. a) The maintenance staff shall be trained in disaster management and a detailed procedure for the same shall be developed by the Entity and displayed prominently b) This detailed procedure shall be reviewed periodically and also based on mock exercises carried out by the Entity. c) The maintenance staff shall be trained in emergency restoration procedures for managing major failures and breakdowns. d) The equipment including vehicles, diesel generating sets and firefighting equipment and Emergency Restoration System for transmission lines shall be kept available at sub-station or at appropriate location for disaster management. 7. Failure analysis a) All failures of equipment and tower collapse shall be analyzed by the Entity to avoid recurrence and a copy of the report shall be submitted to the Regional Power Committee (RPC) and Central Electricity Authority (CEA). b) CEA may appoint a group of experts for investigation and analysis and the representatives of manufacturers may be invited to participate in such analysis. c) All relevant data which may help the group of experts in analyzing the failures shall be furnished by the respective Entities. d) The recommendations of the group of experts shall be submitted to the CEA and the recommendations accepted by the CEA shall be implemented and circulated to all within the organization and to other concerned organizations to prevent recurrence of similar failures. 8. Training. a) Every person involved in operation and maintenance of transmission lines shall be trained at the induction level and at least once in a year. b) The maintenance personnel of every entity shall be trained in preventive and breakdown maintenance of various equipment and the personnel shall be trained in various detailed maintenance procedures. **********