Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Subject: History Drawing on two topics: Topic 1 Investigating History and Topic 4 Optional Study: The Shaping of the Modern World Target group: Stage 4 (Year 7) Key concepts: The key concepts students explore are that: Multiple histories can be written about any single person or event because history can be recorded from a number of perspectives – there is not one history. When studying the past, it is important to notice which groups were powerful and which groups were disempowered and why. When analysing information from a website, it is important to evaluate the expertise and perspective of the author, and to discover its purpose, audience, context and bias. Lessons: Multiple histories: The life and times of Lachlan Macquarie Estimated duration: Approximately 10 hours. Teachers select appropriate activities. Teacher librarians will welcome the opportunity to collaborate. Why does the learning matter? The learning matters because: It assists students to develop a critical understanding of the past including the fact that there are different perspectives and interpretations of the past. Critical literacy skills assist students to understand and appreciate social, cultural, and historical contexts, and to participate as active and informed citizens. Critical literacy skills are crucial in allowing students to effectively analyse, evaluate and use information from a variety of sources. Quality Teaching: Substantive communication; Problematic knowledge Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Targeted outcomes A student: 4.5 identifies the meaning, purpose and context of historical sources 4.7 identifies different contexts, perspectives and interpretations of the past 4.9 uses historical terms and concepts in appropriate contexts 4.10 selects and uses appropriate oral, written and other forms, including ICT, to communicate effectively about the past Through their study of Governor Lachlan Macquarie, students learn about: the process of historical inquiry o o o o o o fact and opinion the usefulness of sources as evidence including a website differing perspectives the historical context of the person, group or event the significance of the person, group or event the impact of the person, group or event on the modern world Teachers can use relevant activities from the Multiple histories Smart notebook and not attempt every task. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Through their study of Governor Lachlan Macquarie,students learn to: ask historical questions o o o o o o distinguish between fact and opinion draw some conclusions about the usefulness of sources including a website examine differing historical perspectives and interpretations identify significant people of the past explain why the person, group or event was significant within the context of the period studied explain the impact of the person, group or event in shaping the modern world. Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Content Overview Lachlan Macquarie’s achievements and legacy as Governor of NSW – from the perspective of his admirers. These include having a vision for a free settler colony, rehabilitation of emancipists, extensive building programs, opening up of pastoral land, use of the holey dollar etc Lachlan Macquarie’s account of crossing the Blue Mountains When Macquarie appointed emancipist lawyers as magistrates – the consequences of this action, Macquarie as a controversial figure in the colony Lachlan Macquarie’s encounters with Aboriginal people Dispossession; Aboriginal resistance and resilience Convicts and women: some stories from Macquarie’s period Objects from Macquarie’s time as governor. Skills Overview Students will be investigating history and learning historical skills. They will: identify the content, origin, purpose and context of historical sources, including ICT sources draw conclusions about the usefulness of sources distinguish between fact and opinion identify perspectives and interpretations of the past recognise that historians may interpret events differently interpret history within the context of the actions, values, attitudes and motives of people from the past. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. Explain to students that these lessons will look at the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie from a number of perspectives. 2. Explain that the class will complete some but not all tasks. 3. Explain that selected tasks will be introduced, discussed and modelled for the whole class [with an IWB or data projector]. Students will then work individually, in pairs or in groups to complete the task. Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback for students throughout unit of work Smart notebook page Class discussion about what they already know about Lachlan Macquarie. Class discussion and mind map about places in NSW with Macquarie in the name. For each notebook page: Explain that students will need to Move the images or boxes to see the writing underneath. Read each task and click on the text access any linked sites. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. Ask students to identify the various groups living in the NSW colony in Macquarie’s time (soldiers, convicts, women, Aboriginal people, servants, free settlers, emancipists). 2. Explicitly teach students the fact that each group would had a different view of Macquarie and there would have been varying opinions within each group. 3. Create graphic overview posters for the wall, containing the groups. As students learn about different perspectives on Macquarie, they will add information to the posters. Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback for students Many histories Students create graphic overview posters – they add information to these throughout the unit. Students record definitions and practical, contemporary examples of multiple histories and the need for critical literacy. 4. Explain and discuss the concepts of multiple histories and critical literacy, using contemporary or historical examples that students may connect with - for example was Ned Kelly a hero or a villain? Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. Timeline task: Students learn about and timeline the life and achievements of Macquarie. 2. Persuasive wordle: Students read Nathan Rees’ praise of Macquarie in M2009-08 Governor Lachlan Macquarie and Mrs Elizabeth Macquarie Bicentenary Celebrations in 2010. In pairs, they record the persuasive language used to describe his achievements, and create a word cloud. Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback Students summarise then create their own Macquarie timelines at www.timetoast.com 3. Perspective: Macquarie the visionary – man ahead of his time. Students create a wordle in praise of Macquarie, using Nathan Rees’s persuasive language key words, at www.wordle.net 4. A colonial city: Macquarie organised major building programs. Teach students how to analyse the Panorama painting primary source. Students analyse and describe a primary source. 5. Preview LEMA: Teach students how to evaluate a website for expertise, purpose and bias. Teach students how to preview the sections of a website BEFORE selecting information. Students evaluate a website and learn how to navigate it. Optional extra: Student speech: Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction My vision for the country’s future Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment Evidence of learning and activities: ongoing feedback 1. Review with students how to evaluate websites. The teacher librarian would welcome the Students contribute to a opportunity to work with you in teaching discussion, showing information/research skills. These may include how to evaluate the evaluating information, comparing and contrasting website. ideas, selecting main ideas OR teaching skills such as individualised note making, summarising Students make notes or synthesising skills when transforming using the key word information from a variety of sources into deep method. knowledge and understanding. 2. Preview the LEMA Sites2See before students Students report back explore it. after exploring the 3. Key word note making: Teach students how to LEMA Sites2See. make notes, using part of the LEMA Sites2See resource. Use the key word note making method. Instruct students to have a go at writing their own key words down for a few sentences. Students share with the class which key words they selected 4. Allocate different sections of the LEMA Sites2See for student groups to report back orally about, explaining what they have learned. They will record key words to assist with their report back. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback Students plot Macquarie’s journal: Read and discuss the Macquarie’s journey on accounts from Macquarie’s journal of his crossing a map (Or create a of the Blue Mountains. Plot the journey on a map. visual diagram of his Students record the places Macquarie named journey). enroute. Students identify and Discuss the idea that history is often written from record the names given the conqueror’s perspective. Explain that critical to places by Macquarie. Title: Victors have literacy allows us to see what other, less powerful groups may have experienced. Who was ignored naming rights or disempowered by Macquarie in this account? Students discuss whose Discuss what the journey may have been like for history? the servants accompanying Macquarie. Research Students empathise with what the servants’ on the life of convict servants may be undertaken. may have experienced. Macquarie’s sword: Describe this primary source. Optional: Hypothesise about Lachlan Macquarie’s Students describe the sword – source tastes, interests and family background, using the analysis. sword as a starting point. Students hypothesise about Macquarie’s tastes, interests etc. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Optional extra: Student speech Symbolic object: The object that I would commission to be made, to symbolise my interests and/or family background... Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment Evidence of learning and activities: ongoing feedback 1. A convict’s life: In groups, students explore Students research and conditions and report back to contribute to a class report back on convict mindmap poster about the lives of the convicts. conditions, for a class 2. Discovering democracy: the law rules - Walk mind map. through this learning object with the students. Students make notes Explain about the legal status of convicts in after looking the colonial times. Explain the gains that emancipists learning object slide made in Macquarie’s time as governor. show. 3. Discuss the legal controversy that ultimately led to Students hold a debate the Bigge report and to Macquarie’s resignation. about, or discuss a Multiple histories describe every era or famous controversial topic of person – it would be simplistic to simply recount their own choice (to Macquarie’s achievements. He was a controversial consolidate their figure. Discuss some of the criticisms levelled at understanding of Macquarie. multiple viewpoints and 4. Francis Greenway: Discuss the different views multiple histories). that Greenway held about Macquarie. Students write a complaint letter from NB The Resources list has a background briefing website Greenway’s point of on Francis Greenway which shows he was extraordinarily view, claiming extra extravagant and his bills were a huge part of Macquarie’s pay. downfall. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities 1. 1816/Dispossession and resistance: As a whole class, select key events from the timelines provided, to summarise the encounters that Macquarie had with Aboriginal people. Evaluate the impact Macquarie had on Aboriginal people. There were, and are, varying views. 2. The Native Institution: Students consider and discuss the implications of this initiative of Macquarie’s. 3. Windradyne: Watch the First Australians video extract about Windradyne. Discuss the saying ‘One person’s terrorist is another person’s freedom fighter’. 4. Maria Lock: Read and discuss information about Maria Lock. Why is she significant? 5. What’s in a name?: Students discuss and record the changed meanings of “squatter” over time. Explain the crucial importance of power, money, violence and territory in understanding history and emphasises the importance of critical literacy. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback Students contribute to class discussions and record notes about the impact of Macquarie on Aboriginal people. (Activities 1&2) Students explain the saying ‘One person’s terrorist is another person’s freedom fighter’. Students create a timeline of important events in Maria Lock’s life. www.timetoast.com Students identify and record the various meanings of “squatter”. Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. Servants: Discuss with students how many servants wealthy people typically had in colonial times. (Include information about the more rugged, informal lifestyle for wealthy people in Australia, compared with England.) As an extension, students may research the daily lives and tasks of colonial servants. 2. Aristocratic women + Mary Rouse + Molly Morgan: Teach about the life of women in the colony, including the high mortality rates of infants and lack of full access to an intellectual and professional life and to legal rights. Students complete some research about one of the women identified above. Georgiana McCrae is the aristocratic woman whose life is described. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback Students discuss the likely roles of the servants present on Macquarie’s seat trip in July 1818, based on research about the daily lives of colonial servants. Students create headlines about the main events in the woman’s life they investigated. Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. Spin the holey dollar: Teach students that the holey dollar and the dump were ingenious solutions proposed and used by Macquarie for a currency shortage. Students use their own ingenuity in suggesting unusual uses for objects. 2. Open the collector’s chest: Discuss the fact that there was a scientific fascination with collecting dead animals – to show different species to friends back in England. This may seem to be a wanton waste of life to our eyes. Critical literacy involves a capacity for us to identify certain events or behaviours as controversial. It means not always accepting an historical account as “normal” and “neutral” – students need to look for the motivations underlying the event and to consider the prevailing points of view of the times and the author’s POV. (Time traveller task) 3. The panorama: Students analyse and describe this source. 4. Macquarie’s gothic revival armchair: Students analyse and describe this source. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback Students suggest ingenious uses of objects currently used for other purposes [recycling as a heroic action]. Students draw up a list of what a time traveller from the colonial past would be likely to find extremely disturbing in our current lifestyle in Australia. Students analyse sources (3&4). Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Suggested teaching, learning and assessment activities: 1. Review the concept of multiple histories with students. Students discuss multiple histories in the context of a hot topic which interests them. Explain that the views and events of today will be tomorrow’s history. History is made daily... 2. Students discuss the findings they have recorded on their graphic overview wall posters, about the perspectives of different groups during Macquarie’s time as governor. 3. Students synthesise their understandings by writing about varying perspectives on Lachlan Macquarie, and concluding with their own judgement of his time as Governor. Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Evidence of learning and ongoing feedback Students record current news headlines that will be history in the future Students now finalise their notations on the graphic overview wall posters, (on different perspectives) and then discuss these multiple histories they have identified Students write a 4 paragraph piece, summarising varying perspectives on Macquarie and concluding with their own opinion Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Optional task: Student speech or Student debate Lachlan Macquarie: Hero or villain? Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Resources Convict life http://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/discover_collections/history_nation/justice/convict/convict.html Discovering democracy: The law rules Within the DET portal, access through TaLe at http://www.tale.edu.au or through Firefox at http://tiny.cc/bjMaA First Australians series podcasts http://www.sbs.com.au/podcasts/documentary/first-australians/ Francis Greenway http://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/discover_collections/history_nation/macquarie/greenway/index.html Governor Macquarie’s gothic revival armchair, c. 1821 Within the DET portal, access through TaLe at http://www.tale.edu.au or through Firefox at http://tiny.cc/kcJme Greenway, Francis (1777-1837) Background reading for teachers http://adbonline.anu.edu.au/biogs/A010434b.htm Impact on Aboriginal peoples http://www.ltscotland.org.uk/scotsandaustralia/impact/index.asp Incidents between the Aboriginal people in NSW and the British colonisers 1810-1822 http://k6.boardofstudies.nsw.edu.au/go/hsie/background-sheets/british-colonisers-1810-1822 Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Lachlan and Elizabeth Macquarie Archive - www.lib.mq.edu.au/digital/lema/ Lachlan and Elizabeth Macquarie Archive Sites2See – Sign into DET Portal, access at URL below or through Firefox at http://tiny.cc/WrgBr https://portalsrvs.det.nsw.edu.au/f5-w-687474703a2f2f6c72722e646c722e6465742e6e73772e6564752e6175$$/LRRView/9280/9280_00.htm Lachlan Macquarie’s sword and scabbard, 1808 http://www.nma.gov.au/collections-search/display?app=tlf&irn=52566 Lock, Maria (c.1805-1878) http://adbonline.anu.edu.au/biogs/AS10292b.htm M2009-8 Governor Lachlan Macquarie and Mrs Elizabeth Macquarie Bicentenary Celebrations in 2010 – NSW Premier’s Memorandum http://www.dpc.nsw.gov.au/publications/memos_and_circulars/ministerial_memoranda/2009/m2009-08 Macquarie era: Australia’s first unique coins: Holey dollar and the dump http://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/discover_collections/history_nation/macquarie/coins/index.html Macquarie Era: A colonial city http://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/discover_collections/history_nation/macquarie/governor/city.html Macquarie’s journeys – Two particular journeys have been used in this learning sequence http://www.library.mq.edu.au/all/journeys/1815/ http://www.library.mq.edu.au/all/journeys/1818/1818a/july27.html Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training. Multiple histories: the life and times of Lachlan Macquarie – Teaching ideas Major General Lachlan Macquarie 1: Jan, 1810 to 1 Dec, 1821 – Background briefing http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au/nswconstitution/html/3rd/bgr/gov/macquarie.html Mary Rouse http://www.library.mq.edu.au/all/journeys/people/profiles/rouse.html Morgan, Molly (1762-1835) http://adbonline.anu.edu.au/biogs/A020223b.htm Panorama of Sydney Harbour with Government House and Fort Macquarie from Mrs Macquarie's Chair, c1845 Within the DET portal, access this through www.tale.edu.au or through Firefox at http://tiny.cc/E4bxu Squatting (pastoral) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squatting_(pastoral) Tracing the history of citizenship and rights for Indigenous people http://k6.boardofstudies.nsw.edu.au/go/hsie/background-sheets/tracing Windradyne – First Australians video extract – 5 minutes 42 seconds http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wm57Un8bsW0 Women in colonial times http://www.cultureandrecreation.gov.au/articles/colonialwomen/ Intellectual quality Deep knowledge Deep understanding Problematic knowledge Higher-order thinking Metalanguage Substantive communication Quality learning environment Explicit quality criteria Engagement High expectations Social support Students’ self-regulation Student direction Significance Background knowledge Cultural knowledge Knowledge integration Inclusivity Connectedness Narrative © 2010 School Libraries and Information Literacy Unit and HSIE Unit. Curriculum K–12 Directorate. NSW Department of Education and Training.