(5E Lesson Plan Template) Creator: Sarah Geren Title of Lesson: Sounds in nature—animal interactions, and how we alter them Intended Grade Level(s): Grades 7 & 8 Main Objective(s): 1) To learn the different ways in which sound is used by living organisms, and various reasons that sound is needed. 2) To introduce students to the concept of noise pollution 3) To expand students’ knowledge of local fauna, and be able to recognize a variety of animals by sound. Arizona State Science Standards Addressed: 1) Design an investigation to test individual variables using scientific processes. 2) Communicate the results and conclusion of the investigation 3) Analyze environmental risks (e.g., pollution, destruction of habitat) caused by human interaction with biological or geological systems. 4) Explain how an organism’s behavior allows it to survive in an environment. Common Core Standards Addressed: 1) What are the characteristic properties and behaviors of waves? 2) Human impacts on Earth systems: Human activities have significantly altered the biosphere, sometimes damaging or destroying natural habitats and causing the extinction of other species. But changes to Earth’s environments can have different impacts (negative and positive) for different living things. Suggested Supplemental Teacher Resources – References/ Websites: 1) http://jeb.biologists.org/content/207/3/427.full: This is an article about the effects of different sound levels and durations on goldfish: 2) http://www.dosits.org/animals/effectsofsound/marinemammals/strandings/: This website is great for general information about sound as well as for information about sound in marine habitats. 3) http://www.inspirationgreen.com/noise-pollution-alters-bird-behavior.html: For general information on noise pollution 4) http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/12/061206-birds-cities_2.html and http://www.cell.com/current-biology/abstract/S0960-9822(06)02308-6: For effects of urban noise on bird songs. Lesson Plan Description: Animals use sound for a variety of reasons, and we are exposed to some of these sounds on a daily basis. The first part of this lesson will get students thinking about the different reasons sound is used, and will introduce them to some of the sounds they can hear even in urban areas. If there is not a good location near the school to listen for animal sounds, then the teacher should have some sound clips or videos of local fauna producing sound to show in class. Students will learn about sound waves, how animals use sounds, and how anthropogenic sound can affect animals, which is the focus of the second part of the lesson. After learning about behavioral changes and masking affects related to anthropogenic sound, students will get to observe these effects by exposing goldfish to different kinds of sound and observing how the goldfish reacts. Students will then get to present their experiments to the rest of the class. Engage Purpose: This section of the class is intended to introduce students to the concept of sounds in nature through observation of local fauna. Materials: Access to the outdoors where birds, bugs, or other local animals can be heard. If this is not possible, or there were not sufficient examples, the teacher can play recordings of sounds of local fauna. For example, the teacher can visit the Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s lab http://www.allaboutbirds.org/Page.aspx?pid=1189 for a multitude of bird songs. Youtube can be used to find sounds from other local animals. Instructional Sequence: 1. Show students a few extreme examples of sounds in nature. Present it as a game, and ask students to guess what they think the animal making the sound may be. 2. Explain that the class will be spent studying the role of sound in nature. 3. Take students outside, and have them bring paper and something to write with. 4. Spend 3-5 minutes (depending on length of class—could be more time if class is long, or if few sounds are heard in this time) silently listening for animals sounds. Instruct students to write down any sounds that they recognize. The teacher should note sounds as well. 5. Bring students back inside and ask them to describe what they heard. If they know the name of the animal making the sound, they can share the name with the class. If they do not know the name of the animal, they can describe the sound, or even try to make the sound (it may be necessary to give a 5-10 second time limit on duration of sounds, as some students may get carried away and distract the class). 6. Spend some time, depending on the length of the class, sharing some of the sounds so all the students can hear and identify it. Exploration Safety: Students should be told not to try to touch or pick up any animals seen outside. Students should only be listening for sounds and making notes while outside unless otherwise directed by the teacher. Purpose: Now that students are familiar with the concept that animals use sounds, this section will serve to elicit from students possible reasons an animal would need to produce sounds, and to give some examples Materials: Some videos or sound clips would be necessary to give scenarios, however examples would be specific to location and class. Instructional Sequence: Conduct a think-pair-share exercise: Tell students to talk to a partner and write down all the reasons they can come up with that animals would need to use sound, then have them pair up or get into small groups to discuss their ideas. Ask students to share their ideas with the whole class. If students have difficulty coming up with reasons, help guide them to some possibilities by asking them to think of different reasons they use sound in their daily lives, and examples of animals using sound for the same reason. o Explain echolocation when predation or navigation is brought up (Using reflected sound waves to locate objects (bats, dolphins, toothed whales)) Present students with several scenarios (i.e. walking through the desert and hearing a rattling sound from a snake, a lone mockingbird running through a series of sounds it has learned to mimic, two cats growling and hissing at each other) and ask them to explain what reason the animals in each scenario may have for making a sound. Explanation Purpose: Now that students have been exposed to various animal sounds and have begun to think about the multitude of ways that sounds are used in nature, they should be introduced to some mechanics of sounds and how anthropogenic sound affects animals. Materials: Examples of sounds students are likely familiar with. For an exercise being done in Phoenix, some possibilities are: Rattlesnake: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7raYkYyB1wo Cricket: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQFEY9RIRJA Instructional Sequence: 1. Explain that sound is produced by vibrating objects compressing and expanding the air around them to create sound waves. Use examples, such as instruments and vocal chords, or return to some of the videos of sound being produced that were shown in the engage section. 2. Animals can manipulate tone, pitch, volume, and other aspects of sound to communicate in different ways. 3. Noise pollution and other anthropogenic sounds: Introduce the idea that humans make a lot of noise, and this has effects on animals. a. Behavioral changes: First, see if the students can think of potential behavior changes and write them down, as these will be referred to during the next activity. Some examples include hiding, mimicry (like the Northern mockingbird mimicking a car alarm), reducing or altering the pitch and intensity of sound (pilot whales stop vocalizing around oil field drilling, humpback whale increasing dive time and travel distance, beluga whales swimming away from food source to avoid ice break ships, European robins change the time they sing, Great tits don’t sing at lower frequencies, and German nightingales sing louder) b. Masking: Explain what “masking” is in this sense (when a sound that is either natural or anthropogenic prevents other sounds from being heard), and ask students to brainstorm what sort of important sounds might be masked by human activities. Answers should be written down for the next activity. Some answers that students may name are masking of predatory sounds, other environmental dangers, and other individuals of the same species communicating. Ask the students why these abilities are important for an animal to have. c. Hearing impairment or loss: If animals are exposed to very loud sound, or to a sound for a long period of time, it can affect their hearing, shifting up their hearing threshold, or the softest sound the animal can hear at a specific frequency. d. Stranding: Stranding is when a single marine mammal or group of marine mammals are stranded on shore, often for unknown reason. Naval sonar has been connected to mass strandings of beaked whales, a species where stranding is usually very uncommon. The link between sonar and the strandings is not well known at this point, and research is necessary. Extend/ Elaboration Purpose: To use the information about the effects of anthropogenic sounds on animals learned in the previous section to study how different sounds affect goldfish. Materials: large tanks or clear plastic tubs hissing cockroaches variously weighted objects (i.e. rocks of different sizes) fruits or vegetables for food plants, rocks, or other objects that the cockroaches can use to hide in. Instructional Sequence: 1. Instruct students to look at the four kinds of effects anthropogenic sound can have on animals. Explain that they will be using the hissing cockroaches and other materials to test some of these effects. Ask students which of the four categories they think they will be able to test. 2. Students should come to the conclusion that stranding cannot be tested in the classroom. While hearing impairment and loss could technically be tested, if Evaluation the students do not reject it, then inform them that this option will not be tested. 3. Show students the materials they have and tell them to think of ways that they can use these to design an experiment. Some possibilities include: a. Test response to short sound burst by providing tank decorations to hide behind. b. Test response to sound in presence of food to see if they would abandon it, leave and return later, or continue eating. Students can test different placements of sound and food. c. Test how the sound affects predator response. Students may play a predator’s sound, and see how the response changes when different levels of ambient noise are also present. d. Show how different lengths of exposure to sounds affects response. Purpose: To allow students to show comprehension of the topics discussed, and to gain experience presenting an experiment. It will also familiarize the students with the different ways that the topic can be studied. Materials: If desired, students can create a PowerPoint or poster to present their project. Instructional Sequence: 1. Have students present their experiment and what they observed to the other students in the class. They should use concepts and vocabulary learned during the lesson. Possible Alternatives and Troubleshooting: For older students, the lesson can go into more detail about the mechanics of sound. The experiment can be expanded to not only test how sound affects fish, but to apply the knowledge of this behavior and the mechanics of sound. Have the students imagine that they are part of a company that will be doing some activity that produces sound under water, such as oil drilling, construction, or mining. They must determine what types of sound affect the fish in the area (in this case, it’s goldfish), and then using information about the work site and the mechanics of sound, they should design a worksite that minimizes effects on the fish. If the class does not have access to enough of the equipment necessary for several groups of students to do their own experiments, then the teacher can give an example and have students describe the fish’s response. If possible, there should be at least two different trials, one for short sound bursts, and another for longer consistent sounds.