ZCAP ZION STATION COMMUNITY ADVISORY PANEL
MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2014
AT THE NEW TECH HIGH/ZION-BENTON HIGH SCHOOL
Present:
Brent Paxton, Chairman
John Lewis, Secretary
Joel Brumlik
Craig Dyke
Sheri Jesiel
Cynthia Johnson
Audrey Liddle
Kent McKenzie
Doug Ower
Linda Sittig
Larry Booth
Absent:
Craig Mason
Item 1: Call to Order
The Chairman called the meeting to order at 6:00 pm.
Item 2: Approval of Minutes
Motion to approve March 17 and June 30, 2014 meeting minutes was accepted, seconded and
approved by all.
Item 3: Chairman’s Remarks
The Chairman gave a friendly reminder to silence all cell phones during the meeting. Chairman
introduced Sherry Jesiel who is taking over for JoAnn Osmond.
Item 4: ZionSolutions Presentations
Decommissioning Status Update
by Gerry van Noordennen, VP of Regulatory Affairs
Mr. van Noordennen introduced himself and gave the audience his background information. He
then gave a slide presentation on the Zion Status which included a short video of present site
conditions.
1
Disbursements and Balances
ZionSolutions Nuclear Decommission Trust
Balance Roll Forward – Cash Basis
As of June 30, 2014
Beginning Balance
Earnings – Net of taxes and fees
Disbursements
Ending Balance
($ millions)
801.4
110.2
(522.8)
388.8
Majority of Expenses incurred as follows:











Project Management
Procurement of casks and canisters for dry fuel storage
Waste disposal
Planning and preparing for spent fuel transfer
ISFSI construction
Unit 1 and Unit 2 reactor internals segmentation
Asbestos remediation
Plant maintenance and security
Unit 1 & 2 containment preparation and support
Fuel transfer operations
Unit 1 and 2 reactor vessel segmentation
Item 5: Comments, Questions and Answers
Panel Comment and Questions
Q:
A:
What happens to the water from the pool?
We have a discharge permit with the Illinois EPA which allows us to discharge, under
very strict limits, to Lake Michigan. The water is processed, filtered, it goes through ion
exchanges, then goes into a 20,000 gallon test tank. It must meet the state release limits
before release into Lake Michigan. There are also dilution flow pumps to further dilute
the water. Thus far, there has never been a discharge permit violation.
Q:
A:
Have there been any radiation safety issues?
We have had a few personnel contaminations (particles) inside containment, but there has
never been an over-exposure contamination. Personnel working inside containment have
to go through three sets of scanners before leaving the site.
2
Q:
A:
Regarding license termination – what happens if you can’t meet the threshold?
Must reach 25 millirem/year. Just keep cleaning up the site until you get there.
Q:
A:
Is the 25 millirem a Federal standard?
Federal and State of Illinois standard.
Q:
A:
What type of contamination are you finding around the site?
Near the Class B & C waste storage area, a couple of little particles have fallen on the
soil. This could be due to the drain holes in the casks. All of this will be cleaned up and
the soil will be removed.
Q:
A:
Have there been any leaks into Lake Michigan?
Nothing.
Q:
A:
Who is responsible for security on the ISFSI pad?
ZionSolutions until project completion. Exelon will take over once the license is
transferred back.
Q:
A:
Is there a delay in receiving some of the liners?
Closing of the GE factory has put them behind schedule. We are short six liners, we have
been promised four from another site and the other two when production is back on
schedule.
Q:
A:
What if costs exceed the trust fund?
ZionSolutions has a letter of credit and would be responsible for the difference.
Public Comment and Questions
Q:
A:
Please explain the letter of credit.
That is the guarantee that EnergySolutions has with Exelon that we would finish the
decommissioning.
Q:
A:
How much is it to hold the line of credit?
Will ask our finance department.
Q:
A:
How do you monitor the casks through time? How do you monitor in the lake?
There is a radiation monitor with an automatic shut off at the discharge to the lake. Every
quarter we do a radiation survey at the ISFSI pad. There are film badge dosimeters hung
around the pad and the State of Illinois also has monitoring equipment around the site.
Q:
A:
What if something happens to the cask?
We send inspectors to the factory that manufactures the casks. We also do inspections on
site.
Q:
In the next 5-10 years?
3
A:
The oldest ones in existence are 40 years old. NRC requires an Aging Management
Program. Inspect them regularly – look for cracks or rust.
Q:
A:
Who is responsible for the cost 20 years from now?
Exelon as the license holder, DOE, or the Federal government.
Q:
A:
Is there any potential for the fuel rods to be reprocessed?
It has been done overseas but not yet in the U.S.
Q:
A:
Why don’t we have reprocessing?
There is no incentive – it’s cheaper to buy new.
Q:
A:
What is the size of the pad? How deep is the concrete?
There are two pads and each is about the size of a tennis court, 5-6 feet deep.
Q:
A:
Are you still planning to be finished in 2019-2020?
Right now we are forecasting to be complete in 2018.
Q:
A:
When would the resident farmer be able to use the land?
2018, but that is the cleanup standard for License Termination, not for future use
Q:
A:
Are those sales taxes primarily – not income taxes?
Sales taxes I believe, but will have to verify with our financial personnel.
Q:
A:
Was any money used for characterization or testing?
I will get you that answer.
Q:
A:
The cutting instrument – is that one of a kind?
Yes, that was made for Zion.
Q:
A:
Why cutting instead of torching for the reactor internals?
It would be more difficult and take a lot longer. It would also expose more people to
radiation
Q:
A:
What was the $16k fine from the NRC?
During the ISFSI construction, some drawings were deemed to have had a loss of control
between the contractor and subcontractor.
Q:
A:
What is the security and monitoring around the site?
Security procedures are not public knowledge. We do have scenarios and a terrorist
attack is one of those scenarios.
Q:
A:
Isn’t the ISFSI pad too close to where the general public could access?
No, there is over 100 yards between the pads and the surrounding area.
Q:
Two tennis courts are holding all those casks?
4
A:
Yes.
Q:
A:
How do they ventilate?
Natural circulation.
There were 2 questions previously submitted to the panel in writing. 1.) Is there any reason at
this time to think that the current reported level of Decommissioning Trust Funds may be
inadequate or insufficient to complete the Zion Decommissioning & Site Rehabilitation Project
as was originally forecast? Mr. Van Noordennen answered No. 2.) Are there any large scale
pending project forecast changes that will change the original schedule or the parties charged
with the Zion Decommissioning & Site Rehabilitation Project? Mr. Van Noordennen answered
No.
Item 6: Old Business
None
Item 7: New Business
None
Item 8: Adjournment
The next scheduled meeting will be December 8, 2014. The Chairman entertained a motion to
adjourn the meeting. Motion by Brumlik, seconded by Sittig. Motion was carried unanimously
by the Panel. The meeting was adjourned at 7:05 pm.
5