FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
NAME
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
Gregg Anderson
Jerry Smith
Andrew Onken
Matt Maki
Andy Fry
Ron Boyd
Doug Clark
Jonathan Smith
Bruce Quade
Chris Collings
Kiem Hoang
Nassissie Fekadu
Carol Burr
Tracey Gibson
Kathleen Kearns
Chad Geyer
Bruce Eckstein
Ron Tornese
Steve Gulstrom
Matt Johnson
John McCormick
David Strider
Mark Patterson
Ammar Chaudhry
Tracy Lennertz
Scott Johnson
Moin Abulhosn
Rafael Quezada
Todd Kilbourne
James Tochihara
Steve DeHart
Eric Harrell
Ross Dickinson
Jon Pendleton
Greg Sparks
Michael Yablonksi
Steve Corrie
Franco Basti
Joseph D’Hedouville
PHONE
202.493.4779
202-510-3156
410-266-2949
617-874-6699
202-510-4966
202-510-3087
609-485-4107
202-510-1719
410-573-3516
321-427-5141
609-485-5021
703-610-2414
609-272-4027
202-267-4161
703-491-0661
661-713-9091
703-668-6074
202-267-2527
901-397-8216
480-861-6244
901-647-3717
202-385-4884
202-385-4352
301-7601-0742
617-494-2945
202-493-5498
202-385-4645
202-267-5190
703-801-4285
847-208-1376
315-445-5092
410-266-2060
901-240-7389
612-310-9535
202-385-4987
703-610-1930
202-799-8624
703-518-6313
571-242-6166
EMAIL
Gregg.anderson@faa.gov
gsmith@thaneincorp.com
aonken@arinc.com
Matthew.maki@dot.gov
afry@thaneincorp.com
rboyd@thaneincorp.com
dclark@bcisse.com
jonsmith@thaneincorp.com
bquade@arinc.com
Chris.collings@harris.com
Kiem.hoang@faa.gov
Nassissie.fekadu@noblis.org
cburr@mitre.org
tgibson@northstargroupllc.com
Kathleen.kears@sita.aero
cageyer9@msn.com
bruce.eckstein@exelisinc.com
rtornese@thaneincorp.com
slgulstrom@fedex.com
mjohnson@systems-enginuity.com
jtmccormickiii@fedex.com
dstrider@northstargroupllc.com
Mark.patterson@faa.gov
achaudhry@northstargroupllc.com
Tracey.lennertz@doyt.gov
Scott.r.johnson@faa.gov
Moin.abulhosn@faa.gov
Rafael.quezada@faa.gov
tkilbourne@systems-enginuity.com
James.tochihara@united.com
Steve.DeHart@Sensis.com
eharrell@arinc.com
Rdickinson64@comcast.net
Jon.pendleton@delta.com
gregory.ctr.cparks@faa.gov
mike.yablonski@noblis.org
Steve.ctr.corrie@faa.gov
Franco.basti@us.thalesgroup.com
Joseph.dhedouville@us.thalesgroup.com
PHONE PARTICIPANTS
1
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
1
2
3
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
Rob Mead
Jeff Bass
Doug Egan
Bruce Notley
Chris Byrd
Karen Bisbee
Bruce Gustafson
Pete Muraca
Andy Colon
Geoff Shearer
Gerry Shire
Christophe Hamel
Jerome Condis
John Gonda
John Noblitt
Kathy Lane
Kevin Swiatek
Perry Clausen
Rick Shay
Cindy Freud
Bill Stine
Dongsong Zeng
Glenn Morse
253-951-8447
Rob.mead@boeing.com
Jeffrey.bass@faa.gov
degan@systems-enginuity.com
bruce.notley@faa.gov
christopher.j.byrd@faa.gov
karen.bisbee@fedex.com
peter.muraca@faa.gov
andy.colon@faa.gov
Geoffrey.L.Shearer@boeing.com
Gerry.shire@united.com
Christophe.Hamel@faa.gov
jerome.condis@airbus.com
jgonda@mitre.org
kathryn.lane@lmco.com
kswiatek@ups.com
perry.clausen@wnco.com
Rick.Shay@united.com
cfreud@mitre.org
bstine@nbaa.org
dzeng@mitre.org
glenn.morse@united.com
Plenary Meeting:
 The Plenary meeting started with an introduction and welcome by Jerry Smith. Please
view the file “20120712_DCP_DCIT_16_Plenary_Agenda.pptx” to review the agenda.
o Thanks to Thales for hosting the DCIT for the second time.
 Matt Maki presented the trials update briefing. Please view the file
“20120712_DCL_16_MMaki_Trials_DCIT_Update.ppt”. The discussion points were:
o Significant updates since the last DCIT in terms of November start date at
Memphis Tower.
o DTAP Development – Continue to work towards delivery on August 17th for initial
operational DTAP.
 For this date to happen, coordination between the teams for work to be
done in France and Australia will need to be facilitated.
o Work with Thales:
 The DTAP SSS baseline and functional requirements are notionally
finalized with Thales, which is meeting delivery dates.
 Thales has delivered the initial PSAA, SSHA, SSPP delivered to FAA
2
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
o Three CHI Design Reviews
 Facility representation at MEM, EWR, ATL - facility and National Data
Comm NATCA with Trials and Thales reps where CHI changes were
recommended and documented. These changes are reflected in the DTAP
schedules.
 EWR had specific changes to be addressed.
 A Webex has been scheduled to revisit with each of the reps.
o The DCL Trials Timeline graphic
 Unexpected training requirements in Memphis could potentially shift
some of the scheduled dates, possibly affecting Tech Center trials.
o Memphis connectivity
 Construction activities are progressing and nearing completion.
Supervision and support are all in sync and working towards the goal.
 12th floor electronics equipment room construction is progressing and
taking shape. See the PowerPoint slides for photos and labels pointing to
components and locations.
o Ongoing
 FAA/FDX Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) is officially completed.
 Volpe/Boeing Trials Service tasking progress reports are good.
 Pete Muraca is establishing connection with ARINC, and meeting with
SITA for that network connection.
o Trials SMRD are approved. Trials Activities
 Second NCP approved through CCB and remote host patch will be pushed
to HADDS in late July.
 Space and power test NCP have been submitted for SME review. Results
are attached with no negative feedback to date.
 Final NCP with FIDO echoport will allow for revision number data when
MEM converts to an ERAM feed to HADDS in March 2013. ERAM could
not accommodate the modification request to include the revision
number due to schedule, cost, etc.
 The backup plan to this scenario is the FIDO echoport. This will
require a separate NCP.
o Security Office
 A final security document package was submitted by Guy Corneille.
Security has reviewed the document, but will need approximately two
weeks to complete the evaluation process.
 The DCIT intends to accomplish the following with this process:
 Approval to Proceed; based on planned architecture and design.
3
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202



A smaller requirement level proxy at Atlanta NESG, which would
allow conduct NAT translation.
 Cannot proceed with FTI provisioning until the ISSM review is
complete.
 These items are significant factors with the program and as such,
the Program Manager is involved with this process to ensure that
there are no holds ups from a Data Comm perspective.
o Memphis training procedures are formally reviewed.
 Memphis has provided documentation complete enough to start training.
Jerry Smith asked the DCIT for feedback on the following:
o Comments and/or questions regarding the meeting minutes from DCIT #15.
There were no questions or comments.
o DCIT Website – The website link will need more visibility when sent to the DCIT
members.
o DCIT Meeting Invitation/Google Docs tracking spreadsheet – Link to
questionnaire that calculates attendance will be added to invitation. All agree.
Pete Muraca discussed key dates to achieve events delivery of pDTAP on May 10
ground-to-ground connectivity in conjunction with the DCL Trials OTE Timeline.
o The intent of the timeline is to emphasize key dates. The delivery of pDTAP
occurred on May 10th. The following events are to be accomplished between
that time and August 17th:
o Ground to Ground connectivity in place; Avionics connected
o Documentations in place with testing procedures and plans
o The VRTM; coordination in place.
o Opportunity to do ground-to-ground/air-to-ground connectivity over the next
couple of weeks, as well as connectivity to Tech Center Aircraft.
o Recently, permission was granted to transmit to and from via antennae on roof
of lab to exercise avionics suite in the lab itself.
 License from Spectrum Office is a clearance to act as a target out of the
building more functionality/capabilities across DTAP.
o Extra capabilities show that requirements are met. Work continues with
Boeing/Airbus and the integrative solutions as platforms.
o Week of August 27th will entail participation with DCIT aircraft to introduce
connection and clearance / logon for formal testing. This is a way to get air
framers participation and communication prior to the Memphis dates.
o Move to Site Acceptance Testing (SAT) in late September in Memphis. Will begin
to concentrate on End-to-End operational scenarios with facilities.
4
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:


July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
o Will meet with Boeing next week to attempt connectivity, logon and
communicate air-to-ground to ensure DTAP is performing as designed.
 Jerry Smith asked for a telecom to go over particulars during the week of
the meeting.
 Rick Shay offered to facilitate testing from United Airlines perspective.
 Kevin Swiatek from UPS will check with management crews and
availability to participate.
 Southwest – no FANS working at this time.
 John McCormick with FedEx recommended an aircraft taxi scenario at a
later phase of testing.
Gregg Anderson gave a Programmatic update
o Final Investment Decision was successful, and Data Communications is a bona
fide program. Now that workflows have been triggered to move forward, there
are multiple deadlines, the lifecycle is getting full, and funnel situation is
occurring with many tasks and details due at or near the same time.
 As a result – The November deadline is gaining a lot of risk because of the
amount of detail that needs to be accomplished between now and then.
 If the November 1 target date does not happen, it does not deem a
failure. It is more important to mitigate risk and deliver a complete
product than to rush to the finish.
o Chris Byrd (Memphis Management Rep) has asked to back up training to occur in
September. This creates more risk for training to happen subsequently to OTE,
which may require some fixes. There could potentially be backfill and
OT/Schedule issues. The DCIT will work collectively; but Nov 1 is unlikely. The
goal is to build the moratorium, and that looks like it will happen.
o John McCormick assures the group that the Data Comm Program, and the DCIT,
has the support and commitment from FedEx. A “thanks” was conveyed to Gregg
Anderson and company for keeping this program on target.
Gregg Anderson went through the briefing that was presented to the JRC. Please see the
file “20120607_DCP_DCIT_16_GAnderson_30May2012_JRC_FID_41_sites.ppt “ for
details. The highlights of this briefing are as follows:
o The first FID occurred on May 16th. The pivotal question at the first meeting was
- If there are 70 CONUS installations of TDLS (along with maintenance funds over
the lifecycle to sustain), “Why are sites being chosen that have no benefits?” The
group disassembled and reworked the sites and budget numbers to reflect
positive cost benefits. They reconvened on May 30th. At the May 30th meeting:
o The CONUS installations number changed to 57, instead of 70.
5
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202

o
o
o
o
o
Requesting an Investment Decision to award the Integrates Services
Contract, the ERAM modifications to support the Tower service.
 There are 35 sites that have positive Net Present Value (NPV), plus
6 others that should be considered. This brings the number from
57 to 41.
o This reduction translates to a $3.2M savings, and a savings
of $2.6M per year for 24 years on the recurring fees.
 15 of the sites claim 86% of the benefits. (Slide below outlines this
discussion.)
The program will return to JRC in FY13 to present the contract modification after
awarding DCIS to refresh the information for network services and negotiations,
as well as update the work completed on the site selections.
Decision approved to move forward with DCIS and award the contract
modification to Lockheed Martin on ERAM. The 41 sites were also approved.
John Pendleton asked a question regarding deployment schedule pressure?
 DCIS Contract – Vendors are required to provide equipped aircraft and
partner operations as part of the contract, therefore, they have an option
to request how to proceed with the roll out. (First five sites) Until the
contract award happens, the roll out is unknown at this time.
TAAMS Airport Modeling - Mike Yablonski to show the Kennedy and Houston
airport models at DCIT #17; August 22 – 23 at ITT Exelis in Herndon, VA.
It is possible to decompose the list logic more – Cost ratios / direct operating
cost.
 Airline Direct Operating Cost (ADOC);
 Passenger Value of Time (PVT);
 PVT + ADOC is the formula that created the list of airports.
6
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
Slide 6 from brief.

Rob Mead presented the End to End document v1.0. Please see the document
“DCL_end2end_Build_1_v1.1.docx”.
o The End to End document was reviewed as the group discussed changes. This
version represents DTAP Build 1. The End to End document for DTAP Build 2 will
be started.
 A question was asked whether or not FRDCL is part of the flight plan
correlation process? This discussion was not resolved and still needs to
be addressed. It was taken offline and may be revisited at the next DCIT
or working group meeting.
 Note in the FRDCL section: The Thales system also checks for 24 bit
address in flight plan and logon. It should not be done with FANS. It will
be changed to Build 2.
 777 Operators should not file a 24 bit for Build 1. (ATN version of
the 777 will be in CM contact message applied as part of ATN/new
package.)
 Propose that this be a removable item for the DTAP for Build 2.
DTAP should not check for this.
7
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:

July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
 Exception to this is FANS2/Flight Plan to Europe.
o Revise current scenarios list. Entire appendix for capturing parameters will be
updated with renewed information.
 Ron Boyd and Andy Fry to create new message sample selection and
circulate through leads. This will be delivered in the August timeframe
and added to End-to-End.
 Carol Burr had a comment that courtesy copy SSR code to be deleted.
Overview of working groups
o Operations Management had full participation with each of working group leads,
as well as FedEx, Thales and Memphis reps present.
 Dates for late start of training settled from Oct 29 – Nov 9. Then the
Program start date is Monday the 12th, despite that it is a holiday. (Light
holiday traffic will make for an ideal first day.)
o AOC Working Group has met for two telecons since the last DCIT with a focus on
the Production System that allowed prod to make recommendations to AOC
participants :
 The courtesy copy initial exchange would be the only time information
not completely sent to the Flight Deck would be sent to the AOC. It is the
full route string of clearance, if it was Cleared As Filed (CAF).
 New Message agreed for timing issues in the TOWER to control
controllers’ and print cycle for strips that are printed. There will be a gate
ID message to facilities. “Is this necessary since AOC does not support
Gate IDs?” The decision from AOC was to send only what was sent to the
Pilot. Otherwise, the communication timing could go beyond the strip
production time and message would end up in a bit bucket. This applies
to Trial System Phase 2 and Production System. When trials get to EWR,
this will be supported and invoked because United does use Gate ID
information.
 ICAO 2012 Flight Plan will be active in November of this year. As ERAM
comes in, it will be supported. It is still being worked.
 A Natrack internal meeting with FAA ATOP Ocean 21, who runs outside
Oceanic Airspace and uses CPDLC, were briefed. They have some of the
same issues reported on the ground;
 Must manually cut/paste info for lat/long into Um80 clearance.
 Safety issues were reported.
 The group conveyed: if there is anything Data Comm could do to
help this issue, it would be much appreciated.
8
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
o Currently hard coded to use alphabet; Would like to
accommodate the automation we have now.
 Gregg Anderson suggested taking a white paper to Air Traffic
Controllers in upcoming meetings. The NAT consists of 12 groups
representing air traffic.
o FAA publishes Lat/Long tracks daily on website for users.
 Questions regarding regions in World Wide Database – AOC will
work on this with the Users. The World Wide Database doesn’t
cover everything. The ground system is several iterations behind
the current Lat/Long publications.
o What do we do with the ground system? The Trial system
can support up to v15. Still working on this issue.
 Carol Burr represents the Production team.
o Trial and Production interfaces are being built to be as
similar as possible. The information exchange should be
the same with both systems. There will be mechanisms
available in 2015 that cannot be done now.
 The AOC will have another telecom to recap.
o Flight Deck –
 Andy Fry reported Ops schedule and working out dates with
FedEx/United and Delta.
 Made contact with Coordination with flight Centers/CMO APM on August
17th for FedEx material to be approved for data link operations.
 Plan for United schedule – More clarity on dates to give to United reps.
 End-to-End impacts regarding features of logon and what impact it will
have on Flight Deck. Conclusion has not been reached, but a good chance
that it will be to revert to voice. Once in En-to-End, it will be added to FD
Users’ Guide.
 Shorter version of questionnaire has been created, but both long and
short versions will be provided, and it will be hosted in electronic format.
There will also be a paper version.
 How info to be measured and collected will be revisited offline.
 The Flight Deck Users’ Guide has been edited with very few comments.
The AOC scenarios will be updated and passed on to team leads.
o ATC, training procedures –
 Ron Boyd reported that the group has met with reps from Atlanta,
Newark and Memphis to view how the CHI looks for Air Traffic Control.
9
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:

July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
There was very good reception. ATCs gave feedback about CHI and
modifications to consider. The SSS has been modified to reflect changes.
 EWR’s complex in Build 2 after Memphis. The functionality and OTE
training will be available in November at Tech Center Training. The date
to test OTE is flexible, depending on functional testing.
 Trip to Memphis Center – Air Traffic Management unit and automation to
FRDCL in Field 11 of Flight Plan: Reroute scenarios at Memphis to not
remove FRDCL out of remarks. Emphasize – DO NOT REMOVE FRDCL.
 Patch is done for ICAO 2012 Flight Plan upgrade.
 Training procedures at Memphis - Memphis completed impressive
training and procedures documents. Everything is understandable and
everyone was in agreement. May have minor changes to document
depending on upcoming trial starts.
 Memphis training will take precedence over trials training, but
Memphis will support the Trials to start on time.
System Integration - Andrew Onken discussed the System Integration Description
Document v0.7. Please see the file
“20120711Systems_Integration_Description_Documentv0.7.doc”.
o Will get all comments incorporated.
o Test section reflects methodology Example messages; waiting to hear from
FedEx regarding spacing.
o FRCDLC – unresolved comment in End-to-End regarding correlation. Will be
resolved when End-to-End document gets resolved.
The Plenary Meeting concluded for the day.
NEXT DCIT MEETINGS
DCIT #17: August 22 & 23 at ITT Exelis in Herndon, VA
NOTE: There will not be a formal DCIT meeting in the month of September, but the group will
convene via Webex/Telecon to allow for preparations of upcoming deliverables and milestone
dates. Formal DCIT meetings will resume in October.
Respectfully Submitted,
Ammar Chaudhry/Tracey Gibson
Data Communications Program Support
North Star Group, LLC
600 Maryland Ave SW
10
FAA NextGen Data Communications Program
Data Communications Implementation Team (DCIT)
Plenary Meeting #16
DATE:
TIME:
PLACE:
July 12, 2012
9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Thales USA, Inc.
2733 South Crystal Dr., Suite 1200
Arlington, VA 22202
Washington, DC 20024
11