BBC News Science and Environment
Moon formation: New spins put on old
questions
The impact is supposed to have thrown debris into space that then coalesced into a satellite
Scientists have put a new turn on the theory of how the Moon was created.
It has long been thought that the lunar body resulted from an impact between the early Earth
and another planet-sized object 4.5 billion years ago.
But this theory predicts Earth and its satellite should have a quite different chemical make-up and the data shows in fact they are very similar.
Now, new modelling reveals that if the Earth had a much faster spin before the impact, the
theory fits the chemistry.
It is one idea to fix the composition conundrum explored in two papers published this week by
the journal Science.
The giant impact hypothesis was first posited in the 1970s. It holds that the Moon formed from
the debris kicked into orbit by the collision of a smaller proto-planet with the infant Earth.
But the early models indicated that much of this debris would have originated from the impactor,
whose composition would most probably have differed substantially from that of Earth.
This is not reflected in the analysis of Earth and Moon rocks – for example, their oxygen
isotope, or atom type, compositions are identical.
Matija Cuk, from the Seti Institute, and colleagues ran new simulations in which the early Earth
was rotating on its axis in just a few hours prior to the impact - compared to the present 24
hours.
In such a scenario, the team could get debris material thrown into a Moon-forming disc around
the Earth that had the right chemical make-up. In other words, it was substantial Earth material
from its mantle that was ejected in the collision.
After the impact, the gravitational interaction between the Sun and the Moon could then have
slowed the fast rotation of the Earth to the speed we now experience.
Robin Canup from the Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) and colleagues took a different
approach.
Their simulations involved larger impactors hitting an Earth of comparable size and at
comparatively lower speeds. Again, the team was able to produce a Moon with the same
chemical composition as the Earth.
The Moon


In 1969, Neil Armstrong was the first person to walk on the Moon during the Apollo 11
mission
The Dark Side of the Moon permanently faces away from Earth, but on average it
receives the same amount of sunlight
With only a sixth of Earth's gravity, a 12 stone man weighs just two stone on the Moon


Drive a lunar rover across the Moon's surface
Were the moon landings faked?

Reference
BBC (2012) Moon formation: New spin put on old question ‘http://www.bbc.co.uk accessed
31/05/2012