PROGRAM INFORMATION DOCUMENT (PID) CONCEPT STAGE Report No.: AB7091 Project Name Region Sector Operation ID Borrower(s) Implementing Agency Date PID Prepared Estimated Date of Appraisal Authorization Estimated Date of Board Approval FIRST PROGRAMMATIC PRODUCTIVE AND SUSTAINABLE CITIES DEVELOPMENT POLICY LOAN (DPL) LCR Sustainable Development Sector (100%) P130972 Republic of Colombia Ministerio de Hacienda y Crédito Público (Ministry of Finance and Public Credit - MHCP) July 05, 2012 TBD TBD 1. Key development issues and rationale for Bank involvement The efficiency and productivity of Colombia’s urban system will be a key determinant in the ability of the country to transition from a middle to a higher income economy. Urban activities are an important factor in the Colombia’s growth. Economic growth is strongly driven by commodities in Colombia and other Latin American countries. However primarily urban activities in manufacturing, services and retail sectors also account for an important part of economic growth. Urban activities combined1 have contributed to more than 50 percent of GDP’s growth rate2 in the last four decades. Challenges persist to secure sustainable, productive and inclusive cities in Colombia. Safe and more efficient public transportation is vital to secure mobility, access to opportunities, and productivity in cities. Deficits in public space and low income housing present serious challenges for security and quality of life. Persistent inequality in access to public services such as water and sanitation must be addressed. Improved disaster risk management in land planning is key to mitigating the risks and reducing the high social and economic costs of natural disasters. The quantitative and qualitative housing deficit must be met. Better inter-jurisdictional coordination can help to spread the benefits and diminish negative externalities associated with urbanization. Improved connectivity is vital to support increased productivity and trade, and help support a more efficient system of cities. These challenges are outlined in greater depth below. 2. Proposed objective(s) The proposed operation is for US$100 million. This program has been designed to support Colombia’s National Development Plan 2010-2014 covering three policy areas (See Table 1). The program objective is to support the strengthening of the Government of Colombia’s policy framework on productive and sustainable cities, specifically, policy and regulatory 1 Commerce, restaurants, hotels, manufacture, financing and other services to support among others Urbanization Review calculations based on a moving average of the component of the economy’s growth rate contributed by purely urban activities. 2 reforms that aim to: (a) improve access to basic water and sanitation, urban transport and environmental services for the urban poor; (b) mitigate the vulnerability of the urban poor to natural disasters and promote the provision of affordable and safe low-income housing solutions; (c) strengthen the ability of subnational entities to coordinate and finance the structuring and implementation of regional and metropolitan development initiatives; and (d) improve the productivity of the system of cities through improved connectivity within the network of cities and between cities and ports to external markets. 3. Preliminary expected outcomes include: More large cities with minimum standards for DRM assessment guidelines in land use plans Increase among very poorest residents who are connected to neighborhood water and sanitation networks in large cities Increase in availability of public spaces in large cities Reduction in road fatalities in large cities Increase in number of low-income families with access to affordable and safe housing More regional Contract Plans signed between territorial entities with development objectives that benefit lower-income segments Number of urban PPPs structured Number of intra-urban road construction and maintenance concessions structured 4. Preliminary description The operation is designed as a programmatic series of two Development Policy Loans which aim to support the strengthening of the Government of Colombia’s policy framework on productive and sustainable cities. Table 1: Matrix of Prior Actions for the Programmatic Sustainable and Productive Cities Development Policy Loan Series Medium-term Phase 1- Prior Actions Objective Policy Area 1: Sustainable and Inclusive Cities Establish a multiPrior Action 1: Creation by sector policy Presidential Decree of the Subframework that aims Directorate for Regional and to increase the Subnational Planning within productivity, National Planning Department. sustainability and (Decree TBD of 2012) inclusiveness of Colombia’s system of cities. Facilitate improved Prior Action 2: Facilitate water access to basic and sanitation network services for low connections for low-income income households families through the regulation across Colombian through Ministerial Decree of cities. subsidies for household water and Phase 2 – Indicative Triggers Policy Trigger 1: Approve a CONPES national policy document for strengthening the efficiency and sustainability of the Colombian ‘System of Cities’. Policy Trigger 2: Revision of Decree 3200 of 2007, updating the Departmental Plan framework for the provision of investment to poor small and medium cities to deepen the coverage and quality of water . sanitation connections. (Ministerial Regulatory Decree 1350 of 2012) Prior Action 3: Increase urban and inter-urban road safety through the approval by Ministerial Resolution for a National Road Safety Plan. (Ministry Resolution 1282 of 2012 – National Road Safety Plan 20112016) Increase the environmental efficiency of Colombian cities with stronger risk management systems and an improved framework for urban environmental management, urban redevelopment and the creation of public space. Prior Action 4: Strengthen the regulatory framework for integrated transportation planning in medium-sized cities. (Ministerial Regulatory Decree for Strategic Public Transport Systems – SETP). Prior Action 5: Regulate minimum criteria for natural risks assessment and disaster risk management incorporation in municipal land use management plans (POTs). (Ministerial Decree TBD of 2012) Prior Action 6: Approve national policy guidelines to promote the creation of public spaces in urban areas (CONPES 3718 of 2012 – National Policy on Public Spaces) Prior Action 7: Creation of a National Urban Redevelopment Company to support the structuring of urban redevelopment projects. (Presidential Decree 4184 of 2011 – National Urban Redevelopment Company- EMBARCO). Policy Area #2: Access to Affordable Housing Increase access to Prior Action 8: Approve Law affordable housing for renewing national housing low-income program to increase the supply of households. affordable market-rate housing solutions. (Law 208 of 2011 - and sanitation services. Policy Trigger 3: Approve CONPES national policy document detailing the creation of a new legal framework for urban transport demand management. Policy Trigger 4: Approve CONPES national policy document that lays out the National Policy for Integrated Public Transport Systems. Policy Trigger 5: Revision of Mass Transit Law 86 of 1989 and Law 310 of 1996. Policy Trigger 6: Regulate through Ministerial Decree a methodology for identifying municipal inventory of at-risk human settlements. Policy Trigger 7: Regulate through Ministerial Decree regulating urban noise pollution from fixed and mobile sources. Policy Trigger 8: Approve Ministerial Decree regulating Law 208 of 2011 to define municipal fiscal responsibilities and benefits involved in implementing National Macroproyectos National Social Interest Housing Program) Macroproyectos of Social Interest Housing Program Law. Prior Action 9: Regulate through Ministerial Decree the provision of residential leasing and lease-toown subsidies targeting families in the informal sector. (Ministerial Regulatory Decree 3911 of February 2012 – Residential Leasing Program) Policy Trigger 9: Approve Ministerial Resolution regulating Law TBD of 2012 to define framework for social and condominial management of public housing assets. Prior Action 10: Approve Law establishing a national policy for the provision of public housing to the extreme poor. (Law 1537 of June 2012 – Law of Access to Affordable Public Housing) Policy Area #3: Institutional Strengthening and Regional Coordination Increase inter-urban Prior Action 11: Approve Law on Policy Trigger 10: TBD. and regional Territorial Planning permitting (Regulatory Decree on Specific coordination on subnational entities to establish Issues in the Municipal Land Use strategic development partnerships that facilitate Management Law – TBD) initiatives through the regional-level planning and approval of fiscal implementation. (Law 1454 of Policy Trigger 11: Consolidate incentives and 2011 – Organic Territorial Land the municipal governance structure coordination Use Planning Law) to increase inter-municipal instruments. coordination in de facto Prior Action 12: Approve metropolitan areas through a Ministerial Decree regulating metropolitan areas law. ‘Contract Plans’, an administrative figure enabling municipalities and subnational entities to jointly plan, develop, finance and implement development activities at a metropolitan and regional scale. (Ministerial Regulatory Decree 819 of April 2012 – Contract Plans) Policy Area #4: Urban Connectivity and Regional Infrastructure Finance Increase the economic Prior Action 13: Approve Policy Trigger 12: Approve efficiency of urban Ministerial Decree creating the CONPES national policy system by improving National Agency for Infrastructure document that articulates a logistics-based with provisions to improve national policy on management connectivity between technical, legal and financial contracts for the national road Colombian cities and capacity of the agency to structure system (‘CREMA’). between Colombian regional infrastructure cities and external concessions. (Decree 4165 of Policy Trigger 13: Approve markets. November 2011 - Creation of National Agency for Infrastructure, ANI) Strengthen framework for the structuring of PPPs for urban and regional infrastructure Prior Action 14: Approve Law establishing framework for the structuring and financing of public-private partnerships (Law 1508 of April 2012 – Law for Public-Private Partnership - PPPs). CONPES national policy document that outlines a Road System Plan with the aim of restructuring, detailing, and clarifying development, management, and maintenance responsibilities for the national road network. Policy Trigger 14: Approve Ministerial Decree regulating the PPP Law to provide a framework of guidelines for PPP structuring, financing, and management. 5. Distributional and Gender Aspects The efficient management of cities and urban areas will be the key determinants of whether Colombia will be able to cash in on a potential growth dividend to reduce poverty and inequality. This operation is expected to have significant positive impacts for the poor by providing support to the GoC’s policies that seek to improve the productivity, sustainability and inclusiveness of cities in Colombia. In order to carefully evaluate the impacts of the policies proposed, a robust PSIA will be conducted. 6. Environmental Aspects The DPL includes specific measures to strengthen environmental management, and other prior actions could also contribute to environmental protection. It is expected that the policies and reforms supported by this operation will have net positive environmental impacts in all policy areas noted above, including improved capacity for environmental management and planning, improved waste management, better efficiency and reach of public transit and possible reductions in fleet size, less congestion, and air pollutant emissions, and improvements such as bikeways, upgraded pavements and green areas; better environmental management in territorial planning with improved security of water supply and sanitation and strengthened integrated watershed management and benefits associated with reduced informal and at-risk housing. 7. Tentative Financing Source: International Bank for Reconstruction and Development Total ($100m.) 100,000,000