Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Through this unit the lessons build towards several Performance Expectations in the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) as well as the Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts (CCSS ELA). It is important to remember that the lessons cannot be taught in isolation or the standards will not be addressed. Although the CCSS ELA standards cited here are at the second grade level, the anchor standards from which they were developed can be found at all grade levels. Next Generation Science Standards K-2-ETS1-1. Ask questions, make observations, and gather information about a situation people want to change to define a simple problem that can be solved through the development of a new or improved object or tool. K-2-ETS1-2. Develop a simple sketch, drawing, or physical model to illustrate how the shape of an object helps it function as needed to solve a given problem. K-2-ETS1-3. Analyze data from tests of two objects designed to solve the same problem to compare the strengths and weaknesses of how each performs. 2-PS1-1. Plan and conduct an investigation to describe and classify different kinds of materials by their observable properties. 2-PS1-2. Analyze data obtained from testing different materials to determine which materials have the properties that are best suited for an intended purpose.* Common Core State Standards in English Language Arts Literacy CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.2.1 Ask and answer such questions as who, what, where, when, why, and how to demonstrate understanding of key details in a text. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.2.2 Recount stories, including fables and folktales from diverse cultures, and determine their central message, lesson, or moral. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.2.3 Describe how characters in a story respond to major events and challenges. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.2.7 Use information gained from the illustrations and words in a print or digital text to demonstrate understanding of its characters, setting, or plot. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RL.2.9 Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story (e.g., Cinderella stories) by different authors or from different cultures. To address this standard the Teacher Tip on page 59 has guidance regarding reading versions of the “Three Little Pigs.” Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Informational Text CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RI.2.1 Ask and answer such questions as who, what, where, when, why, and how to demonstrate understanding of key details in a text. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RI.2.2 Identify the main topic of a multiparagraph text as well as the focus of specific paragraphs within the text. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.RI.2.3 Describe the connection between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text. Writing CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W.2.8 Recall information from experiences or gather information from provided sources to answer a question. Speaking and Listening CCSS.ELA-Literacy.SL.2.2 Recount or describe key ideas or details from a text read aloud or information presented orally or through other media. CCSS.ELA-Literacy.SL.2.3 Ask and answer questions about what a speaker says in order to clarify comprehension, gather additional information, or deepen understanding of a topic or issue. Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Grade Level: Basic (Grades 1-2) with Advanced (Grades 3-5) Adaptations Title: Sticky Situation Designing Walls Lesson: Prep Lesson~ Topic: Materials Engineering Technology in a Bag Unit Learning Targets: Engineering, Technology and the Application of Science Science and Engineering Practice P8 Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information Time For Lesson: 30-40 Minutes without Supports 50-60 Minutes with Migrant Supports Content Objectives: (Student Friendly) I can identify everyday objects made by people as technology. I can identify engineers as people who design objects to help people. Focus Question: What are technologies and who designs them? Cross Cutting Concepts CCC 1 Patterns CCC 6 Structure and Function Language Objectives:(Throughout unit make sure all four language modalities, reading, writing, speaking and listening are addressed) I can talk with my group to discuss why an object is a technology and discuss who creates these technologies. I can write complete sentences to share my ideas about what an object can do and what problems that object solve. Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Student Engagement: Leadership I can work with other people in my group cooperatively by showing respect, making good decisions and solving problems. Developing Relationships Making Choices Setting Goals Problem Solving Future Action Planning Students discuss in groups what an object does, who created that object and what problem the object solves. (Discussion of how problems can be solved through technologies) - Prior to Preparatory prepare students to work in cooperative teams by using the GLAD Strategy of T-Chart of Social Skills- Set up groups, define cooperation - Utilize the strategy of Numbered Heads together - Utilize Super Scientist Awards Key Vocabulary: Lesson Supports Materials: Super Engineer Awards Brown Paper Bag EngineeringT-Chart of Social Skills Materials from Pg. 33 Engineer Number Spoons Include materials from the Material (Graphic Organizers, Adapted Texts, Notes, migrant lifestyle Problem Photos, Charts, Realia) - Asparagus cutter Technology Inquiry Chart - Trompo Solution What is… - Molcajete - Recipe card for An Engineer Technology Other Vocabulary: traditional dish List of objects in bags found Panuelo on page 33. (Realia) Template Chart-With Questions Higher Order Questions: What is an engineer? What is technology? Do you know someone who is an engineer? What kind of work do they do? During Lesson: Template/Chart… - Is the object natural or human-made? - What is material(s) is it made of? - What problem does it solve? - How else could you use it? - What other materials could the object be made of? - Who do you think creates these technologies? Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Social and Cultural Processes: Adding migrant related realia during the Technology in a Bag activity. Building Background Activities Introduction on pages 34-35 Comprehensible Input and Output - Charts-T Chart of Social Skills - Charts: Inquiry Chart - Realia-Items in Bag - EL Achieve Cards during student discussions-Specific StrategiesShare your Thinking Card Learning Strategies: Student Activities Student Notebooks Learning Log-at the end of the notebook (write or sketch) Charts Practice and Application: Discussion of realia in bags Technology Around Us Worksheet P-1 Student Interaction Discussion and Discourse of objects (EL Achieve Cards-Present and Idea… I think…, I noticed that… Collaboration using “Leadership” team building using Social Skills and Number Heads. Positive Interdependence Student Reflection Return to the Inquiry Chart What is an Engineer-What is technology) (See page 37) Realize that nearly everything we use is engineered, that we all engage in engineering… How did you work in your group? Review and Assessment A-1 and A-2 Prior to the Lesson- Place in notebook. At the end of the unit Parental Support Opportunities Home-School Connection: Take or draw a picture, or bring in real object of a “technology” found in the child’s home. Explain how it is used in the child’s home, explain what problem it solves, who created it. Ask your parents the following question: - What technology do you remember your parents (child’s grandparents) using? - How has the technology changed from your parents to your generation? Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Grade Level: Basic (Grades 1-2) with Advanced (Grades 3-5) Adaptations Title: Sticky Situation Designing Lesson: Lesson One Walls Yi-Min’s Great Wall Topic: Materials Engineering Focus Question: What is a material? What are the properties of materials? What is a materials engineer? Unit Learning Targets: (Big Ideas Built Over Time) Structure and Properties of Matter Engineering Design Process Science and Engineering Practice Cross Cutting Concepts Time For Lesson: 2-3 Class Periods 90- 120 Minutes without Migrant Supports 3 Class Periods 120-150 Minutes with Migrant Supports Content Objectives: Language Objectives: I know that engineers solve problems by designing solutions. I know the Engineering Design Process can help solve problems. Materials have properties. I know some materials are good choices for some things, but not good choices for other things. I can listen to a story that has a problem that will need to be solved. I can read a story about a girl engineer, Yi Min. I can talk about materials engineering. I can write or sketch a short description of each step in the Engineering Design Process. Student Engagement Developing Relationships Making Choices Setting Goals Problem Solving Future Action Planning Continue working on T-Graph of Social Skills- Add to the list what dos cooperation look like? What evidence have you seen? What does cooperation sound like? What evidence have you heard? Collect more ideas from the class. “What does teamwork look like when you are having a discussion?” “What does it sound like?” Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Key Vocabulary Other Vocabulary: clay design engineer Engineering Design Process material materials engineer mixture mortar properties solution technology structures Ni hao mooncake Lao Shi Yangtze bamboo reeds bandit creativity crumbled detective emperor material mortar munch seedlings Lesson Supports (Graphic Organizers, Adapted Texts, Notes, Photos, Charts, Realia) Big Book of Engineers Observation Charts Materials: (Science Lesson Specific Materials, test tubes, rocks) Student handoutsSection One Basic or Advanced depending on grade level Big Book Observation Charts Higher Order Questions: (See Lesson Specific Questions Embedded within Lesson) Social and Cultural Processes: Change Pre-Reading Questions to reflect the migrant lifestyle. Example… Do you know someone who works on a farm? Describe the farm? What grows on the farm? Building Background Activities Observation charts-earth materials, farm technologies, engineers Big Book of Engineers Comprehensible Input and Output Learning Strategies: Student - Charts: Observation Charts Activities - Charts: T-Graph of Social Which Material Would you Choose Skills Worksheet 1-5 Individually - EL Achieve Cards during Get into small group-decide which student discussions-Specific material/materials would make the Strategiesbest wall as a team. Create a larger Agree-Disagree Reflection picture of what would make the Pg. 50 best wall-defend with the class *Could evolve into “Sticky Note and Language Scaffolds” Add/Revise/Question with sticky notes and discussion cards Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Practice and Application: Engineering Design Process (1-6, 17) Vocabulary: (1-8, 1-9) Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Student Interaction Before reading Chapter Four students work in pairs to complete 1-5 or 1-4 As a class make a list of materials Yi-min and Chen could use to build their wall-connect these with earth materials Teams decide which materials would make the best walls through pictures/labels with the context of this challenge. (Small Group Models http://tools4teachingscience.org/ ) Student Reflection Reflection of student materials and reflection of empowerment as a result of the lesson Review and Assessment Lesson One “What is a Materials Engineer” online assessments. Give A or B depending on age of student. Parental Support Opportunities Home School Connection: Adapt Student Sheet 1-10 to reflect construction in Mexico or other relevant culture. Ideas could be historical construction from their background or asking parents what their homes were constructed. Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Grade Level: Basic (Grades 1-2) with Advanced (Grades 3-5) Adaptations Title: Sticky Situation Designing Lesson 2: Materials and Their Uses Focus Question: Walls What makes a material a good or Topic: Materials Engineering poor choice for a particular task? - - Keeping Warm Carrying Eggs Sitting Cleaning the Floor Unit Learning Targets: (Big Ideas Built Over Time) Structure and Properties of Matter Science and Engineering Practice P7 Engaging in argument from evidence Time For Lesson: Cross Cutting Concepts CCC 6 Structure and function Prep 5-10 Minutes Lesson 50-60 minutes without enhancements Lesson 2 days 40 minutes with enhancements Content Objectives: (Student Friendly) - I will learn that the same problem can be solved in many ways using different materials. - I will learn that materials have properties that make them good choices for certain uses and poor choices for other uses. - I will learn that material can be used in different ways to solve different problems. Language Objectives: - I can speak to my partner about what material is the best choice for a particular problem and give reasons to support my answer. - I can write down a claim and back it up with evidence about why a particular material is best for solving a problem. - I can read Chapter Four to find the steps in the design process. Student Engagement Developing Relationships Making Choices Setting Goals Problem Solving Future Action Planning Developing Relationships: Continue working on T-Graph of Social Skills- Add to the list what does cooperation look like? What evidence have you seen? What does cooperation sound like? What evidence have you heard? Collect more ideas from the class. “What does teamwork look like when you are having a discussion?” “What does it sound like?” Problem Solving: Students work in pairs. As students work in pairs think about how to solve a problem using different materials? Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Key Vocabulary: Vocabulary Specifically Taught before, during or reinforced after instruction Criteria-give examples Properties Purpose Use Other Vocabulary: Properties is a similar to the word to characteristics, qualities or attributes (in math). Lesson Supports (Graphic Organizers, Adapted Texts, Notes, Photos, Charts, Realia) Data Collection Chart for Class (2.9) Graphic Organizer-Design Process Picture on page 21-Have that viewed when re-reading chapter 4 from Yi Min’s Great Wall Think-Pair Share Materials: (Realia) - Cloth - Straw - Brick - Paper Higher Order Questions: (Model with first question-students will use the same process in pairs with a different question and same materials) What could you make a with a cloth to help keep you warm? What material is the blanket made of? What are some properties of this material? Which of those properties make this material a good choice for keeping warm? Which material do you think would be best to use to keep warm? Why? Let’s make a claim about how material could make you warm, then back this up with evidence. Social and Cultural Processes: During introduction- use the metal spoon and the t-shirt to discuss the properties of the object and the properties of the material. Also include objects from the migrant lifestyle in addition for more practice. Ideas could include-bandanas, asparagus cutters Building Background Activities Read Three Little Havelinas (pigs) Comprehensible Input and Output - Charts: Observation Charts - Charts: T-Graph of Social Skills - EL Achieve Cards during student discussions-Specific Strategies- Cite Evidence (Change to reflect grade level) Learning Strategies: Student Activities Model process of Keeping Warm with four objects as a class - Keeping Warm Do worksheets 2-1 through 2-3 depending on age/level together Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Practice and Application: Work through other challenges in pairs… - - Carrying Eggs Sitting Cleaning the Floor Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Student Interaction Whole Group Pairs Individual reflections in notebooks Student Reflection Go over all challenges regarding best materials for the job-class chart Student Notebook- Claims, Evidence and Justification for materials type Review and Assessment EiE Assessments A/B-Multi Level A Advanced Level B Basic Level Parental Support Opportunities: Home School Connections Find several objects in your home. What properties does your object have? What properties does the material of the object have? Ask parents about how they might have used the design process in their home. Draw the steps in solving a home problem that was solved through engineering, like grandpa. Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Grade Level: Basic (Grades 1-2) with Advanced (Grades 3-5) Adaptations Title: Sticky Situation Designing Lesson 3: Testing Mortar Walls Part One: Wall Walk Topic: Materials Engineering Part Two: Testing Mortar Part Three: Sticky Test and Earthquake Test Unit Learning Targets: (Big Ideas Built Over Time) Focus Question: Which earth materials make a good mortar that is sticky (adhesive) and durable? Structure and Properties of Matter Engineering, Technology and the Application of Science Science and Engineering Practice Cross Cutting Concepts P1 Asking questions and defining problems CCC 2 Cause and effect P2 Developing and using a model CCC 6 Structure and function P3 Planning and carrying out investigations P4 Analyzing and interpreting data P8 Obtaining, evaluating and communicating information Time For Lesson: Part 1: Prep 5 minutes- Lesson 20-30 minutes w/o enhancements 30-40 minutes w/ enhancements Part 2: Prep 15-20 minutes- Lesson 50-60 minutes w/o enhancements 40 minutes over 2 days w/ enhancements Part 3: Prep 5 minutes- Lesson 40 minutes w/o enhancements 50-60 minutes w/ enhancements Content Objectives: Language Objectives: 1. I can analyze the properties of earth materials to 1. I can discuss with my partner the features of make the strongest mortar. different walls. 2. I can gather evidence to begin t 2. I can listen to the ideas my partner has about 3. I can compare the results of a controlled which earth material will make the best mortar. investigation. 3. I can record the properties of dry and wet earth materials. Student Engagement Developing Relationships Making Choices Setting Goals Problem Solving Future Action Planning Students begin the design process by asking a question of which material makes the best mortar. Students conduct a fair/controlled investigation to determine an answer for two specific tests. After looking at the results, students will see the properties of the three soil types do not make good mortars and will be asked to develop ideas to make a stronger mortar by mixing soils types together. Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Key Vocabulary: durability experiment mixture mortar particle predict property test Other Vocabulary: Lesson Supports Lesson Part One: Use a box and t chart to show the similarities and differences of different walls students observed. adhesive-stickiness adhesion tests (advanced) failure (testing to the point of…) Materials: (Science Lesson Specific Materials, test tubes, rocks) See materials list on page 75 Buckets of soapy water for clean up Preparation notes specifically tell how to set up materials for lesson. Overnight drying of mortar is required between Part 2 and 3 of this lesson. Higher Order Questions: - How are these walls the same? How are the walls different? (Looking at walls) - What do you think mortar is used for? Do you have any guesses as to what materials are used to make mortar? (Design and construct own wall) - What are some properties that you think a good mortar should have? - How do you think we could test our mortar sandwiches to determine if soil, sand and clay have properties that make a good mortar? - Why do engineers test to the point of failure? Social and Cultural Processes: Show pictures of walls, with and without mortar from students’ backgrounds. Building Background Activities Wall Walk (Part One) Looking different walls thinking about how they are the same and different and how their structure is made to support a specific purpose. (Students will look at four walls on their walk sketching and making notes regarding the features of each wall Work with samples of soil, sand and clay. Comprehensible Input and Output Learning Strategies: Practice and Application: Chart with properties of good Model with Student Sheet 3.2 and Students work either individually mortar-with revisions throughout 3.3 properties of dry and wet soil. or in groups to add to their student lesson sheets for the properties of sand and clay. Student Interaction Students work in pairs to describe properties of earth materials Students work in pairs to complete both sticky test and earthquake tests Students share results of tests to the class. Student Reflection See guiding questions on page 89 Reflect on the properties students learned about dry and wet earth materials Reflect on how the lesson they completed relates to the field of materials engineering. Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Review and Assessment Student Rubric for the following areas: Observations of walls, describing properties of earth materials, making predictions, analyzing’s results of mortar and comparing results of controlled experiment (3-8 and 3-9) Parental Support Opportunities: Home School Connections Draw a wall from your home either inside or outside. What is the purpose of the wall? What is the wall made out of? How does your wall stay up? What are earth materials near your home that could be used for mortar? Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Grade Level: Basic (Grades 1-2) with Advanced (Grades 3-5) Adaptations Title: Sticky Situation Lesson 4-Designing a Wall Focus Question: Designing Walls Part One: Ask/Imagine How can we use the Engineering Design Process Topic: Materials Engineering and Plan to design a wall using rocks and a mortar make Part Two: Create of a mixture of earth materials? Part Three: Create and Improve Part Four: Improve Unit Learning Targets: (Big Ideas Built Over Time) Structure and Properties of Matter Engineering, Technology and the Application of Science Science and Engineering Practice P1 Asking questions and defining problems P2 Developing and using a model P3 Planning and carrying out investigations P4 Analyzing and interpreting data P6 Constructing explanations and designing solutions P7 Engaging in argument from evidence P8 Obtaining, evaluating and communicating information Unit Learning Targets: (Big Ideas Built Over Time) Science and Engineering Practice Cross Cutting Concepts CCC 2 Cause and effect CCC 4 Systems and system models CCC 6 Structure and function Cross Cutting Concepts Time For Lesson: Part One: Ask, Imagine, Plan- 50 Minutes Part Two: Create- 50 Minutes *** Allow 24-48 hours between Parts Two and Three *** Part Three: Create, Improve- 60 Minutes Part Four: Improve 60 Minutes Content Objectives: Language Objectives: I can use the engineering design process to solve a problem. I can analyze the strengths and weakness of my design and make improvements. I can read Yi Min’s Great Wall and compare what I did with what Yi Min did to solve a problem. (Throughout unit make sure all four language modalities, reading, writing, speaking and listening are addressed) Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Student Engagement Developing Relationships Making Choices Setting Goals Problem Solving Future Action Planning Based on what students learned in lesson three, students will be asked to work together to create a mortar that will enable a wall to be more structurally sound. Students will need to make action plans of how their walls will look and other earth materials to strengthen mortar. In the final part of Lesson 4 students will be asked to optimize their mortars by redesign their mortars with other earth materials. These lessons lend themselves to connect with planning ahead in other areas of school and home. Key Vocabulary: Lesson Supports demolition design engineering design process goal mortar predict problem redesign teamwork test Part 1: Activity 10 tells students that they will get 20 rocks and the walls should be around 3” tall. Point out that these are constraints that engineers work within. Part 2 and 3: Sentence Frames or Observational Organizer in science notebooks I noticed… I observed… When the…. Part 4: Use claims and evidence to answer the following: “Did the redesign of the mortar strengthen the wall? Other Vocabulary: constraintsoptimize-Lesson 4 with materials outside unit soil types such as twigs and hay. Materials: Lesson materials for each section… Cleaning supplies resealable containers to hold earth materials Create a Demolition Ball Assembly-See handout 4-10 See Videos on Engineering is Elementary Websitehttp://www.eie.org/classroom_video/u nit/earth-materials Higher Order Questions: (See Lesson Specific Questions Embedded within Lesson) Social and Cultural Processes: Building Background Activities Review Yi Min’s Great Wall (Have students go back through story or pictures to review the engineering design process Review the steps in the design process and ask what step in the process did we do in Lesson 3? (Page 99) Comprehensible Input and Learning Strategies: Practice and Application: Output : Part 1: Demonstrate a Part 1: Students create their own mixture based Use student sheets to create new mixture for mortar on what they have learned. booklet for students using and have students analyze the design process- Student if that would be a good sheets for ask, imagine, plan, mixture. (Page 101) create and improve Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14 Engineering is Elementary ~ A Sticky Situation: Designing Walls Migrant Lesson Plan Template-Materials Engineering Student Interaction Students work in pairs to decide what mixture of soil types they will use to make a stronger mortar. Students work in teams to go through the design process. Students share results of tests to the class. Student Reflection Building a Wall What worked well… What were some Part 2: Use a t chart to reflect on the building of challenges… the wall. Part 3: Use sentence frames or observational organizer to bring out ideas how their walls reacted to the demolition test. Part 4: Refection Questions on page 120. Review and Assessment Administer the Pre-Post Test within the Engineering is Elementary Unit in the Assessment Tab Parental Support Opportunities: Home School Connection With your family describe a problem that had to be solved using the design process. Examples include how to make a special family recipe. How did you find ways to make the “system of making something” go more smoothly, or faster? Science Model Collaborative Washington State MEP/OSPI Work Group 2013-14