Ms Paine 11 ENGLISH Name:____________________ V FOR VENDETTA - KEY IDEAS AND TECHNIQUES – ANSWERS 2014 V for Vendetta is a thought-provoking film that aims to challenge the viewer through several central ideas. Look at each idea listed, and think of at least two examples of its portrayal in the movie and an appropriate techniques. *PLEASE NOTE: These Ms Paine’s own notes and are not in anyway exhaustive. KEY IDEAS MESSAGE – What does the film have to say about this idea? EXAMPLES Find at least two examples TECHNIQUES USED How are these ideas conveyed through at least two techniques. 1. Political Ideas – V for Vendetta as dystopian fiction The film depicts a struggle between freedom and the state. Is explicit in portraying V as the embodiment of an idea rather than an individual through V's dialogue and by depicting him without a past, identity or face. V becomes more than just a man with a revolutionary idea – he becomes the idea itself: "Beneath this mask there is an idea, Mr Creedy, and ideas are bullet-proof." Specifically creates a society in which individual rights and freedoms are subsumed by the idea of collective security – which includes a clearing out from society of anyone who does not fit the accepted norm. Offers two scenarios for undermining a regime: V's violence and Gordon's satire. V's violence works because it lights a spark in the people who respond with their own violence (riots) and with peaceful protest (at the end). Gordon's satire costs him his life – yet will have contributed to the new political consciousness raising. As Mel Brooks has said, you can't compete with dictators by making speeches – that is what they are good at, and it is how they get power. Satire and ridicule are better weapons. 1. EXAMPLE: V speaks to the nation using the BTN Emergency Channel. In this scene, V’s political motives are clearly explained in this speech that he delivers to the nation. 1. a) TECNIQUES: MONTAGE: A montage of shots edited closely together show the reach of V’s message, as they show an upper middle class family watching their broadcast in the living room, a working class pub and a nursing home. b) VOICE-OVER NARRATION: Layered over the footage, is V’s speech as a voice over in which he explains his argument for revolution. 2. EXAMPLE: Final scene, when the crowd outside the Houses of 2. Parliament remove their Guy Fawkes masks and a) several characters who have died during the narrative are seen. By wearing the Guy Fawkes masks, the crowd highlight how V’s idea of rebellion is supported by everyone, no matter who they are or where they come from. TECHNIQUES: SYMBOLISM: V’s Guy Fawkes mask becomes a symbol of revolution, because as he says to Creedy, “Beneath this mask there is more than flesh. Beneath this mask there is an idea….and ideas are bullet proof.” This is especially poignant as when the crowd marchs on Parliament, they are symbolically wearing these masks. 2. Truth and lies Although an important part of the story is Finch's pursuit and uncovering of the truth behind the government, the film suggests a more complex approach to truth and lies. the film questions the honesty of the news; suggests TV's main role is to distract the population from the real problems the Sutler government created and used a lie to gain power – with clear parallels to 'weapons of mass destruction' used to take a country into a war they can't win 1. EXAMPLE: In the first meeting of the inner cabnet they discuss ways in which to distort the truth and fabricate a lie that the Old Bailey was actually scheduled for destruction. 1. TECHNIQUES a) MIS-EN-SCENE: The huge video screen of the High Chancellor dominates the inner cabinet room, like his desire to cover up the explosion of the Old Bailey. b) LIGHTING Each member of the inner cabinet emerges from darkness and shadows, which is a metaphor, for their desire to conceal and hide the truth from the general populace. 3. Masks and identity ties in with the idea that we hide our real self behind 'masks'; and that if we wear our symbolic masks too long we forget who we really are. V's use of the Guy Fawkes mask and persona functions on both practical and symbolic levels. He wears the mask to hide his physical scars, and in obscuring his identity, becomes more than just a man with a revolutionary idea – he becomes the idea itself. Though he – like Guy Fawkes – might be defeated, ideas of freedom and justice can endure and retain their power. 1. EXAMPLE: V and Gordon’s masks – V wears the symbolic Guy Fawkes mask which hides his identitiy, where as Gordon hides his homosexuality behind his career as a successful tv presenter and comedian. 1. TECHNIQUES a) MIS-EN-SCENE Both V and Gordon have hidden places in which they store cultural artifacts like books and artworks that the Norsefire regime considers objectionable. b) NARRATIVE STRUCTURE Each man cooks “eggy in a basket” for Evey strengthening the parallels between them. 4. Story-telling The importance of telling our stories is implicit throughout. Much is explained via the back-stories of character Valerie's story is instrumental in politicising both V and Evey. She refers to the need to tell her story: My name is Valerie. I don't think I'll live much longer, and I wanted to tell someone about my life. This is the only autobiography that I will ever write… Finch comes to an understanding of the truth through uncovering the past, helped by the stories of Delia and 'Rookwood'. What you want – what you really need – is a story. It is stories that link the facts so they make sense. Evey says V will understand her when he knows her story; Finch uncovers her story and that of her family, revealing the treatment of dissidents and protestors Delia's story reveals the horror hidden behind the government's façade. In V's address to the nation he explicitly refers to the power of words: …words will always retain their power. Words offer the means to meaning, and for those who will listen, the enunciation of truth. 1. EXAMPLE: Valerie’s story is integral to the politicisation of V and Evey. 1. TECHNIQUES a) EDITING & SOUND When Evey reads Valerie’s story, Valerie’s story is inserted into the narrative through editing and the use of a voice-over narration. b) LIGHTING A yellow coloured filter is also placed over the camera to give the flashbacks a different colour palate to the shots of Evie in the cell.