EVALUATION REPORT (As Per Rule 35 of PP Rules, 2004) 1. Name of Procuring Agency: Ministry of Planning, Development & Reform (General Section) 2. Method of Procurement: 3. Title of Procurement: Open Competitive Bidding Single Stage-One Envelope procedure. Photo –state machines, copy printer and Furniture items 4. 5. Tender Inquiry No.: PPRA Ref. No. (TSE): PID (1)4235/14 Photo-State Machines : TS-234491-E 6. 7. 8. 9. Date & Time of Bid Closing: Date & Time of Bid Opening: No. of Bids Received: Criteria for Bid Evaluation: 24-03-2015 at 11:00 a.m. 24-03-2015 at 12:00 noon 06 (Six) Terms & Conditions mentioned in the tender advertised on PPRA website 10. Details of Bid(s) Evaluation: Comparative Statement Marks Technical Financial (if applicable) (if applicable) Name of Bidder Evaluated Cost (Rs) Rule/Regulation/ Policy/ Basis for Rejection/ Acceptance as per Rule 35 of PP Rules, 2004 Bid rejected on the basis of whole life value calculated and specifications. Bid rejected on the basis of specifications and non-provision of pay order. M/S Universal Business, Islamabad for supply of photo copiers - - - M/S GEMCO Islamabad for supply of photo copiers - - - - - - Bid rejected on specifications. - - - Bid accepted on the basis of better specifications. - - - Bid rejected on the basis of specifications. - - - Bid accepted on the basis of lowest rates and better specifications. M/S SAVIN works here Islamabad for supply of photo copiers M/S OAG Office Automation Group Islamabad for supply of photo copiers M/S Machine Traders Rawalpindi for supply of photo copiers M/S Gestetner Hascombe Business Islamabad for supply of copy printer Lowest Evaluated Bidder: 11. 1. M/S OAG Office Automation Group Islamabad for supply of photo copiers 2. M/S Gestetner Hascombe Business Islamabad for supply of copy printer the Any other additional/supporting information, the procuring agency may like to share. Signature: …………………………………. Official Stamp ………………………………….. basis of No. 5(2)/Gen/PD/2014 GOVERNMENT OF PAKISATAN MINISTRY OF PLANNING, DEVELOPMENT AND REFORM (General Section) Islamabad the, 22nd April 2015 To, Mr. Rizwan Mehmood, Assistant Director-II Public Procurement Regulatory Authority Federal Bank for Co-operatives Building, Sector G-5/2, Behind State Bank Building ISLAMABAD SUBJECT:- UPLOADING OF BIDS EVALUATION REPORT ON PPRA’S WEBSITE The undersigned is directed to refer to the above subject. In compliance with Rule-35 of the PPRA Rules please find enclosed herewith a copy along-with soft copy of the Bids Evaluation Report emailed at info@ppra.org.pk to be posted on the official website of the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority PPRA. 2. It is requested that the Evaluation Report may please be posted on the official web site of Public Procurement Regulatory Authority PPRA at www.ppra.org.pk. (Mansoor Ahmed Bajwa) Section Officer (General) PH.9207674 Copy for information to: i) ii) iii) APS to JS (Admin) DG (JACC) DS (Admin)