BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 A case study of change management: Greenfox at Linfox Pressures on organisations to adopt environmentally sustainable policies and practices are growing. The following case study examines the successful development and implementation of change arising from pressures for the business to become more environmentally sustainable and to reduce negative environmental impacts of the activities of the organisation. Linfox’s GreenFox policy is an example of a business implementing organisation-wide change with positive results, both for the environment and its balance sheet; all this from a business working within the transport sector, not one that has been traditionally bestowed with ‘green credentials’. Background Linfox is the largest privately owned supply chain solutions company in the Asia-Pacific region. The business was founded in Melbourne in 1956 by Lindsay Fox as a one-truck operation delivering soft drinks in summer and solid fuel for heating in winter. Currently, the business: operates more than 1.8 million square metres of warehousing space utilises a fleet of 5000 delivery vehicles employs more than 15 000 people has more than 260 operating sites operates across 11 countries in the Asia-Pacific region. Linfox caters for other businesses that outsource their warehousing and delivery requirements. Major clients include: Campbell Arnott’s (biscuits and snack foods) BlueScope Steel Kellogg’s BHP Billiton National Foods Ltd. Linfox annually: delivers more than 4.5 billion litres of fuels and 15 million pallets of goods to retailers annually, as well as 1 million tonnes of wood products serves nine of the Asia-Pacific region’s top consumer goods moving producers. Linfox is divided into three business units: Retail Business Unit Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) Business Unit Resources and Industrial Unit. Pressures for change at Linfox In 2006 Linfox’s North American customers began to ask questions about the impact that the transport industry was having on the environment. This showed that sustainability was becoming a core interest of important stakeholder groups, as well as longstanding issues like safety and operational efficiency and effectiveness. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 1 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 There was also a general increase in pressures on large organisations to adopt sustainable business practices around this time, emanating from: increased community awareness of and about ‘green’ issues, such as global warming, prompted by scientific research, environmental pressure groups and media coverage such as Al Gore’s film, An Inconvenient Truth—this placed pressures on both organisations and individuals to act in order to reduce their carbon footprint the possibility of increased productivity and reduced costs of production through a potential decrease in the use of resources, for example reduced fuel costs a potential competitive advantage is being seen as socially responsible through the adoption of a sustainable business model the introduction of a carbon tax on polluters, which will force all transport companies to adopt environmentally friendly and sustainable practices in order to survive and comply with government requirements. GreenFox Linfox initially developed a strategic plan for the 2008–11 period known as ‘GreenFox’. This program was designed to cut Linfox’s greenhouse gas emissions by 15 per cent of its 2006–2007 levels. Linfox’s energy consumption for the 2008–09 period was 95 per cent from transport fuels and 5 per cent from electricity. The three areas of focus were: improved business practices the introduction and development of environmentally friendly technologies changing the behaviours of people within the organisation. Linfox management accepted climate change as a reality from the onset. They saw themselves as having a responsibility to both their customers and to wider society to act on the environmental problem of greenhouse gas emissions. Every Linfox Board meeting now begins with a discussion about the company’s social obligations, including environmental responsibilities. The Linfox view of climate change We have accepted the scientific evidence that Climate Change, caused by Global Warming is a reality. We have accepted that, on balance, it is most probable that man-made emissions play a part in Global Warming. We have accepted that Transport is a significant contributor to manmade CO2-e emissions. We have accepted that everyone must play a part in reducing CO2-e emissions. We have adopted a plan based on a Greenhouse Gas Reduction Cycle that impacts on all aspects of our business. We regard reducing the use of energy and thereby emissions is good for the environment and good for business. Source: http://pdf.aigroup.asn.au/environment/GreenFox_Sust_transport.pdf VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 2 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 Key objectives and activities of GreenFox Leadership Lean organisation through business units for operating environmental controls. Adopting emissions controls. Coach/mentor/train all front-line leaders in environmental management. Behaviour Develop a visible environmental emissions minimisation culture. Involve our people in solutions to manage environmental emissions. Train our people to work in an environmentally sensitive way. Systems Comply with legislative requirements. Integrate environmental emissions into business processes. Improve efficiency through fleet reductions, information technology, and the supply chain solutions group. Initiatives to reduce greenhouse gas emissions Initiatives trialled by Linfox aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions included: 2007—Linfox engaged an accounting firm to identify areas of potential carbon emissions reduction. Eco Driver Training. Linfox drivers are encouraged to complete this program based on 10 principles of fuel-efficient driving. Those who complete the program are given a badge to wear on their uniform. Many have also opted to become ambassadors who go to schools to talk about climate change. Introduction of carbon-mapping software as part of supply chain optimisation. This software provides detailed analysis of carbon emissions from each element of the supply chain, right down to individual vehicle measurements of carbon emissions. This will help with identification of the environmental impact of logistics choices; for example, determining if the most efficient route is being taken, or to ensure that trucks never travel back from a job empty, or that the most efficient mode of transport is being selected. This carbon accounting system generates monthly reports, down to the level of individual trucks. It is an accurate tracking of emissions. A new fleet tracking system, with the aim of achieving improved vehicle utilisation. A hybrid or four-cylinder hire car policy. All company cars were to be replaced with hybrid vehicles at trade in. A tyre pressure-monitoring program designed to reduce fuel use, reduce emissions and improve safety. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 3 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 Electricity savings: project ‘Switch Off’ for all lights, computers, chargers, photocopiers in order to achieve electricity savings. Also, the installation of smarter warehouse lighting systems and the launch of a Linfox Energy Efficiency Guidebook in 2011, which was distributed to all employees. Use of ‘green’ energy. Introduction of paper recycling throughout the entire organisation. A Greenhouse Home Gas Calculator to be provided to all employees to educate them about greenhouse gas issues. Appointment of GreenFox workplace environment champions across the business to mentor and educate colleagues about greenhouse gas issues. Registering for the Energy Efficiencies Opportunity Legislation Act. Working with Monash University on the development of more aerodynamic vehicle designs. The 25C Project, which trials environmental initiatives at 25 sites. Participation in global environmental events such as World Environment Day and Earth Hour. GreenFox is directed to achieve cultural change regarding energy awareness and energy use. It focuses on individual actions and behaviours to inform, educate and change behaviours, both at work and at home. The creation of a new ‘green’ workplace culture is the ultimate goal. GreenFox is supported by newsletters, weekly tips and publications; all are designed to focus on reductions in energy use. In early 2011 an Environmental Management System (EMS) was introduced. This is designed to identify, control and record environmental performance on an ongoing basis across the company. It also ensures that a proper reporting system is in place, so that all sites meet legal obligations. Participative management styles and the participation of employees and customers in workshops have been used in order to identify the most practical and valuable initiatives. This staff engagement program is aimed at making better use of what the organisation has rather than investing in new technology. Staff are involved in initiating and implementing change in their own workplace. ‘Linfox has tried to inculcate its employees with a green approach to life generally which makes for a better environment wherever they’re operating.’ (David McInnes, Group Manager of Environment and Climate Change, Linfox) VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 4 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 Results/evaluation Between 2006–07 and 2008–09 a 16 per cent reduction in total energy use was achieved at Linfox. This was despite the fact that the total number of kilometres travelled by Linfox vehicles had increased by 21 per cent over that period of time, and the company had experienced 40 per cent growth over the period. Linfox is aiming to continue this trend. The rate of greenhouse emissions by Linfox has decreased each year since 2006–07 significantly. The 15 per cent target, originally set for 2010, was met in 2007–08 and a reduction of 28 per cent had been achieved by 2009. A further 10 per cent reduction was achieved during the 2009–2010 financial year. Massive savings have been made by Linfox in its fuel costs. Already these savings have outweighed the cost of implementing the GreenFox program. The Chairman of Linfox, Peter Fox, has since announced a new target: ‘Linfox will reduce its rate of greenhouse gas emissions from its global operations by 50 per cent by 2015 based on 2006–2007 emission levels’. Linfox was the recipient of the Logistics Magazine 2009 inaugural Best Green Initiative Award. Linfox was also awarded the Mercury Award for Best Green Category for the development of the carbon-mapping software. Further information and updates on the GreenFox program can be obtained from: Scrutinising Suppliers: When Your Chain Gang Goes Green, Australian School of Business, 19 April 2010, http://knowledge.asb.unsw.edu.au/article.cfm?articleid=1112 Linfox Logistics’ Sustainable Strategy, LInfox, http://www.linfox.com/Sustainability.aspx. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 5 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 Questions Question 1 Define the following terms. For each term, provide an example relevant to a large-scale organisation such as Linfox Pty Ltd. a. Environmental sustainability 2 marks b. Change pressures 2 marks c. Cultural change 2 marks VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 6 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 Question 2 Explain why it is important for Australian large-scale organisations to be able to respond to change pressures and to successfully implement change if they are to survive in a global economy. 2 marks Question 3 List three features of Linfox that indicate that it is a large-scale organisation. 3 marks Question 4 Discuss how each of the following factors would have acted as pressures on Linfox to adopt environmentally sustainable policies and practices. a. Employees 2 marks VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 7 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 b. Customers 2 marks c. The federal government has proposed the introduction of a carbon tax on businesses that are large producers of greenhouse gases. 2 marks d. As a result of increased media attention and scientific research, the community has become more aware of the potential effects of climate change on the environment. 2 marks Question 5 Explain the potential benefits for Linfox of adopting sustainable business practices and policies in terms of: a. potential cost savings VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 8 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 3 marks b. ethical and social responsibility 3 marks c. business competitiveness 3 marks Question 6 List three stakeholders of Linfox. For each stakeholder group, explain how it is likely to be affected by the adoption of the GreenFox policy. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 9 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 6 marks Question 7 Outline the following aspects of the GreenFox policy at Linfox. a. Initial goals and current goals 2 marks b. Two initiatives designed to achieve the goals 2 marks Question 8 Explain the difference between driving and restraining forces for change. Identify one driving force for change at Linfox and one potential restraining force for change. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 10 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 4 marks Question 9 Identify and analyse two likely impacts of the introduction of the GreenFox policy at Linfox on the following structures, activities and key performance indicators at Linfox. Give reasons for your answers. a. The operations system 3 marks b. Employee training and development VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 11 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 3 marks c. Employee motivation and job satisfaction 3 marks Question 10 Outline three performance indicators (KPIs) that would be used by Linfox when evaluating the level of success of the implementation of the GreenFox policy. 3 marks Question 11 An aim of GreenFox is to achieve cultural change at Linfox. Explain what is meant by this statement. Identify and outline the strategies that Linfox is using in order to change its corporate culture. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 12 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 4 marks Question 12 ‘The implementation of the GreenFox policy at Linfox has been a great success.’ List and explain three factors that support this viewpoint. 6 marks Question 13 Linfox has used the eight-step model for change developed by JP Kotter in implementing the GreenFox model for sustainability. Explain and analyse the Kotter model of change management. In your answer, explain the steps that Kotter recommends should be implemented for successful change management. Discuss the strategies that Linfox would have adopted at each stage in order to implement the GreenFox program in line with Kotter’s theory. VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 13 BUSINESS MANAGEMENT UNIT 4 10 marks VCTA © Megan Jeffery Published July 2011 page 14