Mechanical Engineering FRM-2 (YOU NEED THE SESSION ) FRM-2 Paper # Self-Healing Materials Roland Beard (rkb15@pitt.edu), Callaghan Bradley(cab205@pitt.edu) producing sustainable technologies is the greatest engineering challenge today. Nanotechnology is the answer to the search for a way to make current technologies more environmentally friendly. Nanotechnology can be seen as a performance enhancer for current technologies. Technologies produced on the nanoscale have the ability to inexpensively reduce power consumption, increase life expectancy, and decrease overall negative impact on the environment. More specifically, nanotechnology can be used to impart human-like characteristics upon various technologies. Within the realm of biological attributes, the creation of a synthetic self-healing coating for mechanical devices would allow a device to heal itself with little to no human interaction. The synthetic self-healing coating is actually a self-healing polymer. Two primary methods of implementing the regenerative characteristic upon materials utilize supramolecular assembly and microcapsules. Though the supramolecular method already exists in the form of a paint coating called the Nissan Scratch Guard, it has no yet been perfected. Once perfected, the self-healing coating will have the potential to increase the sustainability and efficiency of a multitude of technologies and mechanical processes. Abstract The repair-and-go microcapsules mimic leukocytes in two main ways. They have similar methods of delivering healing materials and similar structures. Leukocytes entrap themselves in the damaged area in order to release the healing agents into the damaged area. The microcapsules also do this to release nanoparticles into the damaged area. Microcapsules also pass the nano-particles through a permeable barrier, and can be filled and emptied repeatedly, much like a cell. According to -----[1], “In the present work, such biological interactions are replaced with surface energies.” This refers to the main difference between the leukocytes and the microcapsule system, where the active biological work done by the cells is replaced with passive “surface energies” such as hydrophilic/hydrophobic preferences. According to Balazs’, “In our synthetic system the “leukocyte” is a polymeric microcapsule, the healing agents are encapsulated solid nanoparticles, and the “wound” is a microscopic crack on a surface. While in this technology can be adapted to work with different compounds, we will be analyzing the research done at the University of Pittsburgh and University of Massachusetts. Key Words— Supramolecular Assembly, Microcapsule, Polymer, Substrate, ScratchGuard. ENGINEERING GRAND CHALLENGE: SUSTAINABILITY THE IMPLICATIONS OF REGENERATIVE MATERIALS The most pressing concern in our world today is the preservation of our future. In response to the trepidation concerning the world’s future, the unofficial “green” movement has been created. The “green” movement refers to the increase in the desire and production of “green” or sustainable technologies. Engineers have been tasked with the job of protecting our world’s future through the manufacturing of “green” technologies. In fact, Though nano-scale defects are seemingly insignificant, “they can have a substantial impact on the mechanical properties of a system. For example, “significant stress concentrations at the tip of notches in the surface; such regions of high stress can ultimately lead to the propagation of University of Pittsburgh Swanson School of Engineering April 14, 2012 1 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley cracks through the system and degradation of mechanical behavior”. The imparting of the regenerative characteristic on devices and materials would be especially useful in extreme environments such as aerospace and heavy industry where nano-scale abrasions are more common. In addition to extending the lifespan of the machinery or products, self-healing materials would significantly extend the lifetime of sensitive systems as well as lower maintenance costs. For example, a broken circuit in a fighter plane usually results in severe injuries or death. Moreover the plane would have to be stripped in order to find the technical fault, which is both expensive and time-consuming. So, self-healing materials have the potential to save lives as well as money. Furthermore, faulty or damaged plastic consumer products negatively effect the environment. Durable plastics have been universally accepted as consumer products ranging from storage containers to computer. Since plastics are utilized in everyday life, they are highly susceptible to damage, which can result in loss of function. Once compromised, plastics are usually disposed of in landfills, or occasionally repaired. Self-healing polymers offer a solution to this environmental problem. The implementation of self-healing coatings would decrease the toll on the environment that results from consumer waste. continuity and integrity of the damaged area. [2]. The biological inspiration behind repair-and-go method was leucocytes, more commonly known as white blood cells. The repair-and-go method applies a unique synthetic imitation for inflammatory response or triggering/actuation. By using the hydrophobic and hydrophilic preferences of the capsule, nanoparticles and the scratched material are attracted to each other throughout the membrane of the microcapsule. Supramolecular self-healing compounds focuses on mimicking the matrix remodeling aspect of biological response to injury. When a bit of tissue is damaged, the last stage of biological repair is matrix remodeling. Matrix remodeling involves the rebuilding of tissue matrices. Vascular systems are very helpful with this process by bringing building blocks where they need to be and getting rid of broken pieces. Synthetic matrix remodeling is very similar as it also is the rebuilding of the matrix structure of the material. However, synthetic materials do not have a vascular transport system. The synthetic replica involves the use supramolecular polymers that have many flexible bonds in their structure. This gives these polymers the flexibility to reorient themselves into the proper formation. When the bonds are reformed, the material has returned to its original structure. THE BIOLOGY BEHIND THE MECHANICS The design of self-healing materials is modeled after biological regenerative systems. According to [1] “Biological response to injury is threefold: inflammatory response (immediate), cell proliferation (secondary), and matrix remodeling (long-term).” The two different self-healing methods we will be analyzing focus on imitating the biological process healing. The repair-and go method focuses primarily on the emulation of the initial inflammatory response, while the supramolecular polymers behave in a manor analogous to matrix remodeling. The challenge in re inflammatory response lies not only in “sensing” the presence of a “wound” or defect, but then also actively reestablishing the 2 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley Figure 1[2] blood cell filled with microscopic granules containing enzymes that digest microorganisms []. Next, the leukocytes locate and entrap themselves in regions of damaged tissue. Next the leukocytes release enzymes through their thin shell into damaged regions of the body in order to heal the wound [2]. The microcapsules are designed with this course of action in mind, along with the ability to repetitively heal. The repair-and-go microcapsules mimic leukocytes in two main ways. They have similar methods of delivering healing materials and similar structures. Leukocytes entrap themselves in the damaged area in order to release the healing agents into the damaged area. The microcapsules also do this to release nano-particles into the damaged area. Microcapsules also pass the nano-particles through a permeable barrier, and can be filled and emptied repeatedly, much like a cell. According to -----[1], “In the present work, such biological interactions are replaced with surface energies.” This refers to the main difference between the leukocytes and the microcapsule system, where the active biological work done by the cells is replaced with passive “surface energies” such as hydrophilic/hydrophobic preferences. This diagram illustrates the differences between synthetic and biological repair. “(Right) In biological systems, wound healing follows three sequential steps, the first of which is an immediate inflammatory response, including blood clotting. In the second stage, cell proliferation and matrix deposition occur and can extend for several days. The long-term response is matrix remodeling, which sometimes extends for several months. (Left) In synthetic materials, damage healing proceeds by an immediate response that actuates (triggers) the healing mechanism (e.g., the rupture of embedded microcapsules). Once triggered, the second stage involves transport of chemical species to the site of damage at a relatively rapid rate. During the final stage of healing, chemical repair takes place and can extend for several hours or days.” [2] REPAIR-AND-GO METHOD In the research done by the University of Pittsburgh microcapsules were filled with a polymer surfactant, since the experimental compromised surface was a polymer. The polymer surfactant could be replaced with copper nanoparticles suspended in an oil-water mixture. Upon self-healing, copper particles would be released into the crack, thus restoring both the integrity and conductive property of the material. THE SCIENCE BEHIND THE REPAIR-AND-GO The “repair-and-go” process defined in Balazs’ work [3] is a selective self-healing process that utilizes microcapsules for selective deposition of the healing material. A microcapsule is a microsized hollow container created by means of microencapsulation, which is the process of surrounding microscopic amounts of a substance with a thin shell [4]. In this repair-and-go approach, a flexible microcapsule filled with a solution of nanoparticles rolls across a surface stopping to repair any defects it encounters by releasing nanoparticles into the defect, then continuing on to the next defect [2]. This process is very efficient because the microcapsules as well as their contents can be reused. According to Balazs’, “In our synthetic system the “leukocyte” is a polymeric microcapsule, the healing agents are encapsulated solid nanoparticles, and the “wound” is a microscopic crack on a surface. While in this technology can be adapted to work with different compounds, we will be analyzing the research done at the University of Pittsburgh and University of Massachusetts. THE AQUEOUS FILLING The microcapsules are filled with a mixture of oil and water. Hydrophobic, water repellant, nanoparticles are dispersed throughout the aqueous mixture of oil and water. This encapsulated mixture acts as the healing agent, which is dispersed by the microcapsules. CdSe (Cadmium Selenide) quantum dots were the type of nano-particles used as the healing MANMADE WHITE BLOOD CELLS The idea of the repair-and-go method of selfhealing with the use of microcapsules is modeled after a cell in the human body called a granular leukocyte. A granular leukocyte is a type of white 3 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley particles. “Quantum dots are semiconductors whose conducting characteristics are closely related to the size and shape of the individual crystal.” In this case the quantum dots are similar in properties to the material that is being regenerated. Therefore, when the particles fill the defects, the materials regain most of their original properties. The CdSe quantum dots were specifically used because of their inherent fluorescence, which offers a useful marker to locate the restored regions of the material. The CdSe nano-particles are hydrophobic, which means they do not mix with water or other hydrophilic substances. chosen, because of the physical characteristics it possesses. The polymer, when strained, cracks randomly. The resulting abrasions are confined to the outer surface of the substrate, a surface upon which a different material is deposited or adhered, usually in a coating or layer [4]. The generated damage produces cracks analogous to the damage commonly found in the coatings of materials such as rubber. METHODOLOGY “Within an oil/water mixture, the amphiphilic comb copolymers can out-compete the functionalized quantum dots for an oil-in-water droplet interface and thus provide an encapsulating shell for the coated nano-particles, which are dispersed in the interior oil phase. Upon cross-linking, the copolymers form a robust micro carrier for the nano-particles, with a very thin wall through which the nano-particles can permeate under appropriate conditions.” In simpler terms, the PCOE-graft-PC polymers chosen for these “flexible nanocapsules” are specialized surfactants, in the sense that they have a hydrophobic surface as well as hydrophilic surface. The hydrophobic CdSe nanoparticles and oil are attracted to the hydrophilic exterior, thus forming a hydrophobic shell around the particles. This arrangement causes the aqueous solution of nano-particles to gravitate toward the inside of the shell of the surfactant polymers. “The droplets remain stable for weeks, or longer, without substantial coalescence.” [1] OF THE MICROCAPSULES Through experimentation, Balazs’ discovered the need for microcapsules to be propelled across the substrate in order to produce an effective healing mechanism. A constant flow of water was initially used to transport the capsules. The results of this test showed that a constant flow caused the microcarriers to become entrapped in the surface scratches. Additionally, the steady flow only permitted roughly 10-20 percent of particles to be deposited. To alleviate the problem of permanent deposition, a pulsatile flow was employed. The pulsatile flow was found to allow the microcapsules to repair more effectively, delivering more nano-particles, as well as continue moving to other abrasions. Also, the pulse flow allowed the microcarrier to localize and excrete a higher concentration of nano-particles along the interior of the crack. The pulsing of the force in the water allowed the microcapsules to escape cracks where it may have become wedged. In fact the pulsatile flow allowed for between 73% and 90% or the nano-particles to be deposited. Consequently, the pulse flow increased the healing rate. Other than varied water propulsion, there were two notable contributing factors that promoted the deposition of nano-particles in compromised regions of the substrate. The hydrophilic PCsusbstituents of the PCOE-graft-PC, poly (cyclooctene) and phosphorylcholine grafts, polymer provided the droplets with antifouling properties; the ability to prevent undesired permanent deposition into surface cracks. A graft is a polymer comprised of molecules in which the THE MICROCAPSULE EXTERIOR EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS GO METHOD OF THE REPAIR-AND- The self-healing technique was tested on polydimethylsiloxane, silicon oxide-coated siloxane polymer. This particular polymer was 4 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley main chain of atoms is attached at various points to the side chains containing different atoms or groups from those in the main chain. The substituent connected to the main chain in this polymer is phosphorylcholine [5]. Also, the size of the nano-particle droplets played a role in successful delivery of the healing agent. The larger than average size of the droplets of oil, water, and nano-particles released into the cracks prevented irreversible deposition. potentially be specialized to restore broken circuits. The microcapsules could be filled with a material such as copper, which could restore the conductive traits of a wire. Instead of CdSe quantum dots, ionic metal quantum dots could be used to fill the microcapsules. SUPRAMOLECULAR ASSEMBLY THE SUPRAMOLECULAR STRUCTURE Supramolecular polymers are large networks of smaller recurrent molecules, which have been conjoined into long chains with the use of metal ions. The metal ions form non-covalent bonds each of the molecules of the polymer. These noncovalent interactions make supramolecular polymers unique to the traditional polymers, which consist of long chain-like, covalently bonded molecules. The non-covalent bonds can be repeatedly broken down and restored with exposure to ultraviolet light. Due to the reversibility of non-covalent interactions, supramolecular polymers have the inherent ability to self-heal. Figure 1[6] This image shows the chemical structure of a PCOE-graft-PC molecule where the ____side is hydrophobic and the ___side is hydrophilic. Then when they are added to a solution of oil, water, and nano-particles (NPs), the PCOE-graft-PC molecules attach themselves to each other, and orient themselves with the hydrophilic sides toward the water, and the hydrophobic sides near the hydrophobic NPs. THE SUPRAMOLECULAR ASSEMBLY AT WORK When exposed to ultraviolet light, the noncovalent bonds dissociate the metal ionic bonds causing the polymer to begin to flow. Once the source of UV light is removed, the polymer will naturally reassemble into its original state. Due to the polymer’s ability to regenerate without heat, the supramolecular assembly proves to be environmentally and mechanically efficient. The employment of UV light allows for local healing, so none of the light is wasted on an unscathed section of the material. Since UV light is the only required interaction to start the reversible reaction, the sun can be utilized as a source of energy for the self-healing process. So, supramolecular assembly is highly efficient and cost-effective. EXAMPLES OF USES The two largest advantages of this method of repairing are efficient delivery of the healing nano-particles and the ability to repair very tiny defects in the surface. The first makes this both a cost effective and green process. The second makes it very well suited as a surface treatment method during the production process of sensitive equipment (especially that which needs to be under extreme conditions.) The microcapsules could be used to detect damage on a microscopic level. Filling the microcapsules with a fluorescent dye would allow the microcapsules to mark a damaged region of material. So, microcapsules can be utilized as an early warning system. The technology could also 5 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley required two consecutive exposures for 30 seconds at a time to sufficiently heal the cuts. Also, during the exposure, the surface temperature of the zinc triflimidate rose to over 220 °C. Using the change in temperature as evidence, the researchers concluded that the UV light healing process occurred as a result of photothermal conversion, the chemical transformation of light into heat. So, the supramolecular can reassemble with exposure to heat, though the addition of heat is not necessary. Additionally, the results of the reference experiments results yielded that the healing process could only occur in wavelengths inside the absorption band of the 3·[Zn(NTf2)2]0.7 metalligand complex, range of absorbable light. The wavelengths between 400 and 500nm did not cause the polymer to reassemble. However, the particular range of wavelengths of UV light necessary to stimulate self-healing lie in the range of light that the sun produces, between 10 and 400nm. The Nissan Scratch Guard exploits this ability. Figure 2 [6] SUPRAMOLECULAR TESTING A research team from Case Western Reserve University has achieved notable results through experimentation with supramolecular polymers. The research team used zinc triflimidate (3·[Zn(NTf2)2]x) , a supramolecular polymer, throughout their experimentation. To form the polymer, ~0.025 M zinc triflimidate was mixed with ~.05M acetonitrile (CH3CN). The solution of the constituent compounds formed a white precipitate. Afterward, the precipitate was dried in a vacuum to produce a supramolecular polymer. The polymer formed existed in the form of a thin film. To measure the self-healing ability of the polymer, the film of (3·[Zn(NTf2)2]0.7) was scratched by cutting the film to varied depths between of ~50–70% of its thickness. Next, the sample was exposed to a filtered UV light source, which illuminated the samples with wavelengths of light ranging from 320 to 390 nanometers at intensity of 950 mW cm−2. In order to test the effectiveness of the regenerative technology at varied wavelengths, reference experiments were performed with the same lamp system, but with a filter that illuminated the sample with light of wavelengths of light between 400 and 500 nanometers. Under the initial experimental conditions, the films comprised of 3·[Zn(NTf2)2]0.7 only NISSAN SCRATCH GUARD As the maintenance side of products has a much larger consumer market, it is not surprising that there is already a self-healing material. This material is a supramolucar polymer used as a regenerative coating. There is a supramolecular regenerative coating on the market . The coating exists in the form of Nissan’s Scratch Guard. The Nissan Scratch Guard is a protective coating, which Nissan currently applies to the Nissan Murano, 370Z , XTrail, and Infiniti [7]. The scratch resistant coating is combined with the standard clearcoat. The mixture of the two coats acts as a surfactant by reducing the surface tension of the paint thus increasing overall flexibility. The regenerative coating is composed of a highly elastic resin made of polyrotaxane, which is a supramolecular polymer. Rotaxane is a mechanically interlocked molecular structure characterized by the high freedom and mobility of their components [6]. 6 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley Polyrotaxanes are a class of polymeric materials, which are composed of a network of interconnected rotaxane assemblies. The polyrotaxanes are ideal for supramolecular assembly because of their durability that results from the cross linking, the bonding of polymeric chains, of each rotaxane structure. These polymers dissociate quickly when exposed to UV light. Though the specifics of the experimental results are not publicly released, the Scratch Shield coat had a fifth of the number of scratches compared with a conventional clearcoat [8]. Furthermore, the experimental findings show that the time for selfrepair is dependent upon surrounding temperature as well as the depth of the scratch, and the material was nearly restored to its original state. The time required to regenerate damaged material ranged from a matter of minutes to a week. Also, the coating was found to be ineffective when dealing with scratches that are deep enough to sever the bonds within the clearcoat or if the clearcoat has been peeled off [7,9]. This image illustrates how the “high-density bonding” in Nissan Scratch Guard. “-The paint does not self-repair if scratches are deep enough to sever the bonds within the clearcoat or if the clearcoat has been peeled off. The amount of time required for self-repair depends on the surrounding temperature and the depth of the scratch. In some cases, restoration may take up to one week.’ SELF-HEALING MATERIALS: The Good and the Bad These two self-healing materials are good examples of how diverse the applications of selfhealing materials can be. Supramolecular materials have the advantage of using energy from its surroundings, making it a good choice for products that need low levels of protection as well as for machinery that is exposed to ultraviolet light daily. The repair-and-go method has the advantage of efficiently repairing very small defects on surfaces. Even though they are both self-healing technologies, they have very different applications. While the repair-and-go method is better suited as a surface treatment method, supramolecular material makes a very effective self-healing sealant. They can also both be adapted for similar uses. Currently, both of these technologies are in the process of being adapted to employed in the form of an I-phone case. Presently, the supramolecular Nissan paint is being modified to self-heal at lower temperatures and levels of exposure to UV light to fit consumer needs, while the repair-and-go method is still in its experimental phase. In contrast, there are issues concerning the implementation of these self-healing methods. While considering real-world applications of the repair-and-go technique, there are issues to be pondered even though it is still in the experimental phase. The primary concern we see with the usage of the repair-and-go method is the need to create a pulsatile flow to allow the microcapsules to exit the cracks. The supramolecular assembly has a fault as well. The supramolecular coating could not be employed in an industrial setting, because currently, the coating can only repair cosmetic damage. So, supramolecular polymers would be most efficient in consumer products. Figure 3 [8] This image illustrates how the “high-density bonding” in Nissan Scratch Guard. “-The paint does not self-repair if scratches are deep enough to sever the bonds within the clearcoat or if the clearcoat has been peeled off. -The amount of time required for self-repair depends on the surrounding temperature and the depth of the scratch. In some cases, restoration may take up to one week.’ [10,11] ECONOMICS AND EFFICIENCY 7 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley Supramolecular polymers materials and repairand-go healing are in many ways more efficient the current alternatives, though they do pose some practical problems. The repair and go method requires not only the application of the microcapsule solution to the defective surface, but the solution must be propelled with a pulsating flow. This requirement is not convenient for application to consumer and industrial technologies. So, the capsules must be adapted as to propel themselves. However, the fabrication of these microcapsules as well as the repair-and-go delivery method of the healing nano-particle solution is a very efficient process. The “special” hydrophobic/hydrophilic structure of the microcapsules makes their formation very efficient. Traditionally, microcapsule based technologies have required complex chemical fabrication processes to process and fill the microcapsules, which requires energy and money. The repair- and-go microcapsules do not require external energy to be created. The PCOE-graft-PC molecules are simply mixed in a solution of oil, water, and nano-particles. The mixture naturally arranges the constituents into microcapsules. So, the production of these microcapsules is an energy efficient and sustainable process. Furthermore, the conventional microcapsule based self-healing systems involve the rupturing of a capsule to release the contents into the damaged area. In addition to this process lacking precision, a damaged region can only be regenerated once. Also, the debris resulting from the broken capsules can alter the mechanical properties of the material [quote]. repair- and-go microcapsules do not deposit debris from broken shells, thus preserving the mechanical properties of the material. Also, the repair-and-go microcapsules can be “refilled” by simply remixing them in an oil, water, and nano-particle solution [7]. The capsules absorb the solution through their porous shells. The recyclability of the capsules causes the microcapsules to be exceptionally economical and efficient. In Balazs’ experiments, she simply rinsed the substrate with water to remove the microcapsules in order to save them for future testing [8]. Accordingly, these microcapsules are low maintenance and have extensive life spans. The evaluation of each self-healing process’ economical efficiently shows the high level of sustainability of the regenerative materials. Both regenerative polymers do not require added energy in their respective formations. Also, since each substance is capable of regeneration, there are no associated maintenance costs to date. Evidencing the low costs of production and proven regenerative abilities, we believe the self-healing technology to be the answer to the current engineering challenge of increasing sustainability. CONCLUSION Nature accomplishes a lot of work with very little dangerous waste. It grows large trees with only O2, nitrogen , and fertilizer as byproducts. So it is a very good idea to look to natural biological systems for inspiration. The “green” movement will likely become a bigger and bigger part of our professional and political environment in the future. However, one of its biggest setbacks is when its proponents try to be too ambitious. Our entire culture is not going to change of overnight into some “green” utopia for any reason. However, we can make a big difference by refining our current technologies to make them more sustainable. Instead of asking people to change, offer to make what the have stronger, last longer, run cheaper, and be generally “greener”. For example, instead of trying to redesign expensive, sensitive electrical systems for a space probe, we can treat the parts with the repair-and-go method. This will make it last longer under strenuous conditions, thus save money and resources. Nissan’s Scratch Guard is already making the maintenance of their cars more efficient by repairs cosmetic scratches before they can corrode the body of the car. Selfhealing nanotechnologies are a great way to 8 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley Available:http://www.gizmag.com/worlds-first-self-healing-iphonecase/21127/ accomplish this. As illustrated in this paper, this technology can improve our current products in both the manufacturing stage and maintenance. The most productive way to promote the “green” cause is to start with what we already have. While one day entirely preconceived “green” technologies will be very important., it is equally important to find ways to improve and adjust what the technology machinery and equipment we already have. Self-healing materials are a great way that we can refine our current technologies to make them cleaner, cheaper, stronger, and more efficient. ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Kolmakov, G. V., Revanur, R., Tangirala, R., Emrick, T., Russell, T. P., Crosby, A. J., and Balazs, A. B., Using nanoparticle-filled microcapsules for site-specific healing of damaged substrates: creating a "repair-and-go" system", ACS Nano 2010, 4, 1115-1123. Katrina Kratz, Amrit Narasimhan, Ravisubhash Tangirala, SungCheal Moon, Ravindra Revanur, Santanu Kundu, Hyun Suk Kim, Alfred J. Crosby, Thomas P. Russell, Todd Emrick, German Kolmakov, Anna C. Balazs. Probing and repairing damaged surfaces with nanoparticlecontaining microcapsules. Nature Nanotechnology, 2012; DOI: 10.1038/nnano.2011.235 ACKNOWLEGEMENTS I would like to thank Kenechi Agbim for aiding us in our writing process. REFERENCES [1] B.J. Blaiszik, S.L.B. Kramer, S.C. Olugebefola, J.S. Moore, N.R. Sottos, and S.R. White. (2010, August). “Self-Healing Polymers and Composites”. Annual Review of Materials Research. [Online]. Available:http://www.annualreviews.org/doi/abs/10.1146/annurev-matsci070909-104532 [2](2012, January 10), “Healing the iPhone's Wounds”, Science Daily, [Online], Available:http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/01/120110151738.ht m [3] J. D. Rule, E. N. Brown, N. R. Sottos2, S. R. White, J. S. Moore.( 2005,January 25). “Wax-Protected Catalyst Microspheres for Efficient SelfHealing Materials”. Advanced Materials. [Online]. Available:http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/adma.200400607/abst ract [4]S. Miller. (2011, November 22). “Self-healing metals and polymers.” Defying Definition. [Online], Available: http://millersam.com/2011/11/22/self-healing-metals-and-polymers/ [5] B. R.Huber, (2012,January 23), “Healing the iPhone’s Wounds: Balazsled researchers propose ‘repair-and-go’ method for small-scale cracks on digital device surfaces”, Pitt Chronicle, [Online], ,Available:http://www.chronicle.pitt.edu/?p=10273 [6] (2005).“Scratch Shield”. Nissan Technology.[Online]. Available: http://www.nissanglobal.com/EN/TECHNOLOGY/OVERVIEW/scratch.html [7] K. Kratz, A.Narasimhan, R. Tangirala, S.C. Moon, R. Revanur, S. Kundu, H. S. Kim, A. J. Crosby, T. P. Russell, T. Emrick, G. Kolmakov & A. C. Balazs (2012, January 10), ‘Probing and repairing damaged surfaces with nanoparticle-containing microcapsules”, Nature Nanotechnology, [Online], Available:http://www.nature.com/nnano/journal/v7/n2/full/nnano.2011.235. html [8] Y. Zhao. (2011, July). “Self-healing Coatings Containing Microcapsule”. Applied Surface Science. [Online]. Available: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0169433211010488 [9] N. R. Sottos & J.S. Moore. (2011, April 21). “Materials Chemistry: Spot-on Healing”. Nature. [Online] Available:http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v472/n7343/full/472299a.h tml [10] Y. Wang, H.J. Joyce, Q. Gao, X. Liao, H. Hoe Tan, J. Zou, S. P. Ringer, Z. Shan, and C.Jagadish. (2011). “ Self-Healing of Fractured GaAs Nanowires”. Nano Letters. [Online]. Available:http://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/nl104330h [11] D. Quick, (2012, January 16), “Nissan announces world's first selfhealing iPhone case”, Gizmag, [Online], 9 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley 10 Roland Beard, Callaghan Bradley 11