Managerial Economics &
Business Strategy
Chapter 4
The Theory of Individual
Behavior
McGraw-Hill/Irwin
Michael R. Baye, Managerial Economics and
Business Strategy
Copyright © 2008 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Overview
I. Consumer Behavior


Indifference Curve Analysis
Consumer Preference Ordering
II. Constraints



The Budget Constraint
Changes in Income
Changes in Prices
III. Consumer Equilibrium
IV. Indifference Curve Analysis & Demand Curves


Individual Demand
Market Demand
4-2
4-3
Consumer Behavior
• Consumer Opportunities

The possible goods and services consumer can afford to
consume.
• Consumer Preferences

The goods and services consumers actually consume.
• Given the choice between 2 bundles of
goods a consumer either



Prefers bundle A to bundle B: A  B.
Prefers bundle B to bundle A: A  B.
Is indifferent between the two: A  B.
4-4
Indifference Curve Analysis
Indifference Curve

A curve that defines the
combinations of 2 or more goods
that give a consumer the same
level of satisfaction.
Good Y
III.
II.
I.
Marginal Rate of
Substitution

The rate at which a consumer is
willing to substitute one good for
another and maintain the same
satisfaction level.
Good X
Consumer Preference Ordering
Properties
•
•
•
•
Completeness
More is Better
Diminishing Marginal Rate of Substitution
Transitivity
4-5
4-6
Complete Preferences
• Completeness Property

Consumer is capable of
expressing preferences (or
indifference) between all possible
bundles. (“I don’t know” is NOT
an option!)
• If the only bundles available
to a consumer are A, B, and
C, then the consumer
– is indifferent between A and
C (they are on the same
indifference curve).
– will prefer B to A.
– will prefer B to C.
Good Y
III.
II.
I.
A
B
C
Good X
4-7
More Is Better!
• More Is Better Property

Bundles that have at least as much of
every good and more of some good
are preferred to other bundles.
• Bundle B is preferred to A since
B contains at least as much of
good Y and strictly more of good
X.
• Bundle B is also preferred to C
since B contains at least as much
of good X and strictly more of
good Y.
• More generally, all bundles on
ICIII are preferred to bundles on
ICII or ICI. And all bundles on
ICII are preferred to ICI.
Good Y
III.
II.
I.
100
A
B
C
33.33
1
3
Good X
Diminishing Marginal Rate of
Substitution
4-8
• Marginal Rate of Substitution


The amount of good Y the consumer is
willing to give up to maintain the same
satisfaction level decreases as more of
good X is acquired.
The rate at which a consumer is willing to
substitute one good for another and
maintain the same satisfaction level.
Good Y
• To go from consumption bundle A to
B the consumer must give up 50 units 100
of Y to get one additional unit of X.
• To go from consumption bundle B to
C the consumer must give up 16.67
50
units of Y to get one additional unit of
33.33
X.
25
• To go from consumption bundle C to
D the consumer must give up only
8.33 units of Y to get one additional
unit of X.
III.
II.
I.
A
B
C
1
2
3
D
4
Good X
4-9
Consistent Bundle Orderings
• Transitivity Property


Good Y
For the three bundles A, B, and C,
the transitivity property implies
that if C  B and B  A, then C 
A.
Transitive preferences along with
the more-is-better property imply 100
75
that
• indifference curves will not
50
intersect.
• the consumer will not get
caught in a perpetual cycle of
indecision.
III.
II.
I.
A
C
B
1
2
5
7 Good X
4-10
The Budget Constraint
• Opportunity Set

The set of consumption bundles
that are affordable.
• PxX + PyY  M.
Y
The Opportunity Set
Budget Line
M/PY
Y = M/PY – (PX/PY)X
• Budget Line

The bundles of goods that exhaust a
consumers income.
• PxX + PyY = M.
• Market Rate of Substitution

The slope of the budget line
• -Px / Py
M/PX
X
4-11
Changes in the Budget Line
Y
• Changes in Income


Increases lead to a parallel,
outward shift in the budget
line (M1 > M0).
Decreases lead to a parallel,
downward shift (M2 < M0).
M1/PY
M0/PY
M2/PY
• Changes in Price
Y


A decreases in the price of
good X rotates the budget
M0/PY
line counter-clockwise (PX0 >
PX1).
An increases rotates the
budget line clockwise (not
shown).
M2/PX
M0/PX
M1/PX
X
New Budget Line for
a price decrease.
M0/PX0
M0/PX1
X
4-12
Consumer Equilibrium
• The equilibrium
consumption bundle is
the affordable bundle
that yields the highest
level of satisfaction.


Consumer equilibrium
occurs at a point where
MRS = PX / PY.
Equivalently, the slope of
the indifference curve
equals the budget line.
Y
M/PY
Consumer
Equilibrium
III.
II.
I.
M/PX
X
Price Changes and Consumer
Equilibrium
• Substitute Goods

An increase (decrease) in the price of good X leads to
an increase (decrease) in the consumption of good Y.
• Examples:
– Coke and Pepsi.
– Verizon Wireless or AT&T.
• Complementary Goods

An increase (decrease) in the price of good X leads to a
decrease (increase) in the consumption of good Y.
• Examples:
– DVD and DVD players.
– Computer CPUs and monitors.
4-13
4-14
Complementary Goods
When the price of
Pretzels (Y)
good X falls and the
consumption of Y
rises, then X and Y M/PY
1
are complementary
goods. (PX1 > PX2)
B
Y2
II
A
Y1
I
0
X1 M/PX1
X2
M/PX2
Beer (X)
Substitute Goods
When the price of
Artichokes
good X falls and the
(Y)
consumption of Y
falls, then X and Y
M/PY1
are substitute goods.
(PX1 > PX2)
Y1
B
Y2
A
0
X1 M/PX1
I
X2
II
M/PX2
Brussel
Sprouts (X)
Income Changes and Consumer
Equilibrium
• Normal Goods

Good X is a normal good if an increase (decrease) in
income leads to an increase (decrease) in its
consumption.
• Inferior Goods

Good X is an inferior good if an increase (decrease) in
income leads to a decrease (increase) in its
consumption.
4-16
4-17
Normal Goods
An increase in
income increases
the consumption of
normal goods.
Y
M1/Y
(M0 < M1).
B
Y1
M0/Y
II
A
Y0
I
0
X0 M0/X
X1
M1/X
X
4-18
Decomposing the Income and
Substitution Effects
Initially, bundle A is consumed.
A decrease in the price of good
X expands the consumer’s
opportunity set.
Y
C
The substitution effect (SE)
causes the consumer to move
from bundle A to B.
A
II
A higher “real income” allows
the consumer to achieve a
higher indifference curve.
The movement from bundle B to
C represents the income effect
(IE). The new equilibrium is
achieved at point C.
B
I
0
IE
SE
X
4-19
A Classic Marketing
Application
Other
goods
(Y)
A buy-one,
get-one free
pizza deal.
A
C
E
D
II
I
0
0.5
1
2
B
F
Pizza
(X)
4-20
Individual Demand Curve
Y
• An individual’s
demand curve is
derived from each new
equilibrium point
found on the
indifference curve as
the price of good X is
varied.
II
I
X
$
P0
D
P1
X0
X1
X
4-21
Market Demand
• The market demand curve is the horizontal
summation of individual demand curves.
• It indicates the total quantity all consumers would
purchase at each price point.
$
Individual Demand
Curves
$
Market Demand Curve
50
40
D1
1 2
D2
Q
1 2 3
DM
Q
4-22
Conclusion
• Indifference curve properties reveal information
about consumers’ preferences between bundles of
goods.




Completeness.
More is better.
Diminishing marginal rate of substitution.
Transitivity.
• Indifference curves along with price changes
determine individuals’ demand curves.
• Market demand is the horizontal summation of
individuals’ demands.