Chapter 22 Aggregate Demand and Supply Analysis Aggregate Demand • Aggregate demand is made up of four component parts: – C = consumption expenditure, the total demand for consumer goods and services – I = planned investment spending, the total planned spending by business firms on new machines, factories, and other capital goods, plus planned spending on new homes – G = government purchases , spending by all levels of government (federal, state, and local) on goods and services – NX = net exports, the net foreign spending on domestic goods and services Y ad C I G NX Aggregate Demand • The Quantity Theory of Money (QTM) implies the aggregate demand curve is downward sloping. • The QTM results when velocity is assumed to be constant in the equation of exchange: PL Y M V • A constant money supply implies constant nominal aggregate spending • A decrease in the price level is matched with an increase in real GDP. • Recall that inflation is defined as follows: PLis PLwas p 100 PLwas • Hence, a rise in real GDP is associated with a decline in PLis, which causes p to fall for a given value of PLwas. Aggregate Demand QTM: • The quantity of real GDP demanded decreases in p. p p b Y ad C I NX G T r f AD Y Aggregate Demand QTM: • The quantity of real GDP demanded decreases in p. • AD increases when o 𝐶 increases o 𝐼 increases p AD o 𝑁𝑋 increases o 𝐺 is increased o 𝑇 is cut o 𝑟 decreases o Financial friction 𝑓 decreases p b Y ad C I NX G T r f Y Aggregate Demand Aggregate Demand p b Y ad C I NX G T r f Aggregate Demand Aggregate Demand p b Y ad C I NX G T r f The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary fiscal policy involves a cut in T and/or increase in G Restrictive fiscal policy involves a raising T and/or cutting G The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policy Expansionary monetary policy involves lowering the federal funds interest rate Restrictive monetary policy involves raising the federal funds interest rate Aggregate Demand Aggregate Demand p b Y ad C I NX G T r f The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary fiscal policy involves a cut in T and/or increase in G Restrictive fiscal policy involves a raising T and/or cutting G The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policylves raising the federal funds interest rate Aggregate Demand Aggregate Demand p b Y ad C I NX G T r f The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary fiscal policy involves a cut in T and/or increase in G Restrictive fiscal policy involves a raising T and/or cutting G The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policy Expansionary monetary policy involves lowering the federal funds interest rate Restrictive monetary policy involves raising the federal funds interest rate Aggregate Demand Aggregate Demand p b Y ad C I NX G T r f The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary fiscal policy involves a cut in T and/or increase in G Restrictive fiscal policy involves a raising T and/or cutting G The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policy Expansionary monetary policy involves lowering the federal funds interest rate Aggregate Demand Aggregate Demand p b Y ad C I NX G T r f The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary fiscal policy involves a cut in T and/or increase in G Restrictive fiscal policy involves a raising T and/or cutting G The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policy Expansionary monetary policy involves lowering the federal funds interest rate Restrictive monetary policy involves raising the federal funds interest rate Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example: Suppose the economy’s production function shows the volume of output that can be produced by its labor force (L) given its physical capital (K), land and natural resources (R), and technology and entrepreneurial talent (Z). Y Z K RL Suppose R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land, oil, coal, natural gas…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of physical capital like machines, roads, networks…) and z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge in the universe is known on Earth). 1. What is the economy’s short-run production function? Y 1.25 0.4 2.5 L Y 1.25 L Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example (continued): 2. Graph the economy’s short-run production function. Y 1.25 L L Y 0 0 50 8.839 100 12.500 150 15.309 L Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example (continued): 3. Suppose there are 9 million workers that are frictionally or structurally unemployed, and 135 million of the 144 million in the labor force are employed. Compute u, un, uc, real GDP, and Yp. un Un 9 6.25% L f 144 Yp 1.25 L f 1.25 144 15 u Lf E Lf 15 144 135 6.25% 144 uc u un 6.25 6.25 0% Y 1.25 E U n 1.25 135 + 9 15 L 144 Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example (continued): Yp Z K R L f 4. Graph LRAS. Yp 15 LRAS PL 30 20 10 0 15 Y Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example (continued): 4. Suppose there are 9 million workers that are frictionally or structurally unemployed, and 112 million of the 144 million in the labor force are employed. Compute u, un, uc, real GDP, and Yp. un Un 9 6.25% L f 144 Yp 1.25 L f 1.25 144 15 15 13.75 Unemployment is too high u Lf E Lf 144 112 22.22% 144 uc u un 22.22 6.25 15.97% Y 1.25 E U n 1.25 112 + 9 13.75 GDP is lower than what it should be L 121 144 Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example (continued): 5. Suppose there are 9 million workers that are frictionally or structurally unemployed, and 140 million of the 144 million in the labor force are employed. Compute u, un, uc, real GDP, and Yp. un Un 9 6.25% L f 144 Yp 1.25 L f 1.25 144 15 15.26 15 Unemployment is too low u Lf E Lf 144 140 2.78% 144 uc u un 2.78 6.25 3.47% Y 1.25 E U n 1.25 140 + 9 15.26 GDP is higher than what it should be L 144149 Long Run Aggregate Supply Simulated LRAS Example: With the labor force equal to 144 million workers, show what happens if • Resources rises by 0.5 trillion dollars • Physical capital increases by 0.5 trillion dollars • The number of laborers falls by 12 million • Nominal wage rates rise by 1 dollar per hour • Nominal prices of other inputs increases by 1 dollar per hour • Supply side taxes are cut by 1 percentage point. What is monetary policy, and who conducts it? What is fiscal policy, and who conducts it? Short Run Aggregate Supply SRAS is the relationship between the quantity of real GDP supplied and p when all other influences on production plans remain the same SRAS shifts upward (decreases) when Expected inflation rises o Workers expecting the PL to rise will demand one-for-one adjustments in w Dp e = Dw o In the short-run, w is the most important factor to producing products o Inflation increases one-for-one in expected inflation a price shock (up) occurs due to the nominal price of a resource like energy ( r). Government permanently changes the supply-side tax rate (t ) Output gap Y – Yp widens o workers are being offered higher w and better benefits due to u being too low o In the short-run, it is believed this pushes inflation higher due to firms raising their prices. o This makes SRAS upward sloping. p = p e + r +t + g (Y – Yp) p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 6 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 6 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = g Y + p e + r +t – g 15 Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 6 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y + p e + r +t – 7.5 Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 6 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y + 1.5 + r +t – 7.5 Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 6 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y + 1.5 + 0 +t – 7.5 Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 6 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y + 1.5 + 0 + 6 – 7.5 Short Run Aggregate Supply Example: In addition to R = 0.4 (trillion dollars of land…), K = 2.5 (trillion dollars of machines…), Z = 1.25 (percent of all knowledge is known to man), Un = 9 (million frictionally or structurally unemployed workers), E = 135 (million), and L = 144 (million), suppose the sensitivity of inflation to the output gap is 0.5, expected inflation is 1.5 (percent), price shock is 0, and the supply-side tax rate is 5 (percent). 1. Graph the potential GDP you computed in part (3) with AD Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y Short Run Aggregate Supply Example (continued): 2. Graph SRAS: p = 0.5Y p SRAS 7.5 15 Y Short Run Aggregate Supply Example (continued): 3. What happens if government cuts supply-side taxes by 1 percentage point? p p = 0.5Y + 1.5 + 0 + 5 6 – 7.5 SRAS SRAS’ Supply-side tax cuts increase SRAS. 7.5 -1 15 17 Y Short Run Aggregate Supply p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p Short Run Aggregate Supply p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary supply-side fiscal policy involves cutting t Restrictive supply-side fiscal policy involves raising t The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policy Expansionary monetary policy lowers the federal funds interest rate Restrictive monetary policy raises the federal funds interest rate Short Run Aggregate Supply p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p The Congress and President are in charge of fiscal policy. Expansionary supply-side fiscal policy involves cutting t Restrictive supply-side fiscal policy involves raising t The Federal Reserve (our central bank) is in charge of monetary policy Expansionary monetary policy lowers the federal funds interest rate Restrictive monetary policy raises the federal funds interest rate Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 4. Graph LRAS with SRAS: p p = 0.5Y Yp = 15 LRAS SRAS 7.5 15 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 5. Suppose the labor force increases by 25 million workers. Show the effect of this on LRAS and SRAS. p LRAS LRAS’ Y 1.25 0.4 2.5 169 144 SRAS Yp = 16.25 (trillion $) 7.5 15 16.25 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 5. Suppose the labor force increases by 25 million workers. Show the effect of this on LRAS and SRAS. p LRAS LRAS’ SRAS SRAS’ Yp = 16.25 (trillion $) 7.5 16.25 p = 0.5Y + 1.5 + 0 + 6 – 0.5 ·15 p = 0.5Y – 0.625 -0.625 15 16.25 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 6. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: p Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 15 – 0.5 Y LRAS SRAS 7.5 AD 15 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 7. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: p Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 14 – 0.5 Y LRAS SRAS 7 AD 14 15 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 7. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 14 – 0.5 Y p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p p LRAS SRAS 7 AD 14 15 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 7. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 14 – 0.5 Y p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p p LRAS SRAS 7 6.5 AD 14 15 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 7. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 14 – 0.5 Y p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p p LRAS SRAS But wages are inflexible… …need active government policy 7 6.5 AD 14 15 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 8. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: p Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 16 – 0.5 Y LRAS SRAS 8 AD 15 16 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 8. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 16 – 0.5 Y p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p p LRAS SRAS 8 AD 15 16 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 8. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 16 – 0.5 Y p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p p LRAS SRAS 8.5 8 AD 15 16 Y Aggregate Market Model Equilibrium Example (continued): 8. Graph LRAS, AD & SRAS: Yp = 15 p = 0.5Y p = 16 – 0.5 Y p = g Y + p e + r +t – g Y p p LRAS SRAS 8.5 Wages and prices are flexible AD 15 Y Positive Demand Shock AD can shift from temporary demand shocks in which the LRAS and SRAS do not shift Positive Demand Shock AD can shift from temporary demand shocks in which the LRAS and SRAS do not shift p LRAS SRAS 3 2 AD 12 13 Y Positive Demand Shock AD can shift from temporary demand shocks in which the LRAS and SRAS do not shift p LRAS SRAS 3.5 3 2 AD 12 13 Y Negative Demand Shock AD can shift from temporary demand shocks in which the LRAS and SRAS do not shift p LRAS SRAS 2 1.5 AD 11 12 Y Negative Demand Shock AD can shift from temporary demand shocks in which the LRAS and SRAS do not shift p LRAS SRAS 2 1.5 1.25 AD 11 12 Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 AD Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 AD Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD 3.2 Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD 4.3 Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD 3.6 Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD 3.6 1.9 Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 13.5 10.3 6.2 AD 3.6 1.9 Yp Y Negative Demand Shock The Volcker Disinflation p LRAS 1.9 AD Yp Y Negative Demand Shock 2001-2004 p LRAS SRAS 4.5 3.1 AD 11 12 Y Negative Demand Shock 2001-2004 p LRAS SRAS 4.5 3.1 1.6 AD 11 12 Source: Economic Report of the President. Y Supply Shock • Temporary supply shock – SRAS shifts – LRAS does not shift • Permanent supply shock – SRAS shifts – LRAS shifts – E.g., permanent negative supply shock occurs when ill-advised regulations that cause the economy to be less efficient are adopted – Real business cycle theory (Edward Prescott of ASU) says that business cycle fluctuations result from permanent supply shocks Temporary Negative Supply Shock 1973-1980 p LRAS SRAS 6 5 AD 11 12 Y Permanent Positive Supply Shock 1995–1999 p LRAS SRAS 5 4 AD 12 13 Y Negative Demand and Supply Shocks 2007–2009 LRAS p SRAS 4 3 0 AD 11 12 Y Negative Demand and Supply Shocks 2007–2009 LRAS p SRAS 4 3 0 -1 AD 11 11 12 Y Conclusions Aggregate demand and supply analysis yields the following conclusions: 1. A shift in the aggregate demand curve affects output only in the short run and has no effect in the long run 2. A temporary supply shock affects output and inflation only in the short run and has no effect in the long run (holding the aggregate demand curve constant) 3. A permanent supply shock affects output and inflation both in the short and the long run 4. The economy has a self-correcting mechanism that returns it to potential output and the natural rate of unemployment over time 5. Monetary policy has a short-run affect on AD only