NEURO-OPHTHALMOLOGY UPDATE 2012 Anthony C. Arnold, MD Jules Stein Eye Institute Los Angeles, California CASE 1 27 year old woman 1 week history visual loss OD Pain with eye movement VA 20/300 APD + Disc shown Diagnosis? OPTIC NEURITIS Young (mean 29) Female > male Pain with eye movement (92%) Central unilateral visual loss over days Afferent pupillary defect OPTIC NEURITIS: FUNDUS NORMAL 67% DISC EDEMA 33% OPTIC NEURITIS: FLUORESCEIN ANGIOGRAPHY Normal filling, early leakage OPTIC NEURITIS VF PATTERNS (ONTT) Central scotoma 8% Altitudinal visual field loss 15% Generalized depression 48% OPTIC NEURITIS MRI: Mild-mod enhancing optic n parenchyma 95% Kupersmith MJ, et al. Neuro-Ophthalmology 2001;25:34 OPTIC NEURITIS: NATURAL HISTORY Onset of visual loss days Pain resolves over days-weeks Visual recovery onset within 2-3 weeks, complete at months Visual outcome: > 20/20 74% @10 years Recurrence 36% overall @ 15 years OPTIC NEURITIS Risk of MS 15 year data: Overall 50% 0 MR lesion: 25% > 1 MR lesion: 72% ON Study Group Arch Neurol 2008;65:727-32 OPTIC NEURITIS WHAT TO DO? All patients get MRI Risk of MS Corticosteroids for ON? Improve visual outcome? Reduce risk of MS? MS therapy (immunomodulation agents) in non-MS patients who are at risk? OPTIC NEURITIS OPTIC NEURITIS TREATMENT TRIAL (ONTT) Oral prednisone 1mg/kg/day not used No visual benefit Increased recurrence rate (X 2) Higher oral dose may be acceptable1 1Kaufman DI et al. Neurology 2000;54:2039-44 OPTIC NEURITIS OPTIC NEURITIS TREATMENT TRIAL (ONTT) IV methylprednisolone 1 gm/day (single dose outpatient) X 3 days (+ oral X 11 d) Speeds recovery 1st 2-3 weeks No long term visual benefit Decreased progression to MS at 2 yrs (but not thereafter) if minimum 2 MRI white matter lesions OPTIC NEURITIS SO, a single dose of corticosteroids does reduce MS risk long term * Although we don’t know that repeated pulses might not accomplish this Is there anything we can do, especially in those at high risk (> 1 lesion on MR)? ON & IMA CHAMPS (2000) 383 pts 1st acute clinical demyelinating event (CIS), including 192 (50%) optic neuritis and MR showed > 2 lesions All received IV + oral steroids within 14 d Randomized to weekly 30 µg IM interferon beta-1a (Avonex) vs placebo within 27d Planned for 3 year treatment/followup Endpoint: clinically definite MS Jacobs LD, et al: N Engl J Med 2000;343:898-904 ON & IMA CHAMPS (2000) Study terminated after 1st interim analysis Cumulative probability for MS significantly lower in treatment than control (35% vs 50%, p = 0.002); reduction in rate by about half MR lesion volume, new/enlarging lesions, and enhancing lesions all significantly lower Jacobs LD, et al: N Engl J Med 2000;343:898-904 ON & IMA CHAMPIONS (2006) Post hoc analysis immediate vs delayed treatment in CHAMPS Trial 40% difference in conversion rate to CDMS at 10 years early vs delayed Delayed group double recurrence rate Kinkel RP, CHAMPIONS Study Group. Neurology 2006;66:678-84 ON & IMA OTHER IMMUNOMODULATION ETOMS (EU) Rebif (interferon beta 1a SQ) weekly vs placebo BENEFIT Betaseron (interferon beta-1b) SQ QOD PreCISe Glatiramer SQ daily ALL REDUCED RISK OF MS ON & IMA Most MS patients present with a CIS High risk = 1 typical MRI lesion 70-90% of high-risk CIS will go on to CDMS in 15 years IMA’s lower that risk substantially ON & IMA SO, TREAT EVERYONE WITH CIS + MR LESION? ON & IMA I AM NOT SURE THAT I AM RIGHT IMA: DRAWBACKS Expense ( > $10K/yr forever?) Injections Systemic side effects Treatment of the 25% not progressing to MS? Should we wait to see NEW MR lesions (repeat scan) before instituting therapy? OPTIC NEURITIS SHOULD CORTICOSTEROIDS BE USED IN EVERY CASE? MS attacks produce axonal damage early1 ONTT: reduced risk of MS for 2 years Reduction of permanent brain damage and long term disability in MS2 1Trapp BD et al. NEJM 1998;338:278-85 2Zivadinov R et al. Neurology 2001;56 (Suppl 3):A192 SUMMARY Reducing attacks reduces long term brain injury. Use of IMA’s reduces attacks Corticosteroids may be synergistic Consider IVMP or high dose oral to speed visual recovery Do not use oral 1 mg/kg/day prednisone MRI brain for white matter lesions Based on MS risk, consider IMA’s NEUROMYELITIS OPTICA (NMO) Older (mean 39) Female most frequent (9:1) Usually nonwhite Optic neuritis may be sequential or bilateral simultaneous Severe visual loss, poor recovery Extensive ON lesions on MR NMO – 2006 DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA Required • • Optic Neuritis Transverse Myelitis + Supportive (2 out of 3) • • • Brain MRI non-diagnostic for MS Spinal cord MRI lesion extending > 3 vertebral segments Positive NMO-Ig G NMO – Ig G NMO Ig-G binds to Aquaporin-4 • • • Astrocyte foot processes Abluminal surface of blood vessels Optic nerve, brain stem, hypothalamus, area postrema, supraoptic nucleus, and periventricular regions NMO Ig-G • 75% sensitive • 91% specific NMO – SPECTRUM DISORDERS • Limited forms of NMO • Bilateral simultaneous or recurrent ON ON associated with “specific” NMO Brain lesions NMO TREATMENT High dose corticosteroids + immunosuppressive agent (azothioprine) Plasmapheresis NONARTERITIC ANTERIOR ISCHEMIC OPTIC NEUROPATHY (NAION) Male = female, age > 50 Rapid onset painless visual field + acuity loss Afferent pupillary defect VF loss: altitudinal (50-80%), arcuate, or generalized depression Optic disc edema + flame hemorrhages at onset or preceding Edema may be segmental Disc hyperemic, some pallor as evolves NAION: FUNDUS Peripapillary arteriolar narrowing Fellow eye C/D small = “crowded disc” VS ARTERITIC (AAION) Disc edema often pale may be chalkwhite C/D ratio normal NAION: FLUORESCEIN ANGIOGRAPHY Delayed filling, late leakage VS ARTERITIC (AAION) Delayed filling, CHOROID + disc NAION: VISUAL FIELDS Altitudinal 50-80% Arcuate Generalized depression NAION: CLINICAL COURSE Generally stable course Most cases no change VA 42.7% (IONDT) spontaneous VA Resolution of disc edema to optic atrophy in 6-8 weeks (may be segmental) MRI negative NAION: TREATMENT ATTEMPTS Corticosteroids Dilantin Anticoagulants Antiplatelet agents Hypertensive agents Vasodilators Intraocular pressure lowering agents HBOT ONSF Dopamine agonists Neuroprotection Transvitreal optic neurotomy Vitrectomy Intravitreal triamcinolone Intravitreal bevacizumab Transcorneal electrical stimulation (!) NONE PROVEN EFFECTIVE INTRAVITREAL TRIAMCINOLONE Beneficial effect reported for intraocular edema in diabetic maculopathy & papillopathy1, radiation papillopathy2 Postulated to speed edema resolution, reduce compartment syndrome within optic disc 1Al-Haddad CE et al. Am J Ophthalmol 2004;137:1151-3 2Shields CL et al. Retina 2006;26:537-44 INTRAVITREAL TRIAMCINOLONE Kaderli B et al (2007): 4 subjects NAION, 4 mg IVtTMC, 10-22 days after onset 6 controls VA > 3 lines in 75% (3 of 4) treated vs 33% (2 of 6) controls No change in Goldmann VF Faster edema resolution (3 vs > 4 weeks) Kaderli B. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2007;27:238-40 INTRAVITREAL TRIAMCINOLONE Kaderli B et al (2007): Problems: Small n VA but not VF (fixation?) Does reducing surface edema affect retrolaminar damage? Kaderli B. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2007;27:238-40 INTRAVITREAL VEGF INHIBITORS Beneficial effect reported in neovascular ARMD by reducing vascular permeability Postulated to speed edema and exudate resolution, could reduce compartment syndrome within optic disc Rich RM et al. Retina 2006;26:495-511 INTRAVITREAL VEGF INHIBITORS Bennett JL et al (2007): 1 subject NAION IVt bevacizumab (Avastin®) 3 weeks post onset VA CF 1’ to 20/70 VF qualitative Disc edema improved more rapidly than expected Bennett JL et al. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2007;27:238-40 INTRAVITREAL VEGF INHIBITORS Kelman SE et al (2009): 30 subjects NAION IVt bevacizumab (Avastin®) < 2 weeks post onset VA 3 lines in 42% (12 eyes) VF no data Disc edema improved in 1 mo Kelman SE: NANOS Annual Meeting 2009 INTRAVITREAL VEGF INHIBITORS 2 Clinical Trials: Enetzari et al: 15 eyes vs control Bevacizumab + TMC No benefit Rootman et al: 27 eyes vs control Bevacizumab No benefit Entezari M. Ophthalmology 2012;119:879-80 Rootman D. AAO Annual Meeting 2012 INTRAVITREAL VEGF INHIBITORS RISKS Pece (2010): 1/3 cases worsened VF after IVT bevacizumab Prescott (2012): 3/5 cases worsened after IVT bevacizumab 4 case reports 2009-2010 of NAION following IVT bevacizumab for retinal diseases Pece A. J Ocular Pharmacol & Ther 2010;26:523-7 Prescott CR. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2012;32:51-3 ORAL CORTICOSTEROID 364 treated NAION vs 332 controls (1973-2000) Prednisone 80mg/day X 2 weeks, taper over 2 mo Begun within 2 weeks after onset Hayreh SS. Graefe’s Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2008 ORAL CORTICOSTEROID Hayreh SS (2008) At 6 mo VA > 3 lines in 69.8% vs 40.5% controls in pts < 20/70 VF in 40.1% vs 24.5% controls Hayreh SS. Graefe’s Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2008 ORAL CORTICOSTEROID Hayreh SS (2008) Disc edema resolved faster in treated than controls Postulated decreased ONH tissue pressure and reduced compartment syndrome Hayreh SS. Graefe’s Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2008 ORAL CORTICOSTEROID Hayreh SS (2008) Problems: Voluntary group assignment Non-masked VA examiner (SSH) Post hoc selection of < 20/70 VA (70 eyes) for outcome Hayreh SS. Graefe’s Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2008 Lee AG, Biousse V. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2010 ERYTHROPOIETIN? MODARRES ET AL (2011) 31 eyes IVIT erythropoietin within 30 days (mean 11 days) At 6 months, VA improved by > 3 lines in 17 eyes, 54.8% (vs 42% natural history) Postulated neuroprotective effect Modarres M Br J Ophthalmol 2011;95:992-5 ANTERIOR ISCHEMIC OPTIC NEUROPATHY MANAGEMENT NAION vs AAION: ESR + CRP + TA biopsy Symptoms critical; FA may help AAION: Steroids, IV or PO NAION: no proven effective therapy Medical evaluation Follow resolution of disc edema Consider ASA prophylaxis PDE5 Inhibitors and NAION Anthony C. Arnold, MD Jules Stein Eye Institute Los Angeles, California Disclosure I am Chair of DSMC for Pfizer, Inc PDE5i study. I am not on a speaker’s bureau. This is not a Pfizer prepared lecture. I have no financial interest in the company PDE5 Inhibitors and the Nitric Oxide–cGMP Pathway Vascular Smooth Muscle Cell NO GMP GC GTP PDE5 cGMP Relaxation PDE5 is a naturally occurring enzyme which breaks down cGMP PDE5 inhibitors selectively inhibit PDE5, block breakdown of cGMP, relax smooth muscle by enhancing the effect of nitric oxide (NO) and cGMP pathway NO–cGMP pathway also modulates systemic BP through its effect on basal vascular tone PDE5 Inhibitors and NAION How could PDE5 inhibitors be related to NAION? 1. Exaggerated nocturnal hypotension hypoperfusion of optic nerve head 2. Local optic nerve head vasodilation compartment syndrome Levin LA: arterial dilation compresses venous system, analogous to erectile effect 3. Local optic nerve head vasodilation impaired local optic nerve head autoregulation 4. Toxic effect of drug or increased cGMP Levin LA et al. Arch Ophthalmol 2008;126:1582-5 PDE5 Inhibitors and NAION Problems “Patients lie.” – G. House, MD Dose Frequency Other drugs Onset within window of effect? 54 PDE5 Inhibitors and NAION Problems Confounding factors Effect of “activity” (intercourse) • Physical • Psychosocial (adrenaline) Vasculopathic risk factors (often the reason for use of PDE5 inhibitors) Other vasodilators (NTG) 55 Risk of Cardiovascular Disease in Erectile Dysfunction Patients Risk Factor Increased Likelihood of Having ED 1 1.5 Diabetes Hypertension Current smoker Obesity 2 2.5 2.69 1.56 1.74 1.60 Saigal CS et al. Arch Intern Med. 2006;23;166:207-212. 3 Sildenafil (VIAGRA) and NAION Egan and Pomeranz (2000) 52-year-old male, Crohn’s disease, ADD, on Ritalin, crowded discs 1 hour post dose, blue “lightning bolts” OU, and blurred inferior VF OS Superior disc edema, inferior VF loss OS, later superior OA, stable VF loss Egan R et al. Arch Ophthalmol. 2000;118:291-292. Sildenafil (VIAGRA) and NAION Pomeranz and Bhavsar (2005) Seven new cases + review 7 prior cases = 14 total New cases: age 50–69 y, all had at least 1 vasculopathic risk factor and all had “crowded discs” Event within 36 hours of dose Pomeranz HD, Bhavsar AR. J Neuroophthalmol. 2005;25:9-13. Tadalafil (Cialis) and NAION Bollinger and Lee (2005) Rechallenge case 67-year-old, inf VF defect 2 hours following 20-mg dose, resolved within 24 h X 4 times 5th time: permanent INF ALT VF loss with NAION Bollinger K, Lee MS. Arch Ophthalmol. 2005;123:400-401. Interesting Numbers Patients using sildenafil = > 50 million Prescriptions written for sildenafil = > 200 million Tablets dispensed = 2.3 billion Documented cases of NAION in sildenafil users: < 75 Interesting Numbers (2005) Reported cases of NAION in Pfizer studies of 52,000 patient-years of observation: 1 Background studies incidence of NAION: 2.5–11.8/100,000 patients/year Calculated incidence from Pfizer studies: 2.8/100,000 patients/year Summary “Viagra-blindness” has been sensationalized There is a theoretic (but unproven) basis for causal effect (hypotension, impaired disc autoregulation, compartment syndrome) There are < 75 cases, all in patients with risk factors for NAION Several cases are plausible for causative effect FDA-Mandated Study Pfizer NAION Study Prospective international multicenter study Currently recruiting 2012: 64 US + 39 EU centers New cases of NAION interviewed for use of PDE5i (any) Case-crossover methodology (compare window of exposure c/w half-life to prior non-exposed windows up to 30 days) FDA-Mandated Study Pfizer NAION Study 2012: 567 [of est 800 needed] subjects; 30 [of 40 needed] with PDE5i exposure within 30 day window Anticipated recruitment complete in 2012 (after 4 years) Assess link to NAION Summary Advice to patients No prior NAION (disc-at-risk?) Prior NAION not within window of effect Prior NAION within window of effect HORNER SYNDROME Ptosis (mild, both upper & lower lid) Miosis Anisocoria darkness (dilation lag) + Anhidrosis HORNER SYNDROME STANDARD WORKUP Confirm diagnosis Localize lesion Determine etiology CONFIRMATION: COCAINE HOW? Cocaine 4-10% OU If anisocoria > 1 mm, positive If anisocoria increases by > 1 mm, positive Kardon RH. Arch Ophthalmol 1990;108:384-7 CONFIRMATION: COCAINE DISADVANTAGES Not commercially available, pharmacy formulated, nonpreserved, re-supply q 2 months (issues of potency) Controlled substance (issues of bureaucracy) Endpoint may be unclear CONFIRMATION PARADIGM SHIFT: APRACLONIDINE MECHANISM IOP lowering agent (α2 adrenergic effect) Very weak α1 adrenergic sympathetic (mydriatic) effect, no dilation of normals With denervation supersensitivity in Horner’s any location, dilates affected pupil CONFIRMATION: APRACLONIDINE HOW? Apraclonidine 0.5% OU Reverses anisocoria Also reverses ptosis (treatment implications) Requires denervation supersensitivity (onset in days) Freedman KA. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2005;25:83-85 LOCALIZATION Where is the lesion? Brain (central, postganglionic) Neck (central, preor post-ganglionic) Chest (preganglionic) LOCALIZATION WHY LOCALIZE?: Central or preganglionic = BAD Postganglionic = GOOD TRUE? LOCALIZATION: PAREDRINE (HYDROXYAMPHETAMINE) HOW? Paredrine (hydroxyamphetamine) 1% OU Anisocoria increase by > 1 mm positive for postganglionic LOCALIZATION: PAREDRINE (HYDROXYAMPHETAMINE) DISADVANTAGES Postganglionic lesions are not necessarily “good”: carotid dissections and cavernous sinus/skull base lesions are postganglionic Test is estimated 85% accurate Paredrine not commercially available: issues of formulation, potency HORNER SYNDROME Localization Head: carotid dissection, intracranial tumor Neck: carotid dissection, tumor Chest: pulmonary apex tumor HORNER SYNDROME IMAGE (HORNER PROTOCOL) MRI skull base to T2 MRA OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA 44 year old woman 9 month history slowly progressive visual loss Exam: VA: OD 20/50; OS 20/20 APD OD VF: moderate generalized depression OD Mild proptosis OD; EOM normal Optic disc OD: mild atrophy with optociliary shunts OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA NATURAL HISTORY (TUMOR) Intracranial spread 14% at 2-4 years Contralateral spread Intraorbital at presentation: 0% Intracranial at presentation: 2-4% Death, metastasis: 0% OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA NATURAL HISTORY (VISION) 1-3 VA lines/year decrease (Sibony) 72% VA worse at mean 6.2 years (Kennerdell) VA mean 50% drop at 10.8 years (Turbin) 84% deteriorated at 22 months (Andrews) 44% lost VA at 6.2 years (Egan) OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA PRIOR STANDARD THERAPY Good vision, tumor limited to orbit: Observe If marked visual deterioration or MR growth toward contralateral nerve: Consider excision If initial vision poor or tumor extends intracranially: Consider excision OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA PRIOR STANDARD THERAPY Surgery blinding No proven effective nonsurgical therapy Hormonal (RU-486) therapy unproven No effective chemotherapy Standard irradiation • Inconsistent effect • Risk of delayed radionecrosis brain, retina, optic nerve (15%) OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA STEREOTACTIC CONFORMAL FRACTIONATED IRRADIATION Stereotactic: head immobilized (fixation screws) Delivered with intensity modulated beams Fractionated over 20 sessions (5000 cGy) rather than the 1-6 sessions of gamma knife OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA STEREOTACTIC CONFORMAL FRACTIONATED IRRADIATION Decreased risk of contralateral optic nerve and adjacent CNS damage Several reports of significant visual improvement and stability1,2 Longterm damage unknown 1Fineman MS, et al. Surv Ophthalmol 1999;43:519-24 2Moyer PD, et al. Am J Ophthalmol 2000;129:694-6 OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA STEREOTACTIC CONFORMAL FRACTIONATED IRRADIATION Arvold (Harvard) [2009]: 25 cases conformal fractionated (stereotactic photon [13] or proton [9]) Median dose 50.4 Gy; median followup 30 months (range 3168) 21/22 (95%) improved (64%) or stable (32%) 20/22 (91%) radiographically stable 3/22 (14%) radiation retinopathy (asymptomatic) Arvold ND, et al. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2009;75:1166-72 OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA STEREOTACTIC CONFORMAL FRACTIONATED IRRADIATION Metellus (Hopkins) [2010]: 9 cases conformal fractionated stereotactic photon Median dose 50.4 Gy; median followup 90 months (range 61151) 7/9 (78%) vision improved (64%) 9/9 (100%) radiographically stable 1/9 (11%) radiation retinopathy treated with PRP, central loss at 11 years Metellus P et al. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2010;76:1-8 (epub) OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA 2012: MANAGEMENT Consider individual factors If limited to orbit, with useful vision, stable, consider observation If therapy is considered, stereotactic fractionated conformal radiotherapy is the initial treatment of choice in essentially every case OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA STEREOTACTIC CONFORMAL FRACTIONATED IRRADIATION (to date) Complications Radiation retinopathy • 4 cases Radiation optic neuropathy • NONE STEREOTACTIC CONFORMAL NONFRACTIONATED IRRADIATION (RADIOSURGERY) 2% RON in parasellar masses “Multisession Cyberknife radiosurgery” Miller NR. J Neuro-ophthalmol 2006;26:200-8 Jeremic B, Pitz S. Cancer 2007;110:714-22 OPTIC NERVE SHEATH MENINGIOMA 2012: MANAGEMENT Surgical excision reserved for Eyes with poor vision, progression, unresponsive to radiotherapy Disfiguring proptosis or intractable pain, poor vision, unresponsive to radiotherapy CASE 31 year old obese woman (attorney-of course) Presents to ER with 10 day history of headache, nausea & vomiting Exam: VA 20/15 OU, normal pupils & EOM; Fundus & VF shown CASE MRI no tumor LP opening pressure 310 mm, normal composition CASE Is this Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension (IIH)? Friedman criteria (2002): ICP > 250 mm H20 CSF normal No other specific cause of ICP Friedman DI et al. Neurology 2002;59:1492-5 Specific Causes Tumor Hydrocephalus Structural (Chiari, synostosis, etc) Meningeal lesion Medications Other CASE Are we sure there is no specific cause? CASE MR venogram: Superior sagittal sinus thrombosis IIH vs Dural Venous Sinus Disease Venous sinus thrombosis Venous sinus stenosis Venous sinus AV fistula (malformation) Friedman DI. J Neuro-Ophthalmol 2006;26:61-4 CASE Management Anticoagulation ICP-lowering agents Hypercoagulable state workup (negative) Volume depletion + prolonged neck extension?