Seminar Date
2
3
4
Which of your clients’ assets are protected by an insurance program?
Where does the A/R fall on most companies’ balance sheet?
Typically represents from 40% to 70% of a company’s assets
Most vulnerable to unexpected losses
Likely to be affected by business cycles
Provides cash flow for the business
Only under-leveraged asset with financial lender
Few companies can effectively compete without extending credit to their buyers
What amount of loss would seriously impact your client’s annual profit? How many accounts have credit extended over that amount?
5
Bankruptcies are inevitable
Failures come from increasingly unpredictable sources
- Management Deficiencies
- Complex Financial Restructuring
- Regulatory Changes
- Legal Maneuvering (Chapter 11)
- Product Liability
- Political Upheaval
- Global Economic Changes
Large Bankruptcies can cause a bankruptcy domino effect with suppliers
- Set off chain reaction that trickles down
- Demands resources to monitor and manage beyond primary debtor
6
A healthy credit management program customarily budgets for a certain level of expected uncollectible debt write-offs in the financial management of a business. However, even if an unprotected company is able to withstand an unplanned catastrophic loss or multiple losses to its financials, there are other consequences on earnings and future growth.
If a company’s revolving credit line is secured by its accounts receivable, a write-off of part of those receivables immediately impacts cash flow. The same level of funds is no longer available for the company to run it’s dayto-day operations.
The company may become less comfortable with extending future credit without highly secured forms of repayment, impacting the company’s ability to successfully compete and acquire new customers.
Future growth may suffer if the company lacks the necessary cash to invest in product development, distribution, technology and other areas.
At its most basic level, managing trade credit involves making decisions on whether or not to extend credit, setting terms of a credit arrangement and collecting on receivables .
Most businesses use a variety of tools to determine credit-worthy customers and to minimize bad debt losses:
Third Party Information – such as merchantile reports (e.g. Dun & Bradstreet)
People Resources
– such as credit managers, risk analysts, etc.
Financial vehicles
– such as factors and collection agencies
Risk Mitigation Mechanisms – such as letters of credit, liens and credit insurance
7
• Prevent disruptive losses to one of company’s largest, unprotected assets
•
Safeguard revenue stream from bad debt loss due to unforeseen non-payment, slow payment or insolvencies due to commercial and/or political risks; assuring continuity of business operations.
• Reduce the risk of key account concentration levels
• Improve timely collection of receivables, lowers DSO and strengthens cash flow
•
Cap exposure to bad debt loss and smoothes financial results over the business cycle
– unlike an allowance for doubtful accounts - accomplishes this with tax deductible premium.
•
Improve borrowing power and increase available capital by converting receivables into a performing asset.
• Eliminate lender’s concern over account concentration
• Enable eligibility of foreign receivables
• Reduce need for personal security requirements
8
• Increase incremental growth opportunities with existing customers by safely extending more credit
• Mitigate the risk of expanding sales into more volatile or new markets, both domestically and abroad.
•
Enhance customer relationships
– safe profitable cooperation between sales and credit functions.
•
Increase ability to offer more competitive terms attract export customer base.
o No need for letters of credit and collateral requirements on foreign shipments.
o Open terms permit buyers to reserve their own working capital line for other uses.
•
Strengthen structure and discipline for credit decision making
•
Improve credit risk intelligence using unparalleled third party evaluations of prospective customers, industries and countries.
• Install on-going and consistent key account analysis, supply chain monitoring and back-up support for their credit management program
• Increase leverage over troubled accounts by utilizing insurer’s expertise and global resources
9
Financial Guarantee
A Substitute for Prudent Credit Management Practices
Routine Bad-Debt Protection.
Fraud or Trade Dispute Insurance
Accounts Receivable Factoring
Valuable Papers or Accounts Receivable Records Property
Insurance
10
Vulnerability Factors – Greater Need for Risk Mitigation Vehicles
Sales Concentration – vulnerable to devastating losses when a single industry sector or few customers represent more than 25% of total sales
Rapid Sales Growth or New Customer Risk – increased need to safeguard bottom-line results from sales expansion, which is frequently accompanied by write-offs of new customer receivables
Export Sales – relying upon LOC’s or other trade mechanisms can inhibit ability to attract customers and achieve sales growth. There may also be a untapped opportunity to leverage foreign receivables with lender.
Recent Bad Debt History reserves for write-offs in excess of 1% of sales may indicate company that has experienced impact of unusual receivable write-offs on their past earnings and cash-flow.
11
Vulnerability Factors – Need for Credit Risk Mitigation Vehicles
Special Order Goods – If custom-made orders are greater than 30% of company’s total sales, the business is at greater financial risk because inventory can not easily be sold to second party without loss or heavy discounts.
Longer Terms of Sale – open credit terms of more than 60 days increase amount and duration of credit risk (uncertainty of getting paid)
Financing Receivables
Limited Financial Capacity – thin profit margins/highly leveraged companies
Low Risk Tolerance – senior financial executives, especially with public companies, actively seek to avoid earnings volatility
Overburdened Credit Management Capability – prefers to supplement credit decision making with external resources.
12
Self-insurance
– establishing bad debt reserves or captive program to offset deficit should customers be unable to pay
Offers flexibility to respond to issues – with nominal coverage exclusions
May create liquidity problems, especially for unforeseen losses.
Impacts capital allocation of balance sheet and may reveal operating weaknesses
Requires investment in credit management systems, information acquisition, analysis and monitoring, and finally audit controls
No alternative “bad cop” to soften conflict resolution with clients who are slow to pay.
Collateral
– transfer credit risk from balance sheet by using pre-payment, cash on delivery, letters of credit or other assets (i.e. liens)
Mechanism for quick recovery, depending on liquidity of the collateral
LC’s are obligations and require performance of specific conditions
Can make a business very unattractive to potential customers in competitive marketplace.
May damage relationship with a client if the company has to move against the asset
Requires administration to maintain security position (for example, filing UCC statements, monitoring escrow accounts, and/or execution of LC documents)
13
Credit Insurance
– commercial insurance product that indemnifies a company against non-disputed losses from non-payment or slow payment of commercial trade debt
Program flexibility – designed for an entire A/R portfolio or segment of customers
Accommodates both sizeable and smaller exposures; rated and unrated companies; delivered products and trading operations.
Recovery triggered by defined events
As credit quality deteriorates, cover may be restricted or cancelled (depending on insurer)
Business maintains control of customer relationships; bearing cost of protection so customer(s) may be unaware that coverage has been purchased.
Put Option
– the right to sell a named trade receivable at a set price within a defined period of time if an insolvency or other specified event occurs.
Loss occurring with limited trigger for recovery, i.e. insolvency (shipment and loss event must occur within “put period”.
Typically available for public high-risk buyers (or buyers with public debt) that traditional credit insurance market will not cover
Backer is an investor – untested market in terms of claims settlement in event of catastrophic occurrence
Extremely expensive compared to other forms of credit protection.
14
Factoring
–
Unless it is a non-recourse agreement, factoring is usually a financing tool rather than a risk transfer mechanism. This option is typically used by companies with temporary cash-flow problems or unusual cash demands that do not have access to traditional financing sources. A factor usually purchases a company’s accounts receivable at a reduced amount of the face of the invoice.
Immediate access to cash in exchange for a % of the receivables value plus a fee
Many factors offer invoicing, collections and other bookkeeping services for companies looking to outsource their entire accounts receivable function.
Not all factors assume the risk of non-payment for invoice they purchase
Considerable margin erosion
Loss of control over customer relationships
Asset is removed from balance sheet restricting line availability
15
16
Unlike other types of business insurance, once a company purchases credit insurance, the policy does not get filed away until next year’s renewal, but rather relationship becomes dynamic.
Policy can change often over the course of the policy period and the company’s credit manager plays an active role.
Requests for additional coverage on a specific buyer
Request for coverage on a new buyer
Many established credit insurers are “limits underwriters”, meaning the company’s more significant buyers are analyzed individually and assigned a credit limit for coverage.
A company’s less significant buyers may be insured under a blanket type of cover, known as a “discretionary credit limit” or DCL.
17
The ultimate goal of credit insurance program is not to simply pay legitimate claims as they arise, but rather to help a business to avoid forseeable bad debt loss altogether.
It is credit insurer’s responsibility to proactively monitor the company’s buyers throughout the policy period to ensure their continued creditworthiness
Gather financial information about private and public companies from variety of sources, including visits to the buyer, financial statements, data supplied by other policyholders that sell to the same buyer, public records, bank references etc.
When data signals that a company’s financial position is deteriorating, the insurer notifies its policyholders that sell to that buyer of the increased risk, and establishes an action plan to mitigate and avoid loss.
18
The ultimate goal of credit insurance program is not to simply pay legitimate claims as they arise, but rather to help a business to avoid forseeable bad debt loss altogether.
It is credit insurer’s responsibility to proactively monitor the company’s buyers throughout the policy period to ensure their continued creditworthiness
Gather financial information about private and public companies from variety of sources, including visits to the buyer, financial statements, data supplied by other policyholders that sell to the same buyer, public records, bank references etc.
When data signals that a company’s financial position is deteriorating, the insurer notifies its policyholders that sell to that buyer of the increased risk, and establishes an action plan to mitigate and avoid loss.
19
Submit a completed and signed application
Business Description
Terms of Sale
Sales History and Bad Debt Experience
Sales Volume
Current Past Dues
Names and Addresses of Key Buyers
Export – Breakdown of Sales Distribution by Country with Terms of Sale
Brief Summary of Company’s Credit Procedures
Provide a copy of the company’s current Accounts Receivable Aging
Report.
Once policy is active, ongoing administration may include reporting to the insurer past due exposures/invoices for buyers at the end of each calendar month in order to keep coverage active.
20
21
Private Insurers
Privately owned, but may also act on government’s behalf for foreign receivables
Provides pure cover, insurance to business or a lending institution
•Public Export Credit Agencies (ECA’s)
Country created, state owned export credit agency acting on behalf of governments in the countries where they are located.
In some countries, export credit agencies also provide financing support
Cost is frequently more expensive than private insurers. Often avenue used to obtain coverage for high-risk buyers that is not available in private market.
Examples: EX-IM Bank or Export-Import Bank of the U.S., JEXIM or the
Export-Import Bank of Japan, and EDC (Canada).
22
Euler Hermes
Chartis/AIG
Foreign Credit Insurance Agency
(FCIA)
Atradius
Compagnie Francaise d’Assurance pour le Commerce Exterieur (COFACE)
QBE Specialty Insurance
ACE
HCC Insurance Holdings Inc.
Zurich
23
Established in 1934, EX-IM Bank is an independent government agency of the
United Sates headquartered in Washington D.C. with sales offices in NYC,
Miami, Chicago, Houston, Los Angeles and D.C.
Mission – support U.S. exports in order to create and sustain U.S. jobs with reasonable assurance of repayment.
Non-competition with private sector
Products must have at least 51% U.S. content, including labor but excluding mark-up
Mandated Initiative
Small business (85% of transactions)
Africa
Environment
Minority Business
Available Products
Working Capital Guarantee
Short and Medium Term Insurance (Single buyer and multi-buyer policies available)
Medium and Long-term Loans
24
25
Any company that sells to other businesses on short-term open credit terms of 180 days or less.
Concentration of trade receivables
Thin profit margins
Growing sales due to market expansion and/or merger/acquisition
Export sales
Manufacturers, wholesalers, distributors, and service providers with annual domestic or export sales of $3 million or more.
Broad range of target industries including but not limited to:
Machinery and Equipment
Metals
Pharmaceuticals
Life Sciences
Food Products
Electronics/Technology/Computers
Chemicals
Energy/Oil & Gas
Transportation/Global Logistics Firms
Telecommunications
Paper & Packaging
Consumer Goods
26
1.
Strengthen the balance sheet and safeguard sales and gross margin. “The lower the gross margin percentage , the more sales and production required to replace a bad debt.”
ASK – What amount of loss would seriously hurt your company’s financial stability or yearly profit? How many accounts are over this amount?
ASK
– What percentage of total or current assets does your customer’s accounts receivable represent?
2.
Secure the company cash flow and avoid the domino effect – a large portion of business failures are directly attributed to uncollectible accounts
3.
Reduce bad debt reserves and free up working capital to be invested more productively
27
1.
Improve accounts receivable margining.
ASK – Does your company rely on financing, collateralized by your receivables, to fund working capital needs?
ASK
– Do you export products? Would you be interested in a way to include foreign receivables in your lending base?
2.
Reduce cost of borrowing
ASK
– Are you happy with the rate you pay with your current lender? Is your operating line substantially used at this time?
3.
Reduce bank security requirements
ASK
– Do you provide a personal guarantee to your bank? Do you feel significantly over-secured at your bank?
28
1.
Expand sales to new, unknown or higher-risk customers and new markets to which sales are currently restricted. Credit insurance is a tool to increase incremental sales. The higher the gross margin percentage, the greater the contribution from incremental sales
ASK – Are there any new or higher-risk customers to which you are restricting sales?
2.
Improve export sales by selling on less restricted payment terms
(no need to require Letters of Credit)
ASK – Do you have export sales? If so, which countries and under what payment terms?
ASK – Could selling on open account terms make you more attractive to your potential client base and improve your competitive position?
29
1.
Partnership with Credit Management
2.
Access to Risk Management System, Analysts and Evaluation
Intelligence
ASK
– Does your company currently utilize external resources in your credit process? Which sources?
ASK – How well do you know your customer’s customers? Do you evaluate potential exposure to failures in the supply chain that may adversely impact your customer’s ability to pay (domino effect)?
30
www.eulerhermes.com