Raising Children of Character: What Parents Can Do & How Schools Can Build the Partnership Dr. Thomas Lickona Author, Raising Good Children Director, Center for the 4th and 5th Rs www.cortland.edu/character This talk includes material adapted from the author’s books Character Matters and Raising Good Children. WHY IS PARENTING HARDER THAN EVER? 1. 2. 3. Society has changed. Families have changed. The peer group has changed. 1. Society has changed. Much of the media—TV, movies, video games, entertainment and sports icons, porn on the Internet, and the marketplace culture—promotes materialism, hedonism, violence, and vulgarity, all of which most kids can now access via portable, everchanging technologies. 2. Families have changed. More are broken or fragile; don’t provide kids with enough love, guidance, or supervision; lack the structure and support of a faith community or other support system; and are stressed by work responsibilities and overcrowded schedules that reduce family together time. 3. The peer group has changed. Because lots of kids are being raised by the popular culture instead of their parents, the negative values they pick up contribute to a peer culture that considers it okay to lie, cheat in school, shoplift from stores, or have sex with your boyfriend or girlfriend. INTENTIONAL PARENTING A societal environment that can’t be counted on to support good character means parents have to be more vigilant, more intentional, than in past generations. We must take deliberate steps to create a strong family life that builds close relationships, teaches good values, and fortifies kids against the cultural temptations and pressures. The Home-School Partnership The family is the first school of virtue. Schools and families must work together to develop good character. Letter to parents . . . 1. The family is the first and most important influence on a child’s character. 2. The school’s job is to reinforce the positive character virtues (hard work, respect, honesty, caring, etc.) being taught at home. PARENT LEADERSHIP COMMITTEE 1. 2. 3. Organizes school-based, characterrelated events for parents (e.g., special assemblies, parenting talks, family film nights, common book project). Helps parents model and teach character in family life (e.g., monthly “Character Corner” newsletter). Develops a parent resource center. Parent Support Groups Meet every 6-8 weeks in someone’s home. 4 couples with students at the same developmental level. Parents choose the topic for the evening. Parents share success stories and challenges around the focus issue. Character Education Homework Parent and child, independently, each make a list: “Who are 5 of your heroes? Why?” Then compare and discuss lists. MORAL COMPACT WITH PARENTS Ask parents to “sign on”: “We commit to working with the school to promote good character.” Grilled Cheese Sandwich Story We don´t have to be perfect parents. “Our children don’t need to see a perfect role model, only someone who is trying.” Parenting Does Not Create the Child Parents can put their children on the right path, but the final forming of a person’s character lies in their own hands. —Anne Frank 11 Principles of Parenting Principle 1 Know what good character is and make character development a high priority. What is the content of good character? 10 Essential Virtues Wisdom (Good Judgment) 2. Justice (Golden Rule) 3. Fortitude (Inner Toughness) 4. Self-control 5. Love (Sacrifice for Others) 6. Positive attitude 7. Hard work 8. Integrity (Honesty w/Yourself) 9. Gratitude 10. Humility (Desire to Be Better) 1. RECOGNIZE KIDS’ VIRTUES AND AREAS FOR GROWTH “That was generous of you to share with your sister.” “How can you work on controlling that temper? Let’s make a plan.” We should make it clear that we are also striving to be a better person. Our character, like theirs, is a work in progress. performance character (needed for best work); moral character (needed for best relationships) Smart & Good High Schools Download free from: Center for the 4th and 5th Rs (Respect and Responsibility) www.cortland.edu/character Family Impact on Performance Character In their book America’s Smallest School: The Family, Paul Barton and Richard Coley report that students do better in school when: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. there are two parents in the home children are well cared for and feel secure the family environment is intellectually stimulating parents encourage self-discipline and perseverance parents limit TV, monitor homework, and ensure regular school attendance. A father of 7 asked his kids: “What goal are you working on this month?” Make character development a priority by taking the long view: We are “raising adults.” —James Stenson, Compass: A Handbook on Parent Leadership What will my kids be like when they are grown men and women? Will they be hardworking and responsible? Will they make loving husbands and wives and capable mothers and fathers? How might my actions now as a parent affect those outcomes? I was an only child, and my parents knowingly let me have my way most of the time to show how much they loved me. But the long-term effect on me is that I have struggled with selfishness my whole life. I’m used to getting my own way, and when someone goes against me, I take it very personally. Research finds that adults who were overindulged as children have difficulty coping with life’s disappointments. They have a distorted sense of entitlement that gets in the way of success in the workplace and in relationships. Ways to Say No 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. No. No, and that’s final. No, and don’t ask me again. I have thought about it, and the answer is no. I know you know how to nag. It won’t work. Nice try, the answer is still no. A Character-Centered Family Culture THE DAVIDSON WAY We don’t complain or make excuses. We don’t lie, cheat, steal, or intentionally hurt others. We learn from our mistakes. We work to keep our minds, bodies, and souls healthy, strong, and pure. We commit to growing in our faith and trusting in God’s goodness and His plan for our unique potential. We live with an attitude of gratitude and joy. The father says . . . We have this hanging in the kitchen and review it at the beginning of the week. We also refer to it when something comes up during the week. It’s like the foundation of a home—it’s what we build on. WHAT MATTERS MOST? In the course of family life, parents reveal in a thousand ways what matters most to them. —Mary Reed Newland, The Saints and Our Children Principle 2: Build a strong marriage—based on love, respect, and commitment. If you are a single parent . . . Find at least one other parent and share parenting experiences. Be emotionally supportive of your kids. Be firm but not harsh in your discipline. Know where your kids are and what they are doing. Marriage Ritual: Daily Talk Time Plan a regular time for 15 minutes of oneon-one conversation with your spouse. Don’t use it to discuss conflicts or make difficult decisions. Re-connect with each other; share thoughts and feelings about the day. —Dr. William Doherty, The Intentional Family Work on communication— understanding each other’s needs and feelings. In a conflict, take turns “being understood.” (Use active listening.) Reconciliation Rituals Healthy families have rituals that enable them to forgive and make up quickly after an argument. (Traits of a Healthy Family, Dolores Curran) “Please forgive me.” “A hug for health” “Let’s pretend that blow-up didn’t happen—and wipe the slate clean.” Work Together as Parents 1. 2. 3. Share the work of parenting. Talk about the kids. Support each other. If you disagree about how to handle a situation with a child, do so privately. Principle 3 Love children (affirmation, time, communication, & sacrifice) #1. Attention and Affirmation Notice and nurture your children’s interests—an authentic way of loving and respecting them. A sport, talent, or other interest helps a young person develop their sense of being their own person. MOLLY’S STORY A15-year-old girl in therapy because of rebellion against her parents’ values To avoid this kind of rebellion, help kids develop their own interests and their own identity as a person. Praise more than you criticize “My father criticized me constantly. He wanted me to be tough. I guess he thought that by pointing out my faults, I would get better. It made me stop trying.” —Meg Meeker, M.D., Strong Fathers, Strong Daughters EMOTIONAL DEPRIVATION DISORDER In Healing the Unaffirmed, the psychotherapist Conrad Baars describes patients who suffer from “emotional deprivation disorder.” They struggle with feelings of being unloved and unlovable, oversensitive, insecure and afraid of life, depressed, and unable to make friends and relate to others. An Affirmation Ritual: The Christmas Letter “Each Christmas my husband and I wrote a letter to each of our 5 kids and put it under the tree. “We told them what we loved and appreciated about them, the ways we had seen them grow during the past year, the talents and character strengths we saw emerging….” #2. Time We need psychologically intimate, face-to-face time with our children. Attending their sports games and other events does not meet this need. A son remembers . . . “When I had a cold, my father would rub my chest with Vicks and cover it with a red flannel cloth. “On Sunday afternoons, we would walk together to the top of the hill by the dam. We would sit on a rock and look down on the town below us. “Then I would tell my problems to my father, and he would speak of his to me.” —Christian Barnard, originator of the heart transplant A Saturday Ritual “I have four kids. Each of them gets one Saturday afternoon a month where it’s just the two of us doing something we both enjoy.” —a School Superintendent # 3. Communication: Back-and-forth Questions 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. How was today on a scale of 1 to 10—where 1 is “terrible” and 10 “terrific”? Why? What happened today that you didn’t expect? What did you accomplish today that you feel good about? What did you learn today? What’s an interesting conversation you had? The Family Meal: Have a “Topic.” 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. What was the best part of your day? What did you learn today? How did you help someone today? What is something you’re grateful for? What’s a problem you’re having that the rest of the family might be able to help with? # 4. Sacrifice “The most important thing parents can do for their children is to love each other and stay together.” —a mother “Being a responsible parent means putting yourself second for a quarter of a century.” —Albert Ellis Dr. Judith Wallerstein The Unexpected Legacy of Divorce: A 25-Year Landmark Study Help for troubled marriages: www.retrouvaille.org Wallerstein: Children of divorce typically experienced not one divorce but a series of "mini-divorces" as their parents went in search of new partners. Karen’s case was common. After her parents' divorce, her father remarried. His second wife was nice to the children but three years into the marriage left without warning. Then the father had four more girlfriends who caused him a great deal of suffering when each of them left. Karen's mother had three unhappy love affairs prior to her remarriage, which ended after five years. Each of these ruptures renews the turmoil in the child's life. Only seven of the 131 children Wallerstein studied experienced stable second marriages in which they had good relationships with both sides of the divorced family. As a result of this ongoing emotional upheaval, children of divorce typically take longer to grow up. They often fear commitment. They enter relationships wondering when they will fail. They have no template for working out conflicts. For a great many, time does not heal these wounds. WHY MARRIAGE MATTERS: THIRTY CONCLUSIONS FROM THE SOCIAL SCIENCES (2011) W. Bradford Wilcox, Editor 18 Family Scholars “Four in 10 children are exposed to a cohabiting relationship. Cohabitating households with children are now the largest unrecognized threat to the quality of children’s lives.” Principle 4 Be an authoritative parent. Parents must have a strong sense of moral authority —their right to be respected and obeyed. RESPECT: THE FOUNDATION In The Moral Child, Stanford psychologist William Damon states that how well parents teach their child to respect their authority lays the foundation for future moral growth. INSECURE PARENTING In Take Back Your Kids, family psychologist William Doherty says that we face “an epidemic of insecure parenting.” Insecure parents are skittish about exercising parental authority, refuse ever to get angry with their kids, and consequently allow their kids to walk all over them. Occasional (non-abusive) parental anger is necessary. —William Doherty, Take Back Your Kids How to Teach and Get Respect Article by Dr. William Doherty in excellence & ethics (spring 2013) www.cortland.edu/character 3 styles of parenting (research of Diana Baumrind): Authoritarian Permissive Authoritative. Authoritative parenting combines: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Love Confident authority & rule enforcement Reasoning to motivate compliance Listening to child’s feelings if expressed respectfully (parents make final decision) Encouragement of age-appropriate selfreliance. Authoritative parenting combines: Demandingness (setting and supporting high expectations) Democratic parenting (giving kids opportunities for voice) At all developmental levels, the most confident and responsible children have authoritative parents. THE OBEDIENCE SPEECH There’s something very important we want you to understand: Mothers and fathers have the job of being in charge of the family. Kids have the job of obeying their parents—doing what we ask you to do. It’s the same in school: A teacher is in charge of the classroom. Kids have to do what the teacher says. So when we ask you to do something—come to dinner, pick up your toys, get ready for bed—you have to obey. You can’t say, “No.” That’s not allowed. If you forget, we’ll give you one reminder: “Remember our talk about obedience.” If you continue to disobey, then there will have to be a consequence. And we’d like you to obey cheerfully, without complaining. Obeying cheerfully makes the family a happier place for everybody. (Obedience is a virtue, a way of showing love.) Have a zero tolerance policy for disrespectful speech and behavior. Require children always to speak respectfully to you—in what they say and in their tone of voice. Set a consequence in advance: “What is a fair consequence for speaking to me disrespectfully?” Insist on respect, courtesy, and kindness in all family interactions. Don’t tolerate disrespect or disobedience to you, or rudeness (“Shut up!”), name-calling (“Stupid!”), or other unkindness toward siblings. Principle 5 Teach by example. Moral Moments Our Children Remember The stands we take define our values. Do our kids know where we stand on . . . 1. 2. 3. 4. Respect for life? The plight of the poor? Respect for the environment? War and peace? Other Positive Role Models The Giraffe Hero Project, www.giraffe.org www.teachwithmovies.com (hundreds of films categorized by values) Books That Build Character by William Kilpatrick (Touchstone, 1994) Principle 6 Manage the Moral Environment The importance of supervision: The most academically motivated and morally responsible teens—the least likely to engage in risky behaviors: 1. Have warm and involved relationships with their parents 2. Have parents who set clear expectations and monitor their children’s activities in ageappropriate ways. -Building a Better Teenager, Child Trends 2002 research report, www.childtrends.org Your Kid’s Friends We become like the company we keep. What is a true friend? A false friend? Share stories from your life. Media Facts The average child sees about 100 commercials a day. The average young person consumes nearly 7 hours of electronic media a day. Three-quarters of 6th-graders have their own TV in their bedrooms. —Kids and Media at the New Millennium, www.kff.org What The Research Shows 1. 2. 3. Kids who watch the most violent TV are the most violent. Kids are also desensitized by exposure to violence. Teens who frequently watch sexual content are more likely to become sexually active. Set Limits on Use of Media 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. The use of all media in the family is a privilege (not a right) that requires a parent’s permission. “We don’t allow media that goes against our family values.” Have “quiet nights” (TV is off). Make watching TV a special family event, not a private or regular pastime. Set reasonable limits on time spent on Internet, video games, telephone, etc. The Moral Low-Down on Movies www.screenit.com www.kidsinmind.com Explain your rules and expectations: “I don’t want you going to R-rated movies with a lot of sex and violence because I care about you. “I don’t want you putting junk into your mind, just as I don’t want you to put junk into your body.” RECOMMENDATION: Consider having NO TV while you have children in the home. Supervise Social Media “For your own sake, I’ll check your online activity (posts, texts, emails) periodically. “Please let your friends know I’ll be doing this.” —Michele Borba, The Big Book of Parenting Solutions Principle 7 Use direct teaching and questioning to develop conscience and moral reasoning. Judith Martin (columnist): “Raising a civilized child takes 20 years of constant teaching and another 10 of review.” Practice what you preach, but preach what you practice. Parents of Rescuers Samuel and Pearl Oliner, The Altruistic Personality “My mother always said to do some good for someone at least once a day.” Forming conscience in 2-yearolds: Clarity + Concern You hurt Amy! Pulling hair hurts. NEVER pull hair. INDUCTION Pointing out the consequences of child’s behavior for someone else Teach Empathy “There are two kinds of hurts: outside hurts that you can see, and inside hurts that you can´t see—like a hurt feeling.” A daughter remembers . . . When I was 15, I adopted the ungracious habit of referring to certain classmates as “losers.” My father took me aside and pointed out that it wasn’t right to dismiss anyone like that, as if they weren’t persons—as if they didn’t have a soul. That habit ended that day. Dad’s Two Sets Of Threes On honesty: Never lie. Never cheat. Never steal. On adversity: Don’t whine. Don’t complain. Don’t make excuses. -John Wooden Ask-Don’t-Tell Use questions to get kids thinking: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. What’s the rule about this? What will happen if you keep arguing? How can you solve this problem? How can you help make this a good day instead of a bad one? Why am I upset with you? Why is it wrong to cheat? 1. 2. 3. 4. It violates trust. It’s unfair to those who aren’t cheating. It’s a form of lying. It will lower your self-respect. Why not drink? “You’re laying the foundation for your future during these years. You don’t need drinking when you’re learning to drive. You don’t need drinking when you’re learning to relate to the opposite sex. “Save drinking for later, when you’re mature enough to handle it, and it will be legal for you to drink.” Why Wait for Marriage? “Sex is so special, it deserves a special home. It is most meaningful when it’s part of something bigger. When you are married, your sexual intimacy expresses your total commitment to each other. “The ultimate intimacy belongs within the ultimate commitment.” “10 Emotional Dangers of Premature Sex” www.cortland.edu/character (Character-Based Sex Education Tab) The attempted suicide rate for 12- to16-year-old girls who have had sexual intercourse is six times higher than for peers who are virgins. D. Orr, M. Beiter, & G. Ingersoll, “Premature sexual activity as an indicator of psychosocial risk,” Pediatrics, 87, 141-147. What Are the Rewards of Waiting? 1. 2. 3. 4. Waiting will increase your self-respect. It will teach you to respect others. It means a clear conscience (no guilt,no regrets). By waiting, you’re developing the kind of character (virtues such as respect, selfcontrol, modesty, and courage) that will attract a person of character. The Real Love Character Test 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Is this person respectful and kind to me? Does this person always expect to get his or her own way? Can I trust this person? Does this person ever pressure me to go against my values? Would I be proud to be married to this person? Would I want this person to be the father/mother of my children? What’s Wrong with Porn? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. It violates the dignity of persons by treating people as sex objects. It takes something beautiful and makes it dirty. It puts images in the mind that you can’t get rid of. It’s addictive—it brings short-term pleasure but then starts to run your life. For males, it is also usually accompanied by masturbation. It will lower your self-respect. It causes problems in marriage. T. G. Morrow Achieving Chastity in a Pornographic World Chastity: bringing sexual desire into harmony with right reason. Other books about doing the right thing: Sean Covey, The 6 Most Important Decisions You’ll Ever Make Hal Urban, 20 Gifts of Life (www.halurban.com) Tom and Judy Lickona, Sex, Love & You: Making the Right Decision Principle 8 Discipline Wisely Have consistent rules Help with clean-up after meals. Answer the phone politely. (“This is Max Lickona. Who would you like to speak to?”) Don’t call me from another room (“MOM!”); come to where I am. Don’t leave your clothes lying around the house; hang them up. Say, “May I please have . . .” not, “I want ...” When kids do something wrong, require them to . . . 1. 2. 3. Say, “I’m sorry.” Say why they are sorry. Ask, “What can I do to make up for it?” (restitution) “What do you think is a fair consequence for what you did?” Principle 9 Provide opportunities for kids to practice the virtues. Character development is not a spectator sport. Virtues are habits we develop by performing virtuous actions. —Aristotle Children develop character by what they see, what they hear, and what they are repeatedly led to do. —James Stenson HARVARD STUDY John and Beatrice Whiting studied 6 cultures: the U.S. and 5 “developing nations.” U.S. kids had the fewest responsibilities in family life. U.S. kids were the most selfcentered. The New Yorker, July 2, 2012: “Spoiled Rotten” Time/CNN Poll: Two-thirds of American parents think they have spoiled their children. TEACHING RESPONSIBILITY Chores are a way to contribute to the family. Don’t pay kids for doing them. www.10kids.com (chores chart) SERVICE BEYOND THE FAMILY Principle 10: Solve problems and conflicts fairly and with love. Hold Family Meetings 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Set/review rules: Respectful talk, no put-downs. Open: “What’s something you appreciate that someone in the family did for you this week?” “How can we all make this a good week? What’s a problem/challenge we need to solve?” Go around, giving everyone a chance to speak: (1) views of the problem, then (2) suggestions for solving it fairly. (Leader writes down and then reads back what each person said.) Combine ideas into an agreed-up plan; all sign and post agreement, including follow-up mtg. Family Meeting to Assess Progress Set a weekly time. How are we doing? Give everyone a turn to speak. First celebrate success: “I think we did better on . . . .” Discuss areas for improvement: “I think we can still do better on . . . .” The Fairness Meeting 1. 2. 3. Achieve mutual understanding. Find a solution everyone thinks is fair. Have a follow-up meeting to discuss how it’s working. Fairness Agreement 1. If Mom has promised to do something with us, she will tell the person she is busy and will call back later. 2. Will make a list of things to do while mom is on the phone. 3. Mom will try to make her calls shorter. 4. If mom has to be on the phone for a longer time she will tell us, and we will behave. Mom, Phillip (7) and Ben (5) Principle 11 Foster spiritual development I see so many people just going through the motions: get into a good school, so you can get into a good college, so you can get a good job, so you can get a better job, so you can get rich and die. —Recent High School Graduate A 17-year-old high school senior in CA got double 800s on her SATs. Asked by a reporter, “What is the meaning of life?”, she replied, “I have no idea.” LIFE’S LARGEST QUESTIONS What is the meaning of life? What is the purpose of my life? What leads to lasting happiness? Is this life all there is? Is there a God? 3 Sources of Authentic Happiness Affirmed by Cross-Cultural Research: 1. 2. 3. Maturity of character Loving relationships Doing some good in the world. —Tony Devine, et al., Cultivating Heart and Character One Girl’s Mission Statement: 1. Be honest. 2. Do what’s right. 3. Be kind to everyone. 4. Do your best in everything. 5. Have fun. 6. Always remember who you are and what you stand for. 100 GOALS 1. Write 100 goals you’d like to achieve in your life. 2. Divide them into categories (career, family, adventure, service, major accomplishments, etc.) 3. Select your top 10 goals. 4. Write a paragraph on your #1 goal. —Hal Urban, Lessons from the Classroom (available from www.halurban@halurban.com) The Path to Purpose —William Damon Religion’s impact on character Research shows that teens who regularly practice a religious faith are: More involved in service activities Less likely to steal, be violent, or use drugs and alcohol Less likely to have sex. -www.childtrends.org Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (national study) —Dr. Christian Smith, University of Notre Dame sociologist 36% of teens say they feel “very close to God.” 35% say they feel “somewhat close to God.” 25% say they feel “some degree of distance from God.” 3% say they don’t believe in any God. —Soul Searching (2005), based on a longitudinal study of American youth Weightlifter story You can be an ethical person without being religious, and having religious faith does not guarantee that a person will behave ethically. But for many persons, religion provides an ultimate reason for leading a moral life. “If you have a faith tradition, renew it and try to pass it on to your children. It will be your most precious gift to them.” —Barbara Jones, former director of the Council for Religion in Independent Schools The 3 Goals of Life from a Religious Perspective 1. salvation—our own and others’ 2. service—using our God-given talents to build a just and caring world 3. sanctity—growing in holiness. One mom asked, “What if you’re not sure what you believe?” Why do many young people fall away from their faith when they leave home? If You Want Your Kids to Pray, Teach Them… 1. “Give God at least 2 quiet minutes at the beginning of the day.” 2. “Talk to God as if he’s right there.” 3. “Be silent, and listen with your heart.” 4. “Understand how God answers prayers.” Mother Teresa: “I always begin my prayer in silence. God speaks to us in the silence of our hearts.” A high school boy: “I never used to pray. Now I believe that, basically, you need God. You can always go to him—there’s someone who’s always there. “When you’re a teenager, you face a lot of problems—all these things are coming at you. When you pray, your problem might not get fixed when you want, or in the way you want, but you get help.” As in all other areas, modeling matters: “Dad always closes his letters with, ‘Work hard and pray a lot.’ This never sounds phony because it’s what he does. “He has worked hard all his life, and he prays throughout the day.” —a young mother For more resources on developing character in the family or school: Center for the 4th and 5th Rs www.cortland.edu/character