AeroSpace and Defence
Industries Association of Europe
Issues in the
AIA/ASD Suite of ILS Standards
Inputs to the KoM of the ILS Handbook
R. Somoza
Airbus Military
1
Overview of ILS standards
Operational
data
Equipment
identification
design data
Logistic
Support
Analysis
activities
LSA
data
Provisioning
IP Data
Subsets
S3000L
Design
data
Provisioning
data
Order
administration
S2000M
Technical
Publications
S4000M
Logs mat
and data
IETM,
other media
In service use
Design of systems and
support equipment
Operational and maintenance data feedback – S5000F
S1000D
Slide 2
27th June 2011
Main issues on ILS Suite of Specifications
(1/2)
•
Global process unclear. “Ideal” ILS process is in practice impossible, but no
room for parallel development (e.g., S3000L, S2000M and S1000D work) due to
lack of synchronization mechanisms.
•
Feedback relationship and orchestration (S1000D, S2000M, S5000F) unclear.
•
Different business rules / criteria / formats (e.g., for applicability)
•
No common data model. No common glossary or data dictionary.
•
No real data integration – specifications are separate “silos”. No global /
transversal view. Different product structures.
•
Parallel evolution of different specifications, without coordination / configuration
(“mixability” of specification versions?)
•
Computational problems not considered (e.g, required parsing of applicability)
•
Implementation costs of the specifications, cost of evolution
•
Interfaces between specifications are bilateral – “explosion” of interfaces, circular
relationships and coherence problem (e.g., S1003X+S1002X=S2003X?).
Slide 3
27th June 2011
Main issues on ILS Suite of Specifications
(2/2)
•
No common data exchange mechanisms.
•
Exchange not part of the suite of specifications.
•
Exchange of data of a SAME specification (e.g., between supplier & prime
contractor) unclear, except for S2000M.
•
Formal relationship with OASIS – Are the A&D DEXes formally endorsed by
AIA/ASD? How is the evolution of these DEXes controlled? By whom?
•
DEX implementation guidelines (e.g., for SOA) not established globally.
•
No specification/cross-specification Implementor forums
•
Civil/military convergence? (currently only used massively for S1000D)
•
Use of ILS in civilian programs
•
Need for specific annexes (e.g., domain-specific)?
•
Standard integrated data delivery format (e.g., for maintenance systems)?
•
Relationship with ATA beyond S1000D? (e.g., S4000M, Spec2000)
Slide 4
27th June 2011
Gaps in the ILS Suite
-
Configuration of ILS products
-
Operations
-
Use of 3D (Technical publications, training, maintenance…)
-
Orchestration of services
Slide 5
27th June 2011
Design the
Product
Support
Equipment
OPERATOR
Support
Operation
•Design AGE
•Design
Training Devices
•Develop Operational
Documentation
•Design Crew Courses
•Design Maintenance
Courses
•Design Maintenance
Support
Support
Maintenance
Customer
Support
•Develop
Maintenance
Documentation
•Prepare
Material Support
Mission &
Operation of
Services
•Develop
Documentation
•Develop
Slide Processes
6
•AGE
•ATE
•GSE
•CBT
•FFS
•MST
Group 1
Logistic
Support
Analysis
•Operations
Manual Checklist
•MMEL
•Courses
•Manuals
•Courses
•Manuals
•FSR
•SB (Upgrades)
•MRO
•AMM
•CMM
•WDM
•IPC
•IPL
•Repair Services
•Develop Material
Documentation
•Develop Services
Level Agreements
Group 2
Support
Equipments
& Simulators
Support to
Product
Design
•Analyze Results
•Maintenability
•Reliability
•Testability
•Maint. Program
•LCC
Group 3
Support, Maintenance
& Operations
S E R V I C E S
Product
Design
•Influence Design
PRODUCT &
SERVICES
•Deliver
the Contracted
Service
Group 4
Customer
Solutions
INDUSTRY
SECONDARY
PROCESSES
Integrated Logistic Support
PRIMARY
PROCESSES
Program
Office
BASIC
PROCESSES
27th June 2011
Mission & Operation of Services
Customer Services
Product Support
After Sales
Slide 7
•“Classic Disciplines”
-Technical Assistance
-Material Support
-Training
-Tech. Documentation
Product Related
•“Partnering”
-Total services
delivery
-Operation of assets
-PBL
•“Outsourcing”
-Customer Solutions
-Services Centers
-Repair Centers
-Logistic Services
-PBH
•“…abilities”
-RMT
-LSA
-LORA
-LCC
Customer
Related
SERVICES SCOPE OF ACTIVITIES
27th June 2011
ASD/AIA ILS Spec’s Organisation
ASD - CPSC
AIA
Customer & Product
Support Committee
Product Support
Committee
CPSC
Specifications
Group
ILS Spec
Council
S2000M
Steering Committee
S3000L
Steering Committee
S4000M
Steering Committee
S5000F
Steering Committee
Data Model and Exchange Working Group
NB S1000D has separate organisation
Slide 8
27th June 2011
ILS Suite Production plan
S1000D
S3000L
S4000M
Draft 0.1
Iss 5.0
S5000F
S2000M PLCS
Iss 6.0
Iss 1.1
Iss 1.0
Draft 0.1
S1002X
Iss 4.1
Iss 1.0
Iss1.0
Draft 0.1
SX000I
Iss1.0
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
Slide 9
S3002X
S2000M
Iss 4.0
Iss 6.0
S1003X Iss 1.0
Iss 4.0
Iss 5.0
S1003X Iss 1.1
ASD – STE100
S1003X Iss 0.1
Iss 4.0
2010
2011
2012
2013
27th June 2011