Why are questions important? Teachers ask as many as 300 to 400 questions a day. Questions guide students’ thinking and determines how students will process materials presented to them. Questions are the single, most influential teaching activity. Why ask questions? Focus Student attention Help students interact with content Check for understanding Evaluate the effectiveness of the lesson Increase the level of thinking Different questions elicit different thought processes. Four types of questions Convergent Divergent Low-level High-level Convergent Have one correct answer Convergent questions are needed to help students sharpen their focus and attention to detail and accuracy. What is 3+4? What are the days of the week? What are the planets in our solar system? What year did the US land on the moon? Divergent Open-ended, more than one correct answer Divergent questions help students to delve into imagination and creativity while at the same time, build their confidence. What are some examples of amphibians? What is your favorite book? What animals are mammals? Low-level Requires only mental recall to be answered Building blocks to higher-level thinking The student only has to remember something that he/she already knows. What is the order of the planets in our solar system? What are three simple machines? High-level The student must do some kind of processing of information in order to answer the question. The processes include comparing, describing, inferring, hypothesizing, analyzing, and making judgments or evaluations. Examples Compare your community to the communities of the colonists. What do you think will happen to this paper clip when I drop it into the cup of water? Will it sink or float? What do you think life was like for the colonists? Bloom’s Most Taxonomy widely used classification system for analyzing educational questions in the cognitive domain. Teachers tend to ask primarily low-level questions and the students lose the opportunity to think critically. Bloom’s Taxonomy Knowledge Comprehension Application Analysis Synthesis Evaluation Knowledge level Knowledge questions encourage students to recall information in the form that they learned it. Knowledge level verbs Defines Matches Describes Names Identifies Recalls Labels Recites Lists Recognizes Comprehension level Encourage students to communicate an idea or phenomenon in a new or different form Comprehension level verbs: Discriminates generalizes Edits gives examples Estimates infers Explains predicts Extends summarizes Application level Encourage students to apply ideas or skills to new situations or to use the knowledge they possess to solve a problem. Application level verbs: Construct translate Demonstrates relates Modifies show Computes Put to use Illustrate Prove Analysis level Requires students to break down something, such as an idea, into its constituent parts or to uncover the unique characteristics of a “thing”. Analysis level verbs: Break Down Differentiate Classify Discriminate Categorize Simplify Contrast Criticize Debate Outline Synthesis level Encourage students to put the information back together in imaginative and/or original ways. Synthesis level verbs: Blend Modify Construct Integrate Create Combine Design Arrange Develop Reorganize Evaluation level Require students to judge something by determining a standard and comparing it to the standard. Evaluation level verbs: Appraise Evaluate Argue Grade Assess Judge Critique Validate Defend Justify Useful Wait questioning techniques time Phrasing questions Planning ahead Teacher response to questions (redirection, prompting, probing, praise) Wait After time asking a question, the teacher waits 3-5 seconds before accepting answers Give students time to think before answering questions Results in dramatic changes in student responses. Results of Wait time: The length of student responses is increased 300 to 400%. Students increase their use of evidence, or of logic based on evidence, to support their statements. The failure to respond to questions decreases The necessity for disciplinary measures decreases. The variety of students participating in discussion increases. Students gain confidence in their ability to construct responses to questions. Phrasing questions How questions are phrased impact the quality of response and the quality of thinking required. Don’t begin a question with a name. This engages only 1 student, all the others are “off the hook”. Avoid beginning each question the same way. “Who can tell me….” Distributing questions: Research indicates that many teachers: Call on high-achieving students more than low achieving students Call on boys more than girls Call on white students more than minority students Call on students in the front row more than the back row Call on students on one side of the room Use unequal patterns of questioning, students have unequal opportunities to process material and transfer to long-term memory. Planning Be questions sure to write questions ahead of time to ensure higher level thinking questions are utilized Responding Once to student answers students have responded to a question, the teacher decides whether to praise, acknowledge, redirect, probe, prompt, correct, or ask a new question. Praise Use selectively Can limit further thinking when viewed as a terminal response. Praise must be meaningful Stay away from global praise- good job Be specific- I like the way you used your experience to justify your answer. Tell why it was a good job. Redirection Asking the same divergent (open-ended) question to several students in a sequence of uninterrupted by the teacher’s comments. Allows teachers to get contributions from several students. Allows more people to participate in lessons. Allows class members to continue to process the question. Prompting Leading the student to the correct answer by a hint or a series of hints. Encourage the students to take risks and make educated guesses. Teaches the students how to use various thought processes to find answers to questions and problems. Prompting is a difficult skill because teachers cannot plan the hint questions ahead of time, one has to think on one’s feet. Probing Probing is a means of getting students to elaborate on their initial responses to questions, particularly when the initial response to a question has been minimal. Asking the student for further clarification, explanation interpretation, etc. Provides opportunity for more in-depth thinking. Correct Correct misinformation and prompt for correct information. Do not repeat the wrong answer, only repeat back the correct answer. Students can stop listening after the incorrect answer is given. Make sure that the students are paying attention when the correct answer is given. Effective practices related to questioning Plan the questions that are to be asked during a lesson Clarify the purpose of the questions Use a balanced combination of low/high/convergent/divergent questions