VERIFICATION STATEMENT FOR AS/NZS 4325.1 (1995) TESTING OF MECHANICAL CONNECTORS FOR POWER CABLES, HEAT CYCLE TEST Statement No: N141ETRU Valid for products not subject to DNV GL classification requirements. Particulars of Product Product Name: AS/NZS 4325.1 (1995) Testing of Mechanical Connectors for Power Cables, Heat Cycle Test Type designation: Tin-plated aluminium B10 Shear Bolt Lug - 12H400 Application/context: Shearbolt Lug Cable Connector ID/Serial/Tag no: B10-ABXX/12H400 The product is intended for: STOCK Requirements are based on: AS/NZS 4325.1 (1995) + Amdt 1 (1997) Compression and mechanical connectors for power cables with copper or aluminium conductors, Part 1: Test methods and requirements Deviations and limitations, if any, are stated on page 2 onwards. Particulars of Vendor and Purchaser Vendor: TriCab (Australia) Pty Ltd Vendor reference: Purchaser: Purchaser reference: Issued at Melbourne on 2017-08-15 for DNV GL This document has been digitally signed and will therefore not have handwritten signatures Brown, Adrian Surveyor Except for any liability caused by DNV GL's gross negligence or wilful misconduct, DNV GL's maximum cumulative liability arising out of or related to the use of or reliance on this document shall be limited to USD 300 000. Form code: 71.07a Revision: 2017-01 www.dnvgl.com Page 1 of 2 © DNV GL 2014. DNV GL and the Horizon Graphic are trademarks of DNV GL AS. Statement No: N141ETRU Verification extent and result Verification extent: At the request of TriCab (Australia) Pty Ltd, the undersigned surveyor was requested to attend the manufacturer's MV test facility at Port Melbourne for the purpose of witnessing testing of electrical compression/mechanical connectors. Cable Type: 300mm2 flexible aluminium cable, LSFLEX R-70 (X-HF-110) insulation and E-Rubber S-20 jacket, 0.6/1kV 110C Branded Designation: KL-PAXA/1C300 BK Flexible Rubber SDI power cable Connector Type: TriCab aluminium alloy lug (shear bolt), 32.1mm internal dia. x lug palm cross-sectional area 840mm2 Branded Designation: B10-ABXX/12H400 Connector Tests: As per AS/NZS 4325.1:1995 + Amdt 1 - 1997, Compression and mechanical connectors for power cables with copper or aluminium conductors, Part 1: Test methods and requirements, ie 6.1 (Installation), 6.2.1 (Electrical resistance measurements), 6.3.1 (First heat cycle) and 6.3.2 (Second heat cycle). Shear bolt fittings were witnessed assembled on conductors (insulation removed) using an AEG BSS 18C12Z impact drill. Verification result/comments: With reference to the above, the cable connectors were arranged in a test circuit for terminal lugs in accordance to Figure 1 b), bolted palm-to-palm with soldered equalizers. Physical length requirements, ie d, lr & la/b were as per standard. The electrical resistance, temperature measurements, first and second heat cycles were conducted and witnessed, as per attached TriCab Test Report number ACC17013 dated 27th June 2017, in their entirety by the undersigned surveyor. Surveyor Supplementary information: - Please refer to OEM Test Report for further details. Form code: 71.07a Revision: 2017-01 www.dnvgl.com Page 2 of 2 HEAT CYCLE TEST REPORT TO AS/NZS4325.1:1995 TriCab SHEAR BOLT LUGS B10/12H400 Test Report Number: ACC17013 Supplier: TriCab Test Item: B10-12H400 and KL-PAXA/1C300BK Test specification: Testing according to AS/NZS 4325.1 “Compression and mechanical connectors for power cables with copper and aluminium conductors Part 1: Test methods and requirements Test Result: The shear bolt lugs and cable assembly conform to the Test Requirement of AS/NZS 4325.1 in determining the parameter for heat cycling test. Testing Laboratory: TriCab (Australia) Pty Ltd 33 Prohasky Street, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207 Date of Testiing: 27 June 2017 Tested by: Greg Beziuk (TriCab Engineer) George Young (TriCab Engineer) Fernando Agustin (TriCab Technical Manager) Verified and Witnessed by: Adrian Brown (DNV-GL) Results appearing herein relate only to the sample(s) tested. This test report is not permitted to be reproduced in any form without permission of the test center. www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 1 of 9 1. INTRODUCTION The purpose of this test is to evaluate the performance of TriCab B10-12H400 shear bolt aluminium lugs when exposed to heat cycle test. Integrity of mechanical joints between lugs and KL-PAXA/1C300BK flexible aluminium cable was assessed and evaluated by determining the stability of connection resistance of lug/cable joint and the relationship of temperature between conductor and lugs. 2. APPLICABLE STANDARD The test method is based on AS/NZS 4325.1:1995 Standard. 3. TEST DETAIL 3.1. Test Equipment TriCab Medium Voltage Test Facility is equipped with fully integrated, automatic, induction Cable Cycle Heating Test System. The system allows to carry-out long term heating test of copper and aluminium power cables or associated cable connectors with a total load current of up to 6000A. The B10-ABXX/12H400 lugs were tested by means of the following equipment: Cable Cycle Heating Test System with load current of up to 6000A. Pico Technology 8 Channels thermocouple data loggers with associated software Windows PC 8x K type thermocouples assembly (type 12 608-056 c/w F11K/F40 ATT) MILLI-OHMMETER 5894, Tinsley (DC current, 4 terminals sensing ohm-meter) Fluke Power Analyser 3.2. Test circuit The test loop was assembled as per clause 6.1.1 and Figure 1 (b) of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995. The test circuit was designed using the Terminal lugs layout and was graphically presented on Figure A. All conductors used in the circuit were TriCab KLPAXA/1C300BK. The circuit consisted of: 6 units of B10-ABXX/12H400 that formed 3 pairs of connection (lug1-lug2; lug3-lug4; lug5-lug6). Every pair of lugs were connected palm to palm as per Figure 3 (5) of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995. 8 potential equalizers as per Annex 2 of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995. section of reference conductor with length lr =1.6 m, which was calculated using the formulae on page 12 of AS/NZS 4325.1: www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 2 of 9 ≥ ≥ 80√ where: A = 300mm2 is cross section area of conductor. sections of conductors between equalizers and connectors la = 0.26m (approx.), determined by means of expression in Annex B.1 of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995: ≅ 15√ where: A = 300mm2 is cross section area of conductor. additional two bimetallic lugs (BL400) not included in test circuit diagram of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995, marked as lug7 and lug8. two sections of 1C5002 aluminum conductor terminated on both ends with bimetal lugs BL630 (section one: lug9, lug10; section two: lug11, lug12) not included in tests circuit. One end of each section is connected in series to the end of test circuit using palm to palm connection (lug7 to lug9, lug12 to lug8). The remaining ends of the additional sections (lug10, lug11) connected palm direct to palm during the heating test, were used to open the loop when the resistances were measured. Figure A: Test Diagram www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 3 of 9 4. TEST CIRCUIT ASSEMBLY 4.1. Tested lugs Lugs were installed on conductor of KL-PAXA/1C300BK cable using AEG BSS 18C12Z impact drill. 4.2. Potential equalizers Equalizers were constructed using 400mm2 aluminium cable compression links. Hole with diameter of 10mm was drilled at the centre of cable link for soldering. Cables were inserted into both link openings with 3mm gap between conductors ends. The gap was located in the middle of the link. The link was crimped on both ends using IZUMI EPS60S crimping head and 60T-39.0AFAL die. Solder (ALU-SOL 80/18/2 Solder Wire) was inserted through drilled hole to solder both ends of crimped conductors and the link and was heated up using propane torch. The solder filled the gap between cable ends thus forming a solid connection inside the link and crimping points. 4.3. Lengths of the connectors assembly associated with the measurement points after jointing Measured length between equalizer and every individual lug is presented in Table 1. The distance between lug-conductor joint and lug palm is presented in Table 2. Table 3 consists of length of joint between lugs and conductor. Table 1. Length of conductor section between lug and equalizer Equal. - lug conductor la1 la2 la3 la4 la5 section Length [mm] 300 304 308 300 296 la6 287 Table 2. Length of distance between end of lug barrel and conductor-lug joint Joint - palm section lb1 lb2 lb3 lb4 lb5 lb6 Length [mm] 28 28 28 28 28 www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. 28 Page 4 of 9 Table 3. Length of joint between lug and conductor Joint section lj1 lj2 lj3 lj4 Length [mm] 87 87 87 87 LJ5 lJ6 87 87 The length of reference cable that was measured after assembly as a distance between the middles of equalizers is equal to lr.= 1520 mm. 4.4. Additional pair of bimetal lugs Both ends of test circuit was terminated using bimetal lugs BL400 crimped on the conductor by means of IZUMI EPS60S crimping head and 60T-39.0AFAL die. 4.5. Additional pair of 500mm2 cable sections terminated with bimetal lugs Two additional sections of KL-PAXA/1C500BK aluminium cable with 1980mm and 1855mm long, were terminated on both ends with BL630 lugs using IZUMI EPS60S crimping head and 60T-43.0AFAL die. This sections are connected in series with test circuit and joint between them was used to open the test loop when resistances in the circuit were measured. 4.6. Thermocouple for measuring the reference conductor temperature The reference conductor temperatures were measured by thermocouple inserted into the hole at the point in the middle length of the reference cable. 4.7. Thermocouple for measuring the lug temperature The temperatures of lugs were measured by thermocouple secured to the surface of lug by means of nylon cables ties. 5. TEST PROCEDURE 5.1. Measurement of Resistance After installation of all components of testing loop with pair lug10-lug11 disconnected, resistance between potential points was measured as required by AS/NZS 4325.1:1995 (Annex B.1, Figure 3 case 2). The measured resistance together with values of associated temperatures (Annex B.2, Figure 3 case 2) are presented in Table 4. www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 5 of 9 Table 4. The results of measurements resistances before first heat cycle Measurement Rpp1a-pp1b Rpp2a-pp2b Rpp3a-pp3b Rpp4a-pp4b Rpp5a-pp5b Rpp6a-pp6b point Rref Temperature [0C] R [Ω] 15.65 15.72 15.68 15.50 15.47 15.52 15.67 33.1 34.5 33.5 33.7 33.7 32.7 132.1 After measurement of resistances, lug10 and 11 were connected to close the test circuit. 5.2. First heat cycle The first heat cycle is to determine the value of equilibrium current (IN) when conductor temperature reached 140oC. The value will be used in subsequent cycles and the result is presented in Table 5. Table 5. Results determined during the first heat cycle Conductor temperature IN [A] R [0C] 139.59 980 Note: Equilibrium was achieved after 15 minutes with conductor temperature changed from139.360C to 139.590C and median lug (no 3) temperature changed from 94.710C to 95.780C 5.3. Second heat cycle The scope of second heat cycle is to determine the heating and cooling times, t1 and t2 respectively, based on parameters measured during the first heat cycle. The results of the test are presented in Table 6. and the graph of temperature vs time of cycle 1 and 2 is presented on Figure B. Table 6. Heating and cooling time and total period of heat cycle Heating time Cooling time Total heat cycle time t1 [min] t2 [min] t1 + t2 [min] 110 53 163 Note: The heating time includes applying for initial 15 minutes of heating cycle the accelerating current of 1.4kA www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 6 of 9 FIGURE B. Logged of temperature vs time taken from heat cycle 1 and 2 6. RESULTS In order to asses the influence of heating-cooling cycles on lug-conductor joints parameters, based on AS/NZS 4325.1:1995 (Annex E.2), the resistances presented in Tables 4 should be recalculated in reference to temperature of 200 C using equations: - for measuring points spanning the connector ( ) = 1 + (Θ − 20) where: = 0.004 [1/K] is resistance temperature coefficient for copper and is lug temperature; X is a number of connector. - for reference cable ( ) = 1+ Θ − 20 where ref is reference cable temperature. The results of the calculations are shown in Table 7. www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 7 of 9 Table 7. Values of resistances referred to 200 C Measurement Rpp1aRpp2aRpp3aRpp4app1b(20C) pp2b(20C) pp3b(20C) pp4b(20C) point Resistances referred to 33.69 35.10 34.09 34.32 200C Rj [Ω] Rpp5a- Rpp6a- pp5b(20C) pp6b(20C) 34.32 33.30 Rref(20C) 134.43 Subsequently, joint resistance for each connector was determined using data presented in Tables 1,2,7 and the length of reference conductor, by means of expression (Annex E.2 of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995): = + )− ( ( ) where: X is number of tested lug. The joints resistances are presented in Table 8. Table 8. Resistances of lug-conductor joints Lug no Rj1 Rj2 Rj3 4.68 R [Ω] 5.74 4.37 Rj4 Rj5 Rj6 5.31 5.67 5.44 Then, for every individual lug was determined connector resistance factor ‘k’. The factor was calculated using results from Tables 3 and 7, the length of reference conductor and equation (Annex E.2 of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995): = ( ) where: X is number of the connector In Table 9 are included values of resistance factor ‘k’ for each connector. Table 9. Connectors resistance factor k1 k2 k3 k4 k5 k6 0.61 0.74 0.71 0.75 0.57 0.69 www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 8 of 9 7. INITIAL SCATTER The initial scatter provides information as to how the design of a contact system will behave on a certain conductor immediately after installation before any ageing effect starts. It helps the identification of a specific connector type ‘family’. The initial scatter can be determined using equation (Annex E.3 of AS/NZS 4325.1:1995): = 1 √ where: - N is a number of connectors; - is mean value of connectors resistance factor calculated by means of expression: = 1 where X is a connector number; - s0 is corrected sample standard deviation calculated with equation: = 1 −1 ( − ) - ts = 4.032 is the Student coefficient for 99% two-sided confidence level and five degrees of freedom. For N = 6 and results presented in Table 9, the above parameters have following values: = 0.6759, = 0.072; = 0.1753. 8. CONCLUSION The set-up of specimens and the method of measuring the resistances and temperature and the data obtained from verification are consistent to test method stipulated in AS/NZS4325:1. The tested shear bolt lugs satisfied the initial requirements described in the AS/NZS4325:1. It is clearly indicated by value of calculated initial resistance scatter = 0.1753 which lies within the range accepted by the standard ( ≤ 0.3). www.tricab.com The world’s most flexible cable manufacturer Electronics document when printed may become outdated. Please contact TriCab Sales office for current version. Page 9 of 9