ELECTRICAL CONTROL EQUIPMENT FOR THE CONTINUOUS COPPER CASTING ROD PLANT by Steven Glickman A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of the DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE In the Graduate College THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA 19 7 5 STATEMENT BY AUTHOR This thesis has been submitted in partial fulfillment of re­ quirements for an advanced degree at The University of Arizona and is deposited in the University Library to be made available to borrowers under rules of the Library. Brief quotations from this thesis are allowable without special permission, provided that accurate acknowledgment of source is made. Requests for permission for extended quotation from or reproduction of this manuscript in whole or in part may be granted by the head of the major department or the Dean of the Graduate College when in his judg­ ment the proposed use of the material is in the interests of scholar­ ship. In all other instances, however, permission must be obtained from the author. SIGNED: APPROVAL BY THESIS DIRECTOR This thesis has been approved on the date shown below: Professor of Electrical Engineering V ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ^ Sincere thanks must be extended to Mr. Warren Hawes of Magma Copper Company and to Dr. Robert N. Carlile for coordinating the intern­ ship summer work program leading to the preparation of this thesis. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS . . . . . . . . ABSTRACT 1. . ... . . . . . . . . . .............. INTRODUCTION viii ......... 1 A DC Motor Armature Excitation Speed Regulator System . The Rod Plant Product and Process ... . . . . . . . . General Description of Operation . .......... 2. THE THYRISTOR.................. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . .......... Thyristor Control Techniques (Single-Phase, Half-Wave Thyristor) . . . .......... Single-Phase Bridge Semiconverter .............. Three-Phase Bridge Semiconverter . ... . ......... 3. VARIABLE VOLTAGE CONTROL CONCEPTS OF ARMATURE EXCITATION ........................ OF DC MACHINES Introduction ...".. Selsyn Remote-Control Processing . .................... Parallel Control Concepts . Control of DC Machines with Semiconverter as Power S u p p l y .............. 4. THE ELECTRICAL HARDWARE FOR MAGMA'S CASTING ROD PLANT SPEED REGULATING CONTROL SYSTEM. . . . . . . . . . . . Cage A s s e m b l y ................ TPM Semiconverter . .......................... Transductor . . . . . . . . . . .......... . ........ Gate Pulse Generator Card . . . .............. Current Controller and Gate Pulse Suppression .... Voltage Controller . Speed Controller and Ramp-Function Generator ........ 5. CONCLUSIONS vi .......... iv 1 4 4 10 10 12 13 21 23 23 25 27 31 35 35 36 40 42 46 50 52 55 V TABLE OF CONTENTS--Continued Page APPENDIX A - A DERIVATION FOR THE AVERAGE LOAD VOLTAGE VS. FIRING ANGLE FOR A THREE-PHASE THYRISTOR SUPPLY . . . . . . . . . . .................... 56 REFERENCES 59 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1.1 Block Diagram of Armature Speed Regulator . . . . . . . . . 1.2 DC Single Line Diagram 2.1 Thyristor Circuit Symbol 2.2 Static Characteristics of Thyristor . 2.3 Single-Phase Control Circuit 2.4 . ............................... ..........• 2 5 11 ................... 11 ..................... 12 Voltage and Current Waveforms in a Single Phase ThyristorControlled Circuit with Resistive Load .......... 14 Operation of Single-Phase Thyristor Control Circuit into and Inductive Load .................. 15 2.6 Single-Phase Semiconductor with Free-Wheeling Diode . . . . 16 2.7 Waveforms of Supply Load Voltage, and Trigger Pulses for a Single-Phase Bridge Semiconverter ........... . . . . 17 2.8 Waveforms for Semiconverter Bridge with Complex Load 19 2.9 Load Current Waveform with Free-Wheeling Diode 2.5 .... 2.10 Three-Phase Bridge Semiconverter ... . . .. .. 20 . . . . . . . . . .. .. 21 2.11 Waveforms for a Three-Phase Semiconverter . . . .......... 22 3.1 Closed-Loop DC Motor Speed-Control System . . . .......... 24 3.2 Single-Phase Synchrotransmitter Motor . . . . . . . . . . . 26 3.3 Synchro Geherator-Transformer S y s t e m ........ . ........ 26 3.4 Parallel Drive Control . . . . . 28 3.5 Switching C i r c u i t ........ 29 3.6 Operational Amplifier Circuit for Control of Speed with Current Reference Limit . . . . . . . 30 ........ vi . vn LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS--Continued Figure Page 3.7 Machine Control with Semiconverter Power Supply . ........ 32 3.8 DC Machine Control with Additional Voltage Feedback . . . . 34 4.1 Zener Regulators and Filters 37 4.2 Isolation Transformer, Voltage Feedback Loop, and Gate Pulse Generation Card for a Thyristor Power Module. . . . . . .......... .............. 38 39 4.3 Thyristor Power Module Semiconverter 4.4 Calibration Curve of Typical DC Current Transformer . . . . 41 4.5 DC Current Sensing Circuit 42 4.6 Gate Pulse Generator Circuit ............................. 44 4.7 Voltage Waveforms of Thyristor, Capacitor, Transistor Input, and Trigger Pulses .................... 45 4.8 Transfer Curve of V^n vs. a . . . 47 4.9 Current Controller and Gate Pulse Suppression . 4.10 Voltage C o n t r o l l e r .............. 4.11 Speed Controller and Ramp Function Generator .......... 53 A.l Average Load Voltage vs. Firing Angle .................... 58 . ................ .............. ........ 48 51 ABSTRACT This investigation will present the fundamental concepts and circuit diagrams necessary for understanding a DC variable speed motor control center that is basic to Magma Copper Company's Continuous Cast­ ing Rod Plant. The Casting Rod Plant line process consists of thirteen variable speed DC motors with each motor controlled by an electrical control unit. Each variable speed DC motor control unit includes vari­ ations of design; however a basic design theme runs throughout each individual controller allowing for discussion of the basic concepts associated with a single voltage regulating system. This work concerns itself with the thyristor, thyristor control techniques, electric/ electronic control hardware, and control concepts for a closed-loop DC motor control system and its associated regulator loops. viii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION A DC Motor Armature Excitation Speed Regulator System This work presents the basic control concepts; electrical/ electronic hardware, and schematic diagrams required for a typical DC motor speed regulator system used in the mill and coiling drive sections of the Continuous Copper Casting Rod Plant built for Magma Copper Company, San Manuel, Arizona. The armature excitation speed regulator discussed in this paper and common to each individual motor control system used in the casting rod plant is represented in block diagram form in Figure 1.1. This diagram indicates the basic flow of control needed for the adjustment of machine speed. A brief introductory discussion of the components shown in the blocks follows, with a detailed analysis of electrical/ electronic hardware given in subsequent chapters. The thyristor power supply consists of a rectifier assembly which is capable of delivering adjustable levels of direct voltage to the armature of the motor. The operation of this type of assembly will be discussed extensively in Chapter 2. The gate pulse generator, a solid state "firing" circuit, represents the control circuit which ad­ justs the thyristor supply voltage level to that desired for proper 1 2 L E fe U D LEGEND FDR FUNCTION pLQCKS T IT L E U-VOLTAGE FOR POWER C IR C U IT Sf^SOR OLrrPi/T VARIABLE S EM IC O N VE R TE R C IR C U IT inpltt v a r ia b l e INPUT). u QUyVT C U R R E N T X fO R M F R GAIN CURVE L-CH5c TIM E RESPONSE TO 'Nx.c. POWER MOTOR STEP IN P U T SOURCE frrsoootrnxuLZ/r voiTAor eofsr/ooiic/? GW/*jsCGS/*rx'*rBt> rjrAwsDovTOV ci*%wvr covnpoiir# VV Gyrrrfn/isrs'i/*wrs&/ov Figure 1.1. Block Diagram of Armature Speed Regulator. of Westinghouse Electric Corporation.) (Courtesy machine speed. The "firing" control technique is introduced in Chapter 2, and a gate pulse generator circuit schematic is explained in Chapter 4. The speed controller function is to compare a desired speed reference setting to that of a speed feedback signal, producing an error signal indicating that the power conversion equipment (the thyristor power supply) needs an output voltage correction. The speed controller is introduced in Chapter 3, with the circuit diagram explained in Chapter 4. The generator tachometer is direct coupled to the motor and measures the angular velocity of the shaft, producing a speed feedback signal proportional to the motor speed. not be considered any further. The tachometer generator will The voltage controller is a time delay amplifier which has large signal gain. The voltage controller signal provides the input to the gate pulse generator, which initiates the control of the DC voltage output of the thyristor power supply as brief­ ly mentioned earlier. The voltage controller is introduced in Chapter 3 and its circuit diagram will be explained in Chapter 4. The current controller function is to protect the equipment from excessive overloads This is achieved by comparing a current feedback signal to the current reference setting limit. If there is a current overload beyond the limit reference setting, the current controller will slow down the drive system. If the current becomes excessive, gate pulse suppression will be triggered, causing the system to shut-down altogether. The current controller is introduced in Chapter 3, with the circuit diagram explain­ ed in Chapter 4. The current feedback signal is developed by the transductor, which converts a DC current flow into a corresponding voltage signal level. The circuit diagram for the transductor is shown in Chapter 4. The Rod Plant Product and Process The operation of the Casting Plant involves taking refined cathode copper from the refinery, melting the cathodes in a gas-fired furnace and feeding the molten copper to an eight-foot casting wheel. The casting wheel forms a square bar which is fed through a rolling mill operation. . The twelve stands of the rolling mill form a 5/16-inch diameter copper rod. After leaving the rolling mill the rod is treated with a dilute sulfuric acid, rinsed, coated, and finally wound into coils of various sizes, 8,000 to 16,000 pounds. The coils are checked-, weighed on highly accurate scales and then loaded into railroad cars or trucks. In the past Magma's copper was shipped in the form of copper anodes to out-of-state refineries for processing. duction process takes place at San Manuel. Now the entire pro­ This production has met the growing demand for refined copper from western manufacturers of electri­ cal equipment and wire products. General Description of Operation The following description which introduces the line process relates to the single-line diagrams included in Figures 1.2a,b,c. The operation begins with refined copper cathodes of 99.98% purity being loaded into a gas-fired melting furnace. Once heated, the molten copper rxY Phill /HSMAmCX l to cxmcrop P/yVCM POLL S*P s/rro | rtPwee r ~~Z crstr) rv * MILL SP°' - mi Cm u ED Lr- <FHD Auro "1(cAy/f^cc/imk) & -- & — i— <•-> Figure 1.2. DC Single Line Diagram. (a) Casting Wheel Section. (Courtesty of Westinghouse Electric Corporation.) h 8 8 0 8 / il fr s r e r Pin c h p o ll 7 5 HP > ./ ato. z s s /m M /t t. /5 0 H P /S O H P m 3 s -f/tc /S O H P mo rCZ3 A/O.4 AfUt /S O H P D AM.ZSHfPP A” loo><£I 6 N O .Z LO O P S fL S Y s J O/MOCOLPTOP AUTO X TX AO. 2 LOOP rUNNt* PCF SPY CD r-lDsnu> y e e ~CT■z.ouro N O S M IL L , AMD ) NO 4 U\ ED Aoroi: M IL L A P £ MIL P/.tpy NO / d u p l ic a t e TO P / A / ( H r CL L r.-'S * M O J M IL L ^~PNO ^~PCD CZPCV ElPtVD Figure 1.2.--Continued. (b) Roughing Mill Section. ro P/N/P/i/A/f A T IL L 2 0HP M .Z P ffL L , . NO- Z SHEAR S tL S Y A f x-Z/t/ZT/V/^ Sf/M zxacot/fi SrAMD CAL. OOTS LOAD S3 r A/O.Z Figure 1.2.--Continued. (c) Finishing Mill and Coiler Sections. flows from the melting furnace at a temperature of 2100°F to a 15-ton holding furnace. The holding furnace has an adjustable tilt angle which allows for varying pour rates of the molten copper being fed to the 96-inch diameter casting wheel. imately 30-tons per hour. A typical pouring rate would be approx­ The molten copper being fed to the casting wheel and band passes through water cooling sprays, forming a continuous­ ly cast copper bar five inches square with a tempterature of 1400°F. Upon leaving the casting wheel the bar will be moving at 60' feet per minute and guided by an extractor conveyor and extractor pinch rolls. The bar is next fed through the No. 1 crop and cobble shear, which cuts off the initial undertemperature front end until a satisfactory temper­ ature is reached, and then is fed through a downlooper table and No. 1 dowhlooper. After passing through the downlooper the bar enters a preparation unit which chamfers the edges and brushes off bar surface scale. The bar is then fed into the mill entry pinch rolls, which close over the bar and deliver it to the first of four roughing mill stand sections. The no-twist roughing mill consists of four alternate hori­ zontal and vertical mill stands with each stand driven by 150 HP DC motor. The four roughing stands alternately pinch or squeeze the bar into alternate oval and round shapes,, reducing its diameter until form­ ing a round stock approximately one inch in diameter traveling with a speed of 300 feet per minute. The round stock is fed to the No. 2 crop and cobble shear, which.once again crops the front end of the bar until a satisfactory temperature is achieved for entry into the finishing mill. From the No. 2 shear the stock passes over the second downlooper table through the No. 2 loop selsyn into the no-twist finishing mill. The finishing mill is similar to the roughing mill but consists of eight alternate horizontal and vertical mill stands driven by two direct-coupled 800 HP DC motors. The round stock, having passed through the finishing mill, has been reduced in diameter, forming a 5/16-inch solid copper rod with a speed of 3000-3500 feet per minute. The rod then passes through a dilute sulfuric pickling acid solution station where the surface is cleaned and treated and also passes through a finalstationwhere it is rinsed and waxed to prevent further oxidation. The rod is next directed through a delivery pipe by a pair of coiler pinch rolls to the rod coiler. The rod coiler head consists essentially of a section of curved rotating or spinning pipe through which the rod passes. The coiler forms a product such that the rings of rod are coiled and laid on a pallet positioned underneath the coiler. Upon completion of a coil the loaded pallet is pushed out from under the coiler and replaced by an empty pallet. During the coiL change-out period, the rod rings being continuously formed by thespinnerare tem­ porarily collected by the coil collector fins. CHAPTER 2 THE THYRISTOR Introduction The thyristor is a three-terminal four-layer p-n-p-n semi­ conductor device which operates as a controlled rectifier. circuit symbol is shown in Figure 2.1. Its electric Essentially the device is a switch, which remains off or appears to have an infinite input impedance until the device has been " t r i g g e r e d . W h e n both the anode and gate terminals have the proper positive voltages with respect to the cathode terminal the thyristor switches on, and current flows and will continue to flow without further gate signals. impedance when conducting. Ideally the thyristor has no To switch the device off, the gate signal must be removed and the anode current must be reduced to zero. Like a rectifier diode, the thyristor allows current flow in only one direction. The static characteristics of a typical thyristor for both the conducting and non-conducting states are shown in Figure 2.2. With a reverse voltage applied to the thyristor, the voltage current character­ istic is similar to that of a diode with a small reverse current being produced by a reverse voltage until an avalanche region is reached. If the thyristor is not triggered in the forward direction a small forward current is produced until the forward avalanche region is reached and the characteristic changes to the conducting-state characteristic. The 11 ANODE CATHODE GATE Figure 2.1. 6 Thyristor Circuit Symbol ■FORWARD CONDUCTING STATE REVERSE BLOCKING THYRISTOR REVERSE BREAKDOWN Figure 2.2. FORWARD B L O C K IN G Static Characteristics of Thyristor VAC 12 conducting-state characteristic obtained from the thyristor when trig­ gered is similar to that of a diode with a forward voltage applied. Thyristor Control Techniques (Single-Phase, Half-Wave Thyristor) A basic thyristor circuit for single-phase half-wave control working into a resistive load is shown in Figure 2.3. r - CONTROL CIRCUIT Figure 2.3. Single-Phase Control Circuit The thyristor circuit is capable of supplying current only during the half-cycle when terminal A is positive with respect to terminal B. The thyristor is triggered by a control circuit which usually is a pulse generator. For smooth control the turn-on pulse must occur at the same point in each cycle. With a resistive load, the current through the thyristor falls to zero when the anode voltage reaches zero. The thyristor turns off for the negative half-cycle and continues blocking for the first part of the positive half-cycle up to 13 the point at which it is triggered into conduction again. The point at which conduction begins is called the firing delay angle a. See Figure 2.4a,b,c for source voltage, load voltage, and load current waveforms respectively. The form of control used here is called phase control, since the load current and voltage are controlled by shifting the phase of the gate pulse relative to the supply voltage [Rose, 1970]. The operation of the circuit in Figure 2.3 into an inductive load changes slightly from that of the resistive load operation. Now, when the thyristor is fired at time t^, the load current will increase through the inductive load. At time t^ the supply voltage reverses, but the thyristor is kept conducting while the energy stored during time t^ to tg is fed back to the supply. The load voltage becomes negative during the next half-cycle of the supply voltage, and at time t^ the load current falls to zero'and the thyristor turns off. See Figure 2.5 a,b for voltage and current wave forms. Single-Phase Bridge Semiconverter The half-wave circuit operation discussed in the previous section was presented to introduce the basic concepts of a thyristor working into a resistive and inductive load. However, the half-wave circuit shown in Figure 2.3 is not normally used due to the large output ripple voltage and the capability of supplying only a discontinuous load current. The circuit of a single-phase half-controlled bridge called a bridge semiconverter is shown in Figure 2.6 with a free-wheeling diode. 14 (a) (b) -cx (C ) oc Figure 2.4. Voltage and Current Waveforms in a Single Phase Thyristor-Controlled Circuit with Resistive Load 15 L 4 (a) SUPPLY f T H Y R IS T O R current (b) Figure 2.5. Operation of Single-Phase Thyristor Control Circuit into an Inductive Load 16 ADI D2 4 a FREE_X_ WHEELING ' \ DIODE J Vc THY 1 Figure 2.6. D3 THY 2 Single-Phase Semiconductor with Free-Wheeling Diode which will be explained shortly. This circuit has full wave rectifi­ cation and is able to supply a continuous load current for a trigger angle of a = 0. The wave forms of the load voltage, trigger pulses, and current with respect to the supply voltage for a trigger angle of a = 90° working into a resistive load are shown in Figure 2.7. When the voltage at A is positive with respect to the voltage at B and thyristor Thy2 is triggered, the load current flows through Thy2 and diode Dl. Thyristor Thy2 is turned off when the voltage V^B is negative. During the next half-cycle thyristor Thyl and diode D2 conduct the load current. 17 TRIGGER PULSES 'A6 CURRENT THY2I Figure 2.7. D2 1 T H Y ll Waveforms of Supply Load Voltage, and Trigger Pulses for a Single-Phase Bridge Semiconverter 18 The operation of the bridge circuit for a complex load, repre­ senting the inductance of a motor, is considered next. The wave forms and current in relation to the supply voltage are shown in Figure 2.8. At the end of each half-cycle of the supply voltage, current flow is maintained in the circuit by the inductance of the load. The thyristor which has been firing, say Thy2, continues to conduct but transfers current from diode D1 to diode D2 so that the load inductive stored energy continues to drive current through the bridge without including the reverse supply voltage.During this part of load current decays exponentially and voltage. the cycle, is unaffected by the supply When thyristor Thyl is triggered, thyristor Thy2 is reversed bias by the supply voltage and turns off. Current now flows from the source through thyristor Thyl and diode D2 into the load. Thyristor Thy2 is triggered in the next half-cycle and the sequence is repeated. The load current can be controlled by changing the trigger angle a of the thyristor. One limitation, however, isthat it may not be possible to turn off the load current even when not triggering the thyristors. Let us consider how that may happen. If a trigger pulse is removed immediately after the firing of a thyristor, it will continue to conduct for the remaining half-cycle of the supply. If the other thyristor receives no trigger pulse it will not turn on. However, if the load is highly inductive, with a time constant greater than one half-cycle, the first thyristor will still be conducting at the end of this period and will remain turned on for the following half-cycle. circuit will continue to operate thi^s way indefinitely. The 19 TRI66ER P U LSE S 5 U PPLY I OUTPUT VOLTAGES BRIDGE OUTPUT V THYRISTORS FULLY \ COND0CT(NG> - SUPPLY V0L7A 6E FORWARD VOLTA6E DROP OF t t \ y r \STOR AMD D\ODE LOAD CURRENT THY 1| THY^ THY2J THYll THYi IW 2 1 FHY<?| m i m i 0 7 i n? i IM i m i rs7 i Figure 2.8. CON D UCT | K) C, DEVICES Waveforms for Semiconverter Bridge with Complex Load 20 If a free-wheeling diode is added to the half-controlled bridge, as shown in Figure 2.6, the load current is transferred to the free-wheeling diode at the end of each half-cycle of the supply [Mazda, 1973]. The load current waveform for a complex load shown in Figure 2.9 is similar to those of the half-controlled bridge without a free wheeling diode, but the exponential decay part of the load current is now carried by the free-wheeling diode D3. The addition of the free­ wheeling diode ensures that each thyristor turns off at the end of each half-cycle, so there is no risk of conduction carrying over into the next half-cycle. The load current then will always be under the control of the trigger circuit. LOAD CURRENT THY 1 D3 Figure 2.9. D2 TMY2 CO ND UC TIN G DEVICES Load Current Waveform with Free-Wheeling Diode 21 Three-Phase Bridge Semiconverter A solid-state three-phase bridge semiconverter circuit is shown in Figure 2.10. The top half of the circuit is controlled so that con­ duction will occur from the most positive phase in which a thyristor has been connected. The current in the bottom of the bridge will com­ mutate from one diode to the next depending on which is connected to the most negative phase. Figure 2.11 shows the supply and load volt­ ages. 0 -v L °~ Y _ °~ V _ 7 \ TH Y 1 A THY 2 A THY 3 A A D2 A d 2> THREEPHASE SUPPLY di Figure 2.10. Three-Phase Bridge Semiconverter 22 controlled THYRISTOR s Z\ Figure 2.11. PHASE VOLTAGE Waveforms for a Three-Phase Semiconverter CHAPTER 3 • VARIABLE VOLTAGE CONTROL CONCEPTS OF ARMATURE EXCITATION OF DC MACHINES Introduction ; A basic closed-loop feedback DC motor control system is.shown in Figure 3.1. In this section the notation and basic operating principles needed for understanding the control concepts used in this paper are introduced. The elements required in construction of such -a control system are a transducer to sense or measure quantities such as speed, current, voltage, etc.; a feedback network; ,an input signal or reference signal; an error detector for comparison of the reference signal to the feed­ back signal; and a controller and drive system which amplify the error signal and convert it to the required level [Morris, 1974]. For this brief discussion of DC motor control, let us consider the principal parameter of interest, the speed of the machine. The speed of the motor may be monitored with a direct coupled tachogenerator or a voltage divider network using the back e.m.f. of the machine. Once the speed feedback signal is formed it is compared with the inputreference signal speed voltage setting in the error detector, and the difference between the two signals (the error signal) may be used to adjust the thyristor controller so that the motor speed equals that 23 PO W E R I INPUT I MEASUREMENT DEVICE REFERENCE INPUT SIG NAL O ERROR SIGNAL T H Y R IS T O R CONTROLLER AND DRIVE FEEDBACK Figure 3.1. MOTOR SIGNAL X Closed-Loop DC Motor Speed-Control System . 25 ' demanded by the input reference signal. It is the principal function of the error signal to control the flow of power through the thyristor controller to the DC motor and hence adjust the motor speed to that desired. Selsyn Remote-Control Processing Another important control device used in the continuous casting rod plant is the servomechanism. Specifically of interest are selsyns (or synchros), electromagnetic devices used primarily for the transfer of angular-position information. One is operated at the sending point as a generator and is called the transmitter, the other is operated at the receiving point as a motor and is called the receiver, shown in Figure 3.2. Selsyns are, in effect, transformers whose primary to secondary coupling may be changed by varying the relative position of the two windings. The single-phase winding current in the primary induces voltages in the three windings of the secondary. These three voltages are not equal in magnitude, but vary with the position of the rotor. When the two rotors correspond in position relative to the stators, the voltages induced in the transmitter secondary are equal to those induced in the receiver secondary. The voltages are therefore balanced and no current flows in the secondary windings. If the trans­ mitter rotor position is changed, the induced voltages are no longer equal and current flows in the secondary windings. This current with the magnetic fields produces a torque which turns the receiver rotor to a new balanced voltage position. Thus, as the transmitter is turned the receiver follows at the same speed and direction. 26 RECEIVER T R A N S M IT T E R SECO ND AR Y ROTOR PRIMARY ROTOR STATOR Figure 3.2. STATOR Single-Phase Synchrotransmitter Motor A slight modification to the above transmitter-receiver circuit is a circuit by which a control transformer produces an error signal proportional to the rotor angle deviation [Fitzgerald, Kingsley, and Kusko, 1971]. Figure 3.3 shows the modification. STATOR AC SOURCE STATOR ERR0R-V01TAGE OUTPUT ROTOR Figure 3.3. Synchro Generator-Transformer System 27 Down-looper regulators No. 1 and 2 consist of the synchro generator-transformer system as just described. These down-loopers were referred to earlier in Chapter 1 and may be seen in Figure 1.2a,b. These remote position sensors have the function of developing a cor­ rection speed signal maintaining the bar free of tension. consider the No. 1 looper arm. Let us The No. 1 looper is located ahead of the mill entry pinch roll and develops a correction speed reference signal for the entry pinch roll and four roughing mill regulators. The loop sensor consists of a dancer roller that rides on the top of the bar stock. This dancer roller is mounted at one end of a lever arm with the selsyn transmitter directly connected to the shaft at the pivot point. The selsyn device, coupled to the looper arm, provides a signal proportional to the looper arm displacement. If the loop depth changes from that desired an error signal develops and is fed into loop summer No. 1, increasing the speed of the roughing mill section and maintaining proper bar tension. The No. 2 looper also works as just described, but develops a speed correction signal for the finishing mill regulators. Parallel Control Concepts The electrical drive equipment for the motor control systems used in the production of continuously cast rod requires accurate control of a primary variable, speed, plus control of additional criti­ cal variables such as current or voltage. The parallel control concept used in the drive system discussed in this paper will be explained.with a speed control and current limit used as an example. 28 A separate controller for each controlled variable is used in the parallel control scheme. The controllers are connected in parallel, with their outputs feeding through a switching circuit to a common terminal, see Figure 3.4. SPEED SPEED CONTR, SPE.ED REFERENCE SWITCHING C I R C U \T —\ CURRENT L IM IT REFERENCE DRIVE CURRENT CONTR. Figure 3.4. Parallel Drive Control The switching circuit allows only one controller operation at a time. For example, the speed controller is in operation as long as the current limit is not reached. When the current limit is reached, the current controller takes over control of the drive system and the speed controller i. switched off. works as a limit c oiler and the speed controller is in operation as long as a current one controller is This means the current controller l i t in setting is not reached. Note that since only operation at a time, the characteristics of the loops may be independently adjusted for the steady state and dynamic 29 responses desired. Adjustment of the controllers influences only the switch-over point. The switching circuit consists of the diode network shown in Figure 3.5. Consider the diodes as ideal circuit elements with no for­ ward voltage drop, hence the voltage V will always equal the larger of the two voltages and V^. The diode network is connected to the operational amplifier controllers as shown in Figure 3.6. The gain potentiometers IP and 2P are connected to the output of the switching circuit, not the amplifiers, thus allowing for proper switching of the parallel control, since the capacitors of the controller will now follow the output to insure a smooth transition between the two controllers. With zero speed reference, diode ID is conducting and the output V of the controller stays at zero. The output of amplifier 2 tends toward a negative value (due to the positive current reference input), reverse biasing diode 2D which opens the feedback loop around the current controller. The high open loop gain of amplifier 2 forces its output to the negative limit. ? -2 4 V V Figure 3.5. Switching Circuit -24V SPEED FEEDBACK H O ----+24V ID SPEED CONTROLLER SPEED REFERENCE /77T7 /77T7 tiov CURRENT LIMIT REFERENCE Z77 CURRENT FEEDBACK g Figure 3.6. (+> 2D CURRENT CONTROLLER Z 77 77 Operational Amplifier Circuit for Control of Speed with Current Reference Limit w o 31 Should the speed reference input be increased to a value which would cause excessive armature current, the sum of the input currents to the current controller would become negative., forcing its output to switch to a positive limit. During the transient diode 2D becomes conductive, closing the feedback of amplifier 2 to the voltage existing at terminal V. Since diode ID starts blocking, opening the feedback loop of amplifier 1, the current controller takes over and the speed controller is switched off. As the speed approaches that called for by the reference input, armature current falls below the current limit reference setting, and the speed controller comes out of its negative limit and regains control, switching off the current controller. Control of DC Machines with Semiconverter as Power Supply Next a semiconverter armature power supply for a DC motor with a speed feedback reference signal will be discussed. problem existing underlight load conditions reference to the block A major control will be explained with diagram and waveforms in Figure 3.7. A thyristor semiconverter can supply power to the load but cannot absorb energy from it. When a decrease in speed is called for the drive is slowed down only by the external loading, causing a speed undershoot upon reaching the lower reference value. Let us consider a step change decrease of the speed reference signal. Under light load conditions the armature current may go to zero. action, dependent only The drive will then slow down without controller on external loading. In this condition the speed controller output will remain there until the speed of the drive coasts 32 REFERENCE' GATIH& MOD. SPEED CONTROLLER MOTOR TACK REFERENCE SPEED SPEED CONTROLLER OUTPUT T IM E Figure 3.7. Machine Control with Semiconverter Power Supply .' ■ • .33 below the new reference value prior to integrating up again. The time required for the output of the controller to reach the new reference level causes an undershoot of the actual speed of the drive. This problem may be reduced substantially by additional feedback loops as shown in Figure 3.8. The feedback voltage (V) of the voltage loop is proportional to the output of the semiconverter during the normal operational and pro­ portional to the motor CEMF at zero armature current when thyristors and diodes are non-conducting. Under normal operating conditions, the high voltage gain of the voltage controller forces the feedback voltage V to closely match the output of the speed controller . When the drive is slowed a small difference develops between V and Vg which quickly forces the output of the voltage controller to reverse polarity, forward biasing diode ID. This closes a new control loop in which the voltage V can be considered the reference and the voltage Vs the controlled variable. The output of the speed controller will now closely follow the decrease in voltage V (due to the high gain of the voltage controller), which assures the speed controller of having the correct output when the new speed reference is reached by the drive. The only time delay existing with this system is that of the time re­ sponse of the voltage controller (which causes negligible speed under­ shoot) . 34 REFERENCE SPEED co ntro ller REFERENCE SPEED OUTPUT SPEED CONTROLLER OUTPUT VOLTAGE CONTROLLER TIME Figure 3.8. DC Machine Control with Additional Voltage Feedback CHAPTER 4 THE ELECTRICAL HARDWARE FOR MAGMA'S CASTING ROD PLANT SPEED REGULATING CONTROL SYSTEM Cage Assembly The cage assembly mounted within a motor control unit is for housing all the basic regulator cards (voltage, current, and speed cards). The assembly may hold combinations of four plug-in type printed circuit boards used to provide the basic regulating functions. The four cards are. listed below: 1. Gate pulse generator card. 2. Current controller and gate pulse suppression card. 3. Voltage controller card. 4. Speed controller card. The operation of the cards will be described in the following sections. The cage assembly provides, in addition to the regulating cards, card interconnections, zener regulators and filters, pulse transformers, resistor board, and gate control transformer. The interconnections consist of terminal blocks and wiring harness for A-C power connections and control inputs and outputs to the regulating cards. Connecting the gate pulse generation board and gate control transformer are diodes comprising two rectifier circuits. rectifiers, The output voltage from these diode 75 volts, is supplied to the zener regulators and filters 36 in the cage assembly to generate the +_ 24 volts for the controller modules, as shown in Figure 4.1. Gate pulses are coupled from the gate pulse generator to the thyristors in the semiconverter by three isolation pulse transformers as shown in Figure 4.2. Resistors mounted on a pegboard limit peak power supplied to the thyristor gates and also complete a differential voltage feedback loop. A gate control transformer mounted in the cage assembly provides proper phasing for the generation of gate pulses. TPM Semiconverter In Chapter 2 we discussed the operation of a three-phase semiconductor bridge circuit. In this section we will consider the electrical operation of the Thyristor Power Module (TPM) in more depth. In Figure 4.3 is shown a simplified schematic of the TPM. The power transformer is shown in a wye-delta connection and provides isola­ tion, adjusts line voltage to proper levels, and introduces inductance to limit rates of current during commutation. Phase-controlled gate pulses to fire the thyristors are provided by the gate pulse generator described later. The DC output of the semiconverter is shown connected to a motor armature load. A transfer equation relating the average out­ put voltage to the firing angle a is shown in Appendix A [Kusko, 1969]. The voltage applied to the armature is controlled by the thyrsistors Thyl, Thy2, Thy3. The diodes Dl, D2, D3 provide a current return path to most negative line terminal. The difference betwen voltage applied by the bridge V to the motor and the armature voltage V is absorbed m a G A T E PULSE RC. BCARD CA G E ASS'Y -24P SM GATE CONTROL TR ANSFO RM ER SECONDARY PSC Figure 4.1. Zener Regulators and Filters ui 'vl THYRISTOR r power module ______ Q_ -0_ t n ! T VOLTA6E I ICOMTROLLERj RESISTOR BOARD L_ I t i ill ______TPJ i ;ind" GATE ) || PULS E I II ^ G E N E R A T O R , 8 ISO LATIO N transfo rm er^ Figure 4.2. Isolation Transformer, Voltage Feedback Loop, and Gate Pulse Generation Card for a Thyristor Power Module 39 r n THY 1 1------I GATE 1 PULSE I GEN, I_______ THY 2 THY 3 D2 D3 n K D1 J xz CZEHp ^ -D C OUTPUT „ FUSE RC LINE FUSELS r CURRENT ^ L IM IT IN G FUSES W Y E -D E L T A TRANSFORMER AC Figure 4.3. LINE Thyristor Power Module Scmiconverter 40 by the armature inductance and resistance. The free-wheeling diode acts at the end of a conduction period when the armature voltage attempts to reverse as the inductance discharges its energy. Included with a typical thyristor power module is an RC line filter connected across each incoming line to limit incoming transient voltages, and also output filters to provide a network to limit ringing associated with normal commutation. Current limiting fuses are provided in each line to protect the semiconductors during fault conditions, and a DC output line fuse protects the motor against excessive currents or against failure by shorting of the free-wheeling diode 7D. Also pro­ vided is a thermal protection switch (not shown) embedded in a heat sink to detect high temperatures in case of fan loss and turn off the TPM. - Transductor ; - . . ' The basic transductor used in the drive system described in this paper provides isolation of positive and negative voltages propor­ tional to the DC current monitored and provides thermal overload protection for the motor. A typical transfer curve relating output voltage to primary ampere turns is shown in Figure 4.4, The transductor is designed to provide feedback signals for current limit and gate pulse suppression. A sensing circuit is shown in Figure 4.5. VOLTS A 10- 0 5G0 1120 AMPERE - T U R N S Figure 4.4. Calibration Curve of Typical DC Current Transformer 42 i | n S* 475/J476GO/ cx S ^ £ 09C 930HI3 /X I — I A /r f^Hr1 — __ S* *75# 475Go/ \2X5^ Figure 4.5. DC Current Sensing Circuit. Electric Corporation.) (Courtesy of Westinghouse Gate Pulse Generator Card The gate pulse generator card is one of four cards comprising the basic armature regulator for a DC motor control drive system. Each gate pulse generator card may be divided into four sections, a power supply section and three gate pulse circuit generator sections. The gate control transformer, mounted in the rear of the cage assembly, provides six-phase line to neutral voltages for the printed circuit board. These voltages are rectified by two star rectifiers producing an unregulated +_ 75 volts DC. From the basic + 75 V ^ , a zener regulator provides +_ 24 volts for the controller module along with filter networks explained earlier. The + 75 volts feeding the current control card is reduced by a voltage divider to + 40 volts and 43 is returned to the gate pulse generator card and provides the transistor collector voltage. When gate pulse suppression occurs, the collector voltage is reduced to almost zero prohibiting gate pulse production. This will be described in a later section. The circuit for gate pulse generation will be described next in general terms. A phase control range of 180° is required to achieve control of the three-phase semiconverter bridge circuit from cut off to full output. The control interval must be from the point in time that the thyristor becomes the most forward biased device in the bridge (a - 0) to the point in time that it becomes reverse biased (a = 180°). The circuit in Figure 4.6 will be used to explain gate pulse generation. As can be seen in the figure there are three identical circuits producing gate pulses. Let us consider only the production of pulses from terminal 31, the other two circuits are similar and operate in the same manner. Consider one of the power thyristors with a volt­ age from anode to cathode as shown in Figure 4.7. A positive half-cycle of the line-to-neutral voltage between terminals 45 and 41 is used from the gate control transformer to charge capacitor 22C at a time prior to the control interval of the power thyristor. thyristor 21TH must be in blocking state. During the charging cycle At the desired firing time a . gate pulse is produced by turning on thyristor 21TH and allowing capacitor 22C to discharge through the primary of pulse transformer 2X. The basic control element in this circuit is transistor 21TR. Whenever the base emitter voltage is less than .6 volts or negative the transistor cuts off and the resultant increase in collector voltage provides a 44 * ^/S i*y *O lC O / - f O v . X / J i t y * a / C o f - SO*/t /SO ---------------- P% 3in s * 6 .0 /AT S.SSA’ — c^a—t-criaY_?<rs> TP2k 1( J-OS/JO 'Ws/w' y_^> ?3<r. ------ % ^ r /so ------ 9SD— ?*/ n.pz/r <e4ur — os* aa— •-as—i A eO.fSAT r-y*3- fW«9 6/T~ B /A S ■^5 Ia/X« M O T E .- M L © - Figure 4.6. T E S .T C tS tS T O S i. P IN kR L C H W 11C EPT o- W HERE O T H E R W IS E E X T E R N A .L (.T E R U I Gate Pulse Generator Circuit. Electric Corporation.) JJO TEO P T .) (Courtesy of Westinghouse 45 A -K 22C Figure 4.7. Voltage Waveforms of Thyristor, Capacitor, Transistor Input, and Trigger Pulses 46 positive gate to 21TH, releasing a gate pulse as mentioned earlier. When the base-emitter voltage is greater than .6 volts the transistor is turned on and the collector emitter voltage is .2 volts. The control of the base-emitter voltage or the point in time at which cut off occurs is determined by the bias voltage, the cosine voltage obtained from the filter consisting of 29R, 24C, and 20R, and the input voltage. As both the cosine voltage and bias are a fixed amplitude, phase control is essentially a function of the input controller. A typical transfer curve relating the voltage to the firing angle is shown in Figure 4.8. Current Controller and Gate Pulse Suppression The current controller and gate pulse suppression card is one of four printed circuit cards comprising the basic armature regulator. Figure 4.9 refers to the current controller and gate pulse suppression card for the following discussion. The TOA 4X is an operational ampli­ fier consisting of three-stage amplification. The first stage is a difference amplifier, the second stage an inverting amplifier, and the third stage is an emitter follower circuit for the required current gain and low output impedance. Input signals to point B1 are inverted by the OUT terminal point, with the amplifier having an open-loop gain of approximately 2000. Feedback components associated with the TOA 4X are designed to commit its use as a current controller. The diode network (2D,3D,4D,5D) connecting the OUT terminal to B1 prevents the amplifier from saturating and limits its output voltage from +1 to -10.5 volts. Diode 7D is the switching diode for the current controller, while resistor 18R provides FIRING ANGLE o< 180 — 6 0 - 140- 20 - OO - 80 - bO — 40 - 20 - 6 O -10 VOLTS-IN Figure 4.8. Transfer Curve of V. vs. a in 48 srr/f o s r scr* nafr/far rrsyaarrcx* mc.A0360/ /3aCcAO2G0Z s r s r o jprsoe/jrop t3aG A 0 2 G 03 ctna^ra/rrYsye/}/'cva ss (~t*) 3* /rrprs fas+f-'A/Arro hlOy/JL \iOr/£ , 6/* & jciyLtp>.--je>£- u s r o rv:j v t <v /&r/vr "as.ss tmr 70 3C G*Te />utse 37C B6X ALL z /'ovf r O K i> m o h c k /> /? £ OA/AJ fa) <3 S *V £X<1 L P T * /* - /£ * ? £ . ; *ij /s ccxja/ac.r e & ro 6 aocofjK/tcr e 7ZJ7" pm O* £at£/?mal (t£Pah or.) Figure 4.9. 33 r-») 3/ f?) fiS O T l t O T - A /£ /7 t V /S £ A J O T tO re/?** 2 Current Controller and Gate Pulse Suppression. (Courtesy of Westinghouse Electric Corporation.) 49 the reverse bias for all switching diodes in parallel regulators. When used in voltage or speed regulators the current controller provides a current limit function adjustable by pot 6P. For current regulation, a signal proportional to the armature current is brought in to termal 55 and compared with the reference signal. The indicated jumpers allow the printed circuit board to be checked for various performance pa­ rameters or to disconnect the current controller to allow parallel regulator loops to be checked independently. The gate pulse suppression portion of the circuit consists of all the components below terminal 39 (found on the righthand side of the figure). Appearing at terminal 41 is a +75 volts from the bridge rectifier of the gate pulse generator card. Normally thyristor 1TH is in the blocking state, and by voltage divider action the +40 volts is returned from terminal 43 to the gate pulse generator card, providing the transistor collector voltage. Feeding terminal 37 is a signal (from the transductor described earlier) proportional to the armature current, and by adjusting pot IP the gating level of the thyristor is set to a predetermined fault current level (approximately 25% greater than the drive current limit setting). Once gated, the voltage at terminal 43 is the forward voltage drop of thyristor 1TH, which prevents further gate pulses by the gate pulse generator card. By inhibiting gate pulse pro­ duction the failure of devices may be limited to the thyristor in conduction, the bridge diodes conducting when the fault occurs and associated line fuses. relays. Also shown in the circuit diagram are three ICR resets the integrating capacitor, capacitor 4C, by provid­ ing a quick discharge path when the drive is turned off. Relay coil 86Y 50 is provided to sequence the drive off in the event of gate pulse suppression. Relay coil 86X is provided to reset thyristor 1TH after gate pulse suppression. As 1TH is forward biased, once gated on it continues to conduct until 86X is de-energized. Closure of 86X contact shunts current from the thyristor until it reaches a current less than holding current which causes the thyristor to revert to its blocking state. Voltage Controller The voltage controller card is one of four printed circuit boards comprising the basic armature regulator. The differential oper­ ational amplifier and associated feedback components comprise the basic voltage regulator as seen in Figure 4.10. Considering the differential amplifier, a small voltage applied -between points B1 and B2 will be amplified through two stages. These two stages provide a DC differential voltage gain of approximately 4000. For this amplifier a positive differential error signal (B1 positive with respect to B2) will yield a positive output from E01 and an equal and opposite negative output from E02. The feedback components associated with the difference amplifier provide a controller function of a time delay amplifier. The voltage output of the amplifier is limited by the transistors and diodes 10TR, 11TR, 10D, and 11D respectively to approximately +_ 10.5 volts as set by the voltage divider network of 31R and 37R. The voltage loop is closed through the resistors mounted in the basic cage assembly which connects 51 s r y ie O Sf /iZ k A C iO O ! /iP C n A O B C .-O a /3 P C ,A 0 3 0 0 3 S'/Atr/zzzy>z" I ' O /r ^ s A * y z r /- /^ p /j'S y a p T y p s f s p y -’/ ? /p y & o 'z /p r & s ’ - /3 e C > A O 3 0 0 d /r f M S f z /p f /A /z f r y o sz> iZi/AlPZ'yPS" Z&ZZP <v , /o ? y y S<rP. SOZ] 6 P . S P s jp /o r Z o r n s ' (*> 33 Yon/\c,e L/Mtr Q*. V’CfO JAJAf Vt’p.2) 55 (T .ft!) TO OK- I AJOTC. /. »(.L /*/?« 0 . 6 tV © 0I£>CO*jkj£C.T O £XTe.f?KIAL. ( T£#M I © r^sr Figure 4.10. PT.') P iki Voltage Controller. Corporation.) (Courtesy of Westinghouse Electric 52 the output terminals of the thyristor power module with the input terminals 31 and 33 of the voltage controller card. signals are fed into base 1 of the amplifier. Control input For the speed regulator under discussion in this paper IR compensation is not used, hence items 34R, 15C, IOC, 6P and 5P are eliminated. 5J, and 6J. The jumpers used are 1J, 2J, Because in a speed controller armature regulator system the voltage controller card is not used in a parallel configuration, diode 12D is also eliminated. Inside DA-1 are two small.squares labeled DIF7P and CM8P which represent differential balance and common-made balance adjustments for the DC amplifier. Speed Controller and Ramp-Function Generator The speed controller and ramp-function generator card is one of four printed circuit boards comprising the basic armature regulator. The ramp-function generator option which produces a linear change in output voltage from an abrupt change in input voltage, was not used in the individual control system units at Magma and will not be described any further here. The speed controller consists of a DC PIOIA amplifier and associated feedback components as seen in Figure 4.11. The PIOIA amplifier consists of three-stage amplification, with the first two stages being differential type and the third stage consisting of an inverter and two direct-couple transistors providing current gain. The amplifier has an open-loop voltage gain of approximately 20,000, and all plus voltage inputs to B1 yield negative output voltages. Compo­ nents 2D, 3D and 6D, 7D prevent the amplifier from saturating, limiting srcsc? icpxlar I-K— | COACT/?Ol-L£f? (fACH) O — I ^ .0*7 A?ZZ7 &%>' •-P/OM rWzs? ZVJA/Z’/rusSCT/OSVCPACPJPATOA? PAMP K|S T /n £ u p P-OUT xepo AOJ. 'T7^s.TALL *£SISTO#S A*/r '/m U Figure 4.11. <MU£S5 or*f#U/S£ &P£C/f/£D Speed Controller and Ramp Function Generator. (Courtesy of Westinghouse Electric Corporation.) 54 the output to +1 volt and -10.5 volts. Diode 5D prevents reverse volt­ ages from being developed across capacitor 9C, and capacitor 10C limits the output response for step inputs to the speed controller. Diode 4D is the logic switching diode, with the required reverse biasing pro­ vided through the 18R resistor in the current controller card. Remove­ able board jumpter 4J disconnects the speed controller, allowing for performance checks of other independent controller loops. Terminal 35 is connected to the output of the voltage controller card and closes a control loop which prevents undershoot for speed control encountered while decelerating under light load conditions. CHAPTER 5 ' CONCLUSIONS The discussion presented in this work has introduced the static conversion equipment used in a thyristor power system by Magma Copper Company for a speed-regulated DC motor control drive. DC motor was powered by the DC generator. In the past the Within recent years however, the development of operational amplifiers, thyristor amplifiers, and thyristor power supplies has been used to eliminate the generator in many applications. There are several essential advantages of the thyristor power system. One such advantage is the lower maintenance requirements. Al­ though the DC generator is dependable, its bearings require maintenance, the commutator requires careful handling, brushes need periodic replace­ ment, and armature insulation breakdowns must be avoided. Other advan­ tages include a 3 or 4 percent increased efficiency at rated load, smaller size, lower weight, lower installation cost, and faster time response. Some disadvantages of the thyristor power supply are lower power-factor, power-factor correction ability is lost, and no regenera­ tion capability. It is hoped that the interested reader will find the basic principles and circuits presented here a guide to better understanding of modern industrial control system. 55 APPENDIX A A DERIVATION FOR THE AVERAGE LOAD VOLTAGE VS. FIRING ANGLE FOR A THREE-PHASE THYRISTOR SUPPLY A transfer equation and curve is found by relating the average load voltage Vg of a three phase thyristor power supply to the firing angle aby integrating the output voltage waveshape with respect to a. Let the supply voltage be expressed by: v s = /2 V s where V^ is the R.M.S. line voltage. sin wt (1) The average supply voltage is Vs(AVE) = ^ Vs d(wt) ' (2) Sub equation (1) into (2) yields Vs(AVE) = Vs Sin wt d(Wt) • For a three-phase semiconverter circuit where the thyristors are triggered at angle a, the mean supply voltage over a complete cycle is: 3 /2 V rs(AVE) = 2tt 7T / a 56 s in s t d (" t) • Evaluating the integral: 3 /2 V( Vs(AVE) 27T TT -cos wt a S y/2 277 1 + cosa 3 V 1 + cosa = .675 Vs [1 + cosa] /2 TT The transfer curve relating the average load voltage to the firing angle may be seen in Figure A-l. 58 SO FIRING Figure A-l. IOO ANGLE 150 oC Average Load Voltage vs. Firing Angle REFERENCES Fitzgerald, A. E., Charles Kingsley, Jr., and Alexander Kusko. Machinery. McGraw-Hill, 1971. Kusko, Alexander. Mazda, F . F. Morris, Noel. Solid-State DC Motor Drives. Thyristor Control. Electric M.I.T. Press, 1969. London, Newnes-Buttervvorths, 1973. Advanced Industrial Electronics. McGraw-Hill, 1974. Rose, M. J . Techniques of Thyristor Power Control, Vol. 1, Power Engineering Using Thyristors, Technical Services, M u H a r d Ltd., 1970. Westinghouse Electric Corporation. Industrial Systems Division Instruc­ tion Book, Buffalo, New York, April 1971. 59 *k 0 * > 6 7 b 0