Tulane University Staff Advisory Council Minutes of Thursday, October 9, 2008 ATTENDEES ATTENDEES DOWNTOWN CAMPUS OFFICERS Kathleen Brumfield Glenda Folse Karen Hiller Tami Jenniskens Absent Excused Present Present Roxanne Johnson Paula Lucas Linda Miller Cindy Stewart Shirley Tubre Merisa Pasternak (proxy) Yesenia Vasquez (proxy) Excused Present Present Absent Present Excused Excused Susan Barrera, Chair Rhonda Earles, Vice Chair Gwen Chavez, Election Coordinator Lisa Britton, Recording Secretary, Present Present Excused Present Member at Large UPTOWN CAMPUS Marty Brantley Liz Davey Shirley Dymond Excused Absent Present Miriam Espinosa Cynthia Hayes, Immediate Present Present Cheryl Sterling, Corresp. Secretary Jered Bocage, Parliamentarian Present Present MEMBERS – AT – LARGE Rob Platner Present INVITED GUESTS Jason Chretien, WFMO Present Barbara Knill (Tulane Women’s Assoc.) Present Past Chair Aaron Martin Lisa O’Dwyer Judy Vitrano Linda Wright Argentina Acosta (proxy) Jenny Daigle Benoit (proxy) Laurie Orgeron (proxy) Present Excused Present Proxy Absent Absent Excused VISITORS Mike Griffith (proxy for Linda Wright) Present NORTHSHORE Eileen deHaro Mary Little Robert Johnson (proxy) Excused Present* Excused *Via teleconference All Officers are serving the Staff Advisory Council term 2008 – 2009 TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 2 Call to Order: Susan Barrera, SAC Chair, called the October 9, 2008 meeting of the Staff Advisory Council to order at 3:34 p.m. The meeting was held in the School of Public Health Dean’s Conference Room in the Tidewater Building downtown. I. Review and Approval of the Minutes After discussion regarding typographical corrections to the September minutes, Chair Barrera called for a motion to approve the September 11, 2008 minutes. The minutes were approved with the corrections. II. Guest Speaker, Barbara Knill Barbara Knill gave a presentation on the Tulane Women’s Association (see Attachment I). It is a service organization for women - faculty, staff, wives of faculty, wives of staff, or significant other. They are in their 99th year as a service organization with membership at approximately 150 down from over 500. TUWA is an organization that promotes an atmosphere of community within the Tulane environment. As a non-profit, TUWA uses their resources on things the community wants or needs. Their emphasis is on “newcomers”. Newcomers can be anyone from a person just moving to the New Orleans area needing assistance on how to obtain a driver’s license, or how to register to vote. Or a newcomer can be someone who had just heard about them and would like to join. By focusing on newcomers sometimes they tend to forget about the women that are already here part of Tulane and the many campuses. TUWA has many activity groups and are willing to try different things that would interest the diversified organization. Some of the groups: arts and crafts, daytime and evening book groups, a bridge group, mothers and daughters group – which TUWA is reaching out to the Lusher group, a knitting group that made shawls for cancer patients, some groups meet on a Saturday or Sunday. They also have a one hour brown bag lunch and lecture held once a month. Future of upcoming events: a “Fall Coffee” on October 16th honoring three women -Mary Brown, VP of Health Sciences Systems, Carol Habber, Dean of School of Liberal Arts, and Nora Lubbel, wife of Charles Lovell, director of Newcomb Art Gallery, November will be an art gallery showing; December will be a holiday party with all members invited; January will have a women’s basketball game; February a faculty lecture; March will be a tour; and April is their spring luncheon. They invite women to attend the various functions and activity groups that provide an opportunity to meet and become acquainted with women from the Tulane community. TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 3 Their office is located at the Elmwood campus and you can visit their website at http://www.tulane.edu/~tuwa/ for more information on the TUWA. III. Report of the Chair, Susan Barrera Susan Barrera announced that President Scott Cowen would be our guest speaker at our May 12th meeting. This meeting will be held on a Tuesday to accommodate President Cowen’s schedule. Yvette Jones has agreed to be our speaker at our March 12th meeting. Still trying to set a date for Tony Lorino to be a speaker at one of our meetings. The Provost will be our speaker at our November meeting next month and in February will be Dr. Ben Sachs. Aaron Martin was asked to talk to us about the textbook fund. Aaron submitted an “ad hoc SAC Textbook Scholarship Committee” outline (see Attachment 2). The information was the result of a working committee putting together some guidelines and goals for the textbook scholarship awards. Anne Banos will talk to Yvette Jones and Anne was supportive of the idea but wanted to bring to our attention that approximately 450 employees use the tuition waiver. Of that, approximately 350 are staff and if coverage is for staff only, we will be reaching a small percentage of staff. So the concern is we are only reaching a small percentage of our staff that will be eligible to apply for this award. Also we will have to work with financial aid and general counsel. Some staff members take out loans and this will also need to be taken into consideration so we would need to work financial aid on this. Anne suggested if we were interested in assisting in another way, we could have a “professional development fund” for people to attend out of town trips for seminars/conferences. Possibly our fund could put up part of the money needed for a person to attend, with their department matching the dollar amount. This is a complaint that many are not able to attend because of the financial amount required to attend out of town. Either direction we take for granting awards, we will have a lot of hurdles to overcome to get it started. Overall, we would like to reward the staff in some way. Some universities have it set up that you could use the money for textbooks, or to cover cost of certification. There is enough support to want the work group to keep investigating and putting something together to present to SAC as a draft. A suggestion was made that SAC do an outreach for the University Medical Center in Galveston, Texas. As an example, after Hurricane Katrina, Carnegie-Mellon SAC members had a money donation drive for Tulane employees. Carnegie-Mellon purchased gift cards (for Home Depot, Lowes, Wal-Mart) for distribution to eligible Tulane employees. Doing something like this would be a nice gesture from us at TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 4 SAC toward those affected by Hurricanes Gustav and Ike. We will look at this and possibly do something in the spring of 2009. IV. WFMO Liaison, Jason Chretien Two key issues from the July SAC meeting given to Aileen that was asked for further clarification: (1) What does WFMO look like now? Originally there were three different departments – Payroll, Human Resources, and Human Resources Information Systems -- reporting to different senior executives. Since Hurricane Katrina, changes have been made to bring the three organizations under one roof and it is now called WFMO. With the reorganization of the departments, new positions were created – (1) Jason is Asst VP on operational side of WFMO; (2) Strategy Planning and Implementation – how to meet needs and direction of organization and how to effectively meet needs of employees; and (3) Customer Service -- realized that organization of the size of ours needed an element that was lacking in helping employees get the information they need. These three are the core of the organization. Think of graphically, three circles intersecting together. Haven’t changed business of the three original key departments, still have key directors in all of those areas, and people report to those directors. The WFMO website has a lot of good information -- http://www.tulane.edu/~wfmo/ -There is a link at the bottom of this page that gives direct phone numbers and a synopsis of the person’s job duties. Other take away from July meeting, (2) Status of the “compensation study” – a company outside of Tulane was hired to review 868 staff positions. The consulting group has reviewed positions and developed a new grading structure and proposed policy structure to go along with the salary grading developed for the positions that need to be graded higher. This is a small percentage – most were found to be in line. The information needs to go through normal approval process – policy review, admin council, president’s cabinet, etc. Review and presentation to the Administrative Council will be sometime in December. In January the Council will disseminate the information and implementation will go out to constituents and departments and explain the new salary structure and implementation. Doing a “road show” to explain to the constituents. As to direct results of who is impacted / who is not impacted? That is still in formulation process; there is a larger plan in place and we will hear more once the plan is finalized. Salary ranges are being compared on a national scale, along with years of services, and years in the position. Tools to arrive at these numbers are different than what has been done in the past. “Compensation Study” doesn’t necessarily mean a “raise”. Some may get a raise, but not necessarily everyone, but we are evaluating all positions and salaries. Criteria was set on the position, some positions are specific to this area so evaluating not only TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 5 national market data but position specific data. In grading any position, you cannot look at just one piece of information, yet at several elements, including what is financially sustainable within the university. In looking at the national market, there are positions that are specific for this region, i.e. positions at the Primate Center. All this is factored into the grading system. Also considered is years of service, years in position, all are factors that come into grading a particular position. The tool to do this is completely new and we are in a learning curve right now on how to use and implement this new grading system. We now have 26 grades. The result will give us a decrease in the number of grades and each will have wider ranges. Question asked of Jason: the lack of policy that clearly articulates that departments are allowed to offer flex time for their employees. Because there is not a clear statement, departments are not willing to allow flextime. This was related to price of gas issue and this question was given to Aileen at the July meeting. Staff Advisory was asking if WFMO could have something written in the policy to clarify. Jason will take this away from the meeting and will have a response for us at the next meeting. V. Officer Reports A. University Senate Rhonda Earles gave the following report. Following a few housekeeping items, President Cowen gave his update on the university. Freshman enrollment in 2008 was 1565 with an acceptance rate of 27%. We have received 20,000 applications for 2009. The qualification cut-off has been raised to prevent all accepted students being identified in the early decision pool. The faculty hiring/retention enhancement program is in its second phase, concentrating on the schools of medicine and public health. The third phase begins next year. A staff compensation enhancement program is in progress. A total of 142 have been hired. There has been an increase of 116% in chairs and professorship. Jeremy Crigler is the new chief investment officer, with offices in Connecticut. The Promise and Distinction campaign exceeded its goal of $700 million, pulling in $730 million. The fund-raising staff is now evaluating next steps. An expansion project is underway at the primate center. The university finished FY08 with a $20 million operating deficit, down from both the projected deficit of $34 million and the adjusted deficit of $28 million. The FY09 operating deficit is $30 million. The university continues to negotiate with TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 6 the remaining insurance company over Katrina losses/damages of $100 million. Resolution with FEMA is estimated to take another three to five years. The current economy has presented some challenges to the university, but its exposure is minimal because the value of our endowment is based on a rolling 36-month value. If the problems are prolonged, we will face more issues and anticipate student loans to be affected. Among the FY09 goals are finalizing the doctoral program enhancement, which will provide $4 million/year to support doctoral programs. This represents an 80% increase. Project 2020 will continue to work towards its goal of doubling external funding to Tulane, resulting in $300 million. The situation that occurred in the spring at the Pi Kappa Alpha initiation has prompted a major review of the code of student conduct and campus life policies. Searches currently underway include: chief technology officer, executive director of Newcomb Institute, executive director of Murphy Institute, and dean of the law school. United Healthcare has been renewed as the carrier for 2009. An increase of 6.5 percent will be put in place. Faculty and staff should receive the open enrollment materials soon. In addition, UHC is assisting with a wellness program and staff can earn $175 gift certificate for completing a health risk assessment survey, a telephone counseling session and an online session. Walking programs and peer seminars are being developed. B. Board of Administrators No meeting. VI. University Senate Committee Reports 1. Benefits No meeting. 2. Budget Review No meeting. 3. Information Technology No report. TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 7 4. Equal Opportunity No report. 5. Physical Facilities No report. 6. Social Issues No report. VII. SAC Sub-Committees 1. Election Committee No report. 2. Electronic Technology and Information No report. 3. Staff Appreciation Rob Platner gave the following report. Prior to this meeting, we met to discuss ideas for having another Staff Recognition event. It was agreed that we should rotate an event on the three campuses giving everyone a chance to see the event, and doing something similar to what was done last year with the Ricky Graham event. 4. Staff Issues Linda Miller will be the chair of this committee, and no meeting held yet. 5. Constitution No Report. VIII. Old Business Gift given to Cynthia Hayes for serving as Chair. TU Staff Advisory Council October 9, 2008 Page 8 Susan Barrera will sending out an email to all staff (see Attachment 3) after each SAC meeting and including a link to our website and our minutes. Community outreach – Cynthia asked if we are interested in adopting the Christmas families again. Cynthia will do the preliminary work and get information on two families and their needs. She will present the information to us at the next SAC meeting in November. IX. New Business Next Meeting: The next meeting will be held on November 13, 2008 at the LavinBernick Center for University Life in the Race Conference Room at 3:30 pm. X. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 4:55 pm. Respectfully submitted, Lisa M. Britton Recording Secretary Attachment I Attachment 2